The Beatles - Where Have You Been (Remember Liverpool Beat 32)

[@Quintellectual]

Can’t someone somewhere take a crack at these tapes with modern technology. Imagine if we could hear John a bit better?

[@CleberHarrisonGuitar]

There's not enough raw material to work with. They'd probably have to do the same they did with Free As A Bird, with Paul 'emulating' John's voice

[@b_erliner]

@@CleberHarrisonGuitar I tried messing around with this on audacity, I pretty much just messed around with the treble then compressed it but it still doesn't sound correct, I will admit though I don't even work with audacity that much.

[@kevanbrown7620]

@@b_erlinerAt least you tried. I'm grateful for you doing that.

[@elvisleeboy]

@@CleberHarrisonGuitar Technology is improving day by day. Many of the things they have done with the new Peter Jackson film Get Back were not possible as little as two years ago, so it is becoming ever more possible that we will be able to hear this with amazing clarity someday in the near future.

[@CleberHarrisonGuitar]

@@elvisleeboy I hope you're right.. I believe someone could improve that, but 'amazing clarity'.. not sure about that, the vocals are very quiet and they share many of the same frequencies of guitars and cymbals even.. it would be way easier if it were the other way around

[@PISStopherNolan]

Only Real fans here! Love y'all and love this song so much

[@walleyrange]

What I'd give to have seen The Beatles in Hamburg

[@lloydpinto623]

Me too..

[@pietvanbreemen5334]

Where's my Time Machine!!!!!!

[@rockinrobb4350]

Oh MY! I've never heard this song before but man what potential can you imagine this song reworked in the studio with George and the boys!! absolute hit! Love them Beatles!!

[@lorrainebartenbach8854]

Gerry and the Pacemakers do a much better job!! This version sucks!!

[@rockinrobb4350]

Give us a break Lorraine! This is a rough unedited recording ok? If it was a studio recording it would’ve blown Gerry and his boys away!! Long live the Fab Four!!

[@HiltonBenchley]

@@lorrainebartenbach8854 Arthur Alexander does a better job than all of them.

[@grungeisdead8998]

This recreation ain't bad kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y5aZiJh9bcpknZo

[@Hepnotical]

@@HiltonBenchley Correct!

[@ktpinnacle]

And what were you doing when you were 19-22 years old? These guys were working hard every day to change the world.

[@sallykohorst8803]

What a picture of them and great music in the early days.

John Lennon with a Rickenbacker 325c58 makes me cry. Love this song. Love George Harrison's Guitar solo

[@sephia_bae]

RB capri... George with Futurama

[@mangomonkey6938]

​@@sephia_bae By December 1962 George was long past the Futurama. This is his Gretsch Duo Jet

[@walleyrange]

Sends shivers down my spine. What a band

[@lorrainebartenbach8854]

Eeeech! Try Gerry and the Pacemakers!!!!

[@elisiamarie2000]

here is another example where John Lennon yet again succeeds in making me cry like a baby when he sings.

[@rocknrollpipol5463]

Same

[@Quintellectual]

Unreal voice

[@Veronica-kz5dq]

No son los Beatles, son los escarabajos

[@melissabheekha7262]

The Beatles were genius and legends

[@FIRSTNAME-wr7ir]

Since we kiss I never knew the thrills I could be tasted Since we kiss I never knew the years that I am wasting But now I know I was waiting For you to come back, I was waiting girl, won't you please tell me why that's took a long to begin Darling where have you been all my life Oh don't you know that until we touch I never knew the touch was of revealing Until we touch I never knew my heart was really beating But now I know I was waiting For you to come back, I was waiting girl, won't you please tell me why that's took a long to begin Darling where have you been all my life Oh where you've been, where you've been [Solo] Now don't you know I was waiting For you to come back, I was waiting girl, won't you please tell me why that's took a long to begin Darling where have you been all my life Where have you been, where you've been, where you've been, when I was feeling blue Where have you been, where you've been, where you've been, when I was needing you Oh where you've been, where you've been Where you've been Darling where have you been all my life

[@DocReasonable]

'Since we kiss I never knew the thrills I could be tasted' - do you realize that's not English?

[@glumfounded3046]

@@DocReasonable all of it is English. Just doesn’t make sense

[@TheRobertpiotr]

The early Beatles are the best!

[@edmurnico7508]

Hey John, please come back!

