The Caretaker - Libet's Delay - Comparison

Another comparison video, this time on the use of Goodnight, My Beautiful/Libet's Delay throughout some Caretaker Albums.
(Reuploaded because I forgot Libet's All Joyful Camaraderie.)
Original Sample: www.youtube.com/watch?v=nK2vJ...
00:00 - Russ Morgan - Goodnight, My Beautiful (Sample)
01:47 - AEBBTW - Libet's Delay
02:39 - Stage 3 - Back There Benjamin
03:42 - Stage 3 - Libet's All Joyful Camaraderie
04:45 - Stage 3 - Libet Delay
05:47 - Stage 4 - Post-Awareness Confusions 2
06:58 - Stage 5 - Advanced Plaque Entanglements 2
08:20 - Stage 5 - Synapse Retrogenesis
09:23 - Stage 5 - Sudden Time Regression into Isolation
09:58 - Stage 6 - A Confusion so Thick You Forget Forgetting
11:12 - Stage 6 - A Brutal Bliss Beyond This Empty Defeat
Support The Caretaker here: thecaretaker.bandcamp.com/

[@audomarisgay]

The madman who was able to hear the song all the way to stage 6 and perfectly identify it is the real thing we should be afraid of

[@juicebox6124]

Pretty sure most of those people either speed up the “song” like crazy or use spectrograms at the point, very rarely people also do get lucky of course

[@OofioTheOriginal]

Real

[@watchpointoh3354]

I could hear the signature muted trumpet, albeit extremely low pitched and almost inaudible next to the other sounds.

[@erinerwine2809]

Actually, post awareness confusions is literally libets delay backwards and slightly tweaked, looking up “libets delay reversed” and going to 0:12 on one of the videos will give you the start of “post awareness confusions” not many know this!

[@penitentestudios1492]

This man is no ordinary human being

[@easygoing9328]

I love how the Caretaker added the little Easter egg of late neurologist Benjamin Libet throughout the album

[@Joesgamesntech]

Now I finally know who Benjamin is! Wow that one was annoying me, I was wondering if we would ever get an explanation, idk maybe a grandson but now there's context!

[@Binx_Official]

Back there Benjamin and Libets Delay or Libet Delay and the many alterations

[@TheEditFactory]

So that's why it's Back There Benjamin, Libet's Delay, ect.

[@blazoraptor3392]

@@Joesgamesntech Also, "libet's delay" is the scientific term used for the phenomenon in which one consciously feels a touch approximately 0.5 seconds after they have been physically touched. It is one of the findings that structured the idea that our memories and consciousness are directly linked to our physical brain, and not an external entity such as a soul. Meaning, if parts of our physical brain are destroyed, so does part of our consciousness. However, terminal lucidity puts a massive hole in a lot of this. It happens too little and for too little time to be studied and as it is, we don't understand why it happens.

[@PacoCotero1221]

@@blazoraptor3392 Is terminal lucidity an actual thing? Or is it like spontaneous combustion

[@ford9505]

The Stage 4 rendition stands out to me because it's the chunk right before the hell sirens. It's like the Caretaker's inability to recall the song is what triggers the outburst of despair. Even if that's not what was intended, it's what I take from it.

[@connortollit6120]

That’s... wow, that’s a really interesting take. I’ve always just thought it was the last time the caretaker remember he has dementia but that makes a LOT more sense considering libet’s delay plays 3 times in stage 3. I love all the little details hidden in the masterpiece, it’s amazing!

[@muhammadriedhoramadhansyaf5086]

Agreed

[@loganmcgranaghan5324]

Me listening to that stage 4 song: What a horribly scary song, I sure hope the next one isnt as scary

[@babak1hehexd908]

Wait, you guys are able to remember the post-awareness stages? I can't even remember them at all. I forgot everything about those stages, so I had to listen to the album again. I honestly never knew that the Hell Sirens even existed, it sounded so new to me when I listened to it. The only parts I can remember about those stages without anyone telling me about it is the last few minutes in stage 6. That shit was terrifying

[@theununtrium]

@@babak1hehexd908 when i first listened i didnt even notice the hell sirens

[@ball730178]

the fact I didn't even know they were in the later stages retroactively reinforces the bone chilling reality of this album's message. it's a song I had already heard, even enjoyed. and it was right there again. but to me, it was nothing. just noise. noise I had never heard before

[@Iknowhowbadthisnameis8828]

Fuck dementia

[@illioptopede]

Its weird, as much as I love Goodnight, My Beautiful, it doesn't quite have the same charm as Libet's Delay.

