The Big Picture: Naga Talks - Issues & Way Forward

[@danswrangbrahma975]

People of Nagaland may lost but Naga history haven't lost till today. We should think carefully and give their on stock. Let them enjoy their on life of freedom. Love Nagaland from Haryana.

[@Atsubrak]

Thanks for the support👍👍👍 ... Love from Nagaland

[@musicheals.3997]

@@Atsubrak love from Manipur Nagas.💙 Kuknalim.

[@rigakhing2832]

Love you all, From Nagaland

[@vezholhunyekha9960]

Thank you sir for your support..

[@dikhodeziio5136]

love from Naga

[@alishaabraham9164]

It is sad to see that there are no nagas on the platform when they themselves are being discussed.

[@balwantyadav1238]

@@maxedoutbeing3239 what do u want???

[@Change0005]

Alisha Abraham truly said.

[@firstsparkle5378]

This is just a discussion on issue.... Not judgement on naga people... Let's talk about content of discussion rather than panelists... If u think that something is missing from the discussion.. U can add it in comment section..

[@jimmykhrasi5028]

Rightly pointed.

[@robertnorah6616]

Bull's eye! Very unfortunate

[@jsjdhhd6702]

How are you discussing Naga issues without including any of their real representation. Here is the problem with us. West decides for East and East decides for West.

[@Change0005]

Jsj Dhhd true

[@firstsparkle5378]

This is just a discussion on issue.... Not judgement on naga people... Let's talk about content of discussion rather than panelists... If u think that something is missing from the discussion.. U can add it in comment section..

[@premchopra6519]

Non of them mentioned the fact that Naga territory was never under any Indian ruler from time immemorial. That it was the British who governed about half of the Naga land. And when India got it's independence from the British, Nagas also declared to the world that they would go back to being the free peoole that they were. But India sent armed forces and massacred lakhs of innocent Nagas which started the whole armed movement of the Nagas. So the same as India fought for Independence from the British, Nagas are also fighting for their freedom. Nagas were never the aggressors, it was India. And India need to acknowledge this fact instead of saying things like sovereignty is out of the question. What if the British also said sovereignty of India was out of the question? Indian leaders and media needs to be honest and humble. Let's not forget that India is the occupational force and the aggressors. Nagas never attacked any Indian state or threatened India in any manner. If we cherish our Bharat, let them also have their freedom!

[@mmjn97]

good point!

[@Atsubrak]

Rightly said 👍👍👍

[@rokuokesi3915]

Thank you for the good point... 👍

[@prashantjeetchowdhury634]

Shut up khalistani you did not mention about merapani war Golaghat mascare thousands of Aadivasi kill by Nagas how many Marwadi Bihar Bengali killed in Nagaland by militants

[@premchopra6519]

@@prashantjeetchowdhury634 You should ask Assam as to why they used Aadivasis as human shield to occupy land. As for those killed by militants, more Nagas have been killed by Naga militants than any other Indian citizen. These Bihari Bengali went to Nagaland on their own will knowing the situation very well. They knew the risk but went anyway. So don't vomit your narrow mindedness here.

[@musicheals.3997]

Dear brothers and sisters, I myself a Naga here. Let's not be misunderstand about this issue. By fighting to have separate flag and constitution or separate government doesn't meant that we hate India. We love India but there is a big reason behind why we are doing this for. We don't have any history about being under the rules of different tribes or countries Since time immemorial. We've been a sovereign people. Now we are under Indian govt. coz of force occupation. So now we are having a peace talk so that we can govern by ourself. Hope you will support us to Achieve it . Just briefing about the issue in a simple way. Thanks for reading. Good day.

[@Techtalkpathou]

Thats not a new story in the history. It happens all around the world and in India too. Not all the states were under the rule of so call India govt. Now should every states which were once a sovereign state should ask for a separate flag and constitution.????

[@musicheals.3997]

@@Techtalkpathou you got me wrong brother, the case is different here. Example regarding the state of Manipur, the state was also a sovereign state but the Maharaja, the ruler of the state people which is obviously the meitei people sign an agreement to be with Indian union. Before the force occupation on Nagas within India or before the creation of Manipur state including some Naga areas, the Naga people were living by themselves sovereignly. And we never agree to join with Indian Union unlike the Meiteis. We never wanted and chose to live under anybody. would you be ok to live under anybody since he or she has the ability to control over you when you don't want to. Why did India fought for freedom? It's the same So don't get confuse.

[@malemyensenbam7978]

@@musicheals.3997 The truth is oblivious to most people. The maharaja of manipur was forced to sign the treaty and everyone in manipur knows that. Do you even know the seperatist movement that has been going on in maniour for the past few decades demanding that we be freed from India ? You're not the only one. But we are not demanding territory from our neighbors like you guys are. That is just utterly disrespectful and wrong. You may argue that it is because there are naga inhabited lands in these neighboring states. But you should know that it is not just nagas that are residing in our state. There are numerous tribes and minor cultures in manipur that we cherish and preserve. The Naga tribe in manipur has been a part of this beautiful brotherhood for ages.

[@sauravdas7087]

Don't forget that before your naga nd tibeto _ Burman people entered India land , it were Hindus area . Nd why your nsgas drived away dimasa from Dimapur . So communist some nagas but not all . Be happy with facilities provided by our taxes from india

[@musicheals.3997]

@Neos Home Studio but why not Nagas of other states.? Didn't they treat you well or they treat you in the way you deserved.😁

[@Fzk2022]

We stand for Manipur... Long live Manipur

[@nishita7604]

Although I agree that integrity is necessary , but it is sad that this discussion is for Naga but no participants from Naga, we should also look for their point of view 😐

[@ChangNagaKundaBaba]

They are hiding the truth behind.. includes media..

