Who created secularism?

[@Faisal.Warraich]

Thanks, Dr Taimur Rehman, for your enlightened views

[@funnybunny_28]

Amazing to see pakistani Intellectuals supporting and learning from each other.🙌 Big fan Faisal bhai

[@manahil558]

Glad to see you here!

[@Taimur_Laal]

My pleasure my friend.

[@DWAGON1818]

What is enlightened Faisal?

[@hiddentruth1424]

@@Taimur_Laal You are saint.

[@malikfahdaliawan178]

Professor Sahab. You're a gem and you don't know it. You don't know how many people you inspire with your knowledge and understanding of the politics and economical situations. Thank you for being.

[@AlMuqaddimahYT]

An interesting thing about Martin Luther, he also sponsored the translation of the Qur'an into German and Latin. He even wrote the foreword of the Qur'an. That was meant to "prove" that the Qur'an was "fake" but still, he did that.

[@muhammadabdullahqureshi1941]

Mashallah, I would love to contact you.

[@alertcitizen6104]

Its still fake and man made garbage

[@Newsandanalysis-h2t]

Israr Ahmed Sahab was a very pious and honest person.He has also served the Quran , But his political knowledge was outdated and imaginary.

[@1neminutebonk3rs3]

he was obsessed with NEW WORLD ORDER and Illuminati! I don't know why

[@Urdupoetry465]

کیسی معلوماتی گفتگوہے۔بےحددلچسپ ۔۔۔بہت شکریہ

[@hereticmorte666]

you're doing an amazing job Dr. Taimur. much needed.

[@iramnabj2928]

Very nice tons of information on various avenues. MashaAllah I am truly fan of all my Pakistani young minds such as yourself , Fasial Waraich, Mooro, Syed Muzamil who in such a grim and confused situation pass on true knowledge to younger generation. You all are doing real Jehad by spreading truth among masses, where, what we learned in our curriculum and religious education is based on 80% of wrong and biased information. May Allah bless you all. Aameen ❤🤲 Your concluded remarks are amazing by saying that when our strategy will be based on wrong ideas and information there we never will be able to correct ourselves to rise above and beyond. Thanks

[@Babukhan-ut6lx]

We can imagine how difficult its to say something against Molvis.

[@heheboiii3566]

Like walking on a rope

[@mr.xyz32]

Islam aur christianity me interest fully banned h lekin ek yahudi non yahudi se interest le sakta h. Means yahudiyat me interest jaiz h isliye interest yahudiyo k zariye hi faila aur Dr Israel bilkul sahi bol rhe hn. Bato ko ghumao mat Professor. Isse fark nhi padta k sare yahudi interest lete the ya thode se yahudi interest lete the sawal ye h k usuli taur pe yahudiyo me interest jayz tha ab interest lega to wahi na jiske pass capital hoga jabki zyadatar yahudi garib the apne hi bola to sare yahudi to practically interest le bhi nhi sakte obviously. Apne bola Hinduo me sirf baniya interest leta h.. not at all Professor anybody in Hinduism can take interest because their religion doesn't restrict it. Ye alag bat h ke baniya sabse jada ye kaam karte hn I know because me myself from India. To ap bat usooli taur pe kijiye number mat bataiye ke kitne yahudi interest lete the. So Your whole conversation doesn't prove k yahudio ne interst nhi spread Kiya baki apki history ki tarif zarur karuga. I hope you understand my point 👍

[@mr.xyz32]

I addressed to Dr taimur so understand my point of view. Actually he is misguiding Muslims by using smart tricks bro read my full comment carefully

[@tehseenanjumkhan8650]

He is not saying anything against molvis. He is just being carefull to not to hurt feelings of followers of any religion or sect.

[@naveedakbar34]

The way you explain points is extremely easy to digest. Much Respect

[@rashidrahman9673]

Yes i agree with Dr.Israr ,add few points Europeans who hated Catholic Church, they were with this idea, to get rid of religion out of politics,

[@javediqbal6978]

ڈاکٹر صاحب مرحوم کی بہت خدمات ہیں لیکن بہت سی باتیں محض اندازے اور اعتماد سے کہ دیتے تھے۔ اللہ مغفرت فرمائے آمین

[@Stoooray]

thank you, sir! it was an interesting and informative lecture.

[@saqibaliilyasshigre5508]

well articluted and well reseacrched ...dr irshad and you both are gems

[@asifsadhu]

Thanku Dr sb, it was my wish to learn from you. Thanks to KZbin ❤🎉

[@rajamuzammilhassanhassan2373]

Thank you sir apki. Wajah new things ka pta chala or aj me apky lectures sunta rhta hu or smjhta hu

[@sikandarali320]

Thanks for very informative lecture.

