SUPREME COURT OF INDIA dismisses challenge to 70% LLB Marks requirement for MP civil Judge Exam

[@mitakshara158]

I bet 90% of the sitting judges of DC, HC or even the SC, they themselves don't have 70% in their llb course! Hon'ble Mr. CJI D. Y. Chandrachud says its to bring good people in the judiciary.. Isn't the whole purpose of the various judicial entrance exams just that? If you are not satisfied with the quality of judges.. make the entrance exam more difficult or make changes to the training of selected judges.. By allowing the 70% mark, the SC is ultimately supporting the rattafication!!

[@SuccessLawClasses]

this is for exemption of 3 years practice or 70% marks in LLB but not both sir, if you have 3 years practice then this 70% not applicable

[@venkateswararao9440]

Correct. 50% marks enough for appearing tests

[@mitakshara158]

@@SuccessLawClasses doesn't matter! Students from NLU, DU can't wait for 3 years after llb degree!

[@anujkumar-tt4el]

There are many third class law clgs/Universities in india which can award you as much as you want with a minimal consideration. You dont even need to attend classes With the decision of 70%, the demand for these universities is fit to increase, people will take admission and leave for delhi in some big judiciary coaching. They'll prepare for judiciary and will have their attendance fixed at home. With this decision only the students of tier 1, 2 colleges are going to get affected. Its extremely tough to score beyond 70 in most of these tier 1-2 universities.

[@sovereignsoldier3421]

Absolutely!!! It must be asked % of these judges

[@president7976]

In Delhi University they hardly give 70% marks to anyone. The majority gets below 50-60% no matter how good an answer they write in 3hrs. These third tier law college students show 80% marks like a joke and it haunts us top tier DU students when it comes to competition minimum requirements.

[@shivank7290]

correct

[@Sumantclc]

Exactly

[@vanlandings7466]

So true

[@pakchikpakrajababu3206]

Exactly, every govt. University give 50-60% only...

[@punisher419]

I am from KSLU trust me. Marks is a dream for us

[@Study-nh8ej]

I scored 61 percent in govtcollege ...... I wrote exam litereally sections and case laws as it is ...still i got 61 percent....while private colege nearby .....students do not even attend classes and never studied and scores 75 percent 😢😢😢

[@imsaurabh16]

Every law student from DU crying in the corner.

[@Aesthetic_fighter]

I got du clc this year...now i am regretting my decision to join clg😢

[@harshitdwivedi7006]

@@Aesthetic_fighter I ALSO GOT CLC BRO

[@Sagarvatsal5702]

@@Aesthetic_fighter😂 lol, worst decision ever.

[@Aesthetic_fighter]

@@Sagarvatsal5702 should i withdraw admission?🤣

[@Aesthetic_fighter]

@@harshitdwivedi7006 section allotment ka koi mail aaya?

[@VickyGarg-yl7td]

A great argument must needed

[@vanlandings7466]

The argument that 70 percent criteria ensures the quality of candidates makes no sense. Doesn't qualifying 2 exams and a interview itself ensures the quality? How many senior advocates or Judges of high courts have 70 percent marks in their graduation? Graduation marks are so subjective, it makes no sense to equate it with quality of candidates. In college exams mugging ability and filling pages matter more than actual knowledge. If the percentage criteria is that important then atleast develop an objective and scientific framework for evaluation of papers and not leave it to the whims of universities.

[@ravindrajinde3534]

Subtly correct

[@piyushmisra1839]

This is strange. I am a doctor and in mbbs we in government college never give marks above 70 percent no matter how good the student. If a students gets 70 percent he is gold medalist and private colleges give marks excess of 80 peecent. This can be applied to only those exams in which simular conditions are present for all examinees

[@harisruthi8052]

Excellent Council arguments difference between the institutions Given the Mark.

[@balaji2115]

Any law education will not save justice in this country common people cannot get justice in this country money money money

[@deepakanuragi5728]

Plz sabhi judges ki llb ki percentage bhi koi publish kre, uncle judge quality maintain kr rhe h, garib family k log ab civil judge b n ban sken. Howerd se pdhe log hi judge bne is judgement se mera dissent h

[@Kathiravan84]

I don't know what is the Logic behind such absurd rule and why SC has dismissed such application without application of Mind..