[@blessinggangmei4580]

@@ChangNagaKundaBaba hAciJ+ZgbqiO0r7QsDjSQLIv8a08L4GJ+wN9fDEcVnVDHGFGxj6/I+rXgdQ/rRNx

[@Dragon94560]

Nishita Kumari this is what Ur government do.

[@firstsparkle5378]

This is just a discussion on issue.... Not judgement on naga people... Let's talk about content of discussion rather than panelists... If u think that something is missing from the discussion.. U can add it in comment section..

[@nishita7604]

@@Dragon94560 sir don't blame our government, it was just a discussion from an independent media🙏

[@shashiketan]

*114. NAGA ISSUE* • Demand for separate nation started with the formation of Naga National council - Insurgency • Naga people want to protect their dignity & their uniqueness in culture, language. • Demand for greater Nagalim in 1960’s - 1980’s • Cyclic process of violence & dialogue. In 2015, framework agreement was signed between GoI & NSCN-IM • Naga Constitution & flag is non-negotiable by their groups. Challenges & Realities • Multiple stakeholders spread across different states - different political groups, youth, Churches, civil societies. • Special status of Kashmir taken away: Separate constitution is out of question • Redrawing of boundaries is not possible & Nagas understand that. Way Forward: • Democratic perspective: include all stakeholders & political groups. • Integrating the Naga society. • autonomous governing council which can be beyond boundaries • Role of church could be more definitive: Naga mother’s association role has been positive. • Just like Mizoram National front - Naga groups should be included in the political process Any solution should be inclusive, honourable and acceptable to all sections of the people

[@v.happy_khushboo]

Thanks Concept is clear😋😊😊

[@MrHitchfan]

Very well elucidated for those preparing civil service exams.

[@Sandeeplayakvlogs]

Thank you sir

[@jysaj19]

Please translate Desh Desanthar discussion into English... Thank you

[@jeetk5663]

Thanks

[@jamesesper1826]

Thanks you Frank Rausan we need more of the this kind of respectful, issues- base conversation between people from different intellectual.

[@joshualons3483]

Naga nationalism movement started way back in the year 1918. The Naga Club submitted memorandum to Simon' Club in demand of creating separate Naga-land. But the devil designed attitude of Nehru had made Naga's suffer till today. Nehru must be in hell

[@Kidsfriendly-95]

May our Almighty God protect our Naga brothers and sisters from any harm and danger. Kuknalim.

[@therealcdert]

People of manipur want to know the truth real naga history and exact land boundaries of nagaland Indian shame for supporting insurgency groups

[@pongshingkonyak5789]

All the speaker talk honestly & in most perspective way that should be honoured & respected .

[@dilung20]

They should’ve included some naga intellectuals in the discussion so that others would be able to understand the issue in depth.

[@chetansingh86]

Yes gud point...... wat did they know about d under points of the issue

[@batoyhokha6607]

Sorry to say but I don't find any matured intellectuals in the Naga society

[@dilung20]

@@batoyhokha6607 maybe you could say that had you known the entire Nagas living in the country, but I doubt you hardly know a single Naga. Just because you don't get to see us on tvs doesn't mean that we're incapable, but it's because the media houses do not give us the privilege.

[@batoyhokha6607]

@@dilung20 this is your mentality towards the mainlanders. U know what?? I've been there in nagaland for more than a decade.. Please stop considering us as if we knew nothing about your state Nagaland and your people. Grow up kid

[@dilung20]

Bato Joo ohh well maybe the entire time was spent in your room then. You should’ve gone out and interacted more with people. Maybe you should’ve met me before you left the place. To be frank, staying in someone’s place don’t guarantee that you’ll know everything about them. And talking about mentality, you first rectify yours about my people and come back. You maybe old in age but you’re no better than a primary student.

[@mentiaier9708]

So an Indian has better understanding and in-depth knowledge about the Naga issue? Why aren’t there any Naga intellectuals on the panel?

[@Sanatani_kattar]

Indian? is not naga people are Indian? but i agree with you there should be a Naga in this panel

[@johnchinirmoyon2245]

Nagas are not asking or requesting India to give freedom but to respect the dignity and sovereignty of Nagas, remember Nagas are not Indian. Forcefully occupied by Indian military force.

[@Sk-ct8fp]

Seriously seriously man, you seems to talk with a lunatic state of mind,this great india is one such nation in the world where minorities enjoy more rights than the majority,nagaland has been flooded with central fund,reservation ,and nagas being in nation service such IAS,IPS and various A class services,u think all this could have been done without being indian ,seriously!infact you should be proud enough to be indian.If u could give up all these then you might be capable enough to quote whatsoever u want,u want to enjoy all the benefit and sametime not proclaimed that.u seems to lack the basic history and knowledge,please brush up those.

[@shenmankonyak4319]

@@Sk-ct8fp before Independence didn't Indians hold any official posts under British rule?? Why didn't Indian nationalists choose to give up all the benefits of English and fight for complete swaraj? It's simple because Indians are not English.. That's the same case with us. Nagas are not Indians.

