The BEST And WORST Rye Whiskey

[@JordanG_3031]

SLB Classics 1:02 Kurt avoids the 🦄 2:01 great job pvb_nole🎉🎉 3:06 Kurt gets A-E ordered correctly 3:28 Trenton’s sticky note game is on point 4:09 QUINTESSENTIAL!!!! 4:33 First sip burn😂 5:48 Trenton tries to expand his vocabulary “astringent” 6:52 😂 That’s “wild” on the wild Turkey 101 rye 8:26 Trenton is losing is nose like his dad 9:06 Trenton nails the honey/maple note finish 11:53 Trenton’s candy note, grape laffy taffy 12:45 mom swore Kurt to secrecy😂😂 13:11 almost had the first swear on the channel but Trenton is too controlled 14:38 Kurt isn’t giving a lineup 😮😮 14:54 Trenton is really practicing his new vocab words 17:46 Leafy notes, peak fall 18:59 Kurt proves he doesn’t let Trenton influence his orders 20:32 nice guy Harry to remember the price 21:12 Trenton tries to break the glen 21:41 Trenton is changing the rules of the game 23:01 tacos and pizza always sounds good 23:56 Nice guy Corey S. 25:28 will Trenton have more sticky note power? 25:56 unfortunately Kurt ranks the wild Turkey low 27:46 Trenton absolutely nails the 1st place guess 29:50 Kurt sticks to the theme well 30:59 Trenton had not had 3?!?!? 31:30 Sticky note power, nice nod, great grammar

[@doogie64]

Having lived in Pikesville, MD for several years, I bought this for the nostalgia. It is now my favorite rye, with Rare Breed coming in second. Honestly, I was rooting for Pikesville the whole tasting. Well done! 👏👏

[@spencerjcolling]

Astringent is a drying effect that can also have numbing associated with it. That being said, it is caused by wood/herb tannins or unripe fruits which are bitter/sour.

[@jswarner319]

Unsweetened Tea, cranberries and Cabernet Sauvignon are what comes to mind for astringent mouthfeel.

[@OldManDan2024]

I considered writing something about this, but honestly you killed it. Definitive and correct, while also relatable. Well done!

[@userperson5259]

And isopropyl alcohol or witch hazel@@jswarner319

[@DBTdad]

Green persimmons, black tea, pine needles, pomegranate.

[@chasecowell9017]

It’s an effect of rapidly adding water to proof something down to fast also usually that’s what they are referring to

[@OldManDan2024]

This comment isn't really specific to this video, but I didn't have a good place to put it. Just wanted to let you guys know, I really appreciate this channel alot. In a youtube bourbon world where I feel like alot of channels are very elitist and unwelcoming, you guys are truly the "everyman" channel. You create well produced, thought out, and considerate content while maintaining the feeling that I am sitting in the room having a conversation with friends on the same journey as I am. I love your personalities and I hope you guys keep doing what you're doing, the way you're doing it, for a long time. I honestly feel good watching your videos. Thank you.

[@josephcianci1182]

Hey guys, I’m a big fan, luv your videos…they are insightful and informative…just fyi Peter Fasciano of Whiskey is a Journey has a specific video titled Sip it or Skip it… How about “Try or let it fly”? Thanks for your content! Best, Joe

[@rmbettac]

Rare Breed Rye is WONDERFUL. That and Pikesville are my two go-to’s. Love them both. Great selection.

[@GabrielLerma1029]

Hey gentlemen, thanks for this video! Here’s another request to put bottle information in the description of each of your videos! We don’t need all the info, just the important basic stuff (year, distillery, model, batch). Thanks!

[@ChapsChris]

Can’t beat the WT 101 Rye as a bargain sip. Thanks, gents. Another great show!

[@marvinwilks5893]

I was looking for a comment that mentioned Wild Turkey I'll pick up a bottle. I seen it the other day at the liquor store $23.99..

