Syria - Signs of the Day of Judgment on Their Nation

[@BrRizzy1]

Mashallah, so much wisdom from our respected shaykh, may Allah preserve him and grant him greater and greater wisdom and give us all the tawfiq to continue learning from him. Ameen.

[@abeliever6823]

Dr. Yasir Qadhi. May Allah increase you in sound knowledge, ikhlaas and taqwa. May Allah bless your efforts and work and protect you and your family from evil - seen and unseen

[@v1nc3nt_bl4ck4]

Ameen

[@FaizaanDoria]

Ameen

[@3boys1family]

Ameen

[@hidayajiffry185]

Allahumma aameen. So deep explanation, Alhamdulillah

[@samiraelyahiaoui2918]

Afrer the suddenly dead of my beloved mother..Allah i Rhamha, about almost 5 years ago...i found peace and tranquility in the lessons and lectures of dr Yasir Qadhi about the Barzakh...May Allah azawajal grant him Jannah for this..

[@OnePathNet]

May Allah guide us towards the right path and grant us all Jannah Tul Firdaous

[@abdikaniabdi-tl5jp]

30:51 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊 30:51 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@ab6915]

Ameen

[@3boys1family]

Ameen

[@MunsurSilpy]

Please pray for the all suffering people of Palestine. May Allah help and protect all Palestinians. 😭😭😭😭😭😭Allah! Please fulfill my right wish.

[@mossaabmossaab8689]

Jazakallah Khair I’ve been seeing this everywhere and I actually believed it !

[@Styrophoamicus]

It's important to have scholars like Sheikh YQ during times like this to cut through a lot of the emotional rhetoric and approach things from a rational perspective.

[@rifaatj]

Valuable lecture. May we all be guided. May tge Almighty Have mercy

[@desirableboy1524]

To confirm sheikh statement about ulama not involving is politics, I'm from Iran and for 40 years this regim of isna ashahri shia are extreme specially for things like hijab, but result is after 40 years I can say 50 percent of people hate Islam to the core, because of that they insult our prophet and even quote and quote their imams. Besides I confirm this reality, I live with this drama

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

SubhanAllah how unfortunate. I don’t know why people in the comment section are complaining they should take a look at the situation in Iran and Afghanistan. They thought forcing Islam would help but it did the worse thing ever. I’ve met people from Iran who completely abandoned Islam, it I can’t blame them. I blame those mullahs

[@neoakram6354]

Salaam from Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@shifeq9770]

what are the main tourist spots in Scotland, planning to visit on January

[@Zohaib_Films]

Wa'alaikum assalaam ❤

[@mohamedadan5842]

Slam from England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿

[@KingRapz13]

Wa salamu 3laikum

[@neoakram6354]

@@shifeq9770 Loch Lomond

[@ibraheemahmad2219]

Can you make a series briefly/in-depth on the Science of Hadith? May allah reward all your efforts. Ameen

[@vvaloachi7263]

What a Great scholar ALLAH Has blessed us with !!! May ALLAH grant you more knowledge and wisdom to serve the Ummah.

[@faheemanighat7632]

SubhanAllah ♥️ beautiful series ♥️

[@snail1833]

thanks for sharing , i learned something new 🙂

[@Afthab19]

Thank you so so much for this clarification sheik I have never watched lectures of shia islamic scholars but my youtube feed was filled with recommendations of Sufyani , Khorasani and Yamani etc See how algorithms work!!

[@shaemaarif9944]

same here

[@muhammadamin6742]

Mashaa Allah Shaikh

[@InspiredStrangers]

Jazak Allah Khair shaikh, beneficial. But thumbnail is a bit of a click bait 😉

[@lakiglasgow]

I am happy to hear this kind of lecture whic not afraid to address the sensitive black chapters in islamic history

[@AKirenM]

Walaikumusalaam Wa rahmatullahi Wa barakahatuhu Barak Allahu Feek, Aameen Alhumdulillah for a thorough discussion and some well-stated points regarding Hadith and Hadith authenticity. A future khatirah incorporating authentic Hadith regarding Dhajjal etc,. would benefit the Ummah in sha Allah. Thank you very much for emphasizing that ulema can serve as guides to Allah(swt)’s laws without being involved directly in politics and that countries’ leadership should take a “soft approach” in order for religiousity to thrive while enjoining good and forbidding evil in sha Allah. Aameen to the duas. May Allah (swt) guide us all to be the best of role models, leaders, and implement that which pleases Him, Aameen. Jazakum Allahu khairun As salaam u alaikum Wa rahmatullahi Wa barakahatuhu

