187: Reasons Behind Prophet's Marriage & Divorce to Hafsa bint Umar | Our Prophet

[@Thaqlain]

Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on KZbin & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support

[@shabshab6420]

😊

[@shabshab6420]

😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@shabshab6420]

😊

[@jjeanniton]

HAFSA NASHIZA! Aisha and Hafsa MUTINIED on their husband the Prophet MUHAMMAD (of whom the Sunnis say to this day, Sallallahu aleihi wassallam) and USURPED his exclusive prerogatives in affairs of religion!

[@ferozkhondaker5316]

Please respect mothers of believers

[@rabiasaeed2206]

Bravo Molana You nailed it ! Explaining from Sunni Books Allah helps us all to accept the harsh realities of our Islamic History. Educate and use your Pulpit with truth to unite all Muslims to expedite the arrival of the Final Savior of Islam the last Son of Rasool Allah .❤

[@Flower-kx4qe]

Allah guide us to the right path of Ahlebait a.s 👍

[@Flower-kx4qe]

Allah also mentioned in the Quran about the Good & Bad wives of Prophet (pbuh) & his family 👍

[@multanprarie2600]

Do not attack the wives of the Prophet salAllaho alaihi wa alihi wa salam, Fear Allah!

[@Flower-kx4qe]

@@multanprarie2600 I’m not attacking I’m telling the truth 👹🔥

[@Flower-kx4qe]

@@multanprarie2600 Truth is bitter 😔

[@Rizvi-2]

​@@multanprarie2600 man it's the truth, Aisha is the like the female companion of Yousuf AS

[@youtubeuser6407]

​@@Rizvi-2why don't you tell us who the female companion of yusuf is?

[@ayturalfil]

My beautiful brother muhammed speaks the truth!!!❤❤❤❤❤

[@yasminsaid3447]

Basically,The Prophet married Aysha and Hafza with the niyet to protect and reform them, but both of them failed the test and exposed their wrong intentions .They had weak personalities and made wrong choices of opposing the Holy Ahlebayt AS

[@r.b7979]

Why would you marry someone who requires reforming in your eyes?

[@popeye511]

@@r.b7979 😂😂😂

[@popeye511]

Yasmin you are unimaginable🤣🤣🤣🙏🙏

[@r.b7979]

@@ma_dalalo im not sure where they said they were shia? Im african too and not fond if this comment but what i do know to be true is that they both had strong personalities which did cause altrecations every now and again.

[@IAlephI]

@@r.b7979 I like my life and my marriage to be without trouble, but thats me, not necessarily how Prophets think. The Prophets (p) do not think like we do. What makes the Prophets endure so much pain, suffering and patience when mocked, threatened and assaulted if not for their commitment to change those same people towards salvation? Do we have that in us? I'm not saying this is the reason but i'm providing possible answers to your question "why marry someone who needs reforming?" Did the wives of Prophet Nuh (p) and Prophet Lut (p) need reforming? Whether or not they made use of such opportunity or not is a separate question but they cannot claim they never got the opportunity. They were wives of Prophets that needed serious help. Salam.

[@BraveAhsan114]

Exceptional lecture Sayed ❤

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Masha Allah Jazakallah khair Syed ... for a very nice explanation

[@alinaabbas5964]

The thing is if we respectfully share this reference from Bukhari with ehl-e-sunnat, they would still side with Aisha and not Ammar bin Yasir, the same way they defend Banu Umaya in comparison with Ehl-e-Bait, they'll say 'it's just Ammar's words.' If they can defend the umayads and the members of saqifa who went against Prophet (PBUH)'s children, they can easily discredit Ammar bin Yasir's words. An average suni hasn't heard of Ammar bin Yasir's name, so they don't respect him like we do. They can say he was wrong.

[@lunarious87]

I agree :) with Honoring the father

[@decomposed4295]

why are ppl here defending Hafsa😂 like didnt you watched the lecture the very fact that the Qur'an rebukes her did that all fly over their heads ⁉️‼️❓

[@aql78614]

indoctrination by the bakri scholars

[@FatimaZakari-y8p]

Even me I'm still wondering 😂😂😂

[@UmmiGhazal]

Brother these Sunnis believe what is pleasing to them & not what is pleasing to Allah swt. It’s sad even when their Sunni revelations & our Quran rebukes these munafiqs yet they’re still following them. May Allah guide us all🤲🏾

[@AnaSunniSufiQadriHanafi]

الله يهدي إخواننا المسلمين ويحفظهم من فتنة الدجال (لعنه الله).