[@CorvetteBill364]

Great show guys I really enjoyed it. I am new to whiskeys so I have never had a rye whiskey. You guys have given me some advice as to which to start with but today the bottle s you suggested did not fair very well LOL. But looking forward to my trip to the Liquor store this weekend. Thank for the information you gentlemen provide.

[@markknister6272]

THANK YOU for putting the name on the screen - and leaving it through the taste. Pikesville in Phoenix is $70. :-(

[@Abby_Normal_1969]

I first heard of Pikeville on the Bourbon Judge a few weeks back. In a moment of serendipity a day later, a store near me stocked it. Loved it. I am a fan of Old Forrester Rye as well, but the prices just shot up significantly.

[@whiskeymusic9684]

I really like your videos. They are very honest and real. Any whisky drinker will gleen knowledge from your insights and descriptions. Thanks fellas.

[@CSAN]

Nicely done all around. And, Trenton calling the bottle for 1st place was super impressive 👊

[@toddcorbett3210]

I never agree with any of your placements on anything you have ever reviewed but I do enjoy the banter between y'all on why you chose what you did and I can agree with that. My flavor profile is so far off what you enjoy it's crazy but I do enjoy the banter. Keep up the good work!

[@nicksteven3020]

Thanks for all the videos love them. They really help me in my choices. Question… how much do you spend in a year on bourbon

[@EddieCorbin]

Been following for a good while and love it, what careers to yall have? Thanks

[@Danr07]

The KZbin channel “Whiskey is a Journey” has an ongoing segment called “Sip it or Skip It”

[@Robert.Sheard]

The WT101 is the only one of these I've tried (and love it). I clearly have some work to do! Pikesville is $55 here, and I "think" it's actually available here. That may be my next rye buy.

[@TorridDesign]

I bought the Pikesville a while back when you said to go get it, and i love it. Not surprised it was your #1.

[@darenholste2299]

I am a newbie maybe 2 months into my journey. Didn't know I liked Rye until I had Bear Wallow straight rye, whiskey, bottled in bond. Nashville Indiana 3 miles down the road from Hard Truth. Hard Truth has some great stuff to.

[@ashleyboyd4262]

Sip it or Skip it is a great title, and is very fitting....but there is another channel using this for one of their regular video series...."Whiskey Is A Journey"...not that they have a trademark on that, but just happened to watch one and it was fresh on my mind. Just trowing that out, I think it's fine you both use it, but wanted to mention. Love your channel, always great content.

[@userperson5259]

I like Pikesville Rye too but it's a "barely legal" rye and my palate definitely leans toward the earthy/grassy in the WT101 Rye.. So that probably would have been my #1 in this lineup but I say probably because I haven't had that maple rye or even the OF 100. This was awesome though...beautiful piano outro as well. Goes well with my OGD nightcap here.

[@padave7505]

Great show. Getting more into rye so going to check a few of these out.

[@billybruticus4719]

Turkey 101 rye is my budget rye hitter. Always available and often slept on as far as taste

[@davidcolgan3268]

I have only had WT101. Almost a daily pour but with a couple cubes. Interesting video.

[@techarch1795]

Have you guys tried Russell's Single Barrel Rye? It's super good IMO.

[@LP23D6]

I am a big rye guy. It's interesting that you did this and I have been tasting through my ryes in the last few nights to find my top 5 for a tasting with friends. So far my top 5 are Nashville Barrel Co. (store pick) Old Ezra 7 year, Rare Character (ADHD pick), Rossville Union (MGP) and Knob Creek (It's Bourbon Night pick) The Knob creek is #1 so far. with the first 3 all a close second. Rye's are often much more complex than bourbons. I get a lot of different flavors and they change a lot in as they set. (nose and palate) Cheers.

[@paleggett1897]

¿ New Riff Ryes?

[@LP23D6]

@@paleggett1897 I have a 113.3 proof New Riff Rye but I haven't got to it yet.

