The Binding of Isaac: The Whole Story Doesn't Make Sense - until now

►► Support Rabbi Friedman's work today with a donation of any amount! Campaign ends on THURSDAY: raisethon.com/...
►►Ask Rabbi Manis Friedman Your Questions In His Private VIP Community: go.itsgoodtokn...
Click Here To Get Access To Weekly Conversations! itsgoodtoknow.....
We Need Your Help!
To support the work of Rabbi Manis Friedman, please visit- itsgoodtoknow....
To join the online community and for weekly live webinars, please visit- itsgoodtoknow....
To book a private session with Rabbi Friedman, please visit- itsgoodtoknow....
For information on upcoming events and to join the email list please visit- itsgoodtoknow....
Follow Rabbi Manis Friedman:
Facebook: / therabbimanisfriedman
Twitter: / manisfriedman
Linkedin: / rabbifriedman
Instagram: / rabbimanisfried. .
About Rabbi Manis Friedman:
Rabbi Manis Friedman is a world-renowned author, counselor, lecturer and philosopher who uses ancient wisdom and modern wit to captivate audiences around the world. For event bookings, please call our office at 800-656-5669 or email us at [e-mail]

[@suzybailey-koubti8342]

Rabbi Friedman, thank you again for explaining these stories in the Torah/OT to someone like me. I appreciate it from my heart.

[@nightdance1611]

Hhhuhh

[@nightdance1611]

H 🧠hhhh

[@hiruthseyoum5969]

Abraham/ Isaac:- tear jerking story. An Ethiopian Monk/ Sage (40 years in prayers and communion with our Creator ) answered me the many “why this and why not that” we often ask about some biblical narratives. His answer was simple. He said, “nothing is about our fleshly impressions, thoughts, logic, perceptions etc! But instead, it’s about His Eternal love, Mercy, Majesty, Glory!” Here, we see that God gave remarkable Faith and strength of obedience to His servant Abraham because it’s what he choose and therefore we see ABRAHAM became empowered to do God’s will Blessings🙏 from Ethiopia

[@garyjacobs2789]

This was my take on this for years . No human must die to please God.

[@alainlouis5476]

Why? If all human beings are born sinners.

[@motorola1543]

@@alainlouis5476 the Christians say that. Not us. Original sin is a heretical belief

[@marksingleton7199]

@@alainlouis5476 God does not like us dying. Its like the prodigal son. The Father looses his son to his own thoughts. He messes up but learns alot and realizes what fool he was. He had all he needed, so he goes home and the father is ecstatic his son saw sence. Thats life as we know it. Death is lovingly going home. We think selfishly so death is taking away, stealing our life. Its the opposite.

[@jacovawernett3077]

God gives and takes to teach. Have you heard of Passover. L'chaim. My Hebrew name Jacova is the female form of Jacob. I was born March 11 in Bethlehem. Are you all enjoying the pandemic that was declared global on my birthday that I saw behind my eyes for 2 years. 2020 is the biblical year of Jacob. My Covenant with God Elohim Adonai is to make Israel One...It means to bring peace and reconciliation between Jew Christian Muslim..Cousins by Abraham. My middle name is Sue..One of the things God told me I am is Evergreen .Remember the Suez Canal and Evergreen freighter...Happy belated passover, Easter and Ramadan.

[@jacovawernett3077]

Adam and Eve did not bite the apple of knowledge for baloney sandwiches. To say we are all born sinners is a misinterpretation. God wants us to have knowledge. It's why free will can be messy but worth it. God told me people earn what they learn.

[@dinushblau4247]

Yhank you Rabbi Friedman for life changing. Finally understanding the Torah, feeling so much more connected.

[@lanerovito4324]

Rabbi I am an Orthodox christian, you make so much since, and wisdom, God bless you every Bodie else.

[@ptwlk]

Thank you Rabbi. I have been praying recently to God that He would teach me the truth, as I have difficulties understanding some parts of the scriptures.

