The Black Day Of The German Army - The Battle of Amiens I THE GREAT WAR Week 211

[@Losthopeglory]

We may take it for granted after 4 years, but it’s impossible to overstate how much of an achievement this channel, with its consistent, quality uploads, rich detail, historical accuracy, and a wealth of other qualities. Thank you so much to Indy and the team for shedding so much light on a catastrophic four years of human history.

[@duckncover3567]

here here, rob my friend, here here...……..

[@jacookie9707]

This should require a mandatory viewing by all people

[@Illiteratechimp]

Hear hear!

[@Mcquiz95]

I am adamant that this is the greatest 'popular' history project ever, yes ever.

[@ThePaultje106]

I miss it

[@jamesquick3752]

I was only 67 years old when I started following this epic retelling of perhaps the pivotal event of the 20th century. I'm now 71. Thank you sincerely for an outstanding "long strange trip."

[@shrillbert]

On September 1, you can see him do WW2 over at that channel.

[@DylanMcMullen]

shrillbert Which channel is that?

[@ColasTeam]

Dylan McMullen look for "world war 2 every day" on youtube and you'll find it.

[@VladTevez]

The moment you realize that if you survive this, indeed you will be home by Christmas

[@marrymekatsuya]

V. Athanasiou were coming home!

[@AnimeOtaku2]

Sadly I’m pretty sure that they will be fighting until 1920 at this rate.

[@arjan6111994]

Hurray!

[@astrobot4017]

And then you get killed by the Spanish Flu

[@VladTevez]

Player 1 Yes, but it's different to die in your home than a muddy trench

[@namewarvergeben]

We've had a lot of 'firsts' in this war so far, now we're getting to the 'lasts'

[@teh_reel_nb5632]

Cheers to all our Aussie friends from Canada!

[@anomalocaristheabnormalshr3248]

Me too! I’m from Canada!

[@geoffrogerson9937]

🇦🇺+🇨🇦 forever

[@susanhampson446]

Indeed, The ANZAC and Canadians combined were the Allies Shock Troops. The difference as noted was that the ANZAC Soldiers were literally abused prior to Amiens.

[@andreavoigtlander1087]

no cheers

[@TheLazer3]

What is interesting to note is that the air defences that were erected in south eastern Britain during the war, were largely constructed by the Canadian Forestry Crops in 1916. The Corps was asked to assist in the construction of airfields for defence against air raids by the RFC and within a few short weeks the first airfields were finished and by the end of the year a network of airfields had been built all along the coast and outside of London. The contribution of the Forestry is largely unknown even in Canada where it barely rates a mention at all even from the most important military historians like Tim Cook. That is why I have settled on writing my masters thesis on the history of their operations in Britain and France during the war. These men made a huge contribution to the war effort and they should be recognized as having done such.

[@kjeezy2990]

TheLazer3 cool, thanks for the interesting bit of Canadian history

[@bencobley4234]

Nice one.

[@hemshah4127]

DO NOT LOSE YOUR FAITH! Our Connie ( Hotzendorf) will rise from the ashes and secure a Central powers victory.

[@arjan6111994]

With experience in winter offensives, it would be easy to end the war with a victory for the central powers. By Christmas, the victory is celebrated with a dinner between Hötzendorf, Hindenburg and Ludendorff in Paris.

[@finntadie191]

I forgot is it next week or the week after when Hotzendorf ousts Franz and proclaims himself Kaiser?

[@nekman8521]

I will cry if we don’t win. Deutschland Deutschland Uber alles.

[@MrCordycep]

His cunning nature merely has him biding his time, waiting for the perfect time to attack.

[@silvioevan11]

In his autobiography, the Red Baron commented about his first meeting with Ludendorff: "It is a weird feeling to be in the room where the fate of the world is decided." Just change "room" for "battlefield" and I bet many soldiers from both sides would say the same about the Battle of Amiens.

[@dclark142002]

Indeed. Though most would say that Amiens was merely the moment when it became apparent that the stalemate could and would be broken. At last, all the effort building an Allied war machine...mobilizing the colonies...figuring out modern war...keeping everyone fed...holding off revolutions at home...convincing the last great industrial power to fully support you...was paying off... ...and the average German soldier, whose efforts for months before this only resulted in the capture of some worthless ground and an inability to break an obviously better supplied enemy; decides to give it up and go home (and try to build a new Europe out of a nationalist or socialist system instead of a monarchy).

