The 3 Questions Posed To The Prophet Muhammad

[@abuakmal9618]

We in Malaysia call all mu'azzin as Bilal. Even the official designation is Bilal.

[@nurama]

Same here in Indonesia

[@abuakmal9618]

@Mamat bin Mat hahaha hebat jang

[@deadhead532]

God bless u all.....from ur brother from Cairo Egypt

[@bilalomer1675]

😁

[@iss-hakabu2574]

Interesting to know

[@mobashir31]

Youve become more n more knowledgeable about this religion since i first started following you. You are actually teaching me something i never knew im every video. Masha'Allah akhi. May Allah give us more n more understanding about islam. My brother in emaan

[@FaisalKhan-iw6tw]

Bro it's his religion too

[@mobashir31]

@@FaisalKhan-iw6tw i know. Whats your point

[@mobashir31]

@@annabanna8852 dont know who hes talking too lol

[@mobashir31]

@@annabanna8852 im salafi... Even though hes a sufi, i think the context of the book is correct, as its a biography. Im not taking Aqeedah or manhaj

[@FaisalKhan-iw6tw]

May Allah unite the muslims. And bring back the glory days

[@andrewcohen786]

Thanks!

[@wafafarhat3656]

pls save money for charity(zakkat) not this channel

[@andrewcohen786]

@@wafafarhat3656 why don’t you save your energy and not your nonsense. Paul’s work is an inspiration and I am a better Muslim because of his exceptional work. Now what’s your problem .

[@andrewcohen786]

@@wafafarhat3656 Paul is my inspiration and a light in this dark world. At the risk of sounding impolite what have you done for Islam at any stage ?

[@AE86FTS]

I am grateful that my parents chose to name me after such a noble companion.

[@caressandkiss4454]

@@TheWatchmanWebsite Yeah all this is great. Jesus Christ this and that blah blah whatever. Jesus said his kingdom was of not this world.. the real story suits is that Jesus was unsuccessful in making a kingdom of this world so he made an excuse that his kingdom is not of this world... Sounds like failure to me. You say Jesus was born from a spirit and was able to remain without sin. Well Mary is from Adam so I guess she's sinful so as her son. First you should prove "YOUR" Jesus was born of the holy spirit. You say all prophets are dead but Jesus is alive.first you're admitting that Jesus is a prophet secondly. Didn't your so called Jesus Christ die for your sin so how is he alive... Spiritually all prophets are alive then. You say devils used to tremble by his name... But looks like Satan was successful in getting close to him tempting him and taking him for a ride on whole flat earth According to the bible. You say that Jesus was compassionate.. a man who calls others bad names like pig and dogs or filthy or adulterous seems to be forgotting that he said forgive and be kind... Looks like all talk and bad role model. Just because your Jesus was unsuccessful in obtaining slaves and killing as he was weak. Then he's just a failure.. he's just talking big that forgive and this kingdom of heaven and all are below me and all that nonsense. The man who say all are below me and in the end getting killed by all those below people and naked shameless on cross and asking for help. Your model of Jesus is a complete failure and a disaster. Those are some facts about YOUR version of Jesus. But Islamic Jesus is not so weak to be killed by lowlifes like your Jesus did... All christian can do is insult the prophet Muhammad by those slave allegations and marriage with Aisha... They got nothing else to say . If you have a problem with Aisha being nine the Your so called Jesus. Who you say was born of spirit but actually was of Joseph.. who was over 90 and Mary was 13 and banged out a baby from her.. Your religion is a scam which is built on distorting some holy people and making them look like worse then devil

[@caressandkiss4454]

@@TheWatchmanWebsite and please don't reply me back you pathetic fool .. just read and fix this in your head... And scram

[@AE86FTS]

@@TheWatchmanWebsite I don't think of the prophets as being in competition with one another. I respect all of them and the message they provided

[@caressandkiss4454]

@@TheWatchmanWebsite OK first of all I said. Don't talk to me . Secondly. You can't prove that the source your quoting from is true.. you have no chain of authenticity going back to Mary or Jesus or even those deciples who allegedly wrote those gospels... But for the sake of argument let's agree those "gospels are authentic" Kingdom of David was very big let's assume. But that poor fella of yours didn't even get to rule a single human being let alone the whole humanity. I repeat. Beside those merciful quotes of Jesus, all Jesus is doing is talking big .. nothing else... He's just saying I'll get this and that and everything is under me and I'm god (which he never claimed) but ends up getting killed naked on the cross all those whom Jesus was belittling were watching him naked and being a crybaby. Is that you call god? Man this god of yours is worse then those idols worshipped by pagans

[@AE86FTS]