[@mariamachado3371]

After this explanation, as usual, the wise words of Rabi Freeman made me feel less ignorant about Isaac story. Thank you again

[@dkbrain3434]

Feel the same way.

[@hasisahi1784]

What if this rabbi lie to you.

[@louisalorida9849]

Friedman means Peaceman not Freeman. A man who preaches the Shalom

[@danielleagni2664]

My parents were holocaust survivors and growing up I was privileged to hear discussions between them and other survivors in the neighbourhood as to why this happened, what and where did we go wrong to endure such a devastation, where was the justification in such obvious injustice. I know this is past tense, but for me at least it still colours the present; please could you help to untie the knots. Shalom

[@felipesantos2]

Sir, thank you very much for all your words. Isaac's sacrifice has been haunting me for years. Thank you very much for helping me. You cannot imagine how grateful I am. (Felipe from Brazil)

[@donaldmacaskill5845]

The LORD knew, the story is for our benefit.

[@louisalorida9849]

WHO'S TO SAY WHAT GOD CAN'T DO ?! The impossible get be possible. Thanks so much Rabbi Friedman for your precious teaching. God bless

[@jackfish38]

Never ever heard such a profound interpretation .. and explanation... thank you so much Rabbi.. i am deeply blessed... bless me please so that i may have godliness in me always... please bless me... thank you so much

[@almalopez2409]

Rabbi Friedman, I want you to know why your talk are so different and amazing, you know your nature and you understand your call, you don’t preach you teach in a way that it feels as if we having a conversation face to face, to me that’s a great way to understand the messages of the Torah and the Bible in general. Like many others I still have questions, but one of your explanations can click to find correlations and answers. Thank you so much for your devoted special teaching. Shalom Alechem 🙏🏼 Alma

[@lesbouma9666]

Thank you for the background on this part of Torah. Always thought there was more to it than we were taught.

[@ds7564]

Thank you, Rabbi. I am not jew, not Christian. Recently started reading old testament out of curiosity. The way you explained gives me deeper understanding of great prophets.

[@elizabethbooth5446]

Thank you

[@nimagirengineers2854]

Thank you Rabbai Friedman, making us see Hasham how we supposed to see HIM.

[@ITatic-nf4wr]

There may be a certain difference between the two situations, first when G. says I will destroy something, and the other when He tells you to do so. Seems that only the second is unnegotiable.

[@fluffyribbit1881]

This helped me work out some things with God and a... troublesome friend. Thank you. It was exactly what I needed and I believe the LORD has used to bless me and many other people. I will pray that he rewards you for your service.

[@stefanjohansson2395]

Thank you,Rabbi!!!

[@marekmosiewicz2872]

I do not know Hebrew but KJV it is translated as it "And he said, Take now thy son, thine only son Isaac, whom thou lovest, and get thee into the land of Moriah; and offer him there for a burnt offering upon one of the mountains which I will tell thee of" That the command. And then G-d says not to kill Isaac, That seems almost like contradiction.

[@paulafrancksr9296]

Thank you much for sharing your tremendous vault of wisdom and knowledge with us. I am so very greatful and have received much healing in such a short time. Thank you ❤️

[@bilbil7331]

Thank you.

[@janetkilkelly939]

Rabbi you give me great comfort in your knowledge thus increasing my faith each and every day .. particularly in these covid times .. a very gracious thank you from me to you.

[@markcrook1146]

Rabbi thank you from the bottom of my heart for your wisdom. As a Christian I'm enlightened by your teachings. I hope the light and love shine on each of your days. Respectfully Yours, Mark.

[@naomistarlight6178]

Abraham being sad that no guests were coming reminds me of my grandpa! If he's not on his phone he has to be talking to someone face to face and always wants people over. Doesn't know a stranger. :)

[@baddbeliever]

In India and Persia, the old priests would tie a thing around their waists...to bind them in tight. The word cunberband that we wear under tuxedos is from Hindi meaning close your waist. A common term used in Hindi to describe a religious person is "banda" or worshipper or more closely, binded one. I think even bind comes from banda. I know religion comes from religare which means to bind. Thanks Isaac. You have set a huge standard.

