Objectively speaking, the player who got the most Robbed at the final tribal council was Amber at season 8. If you know what I mean 😏😏😏
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Boston Robbed
@waz2072 ай бұрын
Took me too long to get what you meant… I was like…Amber won against Boston Ro…ohhhhh
@Feitan182 ай бұрын
lmao
@roycesharp83142 ай бұрын
Clay got Robbed in Thailand too.
@MorganLefeuvre2 ай бұрын
i would definitely include Devon from 35 who got screwed by the fire making twist ; And although it is technically not at the F4 but at the F5, Janet from 39 was also screwed by the idol nullifier which made it impossible for her to survive the tribal anyways (and she was very likely to win the fire making challenge against anyone else apparently making it very likely that she seats as a finalist in the FTC)
@calebos042 ай бұрын
13:29 An underrated part of the quote is when he says: "If Jaison can win two in a row, anyone can win two in a row" 😂
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Russell was always willing to talk about smack about anyone, even his closest allies.
@atufbrandbusiness35812 ай бұрын
Friendly Fire 😂
@giovanniorellana22002 ай бұрын
I would include Rafe, Yau-Man and Holly in the next edition of this series!
@zehnpie2 ай бұрын
Obviously Ciera should have just been giving the 1 million after doing something that we have all forgotten of course SHE VOTED OFF HER MOM
@polaritygames30462 ай бұрын
Sami was robbed. Bro was only 19
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
I thought he was 22?
@polaritygames30462 ай бұрын
@@OnceUponAnIsland you’ve been severely misinformed
@roypalmer692 ай бұрын
Wait are you sure he is only 19? The show NEVER mentioned that
@polaritygames30462 ай бұрын
@@roypalmer69 incredibly so
@snobey2 ай бұрын
At least we are sure that Sue is 45
@TheDXJC562 ай бұрын
RIP to the GOAT Keith, hopefully his spiritual successor Kyle can stick to the plan and get the job done in his honor
@roypalmer692 ай бұрын
@@TheDXJC56 lol I thought Kyle was Ian from survivor 10's successor
@DonaldKeebals2 ай бұрын
I knew there was a familiar air around Kyle..
@scottwaldo2 ай бұрын
Not including Spencer in season 28 is crazy. The entire jury would have voted for him if he made it
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Good one! He barely missed qualifying for this list since he finished 4th on a final 2 season.
@TChaff2 ай бұрын
Against Tony tho?
@Kingofthegalaxies2 ай бұрын
Cirie loosing that final immunity hurts so much…
@alkholos2 ай бұрын
But Amanda - who should have won - blundered after the final immunity challenge by taking Parvati to the jury. Amanda was robbed, too.
@unstablefallout3922 ай бұрын
Know these videos only include American Survivor seasons, but think Harry from Australian Survivor Champions vs Contenders 2 deserves a shout out as well, dude played an amazing game from the bottom all the way since the swap and was one challenge away from winning it all!
@rogerdodger19842 ай бұрын
Totally agree, but Im so happy we got that FTC performance from Pia instead. One of the best performances of all time in any Survivor.
@unstablefallout3922 ай бұрын
Very true, that FTC at least meant the season still finished strong!
@aang_arang2 ай бұрын
Rest in Peace Keith, you're in my thoughts always ❤
@jamespatton84022 ай бұрын
David Wring and Kelley Wentworth have got to be a lock for the next list.
@Battle9862 ай бұрын
I mean…. Rick Devens I feel is the most obvious choice for me
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
I was devastated watching Chris win fire.
@silentassasin-q8l2 ай бұрын
I know people refer to the as "fallen angels", but I prefer calling them final bosses Also, Malcolm in Philippines comes to mind
@TheOpinionator16102 ай бұрын
I think Jessie was screwed when he didn’t win Final 4 immunity, not fire making. Here’s the thing-If the fire making thing wasn’t around, Jessie was going to just get voted out 3-1 in the old format. Fire making ACTUALLY gives Jessie one last chance. He got robbed, sure. But he also had TWO individual chances to win to F3 and didn’t succeed in either challenge.
@logansmith27032 ай бұрын
He was screwed when he burned Karla's idol. Should've made sure she had it at 5 so he can force either himself to go against her or someone else to pick between them at fire.
