Cmon the real reason world apart is so high is because of fan favorite game changer Sierra Dawn-Thomas.
@thenic3stguy6 ай бұрын
It's always a relief to find someone who doesn't like 44 too
@masonban16 ай бұрын
Agreed very boring season with horrible editing
@tvandeu006 ай бұрын
I found Carolyn very entertaining in the first couple episodes then everything beyond that was so forgettable
@creative_commander49735 ай бұрын
Heavily agreed. I was never a fan of 44, and while I don’t think it’s an AWFUL season, it’s definitely one that isn’t that great. I always just think, 45 outclasses 44 in nearly every way
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
I was so happy when he put 44 low
@birdinflight38615 ай бұрын
Third worst season for me. I actually don’t find yam yam or carolyn to be interesting
@TrashOpinions5 ай бұрын
One World at #1? I may not always agree with you, but I respect you for having your own opinions and sticking to them. Also congrats for the anniversary, thank you for inspiring my channel.
@Mitchie465 ай бұрын
Um he put Cagayan at #1?
@matteopaolillo33175 ай бұрын
@@Mitchie46u must be pretty fun to be around aren’t you
@Mitchie465 ай бұрын
@@matteopaolillo3317 ok that’s nice of you I wasn’t meaning that in a rude way, I was rather confused about your comment
@chronologikillgaming58873 ай бұрын
@@matteopaolillo3317I mean the joke was pretty lame. I’m not surprised they didn’t get it
@namespelldwrong977924 күн бұрын
r/wooosh
@lightningmonkey7065 ай бұрын
I completely agree with your comments on Winners at War - watching it live was interesting but letting it settle and treating it as Survivor's legacy season (knowing there is an incredible and well-deserving winner) is awesome as a fan
@apecentury2283 ай бұрын
yeah it's my favorite season and was surprised to learn there were people that had it low in their rankings. I mean boot order as a rationale?! REALLY?? So, yeah I'm with ya
@Carson_yep6 ай бұрын
MeranianReview fans STAY winning, keep up the good work king!
@baileylynn55625 ай бұрын
It’s gonna be so sad when it’s no longer the 5 year anniversary of the channel 😢
@antoniomarcos25045 ай бұрын
@@baileylynn5562why
@baileylynn55625 ай бұрын
@@antoniomarcos2504 I’ve been enjoying these big ranking videos, which he’s doing for the 5 year anniversary
@zoharshaked7265 ай бұрын
Love your vids man!!! I disagree with many of your opinions but you have this very logical and calm demeanor that makes if easy for me to watch and respect your opinions and you talking about them even when I disagree, which I rarely feel!
@itzwakk3355 ай бұрын
fr, it's nice to hear someone else talk about niche rankings like this even if you may not disagree with their criteria or rankings
@TheGamerGirl23305 ай бұрын
I was shocked by 2 things 1-Island of the Idols not being last 2-Season 41 being as high up as it is
@BigShowGunnoe3 ай бұрын
41 is underrated. Best pre-merge in the new era.
@superraul6449Ай бұрын
@@BigShowGunnoeYou says that but also where the competition
@snobey5 ай бұрын
Finally fellow Nicaragua enjoyer. I like Gabon more, but Nicarague imo is more chaotic mess and funny too. The major issue is that it's one of the worst edited season ever - purpling of many players, ultra purpling of Kelly, some of the confessionals or scenes were just obviously badly edited into one making it feel like staged. And the worst: tricking Kelly into bringing only sun dress and bikini and then production really wanting to destroy her when she can't take it anymore
@realitykenzies6 ай бұрын
Just finished my rewatch in s44, (i considered it a mid-tier season) and the season was just sooo uninteresting. Even the well-liked Tika 3 doesn't enjoy me as much compared to my live watch. it also feels like s44 is the farthest from feeling Survivor on a Survivor season (if this makes sense)
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
@@realitykenzies Yam Yam was the only truely good thing about that season. That and a few idol plays. But so many people wasted opportunities to take down the Tika 3. Most of the players were just blind to them dominating the game and wasted perfect chances to do something. The only move against them was at final 4. They also never flip on eachother which is good for them but boring to watch. And yes I was rooting for Yam Yam and I love him to death but it was also the most predictable outcome as he was an obvious winner(Although most winners these days are clear). There was also no one else to root for. Good seasons have likable underdogs and/or great antagonists, this season has neither. The vote offs themselves were slow, the Helen boot, Claire boot, Josh boot, the awful Matt boot, Jaime boot, Lauren boot, are all pretty boring and even some of the other ones aren’t that great. No special episodes either when almost every season has at least one truly fantastic episode. But the worst part about it is how hyped it was, with Jeff calling it one of the greatest seasons of all time only for me and probably many others to be disappointed. While he’s entitled to his own opinions, it still let me down. I would still put the season above One World but other then that I agree with merenian’s thoughts on it.