[@shakhan1535]

More lectures like these please. We need to awaken the Ummah. The children. Inspire the next Salahuddin, Othman, Haroon Rasheed, in Sha Allah 💕

[@LegendaryZakaria]

Good upload

[@zulihumamushtaq6345]

Alhamdullilah. very informative.

[@drosamahassanniazi8946]

Mashallah Excellent and wholesome approach

[@WalkInthepark-gz4vc]

Really looking forward for similar lectures on Pakistan with the same veracity as you've used when talking about the Israel Gaza war and Syria.

[@eHidaya]

Syria and Palestine are from bilad us sham,the blessed lands..المسجد الاقصیٰ الذی بارکنا حولہ۔۔and prophet prayed for that land...what is there to talk about Pakistan Islamically?

[@junaidsalie3560]

What’s happening in Pakistan

[@Doobler-m5v]

May Allah SWT bless you so wise and so clear. I am now one of your fans Sheikh Yaasir

[@zraruko9683]

It's worth listening. 👌

[@johhnlawrencee3651]

Abu Suftan fought Rasullullah, Muawia fought Ali ra, and Yazid fought and killed Husain ra. What other proof do you need. Our religion Islam comes from Muhammad saw, Abu Sufyan and his family fought against the family of Muhammad saw.

[@Sitschuu]

Does anybody know the name of the song at the end?

[@HafizFaridAhmad]

People of Afghanistan were so respectful to the Islamic scholers before. And now when they see the smallest mistake done by a politician, who is obviously a Mullah, they start discriminating all the scholers of Islam. It's the reality of today's Afghanistan

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

That’s the Sheikhs point. It actually makes the public hate the scholars and Islam as well unfortunately

[@Bosnjo24]

Mahdi comes in a time where only thing left of quran is it's calligraphy.

[@hamadalisuleiman4694]

Alhamdulillah I know English so I am well connected to the people if knowledge.

[@uponsunnah6986]

I, a no body, politely disagree with YQ on the idea that "scholars shouldn't get involved." Syria is in need of scholars to guide them to what is right. There are so many different ideas and sharks out there looking to get a piece of something. The people in podcasts are asking where are the scholars? The scholars are needed to guide the leadership, not run the country. When the scholars don't want to get involved, how can you expect any good to come out of the situation?

[@miah146]

He said not to get involved in politics

[@shifeq9770]

there are many rules in Islam which can only be applied if there is political power, if scholars get out of it, who will do it ?

[@shifeq9770]

for example Islam says riba is haram, it is something to be applied practically at the political leadership, not just theoretical preaching. Yusuf (a.s) asked king to grant him finance ministry to run the economic affairs of country.

[@Noor-e2t5c]

​@miah146then wat just watch ppl being masscrd or ppl indulging in interstate hypocrisy n just keep mum???

[@Kangaroo-f5t]

Except the last line, I think YQ said exactly what you said. What are you disagreeing to?

[@ashaluwalakazeem9063]

Jazakumllahi Kharan for the lecture. May Allah accept it as an act of ibadah. By the way, what's the name of the nasheed that always plays at the end of the lectures?

[@redo8286]

Zjazakolah ghairan sheikh

[@Bambino2440]

ONE UMMAH ONE CURRENCY! ☝🏽

[@SadafKhan1407]

Masha Allah, I feel people are celebrating, and deep down I am feeling fear .

[@mektrode]

Very important reminder overall. A leader should not be a scholar but should be god-fearing and practicing. People conflate that these days. In many muslim countries anyone who prays 5 daily and constantly recites quran is jokingly called a "Sheikh" and I feel that is part of the problem. A scholar is on a whole other level above. But a practicing leader who has scholarly advisers as well as various other advisors seems best wallahu a3lam.