[@abhaokip]

Ha3

[@younggunsuyansh5235]

Really funny...naga,lol

[@funfact9715]

@@Sk-ct8fp you aren't even a Naga to interfere in our issue why don't you just mind your own fucking business.. Whatever we Nagas are doing is at our best and to protect and safeguard the customary rights and culture of nagas.. Because we are completely different from Indians in terms of culture, religion practice, and other custom so it is sole birthright of us to be free from external aggression though not completely a separate nation in terms of sovereignty but atleast with a different constitution and flag which will be used by the nagas and its right and unique identity will be preserved and forever put into practice so that our root, culture,won't go lost in vain Understand!? You alien nerd

[@thakuranuraganand738]

Pointless discussion without Naga representatives in the debate. This is really distasteful.

[@thakuranuraganand738]

@@finding.nirvana Funny that you think the only qualification to watch these debates is to kknow everything in advance xD

[@lungan7704]

Have you guys forgotten about what MAHATMA GHANDHI says "Nagas have every right to be independent “. Will India just leave us alone.

[@vahboihaokip3684]

if you say that then everyone has the right to say.

[@lungan7704]

@@vahboihaokip3684 brother from kuki tribe.... Gandhi not just someone. He's the father of nation, who fought with non violence and knows who the nagas are.

[@lungan7704]

@Miku Kumar then u should be shameful if u dont respect him. You're enjoying the fruit of his work yet u didn't respect him.

[@interestingfact7788]

brother, calture,identity, etc is only political issue..some one gain power..but common people are influated by this word. and saffer more....so please demand only devolpment....,infustructure,etc...so every naga was happy..but calture,identity not full human satisfaction or desire...but full fill of some political power..you are naver given nothing..

[@thangjamboriskhanganba3588]

Why Naga peoples are so greedy on land ?.. U people don't have any place to shelter or what.

[@geographybynirmalendu8444]

Honour of Naga people is honour of union of India so it must be kept in topmost priority...

[@Kangshou_Chang]

Just like you are discussing about Nagas without any Naga, India took decision to include nagas with India and some went to Burma without our consent 70+ years back.

[@yog-sadhna3415]

We were partitioned without our consent. We lost our 5000 year old land to pakistan.

[@indiafirst.90]

I respect Naga culture,History but,We are all one.

[@itzy_ft_pika9631]

How so ? Were one?

[@indiafirst.90]

@@itzy_ft_pika9631 mam we believe in vasudaiva kutumbakam.

[@itzy_ft_pika9631]

@@indiafirst.90 I respect what you think But We Naga were never Indian or never will be you should understand that if your civilized enough

[@indiafirst.90]

@@itzy_ft_pika9631 mam,Catalonia and bosque in Spain,Hong Kong in China, North Karnataka in India they also raised same issue,We should think like a whole universe is one mam,not only World. It's all about your perspective mam.bye

[@itzy_ft_pika9631]

@@indiafirst.90 don't compare us with others if u don't know our history Other they were itself of their own country But we Naga are not

[@ardydorjee5982]

First of all this discussion was about the North-east but I didn't see any Northeast people giving their views on the topic. It's totally insane and indigestible. Good job guys keep it up👍👍👍

[@mymusicchannel2668]

Why Naga should not have their own National Flag and Constitution....It's the choice of Naga, we nagas never make any agreement to join the Indian. We have our history and that history is not lost. Just imagine, if the earth could talk, the water could speak and the beautiful mountain and the sky could talk in Naga , am sure they will say, we want naga nation and would want to live as one.

[@IMN-r5w]

Lol...

[@Abijitdebnath813]

This land not belong to u it's my mother land if u want A country go to China

[@mymusicchannel2668]

@@Abijitdebnath813 Am so shock to hear your ignorance. Please read history before you reply me and let me know.

[@IMN-r5w]

@@Abijitdebnath813 well said..

[@vahboihaokip3684]

Everyone has the right to say that and if everyone gets what they want then their will be another war.

[@somenningthoujam9111]

We are not jealous and also accept to stay in peace (people of nagaland)...but we didn't accept for taking piece of other neighbouring state in the name of nagas peace talk.... And why do you need other state piece? We also want to stay in our own..... We also love your history but in the name of that don't try to take advantages...

[@esthermashangva838]

Try to bring greater development reaching every corner and see the change. Let's be more practical. Give the share which was due. Many uneducated are still under the spell of few vested interest. As the talk goes on development should follow along.

[@PKNEHAL1]

happy to watch this big picture of NAGALAND'S NEGOTIATIONS

[@avinaga21]

I don't understand what do you mean by saying this, "what can be given to Naga people to preserve their unique culture, language etc.?, When we already owned it and does not need to ask or beg for" we are asking our freedom as to which was already ours, we are asking Back to give us the freedom that was taken from us. And yes we are very proud of our rich culture and heritage. Free us, we are not Indians so no need to exaggerate so much on this. Don't tell us that we Nagas need to understand, instead we tell you to understand that we are not Indians, we have different culture, we have our own flag and we need our freedom.

[@YuvaKishore242]

*Kashmir wants separation based on religion ie islam* *Even Nagaland, mizoram wants separation based on religion ie Christianity* *So we have to fear about massive Christian conversions in India, converting poor Hindus in every section* *The interesting issue here is nobody wants to convert to other cool religions of this land like Buddhism or jainism or Sikhism* *Majority convert in to the religions which are not from this land.. may be because of money received from foreign in the form of NGOs and finally they will ask for separation from India based on religion😬😬* *Let's see where it all takes😊*

[@openmind2681]

Naga tribes itself controll by vetican christein missionaries,which are working with islamist as well naxalite.. Banned vetican churches from india..

