The Chinese Dream is Over!

[@garylester8621]

When the government makes it to the point where people say, "What have I got to lose" they are in trouble.

[@kellysouter4381]

I wonder if it's the same on a global scale?

[@omegajoe7014]

@@kellysouter4381 Almost there...

[@Operator8282]

The people are only three meals away from rebelion. Maybe 6, if they are made of sterner material. Pretty much holds true in any country. When the ammount of hungry/cold/destitute people reach a critical mass, they will, even unconciously, collectively revolt.

[@neltins5308]

ppl think the USA is going to **** right now, they are censoring so much stuff in China right now so America doesn't pay attention to how messed up its actually being to its own citizens right now, they're disappearing billionaires, wealthy people & censoring all the people with power/authority who speak up against them. there isn't any big name celebrity calling out China's **** in China, they know they will get taken out

[@TheSulross]

@@kellysouter4381 Consider the attempt to push the Netherlands into the Great Reset and how the farmers there launched a revolt - then there is the collapse of Sri Lanka - another product of the globalist great plan for the world; yeah, this is going on around the globe

[@robertburke1486]

"The market is cooling down..." That's a bit of an understatement. The Chinese housing market is in freefall.

[@MrKillswitch88]

The whole thing is going into a black hole sooner than later and the show we're going to be witnessing over the next year or so will be unreal.

[@nelzelpher7158]

Western propaganda

[@michealmccann]

It's built on sand and lies and is collapsing arround their ears.

[@magetsalive5162]

Well, to be fair, all the wind whipping past the housing market is making it very cold on its way down.

[@Gravora]

@@nelzelpher7158 Pffft. Funny.

[@leqingwang9181]

I am from a third-tier city in China. I was born in a rural area. The local per capita income is very low. Without the help of my parents, I cannot afford a house and a car, and it may take 10 to 20 years to repay the loan. Most of the young people at the bottom of China are like this, we are very tired, I feel sorry for my parents but there is nothing I can do.

[@lawrenceiverson1924]

Lie Flat !!!

[@arned432]

Can you explain a Tier city system in china. I read wiki about it's and even if half of this is true, this is bad...

[@FoolishMark90]

True Wang stories

[@M123Xoxo]

Same as the US, except your loan will be 30+ years for a home in the US. And most young adults cannot afford the downpayment without first saving for 10-15 years or getting money from rich parents. Canada, Australia, and most European countries have the same issue. It's a worldwide problem.

[@RollerBladingSuxs]

Let’s hope you stay there and not leave

[@ululug6381]

You know what's crazy? I've been watching you for a very long time now, I've watched you love China, brag about China etc and then watched you very slowly change your tune in China and started highlighting more and more bad about China, then I noticed your Chinese viewers abusing you, ridiculing you etc and now a lot of them are starting to support you now too. It's wild watching you grow and reveal truths and how angry Chinese people were with you at first and now you have a lot of support from a lot of Chinese people. You're definitely ruffling feathers and it's awesome, keep it up!!!

[@WorldKeepsSpinnin]

I agree

[@kazezeze]

I agree. Many aspects of China is great, such as the food, culture, landscapes etc, however the government sucks. He isn’t slandering China, he’s just revealing the truth, and I respect him for that.

[@Bos_Meong]

@Brandon mmm yes amazing delicacies 🤤🤤 edit : noo why you delete your comment 💀💀💀

[@zhu_zi4533]

Maybe just because not many people would want to comment on a brainwashed propaganda channel and its sewer discussion board

[@rick-be]

Same cycle I see and I followed the same course....

[@jakehands]

My uncle, an engineer from the UK, helped modernise China during the 80s and 90s. He was staying at a hotel near Tiananmen square when things kicked off in 89'. All guests were suddenly escorted onto a coach and whisked off to the countryside. A week later they returned to the same hotel and all the staff had been replaced. Everyone. None of the new staff had any idea of what had happened a week earlier.

[@kushagrakhandelwal6303]

Oh but what did happen a week ago can you tell us please

[@ElektrykFlaaj]

@@kushagrakhandelwal6303 nothing happened, trust me

[@jakehands]

@@ElektrykFlaaj my uncle witnessed bodies hanging off a bridge so something did happen.

[@senzium]

@@kushagrakhandelwal6303 there were democratic protests and china crushed the protests and killed them all. they would then flush their dead bodies through water hoses and stuff like that. theres pictures online of aftermath you just gotta search really deep

[@shayon1174]

@@jakehands that comment was a joke about how chinese government conceals the massacre by saying nothing happened there

[@cykablyatifulscheisse]

As a native, sadly you are right. The country is in an inevitable death spiral. Even my parents who grew up in the era of brainwashing propaganda now can tell there something serious wrong and the worse is yet to come.

[@tonkysue207]

💙uk

[@targetfootball7807]

Death spiral? Compared to which country?

