Tested new MACximal Matte Lipstick vs the old Matte Lipstick formula

As a MAC Matte Lipstick lover, I had to test out the MACximal reformulation in my two favourite shades, Lady Danger & Velvet Teddy, to see if it lives up to the old formula.
Bonus quick comparison between Velvet Teddy, Teddy 2.0 and the new Warm Teddy shade
These are now available online and in store at MAC Cosmetics
---------------------------------------------------------------
Kat's details:
TikTok: / kitschsnitch
Instagram: / kitschsnitch
---------------------------------------------------------------
DISCOUNT CODES
GLAMINATRIX COSMETICS
Use "KAT" for 10% off your order
glaminatrixcosmetics.com.au/?... (affiliate link)
BOCAJ BEAUTY
Use code BEAUTYNEWS15 for 15% off site wide at bocajbeauty.com (non affiliate code)
DAWN EYES COSMETICS
Use code BEAUTYNEWS for 15% off your order at Dawn Eyes Cosmetics - dawneyescosmetics.com (affiliate code)
ELA COSMETICS
Use code BN10 for 10% off your order at Ela Cosmetics (non affiliate code)
elacosmetics.com.au/

[@vlindertje235]

I've been waiting for this! I hope they will bring back the mini's. I don't want the (now even bigger) full-size ones. They take too long to finish.

[@catnip4587]

I have never had a MAC lipstick go bad. Some I have had for years

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

@@catnip4587really? Mine have for sure.

[@irairod5160]

@@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE I hate to admit...I have some MAC lipsticks that are at least 15 years old and I still wear them AGAINST all wisdom and recommendations. They don't smell bad, haven't dried up, glide as well as they did when they were new, and the color has not changed. Russian Red and Diva are two of them.

[@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE]

@@irairod5160 mine never change texture but def get that old lipstick smell 😅 I don’t judge though.

[@mercedesvelasquez8781]

They last but all depends on how you store them ​@@NataliaPessoaXOXOMAKE

[@Abbstrackt]

Another avid Mac lipstick wearer here… thank you for this vid! In my own daily use, I notice touch-ups with the new formula don’t get as gunky and thick as the old formula did. For me, this makes it much easier to wear! (Russian red is my go-to shade)

[@KitschSnitch]

Yes! I didn’t do touch ups here, but I definitely agree! ❤️

[@vlindertje235]

If I'm nitpicking I'd say that the new ones look like they are slightly lighter / less intense of color when just applied. They are close, but I like the original Lady Danger a bit more, the color seems to pop a little more. Later in the day I can't see a difference anymore though. I'm so glad they didn't ruin the formula!

[@KitschSnitch]

They are thinner, which makes them look sheerer, but one extra swipe and they are virtually indistinguishable ❤️

[@funkmoppet2]

I don't even buy Mac, but I'm invested in your Mac journey and needed this chapter. Super pleased for you that you don't have to deal with a limited supply of your faves. No one likes that ride!

[@Cascadeis]

Same thing here! I do not buy Mac products, but I’m deeply invested in Kat’s opinion on these shades specifically. 😂

[@Yolanda8419]

Well done, Mac. Happy to see they did this iconic formula justice.

[@iamsaisai]

My theory is that it would cost more if they keep working with the old formula. I guess the manufacturing process and raw materials now are quite different from when it first came out. Sometimes the processes or manufacturing facilities are just too out of date, they have no choice but modernizing/evergreening things. They wouldn't really risk one of their best selling products unless there is no choice. Anyway it is just my speculation, I think the same rule applied across different industries in general.

[@KitschSnitch]

Yes. I completely agree! I should have been a bit more clearer about that, but that’s also what I was trying to say when I said they are likely modifying the formula ☺️

[@madeleine6749]

16:08 c. C

[@ronig3952]

I feel like since MAC is such a cult favorite makeup and truly the most collectible with a giant fan base....that MAC really should at least give an official statement as to the reason for the reformulation decision.

