The Challenge 40 - Rumored Cast Reaction

[@diegoprodriguez]

Seeing so many faces from All-Stars 4, especially Derek and Avery, as well as Jay, leads me to believe a lot of these “outliers” probably had decent runs in All Stars 4

[@kristinab3838]

Or they were just available and were willing to do the time commitment.

[@CamMur-un2jo]

They asked Asaf back for 39 lol they were just available

[@cotterjordan01]

They don’t

[@isaaclillywhite7127]

It's a shockingly good cast to have from the last few. I do wish their alternate of Carley was cast in her era.

[@hudjames11]

CT hasn't lost in a while. He even won The Traitors. Honestly he's the bridge between old and new at this point so while it may be dangerous, he might have the easiest time with alliances.

[@gabihunter1749]

I would love to hear your dream cast in this scenario! Mine would definitely include people like Svetlana, Evelyn and the Miz. I would also love if you did more Challenge reviews. Would like to hear a review of the Island, as you have it higher ranked than most people :)

[@ramblingrandomthings]

IDC if Aviv brings anything her being back just has me excited and intrigued cuz it's so different

[@TheWesterosiNinja]

She carried Darrell more than Darrell carried her in the Duel...

[@ramblingrandomthings]

@@TheWesterosiNinja she definitely held her own she did her thing fr she wasn’t the most entertaining super under edited sadly but I love a viv and hope she does well despite not having the most connections on the cast

[@nh979]

I really don't think Bananas is in danger whatsoever. He may be the most insulated one here. He has a GIANT core of allies in Leroy, Tony, Derrick, Mark, Laurel, Emily, Tori, Jordan, Jenny, Theo, Aneesa, and Kaycee (by extension of Nany) who aren't going to say his name. He also has a bunch of other friends like Michele, Kyland, Brad, and CT who I don't see saying his name either. He's made up with Paulie, Cory, Devin, Rachel, and Amanda who would have normally been people going after him. Josh said he feels indebted to him after he snaked him in USA 2. I think the Era 2 team isn't the biggest fan of him in general, but that's sort of negated by the fact that he's far and away the best guy for them. The only ops I see him MAYBE having are Cara, Nehemiah, and Nia, but I don't see that being a big deal especially since the first two are on his team. His biggest struggle will be navigating the endgame cleanly with too many allies.

[@TheWesterosiNinja]

True if it's a S20 Cutthroat team format where the four teams will be competing. In this format you want to put up your layups for elimination in the beginning and can definitely see everyone on Era2 keep Bananas over Derek C, Ryan, and Brandon.

[@ClitneySpears]

They could’ve easily replaced Ryan with Tyler. I would’ve loved to see how Johnny and Tyler would’ve played this game together.

[@nomoremusic3738]

I would have liked Kyle to come back

[@benscribner2483]

This is a fantastic cast and has a bunch of potential to be great! I wonder what the format could be though? Winning team is immune and the losing teams each have someone thrown into elimination?

[@ZavidWebster]

My Rankings+Alts.: 47. Josh 46. Ryan 45. Derek 44. Jay M. 43. Michele 42. Big Easy 41. Devin 40. Aviv 39. Aneesa 38. Jasmine 37. Olivia 36. Carley 35. Syrus 34. Big T 33. Katie 32. Amanda 31. Brandon 30. Mark 29. Averey 28. Nurys 27. Theo 26. Jonna 25. Darrell 24. Emily 23. Tina 22. Kaycee 21. Nia 20. KellyAnne 19. Ruthie 18. Tori 17. Nehemiah 16. Brad 15. Paulie 14. Fessy 13. Bananas 12. Tony 11. Jenny 10. Horacio 9. Jodi 8. Leroy 7. Rachel 6. Cory 5. Derrick 4. Kyland 3. Laurel 2. Cara'Maria 1. CT

[@nooba220]

Wish dayvonne was on this season

[@TDRyan]

I am obsessed with this cast (except aneesa ryan and jay -if he's on-but we don't talk about them)

[@chriscapps206]

Problem w era 2 men is that that era was dominated by evan,Johnny and Kenny,11-18 was the Kenny,evan and bananas show and w no Wes either,not as many huge options for that era men wise,i woudlve liked to see Tyler,Wes,bananas and idk who else,obviously wish Kenny and evan weren’t blacklisted cuz of everything cuz they dominated the teens and woudlve been a easy choice for the teens era if they weren’t

[@superraul6449]

Evan, Kenny and Banana was not in Season 11

[@kristinab3838]

​@superraul6449 well Kenny and Evans first challenge was fresh meat. So if Aviv who's won her one and only challenge season, Fresh Meat. Kenny and Evan would be Era 2.

[@chriscapps206]

@@kristinab3838 exactly they started in 11,and competed either one of em combined in 13-19 then again in 21 so they basically were the faces of the teens

[@andrewtaggart6370]

I wish they would have shelled out huge money and got The Miz, Theo Von and Landon back. That would have be insane!

[@minerzach1236]

Wish Georgia was on this cast

[@revupthosefryers3121]

Alton and abram shuda got cast

[@jakubhejny1628]

I think it would be interesting to have 10 teams of 4 people, two men and two women and every person in that team would be from a different era

[@ThatOneDude6009]

I know it is widely speculated Jordan made the cast, but is it confirmed? They already started filming apparently.