[@NeelRah]

Islamic scholars, sheikhs or Imam in America have a key role in guiding and representing the Muslim Ummah, especially during times of global challenges and injustices, often linked to U.S. government actions. They should focus on uniting the community, advocating for justice, and voicing concerns to the government through proper channels. if needed they need to give some concessions to their lifestyle. Their Knowledge should not be used for personal gain but to serve the community. Avoiding leadership while accepting support like sadaqah and hadiya undermines trust. Debates on Hadith, such as those about Khorasan or the black flag, should focus on their relevance to current Muslim struggles. Whether these Hadiths are strong or weak, what practical impact do they have? They speak of events in the future-so why create fear? Scholars should aim to promote unity, strength, and informed action, not fear or personal influence. When academics block others for differing opinions, it shows a lack of respect for open dialogue and truth-seeking. This attitude harms unity and hinders the ability to address the challenges facing the Muslim Ummah

[@Nafshadow]

الحمد لله دائما و أبدا 😊🤲🏽 Al-Hamde li-Allah Forever

[@الاماني-ف4خ]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@riantje]

I’m not sure if I agree with the scholars not being fit to run countries or to get involved into politics, because that will mean that Islam is only a vision and something that you preach. I think the issue that we have in the Muslim world is that scholars are not educated or experienced enough in the field of management and politics. You need a different skills set to run a country with a lot of diversity than when you are studying or researching Hadiths and preaching about the ideal Islamic world. To help people grow to the ideal world you need to help them figure out how to reach that world. So scholars have an important role to play in politics, but need to learn to play the game according to their own terms while giving room to others to play the game according to their terms.

[@bilalbaig8586]

The issue with scholars in politics is that you have to make compromises. A scholar who teaches Islam cannot make such compromises because he is synonymous is with Islam itself so it appears as if Islam itself is making compromises. A politician is not held to the same standard so if he makes a mistake theh he is replaceable.

[@islamictreasuresacrosstime5529]

Well said

[@Noor-e2t5c]

well said

[@Kangaroo-f5t]

yeah, I agree with you. Scholars ... are who they are. I mean that's why they are scholars. They live in a different dimension. AND that's the problem. Realisticly, one need to , sometimes take some majors that can be.. conversial. Look at Salahuddin Ayubi. Everyone knows his bravery and leadership. But he also has some dark history. Which is why he is a great leader. BUT can scholars take those dicisions?

[@VangolaXProdiGee]

Sheikh I’m genuinely confused. Who do you suggest leads us in politics if not scholars. And weren’t you saying the importance of Muslims being involved in politics not too long ago now you’re saying the scholars should be the furthest from politics ¿ I’m genuinely seeking clarification. Jazak Allahu Khairan. Something’s seems sporadically different about the sheikhs views. I hope he wasn’t visited by the man.

[@shifeq9770]

maybe he wasn’t invited for any political role

[@Noor-e2t5c]

wow my thoughts too...arent we always told islam is a way of life?? arent we always told religion n politics go hand in hand?? now shuld we believe like th rest who think state n religion shuld b separated?? am confused too

[@HHasan-of2vi]

The problems we are facing today because of two major tasks we as a Ummah leave long ago, we separated politics from Islam and the other thing we abandoned Jihad.

[@Bekabai]

Scholars are basically nerds who never been in a stressful situation, warrior with some basic Islamic training should lead the country, or scholars with military background who participate in ghazawat

[@callistoscali4344]

If you are American, find someone who will lead you in politics based on your own values. America is not an Islamic state nor will it ever be one. Other people, Christians, Jews, Hindus, atheists, etc don't ask for political leaders based on religious affiliation, neither should Muslims.

[@DealsDirectOnlineTeam]

Shaikh, why are you using the wrong title for this lecture. Isn't wrong?

[@FindingTheTruthSeries]

With all due respect sh yasir, but politics is a part and parcel of scholarship since islam is a socio-political ideology. In fact, the scholars have said that one qualifications to become khalifa is to be a scholar.

[@skepticalplatypus55]

Which scholars? YQ just referred to Ibn Khaldun who said the opposite.

[@maverich767]

Umar r.a wasn't a scholar but his son Abdullah was more scholarly. He didn't get himself to be involved in the first and second political fitnah. His contemporaries Husayn r.a and Abdullah bin zubayr stood up against the tyranny. Hence , in my opinion, the madrasah made scholars during our time are not the best candidates to be a khalifah. Need a braveheart. That's why Imam mahdi is not a scholar. Allah will change him overnight.