[@venkateswararao9440]

Sir kindly make uniform recruitment rules for judicial employments. some states putting 55% 60% marks in LLB. This should be rectified

[@haribabue4202]

Percent of marks indicates knowledge of the candidate on the date of examination which may be improved later. You can test knowledge of the candidates before appointing as judges. A second class graduate may succeed in IAS while a topper in graduation may not be able to make it to that.

[@VickyGarg-yl7td]

Students are now days being treated like football every one is playing 😔 hope sun will rise 🔜 .

[@legallog1340]

Mera to kaise ghich ghach ke 71 pahucha😅, lekin ye faisla arbitrary ha, Aise m upsc ke lia bhi 90% krna chahiye graduation m

[@scientificatheist9381]

these guys have no ground reality. being good in college doesn't mean anything

[@keshavgarg1293]

Very good arguments.

[@sunilchoudhary-xb9rn]

There will be four stages for the creaking judiciary examination that are as follows 1. Obtaining 70 percent marks (in not similar circumstances) 2. prelims 3. Mains 4. Interview All of you know that - Every person is treated equally in the same circumstances in the eyes of law, this is called equity before law. But there are no similar circumstances in obtaining 70 percent marks at all. So this principle can't be applied here.

[@chilmarldke2273]

Sir are their any exceptions to article 14 or is it absolute?

[@vikramjinmp426]

Supreme Court must understand that 75+ years no government could developed through reservation and such discrepancy to youth's that nation now ruled by reservation and deserved are leaving our beloved Nation. World over Indian Deserved are reaching power to promote those respective countries. STRICTLY STOP RESERVATION & ALLOW DESERVED TO BE PROTECTED

[@AmitSingh-bi5tu]

State should oppose these rule becoz govt law they run ground reality they should better like mp state so rural and poor how can quility judge came judiciary I think out mp students selected this kind exm

[@sureshlovanshi3238]

The quality can be checked in the entrance exam of civil judge ..simple ! But can never be checked on the basis of different university including private universities where anyone can get a degree with 70%

[@khanyariduja1070]

In Govt law universities, faculty are reluctant to give marks in liberated manner

[@sarvankumarpursavakam3369]

That's more required, as a sr member of bar, no quality output of those enrolling frim university. Jaitely sir daid rights difficult to fail llb easy to pass ca

[@varghesecherian6610]

Minimum marks awarded in Law Colleges will be henceforth 70% onwards. Why this litigation court cases etc etc.. Chill folks..

[@dr.v.sundaresan1862]

Is the age limit prescribed for M.P.JUDGE POST?

[@SuccessLawClasses]

yes

[@tushar1second]

😊

[@vanditamishra-yf7hr]

Sc descision is unfair y don't yu extend training period

[@CreativeGearbox98]

Not satisfied with this judgement. Because in up judiciary many district judges and civil judges are 3rd division in llb course. That keans they are not capable to handle judicial work.

[@SuccessLawClasses]

this is for exemption of 3 years practice or 70% marks in LLB but not both sir, if you have 3 years practice then this 70% not applicable

[@siddiramulugondlala3725]

With due respect, this is a bad judgement in law , when a minimum graduation (pass marks) are prescribed for UPSC civil services examinations and why not judiciary and such a qualification of 70% is dangerous move

[@SuccessLawClasses]

this is for exemption of 3 years practice or 70% marks in LLB but not both sir

[@SachinNayak-v6k]

Supereme court 🤡

[@prabhashyadav9979]

Supreme Court judges can you tell me how much percentage have u got ?? This is how u decide, listen in Govt colleges no one will get above 70 % marks this is rare who will get it so my dear bench u should do analysis then u have to give judgment u don’t even think what impact is going to happened of ur judgement to the student who r in appearing stage so pls think about this And Now onward the student have to take admission in private colleges u will surely get 90 % marks without any hardwork

[@AjitJi-w4k]

My ❤ give me❤

[@Republicnews-h3v]

Heen judge. Notice bhej. Im involved and affected party.

[@Anuradha-cd6hr]

Sc always ryt