The BEST Pencil to Sketch Under Watercolour - Materials Test

[@barbhayes5613]

The best demonstration of the differences in simple graphite pencils I've seen yet. Thank you for sharing this; this time I think I'll remember the grades next time I need pencils! Cheers!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much Barb!

[@OkieSketcher1949]

I normally use an HB or on occasion a 2B graphite pencil for my watercolor sketches. I try to use the lightest line I can get away with and still be able to see the line. I do occasionally use watercolor pencils, but I try to use a color that will closely match the area to be watercolored when actually coloring the picture. The watercolor pencil will dissolve and blend in with the watercolor paint and thus not leave a line that may need to be removed. I do like your presentation. You have a good way to make an artist think about the proper tool to use when sketching, especially if one intends to paint over the sketch later on.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Robert!

[@digitoes]

This was a very informative test. I checked on Amazon US and they sell both pencils. The Faber Castell pencils (pack of 6) cost $2.99 and one Derwent mountain grey watercolor pencil costs $16.00. Quite a difference. Thanks for your great teaching style.

[@gailgyngell1108]

I think your teaching methods are just brilliant. So east to understand. I love listening to you. This pencil demo was so well done. Thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Ah thanks so much Gail!

[@joeytipping7436]

This is the best and most comprehensive video on which pencil (s) is best to use under watercolour painting! Super. Thank you so much.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much!

[@vanessap9124]

I always learn something from your videos because I am a visual learner. You always have great demonstrations.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you!

[@TheBeverleyann]

I have been binging your lessons for 3 days now & love love love your teaching ! I got into watercolor a few years back *covid* and get art block now & then , your lessons have brought me back to life :) Thank you so so much for everything you are doing for us ! Happy Holidays & Blessings to you & yours 😊

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You are so welcome!

[@tammiecampos1928]

Thank you for offering this video. Very helpful information.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

No worries, I thought it would be helpful!

[@yulianwardhana1649]

This is soooo valuable! Thank you so much for this well-thought video. Much appreciated!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@christinefoss5767]

Thank you for such an informative demonstration!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

No worries, I’m glad it was helpful!

[@norenebroyles283]

This video is full of helpful info. I didn't realize one could erase the pencil lines after they are painted over...I'm going to do some experimenting. Thanks so much Harriet. I’m have learned so much from your videos!!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So pleased!

[@martiwalsh2069]

Thank you for doing a practical test, and not simply talking about it. Seeing helps me understand.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You’re welcome

[@marlene7991]

Hi Harriet. I loved the botanical painting you used as a reference. It is gorgeous. Love your animal paintings too!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you, the blossom painting is in my new book, coming out in October!

[@marlene7991]

@@deWintonPaperCo Really! That is wonderful to know. By any chance does it include any of your adorable animals? I’m enjoying your first book

[@tarotbysemaj2424]

This was a lovely teaching. I really appreciated you taking the time to share this with us. Your content has been brilliant. I keep learning so much. I really appreciate you sharing your knowledge. You being self taught, seems to have leant to some very good learnings, taking your personal experience and being so willing to share. You definitely have the 🧡 of a teacher.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much!

[@karenmurdoch7450]

I love your teaching style. Very patient and informative. I have learnt so much from your teachings. Thankyou.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you so much Karen, happy painting!

[@aricar325]

Thank you so much for making and sharing this video. I appreciate that you tested so many options. Very helpful!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@eddiejohn7744]

Very interesting and detailed summary , thank you

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad you liked it!

[@michaelkalanty3594]

Really totally interesting, exact, and technically solid demonstration. And well narrated with no empty space. Brava!!!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad you found it helpful Michael

[@melindaavila498]

Wonderful demonstration!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad it was helpful

[@neelofurk576]

This is such a thorough explanation/ demonstration .... Thanks!!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@anitadavidson1266]

Thanks Harriet, that was extremely informative. I think I’d enjoy using the Faber Castel HB aquarelle pencil slightly more than the standard as I occasionally have a problem keeping my sketches very light due to neurological issues affecting how my hands work, so I would hope that the Faber Castel would help balance that issue out, with the least rubbing out. Thanks again! I’m proud to be a Patreon 🎨👩‍🎨😻

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Ah wonderful Anita. I’m so glad this was helpful

[@mickigarvey7608]

Oh what a joy to watch such a methodical approach to finding what works. Thanks so much 🙂

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You’re welcome!