[@marceloberardi8140]

Un tema excelente, lástima que no la hayan grabado oficialmente. Las canciones de Arthur Alexander encajaban a la perfección con el estilo de la primer etapa de los Beatles y sobre todo en la voz de John. Por suerte si grabaron Anna y soldier of love de este gran artista.

[@inkari1981]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/f6uodZZ9n5tjm9Usi=GHTfnOKXE6iWWtQF

[@scfled]

What a song. This is my fave one

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

We could’ve had this instead of A Taste of Honey on Please Please Me

[@Flyingwithoutmings]

Billis Lopez would've been way better

[@BassicVIC]

Instead of Boys rather.

[@brianvina9228]

@@BassicVIC Despite the homosexual overtones it was good rocker

[@nathanb.8114]

This song would rather fit well on With The Beatles album.

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

@RATTLED BY THE RUSH I mean it could have been a B-side or something. They turned Matchbox into a single. Slow Down too. Surely ATOH would have found a place easily as one of those early singles. There were just many more deserving songs of that spot in my opinion. Where Have You Been, Keep Your Hands Off My Baby, Ain’t She Sweet, Soldier of Love, So How Come No One Loves Me, To Know Her Is To Love Her, the list goes on. I kind of feel the same about Till There Was You on With the Beatles. I like Till There Was You, I don’t think it was the best fit for that album, it should have been a single instead.

[@donworks]

Oh, and it's John singing. No question.

[@pinup60]

omg his voice gives me the chills

[@joehinojosa24]

The garage band that MADE IT!

[@christinaventh]

It sounds more of John than Paul. Unless they interchange throughout the song. This song is just pure bliss :)

[@reneperezjr8383]

When you been? Where you been when I was feeling blue?

[@DieHardBeatlesFan]

Musical Genius John's death was a Tragedy but his life was a gift R.I.P John & George sorely missed 😭 😭

[@elvisleeboy]

I really love The Searchers version of this, yet even though this is poor quality recording, it still manages to blow it away, especially John Lennon's voice, and he was a mere 21 years old at the time.

[@miguelmanzano3960]

We need a remastered version

[@CesarBugarin]

The Beatles! Una maquina musical!

[@thecountofbasie]

As good as I've ever heard this one sound...have to agree, this should have been at least an LP cut...easily my favorite version of the song

[@2Fa2Bu]

+thecountofbasie The original is better than this one. but gene vincent's version is the best

[@ovelonse]

Instead of "Chains" for me

[@fabiodean5789]

The Searchers' version is so incredible better

[@marcosc_T.B.]

I have very fond of this song in a version by The Beatles!

[@seaniswan2798]

me too....

[@sbsv63]

John really loved Arthur Alexander's music. He sung Soldier of Love Anna go to him and this one. Just like George loved Joe Brown's country style (Sheik of Araby and A picture of you)

[@SleazyNice]

John Lennon copied his vocal style and phrasing from Arthur Alexander.

[@illinoizrichy1]

ringo was pretty new 4 months with this band.,,pretty steady with his new band

[@christinaventh]

okay, i was checking out some beatles tribute bands... and "John" was singing all of them for this song. :) so yes, let's go with John

[@therotiv4]

nice version the best

[@albertoc4038]

Es asombroso que cada vez que escucho esta canción, esta versión, me trasmite lo mismo: la de un grupo a punto de despegar a la fama; y así es, casi en seguida los Beatles llegaron a la cima

[@M5guitar1]

Agree this should have been on Please Please Me. It evokes sad emotions...

[@bonsummers2657]

Best recording/best version of this live by The Beatles

[@Eder5837]

Esperando que si sean los Beatles.. esa canción cover fue una de las mejores que he encontrado.. Ellos (Los Beatles) todo lo que tocaban lo convertían en maravilla y moda.. genial su estilo como siempre, Eso solo lo hacen los GENIOS.

[@bfelix4480]

👍😊👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@RobinCampbelldrummer93]

Yeah it is,it was recorded live at the Star Club in Hamburg in 62.

[@danmargarita3066]

I know of the Gerry & the Pacemakers version of this song. I had no idea The Beatles also covered it..

[@ubleakhouse]

It's John singing. He has a very distinctive voice.

[@brytanlodz]

it's not Lennon's voice

[@missingno88]

@@brytanlodz yes it is lol

[@anneteller3128]

All their music makes you smile whether early music or music polished in a studio. I would have loved to be at a club listening before they became famous to be up close and enjoying the music.