[@Nakrin27]

“August 8 is the _black day_ of the German army in the history of this war.” -German General Erich Ludendorff „Der 8. August ist der _schwarze Tag_ des deutschen Heeres in der Geschichte dieses Krieges.“ -der deutscher General Erich Ludendorff

[@Nakrin27]

The Battle of Amiens marked the start of the _Hundred Days Offensive_ and the collapse of the German army. Tens of thousands of Germans began to surrender en masse. German morale had crumbled. The lines along the Western Front were disintegrating. Soldiers were no longer willing to fight to the death. This was the beginning of the end. _Es war der Anfang vom Ende_ ...

[@11Kralle]

"Die Zeigefinger in die Ohren gesteckt und lauthals 'Tri-tra-tra-la-la...' singen!" - Bund deutscher Optimisten. "Put both index-fingers in your ears and shout 'lalalalala...' as loud as you can!" - the unknown german zelot.

[@mikhailv67tv]

The day the WAR was won in the West.. yeah..for THE ANZAC CORP & CANADIAN CORP... BUT SADNESS ENSUED AS IN 3 MONTHS THE ANZAC's WILL BE EXHAUSTED AND TAKEN OUT OF THE LINE.😀 But 😢

[@wattlebough]

mikhailv67 That’s right. The 5th of October at Montbrein was the last action the Australians saw on the Western Front. The entire 5 Divisions of the Australian Corps had been in continual action since April 1918 without relief as the British High Command squeezed every drop of effectiveness out of the Australians until they were exhausted. After 5th of October the entire Corps was removed from the British line and sent to Paris and London for rest and convalescence. They were heading back to the front as the news of the Armistice was announced. They’d done more than there fair share of bleeding. In the final year of the war they’d captured over 20% of the Germans captured by the BEF, and a similar percentage of the ground taken, but they comprised only around 10% of the British forces.

[@seanlander9321]

Thanks to the Australians, the breakthrough was made.

[@brettfavreify]

Thanks for the shout-out to Arthur Currie and the Canadians. They were the shock troops to the start of the 100-days war. They kicked off the offensive, kept the pressure on and had the German army backpeddling into the fall.

[@timmcdonald5335]

Aren't you forgetting the Australians?

[@seanlander9321]

Incorrect. The Australians led, the Canadians, British, Americans, then the French followed. The proof isn’t just the record of the Amiens offensive, it’s the capture of the German artillery by the Australians that is all the evidence needed of which army was in the lead, and which followed, because artillery is positioned miles behind the front.

[@brettfavreify]

@@seanlander9321 Bullcrap

[@brettfavreify]

@@seanlander9321 Between Aug and Nov 1918 Arthur Currie and the Canadian Corps spearheading the 100-Days Offensive.

[@seanlander9321]

@@brettfavreify Simply not true. The ‘spearhead’ was the Australians, the Canadians followed. It was the Australians who captured the German artillery, without that the breakthrough would have failed by a German counter attack. You also seem to be unaware that Rawlinson asked Monash who he wanted on his flank, he asked for the Canadians. Being on the Australian flank meant that the Canadians were behind the Australians, as was every other allied army.

[@cbut_1727]

I have a question for Out of the Trenches. Have there been any reports of strange paranormal events that might have happened in the trenches. I imagine the shell shock and all the dead bodies might’ve made some soldiers see things. Thank you Indy and the crew for making amazing content.

[@harshmalarkey5916]

ButterWarrior this, bring on the inexplicable

[@comet1970]

There's the Angels of Mons. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Angels_of_Mons

[@akillerpacman1709]

I asked the same question!

[@cbut_1727]

comet1970 thank you, guys.

[@billhuber2964]

ButterWarrior look no further to Europe . a lot of American. C.W. battlefields have a lot of paranormal activities .Gettysburg for one .

[@1969cmp]

The blueprint for the Amiens offensive comes from Monash's Battle of Le Hamel on the 4th of July, the first battle to incorporate infantry, artillery, tanks and planes simultaneously. Mongomery inspected Monash's plan post Le Hamel and use this plan at Al Alamein a few decades later.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

Your last statement is total nonsense. At that time in WW1 Montgomery was a major . So he goes to a Lt General and has a look at his plan. 😂

[@1969cmp]

@@anthonyeaton5153 ...what on earth are you on about...after Le Hamel, Monty went to Monash and absorbed everything that Monash had planned and utilised that plan decades later. What has their rank to do with anything.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

Hamel was a tactical battle in which more Australians were killed than there were wounded. British artillery facilitated the victory.