[@DiabloDelMer1]

Washy identified.

[@breakingthewall2112]

@@targetfootball7807 True whole world is in one now but China has 1.5 billion people so will be pretty messy

[@jefftan-xw2jy]

@@tonkysue207 / . F

[@cowboytanaka6675]

Can we talk about how people actually had the balls to hold a public gathering let alone a PROTEST in MAINLAND CHINA? This is insane. This is beyond insane. People don’t realize how huge this is.

[@praetorianstride5948]

I wish I could actually interact with the Chinese people via the internet we all share. But; some determine they need their own, separate from the rest of the free world. I wonder why.

[@elektrotehnik94]

@@praetorianstride5948 You can run into some from time to time - those that use VPN services. At least, their depth of local knowledge suggests they're from China... But it's rare.

[@AnEnderNon]

@@praetorianstride5948 most chinese people know how to use a vpn lol

[@dickon728]

Yes, it is most surprising. And incredibly brave. Or foolish perhaps.

[@Fopenplop]

@@praetorianstride5948 you literally could just talk to chinese people if you bothered to learn the language

[@HarveyLeeAo]

I've fled the Communist China about 15 years ago. My proudest thing in my life is I made the decision to migrant to a free country, so that my next generations have freedoms.

[@marymartin090]

what country?

[@wohendumwing3ee9]

Probably ran to a white country. Typical behavior. I'm sure you also vote Leftist and bash white people when pressured?

[@marcobelli6856]

@@marymartin090There is choice. You can come to Europe. Or Usa. If you prefer Asia you can Go to Japan or south korea or Taiwan

[@JoannaZhu-iw7wh]

good for u and plz do not come back，we got too many ppl，doesn't mind losing some

[@-highvoltage4685]

​@@JoannaZhu-iw7wh Are you chinese? Isnt youtube banned?!

[@Dius765RS]

“The masses never revolt of their own accord, and they never revolt merely because they are oppressed. Indeed, so long as they are not permitted to have standards of comparison, they never even become aware that they are oppressed.” ― George Orwell, 1984

[@indrapratama7668]

“The best slave is the one who thinks he is free.” - Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

[@robertagren9360]

Speak and act as 'those who are going to be judged; by the law of freedom - James 2:12

[@dancroitoru364]

Sure - Orwell is like popularized science and everybody is an expert in freedom these days. Especially kids in their 20ies. "As they say in the United States: "to be different is to be indecent." The mass crushes beneath it everything that is different, everything that is excellent, individual, qualified and select. Anybody who is not like everybody, who does not think like everybody, runs the risk of being eliminated." The Revolt of the Masses - José Ortega y Gasset

[@targetfootball7807]

Which country should China compare itself to? No other country has done what China has done.

[@chad_bro_chill]

@@targetfootball7807 Plenty of countries have or have had secret police monitoring civilians, widespread famine and flooding as a result of poor management and poorly-built infrastructure, etc. China has done it on a larger scale, sure, but the root problems are the same).

[@F15ElectricEagle]

It's not about no longer able to achieve the Chinese Dream or the American Dream. It's about hope. When you attempt to take all hope away, the people that you're taking it from will eventually fight back since they have nothing else to lose.

[@bradley8575]

The American Dream is not that achievable anymore considering we’re in a pandemic although we are still a A Land of Opportunity .

[@taraswertelecki3786]

@@bradley8575 Yeah sure, for everyone but the NATIVE population. Opportunity for native Americans is gone, especially white Americans.

[@wangzhi1948]

the children got shot at school. people can buy addicted drug legally at street. really geat hope in America.

[@PrograError]

@@taraswertelecki3786 right... white americans are natives... it's as native as plastic surgery Micheal Jackson

[@Reiner547]

@@wangzhi1948 civil war, two world wars, a nuclear threat... yeah web can handle this 🇺🇸😎🤠

[@georgyporgy929]

I'm 14, I was born in Beijing and I moved to Canada in 2018, and that was the smartest move that my parents have done. Everything went downhill for China in 2020 and I am glad that I am not living in that hell hole any more

[@nostro1940]

How many indians are there?

[@georgyporgy929]

@@nostro1940 In Canada or in Beijing?

[@Pratt11]

@@georgyporgy929 both if you know

[@georgyporgy929]

​@@Pratt11 so back in 17-18, there wasn't took much indians living in Beijing, at least not in my area. I saw a couple here and there overtime but not that much. I currently live in Vancouver, and there are a lot of Indians in the city, mainly in Surrey.

[@rugbydazz2264]

@@georgyporgy929 You wanna try coming to Leicester in the UK its over run with them and they have ruined it, we hate them!

[@eoin4529]

I lived in China for many years, but my wife and I saw the writing on the wall and got out in 2018. That was good timing!