[@Kveldred]

Politics is part and parcel of scholarship in the same way that corruption is part and parcel of government: yeah, people will definitely mix these things together, but it is invariably to the detriment of the latter.

[@shaguftanasreen-z4x]

Very interesting Dr Qadri might be going to Canada for RIS, and therewould be more religious scholars there ,maybe they should asked to debate this.

[@tamilm2812]

You are right ...

[@omerkhan7724]

Towards the end part of the talk, there are some missing points like when its said "Ulema should be the farthest from politics", then Gaza genocide happens and Bosnian and so on, without Muslim rulers doing nothing. Consequently, many ayaat of the Quran and many authentic ahadith are not acted upon. So, thats a big statement sheikh has made, based on my knowledge. The naseehah that "let other live" is within the Islam, so if some Aalim as the ruler doesn't do so and impose a hardcore narrow minded way to accept and be a certain way or be punished, then that aalim ruler has not understood the Islamic political system that our beloved Prophet (Sallallahu alaihi wasallam) showed us and the khulafa ar rashidoon followed! my humble advice would be: Ulama should not just be indulged in Fiqhi issues and discuss and debate with one another about matters that are completely theoretical and extra complicated, but should start seeing Islam as a political system and study that. so when Allah gives them chance to rule, they do it well and not do as the sheikh referred done in history and currently as well.

[@pierreclifton1865]

Respectfully, cohabitation between sects is the heart of the issue. No schools, no real medical service, no life in these war zones. I am not motivated by continued and renewed fighting. Syria started this in 2011...its going into 2025. How many dead??

[@buzzybeee7122]

Assalammualaikum, we are asian and dont have winter. Sorry to ask this - how cold is it in the masjid?

[@mturzo]

Can you summarise please?

[@maxshah6426]

Dear Sheikh, Please answer my dillema, you have always talked about how the Shiia Muslims are on the wrong path and our version is the true faith but we have seen that it is the Shiia Muslims that are standing in the face of tyranny and Kufr, Lebanon=Shia / Yemen=Shia/ Iran= Shia... I don't understand why the Shiaa Muslims are protecting and helping Palestine which are Sunni Muslims. Please Talk about this. Thank you dear Dr.

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

People keep saying this. But ask yourself how many IDF soldiers have the shia killed? People keep repeating that Iran is the defender of the Muslims, but who have they defended except for themselves? The only time they ever hit Israel was in retaliation for when Israel hit the first. Until now Iran has yet to kill a single IDF soldier but people keep calling them the defenders of Islam

[@makparto]

Beautiful work mashallah. Please Ustadh the name of the Nasheed at the end of

[@r.s.nowrin6243]

Ibrahim Bakeer- Bakat Ayni

[@makparto]

@@r.s.nowrin6243 Jazak Allah ya akhi

[@Ojw-z8r]

As-salamu alaykum wa rahmatullah, Respected Shaikh. I was quite confused by your statement today that religious leaders should not get involved in politics. My question is, where are religious leaders involved in politics, except for Afghanistan? Afghanistan has become far more peaceful than Western nations. They may be poor, but that is not a cause for concern, as our beloved Prophet Mohammed (S.A.W.) was also poor. Another point you mentioned, Respected Shaikh, is that there should be a kind of freedom. Fine, but to what extent? Should it be like MBS's way, Sisi's way, Dubai's way, or the Pakistani way? You also mentioned the issue of black flags. While that may be a "Hassan" Hadith, you yourself are weakening it by following one Islamic scholar. This has created a lot of confusion.

[@sabriahabib893]

SubhannAllah

[@eduzoom3476]

When will you talk about saee hadeeth. Why you people are afraid to tell the hadith related to sham and yamen. Are you on the other side.

[@isi70.90]

Does someone from whom the nasheed at the end is?