[@flores841000]

German soldier 1918, "With our war being so close to being over i am more scared than ever before. At last i can imagine a future. Not one with Germany as victors but one where i see my family once again. So now the thought of dying terrifies me."

[@LeHappiste]

This game is so dumb.... German soldiers in summer 1918 didn't have that hindsight about the war coming to an end. For what they knew, Germany could have stalled the war for another 2 years

[@HaNNibal97smiTH]

That's it...that final Ludendorff quote means the beginning of the end.

[@ncrveteranranger9126]

Massimiliano Palladini sadly...

[@NotSaddamHussein]

The ending quote is deep man....

[@michaelsnyder6922]

This has to be one of the most brilliantly conceived and produced series ever on KZbin. I love everything about it

[@Bobbymaccys]

So great meeting Indy and Flo at Bovington tank Museum! People say never meet your heroes. I disagree!

[@timmcdonald5335]

I think it is accepted that General Monash prepared the battle plans for Amiens. Rawlinson just recommended them to the high command.

[@brasschick4214]

This constant negating of Monash’s work is sad and shows the ongoing effect of the anti-semitism that he faced.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

Monash picked the brains of other commanders and conferred with them asked their opinions. It was the brilliant accuracy of the artillery that made the attack such a success. Australia had 800 men killed out of 1300 casualties a shocking percentage for a battle meant to protect the infantry.

[@seanlander9321]

@@brasschick4214 Not antisemitism at all. Monash was Australian, that was enough for the British to despise him. Britain continued the tradition after the war by insisting that only Australia had to repay war loans in full, then again in 1953 by agreeing with the Germans that only Australia be excluded from reparations.

[@matt6477]

@@seanlander9321Monash was held in the highest esteem by the British…. It was an Empire Army. Lots written by people who have never served in the military (at a reasonably high rank) 7:34 and don’t understand how a military command system works.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

Monash picked the brains of other arms senior officers for his Hamel plan .

[@ltdowney]

Will you be doing a special on the so-called "Lost Battalion" and Major Whittlesey next month when the Meuse-Argonne kicks off? As an American, I recognize that our overall contribution in the First World War was somewhat limited, especially by comparison with the Second, but their story is truly harrowing.

[@the_Kutonarch]

They should make a special on it just because we've finally got an American to admit -in writing- that they're not biggest badass ever and that they're the reason that the Allies won WW1, simply because of them, and them alone. I mean I get ww2, but when you get seppos trolling how they won ww1 single-handedly... 😐

[@bazzatheblue]

I saw the service for the first day of the battle at Amiens cathedral yesterday on bbc1,very moving.All nations who took part represented as far as I could tell.

[@gaslightstudiosrebooted3432]

No matter. The Kaiser will dine in Versailles yet.

[@marrymekatsuya]

Gaslight Studios I agree

[@happy-go-commie]

I'm not sure if he ever managed to visit Paris after his abdication and exile, but in Miranda Carter's book The Three Emperors, one of Wilhelm's frustrations in life was not to be invited by anyone even once to Paris -- he's probably one of the few European royalties never to have visited the city at all.

[@dorkmax7073]

The most incredible cannonade I've ever heard, quite unending! Swept round us in a wide curve of red leaping flame! This infernal bombardment! The noise and the smoke! Just concentrate on your bayonet. Imagine it piercing the hearts of the Hun. Every last one of em!

[@viliussmproductions]

"And I reach the end of another week" A true hero, Indie!

[@rexmundi3108]

Amiens has always been of particular interest to me as my great uncle died there fighting with what would later become the Cape Breton Highlanders. Always hoping to see his face in some of this old film footage.

[@justsceptic3085]

in march 1918 when british front at amiens were crushed by germans petain send immediatly 40 french divisions and save the british army,on 1940 in the dreadfull days of dunkirk, petain ask to churchill"where are your 40 divisions? that's the different point of vue of french and british history...

[@RobertReg1]

So hard to listen to this stuff. So sad. First time I listened to Carlin's BFA I was kind of sickened... Thanks so much for sharing the true depth of where our leaders took us.

[@Nick_Thorne]

What an absolute pleasure to meet you and the team in Bovington yesterday. What a great day.