[@RachieRach77]

Kat when you first swatched the new lady danger I was thinking it’s not the same, there will be hell to pay lol then you went over it and it was exactly the same - phew 😅 for all who love the shades, great vid 😊❤

[@isadoraduncan1246]

Your reviews are flawless…you cover every question I had and give such a comprehensive video. Thank you so much 👏🏻

[@elainebines6803]

That's definitely not a easy feat to get Kat's seal of approval - well done Mac 🎉

[@marylaverty8929]

My daughter has worn brown for years ,,distraught she can’t get Brona any more % will they ever bring it back,.,

[@CarynHaralson-ji3jl]

I’ve never tried the shade Velvet Teddy, but it’s a must now. Also the new Warm Teddy looks beautiful. Thank you so much for this video Kat❣️

[@margaritaalvarez8462]

I have been so excited for this video, and I am not even a matte lipstick wearer. LOL. I just love when Kat takes a deep dive into comparing products, -especially considering her personal invstment in this case 💓

[@coffeeoniceak279]

The comparison I’ve been waiting for! ❤

[@PamelaH_HappyVibes]

I’ve been waiting for this video! Thank you so much. I’m so excited. 👏👏👏 I guess I will be buying some new Mac Lipsticks. ❤

[@Andi_with_an_eye]

awesome! thanks for taking one for the team

[@dobcsek]

I’m so relieved. I love these lipsticks.

[@emilytheimer1094]

I'm so glad you tested the new formula, I trust your opinion when it comes to MAC! I'm looking forward to trying it out, I need a new Velvet Teddy.

[@ByHerHand]

I loved the warm teddy on you!

[@AlcideIzMine]

Warm Teddy looks so nice!

[@daphnegarzarelli-lawson324]

Finally a brand that doesn’t do us dirty! I’m so excited! Glad you were able to make this video. I’ve been waiting! ❤

[@synteis]

I've been waiting so long for this review!!! You have my favourite review structure!

[@KitschSnitch]

Thank you ❤️☺️

[@elizabethsmith583]

I ordered Warm Teddy. Can’t wait for it to arrive.

[@zahraonokevbagbe2725]

Lady danger is such a great shade on you!! Such a great shade.

[@maszilvi2951]

What a nice,simple, informative HONEST review 🙏thx a lot ❤

[@irairod5160]

This was a wonderful presentation. Thank you!

[@lorrainemallory6951]

Thanks for the review! I will definitely order some of my old faves! I feel excited about MAC again ☺️ maybe next they will revamp their blushes!

[@Ioanna_g_k]

Great video, thank you! Warm Teddy looks great

[@DrHailin]

Thank you for a very genuine review ❤️❤️❤️

[@BlingyBea]

I purchased one yesterday Twig twist and it’s a pretty mauvy color. My sister bought Keep Dreaming and it’s a deep rose with blue undertones, her favorite color to wear. We swatched quite a few at Ulta and boy was I surprised when I went to wipe them off they left a stain, had to use a makeup wipe to get it off. It’s been a long time since I’ve purchased a lipstick from them. Cant wait to get more when Ulta gets them all in testers. They had about half in testers.❤💄💋

[@Unfugrundfunk]

What a relief! I dont have to buy another lipstick in this life, BUT that being sad, I probably will. So good to know, thanks for this video Kat 💚

[@Silviaexcuchuflus]

Thanks for the video, I was really curious about these new lippies 😊

[@KitschSnitch]

Happy to help! I was super curious too haha

[@nataliamruz]

Now I'm curious to try the new range!! Would love to know what eyeshadow you are wearing at the first part of the video. Looks stunning onb you Kat!

[@Queenofcats36]

This is good to know!! I've been wanting to purchase another MAC lipstick. I might get Lady Danger, cause damn, that looks gorgeous on you!

[@alettaa]

I'm incredibly protective of both of these shades, especially Lady Danger and have been dreading any possible changes they've made. Couldn't wait for your video to break the news😅

[@traceyvincent2217]

Super helpful video....am about to take advantage of the 20% discount this week. Thanks so much x

[@marylove909]

Yep.....I'm definitely ordering Warm Teddy!!! Velvet Teddy pulls a bit too gray with my coloring, but Warm Teddy looks right up my alley!!

