The Big Picture - Privatisation of Public Sector Enterprises

[@amt4095]

Kindly check the sound quality of all the panelists before starting the discussions.

[@neelampol0658]

Really 👍 The rest of members are more or less fine but Charan Singh's voice completely useless 😅

[@ankeshsh9211]

If rajya sabha will not improve sound quality .. In near future it will also be privatised to zee news aur aajtak 😊😊🤣🤣🤣

[@discipline1255]

😂😂

[@prateekkumar6295]

Ndtv 😋

[@neelampol0658]

There is more possibility of occur it😅

[@ansyjohn7911]

Adding subtitles would help . At times it’s difficult to follow what the panellist are saying

[@venugopal6446]

Switch on caption while video running

[@ritamverma8833]

Yeah right

[@nipuntyagi279]

Privatisation is more about reforms, not about running business - What a Statement

[@mithunc1202]

Private sector enterprises is also making huge debt and they're looting us. No one has any social responsibility or accountability to the public. But as far as public sector enterprises are concerned it's the people who're controlling the enterprises.. If people want some voice, enterprises should continue to be public sector enterprise..What is your opinion about recent yes bank debacle?!!. If we're moving to a less government mechanism the why do we need a election system?

[@rahulsharma-do7ke]

Cz ministers k ghr walo ko jugad lagana hota h in jobs etc. So elect ho jao become n minister(even if u r uneducated) then do reforms

[@shivanshtyagi3254]

Because government control doesn't automatically give control to gen pop. Leaving aside few debacles and isolated incidents private sector has always been much ahead despite less backing and financial support. Even the best of our PSUs can't match the performance of private sector despite so much of cash infusion. A private firm is vulnerable to competition and hence much more vigilant about its money. Sure they can go haywire too but that is not a signal for government to take upon every bloody business for itself. Governments job is to govern not do business. You can bring out policies to regulate businesses.

[@dikshadogra7609]

It's my humble request to RSTV kindly check the sound quality before starting the show 🙁

[@SS-hw1ou]

This is not their studio

[@nipuntyagi279]

Jayant das gupta looks very exciting about the discussion.

[@Rahulpriye]

Some kind of accountability & responsibility should lied upon the public sector undertakings in order to bring efficiency in it so that there would be no need for further privatization

[@---me---]

Workers will be same those kaamchor babus will remain same only management changes. So why not bring reforms in PSU management. Hire few MBA grads from IIMs and CA experts. At now PSU management is governed by non management grads like IES IAS officers who are permanent employees of GoI not the employees of those PSUs.

[@Ironfist1109]

अद्बुध

[@yuvrajsingh3378]

Happiness of being on tv - Jayant Dasgupta

[@gkplus2877]

सफल होने के 'तीन नियम' खुद से वादा मेहनत ज्यादा मजबूत इरादा

[@UnEngineered]

thanks for the motivation🌻

[@donbuddha8341]

Reduce Political interference in PSU , instead appoint third party investigation and recommendation body to review periodically and let them suggest solution

[@arjuntyagi5144]

Privatization of public sector undertakings 1 - unlock the capital in corona. As some is seeing loose because of less infusion of technology and capital. 2- buy some other which can assure the profit and employment. 3-optimal utilisation is not taking place. As tax payer money is wasted in bailing out these enterprise's. 4- air india failed find capital, used in corona time. But it expected by every cooperation. 5- two macro message- ( Maximum governance minimum government) ( Self reliant) 6- maruti was govt developed but now it's totally privatised. And pay a lot of taxes. 7- privatization is not divestment. Where govt give upto 50% to 100% shares. 8- keeping air india running is erosion of money and loss of it value.

[@gkplus2877]

खुद को वक़्त दो! आपकी पहली जरूरत आप खुद हो!!

[@Binaykumarjha1502]

All the ministry level post should be privatised first and why is the sense central government job in this country? Doing nothing getting everything

[@ashritha9584]

Thank you for providing such profound analysis regarding current issues...and only problem is about sound quality plz consider this as we are missing some important points which are provided by these eminent personalities

[@pemmaiahns1254]

Jayant sir makes the viewers understand the issue, points out the difference and then discuss, which really helps us understand the concept

[@---me---]