[@LuvBorderCollies]

It seems so long ago but there are people alive today who were alive on August 9, 1918. Growing up I knew a lot of people who were born in the 1800's. My great grandparents were alive when Custer got killed. Time and history really get compressed when you view it through your preceding generations.

[@OldFellaDave]

Rawlinson should take a LOT of credit for the spectacular successes of August and onwards to the end of the war. He encouraged and fostered the plans of his subordinates - including Monash and Currie, and gave them the room to develop their tactics and 'fight' the war. it's also worth noting that King George would rush to the front and Knight John Monash in the Field on August 12th - the first man to receive a knighthood in the field in over 300 years. Might give clue as to who many people thought was responsible for the breakthrough ;)

[@seanlander9321]

Exactly. Without the Australians the attack was lost, because they took the German artillery which meant that there was no counter attack, for the first time in four years of war.

[@GeneralSmitty91]

The beginning of the end

[@comradecallum5564]

Great video again, also was great to see you at tank museum yesterday as well as seeing you last year at stow Marie's

[@akillerpacman1709]

Question for OOTT besides old Franz’s assassination, were there any attempts made on leading generals,heads of state lives during the war? Keep up there great work, your almost out of the woods yet *subtle foreshadowing*

[@happy-go-commie]

Lenin survived an assassination attempt on 30 August 1918 by a woman named Fanya Kaplan. Wilhelm II survived an assassination attempt too, but that was in 1901. Rasputin wasn't a head of state, but he was very influential in Russian politics.

[@akillerpacman1709]

I’m convinced Rasputin must’ve been a vampire or at least very lucky for the amount of effort it went in to killing him

[@jonwebb6644]

There is the murders of the Tsar and his family.

[@jorikrouwenhorst7220]

must be weird being a English/french soldier landing in vladivostok

[@eduardovaldivia5572]

I wonder what the locals were thinking?

[@mikefingbond3888]

Wow, fellas. 3 months left. This has been such a fantastic project. Thank you for all your hard work the last 211 weeks.

[@foxph0rus]

Here it is: Everyone’s favorite map.

[@iineo]

That game died over a year ago

[@HaNNibal97smiTH]

I hate it

[@ChevyChase301]

Foxphorus what about Sinai?

[@HaNNibal97smiTH]

Quentin, Sinai, Grappa are the best maps of vanilla game

[@kueller917]

Its so surreal hearing about even little things like the "last" zeppelin destroyed. The whole war now feels like it's grinding slowly to a halt, and this show has been so routine for the past few years I still can't comprehend that finishing too.

[@blockmasterscott]

Indy, I just wanted to say thank you for these 4 years of a really deep education. I cannot possibly over state how much I learned. Thank you.

[@atsekoutsoube]

Started watching this excellent series in February 2016 and today I finally caught up. Still many special episodes to be seen. But surely well done to all contributors of Great War

[@Daniel-vi7ci]

Best Channel on youtube. You make history lessons in school obsolete. Keep up the great work!

[@StickWithTrigger]

4:20AM? YEAHHH BOIIII BLAZE THAT GERMAN ARMY

[@averageconsumer0]

*smoke gas every day*

[@MrCordycep]

The German army got pretty badly ripped.

[@Lurch4539]

Lmao

[@JPEnoobs]

I truly love watching these videos, keep up the great work indie!

[@breandank3026]

I feel like before the war ends, you guys should do a poll, to see how many people support the entente or the central powers.

[@ProvidenceNL]

fantastic video as always, Indie, every video i see on this channel makes me more eager for the second world war series. love it!

[@shanelennon9359]

General Monash seams to have a different view of August 8th. The way it reads the plan to counterattack the Germans was his. I expect you have read it if you haven't then you can find his memoirs in the Gutenberg Libary. Search the Australian victories in France in 1918 by general sir John Monash, g.c.m.g., k.c.b.

[@sam_uelson]

Pause at 5:20 you'll see a tank labelled fray Bentos. This must have been footage from earlier in the war, as she became famous at the battle of paschendaele in 1917

[@thechief00]

Been looking forward to this episode ever since I caught up last Christmas - bring on the Hundred Days!

[@jonjits]

Hope you enjoyed meeting all the fans at Bovington yesterday. I was the guy with the AT-AT Imperial Walker t-shirt. Thanks for the photo.

[@shakeyraver]

Anyone else see that that tank was called fray bentos at 5.19 made me chuckle.