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
@@realitykenzies I did not expect that reply to be that long I just had so many thoughts.
@swedishfishoreos5 ай бұрын
@@eastonburnor4018agree with this! Wdym that they made a move against the Tikas at f4?
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
@@swedishfishoreos The fire-making. It was barely a move but it was something
@padengeddings37465 ай бұрын
your videos keep me going
@mattleistra78804 ай бұрын
Literally Australian Outback is my favorite season -- not even joking. Devestated
@nealsidhu26975 ай бұрын
My top ten: 1) Micronesia: Fans vs Favorites (16) 2) Cambodia: Second Chance (31) 3) Cook Islands (13) 4) Cagayan (28) 5) Winners at War (40) 6) Game Changers (34) 7) China (15) 8) David vs Goliath (37) 9) San Juan del Sur (29) 10) Tocantins (18)
@Dej17385 ай бұрын
This and a box combo 🤤
@ramblingrandomthings5 ай бұрын
I been waiting for this one! Let's Goooooooo!
@Rp101015 ай бұрын
Love the higher ranking of south pacific. I have always thought it was a solid season but people hate it lol
@boomz25266 ай бұрын
I actually really like Ghost Island. Not because it's a good cast, but because there's such a hilarious story to it. Chris Noble of all people noticing the threat Dom and Wendell posed, sinking his entire game to try and take them out, only to not play his two-round idol that would've sent one of them home is the funniest storyline in Survivor history. You have anyone remotely capable of coming after Dom and Wendell going post-swap/early merge, with all of the fodder wondering why the hell they can't take out Dom and Wendell once they obtain total control. It's so funny in how bad the gameplay is, and for that reason I love it.
@AlexandreFilho17054 ай бұрын
lol it's been years since i watched australian outback (and then never watched it again) but my recollection of it is a very DRAMATIC season, with floods and people falling in fires and Jerri being horny af
@TrashOpinions5 ай бұрын
OMG THANK YOU for putting All Stars at the 3rd worst, it's so bad!
@EcneBanjo5 ай бұрын
David vs Goliath and Cagayan are the peak of series, in my eyes.
@renything580615 күн бұрын
Completely agree with season 41 xx
@ZaynIqbal-e3g2 ай бұрын
I rematches survivor 41 and I found it so entertaining even the pre merge and the Sidney boot tribal is an all time great tribal but i do have the amount of advantages
@supermish89125 ай бұрын
I’m at work and NEEEDED this
@brienkillingitweber15585 ай бұрын
Damn edge of extinction number one flaming hot take
@darrylseymour-i2f10 күн бұрын
I love Redemption Island. I have watched it so many times.
@FrogInTheAlps8 күн бұрын
Rewatching worlds apart this season is incredible
@superwilly555 ай бұрын
I’m tuned in to watch this before I see people post their thoughts on your rankings on their social media’s.
@TrashOpinions5 ай бұрын
I respect you so much for being the only other one who understand that Australian Outback is bad.
@jacksonhart59615 ай бұрын
And it takes a lot of balls to say that in this fanbase
@TrashOpinions5 ай бұрын
@@jacksonhart5961 I recently posted my Survivor rankings in a Survivor group with All Stars and AO in bottom tier and Cambodia only mid. They were MAD
@queenzoroark5 ай бұрын
AO's post-merge is trash, but it isn't worse than Thailand, it can't be unwatchable than Thailand.