[@YuvaKishore242]

@@Thatwasawesome07 *By the way, which state lost it's identity by joining India* *In Maharashtra, they say they were Indians first and proud marathas next, they did not lost their identity even after 72 years* *Even in kerela they they saw the same thing* *Did punjab loss their identity as Sikhs according to you? Who are only 1.7% in population* *Which state loss their identity by joining india according to you in this 72 years if it is not religion*

[@YuvaKishore242]

@@Thatwasawesome07 *It's not about nagas, if I keep all the Christians in one state, I am 100% sure they will ask for separate nation* *Samething with Muslims too. If I keep all the Muslims in India in one state, I am 100% sure they will ask separate nation and Islamic countries will support them too by saying Indian army is killing them* *It's not about identity because no state in India have lost it's identity even after 72 years, it's all about religion* *We will be happy if you join India, if not we would be still happy, to realize, the essence of religion in forming an identity*

[@YuvaKishore242]

@@Thatwasawesome07 *Sikkim is also not a part of India it joined in 1960s. Haven't lost its identity still yet and I guess will not lost in future too. If you are really concerned about identity*

[@YuvaKishore242]

@@Thatwasawesome07 *All the best bro, fight till the end and succeed in getting separate nation in the name of identity* *Then only the Indian government will ban foreign Christian missionaries from converting poor Indians and after then injecting hatred on Hinduism in the name of idol worshippers are SATANS and they will go to hell similar to ISLAM* *Your fight should be an eye opening to Indian government. ALL THE BEST*

[@thon2226]

We Nagas want freedom ,our rights, our flag, our constitution ... Not under your indian union!!

[@tathagatamukherjee5794]

@@balwantyadav1238 😁🤣

[@gaidinkamei8462]

@@balwantyadav1238 First of all, Nagas are not immigrants who came from foreign land to settle in India. The Nagas were there in Nagaland as their homeland before India got independence. When India got independence from Brits, Nagaland was included in India so as many northeastern states. They are just demanding an exit from Indian Nationality. So, there is no Madar to be Chod about. I also don't care much about their demand for independence but i protest against greater nagaland territory.

[@thon2226]

@@balwantyadav1238 what are you saying??? Don't jumble mumble in ur stupid native language.

[@chingmakchang8074]

@@balwantyadav1238,👈this kind of rats always interfare without knowing any ,just to make misunderstanding.SMALL BRAIN

[@rajkumardiamondton]

@@thon2226 lwra School ja ke hunting krne jayega to kaha se English samjemz me ayega!

[@MP-jg5kn]

Even being am Naga , and I don't want to separate with India but when some Indian claims Naga land is for Indian mother land is totally wrong. Because in olden days there is not a separate country ,we stay by kingdoms by kingdoms then British came and we fight the same freedom from British and British declare 14th August Naga independent , Pakistan 14th August and in 15th August India got independent. But the Indian government capture the area of Naga land and now we are asking our own rights. What's the problem??

[@asbmbs5530]

You can only ask for rights when you are independent and sustainable. Right now you depend on India for everything, infact like bhutan.

[@rohitroll2119]

All my Naga friends are proud of their culture and are greatly patriotic. So I don't understand such separatist movements.

[@wibonbouabonmai9536]

Making 31st October as dateline is nothing but an ultimatum and imposition. This wouldn't work in Nagalim.

[@Aryan-iu9ck]

It's naga people choice for how long they want to extend this issue bcoz goi has alot of time, they want solution not bloodshed so they will again extend the deadline!!

[@asbmbs5530]

Yes , it will never work.

[@vekutetseo8914]

The mechanical stance of Mr. Phukan reflects his ignorance and prejudice towards Nagas. If one have to go as per your perspective, then there's no and cannot be any viable solution.... If Mr. Phukan doesn't know well about the Naga political issue then he should have decline to be in the panel in the first place . .....

[@achingzeemeek2768]

What they discussed here is not what the Naga feel about the issues but what they think the Naga think about the issues and thats where the difference is.

[@lungan7704]

And this situation is not about development, its about sovereignty and integrity, not development.

[@lungan7704]

@yogesh pal that's true brother you're not wrong but here's the thing we want to work things out by ourselves. Whether its easy or tough we want to sort things out as a people of greater nagalim.

[@rajeshdubey6030]

India has a federal setup of Governance where centre and state both shares power to Govern ....In return ,All the states are benefitted as people get to enjoy resources of the entire union rather than the state alone ..Nagas are already given autonomy , Exclusive rights to not be interfered by Indians from other states while Nagas themselves can settle in any part of India and they also get the shares of taxes from other states for the development of their own state along with right to chose government both in centre and in their state along with the say in Governance ..The Chief Minister and its party members are Nagas ..Indian army protects the border of Nagaland and so are Naga Flags respected ..Nagas themselves gets fundamental rights that are availed to all Indian citizens and are treated equal to others ..Plus they also get reservations in Government jobs due to them being tribals ...Central Government is also allowing insurgent groups like NSCN to speak on the issue and is listening to them ...I believe Nagas are getting more than they deserve being part of Union of India ..Should it not be the responsibility of Nagas to ensure that they altleast respect the territorial integrity of Union of India which is willing to listen to them and treat them as equals rather than being greedy for piece of land and fighting for the sake of pride ... The relation between India and Nagaland is symbiotic ,not of a conqueror where people are repressed ,Discriminated and their resources looted ... It's time that Naga people also act maturely ,Fighting for the sake of pride rather than better future in which Nagas can live with respect and dignity with rest of India surely is a far better prospect ...