[@yoohz6874]

Agreed!!

[@petra6902]

Yeaaa i’ve been waiting for this 🥳🥳

[@DrinkYourNailPolish]

Grateful you did this. I was skeptical at first thinking oh they reformulated for cheaper ingrdients (shrinkflation) and worried the quality would suffer. Glad to see I was wrong.

[@PamelaH_HappyVibes]

I wasn’t buying unless I had Kat’s seal of approval! ❤

[@kristincusick1342]

Girl….i couldn’t wait for this. I’m a Mac lipstick girl too. I bought my first one, after I got my first grown up job at 21. That was 20 years ago. I’m a huge fan of their reds. I love Russian Red and Ruby Woo. I like Velvet Teddy too. I own a tube of it and I wear it occasionally. But, I have other nudes I like better, from other brands. It tends to pull purple-ish on me. Also…I can see why you love the original Velvet Teddy. I think it looks stunning on you and it’s the best out of the three.

[@mcomeslast]

Thanks! Just put Ruby Woo in my cart!

[@shinyhappypeople9043]

Great review, I’ve fallen in love with MAC lipsticks over the past 18 months. I’m looking forward to hearing your thoughts about the new Velvet Teddy collection..

[@AmaniMaharet]

So glad you did this! My favorite red ever is MAC Viva Glam 1 which I was terrified they were reformulating. They changed the name to Viva Heart but hopefully the rest of it is the same.

[@jwychau]

Those earrings are everything

[@dee8269]

OMG🤩 I’ve been waiting for a proper review and wear test on the new Macximal lipsticks for weeks. At least I’m convinced I don’t have to buy backups for Ruby Woo. Too bad that some fave shades they don’t make with the new formula like Please Me and Runaway Hit😕

[@mafer6729]

Loved the video! I started getting into Mac lipsticks at the beginning of last year and I'm now obsessed, I would love to see you try whirl in this new formula!

[@KitschSnitch]

Thank you! I used to own Whirl, but I declutterred it, so I couldn’t compare it 😅

[@ashleighmcewan60]

Great video as usual xxx

[@jenniferjsaracino]

I picked up VT & LD based on your color recommendations this weekend on my lady friends shopping weekend

[@thefreevolous]

So glad to see this, and happy for everyone who uses these colours. I never felt this was a move to cheapen the lipsticks, at least not at the expense of quality/finish for the customer, I just felt they were updating the formula because technology has changed and improved. That being said I was very weary of the results and I’m happy to see they kept true to the originals. I’m still concerned about my favourite, Ruby Woo, since it was a different formula and absolutely flat finish, which I actually loved. Oh, and side note: I’m actually happy they didn’t put magnets in the packaging. It’s a frivolous change to make things “feel luxurious” that renders the packaging impossible to recycle in most places. If it’s not refillable, I’m more than happy that the lipstick case has just a click closure.

[@GlitzNGlitterCafe]

Ohhh I need the warm Teddy ❤

[@annettelee9245]

Loving the the eyes

[@pamelawolf313]

I loved the teddy 2.0 against your skin. ❤💋❣️

[@ninao8382]

Great review x

[@JB_Fraulein_Kunst]

Appreciate this in depth comparison so much and I feel so relieved! I love Taupe, its my perfect everyday colour and I was worried when they announced the change. Thanks to this video I'm not ❤. I also think I'll give warm teddy a go, as velvet teddy was always a touch too light for me. I'm curious how warm teddy compares to taupe

[@KitschSnitch]

If I still had taupe, I would have compared it! But sadly I decluttered it a while ago 😆

[@victoriaryan1509]

Hooray! So glad it's still as good & not twice the price. I agree, I think they probably wanted to modernise their basic lipsticks to keep up with everyone else as there's so much more competition for them these days.