@Shutterbun42 ай бұрын
Lex was quite literally robbed due to the producers screwing up the trivia questions at final 4 in Africa.
@Guitarfreak123452 ай бұрын
Devin Pinto was completely screwed imo. The sudden fire making took him out and I feel he would have won over Chrissy.
@Derevko912 ай бұрын
Victoria from Season 38... she was so great under the radar, but then Chris returned from Edge of Extinction and exposed her as a jury threat
@eeg04152 ай бұрын
The good ole seasons. That was a nice trip back to memory lane.
@markjackson64312 ай бұрын
If Micronesia had a final 3 Eliza: Cirie Ozzy: Amanda Jason: Parvati or Cirie James: Amanda or Cirie Alexis: Cirie Erik: Cirie Natalie: Parvati Cirie wins with atleast 3 confirmed votes
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Who are some other Survivor players who got robbed of winning one million dollars?
@Destroyer81042 ай бұрын
Rick Devins
@patrickkenneally30162 ай бұрын
Matty from Gabon. Had Sugar not caused a tie at the final four vote, he would not have lost to Bob in fire making.
@tylerhaggerty48052 ай бұрын
Lex in season 3 Africa. There's no guarantee he still beats Kim at final immunity even if he doesn't get sick, or even beat Ethan at FTC if he does. But after everything to go out on a case of the runs is robbery.
@007hunter132 ай бұрын
Lex/Big Tom from Africa. They were robbed by a production mistake at the Final Four which resulted in 1) being awarded 2nd place prize money and 2) being guaranteed spots on All Stars.
@jburnaquatic2 ай бұрын
I love Natalie and Russell both, I like that Natalie won but by gosh do I wish that Brett won but had the same edit lol could you imagine if Brett had the same edit up to before he was voted and ended up winning the whole season? That would be, ah, the chefs kiss lol.
@ididwhatihadto3692 ай бұрын
I love Jeff saying that’s a record to Kelly as if it’s not the first season 😂
@jamesstudley11662 ай бұрын
It’s only $600k after Obama get his cut
@payotimeRamsYT2 ай бұрын
Gavin was the most underrated robbed player bc he was underrated and even underrated his own game at final tribal
@machoman10162 ай бұрын
3:23 Correction Ozzy was aggorant in ALL of his seasons....minus maybe Game Changers.
@DudeNinja292 ай бұрын
Spencer in Cagayan bro had everyone's votes 😢
@itacryan2 ай бұрын
I think Lauren in IOTI. Maybe Carson in 44. And David of Millennials Vs. Gen-X?
@michaeldesimone87632 ай бұрын
Surprised Lex wasn't on this list with the whole final four fiasco in Africa.
@lapniappe2 ай бұрын
Cirie in Micronesia makes me sort of mad [because they changed it from final 3 to 2 in season and imo that should have been stated not. oh well SURPRISE] but for me the one where cirie got robbed was in that stupid season where EVERYONE had some sort of vote immunity but her. no one voted for her and she still gets bounced. that's really what killed the series for me and i stopped watching for the most part. the fact that Jeff doubles down on it being "a good thing" reinforces my feelings.
@esinger232 ай бұрын
Her elimination in Game Changers was brutal af
@diandranyirinkwaya77702 ай бұрын
@@esinger23it was staged they wanted her out so bad
@andyadams4202 ай бұрын
Cirie was definitely the most robbed. Twice even. At least she has that traitor win and she's going to appear in one of the new Australian Seasons. And hopefully S50
@DimensionalMan2 ай бұрын
Designed as an individual challenge and it will remain an individual challenge.... wish that rule stayed consistent. Maria got screwed.
@esinger232 ай бұрын
I was thinking the same thing tbh. Jeff shouldn’t have allowed Liz to go back and get Kenzie’s piece for her
@victoriastillwell50102 ай бұрын
im just gonna say it, my boy charlie got screwed so bad :/
@Funnynick2 ай бұрын
💯
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
How do you feel about that Maria vote? I don't mind her voting Kenzie, I just wish she would own up to the real reason why.
