TDI: What if Harold rigged the votes against Duncan?

[@burningeagle1298]

With this what if there’s another thing to look at is courtney won’t do the lawsuit for being wrongfully eliminated thus wouldn’t be on Total drama Action.

[@Give_luv_to_rodney]

Well that is true but she would be on action beacuse she would have made it far enough to be on action if the votes were not rigged

[@ABHyt]

​@Give_luv_to_rodney The characters on Action were determined by the special, not by how far they made it

[@audreybsullivan84]

@@ABHytbut like, aside from Justin, everyone who made it into action made merge

[@therealshadowult]

and thus, Owen doesn't sue his way back onto the show as a mole.

[@J-G9991]

​@@audreybsullivan84 Beth and Harold didn't. Justin was the lowest ranking TDI character to make it into Action, but he isn't the only pre-merge.

[@TD_Heather4TW]

New what-if unlocked. Reminds me, speaking of this island what if, I want to see you tackle the original idea of a HeatherxNoah alliance that was supposedly planned to be in the season {TDI}, so yeah.

[@FillerofaName]

Yeah I mean I think it was confirmed at some point?

[@TD_Heather4TW]

​@FillerofaName Not sure, but I would love to see that.

[@XD-yn6hb]

I’ve checked online and there are no credible sources, it’s just a rumor that spread.

[@Michael-ew8jn]

I mean he already explored that in What if Ezekiel wasn't sexist universe

[@TD_Heather4TW]

@Michael-ew8jn I don't think he did. He only tackled Noah getting a bigger villain role in Island. The alliance got underused.

[@juancruzdiazbravo7338]

the final comment about how as long as Heather is around, many eliminations will be the same, made me think of a potential what if, what if Heather was the first drama island eliminated, the way I would justify it is that she doesn't jump in the first challenge (resulting in Lindsay not jumping either) and that causes her to argue with Leshawna during the construction part, which breaks down the team enough so that they don't make a hot tub (it's just an idea, you can justify it another way , if you think of another thing) it would be interesting to see what the season would be like without the main antagonist, I even think it could be a series of what the seasons would be like and the main antagonist was the first eliminated

[@TheGodIvy]

I think this can moreso be like a what if of the first reasonable time the main antag can get eliminated. For Heather this would be the cooking challenge, where she would get out instead of Beth (like she shouldve since the entire team was after her that episode) The only villian this cannot work for is Courtney in TDA, as she never even had a chance to be voted out till like episode 20 or whatever, but we can just say she loses the case and cant come back on

[@Asherah_Ketchum]

@@TheGodIvy It could also make sense for her to go in the talent show episode instead of Justin. Like if Izzy wasn’t convinced to vote Justin off ‘just cause’ I’m pretty sure she would have been anyways.

[@klausing8]

47:03 This is SUCH a better way for Leshawna to get voted out by the BS vote Chris gives. Plus technically Heather's vote is a real vote. BRAWK LESHAWNA

[@NightShadowNS]

Here's a fun idea for a PI elseworld: *What if Sammy's Revenge Plan Backfired?* Now... I _know_ that you did a scenario _similar_ to this, but this one has a twist put on it... a bit of a _cruel_ one. Rather than having Sammy just give up, think about the following scenario: what if she still tried her scheme in a world in which the cruel whims of fate dictate that while it would be completely deserved, revenge against Amy was just... never meant to be? (To make matters worse, it wouldn't affect Sugar all that much, as she'd recover in time for the next episode) Details: The first three episodes play out like normal up until Sammy is about to trick Amy into taking a bite from the Manchineel in the hopes of saving her skin from elimination and getting much-needed revenge on Amy for years of abuse. _However,_ while things are going to plan and Amy snatches the fruit from Sammy, she fails to realize that the cave she chose to do this outside of couldn't have been any *worse* of a place to enact this plan of hers... because it's *Team Maskwak's...* (like, seriously, has _nobody else_ noticed this?) where in this timeline, *_Sugar_* just so happens to be passing by. Ever the greedy and gluttonous pile of lard, Sugar, looking for an excuse to fill her gullet, sees the Manchineel as a free snack, and tackles Amy to the ground before Amy can take a bite. Sammy can only watch in _horror_ as the ensuing struggle results in Sugar winning out and wrenching the fruit from Amy's grasp before (most likely) gorging herself on it. With so many pieces of the Manchineel's toxic skin sliding down her throat at once, it doesn't take very long for her throat to swell up... something that Amy can't help but notice. Amy's suspicions of foul play are only confirmed when she notices her sister's blotchy and swollen hand from holding the fruit herself. _Outraged_ that her own sister was 'trying to poison her,' Amy runs off to tell the rest of Team Kinosewak, (sans Jasmine, of course) even _further_ souring their opinion of Sammy and all but sealing the nicer twin's fate as her last-ditch effort to save herself and receive much-deserved retribution against her tormentor *_goes up in smoke._*