[@illioptopede]

Also, Back There Benjamin sounds like a mix between a fever dream and overstimulation

[@t__9119]

For me it’s the grainy sound in the background. It feels like it’s a really old record playing on a gramophone

[@alexsiemers7898]

Libet’s Delay has that sense of reminiscence to it

[@enbylez1170]

i completely agree. something about the reverberated/echoing piano roll in the beginning in libet’s delay has so much weight to it. it sounds like what i can only imagine recognizing someone from a past life would be like.

[@omarzahr2414]

yes i find the caretaker's renditions of the old timey songs much more pleasant to listen to (i.e it's just a burning memory, misplaced in time, libet's delay, all you are going to want to do is get back there)

[@OriArian]

"Reuploaded because I forgot Libet's All Joyful Camaraderie". Oh no...

[@gamerreal-real-]

A1 its just a burning memory starts playing

[@Jay-uu5lu]

He forgor 💀

[@Thetumbleweed662]

NOT HIM TOO!

[@774game]

I remembered it as "Benjamin's Camaraderie" honestly

[@user-fs1tc3xp3f]

​@@774game [Heartaches, heartaches Me loving you meant only heartaches Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me I can't believe it's just a burning memory]

[@capitaln8826]

The fact that someone could tell there was pieces of the song in stage 6 is quite the talent

[@JustinCantDoUsernames]

The power of people with *really* good headphones

[@nathanjohnpalaogaming4872]

Dementia: you can't defeat me. A persin trying to remember a song: i know, but they can. *_PEOPLE WITH EXPENSIVE BLUETOOTH EXPLODES A RANDOM BUILDING LIKE A CREEPER_*

[@samtamargo7232]

Yeah I couldn’t hear anything

[@RaiNIceDog]

@@nathanjohnpalaogaming4872 CREEPER?! AWWW MAN...

[@Wind-nj5xz]

@@JustinCantDoUsernames And people who speed up the songs

[@CyphersBasement]

I describe this video as "a simulation of what it's like to get a new job, from loving it to dreading it."

[@themancaph]

XD it's good damn true bro

[@Guest-lq6vt]

😂

[@erikbrand6682]

facts

[@ShwappaJ]

Yep

[@maglev957]

So BTB is angry Libet's Delay, LAMC is sad Libet's Delay and Libet Delay is very sad Libet's Delay

[@finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838]

Yup, I guess its supposed to represent the sudden mood changes. In BTB alone, the mood changes from anger, to sadness, to an uncomfortable happiness.

[@AmalgraemeV]

@@finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 That's exactly what I took from each song, interestingly. Fascinating.

[@poppingcandycookieuwu3115]

i think lamc is lajc

[@richardw6859]

libet delay is anggry

[@wvvj_animates]

And in LAJC its more upbeat

[@connortollit6120]

Back there Benjamin is so creepy to me, the way that it cuts from a sad song at the end of stage 2 to a upbeat, reverby song is just weird and the fact it repeats so many times on the same stage like you forgot you just tried to remember it. I wish I knew what Layland Kirby went through to make this album because listening to it is scary enough I can’t imagine what you would have going through your mind making this.

[@benibebenamme]

If I remember correctly, Kirby didn’t have much personal experience with dementia, but he was fascinated with the idea of memory distortion and loss. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nWXVemeuqtSghbs here’s an interview where he explains the story behind the caretaker.

[@hauntedvessel8721]

It’s almost like, at stage 2, the patient is almost fully acknowledging that something is wrong and they need help very badly, but then at stage 3 they fall back into denial by trying feign contentment. ‘Back there Benjamin’ almost sounds like they’re making fun of the idea that they have dementia, or that the whole situation is behind them.

[@masonthechemistryfreak6894]

@@hauntedvessel8721 They probably develop agnosia as the receptors that allowed them to understand what a brain illness like dementia is fails

[@nukacolacompany2534]

I wouldn't even call Back there Benjamin upbeat, the word i would use to describe all of stage 3 is desperation. The entire stage has an intense sense of desperation mixed with the mental decline so that's why it's so hallucinatory sounding

[@reddodeado301]

I'm pretty sure Kirby saw the success of An Empty Bliss Beyond This World, but didn't want to just make a second one of it. Instead, he wanted to make something better, and so he made EATEOT

[@eggegggegg]

"All you are goint to do is want to get back there" Back where? "Back There, Benjamin"

[@melissacapps7349]

"WAIT WHY AM I IN A HOSPITAL BED"

[@namealreadytakenonyt191]

Back there benjamin sounds violent

[@sarahgaming666]

i heard someone say it could be related to the mood changes in late stages of dementia

[@namealreadytakenonyt191]

@@sarahgaming666 oh really?