[@lungan7704]

@@rajeshdubey6030 You don't understand at all. Please redefine yourself the meaning of living with dignity. Imagine someone rule over your family by force and they took all your family properties but they allow you to live as it is, since killing you all will be consider as crime. Won't you like to get out from their rule and live your life?

[@rajeshdubey6030]

@@lungan7704 India is a Union not an empire which rules over other states ...We have a federal setup where States and centre shares power and the citizens are assured basic fundamental rights like right to freedom of speech ,protection of culture , Right to elect ones own Government ,form political parties etc ..Nagas are guaranteed all of the above things which a common Indian citizens get and even more ..I do agree that we should not have annexed Nagaland but that time is long past and instead of looking in past Nagas should work with Indian government for better future and peace .... Government of India is willing to listen to Nagaland and so should Naga people listen to Government of India rather than making it a matter of pride ...If Nagas cooperate then like Mizoram they too can earn fruits of better development and a long lasting peace

[@lungan7704]

@@rajeshdubey6030 We the naga has never Surrender ourselves to join the union, so it can be considered as government of India rules over NAGAS. GoI rules NAGAS democratically. If we agreed or surrender ourselves to join the union it would be a different story. Yes indeed we are guaranteed with all the benefits you mention above, but that's a part of political system. Since India is a democratic country she cannot left the NAGAS out from the benefits you mention above, if she do so world will know that its not how democracy work. One thing India did wrong as a democratic country is that she fail to listen to the voice of the NAGAS. WE THE NAGAS NEVER AGREED TO JOIN THE UNION OF INDIA AND WE NEVER SURRENDER TO INDIA BUT SHE TOOK THE NAGAS BY FORCE TO JOIN THE UNION.

[@luwang6136]

well discussed.. and govt of INDIA should never ignore the true history of MANIPUR ..and leader of NSCN IM is an indigenous Manipuri..based on facts and written history ..solution of NAGA should not disturb the interest of Manipur integrity and its peace at any cost..Manipur had a history as an independent nation of 2000 long years before INDIA as a nation exist. which can never be denied by the world based on facts, reality and historical proofs...

[@shonyohoram9044]

Yes exactly, you Meiteis should stay in your lovely land Imphal, stop putting your nose around Nagalim. Btw nobody gives a damn about your opinion. We are fighting for our cause which have nothing to do with Meiteis. KUKNALIM

[@shonyohoram9044]

We don’t want inch an beyond Naga hills, but don’t sniff around with your nasty and selfish interest in our issue for your betterment

[@empoweringyouththroughknow727]

Naga are the one who want someone's place claiming as there. Have some respect about urself

[@luwang6136]

@@shonyohoram9044NAGALIM!!! hahaha born in 1980 through MUIVA a victim of untouchability!!!! ...Boy MANIPUR/KANGLEIPAK as an independent country/kingdom exist before INDIA as a nation exist..based on all historical facts..naga is the word given by british to identify naked hillsmen...no offence.. its fact.. based on historical records of both india govt and british empire .Manipur boundaries include Kabaw valley present Myanmar until 1952 that too given away by indian prime minister Jawaharlal Nehru...and read some true histories not distorted histories...

[@luwang6136]

@@shonyohoram9044 Manipur boundary before merging into India exist with a historical records of more than 1000 years its far greater than the present boundary...Manipur was a nation... comparing hills which was never once a country with a definite ruler but rather inhabited by various tribes speaking different dialects and manipur will be like stone vs egg...

[@seonaga684]

Thank you everyone for ur concern and continues support for naga political issues

[@shreyasdethe9386]

Can you please tell what's happening not just in nagaland but in whole northeast ????

[@mktoalim1164]

Nagas will never be Indian in our hearts.

[@Sanatani_kattar]

i m from delhi Noida , and i love Naga people meetie kuki etc every Indian

[@nelsonkhwairakpamii2261]

See people's stop saying we are Indians2 and act like different species, let's say if Naga stays in some parts of all the Indian state and they tried to claim the place where they lived would you allow them to claim all the place where they lived think people's. This is just the small part. Long live Manipur

[@rajeshdubey6030]

India has a federal setup of Governance where centre and state both shares power to Govern ....In return ,All the states are benefitted as people get to enjoy resources of the entire union rather than the state alone ..Nagas are already given autonomy , Exclusive rights to not be interfered by Indians from other states while Nagas themselves can settle in any part of India and they also get the shares of taxes from other states for the development of their own state along with right to chose government both in centre and in their state along with the say in Governance ..The Chief Minister and its party members are Nagas ..Indian army protects the border of Nagaland and so are Naga Flags respected ..Nagas themselves gets fundamental rights that are availed to all Indian citizens and are treated equal to others ..Plus they also get reservations in Government jobs due to them being tribals ...Central Government is also allowing insurgent groups like NSCN to speak on the issue and is listening to them ...I believe Nagas are getting more than they deserve being part of Union of India ..Should it not be the responsibility of Nagas to ensure that they altleast respect the territorial integrity of Union of India which is willing to listen to them and treat them as equals rather than being greedy for piece of land and fighting for the sake of pride ... The relation between India and Nagaland is symbiotic ,not of a conqueror where people are repressed ,Discriminated and their resources looted ... It's time that Naga people also act maturely ,Fighting for the sake of pride rather than better future in which Nagas can live with respect and dignity with rest of India surely is a far better prospect ...

