The Big Picture - Freebie Model of Governance

[@JITENDERKUMAR-zh6gp]

I really hate the continuous talk by vishal..he keeps on asking same lengthy questions again and again to all the panelists in different ways..and speaks a lot unnecessary by asking these questions...Please bring back Frank..he is the best facilitator.

[@rahulg5271]

Vishal also interupt panalist Countineously.

[@manujtrivedi8682]

Summary: Introduction: Freebies have been a part of our political system for a long time. From TN, where the issue reached Supreme Court to now Delhi which recently has announced free DTC rides for women, this model of governance has come under question of sustainability and how it impacts Indian democracy. Problems- Freebies primarily originate out of the shortcomings in achieving good governance. Political parties in power, being unable to deliver the expectation of the people, indulge into such practices. On the other hand, exageratted poll promises of freebies by the opposition parties in response distract the people from real issues undermining the purpose of the election. Conclusion- This is an unhealthy practice and an unsustainable model of governance. Electorates are now more aware and have proved at times not to be swayed by these promises, yet the reiteration of such promises by political parties before every election is a common sight. The revision of the Model Code of Conduct by the EC will definitely help the situation but it is the people who can reject such promises that will bring the ultimate change and will make our political parties more responsible and our democracy, a thriving one.

[@singhrandeep7451]

Central govt and state govt must free all basic needs like necessary food ,electricity ,water health and education. Jo de rhe hain like AAP ,unko encourage to kya dena tha ulta tng kr rhe hain like bjp. Supreme court ko unke khilaf action lena chahiye jo vada krke bhi 5 saal me poora nhi krte. Economy will led down only if rich people doing corruption with help of polititians and doing tax chori ,,,,not because of Freebies .its not freebies its basic needs which must free and must be fundamental rights.

[@negative_thots]

@@singhrandeep7451 basic needs can be subsidize but should never be given for free. This model will always be unsustainable and we will enter into a economic crisis.

[@singhrandeep7451]

@@negative_thots free up to a limit is also known as subsidized ,my dear

[@neerajkant3728]

It means KISSAN SAMMAN NIDHI YOJNA is a REVADI CULTURE SCHEME...THERE SHOULD BE A PLEA AGAINST THIS SCHEME IN SUPREME COURT

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

Mr.Ashok Tondon is now the Sudhir chawdhary of Rstv. Good luck sir.

[@jayantdixit1517]

Mr. Tondon shouldn't be biased being a senior journalist.

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

Why don't Rstv team go to a Delhi govt school or a govt hospital to see from their own eyes of what AAP has done a revolutionary work in Delhi.

[@aartiodd1791]

Biased against one particular party for giving freebies 👎 We don't expect these kind of things from RS TV. Ashok tondon ( prejudiced opinions)

[@livewithapurpose5651]

Indeed

[@thetruth3460]

Tandon talks more like a BJP spokesperson

[@Anubhav_6444]

Hey...I was going to comment exactly the same ..

[@prajakt0789]

Kaisa aadmi hai bhai. Everybody pays taxes. He is simply biased and misleads people.

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

Governance of the Aam Aadmi party is way better than the Modi's. People from bordering states like Uttar pradesh and Haryana come Delhi for their treatment in Delhi govt hospital which is absolutely free and the best in India. AAP has the best govt schools and hospitals in India. The electricity rates in Delhi is the lowest as well as subsidised for poor people who consumes less electricity.

[@lavlendrajaiswal7626]

Sir hospital quality you can visit in state of kerala & tamilnadu their primary health is way better than delhi & in primary school education karnataka & kerala no state can match them.

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

@@lavlendrajaiswal7626 It is a healthy competition. Good for everyone.