[@reddeadfan-jz7sx]

@@namealreadytakenonyt191 yes they get really violent then die later due to their brains being into mush

[@namealreadytakenonyt191]

@@reddeadfan-jz7sx maybe its cause that they are too confused and questioning people but the dementia patient doesnt understand everything and it ended up as them going to be violent

[@reddeadfan-jz7sx]

@@namealreadytakenonyt191 i think if you go near the top few comments you check the replies and you'll see it

[@gummigirl]

Goodnight, My Beautiful was used once in the background of a horror show I watch a lot, so I was alarmed when I recognized the song but couldn't place where i heard it before lmao. Creepy

[@MrDill-hr7mk]

If I may ask, which show?

[@mildrewphiladelphia]

Same thing happemed with me with Misplaced in Time, and how it appears in FNAF VHS

[@yeetmyneet1207]

Which show?

[@bella_ciao4608]

@@MrDill-hr7mk probably The Walten Files

[@bella_ciao4608]

@@yeetmyneet1207 i know The Walten Files uses it

[@LittleBigSmoak_]

god damn stage 5 sounds violent

[@luckyotter623]

It is. It's the violence of the mind and all its memories being destroyed by protein plaques and tangles.

[@SomeName_AlsoHandlesSucc]

@@luckyotter623 I interpreted as the caretaker trying harder and harder to remember, and just slips into pure horror at what they have become. Until they forget a out even that.

[@konicks2359]

Actual dementia patients do actually grow extremly violent in stages 4 and 5, because their brains can no longer make sense of the world so it interprets it as a threat and enters a sort of fight or flight, many dementia patients during this state brake down really easily, go into random crying and screaming fits, become violent etc. Then by late mid stage 5 their brains becomes mush so ut stops

[@luckyotter623]

@@konicks2359 I remember my MIL, when she reached stage 5 (actually stage 6 in the medical community) become very emotionally labile, not so much violent, but would have crying and screaming tantrums like a toddler. At this stage, they are in fact toddlers emotionally and mentally, and it's around this time they lose control of their bowels/bladder and stop being able to use language very well. Most of what they say doesn't make much sense. They are regressing back to infancy (this is what synapse retrogenesis refers to). It was so heartbreaking with my MIL, because she'd sometimes have lucid moments and suddenly become aware of what she had become, which would set off another screaming tantrum. We had to put her into a care home around this time. It broke my heart that the only lucid times she had, were filled with so much self hatred and shame. I wished I had been more understanding. If only I knew then what I know now thanks to the Caretaker and EATEOT.

[@bensoncheung2801]

@@luckyotter623 dang

[@chaospacemarine8330]

4:24 that trumpet is so tonally dissonant, never fails to completely unnerve me

[@MrCrass-th8ie]

ITS A TRUMPET?! I've always thought it was someone saying LIBET!

[@ceilingfan6969]

THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYIN

[@paintball7797]

I thought it was a voice, but yeah it kinda sounds like a trumpet.

[@pinkimark1018]

THAT'S WHAT I'M SAYIN

[@ShwappaJ]

It's consonant, it's just so slowed down and out of touch that it creates a sense of "naw fuck this I don't like it"

[@Jeri2003]

You can barely hear it, in fact, you probably can't hear it at all during " Post Awareness Confusions 2", " advanced plaque entanglements 2", " synapse retrogenesis", " sudden time regression into isolation", but yet in " a confusion so thick you forget forgetting", and " a brutal bliss beyond this empty defeat" you can hear it just a little

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

It’s definitely there, just that it’s slowed down and the pitch is shifted, as well as it being all choppy. A huge chunk of Post Awareness Confusions 2 is Libet’s Delay

[@upseguest]

@@thelegendarybulldozer7256 hey can u upload post awareness confusions 1 libet delay i want to hear it

[@Derpy_fish63]

@@upseguest I dont think it shows up until post awareness confusions 2

[@luckyotter623]

I can actually hear it really well in Post Awareness confusions 2, but it's chopped up quite a bit.

[@fries5849]

You can hear the vocals in post awareness confusions 2 just very choppy and distorted

[@misterdandy3196]

Libet's Delight, Denial, Delay, Despair, Derail, and Defeat all in one video.

[@Gardengap]

And also Libet’s first name Banjamin

[@byronius7012]

0:41 Back There Benjamin ruined this part of the song for me so much that now even the original version sounds creepy af to me

[@Thorin-MattfromGO]

The original isn’t much faster or higher pitched than it. On audacity, you only have to change the speed of the original by -11 to get it to sound like it. Usually if you want a sample to sound like a caretaker song you have to change the speed by at least -30.