[@nelsonkhwairakpamii2261]

Earning their flags, we give such a respect to that Bruhhh but That hippi NSCN(IM) TRY TO OVERUN ON OUR Manipur States that what people of Manipur disagreed to that and also , they being so selfish to claim our land . And being the Citizens of India sometimes i regrets coz we being used like a slaves remember and keep this in your head when things changes we would shed every last drops of blood that run through our Body , It's better to die than to be a black Inadian Mamba slaves .

[@rajeshdubey6030]

@@nelsonkhwairakpamii2261 how are Manipuris treated as slaves ? Do you even know the meaning of the word slavery ? Are Manipuris subjected to hardship without any compensation or rights ? Please talk sense and don't show racism ..Manipuri tribes get reservations in jobs which even we Indians don't get ,They can settle in any part of India while we can't settle in Manipur ,They get autonomy to govern and right to vote and elect central and state Governments ...How is this slavery when you get more rights than a normal Indian citizens ?

[@DudeApril]

Naga people are great people they will have congruence with indian govt and their honour dignified

[@lizzzylee7828]

Gautam sir church is playing the key role almost a decade ..I wonder why not a single intellectual of the Naga are included in the debate they can tell the issue in depth ..

[@Techtalkpathou]

Naga should go for separate Country. Which country will accept 2 flags 2 Constitution in a single country.?????

[@chubalongchar71]

Not that all Nagas want freedom, or are expecting freedom, but all Indians must know that Nagaland was never a part of India. Nagalim was only taken as a colonial bounty by the Indians.

[@jimmykhrasi5028]

Indian government should respect the history of the nagas.

[@Kho_Lee]

The very fact that they have not included a Naga in the panel shows how much of sentivity they have towards the nagas. From the beginning till today, India has not taken the Naga issue seriously. The haphazard FA is not going to solve the problem.

[@PRAWALKAKATI]

Why not a single Naga in the studio 🤔

[@firstsparkle5378]

This is just a discussion on issue.... Not judgement on naga people... Let's talk about content of discussion rather than panelists... If u think that something is missing from the discussion.. U can add it in comment section..

[@kapilnunisa3769]

Few years back NSCN IM crossed the Dhansiri river (border between Assam n Nagaland) n camped in the Dimasa village n warned people to leave the village immediately. Villagers fleed n for many days there was a sand off between Assam police n NSCN IM. The encroachment ended after intense gunfight, district magistrate from Karbi Anglong was shot by a sniper n several NSCN cadres were also killed. Even today hundreds of acres of land of Karbi Anglong has been encroached by Nagaland near Dilai n Dimapur. They usually comes at night n clear the forest bringing JCB n other machines to cut trees.

[@ponglihwancho9990]

Mr.shekhar Iyer it's not Mizoram it's Naga from Arunachal you miss out Naga from Arunachal

[@khotodovih2469]

Naga history is very well known by the GOI and the world. The true and it's old geographical history much known better by Indian. We respected Indian as our own parent. Indian known how to do and how to live for their son's future lie in the hand of our parent Indian.

[@ngasepammangal70]

Do the framework within Nagaland. Manipur will not oppose to that but if India attempt to distort our unique history of MANIPUR. That will be most sad day for the both sides. In manipur if u found any document of Naga pliz bring in out. July 11 2001 recognition of Naga unique history should only confine to Nagaland.

[@Revotech123]

If you can carve out andrapradesh n create telengana! Why is it impossible to carve a new nagaland?

[@prashantjeetchowdhury634]

Telangana is not a separate country

[@Revotech123]

@@prashantjeetchowdhury634 when did i say telangana is a country?? It is a state i'm very much aware of it!

[@prashantjeetchowdhury634]

Can you explain me about new Nagaland what is new Nagaland can you explain me if you don't mind

[@prashantjeetchowdhury634]

@@Revotech123 this is not possible as you think this is not singer matter of Naga freedom its about greater Nagaland Naga claim some part of Arunachal Pradesh and certain part of Assam and Manipur ok are you say Manipur Arunachal Assam this 3 states going to agree on this issue according to British since 1947 only Naga Hills belong to Naga now this issue become very critical like east Pakistan West Pakistan

[@Revotech123]

@@prashantjeetchowdhury634 what i mean by new nagaland is integration of all naga inhabited lands. If the indian constitution has a provision where the state boundries can be altered, like in the case of andrapradesh being carved out n creating a new state like telangana. Why is it so hard to integrate all the parts of nagas historical land under one administration? All three stakeholders like manipur, assam and arunachal comes under the indian constitution so its really upto the GOVT OF INDIA!

[@alenghungyootsutsuki3310]

Not A Single Naga In Discussion And They Think They Will Know The Issue And Problems What A Joke..

[@augustinemerry4242]

Without flag and constitution is never honourable solution

[@Techtalkpathou]

Better to form a separate country

[@IMN-r5w]

My foot😂😂😂😂

[@nir4320]

Just don’t be so stupid . Do you think all the states should have its own separate flag and nation¿

[@rohitroll2119]

We Bengalis are proud of our culture. We don't want a separate flag or Constitution.

[@Kaomei21]

Why do some of the panellists say the honour of the naga people should “appear” to be protected in this agreement? Why should it only APPEAR to be protected? It can be taken to mean that the Nagas are simple people and can be fooled into thinking that, when it really is not. Semantics, but it matters.

[@moseskamei]

Noted

[@islandsunset]

2 minutes in and I realize that no expert is actually from Nagaland or Manipur. At least having them should have crossed your minds. They are going to be affected by the Accord. They could've conveyed what those people think.

[@SS-hw1ou]

You can inform on twitter channel they're more active there

[@merenpongen3966]

That’s what I was about to point out... glad you did!