[@moono9614]

Salams my dearest respected brothers I firmly believe that think that you shouldn't have said that about Hafsa (r.a.) at 30:19 of the video since, to start with, she's a human and we all make mistakes, but she still absolutely adored the Prophet SAWS. Additionally, it's impossible to tell how earnest she was about her fast and salah. Especially as she was known to be the one who regularly fasts and prays a lot. We may be aware of her so-called misdeeds, but we may not be aware of the genuine penitence she expressed to Allah swt and to herself in private. I think she is an outstanding lady and a great motivating example for us Muslims. Thank you very much for the lecture. Please be careful how you word your lectures. Jazakullah Khairun

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. Had there been evidence in the Quran or the authentic traditions from the Prophet on the qualities that you mentioned than definitely we would have discussed them. However, the case has been otherwise :)

[@Souce529]

Watch the lecture again please how can you defend that women

[@moono9614]

@@Souce529 Thank you so much for the recommendation! She is not merely a woman, but a highly religious one who enjoys great respect from the Lord of the Worlds, is my first response to your question. Secondly, I feel compelled to stand up for The Mother of Believers. Although she may have hurt the Prophet Muhammad (saws), I firmly believe that you shouldn't say what was said at 30:19 in the video because she still loved him a great deal. As members of the prophet's ummah, we shouldn't try to turn the prophet wives into villains because of mistakes they may have made in their previous life. Because she is the wife of our prophet and a wonderful, powerful woman in her own particular ways, I think she deserves to be spoken about in a more just and elevated manner. Do you think the Prophet Muhammad (saws) would be offended if he overheard us speaking disparagingly about his wives? It is acceptable for us to discuss the difficulties the prophet saw had in life and the life he had with his beloved wives because we can learn from him, but we must refrain from passing judgement on them, especially since they are deceased and have always been superior to us. You can't explain how these particular folks may be counted as people who frequently fast and pray because of this particular deed. Because we cannot be certain of their sincerity in performing the nice deed. She is on her own against her merciful rubb. But ultimately, we must begin to honor each and every wife of our wonderful prophet Muhammad saw. Salamuakum.

[@Thaqlain]

The Quran passed judgements on these two wives specifically. Similarly there are wives like Khadijah and Umm Salamah who are praised in the Quran. So either we can follow the Quran or we can follow our desire to paint everyone with the same brush.

[@moono9614]

@@Thaqlain Just because the Quran does not extol all wives, those wives are nonetheless mentioned in hadiths and are beloved and deserving of appreciation and respect from all Muslims worldwide. We should learn as an ummah to respect, honour, and speak extremely highly of our dear believing mothers since they are still our prophets' wives and deserve respect from all of us, which is something some people don't do. In the Qur'an, God not only protects the Prophet against unjust allegations but also makes notice of and defends the Prophet's family and friends. The Quran has verses that refer to his wives as "Mothers of the believers," an exalted title. God responded to the false allegations made against Aishah, may God be pleased with her, by revealing Surah Noor, which has more than 20 verses defending Aisha. How are they not praised in the quran by God Almighty??? In addition, when the holy Quran was first put together, it was stored in Abu Bakr's home, then after he passed away it was transferred to Omar Ibn Al Khattab's home then eventually it was taken to Hafsa (radiy-Allahu ta'ala 'anha) house. Think about this: the first compiled holy quran kept safe in the house of the beloved wife of Rassulallah saws,Hafsa. This demonstrates the strength and authority of women in Islam, as well as the wifes of the prophet saws high rank and weighty responsibilities. Also our other blessed mother Aisha (r.a) had the honor with the mercy of Allah swt for our beloved Prophet to die in-between her chest and neck. They were both extremely intelligent and strong women who deserve much higher praise from us all. How were we supposed to not honour them whem Allah swt honoured them in a lovely manner. These are just a few examples of how God defended His Prophet and our Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him. The Prophet was a guiding light for all of us, and the more we know about him, the more we will love him. Therefore, let's respect ourselves, respect our mothers, and begin honoring them the way they deserve to be honored rather than talking about them in an inappropriate way. Why can't we honor our mothers since God Almighty gave them great rankings with Him? Strive to understand more about our Prophet, his blessed wives, and the Qur'an (peace and blessings upon them all ameen) Salam.

[@firuzmunosibshoev2411]

❤❤❤ Thank you brother

[@imuskanhussain]

I think this is totally wrong. If it is like that why would prophet said to Aaisha radiallahu anha, that he is happy that in Jannah he will be with her!

[@Thaqlain]

This is something highly debatebale as according to Ayesha herself, the Prophet loved Khadijah more than any other wife. We have explored this in detail in the previous episodes.

[@MuhHuda-su2sf]

Agree....all the reasons are fabrication.... Basically syiah hates Aisha all the way.... can not take any good from Aisha....

[@AddisAbaba1_J]

​@@ThaqlainYeah because she is rich and helped him financially to become who he is. She is what we call a sugar mami to momo in this generation

[@tamanababa5185]

NO, we do not distance ourselves from Ahle-bayat in any way. We love and respect the mothers of ummah (Prophet's wives) ,and Ahle-bayat are equally if not more dear to us. Stop spreading venom please.