Its about collective ownership not about asset creation for few industrialist. It cannot get worse when government starts selling its stake in profit making PSUs just to cover their Revenue Shortfall and not using money to revive other sick PSUs. Use Janta ka paisa(tax collection) to janta ki sewa (subsidies) But don't use earning from selling PSUs to fund your subsidies. In this way after few years you won't be left with any asets you will only left with a Stick of law Enforcement and a carrot of Sovereign Guarantee. You will not have any assets to match with your guarantees. I was wondering a day will come when government will borrow money from public on mortgage of Parliament building in the name of land monetization. So how can we estimate the growth of a Government Department like income tax department. With revenue shortfall, should we privatisate them to have better efficiency. Well i sounds stupid and yet Britishers tried to do so by hiring Zamindars. You don't always measure the importance of an asset in terms of money it fetches, Other parameters are 1)strategic importance 2)presence in Remote Areas 3) importance in delivering welfare schemes 4)trust 5)csr

[@MANISHKUMAR-jd8jk]

Sir, please clear your sound problem..

[@snehasalvi7441]

the points made by charan singh sir was wonderful....but i could not understand all due to sound issue..... plz rstv check the sound issue beforehand......

[@AmanDeep-jn1fo]

Charan singh gave really nice perspective

[@RahulDas-qf1jw]

Thank you rstv to bring us valuable information from experts.

[@gauravchauhan9963]

i think privatization can't be long term solution however we can achieve short term goal . 1- it can solve government revenue shortage problem . 2- as we see some psu not working properly . by privatization may be there working will improve . quality will improve . but - 1- privatization can't be solution for government revenue in long term . what will happen when we have no public entity to sell . so government should come to the other options for its revenue . 2- privatization may be affect government policies in long term . They can make cartel and can influence govt . 3- privatization is based on profit they don't care about welfare state . so as our constitution declares we are the welfare state how will we manage this . 4- privatization of strategic importance psu may not be good option ,as we know they are important for our security sustainability . what will happen when any private entity will leakage official secrecy . 5- privatization during covid may not get proper bidder. solution privatization of some psu can be done but we have to look other revenue resources . privatization cant be option for government revenue options. we should rethink policy making of privatization of strategic importance units, we want to privatize air india but in this covid situation and any other catastrophic situation it helped us .

[@nehasahu149]

Sound quality is not good but its highly appreciable to hold such discussions during the lockdown.Thank you Rstv

[@toddalengeupsc2445]

Kindly improve the sound quality . Thank you.

[@shambho_abha]

Charan singh ji is making sure that we know about his sea-facing apartment! 😂🙏

[@sanketkawale8370]

I thought same

[@SKumar-bs7zz]

He's in Delhi

[@mrperfect6065]

We think privatisation means more revenue genrations,easy work process but why don't we apply strategies that private sector use rather than to privatise these sector ? If private sector is doing great in all aspects ,,we should follow private sector strategy in govt sector rather than to privatise them

[@subhikshamahendran]

Sound quality is horrible today. Only Frank and Dasgupta sir are audible. My kind request to RSTV is please fine tune audio before starting the show. This show is watched mainly by thousands of UPSC aspirants. So take due diligence..

[@manishpaswan5075]

Right sir, Agr privatisation ho jayegaa to job Kese lgega psu me, kyuki Yha Koi competition nhi hoga Isme Sirf relationship Wale ko hi job milegaa

[@vipulkhajuria7893]

You think private sectors give jobs on relationships?aur unhe profit kaise milega agar inefficient people come into jobs?

[@rrtsharma2381]

@@vipulkhajuria7893 right bro, they give money to your talent

[@ConverttoHinduism]

@@vipulkhajuria7893 NPA ka nam suna hai kabhi jindagi in me, sab private sector ki den bai

[@vipulkhajuria7893]

@@ConverttoHinduism Pvt sector ki den kaise hua?jab loan de rahe the mallya jaise dube hue businessman ko tab due diligence kyun nahin ki?Govt sector agar successful hota to India china private sector ki aur na bhagte

[@hemanthkrishna2968]

Loved the background music 😒

[@tatasolarpanel6490]

I think guys using bsnl network or jio's network...if rajyasabha will not improve sound quality it would also privatise in future

[@irshadmohammad2137]

First time the debate has 30mins conducted

[@muskansrivastava9376]

Great discussion...I loved it ❤️

[@rahulsharma-do7ke]

Sir please specify if all police and other central government departments not work like u told ki sarkari naukri lag gi h n ab koi tension nhi h so y nt make them also private, there are many examples of the same in the central government so point will be to improve them and if govt. Needs accountability den it should start by looking at its own people and ministry's n den decide

[@nikhilsonna6765]

Profit profit profit...like seriously no one of the panel member...or rather many people seriously don't feel the need of making a point of investing in the people who run these companies, eventually people run company not the infrastructure or to specify any of the sectors, just look out for the entry level in these companies, the efforts put by students to get here... Invest in people there are heavy minded people who have high levels of IQ as they qualify enough to run heavy business...sadly no one cares in investing in the people...but selling the infrastructure.