[@sulemankhawaja6188]

I was also a little worried by these speech or words of Dr. Israr Ahmed sahb and wanted to know about history because I also felt that maybe history is something else, so with your grace I came to know about it Thank you sir,❤😇🤗.

[@zraruko9683]

بہت خوب ،معلوماتی اور فکر انگیز۔👌

[@SIDRAMAIMAI-xm7ru]

شکریہ ڈاکٹر صاحب اپنے تمام دوست شواہد کے ساتھ یہ اب یہاں کی کوشش کی ہے کہ سود یہود میں نہیں ہے صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کی ہجرت کے بعد مدینے کے جو یہود تھے وہ فل فل سودی کاروبار کرتے تھے جس وجہ سے نصارا کے پاس زیادہ سرمایہ اکٹھا نہیں ہوتا تھا قدرتی طور پر یہ ایک کے پتہ چلتا ہے کہ یہودی ہی سود کے کاروبار میں سب سے پہلے تھے

[@muhammadfasihkhan8508]

Sir Taimur is a natural treasure in terms of educating Pakistanis about history

[@Laraibibrahim123]

اللہ تمام مسلم امت کو ہدایت عطا فرمائے

[@kakkibannu9628]

very grateful for your enlightened lecture.

[@magrayfayaz1478]

Great reply

[@zaheerhassan1574]

Dr Sb. You should have explained who lend money to England and France during Napoleon wars

[@electronicsurdupakistan9181]

he might be afraid that top names will be Dr Tamoor himself and next will be ghamdi ,haha

[@farooqahmed809]

و من لم یحکم بما انزللہ فاولٰئک ھم الکافرون۔

[@SandeepSingh-ey4ih]

Superb, informative

[@saleemsada786]

Sir u r genius I salute u. U r our martin Luther of 2024.changing our wrong concept in our community.

[@sanaullajamshed4205]

Dear Taimur Sir, thanks for sharing your deep knowledge, we all support for your youtube channel.

[@yazdani27]

بہت خوب ڈاکٹرصاحب آپ بہت عظیم ہیں،

[@Uninformed2.0]

Thank you for your services Dr. Sahab

[@AshokGupta-oq6hs]

Sir,just a supplementary. Indian muslims are the greatest votaries of secularism in independent india.

[@mohammadyousuf6273]

Excellent lecture with a sea of information ❤

[@atiqejutt6998]

Dr taimur delivered your lecture on your own ...I think it's best...overall well elaborate..

[@ahmedfaraz5353]

Thank you for making such a detailed video on this topic. I never understood why Dr Israr Ahmed say such things about secularism when it was clear to me that what his is saying can't be true as I have read a little bit of history myself. But your detailed video along with the evidence you provided made it much more clear to me.

[@sabhat786]

Very nicely explained with evidence ....keep it up...

[@meowkitty3100]

Taimur Rahman! Lovely❤

[@hassansaeed3181]

It was enlightening to listen to you.

[@meesumnaqui7930]

Dr. Israr Ahmad was just repeating what conspiracy theorists peddle all the time. There is a famous conspiracy theorist in Urdu known as Asrar Ahmad who wrote the popular Dajjal series.

[@emran2211]

How can he provide evidence for his claims ?

[@Raju-gi3gr]

We Pakistanis have been bombing Balochistan since decades and never raised our voice like we do for Palestine or Kashmir. Karma does catch up sooner or later. Our current situation (begging and terrorism) is the Karma.

[@drshahnoor7302]

Mashallah your knowledge with humility ❤❤

[@jhonplayer447]

Keep it up bro good work❤

[@M.R.Baloch]

What about the Bank of Venice in 1157? It's considered to be the first Bank. Though it doesn't serve the General Public, it was a Bank primarily established to provide finances to Monarchs

[@sairaqureshi8470]

Knowledge is Power

[@fawadahmed7354]

Wow 😮 Dr Taimor I am your fan since 2015 love ❤ from 🇬🇧

[@pitch3697]

Professor Sahab i always wanted to difference between different groups of Christianity. thanks a lot . also do you have a good book in english about this topic

[@kodvavi150]

54:56 Dr Israr Ahmed give his opinion only over Iqbal's poetry and West's support for the state of Israel without any benefit from the Jews in return, he most likely won't be much aware of this history you are mentioning.

[@UzairSheikh]

So if he didn't knew the history then why did he recorded lectures which changed people's mental models in future

[@kodvavi150]

@@UzairSheikh You want him to not give his own analysis just because he doesn't have a little mistake in his analysis?

[@UzairSheikh]

@socker2088 analysis should be unbaised and flawless of any person who is analyzing any thing here we are 20 year after his lectures people like us can't even argue with his followers and listeners

[@kodvavi150]

@@UzairSheikh No one is absolutely unbiased. Everyone is biased in their own way.