[@lavlendrajaiswal7626]

Absolutely

[@lavlendrajaiswal7626]

@RAHUL GANDHI No sir I doesn't means for freebie never only talked about education & health which has been provided free or minimal cost in every government school & hospital , in this sector service delivery has become good in delhi. I never appriciate frrebies like free electricity , water , transport in city like delhi where people have enough earning to pay for it. I want to tell You that I elected you 3 times as MP from my area , but sir a railway line anounced by Mr. Lalu yadav then railway minister in 2008 , whose construction has not started yet, hence this time I chose Nota

[@lavlendrajaiswal7626]

I only talked about health & education nothing else ,

[@livewithapurpose5651]

Vote bank politics Caste and religion based politics Freebies Hyper nationalism based politics These all make Democracy DemoCrazy

[@caesar848]

Unfortunately we have all of them. It's not a mistake of netas but citizens are responsible.

[@j.ramanandnayak4571]

😄😄😄😄

[@imdad8715]

Omg i thought Rstv is Neutral but here I see Dhaiya reflect as a spokesperson😢

[@livewithapurpose5651]

For freebies to us Our children will have to pay

[@aspirant8996]

They are paying, these panelists have come to the stage on their vehicles polluting air and their children are paying. Our PM is begging for loans from WB, IMF, EU, JICA and children will pay, children will pay for your consumerism for your false race to modernism. So, solution: don't marry.

[@krishnamuthurajan6784]

SC take on Tamilnadu government free TV to all as " TV cannot be seen only as an entertainment device ,but a tool of empowerment "....as mam said freebie impact depends on what kind of freebie you give.....some freebies like laptop and TV reduces social inequality and promote inclusiveness in society as it reduces the relative deprivation existing among people.

[@hannibalbarko8748]

Well said

[@abiramib3202]

Still it has huge impact on gvt fiscal..instead of giving a man fish, teach him to catch fish...that's how gvt approaches should be nah!

[@hannibalbarko8748]

@@abiramib3202 Definitely freebie will affect govt fiscal but that was only 1 % compared to 99 % real hidden things affect fiscal and economy "Our perception was deliberatly manufactured to dismay the least one freebie " "As you said ' instead of giving a man fish , teach him to catch ' govt should craft policies based on this...... But instead of opposing freebie/ wealth distribution eliminate root cause for why people look for , expect and in need for freebies first ........... Few things that largely affect fiscal and economy won't be debated or recorded ..... 1.Vote for money 2.huge loans based on fraudulent transactions for un deserved corporates {nirav-malaya}. 3.promised kick backs for politicians through waiving agri-loans 4.fake and 50 % kick backs for govt contracts..... So and so on ............ en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corruption_in_India?wprov=sfla1 www.ey.com/in/en/services/assurance/fraud-investigation---dispute-services/bribery-and-corruption-ground-reality-in-india

[@GauravSingh-hq9wg]

And what is about electricity and net?

[@divya_gm]

where's frank ??? this anchor has this talent of making big picture uninteresting

[@Mommy_and_Shaurya]

SUMMARY : 1. case study : tamil nadu - already challenged in SC . SC refused to stay on the freebies .Subramaniam balaji case . MODEL CODE OF CONDUCT guidelines : parties should not promise freebies in their poll promises / manifesto . 2.Usually happens in states with 'politics of plenty' - where basic needs are already fulfilled .so inorder to still attract voters u give them freebies . 3.POLL PROMISE VS FREEBIES - delhi govt = freebies 4.it affects the sustainibility of the govt finances disapointed with the quality of the discussion compared to earlier discussions .

[@akhilaartin272]

Did BIG PICTURE run out of ideas??

[@Godofschool]

Hmm seems so😂😂😂

[@sikhakumari8934]

That's why Frank is not here 😂

[@TheKsh1]

Slow death of big picture happening from last one year. No debate on issues where govt might be on back foot or even on other issues panelists are homogeneous lot.

[@drpratikshameena1441]

The big picture is very important segment of RSTV it deserves better topics as well as anchor for discussion.