[@istanbul3874]

Dr. Yasir Qadhi. Thank you for the enlightenment on this topic. Can you please also evaluate this supposed Hadith, which I found in a video on the internet? It seems to fit somehow: Hijaz will be ruled by a man whose name is the name of an animal, if you see him from far, you would think he’s crossed-eyed, and if you come close to him, you do not see anything (wrong) in his eyes. He will be succeeded by a brother of his, named Abdullah. Woe to our Shia (followers) from him!” - He repeated it three times - “Give me the glad tidings of his death and I give you the glad tidings of the appearance of the Hujjah (Imam Mahdi).

[@109destiny]

Lmao he would never

[@Youuber-hh4vd]

Well then only time will tell if the Hadith is Fabricated or not.

[@AliÇetinkaya-y3o]

Allah ilmini artırsın

[@naeem6722]

Not convinced on the sufyani bit as there are other equally knowlegable scholars saying it's true. Wasn't too long back when he was saying muslims need to be part of politics and also encouraged voting.

[@adz8709]

Muslims should be a part of politics. Unless and until we are educated and powerful enough to start getting into positions to be able to enact change.. that will ONLY happen when we are in politics enacting change and policy!

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

There’s no discrepancy between what he said before and what he said today. Of course we politicians who are practicing Muslims. He didn’t counter what he said. He just said that those politicians shouldn’t be scholars. Makes sense, ibn Abbas, ibn Omar, Imam Ahmed, Imam Malik, Imam Shaafici and Imam Abu Haneefa and Bukhari were all famous brilliant scholars and not politicians. They left the political scene for the Muslims who know best in that sphere. Also being a leader comes with certain fitna that scholars prefer to avoid

[@omarsalim9562]

so bukhari is the most correct yet we find some of crezzy hadith inside his book

[@shahabandrabi9130]

I have a question concerning what he says. If specifications mean that the Hadith is fabricated, how about the specifications concerning Mahdi (AS). Do you reject it as a fabrication? Also about the Hadith of Hajjaj ibn Yusuf, wherein His Tribe is mentioned? Anyone can jump in to help me out, if Mr. Yasir is too busy to answer. 2.

[@callmechowdree689]

Strange conclusion. What good is there in letting scholarship flourish where dawah remains abstract, theoretical and secularised? Where only individual rituals are permitted and the rest of Islam hollowed out? We need our scholars to be our leaders or to at least account them - that is the way of the righteous predecessors.

[@wasimshaikh9727]

Why so low light 🚨

[@truthseeker127khan8]

N what did Prophet(SAW) said about a leader ?

[@zabirhussain]

So much for the ikwan ul muslimeen and islamist - in reference to last part of the talk, political islam. An utter fallacy we were taught all these years So glad you clarified it here

[@bilalbaig8586]

Without them we wouldn't have the victory in Syria today.

[@shifeq9770]

can you explain what you meant, so that I can dismantle and debunk your statements

[@lashialasunni]

I think you jumped into wrong conclusion, political islam is wronged by the dirty and selfish politicians, other wise political islam was flourish for more than 1000 years

[@NightMare-nq2we]

He himself is playing politics to avoid his responsibilities during the time where Muslims are facing challenges around the world .

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

What responsibilities is he avoid??

[@NightMare-nq2we]

@@naimaabdullahi6272 First , what did you understand about whats is been talking here ?

[@idrea43]

8:09 Depends on their methodology used to declare it weak 'ohhh it doesn't seem like something he would have said according to what i think' which is common in today's age and is illegitimate and worthy of flogging. Important distinction

[@SA-bm2tv]

28 : 35 This is what maulana Arshad madani sahib preaches in India

[@zak2509]

Weren't the first four khulafa not scholars? Ibn khuldoun statement is inconsistent

[@jbs3348]

Prophet Sw: was directly involved in politics and he was the greatest intellectual at the same time. This man says ulamas should not get involved in politics. Crazy

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

The Prophet ﷺ was the best of Allahs creation. He was the perfect role in EVERY single department, whether it be father, husband, relative, friend, imam, army general, teacher, leader. He ﷺ was the best in everything. But human beings are different, that’s why ibn Abbas, ibn Omar, imam Ahmed, Abu Haneefa, Shaafici, Malik and Bukhari and others stuck to scholarship and teaching rather than entering the political sphere. The abandoned the political part to those who know best in that department. So this isn’t a new concept that Yasir Qadhi is first introducing. Many scholars of the past used to avoid getting into politics also sometimes to avoid the fitna that comes with leading

[@anonymoussoul3343]

he was not doing politics after implementing the ruling of Islam, he was just being a autocratic leader of his community dismantling all others political groups.