[@LP23D6]

@@paleggett1897 I have one. It might take me a while though. I have 89 bottles. Some are duplicates but I would guess probably 70 different ones.

[@BrianBegnoche]

"...with Trenton and me." You fixed it! 🎉

[@Brad-ic4bp]

I was amazed he guessed the #1. I love Pikesville too, but I wouldn't be able to pick it out of a lineup of ryes or bourbons. It’s just generally delicious, with nothing specific that stands out.

[@tomhalstead8935]

Fun, indeed. Pikesville doesn’t seem to be available where I am in SW Florida. I’m a big fan of Old Forester (BTW, 65% rye) and WT 101 and Rare Breed ryes.

[@Andrew_mm]

Always love the videos guys! Right now I am loving jack Daniel’s bonded rye. Makes me look forward to trying new rye

[@waynefialo9492]

I'm usually more of a bourbon guy but I have been drinking ryes a little more recently. Appreciating the reviews. PS impressive picking the first place bottle.

[@CPGumby]

Pikesville is a GREAT rye and a worthy winner. The price is ALL OVER THE PLACE in my area: I have seen it for under $40 all the way up to almost $80.

[@leeknowlton7303]

I've tried enough ryes to know I'd rather drink scotch. But the Pikesville and WT101 are very quintessential and on my short list for favorite ryes.

[@stevefromchicago8277]

I was so hoping first place was Pikesville 🙌 when Trent was guessing. My favorite rye, I buy it whenever I see it, finishing one bottle and have another bunkered, not around here often great for $50

[@Razieleatssouls]

I've been tempted to buy Pikesville for months now, and it sits on shelves out here for about $40 so I think I shall go out and get one haha. I'm still new to rye, only ever had Old Forester rye which is pretty good.

[@MrWayneJohn1]

As Ed Sullivan would have said, "It's a really big show!". Great job, as always, SLB!

[@RockulaRandy]

Trent, what would you say is your favorite rye, period? I am just getting into rye and am really liking it, but so far for me, nothing can touch your Sagamore pick from earlier this year.

[@clmartin22]

I had that Pikesville at Heaven Hill this week and really enjoyed it, call me crazy but I got like a sweet potato pie on it

[@maxwellmiller6288]

Appreciate the content fellas.

[@ocd_bourbon_bar]

Love Pikesville and OF 100 rye. I get grape soda on both. I’m ashamed to say I have never tried WT 101 rye. The WT 101 bourbon is one of my daily drinkers. Off topic, are there SLB T-shirts for sale? All I see are long sleeves and hoodies. 🥃

[@markcalhoun8219]

Bulliet 95 is my rye everyday all day but interested in trying pikesville and seeing how it stands up.

[@ddurts]

Pikesville is my go-to neat pour and 101 rye is my go-to mixer - makes a great old fashioned.

[@paulhendershot111]

Another great blind and this one was especially fun. I have not been able to find a Pikeville here in Columbus yet but I do really want to try it. I always have WT 101 rye or the OF rye on hand and like to use them in an Old Fashioned. Very enjoyable video!

[@CurtisMishleau]

Had half a bottle of Johnnie Walker high rye yesterday. Drinking some wild turkey 101 and Angels Envy Finnish Rye along with the show!

[@dustinpulliam9262]

I would love to know you guys opinion on mastersons 10 year rye. I searched and didn’t see a video from you guys on it.

[@brorjace1980]

Man, I love the Old Forester 100 rye.

[@omdahlre]

Trenton giving off serious Charlie Kelly vibes questioning whether hornets make honey 😂

[@pme1967]

I have been told and heard that with bourbon once the liquid gets very near the bottom one should just go ahead and finish it off cuz the taste usually tends to go negatively off. Not saying that it is poo just that the flavor will be off.