[@Thaqlain]

JazakAllah. Then is there a reason that there are only a handful of narrations in Sunni books specially Sahihain while there are plenty from the wives?

[@Rizvi-2]

Dude, that's like saying your love the oppressed and the oppressors,

[@LuluRdhai]

Assalam alaikum, it's a bit out of topic but what is your laptop name? I'm currently searching for one that's why, if I bothered you, sorry.

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. It looks like Sayed is using Microsoft Surface.

[@HYDERI10001]

I am a shia and i dont know why the maulana is talking about this topic when there is a clear fatwa to avoid this so the unity of muslim ummah be preserved..imam mehdi is everyone's imam why is instead of talking about topics which are the current need he is talking about some thing that can sow rift between muslims and make sunnis more hateful towards shias ??

[@Thaqlain]

Because he is in a chapter where he is discussing the interaction/relationship of the Prophet with his wives, and this is a theme which the Quran too has discussed.

[@_Zardari_]

Indeed, the fatwa had 'baseera'. shia shouldn't get invovled in hate speech rather have a academic and honest dialogue with whomever they are discussing this topic. Shia's do not attack these two personalities, istead just show common people what is written in their books. we are not takfirs, we show the path to truth. therefore we must not aggressive in order to spread truth.

[@tripzburner6744]

Can i have a honest answer on why you use some sunni hadith that reaffirm your points but reject ones that dont push your agenda P.s im a newer Muslim and im genuinely curious

[@Thaqlain]

This entire series is based on the biography of the Prophet based on the principles given to us by the Imams from the Prophet's progeny. So whenever we present a disputed point, we offer narrations from the Sunni books for the point we have made. Similarly, when we make a point different from the general belief of Scholars of Ahlal Sunnah wa'al Jama'a, we present reasons for rejecting those specific narrations.

[@rezasadventures1352]

Cause Shia Muslims don't believe bukhari is a reliable book of hadith but sunnis do, so if we want to give them evidence we have to give them evidence from their books , if I open my book it's very ez to destroy sunni religion but they don't believe in my books

[@DaTruth1017]

To my understanding the majority of Christians say Nabi Isa (Jesus) pbuh is God/son of God. To show the Christians the truth, will you show from their own book (Bible) or the Quran?

[@bigboi4307]

@@DaTruth1017both, when giving dawah a lot of Muslims will point out contradictions in the Bible and use verses that are compatible with Islam but will also use Quranic verses that usually resonate with believing Christians

[@Dryusufyusuf]

May Allah guide and protect us. Please let seek for genuine Knowledge about our religion. Not fabricated stories without reference nor from Qur'an and Hadith.

[@Thaqlain]

The entire chapter is based on the Quran and hadith 🙂

[@makavellitheprince5256]

3:05 Uthman did not marry the Rasool (SAWAW) daughter but rather daughter of Haala who was sister of Khadijah (SA). The Rasool had adopted these girls. Only if you had listened to likes of Allama Zameer Akhtar Naqvi or Allama Talib Jauhri you’d know. Refrain from making such statements

[@makavellitheprince5256]

But indeed Umm e Kulthom &/or Zainab were better than Hafsa.

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam. It seems you skipped the episodes related to the children of Lady Khadija 🙂

[@makavellitheprince5256]

@@Thaqlain Walaikum Salaam, please share the link here if you can.

[@Thaqlain]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aHjTq5SMZdmWh5ofeature=shared

[@zainabsb6066]

If you are misled, please do not mislead your listeners too. Your speech is so scattered. Even the audience is asking better questions. As for the respect and dignity of our mothers, it is preserved by Allah SWT and we have been ordained to respect them. You worry for your ending. Indeed no intercession will suffice you on the day of judgment. May Allah soften your heart and speech. All of what our Prophet PBUH went through in his public and private life was to set an example for the ummah on how they should behave/react in their affairs till the end of time. There was Allahs divine hikmah in every difficulty and ease that our Prophet had to go through. Any educated Muslim interested in the seerah of our beloved Prophet PBUH should research and extract this hikmah from his life themselves. Dont let these hooligans sitting on mimbers mislead you!they are doing the ummah disfavour.

[@Thaqlain]

We respect your opinion on this matter. However, the title "Mother of Believers" does not guarantee their respect and dignity being preserved by Allah. We have already covered it in another episode.

[@zainabsb6066]

@@Thaqlain I will reiterate what i said earlier, may Allah soften your heart and speech to hikmah and may all Kalamhgoh be granted jannah at the end of their lives. Ameen.