@TrashOpinions5 ай бұрын
@@queenzoroark I mean I personally wouldn't put AO below Thailand and One World but I respect the decision
@lightningmonkey7065 ай бұрын
I would find it difficult to put 41 above 42 and 43 any day of the week
@simonrappoport36785 ай бұрын
in 43s case for me 43 had the worst pre merge since caromaon and even worse too me
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
id put it over 43 easily, not 42 tho
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
Here’s a few more ideas: Top 10 episodes of all time Top 10 New Era episodes Top 10 premerge episodes Top 10 worst New Era players Top 10 idol plays redone
@charlieblack20wolfpack5 ай бұрын
I get the criticism of Island of the Idols but the strategy combine with real life issues shows how that kind of stuff usually plays out in real life.
@WilsonReviews6 ай бұрын
My ranking: 1. Cagayan 2. Winners at War 3. Heroes vs Villains 4. David vs Goliath 5. Philippines 6. Pearl Islands 7. Cambodia 8. Millennials vs Gen X 9. China 10. Kaoh Rong 11. Tocantins 12. Caramoan 13. Blood vs Water 14. Palau 15. Survivor 43 16. Survivor 44 17. Panama 18. Gabon 19. Samoa 20. South Pacific 21. Survivor 42 22. Ghost Island 23. Cook Islands 24. Survivor 46 25. Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers 26. Edge of Extinction 27. San Juan Del Sur 28. Micronesia 29. All Stars 30. Redemption island 31. Survivor 45 32. Vanuatu 33. Amazon 34. Africa 35. Marquesas 36. Borneo 37. Fiji 38. Worlds Apart 39. Survivor 41 40. Game Changers 41. Australian Outback 42. Nicaragua 43. Guatemala 44. Island of the Idols 45. One World 46. Thailand
@masonban16 ай бұрын
What is it that made you like Caramoan so much
@WilsonReviews6 ай бұрын
Cochran and his arc is what makes Caramoan so great to me. The Cochran arc is imo the best storyline if all time
@masonban16 ай бұрын
@@WilsonReviews interesting I never rewatched it since the initial release but Cochran is one of my favorite characters OAT
@andrewross66825 ай бұрын
Agreed Micronesia is way overrated
@fatseal99995 ай бұрын
@@WilsonReviewsThat arc is so cheesy, Dawn carries
@Foudroyant205 ай бұрын
Amazing how your top 5 is a general consensus in the community
@SobrietyWithDrake5 ай бұрын
I love your ranking videos and agree with most of your opinions but I audibly gasped when I saw Gabon that low, that is my favorite season lol.
@jjccss_6705 ай бұрын
I’d love to see a ranking of your personal favorite episodes of each season and another for you personal least favorite episodes of each season
@thenic3stguy5 ай бұрын
He already made both videos
@jjccss_6704 ай бұрын
@@thenic3stguy :O
@thenic3stguy4 ай бұрын
@@jjccss_670 i just saw that his "worst episode from every season" is currently for members only, but he will release eventually
@NDXLMusic5 ай бұрын
Would be interesting to see you do this same video but with all the international seasons instead!
@noahsrevelations12156 ай бұрын
I am a Ghost Island Stan. I will defend that season up u til the day I die
@aeschneider9915 күн бұрын
my EXACT feelings about redemption island!!
@sammo25605 ай бұрын
agreed about All Stars though rewatched after the retrospective video and yeah it’s just so draining. what should be the most fun season up to that point is possibly the least.
@zacharywooten84995 ай бұрын
Worlds apart really is the funniest season
@Drew-yu4zq5 ай бұрын
Let’s goooo TMR
@BladeBlur5 ай бұрын
I actually really like the first half of IotI...if what's his name wasn't there it would've been ranked much higher.
@Dej17385 ай бұрын
Thank you for the Worlds Apart respect, one of the most entertaining casts and seasons ever
@maxkirk9445 ай бұрын
Damn so many things I don’t agree with I guess it shows how everyone views each season differently
@darrylseymour-i2f10 күн бұрын
If Davie won David vs Goliath, that would have been awesome.