[@kodvavi150]

@@gorgeousedit You are also saying like you are 100% sure, that's also mind programming for blind followers, indeed.

[@ch.khurramazizdhillon-csp3724]

Great Dr. Sahib

[@acousticmaania2969]

Deserve likes and comment's... Very much literate in4mative video ...

[@jhonplayer447]

We need more people like you

[@s.younis1733]

Good job. he put forth his argument by supporting it with historical facts. i am glad he remained respectful throughout the video & did not criticize dr israr as a person or an alam-e-din.

[@zafariqbal-ey5nk]

Doctor sahb,you are just fabulous

[@sirfarhanilyas12]

Thanks Sir

[@Tariqaf]

Very fine and easy to explained .

[@AmjadAli-qk3vc]

Appreciated your point sir ❤

[@Mkhizaralam]

Thanks for your contribution ❤

[@kdshak4904]

31:56 first modern society with secular constitution was USA in 1787. Two years later, in 1789, French Revolution was an effort to be like USA.

[@hassanamjad3179]

Dr Israr will be proud of you!

[@tomt.7414]

Yes you are doing amazing job

[@muhammadfahad131]

Sir, I think Israr Ahmed sb is not available to respond, so it would be better if you address these issues in some other way so that any other ulma/muslim scholar who agrees with the Israr sb ideology and comments may respond.

[@gkvalley9379]

Apna ya 2 parts is liye kiye kio k copy right clam a jata ha.is liye ni Jo vja apna jnab bayan kia

[@benjaminbenjamin8834]

Professor thanks a lot , now you are in the right direction , these are issues of PAKISTAN . Our issues are dogmatism , radicalization , sectarianism and bias against other religions and women. Dr Israr was just a propoganda specialist and nothing else . Dr Israr quoted so many wrong references and nobody was there to challenge him . I salute to your courage Professor , so please make we Pakistanis free from bias and free from dogmatic beleifs .

[@iotasymbol8498]

Aise ghtiya maulvi ki wajah se Pakistan ki aise halat ho gyi 😢😢😢

[@UthmanHumzaAhmet92]

​@@iotasymbol8498cry 😊

[@ijazawan7865]

​@@iotasymbol8498strongly agreed 💯 in Molvion k khilaf aap bol kr to dikhayen gustakhi Ka fatwa lagay ga

[@medicophilic7325]

Sir just wanna give you a kind of sincere appreciation without any exaggeration, sir my studies of medicines have little impact on me as compared to your lectures... Specially regarding the philosophical school of thoughts.. Sir you have no idea how much positive impact you have on us... Thanks again from bottom of my heart..❤️ A medical student from larkana sindh...

[@realsam4553]

Firstly, I love your lectures! I know you face many critics in Pakistan, making it crucial to fact-check everything. Germany is still split between Lutherans and Catholics. Side note: Hitler was Catholic. I understood the point you tried to make but let's not give your critics a platform to criticize you with factual inaccuracies. Once again thank you so much for the work you do!

[@Taimur_Laal]

Thank you for that excellent feedback. Keep sending me more feedback of this sort.

[@RIOUSOCHI971]

Great Dr. Taimor.. from Russia

[@aliwaheed906]

My most favourite video by Dr. Taimur.

[@sameedahmad105]

We should respect Dr Irsar Ahmad it might be because of improper knowledge. Thanks for the correction

[@saba1578]

nice explanation sir ji

[@divyanshsh]

this is a pretty important lecture

[@mr.xyz32]

Yes but just for you 😅😅😅

[@faheemahmad5062]

Sir please make video analysis at Saudi and iran peace prosis and it's impact on international and islamic would

[@shafiullah2620]

Mashallah sir G. Sir, role of military , media and bureaucracy in pakistan , pe aik aik video darkar he . agr bnasake tu bht faida hoga . jazakallah

[@meikylawan3148]

Dr sahab why were jews so discriminated against in Europe for 2000 years and now are discriminated against in the Muslim world. Is there any specific reason, do you know about some good book on history of the jews.

[@ahmedkhanchangwani2077]

Plz make a video on history of cursades and ayubi

[@saleemtaj2647]

Sir Very informative , good job,

[@muhammadyusaf5267]

Sir, want to know your point of view regarding Imran Khan's speech in response to DG ISPR. Thank you.

[@faranrockstar]

Please do a video on sects of Christianity and their history

[@SuNnYaAsH]

Dr. Sahab meray khayyal mein dr. Israr jewish zionist and evalangical Christians ka zikar kar rahay hein na kay orthodox jews

[@1neminutebonk3rs3]

this video could've been 10 mins long if Molvis were a little open to being criticised.

[@tehseenanjumkhan8650]

This is one hour and twelve minute video. How long this video is supposed to be. He talked about every thing which was required.