[@taigahilliard619]

These are really good and I am happy for you that they are the same

[@catnip4587]

I’ve been a MAC lipstick girl for years so glad to hear they haven’t messed up the formula

[@tragical-history-tour]

thanks for this video! velvet teddy is my all-time favourite lipstick and i got sad to see that it's unavailable where i am (is it discontinued?). i'm happy to know that it's same as the og!

[@1015SaturdayNight]

Lol I only wear fragrance free lipstick now but I still couldn’t wait for this video

[@AyValley]

Those earrings are IT on you, please try them with your purple knit in winter!

[@pamelaweber1286]

Hi I just came across your podcast I ❤ MAC & your show 🎉 Thank you 😊😊

[@coralaila]

Wow, I have never used these lipsticks and decided to buy one after seeing your video. What a beautiful lipstick. I’ve been looking for a nice red a can wear and not think about the lipstick and this fits the bill. I’m so impressed about this formula. I think I’m a fan now, there is no need to buy other formulas.

[@KitschSnitch]

They are great! I’m so glad you gave it a try ❤️

[@ajk23ful]

I've been waiting for this. I'm definitely keen to try one now, but I think I will wait for a sale or limited edition packaging 😂

[@sarahmoorcroft8826]

Might need to head in store and swatch Warm Teddy. Velvet Teddy is too pink on me but the newer shade looks like it might work better for me 😊 Also, just wondering if you’ve tried the shade Marrakesh-meh? It’s a really nice spicy red/orange shade

[@KitschSnitch]

Hi! No I haven't tried that shade, it looks super pretty but I rarely wear spicy red/orange shades, 99% of the time I will reach for a bright shade instead haha

[@brendaalston6001]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤yes I have been waiting for this

[@historianlaura]

Been waiting for this ❤ My favourite shades Viva Glam I and Viva Glam II have gone. They do have similar new Viva shades but still. I hope they bring back the smaller/mini bullets too but this video is good news oh and I think I might need warm teddy

[@KitschSnitch]

They have just renamed them. Apparently Viva 1 is now Viva Heart and Viva 2 is now Viva Planet. They have been updated to the new formula too :)

[@historianlaura]

@@KitschSnitch phew! I am passing by a MAC store on this coming Friday. I might need to slip in :) have a great week Kat x

[@LisaF_]

I bought the new shade they put out for Viva Glam I. Viva Glam 1 is my favorite red. I don’t think they look the same on me. The new one doesn’t look as matte on my lips, is a little more sheer, and there is slightly less brown in the new shade vs the original. I can see how some people might not care or even notice, but this has been my favorite red for over a decade and I wear it a lot. I immediately went looking for a few backups of the original before they are gone forever.

[@ashleighmcewan60]

Your makeup is beautiful❤xx

[@kiaraneves8852]

Muito obrigada pelo vídeo! Ajudou super na compra

[@luciejongenpeyroux9148]

Hello, Can you say what palette and shades you used on you eyes please ? It’s beautiful

[@skylilly1]

Very helpful 🙂

[@rizaki6362]

yes i needed that video the ONLY lipstick i wear is Mehr

[@msmurder81]

Lady Danger is my everyday shade so I had been so worried

[@ashwathirajakrishnan3298]

I’m glad they have reformulated. I was starting to feel the MAC lipsticks were getting outdated considering their recent price increases. I was starting to move away from my MAC and get other high end/ luxury brands. I am really excited to try the new mac lipstick now

[@mercedesvelasquez8781]

Weird lol because I always best prefer mac lipsticks over all others

[@ilianakonn]

I went on the first of march to the store and swatched all the shades I already have in the new formula. Surpisingly all the shades are the same. I don't think I could pick up the vanilia scent but maybe that's just me

[@KitschSnitch]

I think it’s definitely more subtle than the original, but there’s a hint ☺️

[@balletlau]

What eyeshadow are you wearing here? It looks fantastic.

[@KitschSnitch]

It’s a Bobbi Brown eyeshadow called Gilded Rose ❤️

[@Ronsonpeters]

On the subject of inflation, Mac lipsticks are actually one of the few make up items that sell better during financial hard times, so I almost wonder if they timed this release to bring it back to the forefront of consumers minds as we hit this level of wealth disparity.