[@Thaqlain]

JazakAllah :)

[@mohamedabu2540]

Asalamu alykum brother did Rasulullah (saw) divorce any of his wife can you show me in quran or Hadith sunn sorce or shia Hadith please

[@Thaqlain]

Alaykum Salaam. We have covered it in the following episode: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aHraY5WiqJuFm6c

[@HafsahShahrukh]

Bro you should see in the sahih Bukhari or sahih Muslim

[@fidahusayn8691]

God bless you aagha

[@infinitewisdom4557]

The alleged incident at the home of Hafsa is just shocking. This alleged behaviour, by the prophet, is exactly the same as non-Muslims. They behave this way. They disrespect and dishonour their wives almost identically... We are now expected to believe, through these secondary sources, that the prophet was a no-good womaniser. Just satisfying his lust wherever and whenever possible. This is why you will undeniably discover, if one bothers to check, that the messenger of the Quran and the messenger of ALL this secondary data is a different person altogether... this secondary data, from all parties, is what the non-Muslim uses as ammunition against Muslims. The big, fat stick is literally being handed over as a weapon to get beat up with. It's absolutely ludicrous... Regarding ALL this secondary data and using the Quran as the ONLY yardstick, it's high time that a) an extensive revision is done or b) it's scrapped altogether. Until this is done Muslims will remain in a state of confusion and the non-Muslim will certainly be no better!

[@Thaqlain]

When the majority of Muslism left the household of the Prophet and choose leaders (both men and women) that suit them this was bound to happen :)

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

Dear muslim brothers and sisters ..Please read authentic sources..With this lecture a lot is wrong...The reality is not like as in this lecture...

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

No, suratul Tahrim was revealed because of the honey which Our prophet (s,a,v) ate at Zaynab (r.a) home..What crazy things are you telling about?

[@Thaqlain]

We understand points here mentioned are new for you. But the reality is they are mentioned in Sunni books in much more detail. The only reason you are not aware of them is because your scholars tend to present certain wives/personalities as holier than thou.

[@habibanathani3747]

First and foremost she is fabricating a lie about the prophet As it impossible for a prophet

[@nilowfar1473]

Hajj it seems like the Sunni’s creating these confusions by these lies in the Hadiths. My question is do you think that these transcribers, Omar, Uthman & Abu Bakr were atheist, Jews or pagans who trying to divide the Muslims? The other question I have these leaders in Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 and other Arab nations why they are so closed minded towards Shia ? Why they side with the wrong people and etc. ?

[@Thaqlain]

Why people reject the divine representatives? Even when they show clear signs. The same answer applies in all situations :)

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

No way ..😢😢😢Hafza (r.a) was qovvoma and sovvoma. Who prayed tahajjud and fasted a lot ...She was a woman of paradise...You are contradicting yourself...She wasn't divorced ..You are hurting our prophet (s.a.v) by backbiting about his wife...(the mother this ummah)How you dare...how dare...Allah chose her to be the mother of this ummah for a reason..If she hadnt deserve ,Allah wouldnt have chosen her to be the mother this ummah

[@faizashahrukh2634]

She was but then was taken back

[@westtibetanadami6717]

please mention the scholars name in the title also

[@Thaqlain]

Definitely we will. He is Sayed Muhammad Baqer al-Qazwini

[@westtibetanadami6717]

nice@@Thaqlain

[@moono9614]

Salam, I advise you all to please watch the correct episode of Our Mother Hafsa R.A Hafsa bint Umar (ra): Saved by Devotion | The Firsts | Dr. Omar Suleiman

[@adamnouri23]

Brother ,, You can cherish Dr 'Omar Sulaiman as much as you wish. That is not a problem. However, in surah / chapter at-tahreem, Allah Almighty had put 'Aisha and Hafsa in the same category as the wife of Nuh / Noah and the wife of Lute / Lott. Both prophets were / are great servants of Allah Almighty. On the other hand their wives were working against them all the time. Allah Almighty says : * ,,,and it was said ; enter you both hellfire along with the enterers *. Praising the enemies of the prophet IS AN INSULT TO THE PROPHET.

[@youhavetoacceptitevenifyou9025]

​@@adamnouri23 ahsant brother, It is indeed very worrying and a warning for whoever respects those two

[@moono9614]

@@adamnouri23 The Prophet Muhammad saws would be very upset he heard that, He loved our beloved mother Aisha r.a. In surah Tahrim it is mentioned in verse 66:9 O Prophet! Struggle against the disbelievers and the hypocrites, and be firm with them. Hell will be their home. What an evil destination! Then in the following verse it says verse 66:10 Allah sets forth an example for the disbelievers: the wife of Noah and the wife of Lot. Each was married to one of Our righteous servants, yet betrayed them.1 So their husbands were of no benefit to them against Allah whatsoever. Both were told, “Enter the Fire, along with the others!” No where did it say that they were compared to the wives of Lut a.s. Their wifes were disbelievers, but all the mothers of the believers (Prophet SAWS wifes) were true believers! Please understand the translations properly!