@@TheWatchmanWebsite Within the Old Testament Book of Psalms, there is Psalm 91:10-16 which states this about the Messiah "no harm will overtake you, no disaster will come near your tent. For he will command his angels concerning you to guard you in all your ways; they will lift you up in their hands, so that you will not strike your foot against a stone. You will tread on the lion and the cobra; you will trample the great lion and the serpent. “Because he[a] loves me,” says the Lord, “I will rescue him; I will protect him, for he acknowledges my name. He will call on me, and I will answer him; I will be with him in trouble, I will deliver him and honor him. With long life I will satisfy him and show him my salvation.” Here this clearly states that the Messiah will be protected from harm and that angels would be commanded concerning him. One thing to point out that this Psalm is mentioned within the New Testament. According to Matthew 4:5-7, there is this interaction between Jesus and Satan. "Then the devil taketh him up into the holy city, and setteth him on a pinnacle of the temple, And saith unto him, If thou be the Son of God, cast thyself down: for it is written, He shall give his angels charge concerning thee: and in their hands they shall bear thee up, lest at any time thou dash thy foot against a stone. Jesus said unto him, It is written again, Thou shalt not tempt the Lord thy God." Here we see Satan quoting Psalm 91 to tempt Jesus to jump down as it mentions that God shall fully protect him. Interestingly, Jesus doesn't accuse Satan of twisting the scriptural meaning, rather he states "It is written again", which affirms that Psalm 91 is indeed referring to him. So with what is said in Psalm 91:10-16, and it's affirmation Matthew 4:5-7, wouldn't the idea of a crucifixion go against what is said here? Doesn't the Islamic belief seem more on line with this prophecy? { وَقَوۡلِهِمۡ إِنَّا قَتَلۡنَا ٱلۡمَسِيحَ عِيسَى ٱبۡنَ مَرۡيَمَ رَسُولَ ٱللَّهِ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ وَمَا صَلَبُوهُ وَلَٰكِن شُبِّهَ لَهُمۡۚ وَإِنَّ ٱلَّذِينَ ٱخۡتَلَفُواْ فِيهِ لَفِي شَكّٖ مِّنۡهُۚ مَا لَهُم بِهِۦ مِنۡ عِلۡمٍ إِلَّا ٱتِّبَاعَ ٱلظَّنِّۚ وَمَا قَتَلُوهُ يَقِينَۢا } [Surah An-Nisâ': 157] Dr. Mustafa Khattab: and for boasting, “We killed the Messiah, Jesus, son of Mary, the messenger of Allah.” But they neither killed nor crucified him-it was only made to appear so. Even those who argue for this ˹crucifixion˺ are in doubt. They have no knowledge whatsoever-only making assumptions. They certainly did not kill him. { بَل رَّفَعَهُ ٱللَّهُ إِلَيۡهِۚ وَكَانَ ٱللَّهُ عَزِيزًا حَكِيمٗا } [Surah An-Nisâ': 158] Dr. Mustafa Khattab: Rather, Allah raised him up to Himself. And Allah is Almighty, All-Wise.

[@theyoungthinker7028]

Pls continue sharing with us chapters from this precious book 📖 💖

[@iaadirana8155]

Yesss. And make a series NUMBER WISE

[@iaadirana8155]

Yesss. And make a series NUMBER WISE

[@moizahmed4705]

*Narrated by Abu Buraidah:* *"The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) awoke in the morning and called for Bilal, then said: 'O Bilal! By what have you preceded me to Paradise? I have not entered Paradise at all, except that I heard your footsteps before me. I entered Paradise last night, and I heard your footsteps before me..." [Tirmidhi, **#Hadith** 3689]* *It was narrated that Anas bin Malik said:* *"The Messenger of Allah said: 'I have been tortured for the sake of Allah as no one else has, and I have suffered fear for the sake of Allah as no one else has. I have spent three days when Bilal and I had no food that any living being could eat but that which could be concealed in the armpit of Bilal." [Sunan Ibn Majah, Hadith **#151**]*

[@homer1273]

Those fake Hadith sound pathetic and ignorant. Why would prophet claim that no one suffered more like him when that is obviously not true. Even today there are people who suffered more

[@homer1273]

The Quran clearly says to prophet Muhammed to say that he does not know the future or the ghaib. It even says that prophet doesn’t know what will happen to him, but somehow we are supposed to believe that he told Bilal what will happen to him

[@noahdanielg]

I admire Bilal, most inspiring of the Ṣaḥāba!

[@imbored1179]

He, and Umar are certainly my favorites to read about. Along with Abdullah bin Salam and Salman Al farsi

[@supremercommonder]

The nabi muhammed saw is our leader and the companions are our hero. Bilal ra for his steadfast and fire reliance. Umar ra for his character, khalid ibn waleed ra and hamza for being strong ect

[@welcometonature9021]

Bilal was slave of muhammad

[@kingmosesix432]

Wht the heck is ur profile pic ?

[@greenzone1127]

بارك الله فيك

[@irfanahmed6411]

Dear brother Paul Allah bless you you are doing great work on this planet and we love you

[@juxtapositionMS]

Great seerah story. I read many times and still loved a lot to hear from you again.