[@Sham_1520]

We demand #FrankRausanPereira 🙏 for "The big picture." pls

[@pratyushkumar4324]

MILTON FRIEDMAN once opined '' There is no such thing as a free lunch''.He means that it is impossible to get something for nothing. Even those offered 'free' always costs a person or society as a whole.

[@ravindertalwar553]

INDIA IS A STRONG, SECULAR AND LARGEST DEMOCRACY IN THE WORLD BECAUSE INDIANS ARE SPECIALLY BLESSED, TALENTED, SMART, HARDWORKING, HONEST AND HUMBLE.

[@AnjaliKumari-kk7yn]

Ashok tandon is absolutely right

[@naveenrajsivasamy812]

Ground reality in Tamil Nadu: 1. People below poverty line, now started expecting freebies as a part of election, even started streetprotest if govt delays freebies after election more attractive freebie wins more vote. In TN, it started from free rice then free cycle then free tv then free laptop now fan, Grinder etc 2. TN is more complicated! There is a good developmental activities, good education, less religious hatredness comparitively etc... but still freebie concept (worst thing) suvives so other states (few exceptions may be) following it may not be a wise choice! I am not discriminating any state, I am sharing it because of the real care on them becuase we were already trapped so dont want others to fell into this. 3. Middle class and Above people in TN : are of two category, ADMK (Jayalalitha madam/OPS) and DMK (Karunanidhi/stalin) (Congress BJP Communist have meagre votebank), they mostly swap their vote based on the performance of the party in the election year! FREEBIES HAS LIMITED ROLE TO PLAY HERE, so to attract them good governance is essential so TN follows that too. How to stop it here : Political parties will never ever stop if ECI or SC just advices them, without punishment how the crime stops? ECI must develope some frameworks that should be strictly followed by parties during campaign (manifesto) and SC must develope some guidelines to be followed by govt to control such freebies during non election years. I know the discussion is about the possibility of such framework only! and ultimately I dont have answer for those final measures readily, I am just sharing the scenario in TN which may be usefull for others to understand about freebie model in TN. Thank you

[@ravindertalwar553]

I LOVE INDIA AND ALL INDIANS OF SOVEREIGN, SOCIALIST, SECULAR, DEMOCRATIC AND REPUBLIC OF INDIA.

[@roshangabhale7129]

Bring frank back....there should be apolitical and well co-ordinated debate...#rstvbringbeckfrank.

[@gajendraghuraiya3840]

Indian never vote by coming in someone’s influence bcos already they are under influence of casteism 😂😂

[@arushiroy5321]

If 300 crore is being distributed amongst the people of Delhi( free bus ticket form) , you all have problems regarding it , but you give me answer if this 300crore is found in the house of one political party ,you are just silent why? And I want to know why this rajya sabha TV always praises about Modi ,they are many faults in his governance also .

[@igniteindia6437]

Corruption is a different issue all together what these free ticket stuffs in metro will destroy metros all together.... Read the letter written by E sreedharan metro man.....

[@shivam7144]

Dear....change people with women....

[@hannibalbarko8748]

👍

[@caesar848]

Freebies hamper morality. And laws should be gender neutral.

[@tincesebastian9580]

Tandon sir spoke about Rahul Gandhi giving so many promises like 60k rupees for each etc and ppl still voted for modi..but he doesn't stated that modi made more promises saying 1 lakh rupees ( black money ) on every citizens account...each government gives a lot of false promises and policies.. please don't be biased while giving your opinions

[@gauravtomer4716]

Sir vishal dhaiya is best

[@amitojha9545]

WTF! How come PMKISAN was not a freebie ?

[@TheKsh1]

Thats what i wonder. Pm kisan is missing from economy debates. 70k cr put a big hole on fiscal front.