[@LordVltor]

Am I really following this show by 4 years now? So long. And I really cannot imagine someone doing war for the same amount of time. Indeed, I was wondering: has been ANY soldier who joined on the first day of war who sought ALL the war until the end, got back home unscathed, or at least without permanent injuries?

[@bobporch]

My grandmother's brother fought in the Canadian Corp, enlisting in 1915. He was wounded twice, and sent to England to recover. Then back to those horrible trenches. He was in the attack on Aug 8. On the 9th, the German resistance stiffened and he was cut down by a machine gun. I came across some of his letters several years ago. The Canadians have an extensive digital war archive I have been searching. Thank you for posting this video. I liked the old photos. I can't even begin to grasp what a horrible affair this was.

[@UnknownUser22759]

May I ask what archive you used? Was it the Library and Archives of Canada? My 2nd great grandfather was with the 8th battalion (90th Winnipeg Rifles) during the battle of Amiens.

[@bobporch]

@@UnknownUser22759 What a unique day to hear from someone who also had a relative in the 8th Battalion. Private Maxwell Melville was his name. He also fought in the Boer War. There Is an extensive online Canadian war library that I will send specifics on shortly. I will look up more specific information for you. Max enlisted at Moose Jaw with a Mounted Rifle Unit that was merged with another before going over. He was from outside of Saskatoon. They fought as dismounted infantry. He had his mother, sister and a brother he lived with before enlisting. The sister came to the US and was my grandmother.

[@bobporch]

@@UnknownUser22759 I was a university researcher and moved recently. I was going through old files tonight to purge files I will no longer use. I will make an effort this evening to find what I printed out and sent you the web address as well as specific pages to go to. Max's " little black book" said 1st company, but I don't know on which of 3 tours he wrote that. The archive provides the secret orders for the battle, basically everything put on paper. I spent hours digging, one thing led me to another. I can't believe I've heard from a relative of someone in the same unit.

[@bobporch]

@@UnknownUser22759 I have tried to reply with web page addresses several times but they do not go through. I will try another way. The 8th Battalion (90th Reg) was part of the 2nd Canadian Brigade, 1st Division: aka Little Red Devils. Their shoulder patch was a red rectangle. How to read a Record of service or casualty form (First World War) from Government of Canada, Library and Archives. 1st Division Plan of Operations: Aug 1918 Appendix # 2 p.1 Aug 1918 War Diary General Staff Aug 1918 War Diary Daily Intel Reports Aug 1918

[@bobporch]

@@UnknownUser22759 How to read a Record of service or casualty form (First World War) bac-lac. from Government of Canada, Library and Archives. 1st Division Plan of Operations: Aug 1918 Appendix # 2 p.1 data2. then collectionscanada followed by .ca then/e/e013/e000312820.followed by forward slash dot jpg Aug 1918 War Diary General Staff /e/041/e001024251forward slash jpg Aug 1918 War Diary Daily Intel Reports Aug 1918 /e/e042/e001027328dotjpg

[@TRUECRISTIANJESUS]

My dad died in battle Amiens R.I.P. dad

[@TRUECRISTIANJESUS]

99

[@TRUECRISTIANJESUS]

supported slavery I would have a profile picture of the stars and stripes or the likes of the British Union jack! Also I'm neither left or right I don't fall for the divide and conquer. You obviousl

[@Jarod-vg9wq]

Today once more is the anniversary of one of the most important battle of history, the era of true modern warfare has begun

[@randomlyentertaining8287]

I just realized how much the Spring and Hundred Days offensives mirror the Kursk and Bagration offensives. A giant, all out attack that takes some ground but is unable to be held followed by another massive attack by the opposite side that, in the end, leads to the capitulation of the originally attacking side.

[@donaldhill3823]

As always a great show and very informative. As we get closer to the end I hope you have a follow up show in the planning.

[@wizofoz0605]

August 8th was 100 percent Monash. He took the plan to Rawlinson as a larger scale extension of Hamel, got the Canadians involved to protect his right flank (cause he didn't trust the French provincials) and co-ordinated the whole battle plan in extraordinary detail. He came up with and executed the 'double leap frog' manoeuvre, where two divisions, line abreast attack, and hold then two more divisions from the rear push through this position- leap frog- them to advance with fresh troops. This was the day where squads of armoured cars were first used like cavalry to push through the enemy lines and capture strategic information and cause havoc.... such innovations, such genius The Aussies and Canadians and to some extent the Brits on the left smashed through the German defences in a major way and left them reeling. then kept up the momentum for the famous '100 days and pushed them back through the Hindenberg line. This was the day that MONASH won the war.