[@leytonwalker1190]

I’d like to see it set out the same way double agents was except not black skull because this is a much better cast and I feel we could end up with tori&bananas cara&ct pairings goifn back and fourth also derrick&laurel those 3 pairs would be explosive

[@leytonwalker1190]

The season is gonna be revolved arums cara&tori beef I hope both of them make finale tori has been active while cara has had time of cara can’t swim or do puzzles while Tory can swim and somewhat do puzzles looking at ride or dies if the finale involves swimming/eating tori takes it otherwise I’m leaning towards 60-40 tori

[@BoldinKrause-no1ko]

The only people who I think got snubbed are Da’Vonne, Veronica, Ashley, and Kyle

[@TDRyan]

Veronica declined the season and I think production want a break from Ashley But yes Da'vonne and Kyle should be on.Maybe if they didn't feel the need to cast a healthy amount from 39 they would have been on.

[@nomoremusic3738]

Jordan better be there if they are calling it best of the best.

[@NanCaraway]

The older era seems to be the ones to be eliminated quickly Half those people I didn’t even know my goodness the other teams are pretty much stacked. You can see that clearly. Sort of disappointed with MTV and how they did the original era they were the group they got everybody interested in them

[@SpriteXP404]

That was quick

[@dino9813]

Ngl I'm kinda sad Kyle isn't back, I REALLY want to see Kyle again

[@lisacuddyrus]

Can i make a prediction About format? It's gonna be "Cutthroat" with 4 teams and more politics for winners (let's say winning team cast a secret vote to pick another team who does not going to Gulag. )

[@ChrissaTodd]

my excitement for this cast is not everyone can go with or be in the vacation alliance and i think people like kaycee and tori might have to work harder

[@KyleSexy]

My winner picks are Jordan (if he’s on) and Jenny

[@okolo22000]

Evan & Kenny would’ve been no-brainers but of course we all (meaning people who follow the series) know why they can’t be brought back. Vinny Foti would belong in this group as well. Tyler* Dunbar Cohutta* CJ Chet JD Davis Alex Smith Zach Mann Isaac Nick Danny Jameson Tyrie* 😬 Dan Jesse Johnnie Pete Jeff Noor Luke That’s not much to choose from that lot… *MJ debuted on season 10 so he just barely missed out.

[@justinpascal8332]

Mj started on season 11

[@okolo22000]

@@justinpascal8332 Oh wait! I miscounted which season is which. Still, the depth of males from seasons 11-20 are extremely weak primarily because of the Evan-Kenny Tierney that ruled over the era. I forgot Wes debuted in season 12 but I’m certain he declined.

[@rashaadgrant4259]

That era had the weakest male competitors Sans JEK

[@AntmanDBD]

Kyle & Ashley not being here is tragic

[@alinsofan501]

Susie, Evelyn, Coral , Frank Roesller , Kam , Melissa . are also sorely missed.

[@Mark-gk3hh]

@@alinsofan501Kam is on all stars

[@Grav3yardguy01]

Josh making the cast over Fessy is crazyyyyy 😩

[@kristinab3838]

Yeah I would rather see him than Josh cuz he's always saying he's better than the OG's. I wanna see if he can back up his talk.

[@KingDCloud]

We needed Zach

[@leytonwalker1190]

I reckon we seem him return with Kyle in another season wouldn’t mind them as a pair

[@iLoveTheEighties80]

Hard pass.

[@hudjames11]

Of course they are trying to remake Winners at War. And somehow Michelle ended up in both seasons?

[@MM-tz2bs]

The cast is awesome (for the most part), but really the men in era 2 are pretty bad lol But I just went through the male debuts of era 2 and really they didn't have much choice here... Obvious male debuts who would fit here are Wes (who clearly doesn't want to come back, which is a shame, he should have at least done s40 before retiring), Kenny and Evan (for obvious reasons) and Cohutta (who I understand just had a baby? So I guess thats why he didn't want to come?)... anyone else who debuted in this era is just meh.. Also, big miss for era 2 on ladies side is Sarah, but i heard she had some surgery, so that sucks.

[@TheWesterosiNinja]

You could've had Tyler Duckworth in Era2 in place of layups like Derek or Ryan. It would've maintained the gay man representation and he was completely deserving having won twice and once with Bananas in Rivals 1.

[@MM-tz2bs]

@@TheWesterosiNinja i had him in mind, but when he did AS, he really seemed out of shape so I didnt include him :)

[@superraul6449]

4 teams of 10

[@BellaLuna98]

Why does noone ever mention Paula?!?!? It seemed like she was on almost every season when I first started watching. I’d love to see her!

[@justinpascal8332]

She’s declining

[@rashaadgrant4259]

Mark ruins the show for me because he will make it to the end, do absolutely nothing and lose. People are scared to ruffle feathers with him because of his status. Find that boring

[@Vinnybball1]

Lmao sounds like you don’t like all of them besides a few 😂 how can you not like devin on the show he’s literally one of the most entertaining

[@boopityb00p]

He’s been very annoying since SLA

[@mattmcallister6319]

Ryan & Derrek... Why? MTV LGBT Quota

[@ThatOneDude6009]

Marlon and Frank should’ve been on

[@JMoney615]

One person I would I could add is Turbo

[@nomoremusic3738]

Wes should be there too?

[@JalebJay]

It sucks that he said he's 100% done because of his child. He would be awesome to see on this season, but it would've been really hard to persuade him.

[@gamer_ap0]

Wes is on something else throughout filming (it is public knowledge of what show he’s on but obviously I won’t spoil for u)

[@iLoveTheEighties80]

@@gamer_ap0spoil it for me! lol, what show?

[@gamer_ap0]

@@iLoveTheEighties80 spoiler: House of villains