[@susanspeidel312]

Awesome test! Very helpful demonstration! Thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you!

[@yvonnelocke7649]

Thank you for that wonderful demonstration and information 🙏💕

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You are so welcome

[@penelopemarshall6320]

I do have quite an array of pencils in my kit but the one I always pick out is an old worn out one with double EE on it! It just works well on the page and is easy to use. Very helpful and informative, always love to learn more tips! 😊❤️

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad you’ve got your favourite pencil!

[@lauramilligan1844]

Very informative video. Best explanation of the different pencil leads I've been able to find. Thank you!!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much Laura!

[@littlemoonillustrations4372]

Thank you sooo much Harriet, dear❤❤🙏🙏 this was absolutely helpful and informative 👍

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you! 😊

[@Penciledbykay]

Great video! Very informative, thank you for sharing your tests!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

My pleasure!

[@golden1789]

Fantastically useful. Thank you.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad!

[@jakkirook6959]

Brilliant! I enjoyed watching that as I did wonder which would be best.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@DarjeeLiArts]

Thank you so much for the thorough comparison and the practical tests, this was very helpful!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@inesucrvenom]

thanks for the effort, it's highly appreciated to really understand how it really behaves!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@adminhome9544]

Thank you so much. This is exactly what I was looking for! Very well done video.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad it’s helpful

[@sallyvaux8819]

So useful! Thank you Harriet ☺️

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad!

[@karenr2404]

Thank you for showing us the difference. It was very helpful. I just received your book and can't wait to use it. Have a blessed week.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Ah thanks Karen!

[@storyofanimal7908]

It’s amazing the talents people have. That’s all I’m gonna say, oh and very very nice work! Best pencil drawing I've seen on KZbin.com. Amazing subtlety and accuracy.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Wow, thank you!

[@theroadhome_Liz_Summers]

Thanks! I know this is an old video but as newbie ... I am starting at the beginning and very much appreciate all of this information.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You are so welcome!

[@maremacd]

Me too! I’m amazed that you can remove pencil without (noticeably) removing the watercolor on top of it!

[@guillerminaayrolo2929]

great demonstration!!!!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much!

[@ginettemelody1035]

Excellent presentation. Thank you. Blessings

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks for watching

[@juststartingover2735]

Thank you for an excellent comparison! Love your channel 💖

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You are so welcome!

[@Carina-2906]

Thank you very much for this informative video! Have a nice week!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you! You too!

[@4seasons546]

❤ Thank you 🙏 very useful & nicely thought out examples 😃 plus you have a pleasant speaking voice 😊 which is helpful when listening to yiu tube tutorials … some people are sharp sounding & it takes the pleasure away . Your voice is soothing 🤗

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You're welcome 😊

[@sonjasmit3855]

Very very informative video, thanks.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Sonja, don't forget we have an art sale of my originals on Etsy, make sure you don't miss out! www.etsy.com/uk/shop/deWintonPaperco

[@ranjanachand9306]

Thanks for sharing such imp information 😀

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So nice of you

[@carrollwilson5169]

Loved the knowledge shared in this video, thank you 💖

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You are so welcome!

[@bethlillis5575]

Great demonstration Such a simple topic but such good information

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much Beth

[@Lollybelle1]

So helpful! Thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@paulinedavis2918]

Thankyou great tutorial... I too love the HB pencil x

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You’re welcome 😊

[@BlessedBeyondAllMeasure]

Wonderful video! Thank you for doing this! It really helped me!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad it was helpful

[@yaeledmonds5158]

That was really helpful, thank you! I’ve ordered the Fabre-Castell HB to try it out.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@cindyknudtson2938]

Thank you so much that was very informative and helpful. You are Awesome

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@noreenkitko8178]

wonderful lesson for me, I needed this info. Bravo!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Noreen!