[@sachaweijdisch9690]

what do you mean by French provincials?

[@seanlander9321]

True.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

So the five British armies of many hundreds of thousands of men were not the ones that helped to win it but c750,000 Australian and Canadians troops. Bullshit on stilts. Don’t you think the excellent delivery of logistics of every kind by the British Army Service Corps might have had something to do with it and the hundreds of aircraft bombing and strafing also. The artillery units had by then perfected their ‘art’ and decimated the German formations to shreds. You always think ‘rifle and bayonet’

[@wizofoz0605]

@@anthonyeaton5153I know that when the Aussies were headed to the front at VB, they encountered theBrits running for the rear away fromn the Germans, They took and held VB, thereby saving Amiens. If the geramns had taken the high ground at VB, they would have shelled amiens rail and logistics depots to shreds and where would your 'excellent logistics' be then? It was after this victory that Monash took his plan to take Hamel to Rawlinson, who approved it, and thus the war was essentially won.

[@markcantemail8018]

There is an August 9th 1918 date on a Tombstone at Mt Hope Cemetery . Seeing this video was timely I have been wondering . Thank you

[@deplorabled1695]

The British were bled white. The insertion of the Australians and Canucks must have been the same feeling for the Empire as having an IV mainlined into the heart. The British and French hung on manfully and grimly along with their allies month after month of unending torture; then the angels from the great north and the sons of the southern cross rose up and slayed the dragon.

[@Litany_of_Fury]

Not bled dry like the Germans, many of the British still had a workforce that was predominantly male. An empire does not run itself.

[@ihjackson5558]

Indy correctly points out that some sources claim that the plans for the battle of Amiens came from the Australian Corps commander General Monash while others do not. It's said that victory has many fathers but it could also be said that the writers of history don't always give credit or enough credit where it is due for all sorts of reasons. While it is undoubtedly true that those responsible for the strategic direction of the war had been planning a major allied counter offensive for some time and had narrowed the area to the Somme Valley (unbeknown to Monash) many still believe that Monash was the true mastermind of the battle of Amiens and the creator of the blueprint on how to win the war in 1918. Former Australian deputy prime minister Tim Fischer, an authority on Australian General Sir John Monash, echoed this sentiment very succinctly when he stated: "It was not at Field Marshal Haig's HQ nearby but at the Lieutenant-General John Monash AIF HQ at Chateau Bertangles where the seeds for victory on the Western Front were devised and implemented.".

[@susanhampson446]

Ian Jackson: I agree that the Aussies raised the CONDITIONS Jointly and along with the Canadians. Canada had more Divisions but they were together formidable and relentless throughout the "100 Days" to Victory at a great Sacrifice.

[@seanlander9321]

@@susanhampson446The battle plan, and the importance of the capture of German artillery to prevent a counter attack were entirely due to the Australians. Every other army followed in their footsteps to Amiens.

[@gnarlycharlie9194]

One indication that John Monash was likely considered the architect of the battle of Amiens by his peers, is that King George V knighted General John Monash the day after battle of Amiens, after inspecting the battlefield. I believe John Monash was the last soldier to be knighted in the field of battle. Please let me know if that is not true.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

Generals plan major strategic battle plans not ! lieutenant generals knighted or not. Enough of this love affair of Monash.

[@Dog.soldier1950]

See “to the last ridge” the memories of W.H. Downing for the Australian POV on this battle

[@Pt_Lacky]

I look forward to this every week! Great work Indie and Crew!

[@scottieman2]

Haven't watched every episode but you are great at keeping up every day. Great videos and interesting.

[@needhelpinwow]

We're gonna be home by Christmas boys!

[@arjan6111994]

Someone told me that 4 years ago... I did not believe it anymore :'(.

[@Groundsey]

This is the episode I’ve been waiting for.

[@The_Furless]

5:52 (and so on in the combat footage) who was recording?

[@Groundsey]

Will you be doing a Special on the Whippet Tank, particularly Musical Box, the Tank which caused havoc behind German lines on August 8th.

[@glm0142]

I think this time war might end before Christmas

[@glm0142]

Prussian Eagle shhh ;)

[@nerdothn892]

Communist dogge me to but don't forget everyone said that in 1914

[@SovietDoge]

C.. Comrade..?