[@tbfyouthtalks1812]

Sound begins destorted with charan singh's view.

[@payalpansuriya516]

I agree

[@rahulsharma-do7ke]

And also a job in PSU is earned by the employee not given by your relatives so try to improve the public sector by some reforms , khch change krna is a big task as usmai dimag khapat hogi private krna is easy man jb khch samaj na aye anyone cn do

[@bikramkumar3923]

Thanks Rstv☺

[@us7764]

"Air India helps in critical situations to evacuate stranded people " => For Air India, govt gives around 6000cr every year do away with its losses. If we pay fraction of the above amount, any private airline will do it.

[@monsterinsideus]

Air India can be act as ace of govt. for any diplomatic mission or social mission in future It shouldn't be completely privatised

[@afsalnajeeb1128]

Home or studio, Frank has the same cool tone and style.:)

[@jyotishnaseema1799]

Privatisation of company and banks It's good decision because government have no money so psu it's good decision and government take the list disciplinary handel situation so then profites company. ✈ very critical point but government comes good plan. Good morning our teams.

[@taamardhwaj]

Well people take it otherwise and protest scaring about the loss of their "Government" jobs and no more "Rishwat"

[@ravimathur4546]

Privatizing PSU's will introduce unethical business practices. Rather privatizing the PSu's the Govt.should better open the sector for all so that a healthy competition can be seen.

[@learnwithme936]

Only Jayant sir's voice is clear and understandable... please improve sound quality

[@lakshaybansal2159]

Privatisation >>>> Disinvestment

[@jatin5674]

Privatisation of public sector prr ek Badhiya saa slogan bta naa Please 🙏

[@jaiswal6050]

Sir please check sound quality

[@anandkangulwar5136]

Pleas i have no got clear voice

[@rajasekarantmanikumar2850]

The panelists' voices are not audible!

[@travelbysoul2565]

After air india sold out.. Then private owner will hire beautiful items to entertain passenger.. Reservation system will no more in existance... These are main reasons.... Guys always blame only on employees not to system

[@taamardhwaj]

We should abolish reservation system

[@_PranayW]

@@taamardhwaj Study history.. You'll understand why it's still going on 😁. Don't you want everyone on same track 🤔...

[@blackmotivation2027]

Please do check the sound quality and adding subtitles would be best.

[@pankajmatta3226]

please check the sound quality

[@praveenR12]

Program producer sagheer solve some sound issue and clear it.

[@yadasmounika]

It would be beneficial to the viewers if you provide subtitles.

[@chulbulpandey6356]

Sound quality is poor

[@foodiiiee]

Govt job is to run Maximum governance not the business for business they can appoint accountable people to the management.

[@DEEPAKYADAV-iz1wz]

According to me this debate was one sided bcz of sound problem... We all were able to listen only one view, one face nd one side of this.

[@bestrong_7-d8o]

Sound problem

[@shashankyadav552]

Since many past episodes there has been problem related to noise. Kindly ensure it clarity from panelist side before starting discussion, else change panelist. And you don't even give captions for most of discussions.

[@_PranayW]

😅😁

[@mayurwattamwar5573]

In all your debates, there is atleast one speaker whose voice is not clear, pl check the sound quality once before starting debate and before uploading on youTube else add subtitles atleast.

[@akshyamm]

Sir may be its unethical for you to call of panel member audio check..but please make a call to penal member for it. Without clear audio the debate is useless.

[@kuaishoushorts]

A lot of sound problem.

[@bholagujjargngyrgyfhccfguy7841]

Pls check sound before starting session

[@mohdshariq5814]

There must be Email Id so that general public can ask questions to the panel

[@bhagyasinghgurjar9923]

Government must bring in some serious administrative reforms as well as police reform, judicial reform and land reform I have great expectations from this govt let's see if they are able to deliver on it

[@dikshadogra7609]

I Could not hear Singh Sir properly 🙁

[@pranavkumar2516]

Charn Singh right

[@ateshsharma3]

Please switch off the air blowing source! Digital india needs simple measures to kick in.

