Cleveland’s NEVER ENDING Cycle of Heartbreak Continues After Trading Another Fan Favorite

[@nathanwilliams4005]

Naylor? I hardly know her!

[@ScareBear75]

😂🤣

[@derekconstantino7759]

​@@ScareBear75wario time

[@SO-if3yn]

Lol

[@LaughingWindows]

Thanks, dad.

[@Padres-Win]

100th like😘

[@samcochran29]

It’s crazy the Guards are always a solid team with the terrible ownership they have

[@bryangonzalez4604]

My Marlins have bad ownership too but at least we won in 2003

[@JosephRhodes-s4r]

@@bryangonzalez4604and 97

[@johnbontea1353]

We keep our head above water but not enough to win a championship we do good at not being last. But also never first I'd rather win 1 and if we have to be bad for 10 years so be it. Like marlins and cardinals

[@PaloVerde1414]

Guards 💂‍♀️ 😂

[@zboy2020vision]

The dumbest part is their owners are supposedly worth a lot of money possibly top 5 in league

[@DavidHull3_OfficialBaseball]

Bo Naylor is brotherless now

[@iTalkStudios]

They killed his brother fr RIP

[@MazeDaGr8]

And this is why I will always say that baseball does Not need a salary cap, they need a Salary Floor.

[@samuelsandate9804]

Exactly. All these owners have money. They're all just being too greedy. The players know that. They already said they will never agree to a salary cap.

[@Dempsey222]

J Ram is the anti Soto. He is not greedy at all. Rare for a baseball player.

[@ooo_Kim_Chi_ooo]

Hes got a mean right hook too.

[@upcomingexpat]

Charles Dolan is worth 5.1 billion dollars. Why do fans count players' pockets and ignore billionaires who pocket so much more. Amazing

[@Dempsey222]

@@upcomingexpat Because paying Juan Soto 51 million dollars a year is going to raise mets ticket prices, tv prices, concession prices and Merch prices. The fans are the ones paying not the team.

[@johnbontea1353]

My life wouldn't be different either if i had 150 million or 200 million

[@Petard01]

@@johnbontea1353 I agree with the sentiment generally but also fuck these owners, they should pay players what they are worth

[@kennyw7820]

As a diamondback fan, I think it’s a great trade! 😀

[@brianmccarthy1029]

As an A’s fan since 68, I’ll say a least they still have a team.

[@adlilzafri2322]

Look on the bright side, at least you still have Mason Miller

[@matteorenner1386]

@@adlilzafri2322 for now lol

[@DatMartianChris]

Watch them just win the division again after doing this

[@jaymesonbell8040]

It's very easy to win that awful division

[@iTalkStudios]

Just a punching bag in the playoffs

[@snerdterguson]

I kind of want to see Minnesota versus Cleveland in a playoff series, because it might just never end, since it can only end when one of them wins.

[@samueldegennaro]

@@iTalkStudiospunching bag ? I disagree with that

[@Adam12R]

@@jaymesonbell8040Though it has been in recent years, it wasn’t really the case last year, 3 teams made the playoffs and all three advanced to the ALDS. Also they weren’t just beating up on the White Sox all year since MLB went to a more balanced schedule

[@andredaquan]

Ricky Henderson just passed and you couldn’t write it any more tragic #rickyhenderson #bayarera #baseballgod

[@derekconstantino7759]

Josh naylor = *W A R I O*

[@willybe6427]

tthhaaattt's where I know him from..

[@lukasgestrine]

Dr. Don Wario

[@Tommy_Montana]

The accuracy

[@johnbontea1353]

I have said this many times. I thought I was the only one. Is this widely known. Or just your thoughts

[@derekconstantino7759]

​@@johnbontea1353 well if you have fantasy baseball you'll see me comment wario time every day during the season on naylors account 🤣 ive been saying it for years

[@sumleegai]

Maybe Arizona will be able to keep him from hitting the all-you-can-eat buffet line during the off season and get him back to hitting the baseball.

[@yesterdaze114]

As a diamondbacks fan, I’m over the mooooooooooon

[@JustMeELC]

Take good care of him he's a good guy!

[@johnbontea1353]

Yea total steal. He's gonna be great in az get a fat contract and then play like a bumb. I can see the yankees getting him. They don't care about guys who can't play defense

[@derekd-j2b]

I hope you enjoy the only player on the guardians roster who couldn't put the ball in play in the playoffs.