[@jennifermiller4]

I was wondering why Knob Creek Rye is rarely featured? They have a recent new 7 year age statement bottle. Would appreciate a review. 😊

[@AaronCarioto]

You guys are always fun to watch. Keep it up 👍

[@TheWhiskeyRambler]

I’ve been on a rye kick lately. Saz has been my favorite, but the Angels Envy Rum finished I had a sample of was really good. I have an Old Overholt and a Jim Beam single barrel I still need to crack and try

[@davidalbright3486]

Don’t know if anyone has mentioned it, but “Sip it or Skip it” is a feature used by “Whiskey is a Journey” KZbinr.

[@jeffscalfano3100]

I hust bought a pikesville yesterday. Its awesome!

[@kevinpardo2048]

i love rye and WT101 bourbon, but not a big fan of WT101 rye myself. Willett is my favorite rye so far.

[@ronmartinez2766]

Stopped by Heaven Hill last week to do a little tasting....the Pikeville Rye was such a great stand-out flavor!

[@algernonftw42]

Heck yes. I was hoping for a Pikesville win as soon as I saw it was on the table. Such a phenomenal rye.

[@ChapsChris]

Great job, Trent! Cheers! 🥃

[@MartyNIcoleAddison]

We tried the Pikesville at the Heaven Hill tour. Liked it enough to buy it!!

[@charlescalvert8647]

Pikesville is excellent, a good old style Maryland rye. Look for Sagamore Bottled in Bond rye. Very good.

[@kybetts1521]

In my own blind tastings, Alberta premium Rye has always beaten Pikesville. I would be interested to see how that one ranks for you guys. Put that one in the blind with willet and pikesville

[@apeekintime]

Pikesville is hard to find in my area (actually never seen it in my state but I live on a border and I usually find it across the river). Clearly I enjoy it - it was the first bottle I actually killed off. I havent' replaced it specifically so I drink something else. It's a great proof point and it's an easy mashbill.

[@johncannon3593]

I would love to have seen Rare Breed Rye instead of WT101. Love it.

[@toddlksbrbn]

I can’t believe Trent hasn’t had WT rare breed when he loves ryes so much! WT RB is soo good!

[@fidddle121]

U guys are so funny together. Lifts me up every time

[@joewinckowski]

The channel I like for sip it or skip it is called Whiskey is a Journey

[@RedSoxFanatic4Life]

Agreed: Pikesville is a phenomenal rye. Definitely one of my favorite whiskeys across all categories. Rittenhouse is another great rye from Heaven Hill that’s $28 in my area.

[@Lemontkd]

There is a whiskey tuber already using sip it or skip it

[@Valath]

Well done fellas! I would love to see Trenton try Rarebreed rye for the first time!

[@gregsgarage1260]

I have been looking for the pikesville for ever can’t find it anywhere!

[@3frogltd987]

Pikesville is excellent rye, one of the best in it's price range ($50+ in Wisconsin). Rare Breed Rye is another favorite in the same price range.

[@jasonpribyl3916]

I love the Bardstown Orgien Rye, but my favorite is the Pursuit United single barrel ryes, super rich flavors

[@teschvalleyrailroad]

I have not found a Rye I like at all so far. I'm more of a wheated guy due to the extra sweetness. The "spice" factor in the Rye's is not something my palate enjoys. That being said, I may have to try to find that Maple Rye!!!!!! I still enjoy everyone of your videos, even those that showcase items I can't get in Michigan. :)

[@3frogltd987]

I suggest you try Rittenhouse Rye, it's very good bonded rye that is smooth a a touch sweet, and is delicious neat and in mixed drinks. My wife didn't like any ryes until she tasted Rittenhouse, now I keep a bottle on hand for her.

[@EJH4197]

Seconded on the Rittenhouse. Also Templeton 6-year is very good however I’ve heard it has artificial flavoring if you’re a purist. Taste is phenomenal tho and can be had for under 40 some places

[@moguy1973]

I hadn't had Hard Truth until last weekend, and I tried their sweet mash Harvest Rye and it was pretty dang good for a rye.