[@ThatoneYuu]

Idk why but one what if no one seem to think about but.....what if Eva airpods didn't feel during the second episode? This is literally what got her out.

[@CloverPandaQ]

based

[@TDMicrodork]

18:33 I don't think Izzy would vote Owen here. She was originally coming up with excuses to not vote him. He plays a mean game of canasta for example.

[@MickeyMouseTotallyReal]

Loving the video so far, when I got the notification on my phone I immediately started watching

[@mysteriousone1206]

I’d love to see a “What If” video of All-Stars: “What if Harold Replaced Sam?” Essentially what the title says, replacing Sam with Harold, but to keep the generational representation equal, Brick and Ann Maria are added to the Heroes and Villains teams, respectively, bumping the total number of contestants up to 16. I think this would have been a much better deal for the cast to interact with, especially because it gives everyone a proper rival on the opposite team: Harold vs. Duncan Courtney vs. Gwen Lindsay vs. Heather Sierra vs. Alejandro Cameron vs. Lightning Mike vs. Scott Zoey vs. Ann Maria Brick vs. Jo Even better if you can make some of their arcs better, like making Mal a more cunning mastermind, and developing Sierra to have a healthier attitude toward Cody.

[@PalaciosAramendiz]

i love listening to these while doing chores around the house, i already know this one’s gonna be sooo good! 🥳

[@eggbow]

what if harold was lowkey locked in with leshawna and the chalenge and didnt get distracted by heather

[@Justheredoingmything]

I JUST WANT TO SEE THIS-

[@LovesVelvette_Doll128]

I do have one suggestion. I don't know if you will see this but What if you did total drama your way? Basically if u were in charge of the show

[@lysanderlonshadow8653]

The king has uploaded another quality video ❤

[@Michael-ew8jn]

I didn't fully watch it but MAN the idea seems so good! So glad you have ended the year on a high note!

[@shellos31oeste72]

I love your what if's omg you are just great

[@ethbeatthem4836]

What if ideas, trying to think of something unique and have writing potential is important, so what change is left, many of the biggest changes have been cover, think of one left that be something that could of happen is hard. But there might be 2, what if the Team swaps of season 1 or 3 at the beginning never happened. Both being Izzy swaps funny enough, mainly season 1 Katy and Saddie wouldn’t be on the same team and Izzy be on the bass. We’ll season 3 have Sierra on Team Chris the whole time and Izzy on Team Amazon. Changes for the first one mainly come down to dodge brawl and Heather trying to get a build an alliance with all the “clueless girl” adding Katy to her alliance and maybe extending it early on to have team control. We’ll season 3 might have Sierra catch on to Alejandro earlier and ruining his plan as when she not Cody crazy she smart and strategic.

[@yellowjack2762]

YAY great video again dude good job! i have a few what ifs for you if you want what if toper didn't take Chris phone, what if Noah played in dodge brawl, what if action was a full cast or what if Chris let everyone compete for action, what is season 4 was the original cast, what if beardo helped his team, what if chase and emma never dated

[@worstspytf2824]

Just heading off for new years eve but I'll look forwards to this.

