State, Diplomacy & Pakistan's Foreign Affairs | Talha Ahad Podcast | Episode 40

[@iotasymbol8498]

So intellectual 😂😂😂😂 i can see why Pakistan crumbled like this😂😂😂😂

[@talwarud]

average copy-pasta endian comment... 🙄 why you so obsessed to come and comment on our channels anyways? 🤨

[@mirhimahere4237]

Sir not all of Punjab were ghulams. Bhagat Singh, Udham Singh and Lala lajpat Rai all hailed from Lahore and they played a big for the independence movement.

[@talwarud]

Lions like Adina Beg, Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Jasrat Khokhar, Husseyn Langah, Zafar Khan, Shahbaz Khan Kamboh, Hyder Ali, Tipu Sultan, Muzaffar Shah, and other Punjabis always fought... our forefathers were brave, strong and charismatic men. Even Chandragupta Maurya was initially supported by Punjabi warriors. We have always been this way... 🦁⚔

[@islamicbayans4548]

They are just jealous and want to make us feel low and create panjabi pathan intishar

[@islamicbayans4548]

​@@talwarudman they just want to degrade us pathan panjabi ka zarya khud ky kasam ya inka racism ky wajah sa ma in pathano sa dil sa nafrat karta hu

[@uniform.jack88]

Listening to him is like listening to an encyclopedia. Loved his thoughts. Indeed we the Punjabis and the Sindhis lack nationhood

[@dipakggupta5933]

😂😂😂 the great Pakistani intellectual

[@talwarud]

average copy-pasta endian comment... 🙄 why you so obsessed to come and comment on our channels anyways? 🤨

[@thinktech8306]

1:23:02 esy kon sy masayl hyn jo awam k samny ni lay ja sakty ye band kamron me masayl hal karna band karna hon gy awam ko isolate karna band kary or awam ko aitemad me ly k fesly karyn

[@nomanali5711]

My forefathers weren’t slaves to no afghans. If that were so then Hari Singh Nalwa wouldn’t have ruled over Peshawar the Eastern most province of Afghanistan.

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

Absolutely 👍🏻

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

@@talwarud did anybody say that Muslims didn't fight side by side with be it Afghans or British... Fact is that Pakistani Muslims are still fighting afghans and that's why Afghans hate Pakistan and Pakistanis...

[@talwarud]

Lions like Adina Beg, Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Jasrat Khokhar, Husseyn Langah, Zafar Khan, Shahbaz Khan Kamboh, Hyder Ali, Tipu Sultan, Muzaffar Shah, and other Punjabis always fought... our forefathers were brave, strong and charismatic men. Even Chandragupta Maurya was initially supported by Punjabi warriors. We have always been this way... 🦁⚔

[@happypanda3812]

Beta g panjab has 5000 years of history. Nalwa was just a genral of ranjit And ranjit rule panjab for 30 years and that too only half of panjab and Peshawar before that punjab was under abdali rule the whole punjab from attock to chandigarh and before that mughals and before that delhi sultanate of lodhi pashtuns and before that mehmood ghaznavi ican go on and on.

[@MrymCaan1991]

A good show

[@dipakggupta5933]

Typical Pakistani intellectual 33:11 Delhi wala best tha. Aur jo #Afghanistan ko Pakistan ka 5th subaa banana tha uska kya hua?

[@talwarud]

average copy-pasta endian comment... 🙄 why you so obsessed to come and comment on our channels anyways? 🤨

[@dipakggupta5933]

@@talwarud 🤣🤣🤣 obsessed??? Hum entertainment ke liye aate Hain

[@scrappy__coco]

Pakistani people's mindsets 1)Alhamdulillah hum musalman hai 2)As a Muslim citizen 3) Musalman hone ke nate 4) Being a Muslim 5) Pakistan main bahot Talent hai 6)Hum ek Azad mulk hain 7) India main musalmano pain bahot zulm hota hai 8) Kashmir Pakistan ka shahrak hai 9) Pakistan main akhliyaton ko puri azadi hain 1 0)India humse jalta hain 1 1)Hum ek Islami Automic takat hain 12)Humare pas zajba Eman hain 13)Humne kalma pada hain 1 4)Hindu Kafir kabhi Musalmano ka dost nahi ban sakta 15) Hum zajbe wali Kom hain 1 6)musalmano ne hinduo pe 1400 sal hukumat ki hain Aloohamdulha

[@rajvanshsingh8165]

Khatarnak yr😂 ye MADAR C-OD ise layak ha

[@dipakggupta5933]

Time line main #yahya and fall of Dhaka kyu nhi?