[@mohamedabu2540]

​@@adamnouri23 brother please show me in quran the two mothers of the believers Aysha (r.a) and Hafsa(r.a) they are the people of jahanem like the wife of Noah and wife of Lott show me in quran places by the way you shaykh in this video give him advice to teach you the good part of mother of the believers our prophet muhammad (saw) nevar put them down.

[@afnaanabdi5189]

@@adamnouri23 Dear brother the tafsir of the Quran is one thing and not liking the sahaba is another plz differ between the two if you truly respect the prophet pbuh show respect to his wives he wouldn’t have been married to some one that is displeasing to Allah swt their fathers the hearing and the sight of the prophet Hafsa bint Umar and Aisha bint Abu Bakar are part of the prophets family whether you aprove or not so please don’t take bad of the sahaba and don’t come with bida perhaps you don’t know Allah might love them way more then you and could be punished for that so be careful about what say not all that shines turns out to be gold

[@wesleyjacobs8694]

MarshAllah

[@AnonymousTR007]

It's not like she is some other women you are talking about. She is the mother of believers. Respect her. She's a human. Look at yourself first and then talk about others.

[@Thaqlain]

Quran rebukes her. The Prophet was upset with her. Who are we to decide things on our own when the Quran and Prophet's sunnah are the guides? Also, we urge you to listen to previous episodes: kzbin.info/www/bejne/fWG6c6WJd7iWgpY&pp=gAQBiAQB

[@AnonymousTR007]

@@Thaqlain your way of talking is so rude. You can't talk like this about someone. Ok. You've got no right!! Understand!!!!

[@Thaqlain]

That same someone who is rebuked in the Quran for causing trouble to the Prophet? Will you have soft corner for someone who gave trouble to the Prophet?

[@louxjoh]

By Allah, be careful! Be careful! Be careful! Do you say about something you have no knowledge of? Fear Allah, for indeed Hafsa رضي الله عنها is an honored woman of paradise! I ask Allah to save us from ignorance and deviation.

[@JadAwwad]

No she's like wives of Noah and Lot

[@_Zardari_]

yes, tell that to bukhari.

[@Rizvi-2]

Read your own damn books brother, truth is with Ali and Ali is with the Truth Allahu Alam

[@MariaH-f7r]

@louxjoh if Uthman RA had a daughter that was married to the prophet SAW they would have called her disobedient too. You can tell by the narrators voice and if you listen to the arrogance of the students questions. Their tones are of disgust. They should be more concerned about the way they treat their bodies in Muharram. To harm your bodies goes directly against the commands of Allah (swt) and the way of the prophet (saw). As their bodies will speak on the day of judgment about what they said and how they caused their bodies harm.

[@Rizvi-2]

@@MariaH-f7r first of all, ruqayah and umme e kulsoom weren't the 'real' daughter of Prophet SAW

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

Brother why are you telling lies about our mothers?To be famous pls find other ways...Why to show disrespect towards the deceased people..Islam doesnt teach to do so..What manner are you teaching to this ummah?Backbiting?

[@md.helaluddin7613]

Don't go towards fire by speaking ill of the wives of Muhammad pbuh. Make tawba. Allah may forgive YOU all.

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you have only heard the episode related to Hafsa. We urge you to listen to this complete chapter here: kzbin.info/aero/PLOXzVYnjThorUIEtu2YYLNRMq6CBgUOu3

[@ehmkannde8673]

If marrying a dead person's wife honors them, why were the wives of the Prophet prohibited from remarrying after he died?

[@Thaqlain]

We have a dedicated episode on this topic :)

[@cameo777]

Whats the purpose of these wives of the prophet series?. Do they contribute to the faith of the believers in any way? What spiritual purposes do they serve . Very petty, in my opinion. A real teacher will devote his time to things that'll uplift the imaan of his listeners. Not spread hatred and misinformation.

[@Thaqlain]

1) The series is not about the wives of the Prophet. It is about the Prophet himself. And like everything regarding the Prophet has lessons for us, so is his relationship with his wives. There is a purpose Prophet married each of the woman he had marital relationship with. And knowing how the Prophet served his divine duties while some of his wives gave such a difficult time is definitely Imaan boosting. 2) The intend is not to spread hatred or misinformation. In fact, most information is from sources that all Muslims agree upon. We understand that it might be new for you and your image of certain personalities might differ, that doesn't mean it is misinformation :)

[@modular7even]

Accept bukhari if it fits the narative, but don't accept if it don't, this religion is based off hate, nothing more, nothing less. The ultimate question is, what would have happened if imam Ali were to be the leader straight after our prophet (s.a.w?

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you are unaware how scientific discussions happen. In order to prove your point, you bring evidence from the opposing school. So except if you belong to a school that hates scientific discussion, which no Muslim should, you should realize that Sayed is only following the scientific method.