[@amirahamdy9433]

Mashallah ♥️🤲 جزاكم الله خيراً🌹

[@instrumentengineer5823]

Allah says "Those who took religion as amusement and play, and WERE DECEIVED BY the (TEMPORARY) LIFE OF THIS WORLD. Today WE will ignore them just as they ignored their meeting of this Day and BECAUSE THEY USED TO REJECT OUR VERSES.” Qur'an Majeed 7.51

[@essa200911]

Peace be upon our prophet Mohammed peace be upon him And May Allah be pleased with our master Bilal Ameen

[@mclovin1071]

This was lovely, thank you Paul. I would most certainly enjoy more of this style of videos. God bless you. Love, from South Africa.

[@iftibaber]

Thank you so much for sharing with us sir

[@evpassion393]

The added value you bring is incredible. You have one of the best KZbin channels. Congratulations

[@faizsheikh9442]

I named my daughter after the first & great martyr of Islam Sumaiya (RA)

[@Rupokhasan2011]

Pray Allah to guide her the best way Our prophet Muhammad peace be upon him has said to us

[@streetlamp669]

JazakAllah brother Paul ❤

[@RoofingConnecticut]

I can’t listen to stories of the life of the prophet ﷺ and his companions without getting teary eyed over their hardship

[@OksintasObones]

Fake prophet you meant

[@Avenged7Xs]

What hardship muhamad was wealthy, he had 11 wives, owned 13 houses had dozens of slaves and servants, owned s€x slaves, and got 20 percent of the war booty, and charged money to people that wanted to hear his advice, muhamad was like a Mafia boss, so spare me you're crocodile tears...

[@Avenged7Xs]

It's time for you to grow up you're not a baby anymore...

[@coolalatool33]

This part of the early Islam and the suffering the early Muslims endured is relatable in so many ways with the conditions of some Muslims today.. it gives both strength and hope of that at the end the truth will prevail and the suffering will come to an end and we have victory..

[@oaa8021]

15:06 I like how you still continue reading even with the church bell ringing 😂

[@wanfirdauus]

Is that a church bell or clock?

[@mansoorahmad5632]

Such an excellent way of explaining the subject, Regards.

[@hafiz5001]

Jazak Allah khair dear 🙏 ❤️

[@essa200911]

May Allah be pleased with our master Abu baker alsteq the honest and the one who freed our master bilal May Allah be pleased with them all and peace be upon our prophet Mohammed peace be upon him Ameen

[@machotkeyz8086]

You'll find the answers to the 3 questions in the book of Daniel. The 3 questions were all linked to one subject. According to this story Mohammed must have thought they were separate questions on separate subject.. Hence why the answers he gave was sadly wrong.

[@chrishoff402]

Daniel is in the Old Testament, written back around 600 B.C. The 7 Sleepers of Ephesus was written around 500 A.D.

[@MadChatter17]

@@chrishoff402exactly, it’s no surprise the correct answers would be found in old Jewish scripture but it’s a big surprise ppL still disagree as to whether or not Muhammad failed this test of prophethood. If he was honest he would’ve admitted how they didn’t accept his answer as incorrect, then claimed it was bc disbelief or w/e

[@chrishoff402]

@@MadChatter17 Question 3 about The Spirit is from the Gospel of John. The Rabbis didn't want to involve their own faith in a test that could result in an execution for failure, because that is the penalty for being a false prophet in Judaism, death by stoning. Question 3 is a Kafka trap centuries before Kafka was born, it is the literal Christian test for false prophets, and if he answered correctly he would contradict what he had been teaching his own followers with them present and listening. The correct answer in Christianity being The Spirit became flesh in Jesus Christ the Son of God who died for our sins on The Cross, and was resurrected from the dead. A Kafka trap is a question with two possible answers that are both incriminating.

[@kingmosesix432]

@@chrishoff402 Any “trap” or whtevrr christian bring in their twisted understanding of the scriptures is rejected automatically based on the fact tht the Christian doctrine is tht of shirk and polytheism and not supported by scripture wht so ever…… I mean the irony.. Here we have a Prophet with pure revelation with pure tawhid ( monotheism ) being somehow questioned by the audacious blasphemers called trinitarians who believe The Lord somehow died beaten and humiliated… May God’s curse be on the fools who say such outrageous things about Him And high above is He above all this

[@kingmosesix432]

He answered the question as it was asked to Him He gave the answer and end of case… Now u have pagans here coming and saying “oh he didnt” Without even proving why he didnt or why he was supposedly wrong.. Go on

[@ameg2707]

🌹💯 Jazak Allah Khair!

[@ItachiAli1993]

I would like to know what happened to Bilal (RA) after the Prophet passed away Peace be upon him and his Holy Progeny

[@zainiabdullah621]

He died of pandemic in Damascus. W/A Allahh Knows best.

[@ryanhunter2987]

Excellent question, as he really disappears from most of the early histories....I wonder why this is....🤔

[@Chidorie12]

Exciled away from Medina for not pledging baya to the current caliphs. Eventually migrated to Syria where he spent the rest of his life and passed away.