[@glm0142]

Soviet Doge komraaade

[@MrRenegadeshinobi]

Communist dogge that's nonsense and you know it.

[@stupidturntable]

If this had been last year, I would have commented on the maps dark backround colours, making place names pretty darn impossible to read, que in to Al Mudawwarah at 2:40...

[@jimbodeathgrip]

Hope TGW team had a great day at the tank museum yesterday, I was the fan who went the great British beer festival instead.

[@nilsalmquist9424]

This is a fantastic channel. Well done.

[@wormholespacetime]

Real fan of what you do....keep up the great work! Obviously, unrelated to the video but ever since you mentioned Alexander Parvus I'm loosing my sleep over this sucker...could you maybe say a few things in "the Trenches", or do a special....or maybe a whole series on him? What an under-reported figure! Many thanks....Psycho Psyche

[@StickWithTrigger]

i like to think that when the German soldiers saw the tanks and airplanes and field guns coming at them,the bf1 theme started to play in their heads

[@anthropicandroid4494]

+1 for the correct "champing at the bit"

[@lachlanseawright4779]

Question for Out of the Trenches: I am an Australian. Growing up, the paintings and images of Australian troops in the Middle East and elsewhere that I saw in school, particularly the Light Horse, most often showed our troops wearing exclusively our slouch hats rather than any helmets. I see in some of the videos in the episode more helmets used. Was it more common for them to wear the hats or the helmets in combat? Is the frequency of the slouch hat just a part of our mythology?

[@davidlowry8765]

Helmets were worn May 1916 on.

[@seanlander9321]

Erm, check almost every war memorial statue, it’s a bloke with a helmet on.

[@kevindoyle1884]

Incredibly interesting love this channel

[@skiteufr]

Hey Indy, Last week we've seen the French stopping the Germans at 2nd Marne and counter attacking, pushing back the Germans and turning the tide But i've read that the French also took part in the battle of Amiens, sending some divisions and taking half of allies casualties. But you don't talk much about them in this video. What did they do exactly at Amiens ?

[@skiteufr]

Rasputin then if it was mainly British, why the French sustained half of the casualties ? It means they had rather more than a supporting role ?

[@Phantomrasberryblowe]

skiteufr The British also took part in stopping the Germans at the 2nd Marne

[@WastelandSeven]

Canadians and Aussies fighting side by side? From their performance so far I'm glad I wasn't a German soldier!

[@generalripper7528]

They can't have been that impressive. In Germany we only talk about the French and British as serious opponents in WWI.

[@vincentlefebvre9255]

@@generalripper7528 Oh yes they have been . It's an absolute fact . Your sources must have been utterly unserious . And just look at the contingent of canadian airmen . It was the most fantastic of the war . If you can't make the difference between dominions' and UK's involvments during the war that's your problem . Europeans forget easily what these nations accomplished during the war . They did way beyond what could be expected.Within the Empire's forces they performed the best . Not an opinion but a fact . Arthur Currie and John Monash were highly regarded as generals .

[@generalripper7528]

@@vincentlefebvre9255 I don't doubt that. I'm just telling you that in German culture, we don't specifically refer to the Canadians. They are normally just referred to as the British.

[@backalleycqc4790]

General Ripper “A British subject I was born - a British subject I will die.” Sir John A. Macdonald (11 January 1815 - 6 June 1891) the first Prime Minister of Canada.

[@ronmailloux9370]

@@generalripper7528 kinda like canadians refer to germans as squareheads?

[@waltertaljaard1488]

No victory parade at the Champs Elysee on the tunes of the Hohenfriedberger March and Preussens Gloria.

[@GravesRWFiA]

Indy is selling short two things. britain's airdefense was actually well desiged in detail with alternating AA ranges and aircraft patrol regions. once the alarm was given naything in the AA regions that flew was a valid target. ships that survived htis then went into the patrol zones with planes and excaping that enough flack belt. add on radar and you have the WW2 defenses. In amien serious credit must be given to the british artillery who earned their lone battle honor- Ubique. they had surprise because there was no test firing. all the opening volleys were worked out on paper with no test shots to warn the germans. the result was as the shells first came in, they were doingdamage from the first moment.

[@RollinRowdy1198]

Aussies and Canucks on the attack together. That is scary.

[@anthonyeaton5153]

If you study the final map of front line on the 11th, the Australians were ensconced in a small enclave near St Quentin some sixty miles from the front line. Corps do not win wars armies win wars.