[@modular7even]

@@Thaqlain there is nothing to prove, it's more theology, not much science involved when things become abstract, it becomes blurred and opinions, if something is crystal clear, there is no dispute. Evidence is there with both sides, whatever makes sense logically is where it's at, the twelvers bring some strong arguments, but then it all falls down with the knowledge of the unseen that's attributed to the imams. What I see is something similar to Christianity.

[@Thaqlain]

We have already covered that in detail in The Real Shia Beliefs. Also, there is a lot in Islam similar to Christianity or Judaism. The pagans also used to circumambulate the Kaaba.

[@sdkhan930]

21: 45 please mention reference of sunni hadith.

[@Thaqlain]

Tabari has mentioned this in his Tafsir while Ibn Saad in his Tabaqat.

[@sdkhan930]

please mention exect page no of reffered tafseer book@@Thaqlain

[@sdkhan930]

Reply please@@Thaqlain

[@Thaqlain]

ask.ghamidi.org/forums/discussion/85181/ This link has all the references

[@chirazzk8095]

lol , the prophet saw thought of divorce, but Allah swt ordered he cannot divorce her because of her piety.... and ofcourse she is ahl bayt and umm al momineen in the quran

[@Thaqlain]

The truth is otherwise. Allah allowed the Prophet to divorce them in Surah Tahreem. The Prophet choose not because he is the guide for Ummah.

[@chirazzk8095]

@ lol i think you cannot comprehend , surah tahreem Allah swt is warning the wives that they will be replaced with better wives, the wives repented and they werent replaced , hence they are the best wives deserving of the best man... thats why Allah swt calls his wives ahl bayt and umm al momineen in the quran ... double the honor... the mothers of ali

[@Thaqlain]

We have already discussed these matters in this series as well as The Real Shia Beliefs. In Our Prophet, you can listen from episode 198 onwards. kzbin.info/www/bejne/n4DQZ5eOqcuSZrM In case of The Real Shia Beliefs, we have covered this in episode 95 and onwards kzbin.info/www/bejne/e4rSiYl5rt6MhM0

[@rickyalfred9710]

I’ve been watching these talks with interest. Yesterday I watched the talk about ifk. When i checked out what the shaykh mentioned however it was inaccurate. For example he says that suratul Nur was revealed in the year 8 Hijri yet it was year 6 according to Sunnis not Year 8. This makes his assertion of a contradiction between the chronology of Bukhari with the revelation. Also he failed to mention the crazy assertion that in the narrative of al Hakim Juryh was ordered to be killed by the prophet saaw. He sent imam Ali who discovered he had no male member and thus wasn’t guilty. The prophet saaw sent some one to kill him without due process ? Doesn’t sound right hence that narration isn’t relied on. Disappointing polemics, inaccurate and poor research again. It would be better to use your own sources to assert your view instead of wading in waters you can’t swim in.

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. It seems you went on the internet to check the year of revelation. Over there you will 8th Hijri as being accepted by the majority of scholars without sharing any reference. The Ahlas Sunnah has to push the narrative of 8th hijri being the year of revelation as the alternate means their entire narrative is fabricated. Also, in the story of Jurayh, one has to understand the intensity of the allegation. A wife of the Prophet has made an allegation in regards to the son of the Prophet being born out of wedlock and due to fornication.

[@manazon6945]

No offense, but he cheated on her, aaid that he was allowed to do so, and then threatened her to a divorce if she rebelled?

[@Thaqlain]

How is this cheating?

[@abdul-latifabdulai-ik6tq]

Basically, Rasurullah failed at the family level. Surrounded himself with bad wives and companions. Be serious for once I've been listening to Shia speakers for 10 years now. In Sha Allah, no amount of hollywood stories will make me consider them. May Allah keep us steadfast on the deen. The right path

[@Thaqlain]

How is the Prophet to be blamed for the lack of commitment from his wife? Is Nuh to be blamed for his son? Is Lut to be blamed for his wife?

[@Rizvi-2]

Bro even Nuh and Lut AS had wives who were kafir what's ur point

[@lunarious87]

Syed, can you tell which of the 4 Sunni Sahih are to be avoided?

[@farahmo4519]

Bukhari has a lot of fake hadiths and we need good scholars to guide us. You and me can avoid Bukhari but unfortunately ahlul sunna take it equal to Quran

[@YaShaheed]

There are 6 not 4

[@adamnouri23]

@@farahmo4519 I am sorry but sahih / authentic of al-bukhari is considered second best after the Quran by the so called sunni ,, but NOT EQUAL TO THE QUR'AN .