[@ItachiAli1993]

@@ryanhunter2987 exactly...... Why is that.... Hmmmm

[@ItachiAli1993]

@@Chidorie12 wow no way???

[@nadirkhan9430]

Another splendid effort paul👍👏✌️

[@Firp353]

Interesting is how the first Muslims had to go through hardship to remain in faith.

[@OksintasObones]

What hardship?? It was all staged and colored by Jewish scholars from khorasan like bukhari and so on

[@sarahhajarbalqis]

0:01 - 8:30 The Three Questions and Inshaa Allah.

[@abraarhussain786]

May Allah swt protect and guide all the people that do dawah and make these videos of dawah as well ameen.

[@wildlife-46]

Brother Paul you will reach one million subscribers soon insha'Allah

[@aimanshaikh1564]

May Allah guide us with more ilm and may give u strength who prevail reality to pepl.thank u sir

[@bruckbedru8178]

Bilal is my fellow country man Ethiopian💪

[@aventus3491]

Muhammad said ur head is like a raisin, including all the ethiopians, your mom dad daughter son father brothers and sisters.... Is Muhammad lying or not? Sahih al-Bukhari 693 Narrated Anas: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Listen and obey (your chief) even if an Ethiopian whose head is like a raisin were made your chief."

[@bruckbedru8178]

@@aventus3491 are you trying to bring your woke culture in your argument? Well unfortunately I am Ethiopian the only african nation that has never been colonized by any nation! The romans, the pre-islamic arabs, the ottomans and the italians all tried to invade my nation, unfortunately for them it ended in a humiliating defeat! am sorry to say this but unlike my african brothers and sisters we Ethiopians don't have this inferiority complex at all. Our recent battle was with the italians in the battle of Adwa 1896 were fascist italy suffered a humiliating defeat at the hand of my brave ancestors! Ironically Ethiopian victory over the italians resulted as inspiration for all African countries including south africa! If you want to be enlightened read about what mandela said about my country Ethiopia. Speaking of islam, when the pre-islamic pagan arabs were prosecuting the prophet families the prophet ordered them to go to the habesha king(Ethiopian) who is a just and good christian leader at the time. And they did come and seek refugee from the pagans. and when the quarayish tribes come to the Ethiopian christian king to ask for the prophet families he refused to give them back and he protected them. prophet mohammed said to his followers in the hadith to not harm the Ethiopians in their quest of Spreading the word of G-d.

[@bruckbedru8178]

@@aventus3491 and by the way Ethiopia is the second nation to accept christianity as a state religion next to armenia in 330AD conversely Ethiopia is also the second nation to accept islam next to medina!

[@aventus3491]

@@bruckbedru8178 im just asking do you believe what Muhammad said that ur head is a raisin? Its just a simple question why u need to cry.. im just quoting your beloved prophet Muhammad calling your raisin head. if you have a problem then its not me. Its Muhammad

[@aventus3491]

@@bruckbedru8178 who cares about your battle with the italians or what.. Im asking do you agree with Muhammad saying Ethiopians including you, your head r raisins?

[@GalaxyS233]

Paul, I advise you to read the «Book of Monotheism» by Abu Mansoor al-Maturidi, and «The greatest universal sureties» by Ramadan al-Buti.

[@theyoungthinker7028]

I recommend watching "the message " movie .. pls watch it if you haven't sir .... it's interesting

[@1cognito]

I love all your content Paul but i have to skip every video where you simply read from this book from Lining because I am planning on reading it soon inchaAllah. So please stop spoiling it :) You're channel is still one of my favorite on YT. Jazak Allah o kheyr.

[@iiMubarak]

Great Job brother 👍🏻❤️

[@johnxina8954]

He got all three questions wrong. They were all about the prophecies of Daniel

[@user-np3cp2cb7u]

the mentioning of Bilal starts at 9:24

[@abdellahbarrous8516]

Dear Paul, Qarn in arabic means also Century.

[@rayees192]

A epoch, an era so it could mean horns or an Epoch or era

[@teenaakhir9105]

Such a treat listening to you bro...❄️💙

[@Cromwell142]

He got three questions. The first one about the Holy Spirit he couldn't answer and basically said 'Allah knows best'. The other two he answered incorrectly and thus walked right into the trap set before him. A proper prophet should have known better I dare to assume.

[@ayyazsiddique5381]

JazakALLAHukhairan

[@junaid7530]

Ammar ibn Yasir also was tortured in the same way by Abu jahl. Even both his parents were killed in that torture. Want a video in that as well

[@AhmadRaza-sy5bh]

Noone cares about ammar ra because of they will talk about ammar then they have to tell who killed ammar on whose permission.

[@ladifmefire2943]

Masha Allah

[@luckheartnoble6718]

Please let the video be uploaded on daniel 9 with Dr Ali Ataie Please please

[@blueblubber6607]

That Muhamed always received his revelations when he needed them the most (and when they arranged his private affairs) 1400 years before the term "just in time delivery" was even coined, shows unambiguously that he is a true prophet.