[@Ange65230]

Yep Pikesville is delicious. Strangely I detect scotch notes in it, but lovely depth and on the sweet side.

[@johndoh4523]

I love your rye battles. But... may it be you never had the Knob Creek Rye on a show? Think it has fantastic value.

[@honker1307]

Great episode on the Rye's, and also a local one in my state of Ohio.

[@CurtisMishleau]

I'm just happy to know sip it or skip it win!! I love rye whiskies! Let's go!!

[@biffgordon5775]

Old Forester rye is perfect for my Manhattan

[@andrewkinder4153]

There is another channel that does a sip it or skip it ... not that it matters ... lol

[@cjetter67]

Was just about to comment this lol

[@davevogelsang6791]

Peter from Whiskey is a Journey has been doing Sip it or Skip for a while.

[@Toolate2024]

$42 for Pikesville!!!!! MSRP 😢is $55 + tax in State ran abc sales. Does that change your recommendation on that price range?

[@iandavidharwin]

Pikesville is allocated in my area, can't find it. Wish I could.

[@JimboGrace81]

“Leaf particulate” lol very descriptive!

[@stuartrollings602]

WT 101 rye 19-20 here in Texas..Hard to beat!

[@itsjackbandit]

Just a heads-up, there's already a KZbin Whiskey channel with a segment called "Sip It or Skip It." You're well beyond their subs, but something to consider. Cheers!

[@treimo7073]

GREAT blind! 🎉 Would have loved to also see my favorite budget rye (also from Heaven Hill) - Rittenhouse - included 😊

[@jasonbaily1707]

A blind taste would be challenging, because you automatically show preference based on label recognition. I do like pikeville rye as it drinks more oaky. barrel aged

[@billrichardson7099]

Hayner distillery is here in my hometown of Troy, Ohio. Theirs a lot of history that goes with the name.

[@peterwhite507]

When HH released those 21, 23 and 25 year Rittenhouse Rye's in the mid to late 2000's, I would have thought they would have some older Rye stock's by now. Would be cool if they released Pikesville 10 plus year version. I mean everybody else is now-a-days. I wonder if those old high aged Rittenhouse Rye's were just leftover Bernheim stock that Willett (KBD) did not get when Bernheim was bought by HH.

[@hennyschuitert4623]

Balcones is also great,do a test sometimes.

[@whodey59]

To me... Pikesville is a very bourbon forward rye. Nice gateway whiskey when transitioning from bourbon to rye. But can't find it for under $50.

[@777Dorado]

Just pick......Trenton really needed to know Kurts picks, which I had that feeling a lot of the time when doing blinds. I always thought they should have gone one at a time anyways.......Blind to the end.

[@georgewalker6883]

Driftless Glen Straight Rye is AMAZING!

[@nickmassa8863]

Video idea: You can only have one final pour and then never drink again, what’s your choice Vs If you can only drink one whiskey for the rest of your life as much as you want, what is your choice

[@Caleb_clement]

Yall going crazy with the commercials. Still love yall though

[@paulring4267]

I was surprised that you didn’t include WT Rare Breed Rye.

[@foobird02]

Woodinville Whiskey finishes a maple syrup in their whiskey barrels. It’s really good maple syrup but pricey.

[@terrencemcdermott5840]

Redwood Empire Emerald Giant CS is a four grain rye. There are a few more out there now.

[@michaelmaggi7637]

Old Forester 100 Proof makes one hell of a Manhattan w/Cinzano Red Vermouth

[@scottgilbertson3112]

Studio Distilling Rye (MN) - all-time favorite Rye. Notes of coffee, chocolate, & smoke. Roknar Maryland-Style Rye (MN) - heavy caramel note. Sagamore Double Oak Rye a new pick up was fantastic. These are top 3 for me. Pikesville, Rittenhouse, OF Rye don’t do much for me. Too bland to use as mixers. I want my Rye to stand above the mix.