[@CorgdVR]

this is painful for Cleveland , but not as having to wait for another upload from you italky

[@Wo1fLarsen]

Shout out Jose Ramirez. Beast.

[@Elephant2024]

Cleveland Guardians management ultimately did not want to pay Josh Naylor when he becomes a free agent after this season. So they brought back Carlos Santana and will probably play Kyle Manzardo at first base. Apparently Naylor did not want to DH.

[@baycards12]

I don’t mind this at all, you well Naylor is not the best shape he can be in. He was terrible down the stretch. The pitching market is so inflated right now, and I know how well my team develops young pitchers. We have a solid farm system that can help with years to come.

[@dhuraiferguson2856]

I can feel the pain in that sigh at the end

[@jonasirw1]

They will forever be cursed unless they go back to being the Indians

[@jeremytarter7557]

Facts

[@evrbody]

I agree. When I think back to all of the championships that the Indians won over the last 30 years, I realized that it wasn't because of the talent on the field, but because of the team name and logo. I was only twelve years old when they won the World Series in 1995, but when they hoisted that championship banner with a giant Chief Wahoo screaming "FUCK WOKENESS" on it, I remember having a lump in my throat, a tear in my eye, and a swelling of pride in my heart, as I said "Yes Chief, fuck wokeness. Fuck it right in the ear. And fuck Kamala Harris, whoever she is."

[@javi994]

The 2016 rain delay wants a word

[@colemilz]

DBacks Fan here. Slade is going to be lethal with Clevelands coaching. This season as a starter he was untouchable the first time through the lineup and then the wheels would fall off. We decided to make him a reliever and closer in AAA and it didn't work well when he was called up. He is nasty though and will probably be either a good starter or reliever

[@markurquhart5064]

Great for the Royals this 👌🏻👏🏻

[@MrDude667]

It reminds me of how I felt being an Oakland A’s fan. At least they get to keep their team…

[@SO-if3yn]

Already a Superman trailer reference mixed in segment. This man is legend.

[@tomk.3428]

Have no fear… the Guardians will be able to pick up Cruz from the Red Sox in two years - - and best of all, the Red Sox will carry 85% of his salary…

[@derekconstantino7759]

My beloved wario is going to my dodger rival dbacks 😭😭 i still love you wario! I'll always be josh naylors biggest fan

[@MLBHighlights-wi1gz]

i was nervous throughout the entire video. As a Tigers fan, I knew they were a team he might be going to, and I was getting hot a so nervous the entire video, hoping he'd say he'd be coming to Detroit, only for him to say arizona and me pulling an austin schultz

[@prickly10000]

Wow since when do the D-backs add pieces?!

[@ahol9120]

I'm still mad we didn't pay Manny in 2000. This is sadly the norm for a life Long Cleveland fan. We develop good young talent then don't pay em when the time comes.

[@javi994]

It’s the Moneyball way

[@markrimelspach7041]

This one hurts. Loved Naylor and everything he gave to the team. Will really miss his play and personality.

[@johnbontea1353]

Being a cleveland fan is like driving with handcuffs on. You can go straight no problem. But as soon as it's time to turn, It's a complete car wreck.

[@jaredkrol3739]

Believe me any Pirates fan would trade the last 20 years of Cleveland Baseball compared to Pittsburgh. AT LEAST the Guardians management is actually somewhat competent. The Pirates are cheap AND Stupid

[@mz.nikkimorris2759]

If Cleveland win the 2025 playoffs / World Series I would love to see all the reactions of the Cleveland players that was traded

[@chrismarston4266]

I’m not even a guardians fan but seeing Naylor leave hurt. Probably my favorite player from that team

[@samueldegennaro]

Manzardo is taking over first for Naylor get ready to learn the name man

[@TheJackyl1313]

i've been a cleveland fan for as long as i can remember and they have been one of the best teams in baseball during that time with the exception of a few years the most pain i experienced as a cleveland fan though was when they traded francisco lindor on my 11th birthday and this is up there cleveland's christmas present to there fans is usually trade one of there best players for basically no one

[@sgrafx]

Yeah, its strange.

[@ryanearles2024]

The Cleveland Curse is so real here and it's basically impossible to break it at this point. And I absolutely hate it, but I'm used to it at this point. #SellTheTeam

[@derekd-j2b]

Did you pay attention to the playoffs at all? Naylor was the worst player on the entire team and didnt contribute anything offensively.

[@szlava3641]

Does Cleveland even bother spending money?