[@KitschSnitch]

I do remember that fact, I think it was lipstick sales in general went up during a recession, not specifically Mac.

[@mirolisen]

I was expecting something more spectacular than pretty mutch the same formula and a heavier package, concidering the price increase compared to the old formula. I'm stocking up on the old ones while I can. Sadly not impressed at all. Very thankful for this review though!

[@KitschSnitch]

That’s fair, they aren’t for everyone. As a MAC matte lipstick fan, if they changed it too much from the original, they would upset people like me, we want the same formula and effect. They have released more lux formulas in recent years so there’s plenty of other matte comfortable, long wear options to try if this doesn’t impress you (I recommend the powder kiss velvet blur), but I still prefer this one. If you consider the extra product you’re getting, it’s actually a price *decrease*, so there’s not much to be unimpressed about from my perspective

[@muumol]

You look so beautiful! Wonder Woman!

[@Ellie-es4ms]

Thank very much for your review. As someone who loves brown tonnes lipstick, do you recommend the velvet teddy warm? Or just the original colour? Thank you.

[@KitschSnitch]

Hi! It really depends on your skin tone and how brown you like your lipstick. I personally like nudes that have more of a brown tone (vs pink, peach or mauve), but I don’t personally use darker brown shades very often. If you like a lighter lipstick but want something more brown than Velvet Teddy, I would recommend another shade, maybe Yash. But if you like deeper nudes with warm tones, then Warm Teddy might be a good option ❤️

[@Ellie-es4ms]

@@KitschSnitch sane here, I like nudes with brown tone, anything with pink undertone get passed on to my family or friends.

[@KitschSnitch]

Google search swatches of Yash vs Velvet Teddy. Yash is a newer find for me (I think I got it earlier last year) and I love it!

[@Ellie-es4ms]

@@KitschSnitch thank you, I will have look ❤️

[@brendaalston6001]

2024 I love it I have been waiting on it ❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@jasmine.lavender]

Completely unrelated to the video, but what polish are you wearing? It’s such a fun colour!

[@KitschSnitch]

Orly So Fly 💚

[@guardself921]

I was nervous Mac would screw up the formula. If your pleased then it seems like they did their jobs. All of them look great on you. I really liked warm teddy on you.

[@dee8269]

Also what is the AWESOME 🤩mint colour on your nails?

[@KitschSnitch]

Orly in So Fly 💚

[@jolanda.c]

I need to check Warm Teddy. Velvet Teddy washes me out as it is slightly too light and turns a bit orange on me. My go to shade with Mac is Twig and Brick O'La but that is not a matte.

[@KitschSnitch]

I would be worried that if VT looks a bit orange on you, this might look very orange on you. Worth a swatch in store though ❤

[@AnUrbanGypsy]

Warm Teddy is like the autumnal version of Velvet Teddy on you, so pretty. They all suit you. It looks like the bullet on the new one is up from 3g to 3.5g of product… but the price probably reflects that as it’s $2 more than the old version. Not bad given today’s constant price hikes on everything.

[@AnUrbanGypsy]

😂 Commented too soon.

[@nadiabeautyo7107]

In uk it’s gone up £3.00 so it’s more than the original

[@KitschSnitch]

Still cheaper when you break it down per gram

[@emo333vampire]

may i ask what eyeshadow you’re wearing in the first bit of the video? satin taupe? 🤔

[@KitschSnitch]

It’s a Bobbi Brown single called Gilded Rose ❤️

[@emo333vampire]

thank you! its beautiful on you! 💗

[@printernoises1338]

I will say lady danger with the night shift (yellow) filter on the new one is slightly more orange and lighter, but wouldn’t notice in person probably.

[@NoOne-wt3sv]

I wish they didn’t touch the viva glam’s 😢❤ glam 1 was different and the perfect balanced red.