[@theodoreperez2868]

Thanks again Rabbi Bless HaShem

[@aminabilal1233]

In our modern society anybody who wants to hurt the child would be arrested.

[@thomasjorge4734]

We hope!

[@cootmaster]

fantastic rabbi, your stories so fantastic

[@lizgichora6472]

Perception, Thank you.

[@comflmregistrynews]

I loved this lecture. Thank you my comment to why no hesitation to binding Isaac is Abraham knew Hashems voice. He was a daily communicant of speaking and listening. He was in a sense testing Hashems. Like a dare oh you want me to put my favorite blessing on Your Altar. This was a highest point of trust for Abraham to be in a powerpoint with the Creator. Do you know that place? Have you ever felt that much tension in your faith ? I wait for morsels of Holiness to drip under the mercy seat.

[@comflmregistrynews]

@@pastoradeboye2952 where are you in Israel or Nigeria. I am sorry I am not understanding. I thought you were Hassidic

[@Pascalierity]

@@comflmregistrynews This is an imposter user name (uses the real rabbi's image but the name is all lower case) who has spammed almost all comments with the same reply. Report it as spam as I have done.

[@felipeallegro9683]

Thanks for sharing your knowledge.

[@NazirBrohi-ht3fr]

❤❤❤❤❤ Respected mentor .

[@TheHenok30]

Saint Paulus taught that Aḅraham reasoned that God would raise Yiṣḥaq (Yitskhaq / Isaac) from the dead when Aḅraham was ascending the MOUNTAIN (or hill) to sacrifice his firstborn son (Heb. 11:18-19). Thus Yiṣḥaq could still have offspring like God said he would previously. He was given a great impression & found out that God doesn't want human sacrifices.

[@kevinmcclainsr.853]

Abraham’s faith in God made him know he would have grandchildren by Isaac even though God told him to sacrifice his son. Abraham knew in his heart that God would make a way some how to save Isaac. God can make a way out of no way. Amen

[@erickjlara3784]

Hi from Dominican Republic 🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴🇩🇴👋👋👋👋👋👋

[@257rani]

Thanks ❤🌏🌎🌍

[@waitahamangi]

Thank you Rabbi for these uplifting lessons...🙏

[@musakabasele9831]

Thank you Rabbi for the illumination of God's word. But what about the same event that happened in book of judges 11:31 about jephthah and his daughter?

[@bozethe]

She separated from human company to live alone, busy with the worship of God. Rashi on Judges 11:39:1 She became the subject of a law. Legislation was enacted prohibiting any repetition of this, for, had he approached Pinchos, or had Pinchos approached him, he would have released him from his vow.24 But they refused to humble themselves,25 and were, thus, both responsible for her ruin. They were punished. The Divine Presence departed from Pinchos, as it is said in Divrei Hayamim,26 "Adonoy was with him previously." We learn that he was not with him later. And Yiftoch was afflicted with ulcerations and the loss of his limbs, as it is said,27 "He was buried in the cities of Gilod."28 Another interpretation: "She became the subject of a law in Yisroel" relates to the following passage.

[@biancamm9500]

Thank you, it was an eye opening and I do enjoy listening to your teachings, could you please help me understand the part of the history of Genesis 4:11....

[@naomistarlight6178]

They sacrificed children because back then children were more seen as livestock than people, look at the story of Job and how that story treats children and wives for men as fungible assets rather than beings of their own agency. This story if anything marks a turning point in human history away from seeing children as things and towards seeing them as human beings.

[@richardbenitez7803]

On youtube, Israeli scholars of the Dead Sea Scrolls said there are writings on why God asked Abraham to sacrifice Isaac. An additional reason as per these writings is that God chose to show the heavens that the humans He created and the people of which God would place His allegiance were capable of highest loyalty, the highest faith, the highest trust that would be the honor of those in heaven and would glorify God with His human creation.

