The 50 Most Disappointing Albums of All Time (according to Rolling Stone)

[@arzabael]

Yes, it would be a good video if you did “albums everyone hates but I loved”, I’ve seen a couple other solid people like yourself in the record collecting community do those

[@OldHead]

I feel like I could do an entire series of videos on that. Lol

[@nicholasfisher2595]

Awesome video Old Head! Flick of the switch by AC/DC was the first album I bought on vinyl and remains one of my favorites.🤘

[@rizlahillofficial]

Be Here Now Is The Definition Of Real Rock N Roll ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤x

[@danny1959]

Everybody I knew read “I’m In You” the way you did.

[@grogueQ]

I was just recently an Aerosmith fan when draw the line came out, and we loved it. When I say we, I mean everyone I knew except for maybe my parents.

[@heyskipj]

I’ll vouch for The Secret Life of Plants. I understand why it’s on the list, but it’s a full experience with a story line. Freely psychedelic and earthy.

[@exploringwithasmr]

Be Here Now is a fantastic album.

[@bobsbigboy_]

its amazing front to back

[@ThinWhiteLuke]

@@bobsbigboy_the production is bad, even Noel admits that. He was high as hell. But the material is great, I love My Big Mouth especially the riff in the chorus.

[@rizlahillofficial]

EXACTLY!!!!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤X

[@bobsbigboy_]

@@ThinWhiteLuke no

[@scottbailey4724]

Be Here Now is jank. That being said, the title track and D'ya Know What I Mean are fantastic. The tour however was brilliant!

[@tonyponchopeters]

I'm Shocked Metallica's 'St. Anger' didn't make the list tbh. Or 'Lulu' instead, since Rolling Stone wets themselves over Lou Reed.

[@sspbrazil]

Some Time In New York City came out after Imagine and The Plastic No Band albums and those were strong albums, plus Some Time has Yoko singing songs on it which could also be why it’s rated as number 1.

[@sspbrazil]

I like Second Coming, it was hard to follow up that debut, but there are great songs on Second Coming, Let Me Up I’ve Had Enough is an underrated album and Tales From Topographic Oceans is, long, bloated, pretentious and also magnificent.

[@kitoyobeni1]

Stone Roses had a lot of singles and were an "it" band prior to that second album, which was much more Oasis / classic rock styled than their previous output.

[@yellowjackboots2624]

There is a b-sides album called Turns Into Stone. _That_ should have been the second album. Imo they threw away all their great new songs as b-sides.

[@troubledjoe6201]

Turns into Stone is a great album

[@kitoyobeni1]

@@troubledjoe6201 I like Second Coming too, just a different flavor. Seahorses offshoot too.

[@Planet_Caravan_94]

I love the beach boys they are my favorite group of all time and smiley smile is a great album. To your question: there are two versions of Smile, first one was released in 2004 by Brian Wilson himself, called: Brian Wilson presents Smile. The album had rerecorded songs with his older voice. 2011, the smile sessions were released under the beach boys which has the original recordings, altough we may never get what Brian truly wanted to put out in 1967 we can be grateful to have these two versions.

[@bobsbigboy_]

people should be listening to SMILE

[@Cracker_Barrel_Kidd_55]

Our opinions on a vast majority of these albums are exactly the same. As I’ve never heard them either.

[@L3ghair]

The Big Day was disappointing because Chance was one of the most sought after and beloved rappers in the country prior to the album releasing, and the album is a 22 track torture chamber. Legit, not a single good song on it.

[@StraightlinePunk]

Muse-Sick-N-Hour-Mess-Age is my fav Public Enemy record. As someone socialized with Punk and Metal - this abum has more Punk and FU DIY Attitude than 90% of all Punk albums i know. Just wanted to mention this cause it hurts me each time that this Album is so Underrated. It was also the Album that brought me into Rap Music. I just bought it accidentally cause with that Artwork i was sure this is gonna be a heavy Punk or Metal Record :D

[@diarmuidmcnally1300]

Chinese Democracy is a House Fire Album for me….