[@byronius7012]

@@Thorin-MattfromGO Interesting. Perhaps Kirby chose to sample that part of the song for BTB because it already has an eerie vibe to it on its own, even if that wasn't the original composer's intention

[@corvax8644]

Honestly tho it does. Like even if I hadn’t of heard btb first I still would think it’s kinda off

[@RubyPiec]

the entire song gives me nightmares because of a shitpost I made where every single song samples that

[@John-X]

I was just about to say that i hadn't heard the original song before, and it sounded just as creepy as the Eatot version...

[@lisandro5612]

It feels like chewing an bubblegum and feel as the flavor slowly fades away

[@no_name_idea7386]

pro tip:eat a bit of something to give the chzwing gum that flavor

[@WereComingHomeBoyes]

@@no_name_idea7386i tried to eat some B R E A D with it, tasted weird but yeah it kinda works

[@finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838]

If you speed up Stage 6 by about 4 times you can hear Libet's Delay very clearly at some points

[@bingobeego]

kzbin.infoV7IhRM2Gi7Y?feature=share

[@birdlovesart]

Yeah you can very clearly hear the trumpet in the first stage 6 part aside from all the ufo sounds

[@droptherapy2085]

I swear this whole project makes me feel like I'm in an old abandoned modernist painting

[@jrk1666]

sounds like its the nightmare artist in audio mode

[@jordanwright9680]

somebody GETS what I feel about this album

[@thezipcreator]

Watching this made me remember just how terrifying this album really is

[@v1c-was-her3]

The fact that samples can still be heard in Stage 6 is incredible and also mildly unnerving cause it implies that the person still has some of their selves left in them, but theyre so far gone theyre shrowded by emptiness and unable to do practically most things. Theyre there still, potentially, deep deep down, but theyre also no longer there

[@MrRussianDollOfficial]

It's like a stage 1-6 all of it's own

[@christiangrey3645]

Back There Benjamin is very scary to me as it's the point where things really start to take a turn for the worst.

[@Zenyx64]

I like how one track with the sample in Stage 3 has the name Benjamin, while the other two have Libet. It's a neat nod to the neurologist Benjamin Libet.

[@Gardengap]

Hi again Yeah, also “Libet Delay” perhaps referencing how he studied that cognitive delay thingy.

[@chillman3606]

​@@Gardengapmaybe also because of his severe timing issues in experiments

[@taylorreal428]

I also love how all the goodnight my beautiful songs have benjamin libet in it's name, it fits so well tbh

[@brandonlee934]

I'm always impressed about people who can figure out the songs in stages 4-6

[@Iknowhowbadthisnameis8828]

They speed Up the audio in Stage 6, and in Stage 4-5 there's some places where you can piece 2 Instruments and notes together

[@bingobeego]

​@@Iknowhowbadthisnameis8828 kzbin.infoV7IhRM2Gi7Y?feature=share

[@H1PP1E88]

goodnight my beautiful: you hear the song while you're in your teen years/twenties libet's delay: you haven't heard the song in a while and forget how it went, not dementia, just bad recollection back there benjamin: you remember where you were when you heard the song and gaze back on the glory days. libet's all joyful camaraderie: same as back there benjamin, but it's starting to fade. libet delay: you try to remember when you had bad recollection of goodnight my beautiful but instead it's libet's delay post-awareness confusions 2: you are very close to remembering when you first heard the song, but it's very foggy advanced plaque entanglements 2: you can't remember it but you have sudden glimpses of it here and there synapse retrogenesis: you try your hardest to remember when you heard it, but all you can think of is your previous attempts sudden time regression into isolation: the last moments you could possibly remember where you were when you first heard it a confusion so thick you forget forgetting: the last moments you remember the song a brutal bliss beyond this empty defeat: you hear a song on the radio. you think it sounds familiar somehow but you've never heard it before, how could you? you must be mistaking this for a different tune

[@MAXTHEKlD]

I’ve been testing myself recently, by listening to AEBBTW before I go to bed, not to torture myself, but to see if it affects my dreams because the music in it reminds me of my childhood. So far it seems to be going well, and honestly, AEBBTW is a very relaxing album.

[@malfunctionnnn]

yeah, an empty bliss and some other not-so-distorted caretaker albums can be really calming and lovely if you allow yourself to forget their context

[@cattoproductions7142]

@@malfunctionnnn I think AEBBTW is Stage 0.5. Its still slowed down looped and a bit distorted but its overall happier

[@Thorin-MattfromGO]

Patience is another calming one and my personal favorite. It’s available to purchase on vinyl right now from boomkat, I bought my copy the day it released.