[@FurkanAli-rb6es]

This jahil budha is a former diplomat 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@knc2111]

All Pakistani foreign officers are like this. They survived like monkeys by getting peanuts from US . As soon as peanuts stopped, they are facing starvation😂😂😂😂

[@haneef.saddiqui3662]

DEAR AHAD MASHAALLAH U DID EXCELLENT WELDON

[@muhammadbilal.1162]

Sir please keep in touch with him, we need more opinions of him.

[@anjummirza1452]

Excellent...

[@kaveee971]

30:50 It is shocking for a person serving the country in their foreign office to say that he was unaware of what was happening on the ground in Pakistan - he was clearly not good at his job which was to really know what was happening in Pakistan and communicate that to the outside world in a form that the outside world can understand. If he didn't even know what was happening in Pakistan because supposedly he always lived abroad and only came to Islamabad for some time in between shows his lack of skill.

[@talwarud]

well said, it is important for officials to know what is happening on the ground at all times

[@ChUfqad]

Salute to you Talha, Sir Shamshad is an asset for Pakistan

[@salarbaig1498]

Thanks talha bai, got some archaic information.

[@actualworld1492]

Wonderful discussion

[@hiwibiwi8647]

Best topic best guest

[@somnathde8680]

A deep self introspection.

[@muhammadnofal2290]

Best podcast, Shamshad sb is a very knowledgeable person. Good work done ✔️ Ahad.

[@user-mx7pt3sm3m]

Books by Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed are an amazing well researched, analysis, meticulous timeline and highly sincere attempt on history of Pakistan. Also, Read Dr. Pervez Hoodhoboy (2024) book..

[@ZubairAshraf-r3o]

Need to do part two❤

[@satyamkumarnishadnishadji3891]

Azam ko aids hua tha

[@muhammadbilal.1162]

What a man!

[@shiwajiraopatil4600]

Kash, every Pak citizen was honest like u . Regards.

[@thedanishmalik1]

Mr. Shamshad need to write books it will help future generation to learn a lot from his experience and thoughts

[@hassaanqureshi7558]

He has wrote books you can check them out

[@MQurashi556]

Allah pak Lambi zindagi atta farmaye Sir ko ❤❤❤❤

[@nomanali5711]

It’s because of the army that Pakistan is the way that it is.

[@tejindersharma8603]

If such top civil servant praises ziaul Haque than Allah is Malik of Pakistan

[@MeryemHabib1991]

😂😂😂

[@MrymCaan1991]

We want 2 more podacsts with him ( shamshad sahab)

[@shaheerkhan4417]

It feels good to have a counter narrative to typical pro politicians anti dictators narrative. We need more counter podcasts like these

[@MQurashi556]

Listening and watching his every interview for quite some time and he say this thing that pakistan is no more a state he is so disappointed i dont know

[@saifuddin7187]

Intelligent deplomate is will spoken ❤

[@globalislamicreminders]

You should have let him talk more on Kashmir... you interrupted him when he revealed shocking history about US telling Pakistan to stop capturing Kashmir from India

[@dipakggupta5933]

😂😂😂 aree Pakistan Delhi capture karne wala tha. Delhi ka area Jayda hai ya kasmir ka😂 Pakistan ko indian Punjab,hariyana, Jammu, Himachal Pradesh,😂😂😂

[@antitoxic2302]

Pakistani madrasa educated intellectual😂😂😂

[@talwarud]

This issue was covered in book: "JFK's Forgotten Crisis"... CIA knows and documented this well...

[@talwarud]

@@antitoxic2302 cope

[@afnanayub]

Talha bhai koi pehli bar Orya sahib ka dost apki podcast me aya or ap un sy sirf kahanian sunty rhy jo yaqinan sachi hon gi lakin ap un sy koi acha sa sawal Q ni puch sky? Un k believes ko challenge Q ni kia ap ny.

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

I agree… Talha let him off without grilling him..

[@khandadadada]

We need a 10 hr podcast with him

[@scrappy__coco]

You need Atta.

[@globalislamicreminders]

Depressing ...

[@iotasymbol8498]

Afghan didn't get colonized and now it is a superpower!! Makes powerful technology plus they have best research and space program 😂😂😂 quote by former Pakistani diplomat😂😂

[@talwarud]

which diplomat said this? what was his name?

[@talwarud]

also, Treaty of Gandamak led to Afghanistan briefly being British Protectorate with internal autonomy

[@zullah67]

the gentleman's remarks about politians and dictators looks very much based on his peersonal or family or a group's like and dislikes.and not fair especially about Zia ul haq. Jihad factor was launched during Zia ul Haq 's regime

[@Vishu1412]

He is insulting you and you are sitting idol without any reaction......