@AYT-d8m3 ай бұрын
No real blindside in 44? I thought Maddy and Brandon getting idoled out were pretty memorable.
@eliotedward211322 сағат бұрын
Themed islands shouldn't be brought back to survivor. They always eat into players screen time (SAME WITH JOURNEYS SURVIVOR 41+) causing the casts to feel hallow. But i wouldn't mind themed casts again many seasons like Cagayan, David v Goliath, San Juan Del Sur, have all been strong cast entries, maybe there's something to it being a theme idk. But those themes can boost publicity for a season without adding some bullshit island to kill time.
@justinpascal83326 ай бұрын
If Katie An was on Australian Outback it would have been the greatest season of all time
@TylerAker-ym9hu6 ай бұрын
yes 44 sucksss lol
@Thumper76395 ай бұрын
Carolyn and jam jam have to carry a bland cast on their backs lol
@helenkellerstampon5 ай бұрын
@@Robrtttt.7Carson was t 💀
@604eign5 ай бұрын
@@helenkellerstampon Carson was annoying as fuck, I would’ve wedgied that lil twerp
@Robrtttt.75 ай бұрын
@@helenkellerstampon the Tika 3 was interesting as a whole
@tyrone-dg9my4 ай бұрын
I loved 44 wdym
@antoniomarcos25045 ай бұрын
My controversial take: tocantins is around 30th for me
@ianscott32895 ай бұрын
41 above Borneo is just insane
@kae-5 ай бұрын
Why do people not like Joe (30,31,38) anymore? Did I miss something?
@math41065 ай бұрын
hes married to a conservative and kinda problematic from survivor game changers
@thenic3stguy5 ай бұрын
From what I know, apparently he's part of a hyper-masculine group and said the n-word sometimes in Edge of Extinction
@gamer_ap05 ай бұрын
He’s like a cultist now
@zoharshaked7265 ай бұрын
@@math4106that conservative has a name and it's Sierra Dawn Thomas Anglim lol
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
he apparently said the n word in EOE and is also part of this weird cult now
@andrewpratt80815 ай бұрын
Let’s go he moved MvGX up
@thosbaus47425 ай бұрын
I’m sorry but I love WAW too
@bigbrotherlivefeeds86255 ай бұрын
I always liked All Stars personally
@AaronJosephCabrera5 ай бұрын
Agree on pretty much all the explanations on the list. I'd shift things around but most are properly explained. I'd put South Pacific lower tho, the religion part of it makes me really uncomfortable.
@darrylseymour-i2f10 күн бұрын
Worlds Apart is a movie.
@troyrondeau63445 ай бұрын
Why do not like Nick Wilson? Makes no sense
@pennisss94334 ай бұрын
He’s a cousin lover
@aidanbrazill48855 ай бұрын
Day made
@gustavocampos77235 ай бұрын
I agree with CI being bad and I would actually rank it lower. The players are either unlikable, boring or Penner. And I actually think WaW is not good at all.
@theninjagamer15 ай бұрын
i still really like s44 and think its underrated
@jayjasperjp5 ай бұрын
One World is way too high
@jasmine1stan8575 ай бұрын
and not redemption island? lol
@jayjasperjp5 ай бұрын
@@jasmine1stan857 One World is my least favorite season
@charlieradant5 ай бұрын
Guess I won’t watch the BB26 live feeds for a bit
@Quatrixjs15 ай бұрын
Love seeing AS that low
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
Ok I feel like 43, 45, and 46 are too low. Sometimes I feel like people are too low on the New Era seasons. I think the others are spot on.
@dantereq5 ай бұрын
100% Agree with the 44 take probably the most overrated season in my eyes
@Clipsb34 ай бұрын
When i see these rankings from people i start to see that in my own personal rankings, the season's grade is gonna be largely decided on how much i like the winner. Redemption island is top 10 for me because of boston rob San Juan Del Ser is bottom 10 for me because i hate Natalie & her voice & attitude
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
Worlds apart being top 15 is a bit insane respectfully. People don't like it because of the bullying...obviously? Like, I thought that would be kinda obvious why most people hate the season
@garypickul26485 ай бұрын
For my money DVG is ahead of Cagayan but probably splitting hairs
@andersonfrazier64595 ай бұрын
as a worlds apart defender, thank you. finally.