[@AngeloMorales-u1e]

Lmfao no.. there’s been so many times this team could have spent money and won 🏆 but they refuse to.

[@iTalkStudios]

I don't think they even know they can at this point

[@ryanearles2024]

@@AngeloMorales-u1e Because The Dolans (The Guardians Owner) are so cheap. That's why.

[@AmtrakCSXFan457]

yes because they got Carlos Santana

[@JustMeELC]

There's the time they literally sold off part of the team to sign Edwin Encarnacion!

[@S_Over_Street]

I know Cleveland has had a good ballclub for the past 30 years. Multiple division titles & a few WS appearances (1995, 1997, 2016) but still no championships. As a Mariners fan, I’d still take that success from the past 30 years compared to what the Mariners have done in that same time period

[@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661]

The heartbreak is insane though. The 97 WS was brutal. The 16 WS was... I don't wanna talk about it. But thrown in there are more heartbreaks not talked about. Blowing a 3-1 series lead in 2007 to Boston in the ALCS only for Boston to sweep the Rockies was just gut wrenching. Winning 93 games in 2005 only to miss the playoffs. Winning 22 straight games in 2017 and looking primed to finally win it all going up 2-0 over the Yankees in the ALDS only to lose 3 straight and blow it. 2018 they faced the Trashtros in the ALDS and got swept. Didn't have a chance. You have no idea the mental torture it is... sometimes I wonder if it's better to just root for a loser...

[@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661]

Also... my best memory is going to Jacob's Field in 2007 home opener against your Mariners. Maybe you watched? The "Snowm-Opener". I was there with some good friends a year or two after high school. Snow squalls kept delayed Paul Byrd's no-hitter (that never was...game got canceled before 5 innings), the smell of the gas engines exhaust from the leaf blowers blowing the snow off the field... getting better seats after ppl left and getting hit with the blown snow like crazy, some moron ran on the field and did a snow angel... Terrible game. But the best experience ever lol. I think they played the rest of the series in Milwaukee bc of more snow.

[@S_Over_Street]

@@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661 I remember that postponed snow game from April 2007. That was an entire 4 game series that was postponed that had to be made up in chunks during the season. Any 1 day off during the year the Mariners had to fly to Cleveland to play 1 game 4 times during to year to make up those games

[@ghost64626]

Can't wait to hear what Fuzzy has to say about this trade

[@Thatguy-isaac]

And now santana is gonna turn into prime barry bonds.😂

[@XxXDestroyer]

I really appreciate your trade/signing updates. I check out your channel first every morning, hoping to see a Roki to Dodgers soon 🤞🤞

[@Raidbossryan]

Jram wanting to stay with this ownership is wild

[@kevinbetts2720]

Manzardo is the Guards’ 1st baseman of the future and while I am sad to see Josh Naylor go, I think it will give Manzo a real chance at being an everyday player. I doubt that Carlos Santana will be at first day in and day out.

[@sortofanoakyafterbirth3661]

37 year old fan of Cleveland. This is par for the course. I don't know why ANY fan of this franchise is surprised about this. It's basically a non-story, no offense to your channel. We're (cleveland baseball) basically Charlie Brown kicking the football held by Lucy at this point. We get there, believe this is the time, only to see the damn ball get lifted away. Mariners/Pirates/whoever else aren't even aware there's a football there. They're just chasing butterflies lol

[@Johnny-Michael]

This makes me sad

[@aaronrhodes7268]

As a Dback fan, this trade really confused me

[@ScottCleve33]

First you praise the franchise for being one of the first to compliment a money ball strategy then you criticize them for making a move based off of the money ball strategy. Because that's what this is, it's money ball. They simply found a more affordable way of getting the same stats. Money Ball is taking over and killing the once great game.

[@cire1867]

Make the owners sell unless they’re %35 of the highest payroll team. You literally get revenue sharing from all the top 15 spending teams and you still don’t pay your players

[@BurgerKing-jm4qy]

They also have like the 5th richest owner

[@cire1867]

@ Cleveland? I’ve been a dodger fan my whole life and you don’t know the pain of watching a Dodger team while Frank McCourt was going through his divorce. Any player we had of value especially homegrown was traded and we signed a veteran out of their prime

[@samuelsandate9804]

​@@BurgerKing-jm4qy and yet there are people who want us to feel for these billionaire owners. Like seriously? These people are completely clueless. The players aren't clueless and they know very well these billionaires'owners have money. They already said they will never agree to a salary cap. I get it. If these owners want to win, then spend. They have no excuse.