[@mikhan5191]

Then why did JIT fail on this occasion???? No Revelation for 15 days!!! Yes, Revelation from God would come to the the Prophet (saw) when God wanted it Revealed. It was NEVER under the control of the Prophet. When Revelation did come, it would sometimes come straight away in front of the questioner and the Prophet's Companions knew when he was receiving the Revelations because they could see and feel the physical changes experienced by the Prophet during this process. And this happend over a period of 23 years in front of his wives, children, relatives and thousands of Companions who all believed in him and what they were witnessing in front of their eyes.

[@blueblubber6607]

@@mikhan5191 "No Revelation for 15 days!!!" 15 days are not 15 years.

[@mikhan5191]

@@blueblubber6607 - then why do you accuse the Prophet (saw) of fabricating the Revelation JUST IN TIME as suited his own needs and desires????? Have you no common sense????

[@OksintasObones]

Actually he failed to answer and when he answered he answered false ... He was a fake prophet and his true name is Qutham bnu abd allat not Mohamed for Mohamed was the surname of Jesus

[@logicalanswers1559]

Assalamu alaikum 🙌🏻

[@saidmohammed7597]

It was Jews who came to ask Rasul if he knew about " Dhulqarnain " Dhulqarnain if a man than it may be the men who traveled between the two horns the West to the East . But also could mean the two centuries. The very two promises that God gave to Moses after the Jews refused to enter the promised land. This means the name of the two promises in the Torah were called Dhulqarnain where in the Quran are called the first promise and the final promise surat Issra. However the two promises Dhulqarnain in the Torah have been omitted, and as such the Quran has reserved the name Dhulqarnain from the question of the Jews to Rasul. This than explains the answer to Jews the return journey for the final promise to the East Jerusalem and the future exodus to Gog ma Gog land when the century expires. The Return was blessed by British mandate for Palestinian 1921.

[@elizabethgeorge4708]

Muhammad truly made mess of the three questions posed to him. 😂😂

[@OksintasObones]

Yeah he failed to answer and when he answered he answered false

[@kingmosesix432]

@@OksintasObonesfor eg ?? Like every can lie just like u did The fact is He answered yet ur too salty to accept.. Plus the jews didnt rebuttal lol

[@kingmosesix432]

Like in wht way ?? He literally answered them

[@abx6732]

Quality of your videos have improved lot over time. Hope you will start uploading in 4k soon. With quality like unbox therapy and mkbhd.

[@schmooplesthesecond5997]

So, about the question of the spirit.. the third question.. can somebody please explain it?

[@kitaro2902]

No, because even God didn't want to explain it

[@joseduarte2146]

They’re related to the book of Daniel. He came the internet today to know but back then God couldn’t gave him the answers ? Claims the Hes in-line with prophets but he’s clearly not Jews are smart because any not claim they’re a prophet so the questions was to weed out the fakes

[@kingmosesix432]

@@joseduarte2146 The answer was clear and precise…. And the fact wht ever is in daniel is wrong.. And if it was so available obviously no need to ask the question in the 1st place.. Plus if the jews are such authority for u How about their cheif rabbi who also asked The prophet 3 questions and became Muslim? How about u take Him as an example?

[@kingmosesix432]

@@joseduarte2146the question jews asked about the “spirit” is not wht they meant …. Hence daneil reference here is not right

[@ghrbaa6727]

Salam Brother Paul Please Read This.. Martin Lings got it wrong, the barrier Dzulqarnayn built was never to contain any “jinn” or any “evil spirits”, but to cantain a tribe of people that was pillaging and spread fasad to nearby peoples of the Caucasus. The belief of later muslims that Gog and Magog are more like “orcs” is in objection of the Prophetic hadith where the Holy Prophet (PBUH) said that Gog and Magog are human kinds, the sons of Adam like the rest of us. In the time of Prophet all the early muslims understood of Gog and Magog as another tribe of people, unlike today where they have been mystified by the Islamic tradition over the centuries as they had lost the capacity to locate and identify Gog and Magog. Another thing Paul that you should pay attention is that after the passing of the Holy Prophet (PBUH), the sahaba (companions of the Prophet) sent expeditions to the area in the gorge of Caucasus mountains to locate the iron barrier, and the expedition returned to the Caliph and reported that the barrier was already in ruin. The Prophet himself warned in his lifetime that a hole was made to the barrier when he was still alive. That means that the process of the release of Gog and Magog had already occured 1400+ years ago. It is quite apt considering the body of murky water could very well likely be the Black Sea (as some tafseer scholars identified as such) that the people whose language was not known to Dzulqarnayn was probably proto-Georgian, and that the Gog and Magog who spread fasad by pillaging was the Scythian tribes, and later from the same area Khazaria emerged. In the 8th century the Khazars who were pagans and worshipped many false gods/idols and also animists CONVERTED to Judaism (only because they were wedged on both sides by the muslim caliphate and the byzantium christendom), and later through marriage with eastern Europeans became the first European Ashkenazi Jews. Which is why Allah SWT says in the Quran that the Jews who were banished from Israel could never return UNTIL Gog and Magog are released. Gog and Magog has become the international banking military industrial complex, shadow government. Any person who can see and is not blind by heart can recognize that Pax Americana which despite the “democratic” elections and change of Presidents over decades, continue to support and arm Israel, including with nuclear warheads. Because the shadow government itself has its origin from Gog and Magog, so is the Zionist lobby groups and AIPAC, and preach godless liberalism, darwinism, and even allow satanic church (they call it new age religion or alternative religion) to take hold in the US, and some other western European countries. I hope this is not too much of an information overload for you brother Paul. Allah Knows Best.