[@Gerald-HampshireUK]

Thank you so much for your intensive review. As a result, I have ordered the Faber Castell Aquarelle HB. Hopefully this will solve my pencil line views under my watercolours, not the best look! Gerald, Hampshire

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Hope you enjoy it!

[@gingerkelly5146]

This is so very helpful and full of information! Thank you so very much!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Great, so glad I can help Ginger!

[@yasmingreger6653]

That was very interesting. To know more about pencils. Thanks a lot.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

No worries Yasmin!

[@PntrGrl]

Thanks for sharing! Great info!

[@amandastratton8242]

Thank you Harriett very interesting tutorial I usually use a graphite pencil and do get grey bleed so will certainly try the aquerelle

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Amanda!

[@jopace9118]

Wow, who knew the vast difference a simple thing as a pencil could make! Thank you for this, I will be trying some different pencils now :)

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad it was helpful

[@juliec.]

This Is an amazing video. I’ve always wondered “what is HB”? Super super helpful. Fantastic work and Thank you 🙏

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@aguacolours]

The regular graphite HB, which I use 😊, and the Graphite Aquarelle by Faber Castell, which I purchased but have not put it to the test myself, are my favorites. Thank you for demonstrating a variety of pencils and how they react under different techniques, it is very helpful, as well as, reassuring. I totally agree that the B ones do smudge and can make your colors mirky. i found out by "trial and error"! Your study was precisely the perfect way ☺.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Fantastic, so glad it was helpful

[@chrischurchley7003]

Supergood! Thank you so much 😃

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you too!

[@joanpringle-canning2834]

Wonderful presentation, enjoyed your demonstration 😊

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Joan!

[@conniepennington5763]

Wonderful lesson! Thank you.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You're very welcome!

[@vi8160]

Thank you for your video. This is definitely helpful for me. Love all your tutorials! 💕

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad!

[@Cashious]

This is such a good video! Very educational and extremely helpful for me personally 😃

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@jolovesnailart]

Very helpful and interesting test, thank you so much 🙏 I am wondering if different sorts of watercolor paper would make a difference in rubbing it out or the solubility?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Yes It will make a difference too

[@wendyizod923]

Very useful information, probably stick with the HB pencil. But would definitely get a water soluble to try.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Yeah sounds like a good idea!

[@CharleyWang]

Pencil gathering, I like to use 4B, this is my choice! Thank you for your comparison and analysis

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Nice!

[@TheCreativeCurator]

Really helpful video Harriet, thank you! I’m just getting used to watercolours again (had to use them previously for fashion illustration) and your videos have been super helpful!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@maud2rolland348]

Very interesting thank you

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad!

[@voliabrandaolaveneremachad7849]

Thank you so much! Really good advice!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

You’re so welcome!

[@jacquiliddell1811]

Very interesting, thank you, things like this you need to know x

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Yes I hope it’s helpful

[@Harper.s_Art]

I have the set of watercolor pencils and love them but for drawing my watercolor sketches, I’ve been using regular (non water-soluble) colored pencils in the lightest value of whatever color I’ll be painting

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Fantastic!

[@cathybates4739]

Thank you so much for this experiment!! This was so helpful. I recently purchased an H9 pencil at the advice of the art store clerk. She thought with the harder lead it would easily make a light line. It did, but even with light pressure it made a groove in the paper! Not good at all. I’m going to try the faber castel water soluble pencil. I also have a faber castel kneaded eraser, but purchased another brand... the FB was so much nicer!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Great!

[@janetc1071]

Great information. I was completely confused about which pencils to try and this was the best explanation as well as demonstration. I'm just getting started learning watercolor and appreciate having this info. Thank you!!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So pleased it’s helpful!