[@ciandoyle1620]

"at 4:20 am" what a bunch of memesters those entente powers were

[@luiscastaneda5250]

Great episode 👍😎🎉

[@xXxKAMIKAZExXx]

5:52 Why is there a poorly implemented cut there? Is this from a movie?

[@De.bu.123]

Question for Out of the trenches: After four years of war and horrific losses, do you think the allies, especially the British, would have been able to fight for this long without their colonies and dominions? There seem to have happened quite a lot of the important offensives using Canadian or ANZAC forces.

[@claudiopomponio7671]

Could you make a video on Emanuele Filiberto of Savoy-Aosta, Commander of the 3rd Army?

[@ohayoch.]

Ok thanks still love this channel

[@leedent6796]

Was just playing this Operation on Battlefield 1

[@frankwhite3406]

I've often wondered if The German Great War Zeppelin Fleet was Heleum filled instead of the Highly explosive hydrogen. Would the Zeppelin lose rate been drastically reduced ?

[@BillThompson1955]

Certainly at first. However, helium has less lifting power than hydrogen, which would have reduced the efficiency of the zeppelins considerably. Also the Entente would have been worked on weapons to cause more damage to the zeppelins. Remember that these vehicles were skinned in doped linen, which burned readily; the internal gas bags were fragile, and even if they did not burn (I assume leaking helium would have extinguished any flames) they would lose lifting power if enough holes were punched in them.

[@frankwhite3406]

BillThompson1955 Indeed Hydrogen has far greater lifting power , and the old Zeppelins were such a large target!

[@frankwhite3406]

BillThompson1955 With no Parachutes provided for Zeppelin Crews. Just think what health and safety would think about it today!

[@BillThompson1955]

I'm sure the crews weren't happy about it, even if they accepted the military necessity--parachutes were heavy, and correspondingly cut into fuel and bomb loads. But I think it was foolish to omit parachutes, once they were available and reliable. Each time a Zeppelin was lost (to combat or accidents) you were likely to lose the entire crew. That's a loss of trained and experienced personnel. I don't buy the contemporary argument that parachutes would have tempted aviators to bail out when the situation seemed tough. There wasn't much cowardice in the skies, and most fliers felt safer and more in-control with their machines than without them.

[@wuugaa6776]

Frank White Helium was extremely scarce back then, even in the 20s the USS Shenandoah alone used a big part the world's reserves

[@fabricio-agrippa-zarate]

Hey Indy, the first world war is my inspiration for a sci-fi novel that I am currently writing. It's a futuristic 3ww very similar to the Great War. It's a little bit crazy the story so far, with Spain, Germany and Russia as allies against the US, France and Great Britain as the "axel".

[@fabricio-agrippa-zarate]

Oh, and "arditi" soldiers.

[@Klingoncodfan]

Sounds interesting! Where it will be available to take a look?

[@fabricio-agrippa-zarate]

José Manuel Aranda I would like to post it in a blog, but I believe is gonna take me this whole year to finish, because it's quite complex and I don't want to mess it all by hurring up.

[@Freddie1980]

5:55 - Is that a reenactment? If that was for real that cameraman must have balls of steel.

[@claymore2000]

You guys had awesome fighting footage today! Where did you find it? Awesome episode!

[@angels2online]

Combined forces attacks warm my heart ♥

[@LordVader1094]

Of course it'd be where the attack would be most successful that launched at *4:20* in the morning.

[@plumpstery5199]

7:45 song name ?

[@MartinIDavies]

Battle of Amiens.. the nations of "5 eyes" take the field for the first time together under a single command and engage in the battle that resulted i the end of WW1

[@jamestang1227]

Lets push the bocce all the way to the Hindenburg Line! And then we will break that! We will push the Germans out of France and liberate Belgium! Push them to the Rhine and then to the Elbe and then Berlin! For His Majesty the King, the Tricolour and the Stars and Stripes! Onwards men!

[@Simping4cats]

James Tang This deserves all the likes. ALL of them!

[@ThisIsEduardo]

GREAT VIDEO

[@007Davis]

Tip top video chaps

[@jonathangray9870]

PS: Monash planned the operation to take place for 90minutes - it took 93

[@anthonyeaton5153]

PPS. and more Aussies were killed than were wounded yet Monashe’s plan was to protect the infantryman. Also, it was the British artillery that facilitated the victory.

[@conradyo9274]

Could you do a video on Douglas MacArthur and Patton meeting on the battlefield