[@davidholmes2932]

I do the same thing but with Eateot stage 3, I think it's actually quite relaxing and helps me go to sleep tbh

[@gameworld0612]

@@davidholmes2932 I Do that with the entirety of everywhere at the end of time not to relax myself but to see what it would do to my dreams and to be stage one is calming . One time I fell asleep while stage two was playing I think it was denial unraveling and woke up to hell sirens

[@Pentax33]

The image for Stage 3 matches Back There Benjamin so perfectly but I can't put into words why. Something about the sheer amount of scattered chaos.

[@yourtypicalcupoftea]

i think it's because the flowers look chaotic or something while the flowers in stage 2 are normal. back there benjamin is more chaotic than the songs in stage 2.

[@pinkpebble4148]

I think with the context of Stage 2 it almost feels like the song explodes out and things are finally breaking down. Stage 3 imo is the first stage to show that in the cover.

[@furrrkidstudios]

hag my beloved

[@leavonderlieth5781]

It's hard to imagine that someone literally decided to try and find All of one songs references in this album.. especially when you just hear the brokenness of stages 4 and 5.

[@lemonstastesour1379]

What these sound like to me: Goodnight, My Beautiful is a city, Libet's Delay is the city but abandoned for 100 years or so, Back There Benjamin is someone finding the abandoned city, Libet's All Joyful Camaraderie is someone leaving the abandoned city, and Libet Delay is the abandoned city after the person left (idk what the others could be)

[@theununtrium]

The city deteriorating more

[@despairy69]

Post awareness confusions is the "city" getting more old and broken and the advanced plague entanglements and Synapse retrogenesis is the "city" getting destroyed, withered and hollow over time Sudden Time regression into isolation is the hollow shell of the "city" and A Confusion so thick you forget forgetting is the empty place the city left when it got destroyed all thats left is nothing but A Brutal Bliss Beyond this empty defeat is "city" no longer existing

[@CubicApocalypse128]

Stage 4 is the dead city becoming one of the countless battlefields of WW4. Rusted-out tanks roll down the empty streets, reducing once-grand architecture to heaps of smoldering rubble. Sewage tunnels, still radioactive from the last great war, are the new trenches. In stage 5, Homo sapiens is on the brink of extinction. The city's ancient ruins struggle to hold up against ever more extreme natural disasters. Climate change is in full swing, and while this city was far inland, its coastal counterparts have long since drowned in the rising seas. By stage 6, the city is nothing more than a layer of rust and broken glass spread across barren fields of rocky soil that was once concrete. A deadly asteroid is on a collision course with Earth, but there's not much left for it to kill. The impact vaporizes a small village, the last of humanity, in what was once called Antarctica.

[@rattailtony2900]

@@despairy69 It's like Life After People but in audio form

[@MendosaMax]

stage 4 is when a tornado forms and stage 5 is when the city gets destroyed in a war stage 6 is the aftermath

[@alarmlessRifleman]

I got shivers when I realized "Libet's delay" sample was present in the final stage.

[@Alt-vw3uf]

yeah its creepy as fuck bro, i thought this song was beautiful and now im realizing its all over the album

[@Ollimus]

0:41 this shocked me a lot. Mostly because it makes the beginning of stage 3 even more painful to listen to.

[@aesthetic1448]

Im so used to listening to a mostly undistorted version of eateot that I forgot how much reverb there is in the actual album

[@whizkeysh0t]

fun fact! goodnight, my beautiful was also used at The Walten Files at Second chapter: Relocation Proyect, in the bunker scene. Because it glitched and repeated many times i would have assumed its the caretaker's version, but it actually has a different mixing. [edit: fixed issue.]

[@WasabiKitCat]

I think the person who made the Walten Files is a Caretaker fan, since there's a lot of the same samples in it. It's kinda funny, since the creator of FNaF VHS is also a Caretaker fan.

[@youwerethere]

Which part of the bunker scene? The repeating makes me think Billy’s time to shine but I don’t know.

[@evacorrell3116]

@@youwerethere the sha part

[@flixtocicgaming3576]

yeah i know right!

[@hardimonaddictyt9976]

Heartache was also used in walten files (it's just a burning memory is the EATEOT name)

[@heiscomingg8870]

I really like the very first part of back there Benjamin, it just comes and slams right at you.

[@777Rowen]

Whenever I hear the song in the third version I always get scared. I hadn’t noticed it in the previous stages, or if I did I wasn’t paying proper attention. Anyway, when I hear it in stage 3 it sounds so haunting like the echoes of time are fading and you’re desperately trying to hold on...Don’t even get me started on the later stages. Just goes to show how powerful this entire album truly is.

[@oldmann240]

Goodnight, My Beautiful Sample...