@jackjacobs98464 ай бұрын
Redemption Island at #1? I may not always agree with you, but I respect you for having your own opinions (Keep them to yourself!).
@idosellsorry7255 ай бұрын
Borneo is a good season if u start there if u don’t tho it’s gonna be a terrible season to most
@jackoshea11845 ай бұрын
i really like watching ur videos but you say again sooo much it actually sometimes makes it very difficult to listen to
@MatthewOstia5 ай бұрын
Lol, Every time you announced a ranking and it wasn't 41 I was astounded. IMO 41 is the worst season of Survivor I have ever watched (including foreign seasons) . The cast sucked, the focus on twists sucked and the edit sucked. I do appreciate that you have opinions that are different from the standard though. It is very cool to hear opinions that are unique compared to the conscientious of the fans.
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
the cast part isn't true, the cast is easily the best part of the season and one of the best of the new era. I found most of the premerge boots to be pretty interesting along with the others. 41 gets too much hate. The twists are bad but the cast and gameplay makes up for it. It's not even particularly close to the worst season.
@kyosotacomics5 ай бұрын
Controversial take. S43 is the best new era season by far lol.
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
I agree that it’s the best 42 minute new era season
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
no, its probably the worst lol
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
@@noahnussbaum8693 bad take
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
@@eastonburnor4018 most people agree on this but ok👍
@Justafella9915 ай бұрын
I definitely disagree with a lot of this list, but I also totally respect it. Always thought that people gave All stars too much hate. It's a depressing season in some ways, but I really do feel that the personalities carry it very well. I really do agree and appreciate your take on Redemption Island. It's like a rollercoaster, you know how it ends, but it takes some bizzare twists and turns to get there.
@eastonburnor40185 ай бұрын
25:15 NOOO!!! BAD
@gregatkins21565 ай бұрын
Just based on gameplay redemption island is the worst season in the shows history hands down. I get that it’s interesting to see boston Rob steam roll simply because it had never been done before (similar to seeing ulong get decimated in Palau, it was weird to see a rare event like that happen).. but I believe this is the worst group of players to ever be assembled. Besides Boston Rob I don’t think a single other person played what could be called a “good” game with over half the cast being actively bad players with no potential at all.
@sanjumitra15 ай бұрын
Wow damn the new era seasons are wayyyy too low IMO! Like I think 42 is a top 10 season, s46 was really strong and S44 and 41 are great too! I have every new era season higher than you do, some wayyy higher lol Also, I am 'insane' then because I have 42 at number 8 and I completely stand by that decision. 42 is a phenomenal season to me.
@owenpierce48745 ай бұрын
Mine are: 1- Heroes vs. Villians 2- David vs. Goliath 3- Winners at War 4- Cambodia 5- Microneisa 6- Cagayan 7- China 8- Tocantins 9- 45 10- Samoa 11- Millennials vs. Gen X 12- Pearl Islands 13- Amazon 14- Koah Rong 15- 46 16- Amazon 17- Borneo 18- EoE 19- Philipinnes 20- Marqeasas 21- 44 22- Game Changers 23- Blood vs. Water 24- 43 25- HHH 26- 42 27- Panama 28- Vanuatu 29- Africa 30- 41 31- South Pacific 32- Palau 33- Guatemala 34- Cook Islands 35- Nicaragua 36- Island of Idols 37- Ghost Island 38- Gabon 39- Caramoan 40- All Stars 41- Worlds Apart 42- Australian Outback 43- Fiji 44- One World 45- Redemption Island 46- Thailand
@thegorzag8795 ай бұрын
Love to see 41 above 42
@sammo25605 ай бұрын
idk I still think WaW is massively overrated. Tony winning is incredible and the return of so many legends makes it memorable but it feels like Cambodia and EoE where it just feels kinda soulless.