[@ghrbaa6727]

@@snowstreams7503 then you need to explain why the Jews have returned to Israel when the Quran says the banished people can only return after the release of Gog & Magog. You’re waiting for some kind of orc-men to descend from mountaintops probably from some kind of magical portals?

[@Harlegeist]

I have a question for Mohammed: Where does the sun set at night? Surely not a muddy pool, right? As Islam is so rational and scientifically accurate and all.

[@Halal_Dan]

Dhul Qarnayn saw the sun setting *as if* it was setting into a muddy pool, it looked like this from his perspective meaning he reached all the way East to the coast.

[@Harlegeist]

@@Halal_Dan The Prophet asked me at sunset, "Do you know where the sun goes (at the time of sunset)?" I replied, "Allah and His Apostle know better." He said, "It goes (i.e. travels) till it prostrates Itself underneath the Throne and takes the permission to rise again, and it is permitted and then (a time will come when) it will be about to prostrate itself but its prostration will not be accepted, and it will ask permission to go on its course but it will not be permitted, but it will be ordered to return whence it has come and so it will rise in the west. - Sahih Bukhari 4:54:421 From the looks of things, it seems Mohammed himself believed the sun to be an enity that orbits around the Earth (instead of vice versa) and "asks for permission to rise again". This is ignoring the fact that the sun can simultaneously "rise" and also "set" depending on what timezone you're in.

[@Halal_Dan]

@@Harlegeist Everything is underneath the throne, and the sun does indeed rise on our horizon, which is the subject in this hadith as there will be a day where the sun rises in the west. The sun rises from the same place no matter what your timezone is, until that Day.

[@ezat1991]

Masha'llah! Your material is too good for us not to make use of it, can you please make a playlist of the readings of martin lings book please? like in the chronological order of the Sira of the Prophet PBUH?

[@iaadirana8155]

Yesss,yesss,yesss

[@bactrian1442]

Please watch the video under the title of (How Muhammad's claims of prophet-hood were exposed) on KZbin, it is about this very matter: The three questions that were asked from Muhammad and how he got them all wrong.

[@sutil5078]

If Abu Jahal, or Umayah, alwalid, Abu Lahab etc would listen now that they become an example of disbelievers after 1450 years (8 years before hijara aprox) they would have realized that their devilish friends, businesses, and pride doomed them and now they are narrations in all corners of the world. they would not have expected that in their wildest dream.. the funny thing they were in their 50s 60s, alwalid, Abu lahab, and Umayah even possibbly in their 70s they died before The migration. this to live with more money and alcohol etc for few more years ,what 10 years more? they sold all this for 10 or 15 years more. and at that age anyways their desire, lust etc are weaker. trading this for eternity is huge loss.

[@sudaysfreepalestineandfree6212]

Assalamualeykum Warahmetullah plz release the Abyssinia chapter I am Abyssinian and I want to listen🙏

[@BloggingTheology]

Later today God willing!

[@sudaysfreepalestineandfree6212]

@@BloggingTheology JazzakAllah hayr

[@aadilqayoom6872]

Rather sayyidna hazrat Bilal radiallahhuanhu

[@tahahajmohamady6932]

Paul , I most say that it's pronounced ajoj a majoj not agog a magong

[@fire.smok3]

اللهم صلي وسلم على سيدنا محمد

[@kamj1969]