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

This fellow is also a tout of Army as saying that it was Army which kept Pakistan intact… Whereas the reality is that Pakistan was broken by the Army dictator… Someone praising Pakistan army is just so so disgusting 🤢

[@thinktech8306]

15:59 q k sir ap logon ny student union or student movements khtam kar di youngsters ko agy a k kam karny k har darwazy aap ki generation ny band kiy hy is my youngsters ko blame mat karyn apny aamal per ghor karyn ye young generation ap sy ziada intelligent hy or kisi bhi foji jawan sy ziada muhab-e-watan hy agar ap fouji jawan sy us ki or us k ghr walon ki roti cheen lo to wo b bagawat py utar ay gi

[@vivekgambhire1379]

Afganistan kabhi colanize nahi huva aur kabhi progress bhi nahi kari

[@talwarud]

Treaty of Gandamak led to Afghanistan briefly being British Protectorate with internal autonomy

[@informationtv7390]

Kia britishers nay k P K aur balochistan par rule nahi kia ? Kia sikho nay k P K par rule nahi kia ? Ranjit singh ke government afghanistan tak the. Mjhay is banday ke smjh nae ati, ya banda mentally mjhay upset lag rha hai..

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

Shamshad is a propagandist and is a tout of Pakistan Army n ISI

[@happypanda3812]

Beta g ya band upset nhi ap miss informed hain. Kpk was NFWP and was independent bufferzone ruled by local agents. Blochistan was kingdom of qalat separate and independent 1956 me qallat became part of pakistan 2015 me NWFP pak me shamil hua officially. Lastly ranjit sing pore panjab pe b raj ni tha Afghanistan tk kess phonch gya. Half panjab jo aj pak hy was under ranjit half panjab todays india was under british. And peshwar usne fatah kia tha us sa agy kbhi sikho na pao nhi rakha . Basically jitna aj ka Pakistan hay ilaqa ghair or Balochistan and sindh nikal kr us pe ranjit na raj kia wo b british support se .

[@dharnidharjha6091]

Kayade azam ka Pakistan! Wahi to bana hi Jinnah chahta tha. Usne to constituent assembly mei hissa nahi liya, use chalne nahi diya. Fir Mountbatten ki khushamad kar 1935 Act mei tabdili karwa ker apne liye dictatorial powers le liya or jamhuriyat aane nahi di. Kyon us nalayak ka nam abhi bhi jap rahe ho.

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

Absolutely 👍🏻 Irony is Selfish Jinnah and Selfish Imran Khan Niazi Charsi are one and the same thing.. 😂😂😂😂

[@nomanali5711]

In one breath this man claims Punjabis can’t be a qaum then addresses us as such.

[@0000000316rs]

Pakistanis considers Jinnah as their hero but they can’t realise he was most selfish because he knew he couldn’t stand in front of high status Hindus leader of pre independence India. Simultaneously elite Muslims class were worried after independence their property will be taken by the government. In view of this Jinnah and elites class stress for partition of India. They bluffed uneducated Muslims that in independent India Islam will be in danger. After separation soon elite class was over powered by army and one after other all politicians were killed including Jinnah.

[@talwarud]

dude we regularly analyze what jinnah did and said...

[@naveedakhtar9078]

Aaj hum is haal me poanch chukay hain ab ye nahi samjh aarahi deshtgard kon hy army elites judiciary bureaucracy PDM police ttp bla isis blf kuch jahil molvi ye sb aik he kaam kar rahy hain (Pakistani logu par zulm) bs way different different hain 😢

[@rajeshc1234]

A Beautiful duffer mind...make some more pls😂

[@talwarud]

average copy-pasta endian comment... 🙄 why you so obsessed to come and comment on our channels anyways? 🤨

[@K_d199]

It's sad to see till date pakistani people are not telling the truth about 1971 It was the military failure, doesn't matter what you say. Even if going by this man's statement ki bhutto ne yahya ka dimag kharab kar dia, to yahya ka khud ka koi akal nahi tha ? The reality is they never thought that india would be involved, and even if india did they thought that they can handle them because kafir se musaalmaan thode na haar sakta h😅

[@talwarud]

We know that 1971 was a defeat... my question is: what need is there to keep bringing it up? India is 7x larger, and they sent in 200k troops, along 185k mukhti bahinis, in order to complete their mission. the end result is 40K soldiers surrender (as per Indian defense minister K.C. Pant). The world has moved on since 1971, and we too have gotten some redemption in 1999 (Point 5353).