[@magnetkhuraijam7698]

Who is Naga? How can you defines you are Naga? The problem starts from here, the obvious definition. And atlast there are no Nagas, it's just a imaginary preconceived idea.

[@Headup987]

It seem u still r a baby in this issue ...sit back n shut up don't asked a question that tell u r stupid.

[@aqiuvlog4740]

Lunatic person

[@khunonokyen2464]

If u don't know about this issue shut up

[@ChangNagaKundaBaba]

Why are you hiding this truth??

[@ashangmuinso2673]

Nagas issue is not an insurgency problem like that of chattisgarth. You should know this first if you talk of Naga issue. You should rather address with some honor and understand the pulse of Nagas. It's an issue of Naga Nationalism. Better use Naga Nationalist rather than insurgent. It is the Indian Government who messed the Nagas issues.

[@miteshpandey989]

Is this why people of Manipur voted for BJP to make them watch this day??????Dear BJP govt. people of entire northeast is against this Naga accord.. These Nagas are really a big burden to the nation....they are people with such a radical mentality...they are no less than any terrorist who only knows how to create havoc and disturbance in the society.. and I hope u aslo also know the fact how these Nagas are, because tomorrow they will become a big headache for you itself if u listen to them today... Its an utmost request to the BJP government to reject all the pleas of these Nagas and better focus on the development of the nation....because if today u accept any of their proposals, tomorrow they will demand for more and ask for their own country....u can see how they have created such an agitation by destroying the peace and harmony of Manipur.Don't get persuaded by any of their cunning moves... Its a call for every tribes living in Manipur to unite for the sake our beautiful motherland and stand against these Nagas and condemn their worthless demands.Jai hind, Long live Manipur.

[@paulphelps7809]

How about a transition time allowed toward any new agreement.

[@baden_sg_naga6694]

Mizoram and Nagaland cannot be compared.... long live Nagalim

[@overratedspeciesspecies6195]

What do you meant by " appear to be honourable solution or preceived to be respectable" ?? What about real honourable and respectable solution? Disappointing!

[@firstsparkle5378]

Here appear to means... It should be felt by everyone..

[@ashwin0309]

Good that u brought The Hindu Deputy Editor in panel. Now ask him why he writes rubbish articles esp. about Article 370.

[@akakichu5156]

We love India.. we are Indians even if we are nagas our flag doesn't meant that we are not indian let's stop searching for old stories it's 2019 thank you bless india

[@shanusahay1897]

Which article will be considered here only article 3 which read only internal adjustment or also 4 which says admission of new state and establishment of new states. As because large tract of Myanmar is also demanded to constitute into greater Nagalim

[@googleyahoo2663]

I will live with dignity rather then live without it. Long live Nagalim.

[@iasdreamtech828]

Very nice discussion in big picture

[@kolviczd6885]

There cannot be any honorable solution for Nagas if India take only contemporaries issues into perspectives. First of all, India need to understand and honour the history of Nagas and why Naga insurgency issue is the oldest in Indian history. Naga Issue is as old as India's Independence or even older, in fact Nagas have even declared themselves an independent nation one day ahead of India i.e, on 14 August 1947. It was only been gradually enacted into Indian union in the later years but that too without the will of all the nagas, and that is the reason why naga insurgency still exist to date. Their demands are legitimate and historical and they are not looking for some special packages here and there, India needs be very clear on that. Also, India should realized that Nagas have narrowed down their demand from a separate independent nation to now Nagalim/integration of all nagas under one administrative unit within Indian Union, that is a lot that they've compromised on their part, so India should also reciprocate by granting them their second wish. It is not easy to redraw the already existing states of India but not impossible if Article 3 of Indian Constitution is invoke. Remember Telangana state was created from AP in 2014 using the same provision and authority of the constitution, why not Nagalim then?

[@rajeshdubey6030]

It's not Government of India's prerogative to force other North east states to give up their part of territory to Nagaland ...At best Government can allow NSCN IM to talk to other states and if they are ready to secede their territories for nagalim than Government can change the map accordingly ...Its all upto NSCN IM and Naga people to convince other states to give up their part of territory for the sake of Nagaland

[@mercy3095]

Nicely Stated, we need to take the word of every group (all the stakeholder)in the state from younger to women to the elders to leaders, as it's about Peace, development, honour and integrity of the State, and that Honour of Nagaland People is also the Honour of the Indian Union,

[@senphakonyak7632]

One of the panelist should be a Naga to have fair and meaningful discussion thats what I feel

[@liangkiumarenmai1484]

Well I really appreciate the BIG PICTURE being taken this naga issue on their show but why don't you include some Naga Intellectuals who can really share the ground reality of our Land and History.I know the penalist are well learned people but they have just read the story and sharing their powerful thoughts but it will be better if a person from Nagaland share the opinion on the issue as well so that the discussion could've have been in better way though it was good to learn penalist thoughts as well.

[@freshfingers2168]

After 70 years they couldn’t conclude n they r trying to conclude in 30 mins🙏🙏🙏just wow

[@sauravdas7087]

Can't see it's a discussion

[@lifetalks.5149]

How are you even discussing without the involvement of any Naga panel???

[@alenghungyootsutsuki3310]

This Is The Only Opinion Of Indains Not Naga..

[@sauravdas7087]

Who the hell r you all to capture Assam nd Manipur

[@alenghungyootsutsuki3310]

@@sauravdas7087 We Are Only Taking Whats Ours?

[@sauravdas7087]

@@alenghungyootsutsuki3310 we all r indian. We r proud of nagas nd all community.