[@neryalonso4185]

Me gusta micho

[@janaparoubkova5895]

Krásná písnička 👍❤️

[@sunap2010]

this song I love it best all of Beatles songs

[@reynasyakilajasmin2520]

Thank's good

[@piggyjo]

Hey I got this back in 1980 too! :-)

[@adriandrouadaine6675]

Gracias thanks!!! 👏👏👏

[@claudiocarvalho7250]

Extraordinário,mágica interpretação, juntamente com os Stones as 2 melhores bandas de rock d mundo

[@EmersonSilva-oo1np]

Concordo.Inigualáveis.

[@kingkandy]

Thanks, not heard the full thing. And without the crummy doubled up solo too. Pity they didn't record a nice clean BBC version, isn't it?

[@pinkjacksonthegreaserakaab1980]

Nice

[@simondoran9682]

It's a sin that Arthur Alexander wasn't a superstar

[@juniorarbigaus9433]

I think thats the best version ever

[@stealthbastard8837]

Lennon is the best fucking voice of rock n' roll music ever. Untouchable.

[@Alsurf89]

Yes, recorded in December 1962 and Ringo joined in August 1962

[@guitars742]

Course it beatles and lennon on vocal,amazing when you think they had already recorded love me do two months before this,shame they never recorded this and other songs like this they dropped them all.

[@bedfordsimon8]

this version contains a verse not found on the starclub album great find!!! thanks very much for posting

[@hectorgallegos9326]

Yes, it is correct! In a Hamburg Bootleg 62 the song of "I Saw Her Standing There" is complete with the complete verses and in the official double album they are cut off.

[@SylentEcho]

This sounds like it BELONGS on Live At The BBC vol1, side 1, but alas, they never did perform it there. :(

[@vincenegra2612]

Club days were the best~

[@kevanbrown7620]

I had the star club album, really bad quality, I was young and preferred to listen to one of their classic albums. I didn't realize the historic importance of it. Surely when they were doing the Anthology CDs, they could have cleaned up some tracks, like they did with That'll be the day, and In Spite of all the danger. If not, surely, they have the technology to clean up these tapes to a quality that would be worth buying. So historic. The Star Club performance.

[@euanthorburn8135]

♡

[@angelros1972]

For some odd reason, I get kind of sad when I hear The Bealtes

[@joseph_trippy2327]

Its probably the thought that you can never see them live and can't go back to that time when they performed, it is for me at least, and its just a shame that that time is gone. Thankfully the sound of it is saved here though and in the Hamburg recording you can almost sense the electric in the air whilst they performed because of how raw it is, but its also such poor quality

[@jaddison1112]

I had a terrible time listening to the Beatles after John Lennon was murdered in 1980 ( I was 30). It took me a lot of years, but now I just love hearing them. They were a huge part of my teenage years. I was 13 when they "Invaded America". .... All that great music of the 1960s, I feel so lucky to have been alive then.

[@blueycarlton]

@@jaddison1112 I was 30 as well. I was at work, there was a shift change and the in coming shift supervisor told me. I couldn't believe it. Had a radio near me and put on the midday news (AEDST) that confirmed it. Still listened to The Beatles though.

[@foofookachoo1136]

@@jaddison1112 The same !! I was 12yr. and going to be 13yr. in 2mo.’s!!! I’m SO glad I lived back in that time to inhale the very first dose of them!! And WHAT a DOSE IT WAS!!!! I love those 4 Brits to bits!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Pilcha.]

To me this beautiful cover make me particularly sad for John 😔, to think he was 22 years old and 18 years later he will be murdered.

[@Pilcha.]

1:42 😔

[@junplanas1403]

Ringo sounds like Pete Best.

[@trevorfromengland]

I had this track on a 7" bootleg single years ago. Quality wasn't half that on this video

[@lenalennon8746]

❤🎶🎶❤🔥🔥❤

[@Deivit60s]

Ok! Thanks! ;-)

[@廣岡成彦]

Full of Young John's Flaver❣️(^u^)♫

[@廣岡成彦]

Full of young John Lennon's flavor❣️(^u^)♫

[@LitaPage]

This song must have been recorded properly, the cover is so damn good

[@K.Marzy3]

GOOD‼️ BACK TO CAVEAN‼️

[@donworks]

Yeah, I'm confused about this recording. I've heard the official Star Club performance and it's always sounded poorly edited together. George's solo cuts in where the second verse should be, and then repeats. Here, it sounds exactly like a full unedited version of that recording. Is it? Either it's an important find, or it's a very impressive reproduction of that recording.