[@manuelakojetinsky8438]

Thank you Rabbi Friedman 💝🕎

[@Unknown-x2n4g]

Isaac did know because he tells Abraham to bind him in a way that he could not break loose so that he will be an acceptable sacrifice. Abraham's servant and Ishmael made a joke about sacrificing if Isaac over his inheritance. In the story. The servant is struck with lepersy.

[@inelation]

Thank you Rabbi for the great perspective. I am a little puzzled though on how is Avraham going against his nature / chesed by doing the aikeda? If the people of the generation did actually follow this practice of human sacrifice and believed they are doing good by liberating the soul from this world. It seems to follow that Avraham was still doing chesed to his son

[@ESU77]

Ancient text tells this story more in detail. The entity called god isn't the King of the Universe. Its an Anunaki aka the fallen angels. That's exactly who is requiring human sacrifices. " I require mercy Not sacrifice" says the Supreme True Creator King of the Universe.

[@thehouseteambuildingcommun2599]

Love your stories

[@pastormrslydiaanti-asare282]

Wonderful.

[@darrellsharrock3859]

I could imagine his pain , his tears he had to sever his sons tie to the earth and to him. He had to give the nearly ungiveable

[@zas5892]

Thank you rabbi Friedman

[@dianem365]

Thank you Rabbi for this explanation. I have a question about what happened after this story. It seems that Abraham lived in Beersheba and Sarah was in Hebron when she died. Did they no longer live together?

[@jaedenamadeussalim2438]

I heard from a preacher that yes Abraham n Sarah split after this event, said that Sarah cant accept what Abraham did - rried to sacrifice Isaac - (because she loves Isaac so much, and she can’t understand God’s purpose) And Sarah didnt live to her fullest age, God shorten her life (the bible said that Sarah died, different from how the bible said about others that reach certain age then died)

[@Certainblind]

Well, As I was I thought, Isaac is not the only son of abraham. Before isaac, abraham had already sons and daugthers with Hagar and Keturah. To his wife sarah, i would say isaac is the only son that is.

[@fahadjavaid7336]

@tate rosemary is ibrahim MGBPWH is citizen of this country? did that particular law existed? using intoxicant is illegall in my country should i judge people in America and europe?

[@elliothass7000]

The story of the Akedah is the story of Y'shua HaMashiach. The story of Yoseph is the story of Y'shua HaMashiach.

[@jeffreyrwilliams9345]

thank you

[@griffinlewis4148]

Love you 😘😘❤️

[@sarrakaplan8214]

תודה רב שבת שלום

[@vitazissel3671]

He was 37? For some reason I saw him as a child? Poor Yitzhak

[@thomasjorge4734]

This changes everything!

[@marcoantoniooso1584]

Where in the book does it say he was 37?

[@thomasjorge4734]

@@marcoantoniooso1584 Isaac is a Type of the Lord as are Adam, Moses, David, etc. He willingly: carries the wood up the hill, accepts his fate, does not push back against a man who can be easily resisted.

[@slngichosen5437]

sipur noge'a la'lev, ahavti et zeh me'od. ani omer todah lekha yaqer ha'Rabbi Manis Friedman, maretz pakistan. shuv toda.

[@mjolnir9855]

Is it possible that part of Avraham’s test was whether or not he would condemn the request for a human sacrifice, which he failed? (Though, he succeeded in passing the test to have faith that God would resurrect Isaac - if need be - to fulfill HIS promises.)??

[@aleksveyg22]

Hello Rabbi, how do I contact you to share the insights i get of the parsha?

[@西芹-s6c]

i have no words to say，and so many tears to my eyes .

[@burcu4711]

Thank you rabbi 🙏

[@glenwoodhouse33]

"Yes, I believe that God knows what's He's doing, I don't see the justice"

[@1GoodDag]

Ty rabbi 🙏

[@ארליןארלין]

Awesome interpretation!