@ingridmoran74976 ай бұрын
"if your able to navigate thru all the ickiness of this season" - referring to Thailand. maybe it's easier for u to "navigate thru it 🙄" cuz it doesn't affect u. u can look past it. as a woman, I can't look past it, I can't navigate thru it. I can navigate thru Australian outback being boring cuz it doesn't include sexual assault. I think a lot of male fans are able to look past a lot of the sexism and sexual harassment and still enjoy the season cuz it doesn't really affect them. it's frustrating being a female fan in this community cuz it seems like some ppl really just don't care
@zoharshaked7265 ай бұрын
I definitely agree with you as a man. It's easier to navigate through these things, no need to sugarcote it. That said, the most important thing to note is you can think whatever you want on a season with icky moments (not just sexual assault stuff, but also other shit like the Varner-Zeke stuff) as long as you know these moments are wrong and shouldn't happen. I am glad that these moments are behind us, and that production has learned from them, even if way later than it should have (I'm looking at you, IotI!!) and even these seasons have some good moments, not that it justifies any of their awful ones ofc. Regardless, BLM here clearly knows how bad these moments are and all of these seasons are like in the bottom 10, some are at bottom five really due to these moments. People have different experiences and things they can and can't navigate through. As long as you respect each other and know what's right and wrong, imo it's fine to think whatever. The patriarchy and it's grasp is awful to women, that's true, but that also doesn't mean that enjoying Thailand/IotI over The Australian Outback means disrespecting women. My cousin is a woman and she loved IotI. That doesn't mean your experience and opinions are invalid, they very much are especially as a woman who has to deal with traumatic men, in a way that I, a man, don't deal with. Sorry for the long comment, just wanted to say that at the end of the day, liking any given season even if it has icky moments doesn't neccesarily means anyone who likes it is a bad person/potential predator, as long as they know that said moments are wrong and shouldn't happen again.
@sovereignblastoise67675 ай бұрын
My favorite is edge of extension😅I like Chris as the winner of that season although I would've loved to see devons win
@jackblacks1fanaccount425 ай бұрын
Someone should do a supercut of every time he says "Alright guy BLM here back with a new video" in a video
@dougfray49475 ай бұрын
Survivor 44 dislikers unite!
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
Survivor 44 is nowhere near the worst new era season. I feel like its a consensus that 43 is. Also it being under one world, redemption island is a bit ridiculous Edit: Upon watching more of the video...41 is not the 3rd best new era season lol
@gregatkins21565 ай бұрын
41 is hands down the concensus worst new era season. I think 43 has the pretty agreed upon worst winner, but there are other aspects of it that bring it up. For me personally 44 is in contention for the worst season but I think the vast majority of fans would say 41
@spenjaminn38465 ай бұрын
From what I’ve seen, the general consensus is that there are 3 tiers of new era seasons: - 45 and 46 are the two best ones - 42, 43, and 44 are all in the same tier, and worse than the two above - 41 is pretty definitively the worst of the bunch
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
@@gregatkins2156 @spenjaminn3846 the only reason 41 is the “consensus” worst season is by the casuals who want to shit on the new era. There is no way 43 is a better season than 41. 41 has worst twists, but overall I find the cast way more interesting than 43’s. 43 is extremely top heavy, 41’s premerge boots actually were pretty memorable to me. Also the ending of 43 doesn’t help its case at all. I can tell you the majority of super fans think 43 is the worst.
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
@@spenjaminn3846 also don’t group 42 with those two lol. It belongs in the top tier of new era seasons.