[@chekkat8956]

​@@naimaabdullahi6272 They went against the state which is why Imam Abu Hanifa Imam Malik Imam Shafi Imam Hanbal went to prison.

[@RTAmin-r6p]

Can you share?

[@muhsinthana]

Feeling very strange about the ending statements from shaikh! Not at all expected

[@ahlulislam313]

He has definitely gone wrong on that point.

[@anonymoussoul3343]

thats why Islam is funny, it makes people delusional

[@billikash2591]

❤

[@user-rn3bb3dj4p]

Saudi arabia under the salafi dawah after the fall of european imperialism in the muslim lands is a perfect example of modern success. All other nations who chose a more secular, liberal, communist path have suffered, like egypt, yemen, pakistan,... Turkey is just now recovering. To all their own views, but we do not need scholars whom graduate from oxford and sorbonne leading us into jahannam, and disgrace in this world like they have been doing for the past 70- 80 years.

[@Asaad-Khan]

The establishment of Saudi Arabia as a nation state itself was the ultimate project of European imperialism. Saudi Arabia and Israel are allied. The success you're talking about is the wealth that was generated from the Petro dollars. What a joke. Dajjal comes with a fire and a river, apparently Saudi Arabia since it's successful according to you is in Dajjal's river which in reality is the way to fire(hell)

[@tajudeenabdulkareem1528]

As'salaamu alaykum waramahtullaah wabarakaatuhu

[@Khan10650]

👌

[@goldenibby]

What was said in 27:00 ???

[@dmvbangla4174]

Interesting is Shaikh pointing hadis and not from Quran.

[@Mohammadz491]

Assalamualikum ......

[@seassault]

10:48

[@khalilullahtaaj8741]

The grave of Abu Muslim Al Khursani is in Afghanistan and He was from Afghanistan.

[@thebachu786]

And what if Dajjal was released? You have to have an open mind to the possibility.

[@jayak3768]

25:00, sorry respectfully I disagree with Scholars not getting involved in politics. In fact scholars should get involved in politics so we get good honest leaders and not corruption as we currently have.

[@zainzoala1083]

To get involved is oke but to make it look like that this time is the time a Hadith is talking about is wrong and misleading. Because only Allah knows best

[@tahmidislam5208]

If you want proof of how this can backfire , look at the example of the deobandi movement and how it’s entry into politics lead to the extreme group of the Taliban

[@anonymoussoul3343]

it's a common delulu, if religions involved in politics then people must criticise the ruling of prophet and his companion, will you like it?

[@maverich767]

Sheikh I listened to your Hadith about Isa a.s coming down at the white minaret of the masjid in Damsyik on the eastern part Isn't this Hadith also very specific. But you didn't mention that Ibn Taimiyyah, Ibn Jauzi or ibn Qayyim said that whenever the Hadith is specific , that is a sign of problematic Hadith regarding end of time.

[@naimaabdullahi6272]

That one is an authentic and verified Hadith. I think he’s talking about ones that aren’t authentic and very detailed

[@hadirajaee]

I didn't know how much you muftis disagree with each other over hadiths. That's why it's impossible to argue with you.

[@Meccabestplace]

Allah ❤

[@ШАМИЛЬМУРАДОВ-о7и]

In shaa Llah.

[@siyawashnishat]

You are a treasure the ummah. I am from northern Afghanistan we respect you here.

[@sk190]

Meh. They said the signs were there at time of crusades and ertugrul.

[@khomol]

The end analysis is completely unnecessary. He says scholars should not talk about politics and yet he talks about politics and yet again undermines himself. Islam is not flourishing in the west, far from it. Only a non-scholar, someone who works with a cross-section of society understands this point. The majority of our kids in the west are not practising this religion. The majority of people in an area taking cross-sectionally, does not pray and has very little understanding of Islam. Contrast this to the Muslim countries it is the other way round. The fact is Muslims in the east are living Islam, I’m struggling with occupation both physical and financial. Those systems of oppression came from the west and still very much have their conception, inception, and propagation from the west. This whole thing is fishy.