[@elizabethnicholson6691]

This was such a good idea. Thank you so much! 🙂

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks Elizabeth!

[@laurajane1900]

So useful thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@tkkozeluh]

Great demonstration! I would be interested in hearing your thoughts on using the graphite tracing paper that you can trace your picture onto the watercolor paper.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Great suggestion!

[@cityhen7]

Very helpful

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad!

[@donnacarraway9182]

Thank you! Great info!!💕

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@scmarinemom24]

This was very informative, thank you. I've just ordered your book (American version) and I can't wait to get it.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Ah thanks Maria!

[@janiceseward585]

That was helpful. Thank you.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Ah I’m so pleased, thanks Janice

[@alisonisboring]

This was so helpful! Would you be able to use a normal eraser (like your standard pencilcase staedtler one) to get the same effect of erasing the light pencil marks once paint is dry? X

[@deWintonPaperCo]

I think so!

[@lincorrie5894]

This was so interesting, thank you. It's made me much more aware of just what pencil I've picked up to use. Very impressed with your eraser as I'm apt to wreck the paper surface with my conventional one. 🙂

[@deWintonPaperCo]

So glad it’s helpful!

[@neelofurk576]

This is so helpful

[@simonmasson3416]

Logical/informative/practical. Go good old HB, still the one. New fangdangle, who needs them only those trying to impress or haven't seen this video. I'll stick with the original. Thanks Harriet.

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Great stuff Simon!

[@TheArtfulAddict]

I've always heard you can't remove pencil markings once you've painted over them. Thank you for the informative demonstration!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Yes it can be done!

[@carlymcevoy6108]

Wonderful video and very informative! You are a wonderful teacher! I'd love to see a video on how you paint peonies! Also, could you link the eraser you use? Thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

I have a peony project in my book! I’ll update the episode notes and add a link for the rubber soon

[@daliaobregon9444]

Thank you!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks so much Dalia!

[@jackiemiller1408]

I use an HB mostly, but I have trouble erasing it when it's been painted over. I also have the FaberCastel soluble HB but haven't been using it because of the issue of it disappearing too soon. How do you get your HB to erase so well? Any special trick you didn't show?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

All my techniques are in this video. The thing I would stress is to draw lightly in the first place

[@toriabyvictoriajowett7130]

So interesting! Do you think the soluble HB would rub out if it hadn’t fully dissolved?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

hmm I'm not sure! Will have to try !

[@TarotThrones]

Ah the good old HB wins the day for me! Will all watercolour shades let you lift off a light HB or are some better than others?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

I’ve only investigated these shades so you’d have to have a look

[@dawnphares1652]

What sharpener do you use to get these so sharp? Please don’t tell me you hand chisel them. 😀

[@deWintonPaperCo]

I use something called a 'long point sharpener'

[@vivianbooth0105]

Harriet, would you consider doing a peony? Thanks for all the videos!

[@deWintonPaperCo]

I have a peony in the book so I try to focus on new things but I’m sure they will feature in some way when peony season begins

[@kpadgett4537]

what about using "watercolor pencil" in appropriate color to sketch?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Yes you could do that if you wanted.

[@ComplexBeauty09]

I might have missed it, but is the eraser a key component?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

To a certain extent but this was more focussing on the range of pencil options.

[@Leonardo.de.A]

The best demonstration of breaking pencil tips! 😂

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Glad it was helpful!

[@julialanger5058]

danke !

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thanks!

[@paolaevangelista3156]

Exelente!!! 🌟

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Thank you!

[@staceystazu]

What are you using to erase the pencil sketch?

[@deWintonPaperCo]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/rV69fqd6pb17ftk this should answer your questions :)

[@anneholloway5896]

What was the putty rubber I can’t see it in the description xXx 🥰

[@deWintonPaperCo]

Hi Anne, its a faber castell kneadbale eraser

[@anneholloway5896]

@@deWintonPaperCo thank you xXx 🥰