[@HettieB8]

I want to know if the more drying ones like ruby woo are similar 🤔

[@KitschSnitch]

I was tempted to buy Ruby Woo, but I no longer have the original to compare it too because mine dried out

[@sillybananachops]

I wonder also if the new packaging and moulds etc are harder to fake too so it’s easier to spot a fake ?

[@KitschSnitch]

Yep! They would definitely be harder to fake!

[@kissmybuttID]

Do I wear red lipstick? No. Do I care about how comprehensive and thorough you presented this info to us? Yes!! Thank you , Kat. I did share the video with a bunch of my girls (and guys) who do wear red! Kim ❤️

[@KitschSnitch]

Thank you Kim! ❤️❤️

[@Amanda-yd2ey]

Thx you for making this! I literally felt threatened with this change. I appreciate that the scent is the same and the weight increased.. the height meh… maybe it was cuter shorter.

[@KitschSnitch]

Haha I feel you!

[@thejulietocean]

Have you noticed any weirdness from the coconut oil in the new formula? It breaks me out and that’s the only thing keeping me from buying. Lady Danger is my favorite red lipstick too!

[@KitschSnitch]

I haven't personally, but I haven't experienced any break outs from coconut oil being in lip products. I avoid it generally on my face because it occasionally breaks my skin out, but my lips can handle it fine. If you have noticed that you get breakouts around your lips from it being in lip products, I would avoid it

[@thejulietocean]

@@KitschSnitch I’ve never had it in a lip product before so we’re going to experiment I guess 😂

[@cwynn1547]

I have silicone lipsticks, but sadly I can't wear them in winter here when the polar cold + indoor heating leads to RH 20% dry air. The silicone formulas are fine in summer when it is hot and humid. The old MAC formula is just moisture-creamy enough to cut it in winter, is *just* wearable, with maybe a top-off with lip balm a few hours later. By contrast, the silcone layer has to be off or lip balm doesn't penetrate. I am not going to buy a lipstick that is wearable mainly in summer for me. The old formula provided that moisture top-off, and I go through these old MACs in a couole months. Your review has clarified for me that I will get YSL Rouge Pur Couture instead, a more creamy moisture formula. Thanks so much! 💄🩵

[@KitschSnitch]

@@cwynn1547 Luckily these aren’t silicone based lipsticks, that was what people were assuming based on the bullet when they were first shown, but they are the same consistency as the original ones, just thinner. if you like the original formula, you will like this one too

[@carolawabdy]

are they still keeping up with their viva glam initiative???

[@KitschSnitch]

Yes they are. The Viva Glam lipsticks have been reformulated and renamed, but the initiative continues!

[@rizaki6362]

i prefer the old packaging when i finish the lipstick i will keep it

[@covfefemaga7918]

I would argue that if you have to apply more layers of the product to get the same look as the original version, then this is a form of shrinkflation. Also, do we know that they're making them more stable or less? Clean beauty products tend to spoil faster. We all know the industry is trending toward using less preservatives. I'll be looking to stock up on my old favorites at discounters.

[@KitschSnitch]

I wouldn't call it shrinkflation, it is a thinner formula so it applies less in one swipe which makes it feel lighter on the lips, but if you want to build it up you can. At the end of the day you are likely using less than the previous formula. They don't claim that this is a "clean" formula.

[@georgianaalina4423]

I have the feeling that nothing changed with the formula. They simply wanted to add some extra money. In Europe the new formula is 10 euros more 😑

[@KitschSnitch]

The ingredients listed are completely different, so something has changed 😅

[@brendaalston6001]

Subscribed ❤❤❤❤❤

[@biblssg]

In my region the MACximal matte lipsticks are priced 10 € more than the old mattes. So while I'm happy they didn't ruin the lipsticks with the new formula, that price gap is horrendous. If I check the American MAC site there's not such a price difference.

[@KitschSnitch]

That’s a hefty price increase

[@Kelly-mi1yz]

I like the new one, it’s blurring

[@amyzan]

Do the new formula smell the same?

[@KitschSnitch]

It’s more subtle, but the same scent