[@JustMeELC]

This makes me so sad... & I bet J-Ram upset!

[@jwanie366]

3:41 I see you guys also watched the new Superman trailer lol. I get that Naylor is a FA after next season, but why didn't Cleveland just wait until the trade deadline to decide whether or not to deal him? If they got into contention again, he might've been a very valuable piece for them

[@johndurrer7869]

Because winning a title isn’t what matters to this ownership. If they are winning at the deadline they won’t be able to trade him without the Fanbase turning on them

[@ooo_Kim_Chi_ooo]

Indians and Rays are the best Farm System in the MLB.

[@LordZark69]

guardians there is no team in mlb called Indians

[@wesleysteeleiv]

So much for the Google story about him being traded to Seattle. I swear those Google stories never happen in real life, not that i wanted Naylor anyway. Just think it's odd Google says Seattle is in on X player and a few hours later they get traded to somewhere else, never fails.

[@jackcooper4936]

You don’t know pain until you’ve spent 40 years a mariners fan….

[@Velociraptor420]

Naylor as a hitter has declined every year. Homer numbers were ok last season but by every other hitting metric, he doesn't deserve to be paid so trade him while he has value.

[@oViisa]

NL West is crazy good, then theres the rockies

[@iTalkStudios]

The who?

[@ryanearles2024]

@@oViisa Rockies? Never heard of em. Lol

[@duncanfromunderthebridge]

Cleveland ownership is a joke

[@derekd-j2b]

for getting rid of the only player on the team who didnt contribute anything offensively in the playoffs? I dont think you realize how bad Naylor was.

[@thepoisonouspotato3631]

Im an Astros fan, and I liked Oscar Gonzalez, and it made me upset when they got rid of him

[@andrewd2652]

He sucked

[@life5161]

Let's go Guardians!! Santana is the bridge to Manzardo.

[@louisminati]

You dont know what you're talking about. This is what Cleveland always does and they are always in the playoffs. You can research it

[@elasmojones]

I wish I could feel sorry for the Indians...just can't.

[@thenolans2172]

Let's go forgot about walker already

[@evrbody]

Naylor dropped off big time in the second half and was practically invisible in the postseason. He also needs to get his weight under control.

[@JustMeELC]

Ffs guess you missed the career ending shattered leg that caused the weight gain but he actually came back from 🙄 Shhhhh

[@gabrielv.2647]

That's the guardian way, same for the rays another I can think on the top of my head, they draft em, develop em and become great ball players and let them walk or trade em other then Ramirez at 3B. Hell of a pick up for the Dbacks. Middle of the order bad to replace Walker

[@javi994]

And of course Oakland

[@gabrielv.2647]

@javi994 that's right thank you. Another one lol

[@smokey_gator_239]

So they traded a player with a 1.5 WAR last season, then signed a player at the same position who had a 2.5 WAR last season. That is why Cleveland is always competitive, despite useless videos like this one.

[@derekconstantino7759]

Wario time ALL THE TIME

[@zachill18]

Who remembers the OG Babe Ruth thumbnail

[@upcomingexpat]

It's funny. In America, we dislike the athlete for wanting top dollar and ignore the billionaire who cries broke. Mind you, the billionaires are about to receive a masive tax cut. These owners inherit their teams, this wasn't hard work. I wonder because athletes are essentially lottery tickets based on the talent they possess fans get jealous and say, they should be grateful. You can't make this up.

[@RTeez79]

Spencer Horwitz will be the full time 1st baseman, they’ll be just fine

[@jayoby7402]

Uh theu already traded him to the pirates😂

[@jdsthird]

Isaac loves to do these videos just so he can say Indians. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@TBAPSB7]

i feel bad for bo naylor now

[@bjsantana8415]

Cleveland Needs a Steve Cohen or Theo Epstein 🙏🙏

[@Frankieefootballmundial]

Or perhaps a Andrew Friedman or John Henry

[@NotMeNaNaNa]

Please do a comparison of him and Christian Walker. I feel the D’Backs quickly replaced the hole in their lineup with his departure however his gold glove defense will be missed. Looking at WAR Walker’s worst season last year at 2.6 was better than Naylor’s best, also last year, at 2.5. The hope is since Naylor is younger his WAR will go up while Walker is on the decline. Also it looks like Naylor strikes out considerably less.