[@hannibalbarko8748]

2019 one rupee napkin scheme initiated.......... 2012 T.N Govt brought free napkin scheme 40 lakh tenagers , 7 lakh mothers 700 women prisoners benefited ....... Do you call this cheaply freebies .....!!!!!! 😊😊😊 if so ask girls near by you.............. Despite of dynastic politics and corruption T.N and kerala was high in human capital development only through these even wealth distribution as u call it freebies...... Tv, cycle, 25 k for newborn girl babies , scoter for working women for you these are freebies but essential for people those who can't afford it ........Laptop for students they can't even dream for there generation.............Only if you came from below 10% you can understand it........... By opposing and eradicating freebie (wealth distribution ) and leaving corruption from this system there will be only < power distance > dynastic politics > syndicate > corporate ........... Freebie is bad for any country & economy but should have an even head start for each and every people....... First Remove corruption , reservation , favouritism bring result oriented poverty reduction policy's try to understand what is really wealth distribution in an uneven corrupted economy like india unless this below 10% will become below 90% for sure....... {( If u want to known how these frebies (wealth distribution ) works in T.N and kerala come here by yourself and feel it......U Can't understand by sitting in AC room in Delhi )}👍👍👍 kzbin.info/www/bejne/haOofaSXrJaNf6M www.google.com/amp/s/m.businesstoday.in/lite/story/oxfam-india-wealth-report-income-inequality-richests-poor/1/268541.html

[@Pranav-rp8wi]

The appeal towards freebies comes due to low direct tax payer ratio and socialist history of our last 100 years.. If more number of people come under the income tax bracket then more families will think about direct impact of freebies..

[@prassannakumar]

one sided debate. TN has done better. So freebies do work at least to some extent!

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

This discussion is so biased! Rstv is working under centre's pressure and is being used as tool against rival political parties. Ashok Tondon is a BJP spokesperson. Free rides in DTC busses might not be big a thing for you guys but ask your maideservants that if they would like to travel free in busses? This free ride scheme is for poor people in Delhi.

[@darshantrivedi4355]

Than why only women. Are only females poor??

[@Shaiva_Amit_Singh]

I m not sure whether Rstv is working under govt pressure but after seeing ur comment I can say that u r an AAP supporter

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

@@Shaiva_Amit_Singh Which is more concerning to you? A: National News agency (Prasar Bharti) is being working under pressure of the state. The news agency on which the people rely for unbaised news. OR B: Me being an AAP supporter.

[@Shaiva_Amit_Singh]

@@AnujGupta-pr5xo for me the concern is that u get offended just bcz anchor highlighted a weak point in Aap governance and u started accusing them as govts puppet(modi puppet). Brother it doesnt matter which party u support. They all are humans & they make mistakes. Aap has done alot of great work but the free ride it offers to women was completely illogical and its true. Women need security, panic buttons etc not free rides. This is the point panelist highlighted and u got offended. Be calm

[@AnujGupta-pr5xo]

@@Shaiva_Amit_Singh The Delhi police provides security which is under Home ministry that should be your concern. The Delhi govt has started installing of cctv cameras in Delhi. My colony is under cctv surveillance for improved women security. @Darshan Trivedi why don't you think it as one family. where if a poor woman gets the benefit of travelling free across Delhi the whole family of the woman gets the benefits not just her. And please don't forget that the free ride scheme is a voluntary scheme same as LPG subsidy scheme. Women that can afford buss tickets are welcome to do so.

[@bikkoo1990]

Aditi Phadnis was telling that women don't want freebies, they hv different priorities such as security, safety....Kejriwal wasn't listening though...

[@JMeaeavjaiad]

i wasted my time to seen this because they are misleading the show

[@sowmithrivinay749]

Only Tandon knows whether toilets, LPG etc. are freebies or not

[@livewithapurpose5651]

Toilets are not LPG is a freebie

[@mohmayakibaat8092]

But the lpg subsidy flows back to the public sector company. But giving tvs and preethi mixes don't.