@victoriastillwell50102 ай бұрын
@ that’s exactly my issue with it, not the fact that she didn’t vote for him because she was bitter but more so the fact that she just won’t say she’s mad he beat her to the punch. l
@victoriastillwell50102 ай бұрын
@@OnceUponAnIsland also thanks for responding, been a silent suscriber for forever but i’m very passionate about that vote. love your work🤍
@SpanishFly1202 ай бұрын
I think Devon's an example that often comes to mind for me when this whole subject comes up. The guy was legitimately screwed by a twist that happened after the Final 4 Immunity Challenge that there had been no precedent or warning for. Like, at least the cast of Ghost Island were all told on Day 1.
@rogerdodger19842 ай бұрын
I think there is definitely an argument for Tina on Blood Vs. Water who could have become the 2nd two time winner at the time. Also, I know it was at final 5, not 4, but Janet getting screwed by the idol nullifier on season 39, really put the nail in the coffin of that horrid season.
@Wezo66662 ай бұрын
Rudy sounds like a soprano 🤣🤣🤣 , the homosexual - imagine if this was said now people will go nuts
@michaelalansara88932 ай бұрын
In HvHvH, there was a new random firemaking challenge, in which Ben beat Devon. I really think this was production interference, and that Devon was going to win this season. A shame that we never got to see him play again.
@oziyard1362 ай бұрын
If you include finalists I'd add Aubry and Charlie in there
@MikeGlasses2 ай бұрын
Idk whats worse Ozzys face at 5:20 or Russels face at the Somoa reunion (realizing he just lost 2 games)
@MuzakMaker2 ай бұрын
"Clear fan favorite" Nah, SoPa where virtually all of Savaii was unrootable no matter how hard the editors worked to hide that the tribe was full of egotisitcal, arrogant bullies (and yes that includes Ozzy) SoPa might be the rare season where both alliances were intolerable
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Didn't Ozzy win fan favorite that season?
@MuzakMaker2 ай бұрын
@@OnceUponAnIsland If he did that just goes to show the power of the editing. Ozzy, Jim, Keith and to an extent Whitney were absolutely horrible to everyone else on the tribe Hard to pick anyone to root for when the season is Cult vs Bullies
@christianthomas327715 күн бұрын
Malcolm from season 25 Philippines seems like an obvious one for this video. Challenge beast that was running the game made it to the final four but was voted out bc they knew he’d win.
@jameshamilton63812 ай бұрын
00:36 Fairplay has got to be on this list. Pearl Islands was his game.
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
Does he actually beat Sandra though?
@jameshamilton63812 ай бұрын
@OnceUponAnIsland if he handles it like Russell, no. But yeah. I think he has a chance against her. I think Rupert would have gone up to bat for him. For most of the season Rupert saw him as one of his boys. That might have been enough to convince everyone.
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
There is no way Rupert votes for Fairplay over Sandra.
@jameshamilton63812 ай бұрын
@OnceUponAnIsland Rupert's tantrum(vs Jon )shows me that he might have. You've got to really like a person to get that pissed off at them. It depends on how he plays Rupert at tribal. I could see it.
@aschmidty112 ай бұрын
I personally think Ozzy and Devins are the two big ones that come to mind for me. CGI Brett rounds out my top 3, but I was happy to see Natalie win that season.
@bravesfan22142 ай бұрын
I keep watching the end of South Pacific and am sad every time he loses final four immunity. I keep hoping it’s a nightmare
@mirandamullet83342 ай бұрын
I’ve said it on another video, but if Brett won Samoa, it wouldn’t just be the Russell show.
@jasonglasser16212 ай бұрын
I do have a bit of an issue with the person eliminated by fire making (in any instance where this is the case, not just the guy in the video) Jeff saying "the tribe has spoken" to that person. The tribe didn't speak, the game did.
@snobey2 ай бұрын
My underrated pick - Matty. He was kinda like Eddie (but a bit better at challanges and strategy) - if he gets to the end he wins because of how likeable he is (Eddie doesn't 100% has to win against Cochran despite a good shot, but Matty for sure wins against Bob, Susie and Sugar). And a fun fact: Rob wasn't the first one to create the buddy system - it was Matty as shiwn in one of secret scenes
@markjackson64312 ай бұрын
Cirie Fields is the only player i’ve cried when they got voted off.