[@anchorsaway9500]

Essentially this what if is more of a what if action Courtney showed up early

[@elitettelbach4247]

Courtney beginning a rivalry with Bridgette and Geoff due to an incorrect assumption of them turning on Duncan?! Oh yeah I can definitely see this happening! I don’t remember what anyone else’s dares were beyond the iconic Lindsay shave your head, but if Courtney is going to get eliminated there I feel it might’ve been more thematic for her to go out on a Geoff or Bridgette or heck even Harold dare to make it full circle. Especially since she had a nice sendoff to Lindsay when she got out complementing her horse bike design.

[@czerwonystudio6301]

57:10 Since this episode is so close to finally why won't you just do a little split of ways where you go through both options of if it's normal vote out or Chef's choice. If both are the same then it doesn't matter but if those are different, then just think of which one gives better finally and makes the more interesting one, and then tell us the better one.

[@riccardorossi7782]

What if Gwen and Harold swapped teams in Island ? I think it's interesting as they both single-handedly gave their teams two wins during the pre merge

[@SkullBinder42-j8m]

What if Duncan got eliminated instead of Bridgette? How would it happen: The 5 girls agreed with Bridgette about getting Duncan out because not only he's mean, but also for the fact that he's a strong player, meanwhile Geoff told the guys vote Lindsay off for being Heather's lackey and thought without Lindsay, Heather would be screwed big time and won't have any help to got invincibility in future challenges which they agreed. And so with 6 votes against him, Duncan gots eliminated from the episode, everyone said their goodbyes to him. The girls purposed that once all the guys are eliminated, it'll be a all girls finale which they all agreod, later Gwon & LeShawna made a tomato bath for Bridgette to remove the skunk stench, and she thanks them and they were about to hug but can't due to the stench. Bridgette then told them why she is afraid of being left alone in the woods in the first place, Gwen & LeShawna feel sorry for her and promised her that they'll help her conquer it after the show is over, and she thanks them for that, the surfer girl then gets inside her bath. The guys have lost their leader, Geoff then steps in to be the new leader of the guys alliance. In the confessional, Geoff was glad that Bridgette didn't get booted out, he said he and the 2 guys that Heather has got to go butthey must eliminate Lindsay first, but said it's a darn shame that Duncan is out.

[@-cookiez-]

I NEED to see a what-if of "What if Eva didn't drop her MP3 player?" or "What if Eva won the challenge in No Pain No Game?" Eva would literally wipe the competition with her strength.

[@totallydramaticme5845]

What Courtney’s prediction in the first challenge was correct and 9 of the screaming gophers didn’t jump off the cliff

[@coriseoris]

2nd time we got a TD Wonderer and Pepsicat episode both in one day so cool. Do you ever see yourself making Ridonculous Race what-ifs despite the difficulty of voting not being in the season?

[@TheGodIvy]

I made an RR suggestion in like the 2nd or 3rd video, and the response was he'll do them when he feels comfortable doing it because its difficult to change because of how it is. The one i specifically suggested is what if Owen and Noah got out episode 3 instead of the Tennis Rivals, which would be a very early what if and would change a lot

[@coriseoris]

@ oh that’s a good one

[@taroknight8464]

Chef did the eliminations and I think in this verse, it’s definitely Owen who leaves over Geoff.

[@nosananolifemwa]

I KNOW THIS FINNA BE A BANGER‼️🎉

[@frickfactor5038]

You aren't the real TD Wonderer. The real TD Wonderer wouldn't upload so fast. What did you do to the real TD Wonderer?

[@ProfessionalSillyMan]

What if al and sierra weren’t in world tour ?

[@tobb7006]

9:10 courtney was great in food challenges she was known for having a strong stomach in s1 + s2

[@milanbeerepoot4260]

Plus she took all of Alejandro’s food for him in world tour since he has a weak stomach

[@tobb7006]

@@milanbeerepoot4260 yeah, then they forgot abt it in all stars sigh

[@luigi4life913]

Idea: What if Heather never stole Eva's MP3 player?