[@adamnouri23]

@@NDHS1990 " sahihs " are supposed to be authentics ; however , they are full of contradictions , lies and descripencies . So , they are not authentic , solid nor reliable . The fact that these books were given that kind of high status is misleading. Well , the same applies to the expression " ahl_us-sunnah " / the sunnis. It was just a claim that they follow the " sunnah " of the prophet. In fact , they have been following Omar's sunnah , Abu Bakr' s sunnah , 'Aisha' s sunnah , Othman' s sunnah ,,, So , it is just a lie . A misleading title ,,

[@evanfreshman2450]

​@@adamnouri23 I would argue the problem is that the modern Sunnis take what was an academic term as a religious term. If a hadith is sahih that means the scholar believes it is authentic in the sense that the quote was transmitted to the present day in a manner that it can be reasonably attributed to its narrators and should be included in historical discussions. As a person living in 2023 if I want to read the words of Julius Caesar Commentarii de Bello Gallico is likely the words of Julius Caesar whereas citing the play Julius Caesar is inauthentic, the words of Shakespeare.

[@MYUSEF-o3g]

CAN YOU JUST tell the non muslims that your are shiite tis would help a lot since people will confuse that you are part of the broader muslims

[@Thaqlain]

Indeed a lot of non-Muslims have watched episodes of this series. And we do provide them this clarity that the School of Ahlulbayt's perspective is different from mainstream Ahlal Sunnah.

[@Anonymous-sr6co]

Bukhari is authentic hadith. The one you mentioned is not.

[@Thaqlain]

Claiming a hadith to be unauthentic requires proof :)

[@rifatara917]

This is so interesting I alwayes wanted to know about this wicked lady bcz not much is available about this gangster.

[@faizashahrukh2634]

Why is she wicked

[@m.m4999]

I thought I'd get historical information instead I was insulted for being a Sunni and not thinking lamely like you do...

[@Thaqlain]

We are sorry you felt insulted. History hurts at times 🙂

[@vivek4969]

​@@Thaqlain Savage brother ❤ It's really good that you are spreading the correct Islam as the entire world doesn't know about these things.

[@michaelallesee304]

Fancy delayed tabloids (in sha’Allah)

[@muhammadhamza3888]

May Allah guide us all. Please be careful saying ‘The trouble maker’. She’s one of of Ummahat Al Mominoon’

[@Thaqlain]

The Quran has referred to some wives as the trouble maker :)

[@UthmanOtieno]

Respect the mother of believers,Hafsa and Aisha RA

[@youhavetoacceptitevenifyou9025]

I wish brother, but history has proven that they were open enemies of the Holy household that Allah swt has chosen and we know for a fact that The Holy Prophet ص doesn't respect them. With that, I can never respect those two individuals Wasalam

[@Crazy88277]

To the contrary. The prophet loved Aisha dearly. There is plenty proof of that. If not why would he go out of his way to marry her at such a young age. It makes no sense. Please give your evidence that shows the prophet peace and blessings be upon him did not Love Aisha, May Allah be pleased with her.

[@Crazy88277]

Also the prophet PBUH did not lay out a clear succession plan so by simply having your own opinion on who should succeed does not make her an enemy of Islam. Maybe an enemy of the party of Ali but not of Islam as a whole. Two different things.​@@youhavetoacceptitevenifyou9025

[@devilhasashi8701]

​@@Crazy88277😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@The_Path_Of_Ali]

@@Crazy88277oh no, you’ve got it all wrong my friend

[@cameo777]

Why so much hatred and disrespect . These people were associated with the prophet. You dont like their fathers ,fine, but you dont have to hate the offspring just because you don't like the parents. Lord!. And stop telling us what Allah thought when He didn't tell anyone what He was thinking. How do you know what Allah was thinking??. You think you are disrespecting these people, but you are only belittling yourself.

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. It seems like you confused academic study with hatred. We, the followers of Ahlulbayt, don't hate Ayesha. As we have mentioned, the information might be new for you, but our purpose is not to disrespect. But we have to see which of his wives were good with him and which of them caused the revelation of Surah Tahrim :)

[@abdul-latifabdulai-ik6tq]

All reasons do not sense.

[@louxjoh]

I ask Allah against the danger of deviation and may Allah continue to honor all of the companions of the Prophet ﷺ, all of them.

[@Johnny-xk7vw]

The family is more dearer to the prophet . Stop worshipping hypocrite companions .

[@yakubumusa5855]

Oh dunyah

[@abdullahassaffah]

Shia kafir being their usual kafir Hafsa radiallahuanha wasnt divirced and she wasnt a trouble maker she simply had a aggressive personality which sometimes got her in trouble but tue prophet salallahualayuwasallam never divorced her and she did what many of his other wives did whethsr due to trying to control compete ro jealousy

[@Thaqlain]

It seems you wrote this comment without watching the video.

[@faizashahrukh2634]

He did but then he took her back

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

Dont please mislead this ummah..Please Ummah be careful before taking his lessons.Listen other lectures about our mothers..Be respectful towards our mothers..