[@dheerajpradhan2018]

Sound quality is the only impact of corona on big picture otherwise best programe among television programe.

[@avdheshmishra3816]

sir please imporve sound quality

[@niteshyu121]

Charan Singh sir's voice is not clear....

[@sbiswas6110]

Improve sound quality please...its 21st century

[@vinaykumarsingh5360]

So gist of this discussion is that the government doesn't have money. They badly need money for that they will sell every public property. But i dont understand one thing, there was no corruption in NDA era and they lessen the subsidy also than where did the money go.

[@yogeshbairwa]

Agree with rakesh khar

[@dawnglianapachuau6433]

is Mr. Signh sitting near an Air Cooler... the noise is coming only when it his turn to speak.

[@ashishshandilya3049]

voice of charan singh sir is not clear

[@gagankumarsingh220]

Sir sound quality is not better please improve it

[@dikiunkhapuinamai5048]

Sir, there's very irritating sound almost on every person. There's some issue.

[@shubhamrai8575]

Sound issue

[@MANOJKUMAR-mq1mz]

Charan Singh audio is horrible

[@mohdshariq5814]

If government sell everything how will it run it's schemes like ujawala yojna Jan dhan account in public banks

[@sakshamsinha2913]

By consolidating the tax base, and increasing sources of revenue.

[@mohdshariq5814]

@@sakshamsinha2913 how revenue will increase when profit making PSUs are on sale

[@divyavethavanisekar3655]

@@mohdshariq5814 pls list down profit make company vs loss making company and then talk about this

[@mohdshariq5814]

@@divyavethavanisekar3655 one very example is bpcl which is profit making but government decide to sale it!

[@koushiksingh5770]

@@mohdshariq5814 in the last 20 years most of the PSU's are running under loss. They are not only running in loss, but is also technically backward.

[@alok21singh]

Kya bol rahe sardar ji

[@akhileshkhobragade3653]

Will psu privatisation affect its working employees??

[@VirendraUpadhyay]

Bilkul Phir jo kam kr rhe h vo drenge phir unko kam krna pdega target pura krna pdenge Isiliye jin psu ko pvt krne ki baat aati h to unke employ virodh krne lg jate h

[@rrtsharma2381]

@@VirendraUpadhyay haha kam karna padega

[@taamardhwaj]

Sir ab aap bhi studio me aa jaiye🙂

[@gaminggirlofficial9940]

What a sound quality.... U wasted my 2 minutes.

[@devendersidhu001]

You can see quality of sound of public sector. We need to private psu .

[@bhagyasinghgurjar9923]

You also need to see quality of discussion Jokes apart I am not a fan of psu

[@DD-ru2lw]

Rakesh Kaur has made 1 or 2 points but he acted like a know it all. Also, why should any sane person sell his business at the worst possible time? Thank god he chose journalism or he would have been a failed businessman.

[@poojapal7196]

A one sided debate with people trying to convince privatization as the need of the hour. How can a distressed sale just to cover a revenue shortfall will help? In long run it wont be beneficial . Mr. Singh tried to show the problems faced by the public sector, the reason behind their failure but again backed by the favour of privatisation. Why not we can have the reforms in that area so that Public Sector can be utilized with full efficacy.

[@koushiksingh5770]

Your comment gives huge amount of information about your brain size 😂

[@bimalkumar4137]

Sir really I want to know about the GATE aspirants, what will be now with them?

[@rajdeeplava]

check sound quality subtitle plz

[@sumitsingh-10]

sometimes voice is not clear

[@tatasolarpanel6490]

Parliament ko bhi privatise kar lete

[@shavithakur1796]

distorted voice....please fix it before starting the session or ask the panelists to turnoff their fans😅

[@rohankaushik5066]

Use of earphones mandatory

[@dhruvratti3009]

Sound is poor

[@gaganagarwal9323]

It's better to do give PSUs autonomy and flexibility and obviously more fund,.. they r still relying on age-old machines and equipments . How can we expect them to utilise their potential with such assets and minuscule fund. Privatisation of Psus is not a solution, rather de-reserve sectors so that pvt sector can private and reforms psus so that they also thrive.

[@rajdeeplava]

again upload in hindi member will be same plz rajya sabha

[@sanketkawale8370]

Discussion was one sided.....

[@alok21singh]

Humesa log shikayat karte hai ....doosra reform chodiye aap pahle khud reform Karie khudko

[@xhandle001]

Poor sound quality of singh sir

[@assassin247]

Worst sound quality a