[@travis6694]

A one year deal because the d backs want to make the playoffs. Hopefully Gallen has a great year so the d backs can make him a competitive offer.

[@JonCz13]

I can’t keep doing this 😔

[@AncestorEmpire1]

Those first 17 seconds of the video, are the best…. Especially after Lebron James tainted fellow Cubs with the CM Punk go to sleep taunt. That aged pretty well.

[@SPREAD_POSITIVITY82637]

WHY TF WOULD THEY TRADE NAYLOR OH MY GOSH SMH

[@Merlin_From_Shrek_3]

Welcome to arizona!

[@idkdoozy]

i can be happy for now

[@robustbottlecap]

More front office content please

[@hopespringseternal2624]

Does that mean we won't see him rock the baby anymore? lol

[@snerdterguson]

Am just just not seeing what others do? Because I see a guy with decent power and nothing else. And not even reaching 2 WAR in 152 games last year seems to coincide with what I see. I get that Cleveland fans love him, but outside of that,what is the allure? Why would he be considered one of the most exciting players? I would bet that almost every team in baseball has multiple players that are more exciting.

[@travis6694]

It’s more of the fact of how cheap and uncompetitive cleveland is. You also can’t always replace 30 home runs even if your defense is bad.

[@balajirao8426]

They replaced 28yr old Naylor whos due $12mill arb next year with 39yr old Santana who they are going to pay $12mill to anyway? just to get a 7era pitcher back from d-bacs?

[@HayabusaRyu]

What's with Cleveland's Carlos Santana love affair?

[@andrewofboston-7939]

This video, while it is sad to see Naylor go, seems a touch too pessimistic huh?

[@Lunar-j6i]

It’s Josh Naylor. Relax.

[@iTalkStudios]

I think it's more about the idea Cleveland will never keep any of their best so you can't attach yourself to any of them

[@derekd-j2b]

@@iTalkStudios Keep any of their best? Naylor was the worst hitter in the entire lineup in the playoffs and got outplayed by manzardo who should have been starting over him the entire playoffs.

[@AmtrakCSXFan457]

But then they get Carlos Santana Back

[@patrickmoreau7592]

So much for the Indians Sad

[@itsyaboi5488]

Am I just down playing him but this isn’t a huge loss imo 😭 idk whenever I’ve watched him he’s been cool but is not clutch when the guardians needed him but idk

[@iTalkStudios]

I think it's more about the idea Cleveland will never keep any of their best so it's hard to get attached

[@Ei8hth_Wonder]

Josh Naylor’s clutch rating was 23rd in all of baseball last year…

[@derekd-j2b]

@@iTalkStudios keep our best? Naylor was the WORST player on the entire roster in the playoffs and needed to go.

[@ItsJacobyay]

But but but the mlb needs a cap 😢 its the yankees fault the Guards are too stingy and wont pay their players

[@JacksonLane02]

I mean sure it sucks but there's most likely a shot that he wouldn't have resigned or signed an extension so traded him although it sucks is better than him basically walking away in free agency considering you at least get something out of trading him

[@JustMeELC]

Make up whatever excuses get you through it 🙄

[@JohnSmith-tz8gj]

need a Salary Cap

[@snerdterguson]

Parity in baseball.is better than all the sports with a cap. So how about instead of forcing teams that try to stop trying, you say the cheap owners don't get to own a team anymore. If Cleveland can't sustain a team that can afford to compete, then Cleveland shouldn't have a team.

[@Mo_Ketchups]

Changing their awesome name to a super-fruity one and sending Chief Wahoo to the woke dungeon is a _pantload_ of bad karma to overcome. 😮‍💨😖🤦‍♂️

[@Am0ment0fB]

As a lifelong Mets fan, hang in there Cleveland. Just get yourself a billionaire who will spend anything to win. LGM. Ha.

[@johnnydepp4866]

WAAAAAA

[@kellypitts8481]

We had the best logo in sports. Bring back the Indians and chief wahoo. I can’t stand the gaurdians

[@Oceanviewcoffeeshop]

Terrible trade

[@MLBFan22]

30s GANG!

[@vincentkrych2158]

Naylor wasnt clutch in the playoffs

[@derekd-j2b]

he was the worst hitter in the entire lineup come playoff time. i dont know why people are sad to see him go

[@therickroller2358]

Dont care, Naylor will regress, and hes garbo in the play offs

[@LordZark69]

Bwahahaha go dbacks

[@seanstuchbery]

Guardians🤣🫵🏻