Tabla Tutorial #6 | Chakradhar of Ustad Allah Rakha Khan Saheb Played by Pt.

We have almost reached 1000 SUBSCRIBERS! THANK YOU!
Here is a very special bedum chakradhar in #Jhaptal of Pt. Suresh TalwalkarGathered and Documented by joshua carro 2024IG - @tabla_knowledge_resource Patreon - www.patreon.com/joshuacarro
(DhaDhin DhatrktDha DhereDhere kitedhin
DhatrktDha tetekata Gadhigene
kiteDhati Dha-neki teDhatiDha -nekite DhatiDha 1 2 Ta 1 2 Ta)3x
P.S. Sorry about the sound quality of this video. My sound file was erased by accident and didn't have time to remake the video! Thank you for your patience and don't forget to subscribe and join our patreon!

[@ericboberic]

Thanks for sharing, beautifully structured composition!

[@joshuacarro]

Always happy to help. I have learned that this is a composition of Ustad Allah Rakha Khan Saheb!

[@jethathuglife3437]

Thanku very much ,very helpful 🙏

[@joshuacarro]

Very welcome and always glad to help.

[@tcsingh100]

thank you ...priceless material

[@joshuacarro]

Absolutely and agreed!

[@Prottay154]

Aha❤

[@joshuacarro]

This composition is absolutely beautiful. I consider myself so lucky to have found it, and did my best to transcribe it, although it was not learned from the source. But I do do my best to learn about the art and craft and beauty of tabla.

[@tablakamath]

It’s a composition of Ustad Alla Rakha Khan Saheb and not Suresh ji😊

[@joshuacarro]

Okay, thank you for clarifying.

[@musicbox94649]

​@@joshuacarro Thats not how the original composition actually is. Willingly or by mistake you have changed the phrases of this composition,which might be miss leading for the students and beginners who are learning from KZbin. I am telling you these because you have mentioned that you have learnt this composition from KZbin. Even if I write down the whole composition in comment,it still might be misleading. As you all know it's a oral tradition and all of the composition and thoughts of the Guru have been passed to the disciples mostly by padhanth. These traditional compositions and the Dynamics cannot be learnt only from notations.If you really like this composition, I request you to learn it from someone who has received and learned this composition to ensure authenticity of this composition. Whatever you share, many beginer students will learn from this, so its your responsibility to ensure the authenticity.

[@joshuacarro]

@@musicbox94649 I learned it right from this video. kzbin.info/www/bejne/mJylZ3uXrJxsnaM Did my best to transcribe. I respect your thoughts and am grateful for your feedback. I will try to do better.

[@musicbox94649]

@@joshuacarro thanks, I'm not connected with you personally. Otherwise I would have tried to correct this composition from my place.

[@musicbox94649]

From whom did you learnt this composition?

[@joshuacarro]

youtube

[@hasush]

All hail the internet gharana

[@tarangpoddar6812]

Dha din Ta-kitataka not Dha din ta-titakita, among other phrases that are wrong. I dont know why you have the urge to teach something you yourself learnt from youtube and that too wrong :D Everyone wants to teach tabla, no one wants to learn tabla.

[@MichaelKlinger-sk6qv]

i think you are wrong, tetekategadigena is a right phrase and after dha din ta anyway does not come kitetaka but tirekite which is same as tetekite, so better you review your comment before you critcise unneeded. and to quote you, everyone wants to teach others but no one can play it, does probably more apply to you than to this guy with good intentions who shared so beautifully a nice thing.

[@tarangpoddar]

@@MichaelKlinger-sk6qv Im sorry, you for sure dont know what youre talking about if you say titakita and kitataka are the same phrase :D These are two distinct and important phrases from the tabla repertoire, Im sure Joshua will himself agree to this. Secondly, this is a 'STANDARD' composition by now, composed by Ustad Alla Rakha, you can hear many many tabla players play it, so to teach such a standard thing in a way thats not written originally is quite uncalled for. Hence the criticism. If Joshua made his interpetation of the composition it would be another thing, but he is clearly attempting to transcribe it, and then teaching a wrong transcription. Good luck ;)

[@MichaelKlinger-sk6qv]

@@tarangpoddar i didnt say tetekite and kitetaka is same, they are entirely different. i sayd tetekite and tirekite is same. read my comment properly before you comment.