[@BassicVIC]

donworks No. I know what you mean. This one version is the only existing recording of The Beatles playing this beautiful song. This is the full unedited recording as they played it. Then you can hear the edited version in which someone had the gut to cut the second verse and pasted the guitar solo twice where the second verse should go.

[@Veronica-kz5dq]

Me encantó, dónde está la versión de los Beatles ?? 😢😢😢 Porfavor

[@pinup60]

Im pretty sure it's John. I can recognise his voice

[@ryszardstychno6827]

Wspólne wartości…..dla całej ludzkości….. Dla wierzących i niewierzących…..najważniejsze…..z dekalogu….. są trzy przykazania …..5 nie zabijaj…..odwrotnością jest ……zabijaj jak chcesz….. …..6 nie cudzołóż….odwrotnością jest …..ruchaj jak chcesz….. …..7 nie kradnij…..odwrotnością jest …..kradnij jak chcesz….. W dzisiejszych czasach…..gdzie jako najważniejsze wartości stawia się…..seks i pieniądze….osoba żyjąca…..przyjmuje odwrotność tych przykazań….. Wzór na duszę ……wyraża się wzorem ciśnienia……czyli….. p = F / S czyli ciśnienie jest równe sile dzielonej przez pole powierzchni…..we wzorze na duszę siła oznacza przestrzeganie przykazań…..moralność człowieka…..a pole powierzchni oznacz ciało człowieka….. Im wyższa moralność …..tym wyższe ciśnienie…..a jak człowiek nie ma moralności…..tylko ważnie jest ciało…..to nie ma ciśnienia….. Dlatego aby ludzkość miała wspólny mianownik…..powinna przestrzegać tych trzech przykazań….........

[@DocReasonable]

This is called 'Til We Kissed'.

[@marcb5374]

I believe that was written by the late great Arthur Anderson???

[@Alsurf89]

You're welcome, it's a pleasure ;)

[@junplanas1403]

Those are the BEATLES in Germany, with Pete Best on the drums.

[@robincampbell3050]

That's Ringo playing drums .This is from Dec.1962 at the Star Club

[@deadbeatdynamo]

Ah, the Purple Chick version. Most excellent.

[@commonman131]

Its to good a song by the Beatles not to be updated

[@AnotherSixStringerChannel]

looks like this is an edited version of the star club recordings, if it is , great job! btw, that's George on lead

[@daypeshmodd]

This is not a Lennon McCartney song. It's an Arthur Alexander song!

[@daneemberluto3457]

MDH it was written by Lennon-McCartney

[@beatlejim64]

It was written and released by Arthur Alexander in 1962. This is The Beatles playing at The Star Club in Hamburg Germany in late December 1962. Lennon singing lead and Paul & George with background harmony...

[@vanillajack5925]

Dane Ember Luto Where Have You Been (All My Life) was written by Barry Mann and Cynthia Weil - and first sung by Arthur Alexander. The Beatles covered a few of his songs including Anna and Soldier of Love.

[@rafaelzapata8375]

Nate , "A shot of rhythm and blues" too

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

It’s not a Lennon-McCartney original, but as Arthur Alexander was one of the biggest influences on John in the early days, he always sang them with as though they were his own (also see Anna), and based many of his early efforts on this style.

[@commonman131]

The Beatles should have resurrected some more songs by other performers and put them later albums like they did with their first two. It would help to balance their albums simply because some of their songs never came up to the mark.

[@thomassabia5750]

This was recorded from a 2 track with Mike in back of room not on any board

[@agustinmoragues191]

For sure is Ringo on drums ?

[@shaide5483]

I can actually hear the chords!!

[@michaelgeorge8671]

do yourselves a favour click onto Gene Vincent singing this song and yes it is a pity they did not record it on an album at some point. but thats life.

[@truebeatlepeople]

i have the hamburg lingasong records from 1977 and THESE sound better.... why? are they cleaned up or from a different sourse?

[@paulmarsh8974]

I could be wrong but not sure if that's the Beatles...

[@Deivit60s]

Ringo? Are you sure?

[@RobinCampbelldrummer93]

Who is singing?

Lennon

[@Korn1holio]

This needs AI re-release

[@vincenegra2612]

Nope~

[@mickmac2223]

All of the star club album needs AI re-release

[@petergalloway7978]

Poor Gene Vincent did a much better cover of this Auther Alexander song

[@vincenegra2612]

Not poor gene, and he did his cover in a studio~

[@jeanmariebasset2544]

Pas la meilleure version

[@marcellolinuskusup1479]

Bad drummer