[@atnalta2]

This is great teaching from another perspective

[@naomistarlight6178]

Human sacrifice = not God's way of thinking. But at that time sacrificing a bull was fine. Not only fine, but necessary? It seems arbitrary the way human life should be valued when animal life, which we now know to be so similar in emotional range to human existence, is devalued.

[@alanalan-mq8yw]

Thankyou for that. Abraham (Hesed-lovingkindness) Isaac(Gevura-power-fear). Abraham taught Isaac love(loved Rebecca), Isaac taught Abraham fear Gen22:12".........; for now I know that thou fearest God,..."

[@mandalamann]

thank you Rabbi ... thank G_D

[@Lorna8264]

Nice interpretation

[@dennydewaal137]

💕💕❣️💞💞💚💘💗❤️💝💝🤎🤍🤍💛💔💙💔🤎🤍💜🧡🧡🤎💗❤️❤️💗💘❤️❤️🤍to you rabbi ..

[@magdagood16]

I love the deep interpretation from the Bible, I always enjoy your videos.

[@mikelstevenson4968]

I am a Christian considering conversion to Judaism , mostly because of your teachings. Quite honestly I have always been bothered by this story as well as Jephthah's Daughter. I can't understand how an omniscient benevolent God would put father and son in such a position. I will read all the comments below and study more. Thanks

[@ΜικαέλαΤουλιατου]

Shalom , I'm trying to learn Hebrew but the language is a bit difficult... How can I say in Hebrew "Praise the Lord", because I am still learning the basics. Rabbi, I am really inspired by your lectures, I wish I could have lived so long ago, and converse with Him !!! I am trying, I deeply believe, but still it's my monologue....

[@Taylor-lm5op]

I think the requested sacrifice of Isaac from God has to do with Abimelech, the Philistines and Beer-Sheba. Abimelech bested Abraham in Genesis 21, and God seemed absent during that. In Genesis 26, the Philistines invoke HaShem by name when they bless Isaac. In the chapter afterwards, Isaac is then allowed or inspired to bless his favored son. Almost as if a part of HaShem is with the Philistines and had to give authority to bless to the patriarchs.

[@zemho2124]

Rabbi , your wisdom is unparalleled. Thanks for the good work. May the Almighty always enlightened you

[@jazz19101]

If all stories are a divine revelation then why are they so confusing? Even the 10 commandments. Why are they so poorly written?

[@Nana_Amprofi]

I love this ♥️

[@emberdawn5283]

I love you and love the good in you

[@garyborgman6407]

For witness

[@burongaroso2538]

All Glory to Yahuah Yahusha yasha

[@margaretneanover3385]

I think k the Holy are supposed to see we all learn as different..yet have same and different ideas. That each part of a motor is part..but all parts might..might make it work ..

[@dee3663]

I admire this man wisdom. Thank you! I would like to know if baptism is part of Judaism. Hope someone can enlighten me on that subject.

[@mmewapino6629]

@@pastoradeboye2952 last you aapered as pastor Abel Damina and later as Bishop Stephen Zondo now you're Rabbi who's are you for the message is the same with details and all what do you represent and may the good Elohim rebuke you

[@Growthisinthedirt]

@@mmewapino6629 ur on drugs. It's Rabbi all the way thru. 😂

[@mmewapino6629]

@@Growthisinthedirt okay dear but the sender knows what am l referring to hence they say don't be quick to judge rather ask first

[@Growthisinthedirt]

@@mmewapino6629 ok.. What drugs are u on? 😂😂😂

[@thomasjorge4734]

No. Circumcision is.

[@MK-sv4vy]

Itzhak trusted his father as Avraham trusted HaShem 😊🙏 and remember Avraham told his men, “stay here with the donkey while we go up...WE will be back.. my parsha last Rosh Hashana 😊 Thank you, Rabbi Friedman. B”H 🙏😊

[@emmanuelgado6342]

Thank you rabbi❤ at least me glorifying 👑GOD👑 through you, is some sort of blessings to you...