@esinger232 ай бұрын
I was devastated when she was eliminated in Game Changers
@lukassvoboda41072 ай бұрын
Kelley, David and Malcolm should be on list. Rob C, Rick Devens and Devon too.
@ratburger16212 ай бұрын
Rick Devins for sure
@sonicducktheinoccent2 ай бұрын
Listen. If jesse Lopez won a single challenge or knew how to make fire he would have won
@jag5192 ай бұрын
You should include Eric here. If he didnt give up that idol he could have won. Just Like Jesse it's one thing that did it (Jesse, it was turning on his ally becoming the biggest threat, and making it that he needed to do what Natalie Bolton did to Eric to have any chance at not losing)
@nvm90402 ай бұрын
Cirie could have won Micronesia if the format that season was a final three But Ozzy would have won South Pacific simply because of the jury would have voted for him but he lost on a puzzle 😂
@kk_332 ай бұрын
Malcolm and Wentworth should absolutely be on this list
@gamingupgradeYTT2 ай бұрын
I like nat was a great player but God dang it I was hoping Keith would have won
@filipbednar71772 ай бұрын
I would like to mention Yau Man from survivor Fiji, he was also really near to be in final three and the most members of jury would have voted for him to win the survivor. It was a big shame to see Yau man’s voting out. When I saw it as kid twelve years ago I was really angry at Dreamz that lied to him and did not give him a immnunity idol. 😂
@jolteon3452 ай бұрын
How can you make a list of people getting robbed without including the only player named Robb, and how Robb Robbed Clay by choking him, an action that only pre-epiphany Robb would make?
@silentjoker91452 ай бұрын
I would include Lex and Rob C
@Shrekiz112 ай бұрын
I’m not sure I agree with the term « robbed » for Brett, Keith, and Jesse; sure, they were fallen angels who would have won final tribal, but they didn’t lose because of production choice, overly bitter jury, another player’s « dirty play » (whatever that might mean), or an unfortunate medical evacuation. I feel « stolen » might suit other candidates (or at least an argument can be made: Yau-Man, Colby, Ozzy in cook island, Parvati in HvV, Erik in FvF2, Cirie in GC, Chrissy, Domenik, Charlie…
@Anthony-gy5dv2 ай бұрын
Good verse at the end.
@rick09332 ай бұрын
can you do a story video of omer from season 42, as he played one of the best games but just didnt lower his threat level
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
05:25
@piznoctsauo81412 ай бұрын
David Wright is the first to come to my mind.
@diandranyirinkwaya77702 ай бұрын
Am definitely convinced that production never wanted Cirie to win like let’s be frr
@sockmonkeyjg2 ай бұрын
Ozzy was the most painful not because of him being the most deserving but because it would have been the best narrative design... It has never set with me that Sophie got away with it all
@zbee64222 ай бұрын
I can not focus on the content with “drunken sailor” playing on repeat in the background 😅
@OnceUponAnIsland2 ай бұрын
I'm glad you liked it!
@tlucas56562 ай бұрын
I really do wish Ozzy was able to get the win in South Pacific
@LaurelRawson2 ай бұрын
I'm surprised Yau Man isn't on this video. Malcolm in Phillipines possibly too.
@4wz72 ай бұрын
I think it's unlikely that Keith ever would have been able to win - Had they made the correct choice and voted out Natalie, it likely would be a tie between Missy and Jaclyn with Keith voting for Missy. (Natalie, Baylor, Jeremy for Missy, Jon, Reed, Probably Josh for Jaclyn, and Alec and Wes for Keith unless Alec votes somewhere else)
@Videoandme12 ай бұрын
My pick: Rob Cesternino. One immunity away from winning Amazon
@antoineharris21762 ай бұрын
Gotta have Yau Man, even though it's debatable between him and Earl. Davis from Millennials vs Gen-X.
@03Majkel2 ай бұрын
Matty on Gabon Malcolm on Philippines Wentworth on Second Chance David on Millennials Vs Gen X
@tubagal132 ай бұрын
How can you bring up robbed players and not being up Rob Cesternino??