[@sunflowermink3110]

What if Nichelle didn’t trip? In ep 3 challenge. I think it would be interesting to see her deal with lying to her team about her stunts.

[@matildacancel3825]

What if Ezekiel didn’t say anything sexiest in the first episode but he’s still sexiest

[@shinnyboppers9802]

yess i love harold!

[@benjaminmustamu9111]

Tbh I’m surprised he didn’t do that

[@santiagoastie426]

what if total drama season winner is decide by a jury vote

[@Angarva]

ngl u might have to make a part 2 of this

[@dracoarton94]

Here's an idea: What if Chef forced Duncan to be eliminated in Basic Straining due to how Duncan kept pissing him off?

[@J-G9991]

I don't think it would be much different from this. Except Courtney would be mad at Chef instead of paranoid over the Killer Bass members. However, she would still have to play the game at the end of the day, so it would be similar to this elimination order, but with less backstabbing and paranoia on Courtney's side.

[@GinCola8090]

Actually I was thinking will Courtney get the Heather Treatment in the hunt for a million

[@SeanLugo-io4pd]

I’m still hoping to see What if Nichelle didn’t quit in TDR S2

[@seanalailima5929]

Do What If The Getting To Know You Trivia Game Challenge was played right?

[@cindy8966]

bruhhh youtube hasn’t been showing your uploads to me I have a bunch of vids to catch up on

[@LightningvsLightning]

OH YEAH OWEN MADE FINALE!!!!! OWEN’S THE CHAD!!!! Oh, and this what-if was pretty good. I liked Courtney trying to figure out what happened, even if I’m not a big fan of her going crazy (it’s not flanderized here at the very least). The only problem I had is less of a story thing and more of a disagreement with one of the What-If choices, as I personally don’t believe Chris would’ve brought back Eva and Izzy as there’s way too many girls and that would make the gender ratio far too uneven for me to believe Chris would do that. I personally believe it would’ve been two guys (probably Justin and Tyler) instead. Other than that, good What-If and OWEN IS SO GIGA CHAD AND PEAK AND SO SIG-

[@tyler-w7w]

Oh ones you haven't seen done? I have something obscure. So remember in world tour when sierra was talking about cody and izzy was tallking about owen so chris made sierra and izzy swap teams. This what if is simple:what if owen and cody swapped teams instead

[@PhycoJoe]

I havent seen this yet i think Harold willl win

[@Sunset-z7j]

I love this. Sorry Courtney but looks like there isn't going to be a lawsuit. I enjoy how she just accused everyone except Harold. Goes to show how much she loves Duncan Idk if you did this already but with this in mind how about if Courtney's lawsuit fails. I wanna see how you do it. Please 🥺

[@Mari_summer]

It really should've been Duncan don't get me wrong the elimination was super cool and is one of my favorite ones

[@Nonya._.]

Yooo W video Spoilers: Geoff final 4 lesgooooo

[@Bltred201]

TD Wonderer Do What If TDPI What If Chris Assinged The Teams Correctly In Pahkitew Island

[@TheGodIvy]

But they were assigned correctly? Wdym by this?

[@SeraphineTopFan]

What if Justin didn't fall for Courtney's seduction in S2?

[@twinberwolves4231]

Finally!

[@CloverPandaQ]

What if Heather goes instead of Eva

[@dylanjohnson3346]

Its was great uo untill owen won lol

[@fireyfan-b7z]

1 hour gang

[@noamhaviv4138]

This Is Not What I Meant With My Idea Of What If Harold Didn't Rig The Votes Against Courtney, I Was Thinking About What If He Got Caught & Never Got To Do That

[@MickeyMouseTotallyReal]

He didn't do it because of your comment, otherwise he would've said so

[@TD_Heather4TW]

This what if is honestly up to interpretation, either getting him caught or rigging someone else still works for this what if, specifically.

[@noamhaviv4138]

What I Also Thought About Is That Harold Would Actually Be Eliminated In Basic Straining Like He Should Have Been Originally & Duncney Getting More Development As A Couple

[@koolykidnik4087]

100th