[@SuperPerry1000]

I swear this put into perspective how nightmarish this album was. The same song, from clear as day, to slightly dying (stage 3), to a jumbled mess (stage 4), to violent static (stage 5)... and then you get to stage 6 and it's fucking *nothing*

[@boop53]

I can only listen to the 1:47 version. I’m scared to go deeper. There has to be something ironic about this..

[@Radithor]

Back there Benjamin and libet's all joyful are ok. But beyond libet delay sounds broken.

[@Derpy_fish63]

If you only seek irony, then finding anything genuine would be a miracle. It's a great album, but not for everyone.

[@totablezeus4189]

Libet's all Joyful is actually pretty nice.

[@berilysoup9999]

​@@totablezeus4189 Libet's all joyful camarderie is the best one imo

[@gameworld0612]

@@berilysoup9999 to me that Sax in the libets all joyful sounds like it found a spider in the corner of the room and is trying to call for help as all the other instruments are just Vibing

[@Phobic_Nova]

I had no idea Libet Delay was even remotely related to Libet's Delay, but now I can totally hear it-

[@ortherner]

lol

[@erinerwine2809]

Post awareness confusions is reversed libet’s delay…

[@erinerwine2809]

Go to a video of libets delay that’s reversed and go to 0:12 on the video

[@HELLOHELLHELP]

I FOUND YOU.

[@donnaquixote7538]

5:52 Cool, I didn't notice before that this part is Goodnight, My Beautiful, too. It's so jumbled and restless, with no clear rhythmic structure. Thank you for this comparison video! EATEOT is a masterpiece, much like Divine Comedy by Dante: a multi-layered gift that just keeps giving. 💗💗💗

[@fwutig1121]

There are videos where people have taken this part and but all the scattered noise back into the melody of goodnight my beautiful. I think it’s the best way to be able to hear the sample in post awareness stages.

[@krasistefanovlol]

@@fwutig1121 reconstructed like legos 💀💀💀

[@CrowCrojoINTJ]

after listening to the album a few times, I find most if not all the album to be kind of enjoyable and nice at times, and Back There Benjamin is one of my favorite songs of the album honestly

[@theczechoslovakiankamerad7340]

Very underrated video, can you please do comparison for "Heartaches" ( It's Just A Burning Memory ) next?

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

Actually, I have done that before! kzbin.info/www/bejne/i3acpYKMbLtgeK8

[@theczechoslovakiankamerad7340]

Oh, wow! Did not notice that, thank you alot.

[@UserUser-xe9kv]

Farm on the gold mine that is EATEOT song comparisons These vids are not only pretty good but it's also pretty good for channels that make them it seems

[@alphalax7747]

@Kian M ok

[@jujmajuj13]

The one from album 4 made me feel physically sick

[@poppingcandycookieuwu3115]

goodnight my beautiful is coincidential because i always hear this in my head before i sleep

[@user-qe8go6ur8w]

stage 4 be like: lib-lay-cam-re-rie-de-ben-back-de-ere-et's-derie-all-there- stage 5 be like: lib-.... cama... back..... erie stage 6 be like: lib.............................

[@0xDEADBEEF99]

lib

[@user-nn3zc1fj4p]

lib

[@jaeorcy]

lib

[@arkhangelskmapping1497]

lib

[@doggonaut9624]

lib

[@OofioTheOriginal]

0:00 ah yes. Some good music to vibe to. 0:41 *PTSD kicks in*

[@jypeps]

Libet delay part 2 sounds like an empty airport early in the morning

[@gridgalaxy_]

Libet Delay was always so chilling in a sense to me because it always represented the track right before mournful camaraderie and the eventual transition to stage 4 that it sort of represented to me.

[@follet173yearsago9]

Hello can i use the same idea but for another song ,i don’t want to steal your idea

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

You can, I’m not patenting this idea

[@follet173yearsago9]

@@thelegendarybulldozer7256 thank you

[@vibrantgleam]

Okay if you go deeper into like Stage 5 it sounds like something you'd hear in a horror movie

[@viagaming7486]

The coherent version of Libet Delay actually sounds beautiful

[@NOTequinox]

Maybe you can do granada, it's in every post awareness stage

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

I know when it plays in 4 & 5, but do you know when it plays in stage 6? I can’t seem to find it in there.

[@NOTequinox]

@@thelegendarybulldozer7256 it plays twice in Stage 5 (its at 12:16 in synapse retrogenesis), for stage 6 it plays in a brutal bliss beyond this empty defeat at 8 minutes

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

@@NOTequinox Thanks, will check out when I get home from school.