[@sauravdas7087]

@@alenghungyootsutsuki3310 who r you to talk about dividing Manipur

[@alenghungyootsutsuki3310]

Lol Thats My Line Who Are You To Judge Us When U Don't Even Know Your Own History.

[@wibonbouabonmai9536]

I hear no fire in the discussion 🔥😂

[@exploringthenaturesks4296]

Why don't you take worst situations of Manipur? Sir, you have lacked of knowledge about Manipur. At first you solved the worst situations of Manipur then you will finish other issues in North east. Why do you focus on naga? Why don't you discuss about meger agreement of Manipur?

[@priyankaj.6498]

There's no point in arguing for a sovereign state , it won't be able to survive. Most importantly, the govt. Should give more focus on the development of whole northeast area, and give them the security of cultural and ethnical preservance. If Tamils, Punjabis, Biharis...can live together in a country why not them ?

[@jeetk5663]

Sandeep Phukan's points are enriching

[@elijahchahum]

They don have broad knowledge about Naga political talks with GOI

[@namreilungjacobnewme5192]

Your discussion doesn't make any sense...........how can u discuss about naga issue without knowing there through colour......u can discuss naga issues only after u hve stay in nagalnd for a year(i mean now there culture ,Identity, n so on) or your team is not eligible to discuss.

[@ardydorjee5982]

Nooo...... we are not at all ready to compromise with Nagaland regarding the territorial rights of ARUNACHAL PRADESH and we are happy that Nagaland will at last be free of violence

[@babagaya7079]

That's why you people killed Gandhi coz he was about to set the nagas free....

[@aquariusgandhiji52]

phukan should be allowed to defined who nagas really are ....to what extend he knows about the history of Nagas...what is honourable and inclusive solution ???..... Answer : He is not qualified enough to here in this issue.

[@alaiglai3821]

Tirap, changlang and longding districts ( TCL three districts) of Arunachal Pradesh India doesn't want to involve in NAGA Accord because we are not a NAGA people. We are a Arunachalees. Tirap changlang and longding districts of Arunachal Pradesh should not involved in NAGA Accord.

[@legally1516]

Sir ye topic hindi main bhi layye please so useful upsc aspirants please

[@RepublicIAS18]

Tab tak aap 4 or 5 august 2015 ka desh deshanter dekhe....😊

[@sapriinagrace9658]

may be they are educated enough but the drawback is I see No Naga!

[@DKWorld2]

The Mainland of India (consists of Arunachal from East to Pakistan at West & J&k From North to Kanyakumari at South) was part of Africa since Jurasic period. Faults began to appear and India got separated from Africa 150 million years ago.. *At Palogene Period (30 million years ago) India collided with Eurasia plate and the young fold mountains (The Great Himalaya) originated which kept Indian mainland unique.. Pakistan separated from its Big Brother in 1947(upon some narrow concerns). We liberated Bangladesh from Pakistan and make it a new nation. Nagaland was within India, is within India and will be also...IF somebody wants something extra, he can leave our India.... May god fulfill his/her wishes outside our India...Vande mataram.. 🇮🇳

[@Naosoofficial]

Nagas were never indians and will never be

[@adahriirii1915]

This discussion is pointless because there is no owner who knows the story & history!! There should atleast two Nagas to talk & share the stories & motive

[@IMN-r5w]

They don't have distinct language... Please don't say unique.. Nagaland people can only communicate to each other .. nagas in Manipur they can't communicate to each other.. and you say they have distinct language?...

[@pougaigangmei2222]

Who the hell are you to decide.? The Indian govt have recognize it.

[@IMN-r5w]

@@pougaigangmei2222 why so mad...??? Am speaking the truth..hahhaha........

[@pougaigangmei2222]

@@IMN-r5w what is distinct language? Our Uniqueness is base on our culture and traditions. We are one so sorry haters 😎😎😎😎

[@mktoalim1164]

Gautam sen for your information Nagas have a national Flag as a whole

[@axligooner]

ULFA FOLLWED BY NSCN, will take on aginst Indian Occupation

[@JPTVIDEOS4U]

My fav show

[@avinaga21]

Oh please, what a discussion, we aren't stupid to not understand what this discussion is leading towards. Please stop fooling yourself. Don't know what you all trying to portray here...

[@anyonecansee8167]

Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland Free Nagaland

[@shedu6078]

A naga panelist should have been included jus to make sure this discussion doesn't look like an all white Simon Commission (1929) of the British era as the subject of discussion is all about the Nagas. Im not undermining any of the expert panelists but one of our naga brothers on the panel would hav been very inclusive n representative.

[@amarjitsharma2607]

Why only Nagas are concerned in dealing the naga issues? If it doesn't effect the interest of other commodities and neighboring states there is no problem at all but the questions are how could it be possible without affecting the interest of the manipures, asamese, arunachalies etc. These states have their own unique histories which is much older than the nagas. NAGAS are created by the British. Present issue is also one of the issues left by them when they left India. It seems non of the panelist are aware of the real issues. One should not be one sided.

[@amarjitsharma2607]

Communities

[@putinmodi3755]

Make nagaland free country...after one monthThey will fight among themself.. And break into 4 to 5 different state.. Haha. Thats the realities....

[@demlinnalo2030]

🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾🖕🏾

[@akshaybhosle7078]

GD like debate.... I agree with u ..

[@ruokuovituotheunuo3983]

Solving the naga problems means solving the insurgency problem in north east or naxalite because there will be no more weapons suppliers