@ermerlie2 ай бұрын
The entire cast of redemption island got (Boston) Robbed
@snobey2 ай бұрын
Amber too - at least 4 times
@BillyGollnerMusic2 ай бұрын
I HATE the final four forced fire making challenge instead of voting. The worst.
@flipcamgamer2 ай бұрын
If there ever was a second version of this video here would be ten more fallen angels that I think had a great shot at winning: #10: Rick Devins (Survivor Edge of Extinction) #9: Malcom Friedburg (Survivor Philippines) #8: Rob Cesternino (Survivor the Amazon) #7: Devon Pinto (Survivor Heroes vs Healers Vs Hustlers) #6: Carson Garret (Survivor 44) #5: David Wright (Survivor Millenials vs Gen X) #4: Yau-Man Chan (Survivor Fiji) #3: Cydney Gillon (Survivor Kaoh Rong) #2: Jerri Manthey (Survivor Heroes vs Villians) #1: Kelly Wentworth (Survivor Cambodia)
@mikerock6212 ай бұрын
Rip Keith and rudy
@mudkipzryan2 ай бұрын
dont know if "robbed" is the right word but Malcolm in Philippines definitely had a winning trajectory if he beats denise in the final immunity. Also another way of looking at it, you could say Fishbach was robbed in tocantins without even being voted out, just simply because JT kept winning immunity?
@verbalelixer2 ай бұрын
I feel like Victoria from Season 38 (EoE) was robbed.
@kodamaakemi97582 ай бұрын
It's been a WHILE since I last fully watched Gabon, but I think Matty could've won if he'd won at fire-making
@belpop2 ай бұрын
Ohhh survivor fallen angels I love it
@CrybabyEm2 ай бұрын
The bitter all hero jury would’ve voted for Colby in HvV
@pennisss94332 ай бұрын
Eh, Cirie is the only person on this list that was robbed. Everyone else was just outplayed. I guess there’s an argument for that Jesse guy because of the forced final 4 fire making, but I don’t consider new era cannon. Plus if forced fire making wasn’t a thing, he would’ve been voted out at f4 anyway. Devon from S35 was probably more ‘robbed’ in regards to forced fire making since it was unprecedented at that time
@deltagolavista12 ай бұрын
Obvious one to me is Devon, the first fire making victim in HHH. Malcolm in Cambodia.
@PintheDog2 ай бұрын
Malcolm wasn't on Cambodia.
@deltagolavista12 ай бұрын
@ meant Philippians.
@PintheDog2 ай бұрын
@@deltagolavista1 Philippines.😋
@esinger232 ай бұрын
Ciera voted out her own mom! She was robbed
@coneil722 ай бұрын
Keith?!?!? Robbed???? Keith didn't play Survivor a single day of his life. He just vibes. Natalie deserved that win, and to say that he was strong competition to her is wild. Agree with all the other picks though. And Terry or Brett over Rick Devens???? WILD choice. Great vid though.
@logansmith27032 ай бұрын
Carson was robbed from this list. He 100% wins if he makes final tribal and he WAS fast at making fire. It's just Heidi set a record so he got 4th
@waz2072 ай бұрын
Ozzy getting robbed is what made me stop watching Survivor for a while. Only started watching again this season actually (and I’m not a fan of most of the cast)
@GK-ob1ni2 ай бұрын
Devon fron HvHvH is another one.
@JarinCOD2 ай бұрын
Russell Hantz.
@lastdayonearthmysteryman48492 ай бұрын
Jessie is a prime example of a final four fired making wasn’t a thing he would’ve won the game! 43 the best player did not win the game.
@XanderMatthews-nv9zf2 ай бұрын
He would have just been voted out 3-1, I still want firemaking gone Fallen angels are half the fun of watching a season
@shofranz-moss40022 ай бұрын
Gavin Whitson sure was.
@HeelBJC2 ай бұрын
The constant bitching about the south pacific coach-sophie-albert alliance was funny at first, but has become quite tiresome. You don't like it. We get it.
@eliotedward2113Ай бұрын
Malcolm wins Philippines
@Wezo66662 ай бұрын
I know this prob won't count , but Russel deserved to win season 19 ( not 20 Pav did)