[@singhrandeep7451]

Central govt and state govt must free all basic needs like necessary food ,electricity ,water health and education. Jo de rhe hain like AAP ,unko encourage to kya dena tha ulta tng kr rhe hain like bjp. Supreme court ko unke khilaf action lena chahiye jo vada krke bhi 5 saal me poora nhi krte. Economy will led down only if rich people doing corruption with help of polititians and doing tax chori ,,,,not because of Freebies .its not freebies its basic needs which must free and must be fundamental rights.

[@gautam161291]

Modiji provided freebie of lakhs of crores to farmers just before the elections as cash.At least state governments are providing freebies and subsidies in services like water,electricity etc.

[@dhriteesingh8805]

@Gautamkumar do you eat? You get food on your plate? Are you alive? Thank farmers.

[@caesar848]

Have you seen condition of farmers and how important are they for our food security?

[@gautam161291]

@@caesar848 And these freebies will make their condition way better,right? We all know what they need and it ain't freebies which will make them happy for short term only.

[@gautam161291]

@@dhriteesingh8805 well u know the answers of all the questions u asked.so i will ignore them. And yes i thank my father and other farmers everyday. And these are freebies which does nothing but short term treatment (even this is overstated) of poverty and not of agriculture problems of india.

[@parthachoudhury4332]

Today take freebies Tomorrow pay for it.

[@subodhvidyarthi907]

tondon spends most of time on praising modi. we are not here for that only

[@Godofschool]

What can u expect my friend ..all government do when they come in power 😂😂

[@socioconceptss]

Bhai is Tondon ko kyu bulate ho..Tondon is like one of my teacher who only advertises BJP in his half of the class

[@AmitKumartakecharge]

Vishal at times asks incoherent questions 😂

[@pavan0219]

Can you throw Tandan out of show, he is such a Chamcha of Modi.

[@ravindertalwar553]

I PRAY TO ALMIGHTY GOD 🙏🙏 FOR THE WELLBEING AND HAPPINESS FOR EVERYONE IN THE GLOBAL WORLD BASED ON LOVE, LIGHT, PEACEFUL COEXISTENCE,NON VIOLENCE AND JUSTICE FOR ALL IRRESPECTIVE OF CASTE, COLOUR,CREED, RACE,SEX,REGION OR RELIGION.

[@arunthattadath]

is it not possible to distinguish between goods and services.. free education is very different from free television

[@rushikeshamale8370]

Bring back Frank vishal is not good anchor There should not be any bias talk as Mr. Tondon has done.

[@anshikasingh6570]

In the mode of conduct and model code of conduct many things.. Are mentioned other than freebie which parties are prohibited to do but instead they partially break all the rules.... Atleast freebie lead people to get benefits atleast for some temporary period which they know; they won't get even if the bestest of best parties rules and at the same time people are well intellectual to know it's a trap and consequently choose the best of all

[@aspirant8996]

they are earning in lakhs of rupees and making hue and cry if 1000 rupees are spent for women mobility or power to poor. It is also mentioned in constitution to decrease the inequality in incomes should be the aim of the govt. of the day. 1000 rupees se to zyada tandon sir apne baalon ko colour karne me kharch dete honge, waise bhi inki umar sannyas lene ki hai faaltu ke discussion me apni zindagi barbaad kar rahe hain bhagwaan inko sadbuddhi den. next life me yahi aake sarkaar se free education maangenge.

[@Sukhiii.]

Waiting for frank to come back.

[@indiamusically]

RSTV, a mouthpiece of govt or a party? The electorate is watching. lol

[@Abhishek_Bhangta]

In my opinion freebies given to some section of society for the sake of winning elections is even not justifiable....as you are wasting hard earned money of tax payers..it is as if you are putting too much of load on those section of society who is working hard to earn money.. Few people will argue regarding delhi that there gdp is increasing and they are having better economic condition then few other states but still i believe that extra money could have been utiliesed properly by delhi govt....roads,railway,pollution were few areas where they could of utiliesed money

[@shahajkhan2442]

This is issue attract people so delhi government want that people are attract in this issue , i think its not a good idea

[@Himanshu.Harleyx440]

Reproduce more , increase illiteracy and vote in return of freebies...nexus between politicians and poor, illiterate people will ultimately cost a lot to all

[@subhranshusekhar7850]

The intro given by Frank perera has no comparison, please bring back Franc

[@aspirant8996]

Congress is going to apply NYAY scheme in Chhatisgarh and this is the future because no govt. can give job to everybody and jobs are declining in the age of mechanisation and AI and ML.

