The All Time Cleveland Guardians Lineups Are AMAZING! MLB The Show 24 Diamond Dynasty

[@kylewingo2879]

Couple obscures: Eddie Rosario, Josh Bell, Mike Zunino. I wouldn’t mind the Jason Kipnis return for theme teams

[@kurtzmann22]

Kipnis’ stance alone is top tier lol

[@ecstrange]

David Justice could have fit in the obscure or AT teams

[@dmcdougal241]

I’d like Belle, Ramirez, Kenny, Sandy Alomar, Roberto Alomar, Travis Hafner, and some bullpen love like 2016 postseason Andrew Miller and Jose Mesa

[@kyleb8382]

Party at Napoli’s! Who remembers that??

[@FuzzyFromYT]

THAT THUMBNAIL THO 🔥

[@kurtzmann22]

Where is David Justice at? He was traded to the Yankees mid 2000 season but was a big name guy for them.

[@ShelfyTV]

Knew I was missing someone!

[@oliverpage1033]

This might ruffle a few feathers........but give us Kluber back! Also, happy holidays, Shelf. We ❤ you

[@hannahburke9647]

He’s back!!!!

[@baseballfan1918]

Roberto and Sandy Alomar would be great additions.

[@AndySeabolt]

Yan gomes if he has a good card

[@battletoad2658]

We need a Ray Caldwell lightning card. If you know you know.😂

[@Lilspoon21_]

My goat shelfy

[@rickmiller4958]

Other player options Omar Vizquel, old heads Tris Speaker & Nap Lajoie, Sandy Alomar, Travis Hafner, Bartolo Colon

[@kurtzmann22]

Vizquel and Alomar are not going to be back in game. I would personally like to see Albert Belle, Manny Ramirez, Chuck Finley, Ellis Burks, Carlos Baerga, and Matt Williams.

[@kurtzmann22]

Sandy is fine, Roberto wouldn’t be in. Meant to add V-Mart to my list lol

[@whopperjaw10]

How is your best hitter 6th in the lineup??

[@wormy5700]

Is there no good andres gimenez card ?? Beiber ? Bibee

[@jonathanmartin8113]

That Grady perfect flyout to the wall is one of the reasons I started to lose interest in MLB the Show since 22...