[@liahnatashah5145]

continue Follow your Bukhairi then😂

[@AceAngel0214]

He’s literally quoting your books. Stop acting blind you and the people who liked your comment. But your hearts are closed to the truth 🤷‍♀️

[@ShaneO-e9n]

By looking at the actions of the mothers is nothing wrong. It's common sense. Was not the wife of Lut as left behind. Open your eyes and heart.

[@DaTruth1017]

*Ignorance is a choice*

[@farnahram512]

Pls dont accept things blindly...do proper research....he is stating facts! Open ur mind the problem wt most Muslims is that they cant accept any challenge...why dont u check 2 see if ur information and what u have been thought is correct or based on faluse information...

[@multanprarie2600]

Do not attack the noble wives of the Last Prophet salAllaho alaihi wa alihi wa salam. Fear Allah, Twelvers!

[@Thaqlain]

Salaam Alaykum. May Allah protect us from attacking wives of the Prophet.

[@Rizvi-2]

Not noble at all, Hafsa and Aisha

[@maisain5511]

Why do Shia scholars always against the sunnis and cursing the Sahabas and spreading hates. I have never seen Shia scholars spreading Islam to the non-muslims. 😶

[@Thaqlain]

Where is the cursing or hate in this video?

[@maisain5511]

@Thaqlain Let not go to the video and see the thumbnail itself. "Trouble Maker" You calling the mother of the believers a "A Trouble Maker". Plus prophet did not divorce Hafsa. Why spread the false.

[@Thaqlain]

We repeat our question: where is cursing or hate in the video? Because that's an accusation you just made.

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

From where are you taking these lies?😢😢😢😢😢😢😢Stupidity...How Umar r.a might have brought up such an evil daughter as you described?....Umar(r.a.) was the one who was annouced to be jannati...No way..Umar (r.a)never brouvht up such a girl as you described..WOULD YOU YOURSELF BRING UP SUCH A DAUGHTER ?

[@Thaqlain]

How Prophet Adam brought up a son who killed his brother? How Prophet Nuh brought up a son who went against him? Is Umar greater than Prophets?

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

The prophet s.a.v. said "Allah has commanded me to marry only with the women of Paradise..

[@Thaqlain]

Please share the reference to this hadith. Because it directly goes against the Quran which in Surah Tahrim rebuked the wives.

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

Quran was revealed to make us decent people not the one who will backbite those who already have lived their lives..We muslims should become decent people by reading The Holy book not gossipy...I couldnt understand the point of your lecture..What can I learn from it?Nothing for morality...What is this lecture for?To teach gossiping about the dead people? May Allah guide us all..What can say nonmuslims listening your lecture ..,Surely your lecture is misguiding

[@Thaqlain]

Before we answer this, please share the reference of your earlier mentioned hadith. Also, the point of this lecture is simple. To learn from the Prophet's life on how to interact with wives who are difficult :)

[@sharminkachwala3128]

What did he go nuts 🌰

[@murtazabandali5609]

Save her from going stray .

[@farahmo4519]

She passed away already

[@fotimakattabekova2171]

Ohh brother you are telling such awful things about the mothers of this ummah..How you dare brother😢😢..We love our mothers..Our mothers are the women of paradice..Dont cause fitna

[@Thaqlain]

Please share any proof from the Quran or hadith that Ummahatul Momineen are women of paradise because Allah rebukes some of the wives of the Prophet in the Quran.

[@mudasirbeigh6250]

Shame on you!

[@Thaqlain]

For?

[@mudasirbeigh6250]

@@Thaqlain for quoting Sunni sources and then misinterpreting, twisting and bending the meaning to fuel your propaganda of hate and venom. More and more I am exposed to this, more clear it is getting that foundation of todays shiaism is hate, poison and filth. How can a truthful person who seeks face of Allah, embed above traits as part of belief in heart. Even Satanist’s don’t preach that. Hate Hate and Hate that is your religion.

[@Thaqlain]

Can you share a proof where we have twisted or bended a narration to fuel our propaganda?

[@ilovelone4329]

Shia no,Muslim

[@arminasangma7981]

Islam Muhammad married Bad woman Kadhija who divorced her husband two times one after another

[@Thaqlain]

There is no truth is this claim :)

[@samyhannah9563]

can I get the Sahih Bukhari hadith number please anyone?

[@Thaqlain]

3772

[@faizashahrukh2634]

​@@Thaqlainisn't it about aisha

[@Thaqlain]

@@faizashahrukh2634 can you share which specific hadith are you referring to?

[@zoyabeig8157]

You are critical regarding every wife of prophet (saw) by saying that Hafsa(ra) was not good or had an attitude. Prophet wanted to set an example is correct but dnt highlight and disrespect any wives of prophet.

[@Thaqlain]

It is deeply disturbing to see that a Muslim's focus on a wife's respect overshadows the profound trials and tribulations that the Prophet endured because of her, as documented in the Quran, hadith, and Seerah.