[@sshray1115]

Superb ✨

[@chitra7338]

Where is Frank? Why Vishal is hosting this show-the big picture???????

[@sivag991]

I'm from Tamilnadu 😂

[@livewithapurpose5651]

Kindly give your take on discussion

[@GauravSingh-hq9wg]

What you got as freebei

[@sivag991]

@@GauravSingh-hq9wg laptop, bicycle, bags,books,Pongal freebies,rice 30 kg free monthly, 100 unit power , television, agriculture power , regular education and farmers loan waiver, marriage gold and RS 50000,etc

[@sivag991]

@@livewithapurpose5651 decision have to based on the who got benefits from this.

[@livewithapurpose5651]

@@sivag991 many of these things like regular education are good for human development

[@amit99996]

Biased against AAP.... Anchor is focusing on freebies by aap only

[@livewithapurpose5651]

AAP is doing very good work in Delhi Health and Education But I think the scheme for free travel for women was not needed

[@amit99996]

@@livewithapurpose5651 I am also against any kind of free lunch... But the debate should also include loan waivers among others

[@livewithapurpose5651]

@@amit99996 Yes I agree Governments could have create good agricultural infrastructure covering farm to fork with the amount of loans which are written of

[@caesar848]

You seem butt hurt

[@britimajumder9137]

Where's Frank? Big picture is best with him

[@kr625]

Let the guest talk vishal... As always you talk more than guest...

[@ankur10227]

No talks on BJP freebie as if there is no freebie by BJP

[@pratapbhansinghchauhan3523]

Where is frank bhai???

[@rushikeshamale8370]

Why you are focusing on only AAP government. It is very good in terms of basic facilities Education and Health. BJP promises loan waiver on maharashtra and other states at front of election instead of doing basic thing good. Is it not freebies ? Don't try campaign for rulling party this is government entities and belong to all people.

[@AbhishekYadav-uj7id]

Dont interrupt within talk ....whare is Mr. Frank

[@tanyapatel562]

Isn’t this vishal Dahiya very distracting

[@jayshelke5096]

Sanjay Kumar Sir Thanks U Are Awesome.......😁😅 ♨️😄.....Thanks RS TV.......Jay Maharashtra.....😄♨️ Aditi Madam Also Thanks..... A Ashok Tondon Modi Ka Chela Hai.....He is BJP'S Puppy.....Isko Mat Bulawo

[@azadparinda9167]

chup

[@jayshelke5096]

@@azadparinda9167 .. CHAL be LAVDE ...GANDU

[@ananthu_m_a]

Bring Frank back pls..

[@shah9212]

Vishal dahiya is an anti-aap government and pro bjp seems, like.....the way he conducted this episode.

[@shah9212]

Ashok Tandon is pro bjp....😂😂😂

[@reshamwaghmare9961]

🙋🙋

[@SamyakJagtap]

6000/- by bjp

[@muktihomagain1368]

ROYAL BANK OF ASIA JOY HIND INDIA TO VICE PRESIDENT OF INDIA AND PRESIDENT OF INDIA

[@shantanusharma7034]

the anchor is not good at all.

[@SamyakJagtap]

Tandon 15lakh mil gaye lagta

[@aky57]

All leader are full for what they do,if any one is wise only and only BJP rulled States for what they do!!!!!

[@naveenbkgowda_malenadu]

Waste anchor of RSTV

[@RCDUP]

Vishal sucks..Frank can only do justice to big picture!!