[@Staytrue-gk6ex]

I don't completely agree with your assessment. There are many people who are practicing Islam in the west and many who are even converting to Islam and better Muslims than born Muslims. It may be the circles you are with but the circles I have been with many are very practicing and we regularly give dawah and many converted and are very practicing Muslims as well.

[@IVFRegulation]

Yes exactly, Ibn Taimia and other scholars were courageous enough to be responsible for their knowledge!! You don't have to compromise your lovely audience with true words!!

[@muhammadkhan7051]

Ibn Khaldun’s statement makes no sense (so I’ll check and verify this myself), given that he himself was a politician and a scholar. Moreover many other examples of learned statespersons, we know of the famous Nizam Ul Mulk.

[@michaelyosef3430]

Yes, and look at Gaza. Even God can`t help them.

[@idrea43]

2:20 Any system that lacks a methodology to distinguish forgeries from true information can legitimately be rejected by a human as something they will follow and presume is from God. No religion has the ability to distinguish between the 2 beside Islam with its science of hadith [documenting the men in the chain back to the prophet and what he says, along with biographies of said men in the chains to establish their reliability]. The jews [in talmud pertaining to conversations had between rabbis] and christians [in bishop lists] and shia [pathetic hadith system] have lists of names but these people are unknown, with no corroboration by others. Historically unreliable. Order of robustness of an ideology's chain of transmission system from weakest to strongest Christian's --> Jews --> shia --> Sunni Islam Only sunni Islam's system establishes certainty beyond reasonable doubt about reports mentioned, able to distinguish true information from false Alhamdulilah

[@prasg1186]

☝️

[@SulaimanLebbe-r5g]

Muslim politics is so weak and pathetic since the time of the 4 caliphs times

[@adz8709]

Our politics is weak? Out of 1400 years of Islam Muslims have been superpowers for about 1200 years atleast! That shows weakness to you??

[@Lun641]

💐🤍🤲

[@hannibalking85]

Hazrar Ali was a philosopher, politician, warrior. Why r u preaching ppl to be apathetic while there is a gencoide taking place and millions are suffering all over the world

[@elif-dq3vu]

"Apathetic " 😂 did you even listen to the lecture?

[@hamnalodhi8946]

Where did he do that brother pls snap out of presumption

[@hassanmakame]

Listen to him again...he is only giving his opinions based on his knowledge and experiences from what he has learned from the writings of great scholars like Ibn Khaldun and what he has witnessed over the last few decades. He is arguing, most of scholars are idealistic while political leadership is about what is practically possible... Example, if someone converts to Islam today, then he has to start following what Islam teaches immediately, but that's more idealistic(it's what the scholars will tell you) because this person lacks knowledge on Islam, what's practical is for him to start reading and learning about Islam and implementing whatever he learns slowly(this is now political leadership)....! I heard someone defining politics as the art of ممكن (what is possible)....!

[@MuslimZealot]

Wasn't Ibn Khaldun involved in political matters himself? 🤔 Let's grant that Ibn Khaldun meant what Dr. Yasir is trying to say, even though I'm not convinced that's the case - let's say he does. So what? How do you quote someone centuries later and hide away the necessity of political awareness and activism from the Quran and seerah itself?? When the Prophet (saw) himself was involved in political affairs of his society?? 🤷‍♂ If Ibn Khaldun or YQ say one thing, but the Quran/seerah orders you to something opposite, who should I follow? How are you going to "enjoin the good, forbid the evil" for an entire society without getting involved in "politics"?? Talk about using the ant to hide the elephant.

[@hopsie9983]

A scholar or a group of scholars guiding the leadership is recommended over electing a scholar to become actual leader is what I think he is saying. It's rare to posses both qualities of being a strategic calculating politician and a religious scholar at the same time.

[@PASSIFICATION]

the scholars muhammed (s) trained was fit to rule an islamic ruling. 99% of those scholars trained by later scholars were not.that means the training is wrong. ulama like abu bakr umar and uthman and ali and a tonna others (r). there will always be people like them in every province in every generation. thats a divine promise. scholars divorcing politics is the crisis that started after ali(r). Gandi said: we need the ruling of umar (r).