[@Stonecutter334]

Rolling Stone 😂

[@seansutton1952]

Definitely do the version of this that you mentioned

[@kevinogracia1615]

You're two thousand light years from home. Pizza on erf.

[@patrickbarry6273]

Feels so very lonely

[@kevinogracia1615]

@@patrickbarry6273 Yea...

[@Andy-m6j]

Be Here Now is my favourite Oasis album. It’s a monster, check it out.

[@saifonlawrence2044]

The R Stones and N Young albums mentioned are great albums.

[@crazyprayingmantis5596]

If anyone wants to get rid of their Rolling Stones TSMR album after seeing this list ill gladly remove that burden from you.

[@kitoyobeni1]

Love Navarro, love Flea, love One Hot Minute.

[@tonyponchopeters]

It seems like we have I'd say 90% the same taste from this list (First time Viewer). Don't worry about not having listened to most of these, I clicked on it to see the list and it was interesting tbh.

[@vengeance_falls_9610]

I freaking love you Old Head

[@offtherecord681]

Flick of the Switch is far better than For Those about to Rock I think.

[@michaelredd-b2t]

I agree,flick of the switch is a better album than for those about to rock,they cover new ground on flick, it's my favorite acdc album.

[@Dramatiker666]

And then you put the Frampton record next to Type O's horrifyingly pictured but aptly named "Origin Of The Feces" and you got a good laugh for every sour moment. I have to get this one as well, that cover alone is really amazing. One Hot Minute? Yeah... It wasn't all Under The Bridge and stuff. But yeah. Breaking with expectations lead to disappointment with the majority of people - who don't want to get deep but just want a BSSM Pt. 2

[@Lamposts]

I agree about "One Hot Minute". Critics are major hipsters, they latch onto whatevers hot at the moment, then they keep hopping around to whatevers hot, nevermind the artist. Then when said artist releases theyre follow-up critic is already onto new horizons, wait what the fuck is this, this is nothing like theyre last album, this sucks. Then artist goes, why didnt anybody like it? fuck you people, then release something that actually does suck. Perhaps by then said critic is ready for another release by said artist who praises it to the heavens even though its actually not as good as the one before.

[@bobsbigboy_]

@oldhead theres a difference between SMILE and The Smile Sessions. TSS is absolutely superior

[@bobsbigboy_]

be here now by oasis and tales from topographic oceans by yes are both masterpieces

[@SuperStrik9]

As a young fan at the time no album disappointed me more than Metallica - Load. I hated everything about that album that I ended up just giving it away to a buddy of mine. Still don't like that album or anything Metallica have done since with the exception of Death Magnetic.

[@brianpiotrowski792]

First to come to Mind is that album Chinese democracy.

[@merikblackmore]

I thought that you'd set the finale up & that Load was #1

[@BillAdams-fb3jm]

I liked Be Here Now and I know lots of fans were disappointed by it because it was a little bloated. I completely understand why Draw The Line is on this list; Aerosmith is a band for whom instant gratification has always been a big deal and there aren't any great singles to love on it.

[@bobsbigboy_]

Yes is the greatest band of all time

[@jhonfloresleon6204]

👍👍👍👍👍👍🤘🏽

[@davidschecter5247]

Have you listened to ANY music? LOL! I'm amazed you've listened to SMILEY SMILE, but not many of the others, as it's one of the more obscure Beach Boys' records. BRIAN WILSON PRESENTS SMILE (2004) is brilliant, even though his voice is obviously not what it would have been in 1967. Maybe you should listen to some of the original SMILE tapes that have been released. They'll show you why SMILEY SMILE was such a letdown.

[@timprescott4634]

It’s Rolling Stone. You KNOW the list is shit. Those “top two” are nowhere close…

[@purplebeard1526]

That PE album, following Nation of Millions, Black Planet, and Apocalypse '91, was horrible garbage. It had like one good song. BAD...eh...ti make T50, I wouldn't be there with it...but it's not a top album. I didn't like the vibe on One Hot Minute. Balance did suck.

[@purplebeard1526]

STP Tiny Music, Metallica St. Anger, Black Crowes Amorica, GNR Chinese Democracy, LL Phenomenon, ....