[@K_d199]

@@talwarud I seriously don't know from where you guys get your knowledge. The number you quoted and regarding the redemption in kargil just confirms the intellectual bankruptcy you people have. But i don't expect anything from the great 🇵🇰 , because you people don't even know who has been ruling you for the past 7 decades. Because in the public discourse we see you guys blaming the government for the mess that the boys have created. BTW you people achieved only one thing out of kargil and that is the reputation of being Nusense. So enjoy with this reputation. Ek hath me bomb h futhta nahi, dusre hath se katora chut th nahi

[@yahyagondal5851]

The reason why punjabis were in British army is because they were considered a martial race and there is nothing wrong with that 🤣🤣. Bara koi chawal admi hai yeh

[@Khankakar0]

Favorite bureaucrat ❤

[@atiyajavaid7200]

Sir gi, Aap ko Emran kahan sye sadiq aur Ameen tha, aik number ka jhoota aur munafiq insan hai, yahan aap nye sach aur haqiqat ko balaye tak rakh diya,

[@anujsethi7845]

sikhs were punjabis so punjab not fall in Ghulam category same punjab was mahajanapadas in ancient india

[@talwarud]

Lions like Adina Beg, Rai Ahmad Khan Kharal, Jasrat Khokhar, Husseyn Langah, Zafar Khan, Shahbaz Khan Kamboh, Hyder Ali, Tipu Sultan, Muzaffar Shah, and other Punjabis always fought... our forefathers were brave, strong and charismatic men. Even Chandragupta Maurya was initially supported by Punjabi warriors. We have always been this way... 🦁⚔

[@rajvanshsingh8165]

​@@talwarudtipu Sultan hinduo ka dushman tha uski tarif na kar tu g@#du

[@rabnawazkhan5285]

Why did the Sikhs beat the pathans

[@haidermehar2422]

How much does TCM Channel had to pay this man for this interview. بات عجیب ہے۔ But being a Pakistani.

[@zenben7727]

Some poor facts narrated facts. 1965 war and seven days march to Delhi is way off the mark. Pak plan was only Kashmir. Clearly anti Bhutto. He should be a tad humble at his age

[@chrizwanali4283]

Or tu samny betha g g kar raha hai tme kya pata hai punjab k bare me?

[@zainulaabdinaabdin9956]

Sir apki itni age guzri apki stories achi lagi hen sun kar but sorry to say apne b bas i think khaya pya maza lia ghuma phira or ab by by kahty time ap na qom or pak ko he apne alfaz ma fozool boldia jis ki base ap ne dunia ghumi life ko enjoy kia ap khud to ek negative personality hen he but genration ko courage or spiits dena banta ha khud to bas rona ro rahe mje to pata b ni tha pak ma underground kia chal raha tha 🥴beshak jitni marzi complications and jitne marzi gid kute a k kha len or hamen tang karen ham apne mulk k nojawan hen or ye hamara pyara mulk pakistan ha or ye hamesha rahega ham dunia ko tabah kardenge ksi ne hamari salmiat ki taraf ankh b uthane ki jurat ki agar 🇵🇰♥️or ap ko sun k acha b laga or ye b soch ai ha k ap jase he usless old high level py the to he aj ham young generation in halat sy guzar rahe

[@0000000316rs]

Every Muslim somehow tries to connect himself either with Arabs or Turks blood even if their surname may be Hindus. This shows their guilt of mindset.

[@talwarud]

Why do you guys keep saying this lie? Majority of Pakistanis know we are natives to this land. I am a Jatt, the son of a Jatt (or as the Arabs say, al-Zutti)... maybe I have some foreign admixture, but mostly I am Jatt.

[@vineetraina119]

😅😂 people who find leadership in xxx immi chacha that nation is domed and will remain domed.😅😂😂

[@talwarud]

average copy-pasta endian comment... 🙄 why you so obsessed to come and comment on our channels anyways? 🤨

[@vineetraina119]

@@talwarud you can open excellent copy paste academy as tharki immi chacha has been doing copy paste from last 25 year's .🤣😂

[@vineetraina119]

@@talwarud Do you owe youtube? Secondly ,demean Amrika 24x7 and than use there platform to earn money.Hypocrisy maximum in Pakistan.🤣🥰😂

[@talwarud]

@@vineetraina119 you help this channel by commenting... lol... keep coping

[@talwarud]

@@vineetraina119 keep crying lil bro 😂 ... maybe your dad will come back from UAE soon... 😂

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

Shamshad praising Mullah Omar what kind of Buffon is he.. Mullah Omar has completely finished Afghanistan.. Afghanistan was such a progressive country before talibanisation happened to Afghanistan…

[@talwarud]

Mulla Omar did one amazing thing... he followed the way of the Prophets by destroying the idols... March 2001... buddhas of bamiyan are gone now... 💪💪

[@Arvindchauhan-qv6gd]

@@talwarud continue to live in 8th century... Your primitive mindset has made you a begger for life... I am loving it...

[@satyamkumarnishadnishadji3891]

Bhikario