[@theolovaj4844]

This is so good.

[@mercymercy149]

Thank you rabbi,

[@zbigniewloboda3393]

11:27 Abraham was totally obedient to the God. Therefore he had no difficulty to do things which could do only not good people.

[@naomistarlight6178]

I like how you're not telling me to just suffer silently about all the injustice out there. Not to become insensitive and callous about it. I like the "obligated to complain" when in Protestant culture we're raised to never complain and it's stifling and terrible. Helps nothing.

[@aminabilal1233]

Society was very different long time ago. Who came to Abraham, one told him to sacrifise son, others stop him and gave him lamb? They were not from this planet

[@johngordon1175]

God knew all along what Abraham would do, however God probably wanted him to know that God knows And was watching.

[@144Donn]

Actually, Avram\Avraham's work throughout the region was famously spreading Monotheism. From early on, he brought close the men and Sarai\Sarah brought the women under the canopy of the One God. Avraham's business card read; "Do NOT perform human sacrifice!" It was obviously known to him from the very beginning this is NOT what God desires! There Paganistic that is more disdainful than human sacrifice. The thought that Avraraham ever believed it was anything but detestable is unthinkable! The test of Avraham was this: to see if the philosophy he was spreading for all those years was his own or was it God's? If Avraham would sacrifice his son he'd be going against everything he stood for, he would be seen as the world's biggest hypocrite and his life's work we be for naught. If Avraham would follow God's command, it would demonstrate his ultimate conviction to God's word because he would do the act he urged others not to do, BECAUSE GOD TOLD him to do so! This would clearly demonstrate that Avraham was not espousing his own philosophy but God's. This test would show without a doubt if Avraham was selling his own religion or God's. By going against the ethics he espoused and was known for; he showed his only desire was to fulfill the will of God...no matter what it was.

[@darrellsharrock3859]

Praise be to God. Thank you Rabbi. I see the holocaust, as one of the people of Noah in the same way. Never again. Thank you teacher.

[@samybaxy]

A test of Avraham's faith and trust in the words of HaShem. I will trust in His words, because they are life and truth.

[@ahoymatey2315]

I knew Santa was Jewish!

[@milivojelancuski2391]

Isus je bio odan i samo je kazao : Bože neka bude volja tvoja kako ti hoćeš, veran i odan do krsta na Golgoti i nije znao, bio je u neizvesnosti i nije nigde nije zgrešio i održao je Zakon. Hvala Isusu.

[@Taylor-lm5op]

Everyone mistreats Isaac: Abraham, God, Rebekah, the Philistines, and Jacob. Even the text of the Torah itself mistreats Isaac by not giving him that much page time (Isaac has two chapters about him compared to Abraham/Jacob/Joseph having 10 chapters be about them).

[@fahadjavaid7336]

oh really??? quran refered people of israel(issac), alot, but takes away the previously known sacrifice story which was assiciated in old scriptures in torah to ishmael. ...

[@NFPura]

Torah Chesed will rectify this. Isaac will be the hero in this Surah. Unfortunately, it was given to the son of Kitura, not the son of Sarah, not directly. He is still the hero though. Mashaallah. The will of HaShem. Not my own.

[@zbigniewloboda3393]

10:29 Values of Abraham in times of sacrifice of Isaac ware the same what ware other people. Therefore for Abraham and Isaac the process of sacrifice of Isaac by Abraham wasn't dramatic.

[@misha8634]

Question. How could the rest of the world be held accountable for sacrificing people only after the binding of Issac? Even if Hashem was teaching us a lesson there is no way say Chine knew that it was bad. Issac could not have passed the lesson to all 4 corners of the world... Something is not making sense.

[@mjolnir9855]

“Their” world, in my opinion. Murder was always wrong, but now the nations will be judged instead of God winking at their ignorance. Just my opinion, however. Love to know what Mr. Friedman would say.