Dzulqarnain was most likely Cyrus the Great. Dzulqarnain means two horns which are the two empires of Media and Lydia that Cyrus conquered and united them to form the Archaemenid empire. The travels of Cyrus also coincides with that of Dzulqarnain in the Quran. First he conquered Lydia in the west and bordering the dark waters of the Black Sea, then he went to the Gedrosian desert where the people there lived a primitive nomadic lifestyle under the hot and extreme Gedrosian desert. Alexander the Great in his attempt to follow the footsteps of Cyrus, crossed the Gedrosian desert at great expense where many of his army perished in the journey. Cyrus was also revered by the Jews and he was prophesied to come by the prophet Jeremiah and Isaiah 200 years before he was born. During his reign as the king of the Archaemenid empire he conquered Babylon and released the many Jews who were exiled there after Nebuchednezar destroyed the first temple. He also funded the building of the second temple of Jerusalem after he conquered Babylon. Such was the honour bestowed on him that he is called the messiah in the Old Testament, the only gentile to have been given this honour. Further testament to Cyrus being Dzulqarnain of the Quran is the fact that Dzulqarnain is mentioned by name in the Arabic bible in the book of Daniel chapter 8:20 which reads ‎20 اما الكبش الذي رأيته ذا القرنين فهو ملوك مادي وفارس. The ram which you saw, having the two horns-they are the kings of Media and Persia. This is the only time that Dzulqarnain ( ذا القرنين) is mentioned in the bible in the same manner as the Quran and it clearly refers to Cyrus the great. The historicity or seerah of the story of Dzulqarnain also points towards Cyrus the Great as the questions posed to Prophet Muhammad by the Arab Jews of Medinah through the Mecca Quraish clearly relates to someone that they, the Arab Jews, knew from their scripture as Dzulqarnain would be only seen in their Arabic bible and not even in the Hebrew bible. Another interesting fact about Cyrus is the fact that he lived at the same time as prophet Danial and it would not be unfathomable to theorise that Cyrus was being advised by prophet Danial and also follows his teachings in terms of religious belief. If such is the case this would have made Cyrus truly worshiping the One true God Allah as alluded in the Quran. The religion of Cyrus has always been a mystery because despite the fact that it is often theorised that he was a Zoroastrian but the irony is that he is not even mentioned in any of their scriptures or annals.

[@rayees192]

Great sharing thank you. However in the part about the great traveler Dhul Qarnain who set a barrier between the two mountain passes near a body of dark water (Because the Quran mentions it is a body of dark water) he came upon a people who asked him to help them against a barbaric people. These people were Gog and Magog, Gog and magog are humans not jinns. Jinns are a separate creation made from smokeless flame, Gog and Magog are actually defendants of Noah AS they’re humans, they’re a tribe from one of the sons of Noah or Nuh AS from Japheth. So Dhul qarnain said he will help by constructing a barrier between the mountain passes which Gog and Magog could neither scale or penetrate. So I thought I’d mention that Gog and Magog are actually humans and a tribe from Japheth, the mountain pass is known to be the caucuses and the people of that region. The Sythians who would regularly go out plunder and even had what are known as berserkers, so the area, the indigenous peoples, the two maintain passes, the dark body of water, these all indicate to the very early Scythians. They wouldn’t wash, and have any hygiene, when laying with a woman six or sex would take turns they wouldn’t bathe and they’d go about on the next village to plunder. These seem to be who Gog and Magog were according to a number of scholars and Allah knows best.

[@hydaromar6532]

Salam alaykum, You will find that this king the Jews asked about is Cyrus the great. You will also find that Gog Magog are not spirits. They were a barbaric tribe. In all honesty they match the descriptions of the mongols

[@mohamedsmaili297]

Rabbuna is ou Creator Allah Almighty the One and only True Eternal Living God who says: (214. Or do you expect to enter Paradise before the example of those who came before you had reached you? Adversity and hardship had afflicted them, and they were so shaken up, that the Messenger and those who believed with him said, “When is Allah’s victory?” Indeed, Allah’s victory is near.) Surah 2 al-baqarah ayah 214 from the Holy Quran the last book revealed by our Creator Allah and Rabb the Almighty to his last prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)

[@ryanhunter2987]

It sounds like there is a bird (or birds?) in the background!

[@badeeyazzamaan102]

Clock..

[@u-kneeque]

Muslims should consider doing هجره like اهل الكهف to the الشرق a.k.a جهنم الدجال, and leave the الغرب a.k.a جنة الدجال.

[@fuzbeatboxern5714]

Okay but how was Muhammad able to get the story if it was a revelation of God then the Quran contains stories that exist outside of it. Wouldn't those stories be as beautiful as the Quran?

[@OksintasObones]

He was copying from a book 📖 at the possession of waraqa bnu nawfal which he brought from the north when he was studying religions in Syriac .. by the way his true name is Qutham bnu abd allat not Mohamed

[@treelee2668]

Thanks there is no religion only stories

[@jeremiahokinyi3128]

He failed terribly in the 3.

[@King-kw1mo]

What were the correct answers?

[@joseduarte2146]

Muhammad got exposed

[@jankopandza1072]

The three questions exposed Profit Muhammad for what he is. He had no idea they asked him three questions from Book of Daniel . If he was indeed a prophet then he should have known this and answer at once.. But first he asked for a day to answer and then as he had no idea he took 15 more days and in the end gave most funny answers one could give .. Interesting thing is that this is written in the Quran . Amazing that people actually think he was a prophet yet the people of the Book exposed him for what he is..

[@mohamedab9033]

You gotta check out Imran Hosein's videos of Surah Al-kahf concerning the 3 questions, very informative. Also his Jerusalem in the Qur'an lectures

[@Halal_Dan]

Yeah but he's a sufi

[@newmanhyde]

too bad prophet google was not around in the past

[@khanalveenayet]

If you are not filthy garbage speak the truth.All those answers were written down in Book of Daniel indeed.