[@AamerPawarymyye]

Thanks ❤

[@MueedVI]

Aik aam pakistani ki koi agar manj bhi chura lay, tab bhi kehtay hain kay "yeh yahudi sazish hai". Dr sahab, apki yeh ilmi baatein 100-200 saal bad samajh main ayein gi. That's why your primary focus should be on writing books, instead of solely relying on KZbin. Great effort, nonetheless!

[@Cameron-o2x]

Videos will be also available even after 200 yrs.

[@heheboiii3566]

Nice Explanation 👍

[@thelyceumacademy7852]

سر جی تسی گریٹ ہو ۔۔لو یو 🥰

[@AbdurRahman-uy5kl]

Sir explain world war 1 please

[@mohammadahmadrocks]

This is the best KZbin channel I've discovered ❤❤❤❤

[@medusaachla]

Never mind, Abuses r appreciation that you r right.

[@Newsandanalysis-h2t]

Biggest fan of dr israr ahmed, but now i admit that Israr Ahmed Sahab has spread a lot of hatred among humans. Divided Muslim and non-Muslim.

[@NONAME-g7u1p]

Aapko sunana boht achha lgta hai Taimoor bhai ..ek shikayat hai apse ke ap such ko itnaa darr ke kehte hain...Har bat ko kehne se pehle ap khud ko uss bat se alag kar lete ho jabki wo such hai ...aur ap bhi ye such logon tak ponhchana chahte ho

[@Zubair409]

Love you sir❤

[@azizhakim5480]

Dr sb, I think that the word Secularism was first introduced when it was said that this or that thing was not in the domain of the Church, Rather it was said that this or that thing lies in the Seculrar domain.

[@zaheerhassan1574]

Yes Christian and Chinese practice d lending but used loophole in their system to do so but some people take it as their God granted right to charge interest to others except their own people. If Christians were doing it, they were charging to their own Christian as well.

[@antid_oto]

Unfortunately, as popular as Dr. Israr is, his religious discourse is filled with conspiracy theories.

[@IAzizIAziz]

Dr Israr sahib’s inference from the Quran regarding the role of women and position of non Muslims in an Islamic state are equally as abhorrent. Also is misleading and dangerous his interpretations that it is the duty of every Muslim to convert people to Islam and if they don’t they will have to become second class citizen in an Islamic state. Although I’ve learnt a lot from him and pray for his soul to be blessed, the legacy of his teachings and of others has caused enormous harm in Pakistan’s economic and intellectual decline.

[@TheAzizalykhan]

What an episode!

[@MuhammadAhmad-ti5io]

Agr secularism yahudiyun ka nizaam hai tou Islam mai mazhabi rawadari ka tasawur kya hai

[@ssingha2071]

Thanks 👍👍👍

[@Akarbakarbambaybo69]

👏👏👏🎉🎉🎉 Shoutout to sir taimur

[@hassanmujtaba000]

Dr. Sahab, very informative lecture. Thank you very much for such a vast and important information. But I have a question. Jews were a minority and historically persecuted as you gave historical examples. But now, What miracle made Jews so powerful that they are attacking the Palestinians and warning the whole Muslim community of the consequences. And surprisingly, the Europe in which they were a minority and were persecuted, the same Europe is now a Shelter for them and USA is taking care of Jews. The same Germans who launched a Holocaust against Jews, are now providing tactical supprt to Jews. The point of my concern is that how the Christian Europe which consists of the same Catholic and Protestant schools of thought, has become so kind with Jews, as they were not historically. I need your response on this scenario in order to understand better.

[@sachinrawat2647]

Sir muslims aur jews me kaafi similarity hai jaise skull cap, kosher ya halaal, circumcision, against idol worshippers but phir bhi muslims me jews ke liye itni hate kyu hain.

[@omarsaeed3753]

Sachin Rawat I have a Question for you as well. Hindus have nothing similar with jews than why they both hate Islam and love each other?

[@arindamsaha735]

Christian also same with them .

[@zahidkalam2147]

ڈاکٹر اسرار صاحب کا مطلب ہے مذہب کا تعلق سیاست ہے اور اگر کوئی (یہودی) کہے کہ مذہب کا تعلق سیاست سے نہیں ہونا چاہیئے یعنی ریاست کی قوانین انسان اپنے عقل اور سمجھ بوجھ سے بنائینگے تو اصل میں یہ اللہ کے قوانین کے خیلاف ورزی کرتے ہیں۔

[@KhairulRahman-yy7wy]

Acknowledging the influence of Iblish and his deceptive forces is essential for a comprehensive understanding of historical events, both past , present and future, within the context of identifying as a Muslim. Removing their contribution would leave a significant void in comprehending the intricate dynamics that have shaped human civilization.

[@smtabishzafar]

Please keep up the good work