[@eggeater671]

@@thelegendarybulldozer7256 It also plays relatively early on in Stage 4, before the full segment in Confusions 2. (around 4:10 in G1).

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

@@eggeater671 Are you sure it plays in G1? I can’t seem to find it.

[@BlackFlagHeathen]

I honestly like Libet Delay from Stage 3. The very distant, echoey sound gives me a vaporwave-y feel, like I’m sitting just outside a tunnel under an overpass after the apocalypse and I can hear Goodnight, My Beautiful playing from the damaged radio of an abandoned car somewhere in the tunnel.

[@Kait16xo]

The fact that stage 3’s libet delay doesn’t properly finish in certain parts literally made my head twitch. I couldn’t imagine experiencing the feeling in real life

[@youarenotsafe333]

libets delay itself is sad,but back there benjamin adds just more sadness to it..

[@jonah9916]

i can imagine goodnight my beautiful being played on a record during the late great depression and someone has finally had enough

[@thatzombiedude78]

How were you able to hear this and figure out where Libet’s Delay was? I honestly can’t even comprehend it in the 4th and 5th stages

[@Derpy_fish63]

I've always wondered what the heck those weird noises that almost sound like voices were. They're in stage 5 and 6 a little bit. Is that libets delay?

[@MysteryKar]

stage 5 does include a sample of james fitzgerald being introduced

[@Derpy_fish63]

@@MysteryKar I know thats in there. But theres occasionally a sound that sounds like maybe breathing? Can't quite discern what it is

[@lordofrandomspaces3469]

It's the dissonant trumpets from the other pieces of Libet's delay, I believe. It has that same long drawn out sound.

[@MusicTheoryLover]

@@lordofrandomspaces3469 Or even Misplaced in Time. But I could be wrong.

[@DrakkarX]

I was sure I heard it somewhere in EATEOT but I wasnt sure when, *oh no.*

[@eab6692]

I feel so empty and anxious listening to this music in all the stages of the caretaker's albums, its wonderful!

[@thevoiidspeaks]

For me, Back There Benjamin and Libet's all Joyful Camaraderie are like a weak light in the middle of darkness, that dies out in Libet Delay to never come back. These are some of my all time favorite tracks, they bring me so much emotion.

[@viagrabuffalo5141]

Anyone else notice that all of the track names in stage three are the titles from A Bliss Beyond This World?

[@gameworld0612]

I did not noticed but what I did notice is that there’s literally a track in stage three called an empty bliss beyond this world And to me it’s quite unsettling

[@progect3548]

@@gameworld0612 F4?

[@gameworld0612]

@@progect3548 F6

[@progect3548]

@@gameworld0612 that’s what I was talking about yeah

[@vinnytheplayer5500]

And everywhere an empty bliss

[@KnellMortem]

Oh this is a pretty cool song. I wonder where in EATEOT it i- 0:41 Oh, oh no.

[@bensfractals43]

Libet delay is like a film stuck in the projector where the credits roll

[@matthours1783]

This is like going to a new school and slowly hating it more and wanting to go back to your old one

[@DanteTimberwolf]

So basically just school in general

[@CaptainLass]

Thank you so much for this! Goodnight My Beautiful is my favorite sample from this whole project, and seeing how it progresses is kind of a good example of the project as a whole

[@RedStinger_0]

The melody grows fainter and fainter until you can't hear it anymore.

[@thecookieheadedofficial6681]

From these excerpts of the work, one can easily understand that “Goodnight, my beautiful” is a sonata allegro. It also has 3 divisions: exposition (Libet's delay), development of the main theme (Back there Benjamin) and reprise (Libet's all joyful camaraderie).

[@kittychan1839]

Post-Awareness confusions 2 is the creepiest to me, its just the sounds being looped like a cry for help and its very terrifying

[@novagasser9337]

I actually really like the "mellow" is it? Feeling of the sample track. It fills me with a feeling like, "everything has gone bad, but it will be okay"

[@theoneandonlynutzley1946]

I’ve always been intrigued by the segment in Advanced Plaque Entanglements 2. The segment is reused in Sudden Time Regression into Isolation. Noise for noise, it’s the exact same. I wonder if The Caretaker did so to imply that the patient was dreading the moment they would begin to fade completely, so it quietly faded into their mind. I’m not sure though.

[@benjamina6618]

back there benjamin terrifies me especially, it’s got my name, my dad likely has early dementia, my grandmother has it and it’s bad also the fact that I’m a kid listening and may struggle to remember it in my heart old ages

[@Musical_gamer69]

Ngl the trumpet sound in back there Benjamin sounds like sounds like laughing. I imagined it as the Alzheimer’s is laughing at you forgetting everything.