@spenjaminn38465 ай бұрын
@@noahnussbaum8693 I never said that was my opinion, that just seems to be the general consensus from what I’ve obvserved
@ci_blanch54076 ай бұрын
Thanks again for another great video! Some thoughts: -I agree that AO is the worst season, and I have All-Stars ranked as the second worst season. So good on ranking those as the worst and third worst seasons! -This may be an unpopular opinion, but I would have Island of the Idols a few spots higher since I do enjoy the pre-merge episodes and finale episode. I do think that it's a better season than 44 and One World. -I can understand not liking Ghost Island, but I think that you underrate it here. It actually has a very good cast; the problem is that most of the interesting players are taken out in the pre-merge. That may have hurt the season later on, but it actually did make for a very good pre-merge. The merge episode and finale episodes are also excellent. Even with most of the post-merge of that season being boring I think that it deserves a bit more love. -I actually do like Redemption Island more than most people do, but it should not be above Ghost Island, Caramoan, and Game Changers. -I am glad that you recognize that 44 is not good! Outside of a great premiere episode that season was awful. I am not sure exactly why Probst seemed to be high on that season before it aired, though I guess that it was because of the Tika 3. -Palau below Cook Islands is just wrong. I really enjoy the story in Palau, though seeing Koror have to turn on each other in the last few episodes was a lot more interesting than the decimation of Ulong that happened in the pre-,merge. -I am glad that we agree that 41 is the best season of the 41-44 stretch, and that 42 was overrated by the fanbase. But I do think that you overrate 41 in this case. It should not be above Palau., Game Changers, Fiji, and Gabon. -It's nice to see that you recognize that HHH is a good season despite the controversy at the end, but I would have it a few spots higher. -It's nice to see that you're not as high on Cambodia as much of the fanbase is, though I think that you still overrate it here. It's easily a bottom half season to me. -I am glad to see the love for Nicaragua, South Pacific, and Worlds Apart. -It's great to see Millennials vs. Gen X in the top 10! -Winners at War should not be this high. I understand wanting to view it as a celebration of the show and not a regular season, but the fact is that it's really not that good. There are so many other seasons that are simply better. But I do agree that the Tony win is extremely satisfying. -I don't agree with SJDS being as high as it is. The last three episodes are terrific, but it had been such a slog up to that point that I can't see it as a top half season. -I know that it is an extremely popular season, but I think that David vs. Goliath is way overrated. Outside of Angelina and Alison I feel like the cast is actually pretty mediocre, and I don't think that the season is that fun to watch outside of the stretch from the John boot through the Gabby boot.
@fatseal99995 ай бұрын
I love all of these takes but DvG and 42 are so awesome
@sethbryant55395 ай бұрын
I disagree with Ghost Island. A lot of solid casting choices
@darriusbethea23734 ай бұрын
46 best new era season. 43 and 41 are some of worst. 44 I think cast for me is great but lot of season problems are production fault. I 100% believe S44 could’ve been a top tier season without production interference
@devinthesupersmosher5 ай бұрын
He would hate naonka if she was white and I am 100 percent certain of this fact ew
@bobisgreat94332 ай бұрын
I feel like you wouldn’t tho.
@cantremember8172 ай бұрын
respectfully, this list is terrible
@cathalmp5 ай бұрын
Thank you I'm sick of hearing about how crazy and quirky Gabon is, completely overhyped
@jacksonhart59615 ай бұрын
It’s not even that crazy. It’s just mean spirited and icky to watch.
@theggamer28245 ай бұрын
I will not stand Heidi and Lauren slander!!!!
@AMZiption5 ай бұрын
Unpopular opinion. Heroes vs Villain's is a bottom tier season. Heroes is a all time bad tribe that just feels ugly to watch, with half the heroes being whiney and jerks. Villain's is a good tribe until rob is out. Russell isnt anywhere as interesting as his first season, as he has gone full jerk, and learned nothing from his first season. Sandra is a boring winner who failed to get what she wanted the whole season and kinda just lucked her way to a win.
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
yea this is a HOT TAKE
@sanjumitra1Ай бұрын
I SO AGREE! The season has SO many slow points, its ridiculous.
@andrewross66825 ай бұрын
Micronesia waaayyyy too high on this list, multiple quits, medevacs, boring and lackluster fans tribe really drag this season down
@thenic3stguy5 ай бұрын
Yes, there's no way a season with so many quits and medevacs is top ten in my ranking. But i think the fans tribe is kinda great tho
@WilsonReviews5 ай бұрын
@@andrewross6682 imo Micronesia is the season that has the biggest discrepancy between its pre merge and its post merge
@andrewross66825 ай бұрын
@@WilsonReviews how can a season with such a heavy distinction throughout the season be top 5….
@noahnussbaum86935 ай бұрын
you're kidding...its like objectively a top 10 season
@andrewross66825 ай бұрын
@@noahnussbaum8693 nope I find it very overrated, would probably rate it mid 20s