[@AJansenNL]

How do we know how historically accurate these accounts are? What do non-islamic sources and archeology say? After all, these accounts are by muslims themselves. As it is true that the victors write history, it is also true when it comes to religion.

[@sammyjoe431]

Nobody is forcing you to believe.

[@AJansenNL]

@@sammyjoe431 That's evading the question.

[@carliemorales204]

@@AJansenNL What archaeology are you looking for, Jansen?

[@AJansenNL]

@@carliemorales204 Inscriptions, documents, coins, mentions by non-muslim contemporaries, etc. You know, the usual stuff.

[@DrBryan-dc8qi]

There hadith (preservation of Prophet saying, doing, etc) narrated orally by generation to generation (the sortest about 2 generations only) by memorising and writing, the compiled in books begin within first and second century of Islam (see Muwatha' from Malik, Musnad from Ahmad) The preservation always mention the chain of who said from who then from who until Companion of Prophet with VERY STRICT CRITICAL challenges and selections. Even one of chain who tell story was ever lied once in his life, or doing bad thing, or unknown or bad in memerizing or his book was stolen or burned, all of hadith or story from him will be rejected as weak hadiths. There also so many fabricated ones that also being greatly warned and schoolar of hadith had mentioned it.

[@makelallbrijlall1027]

37.qurans

[@aq7705]

The Succession to Muhammad (Pbuh) - Madelung

[@joseduarte2146]

He failed in both 3 questions ? They are related to the book of Daniel yeah he’s a false prophet

[@King-kw1mo]

What were the right answers?

[@OksintasObones]

He failed to answer any of them

[@lionsayz8574]

Haha ! Check the fact .He prophet pbuh answered all the questions ..

[@rajarajachola6508]

He failed to answer the questions.

[@tboss6689]

so muhammed couldnt answer ,nothing new , because he was not a prophet

[@irfanahmed6411]

De

[@whychristianity8388]

What a joke!

[@ahmalala]

Martin Lings uses very bad logic. Muhammad's answers to the Questions prove beyond a shadow of doubt he was not a prophet. He believed the (Christian)Myth of the 7 sleepers of Ephesus, yet the Quranic revelation is unsure of the number of them. He further believed the Myths concerning Alexander the great, and Lastly, he did not know who or what the (holy)Spirit was. Would the Quranic revelation be so unclear and unsure of these things if it were from God? It seems obvious that Muhammad gathered whatever information he could over a period of time and it was still incomplete vague information. It is of no surprise the Rabbi's did not believe him. These were likely trick questions concerning Pagan and Christian myths which Jews indeed would not have believed to begin with.

[@sammyjoe431]

Then why some of the stories of previous Prophets (pbut) mentioned in Quran are different than the stories of those prophets in bible. If prophet Muhammad (pbuh) was copying stories from bible than why did he not do it accurately as it was written in the bible. Why did he change so many accounts of prophets (pbut) of God. Also there are some stories of new prophets (pbut) in Quran which are not mentioned in bible at all. Why these new prophets’ stories are only mentioned to Muslims and is not told to Jews or Christians in bible. Also There is no mention of Alexander the great in Quran. Your probably following anti Islamic narrative who are spreading this lie that Quran is mentioning Alexander the Great.

[@ahmalala]

@@sammyjoe431 I never said He copied from the Bible. In fact I believe the exact opposite. The Bible does not contain these myths.

[@carliemorales204]

@@ahmalala Correct, myth like this was NOT copied from the Bible: *"The tombs also were opened. And many bodies of the saints who had fallen asleep were raised, and coming out of the tombs after his resurrection they went into the holy city and appeared to many."* (Matthew 27:52-53)

[@muslimbibliophile1916]

@@carliemorales204 *Evangelizing strategy of Christian missionaries:* 1. *Straw man fallacy* : A. Stipulate erroneous and/or unacademic claims about other people's faith → Refute said claim 2. *Circular reasoning fallacy* : A. Theological claim ←→Bible; B. But Bible ∈ {¬Provenance, ¬Preserved, internal contradictions}, ∴ Theological foundation → Baseless → Fallacious Reasoning

[@wafafarhat3656]

@@ahmalala jesus as god is a myth because ancient greeks and egyptians beleived in human gods like zeus or horus

[@welcometonature9021]

This is so stupid.. they ask the question that only prophet can answer.. so how come they knew the answer? Were those Jews prophet?😂

[@joseduarte2146]

If was in line with the prophets he would have known they’re all related to the book of Daniel but he didn’t know and gave all answers wrong

[@Leon-jp7ch]

If you make a promise, whether God wills it or not, and you don't keep what you promised, namely to come back tomorrow, then you are a dishonest person and are by definition a liar. In this case, Muhammad lied several times. If a liar is the best example for humanity to follow, something is fundamentally wrong, i wholeheartedly feel sorry for Muslims. how is it possible to be so blinded?