[@RaichuWasCancelled]

Now that's just making it less threatening

[@Musical_gamer69]

@@RaichuWasCancelled yea but now it doesnt sound like shit bc that was my first impression of all the albums

[@ookiiani]

Great video!

[@ShwappaJ]

8:40 I hear a violin from What Does it Matter in the center.

[@katomiccomics202]

How do you even hear the song after stage 3.

[@ortherner]

i can barely hear stage 4’s libet’s delay, but not stage 5 and stage 6

[@g-ray4088]

Libets delay sounds like It's just a burning memory and back there Benjamin combined

[@thekeeper9327]

Why the fuck did KZbin think it was ok to slip this into a Russ Morgan mix I was listening to

[@thelegendarybulldozer7256]

I have no clue KZbin keeps doing that kind of shit with my other videos

[@follet173yearsago9]

Actually it is also in post awareness confusion 1 and advanced plaque entanglements 1

[@scroomers]

If you could recognize this song in stage 6, you've got perception skills the government probably wants to get ahold of

[@ThrillzTheGreatest]

I just don’t anything can be as brilliant as Libet’s Delay. I don’t think of dementia when listening to it, but rather nostalgic memories and places.

[@sweesbees]

i think there’s a majesty in how libet’s delay warps into libet delay. a slightly morose song looking back on fonder memories becomes this empty hollow soundscape where rudimentary notes remain. it hurts to think about how much you don’t remember.

[@juanalvarado8480]

Stage 4 Guide: Post Awareness Confusions 2: Here you hear 2 Libet´s Delay at once but one is going forward while the other goes backwards Stage 5 Guide: Advanced Plaque Entanglements: Post Awareness Confusions 2 and a bit of Libet´s All Joyful Camaraderie winds Synapse Retrogenesis: The first 2 notes of the intro of the winds of Goodnight, My Beautiful, a bit of the piano of Libet´s Delay with pieces of the version of PAC2 Sudden Time Regression into Isolation: Same as the last one but more buried Stage 6 Guide: Libet Delay (Stage 3) but this is able to hear at 2X speed, but this sounds like "moans" P.S: Sorry for my english, its not my official language

[@TeaUnicorn]

i cant even hear the original track in half of these anymore jhhjhjsdhjs i have no idea how OP managed to recognize them!

[@piotrnapora5810]

You want even better? Almost, or maybe all, all samples used by Kirby have been recognised and catalogued. Yes, that includes stage 6

[@epichickensoup]

for some reason these songs are so much scarier in this context than the actual album. in the past I've only ever seen Stage 4 as terrifying, they were all pretty scary here thanks for making this, I can never remember which Stage 1/2 songs the recognizable bits in the end stages are from remembering is almost scarier than the ongoing bliss and void in the latter stages though

[@randysigala3976]

The "Goodnight, My Beautiful" sounds something like what you'd hear from a horror movie credits scene or an episode of a certain television show.

[@the-rickster]

Back There Benjamin sounds like my nervous system when I stub my pinky toe

[@gorii_nyahk]

The "Libet's delay" is the most recognizable to me because of a short horror animation from Battington "Two front teeth". Genuinely terrified me as a kid and o distinctly remeber thjys melody at the end with the devastating ending itself. Implanted in my memory as well as the horror.

[@something_ix]

i've gotta be honest, back there benjamin is one of my favorites. it's up there with the heartaches variants and lullaby of the leaves variants

[@MightyWinz]

Stage 3 Libet Delay is the Burning Despair Does Ache of Libet's Delay

[@thomas2390]

Stage 0 0:01 Stages 1 & 2 1:47 Stage 3 2:39 Late Stage 3 4:45 Stage 4 5:47 Stage 5 6:58 Stabe 6 9:58

[@soidutstluafed8819]

Libet Delay stage 3 is just unsatisfying.

[@UGLYcorey]

5:48 - Libet sorrow decay 6:58 - Empty advanced libet 8:20 - Aching back into libet 9:23 - A delay so far libet is in a slight coma 9:58 - Libets all hellish bliss 11:12 - Libet is dead

[@AmtrakCitiesSprinter64]

The sample used for H1 is Libet’s Delay, from an album called “An Empty Bliss Beyond This World (AEBBTW)”

[@liljitproductions]

Stage 3 is very unpleasant and challenging to enjoy

[@jalapenoandbanana]

How did you find ones in the stages 5 - 6?????? That's crazy

[@danmanuevo4364]

Lol

[@lamapper9]

Notice how all the songs that use Goodnight my Beautiful (and that are actually understandable) have the names Benjamin or Libet in their names. Apparently Benjamin Libet has some kind of connection with The Caretaker.