[@primordialarchetypes2927]

Pray why do people even bother to go there? $$$$$$?

[@kiddo8597]

Well it's safer than US or Russia, the scenery is beautiful, China,Russia,USA and Canada scenery are crazy beautiful. And when you go to China there's no such things as "no foreigner cafe/clubs/restaurant" like in Japan or Korea

[@xxkk232]

@@kiddo8597 true,,, but as a Chinese, at the same time, just feel so sad and shamed for all the pressure of our Gen Z after. We shouldn’t have to take all the consequences of those baby boomers who took advantages of early stage of the Chinese economy development. Now our generation has to payback and bear and accept all these unemployment and unfair education opportunities. The whole society is so RED and we even have to carefully express our opinions about local politics, like Shanghai protests few months ago. Hope things will get better after our generation 😢

[@Wes-x9p]

I left in 2010

[@dune5436]

@@kiddo8597 Serptentza has posted about many Chinese restaurants/cafes that don't allow foreigners. Don't lie.

[@mmmirele]

I work in tech for a big financial institution, and I can tell you, our biggest daily, hourly, moment-by-moment concern is making sure our customers can get to their money, even if it's just to virtually fondle it. People get VERY upset when they get an error message on a bank's website. I can't even imagine how people would react if the bank branch wasn't even opening up.

[@OGKillercaptain]

What about sending thugs when you did show up to check on your money?

[@ninamartin1084]

Having a sudden urge to virtually fondle my money, perhaps even virtually roll around in it. That should be a thing!

[@justinlavine9209]

My mother, a frontline medical worker, got into a dispute with a bank teller after an ATM error. The bank teller used my mother's account information to call the police who arrested my mother at her house and remanded her to a hospital for a psychiatric evaulation because she hadn't committed a crime. This happened in New England this year, but I have had numerous problems banking as a teen even though I had a job, my Driver's License and Social Security Card. My family isn't a recognizable minority, but apparently the African American community is just outright being arrested trying to bank in America. There's a reason why the banks keep falling apart in America that has nothing to do with communism or the Chinese. Personally, I wonder if China's social credit system might be better than the U.S.'s current system for evaluating a bank customer's credit worthiness.

[@justinlavine9209]

@@licheong My mother, a frontline medical worker, got into a dispute with a bank teller after an ATM error. The bank teller used my mother's account information to call the police who arrested my mother at her house and remanded her to a hospital for a psychiatric evaulation because she hadn't committed a crime. This happened in New England this year, but I have had numerous problems banking as a teen even though I had a job, my Driver's License and Social Security Card. My family isn't a recognizable minority, but apparently the African American community is just outright being arrested trying to bank in America. There's a reason why the banks keep falling apart in America that has nothing to do with communism or the Chinese. Personally, I wonder if China's social credit system might be better than the U.S.'s current system for evaluating a bank customer's credit worthiness.

[@th3oryO]

@@justinlavine9209 Credit worthiness? Perhaps. But the rest of the social credit system makes the Patriot act and its related legislation look like genuine freedom. Sucks that you had a bad experience but no one in the western world should want the system China has. It's like bringing a nuke to kill a rat.

[@Reathety]

Thought the China building bubble would have ended almost 10 years ago. Now it's a lot larger and a lot more unstable. These things tend to happen very slowly and then all at once. Really concerned about the Chinese people and how this all unwinds.

[@speggeri90]

I hate communism and Lenin, but as that murderous creep said, "decades can go by with nothing happening, but then there are years where decades happen".

[@Kektamusprime]

Like you said slowly at first then all at once, the most concerning part is this isnt just happening in China loads of countries big and small are experiencing hardship and we could see a major world war as a way to get out of this. This is like 10 titanics that have already hit the iceberg headed to crash into each other before sinking

[@secrets.295]

It lasted a lot longer than most other country though. Because the CCP intervenes a lot. While most countries adopt the free market system, well free to a certain limit but much freer than the Chinese.

[@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368]

Don't worry about China, because it's coming for us all. A world war is imminent. Russia-China-Iran-North Korea vs the civilized world.

[@zz3OPEN]

@@Kektamusprime As a result of the response to the pandemic. But still today we get zero open discourse on these events, the policy decisions, what worked and what didn't etc. I don't see things improving any time soon.

[@kathrynck]

I still remember watching your videos when you lived and worked in China, riding motorcycles around, videoing culture. For about the last 18 months or so you were there, I kept thinking "You REALLY need to get out of there, and fast" I'm so glad you did.

[@wlbrobinson]

True but he also was a big defender of the Chinese for a long time, big flip flop. or just late to realize the evil of communists

[@itemushmush]

Did you see the whole drama with Laowhy trying to leave?? It was super damn close to him being disappeared! Crazy times

[@AnEnderNon]

its a ton of misinformation lol

[@kathrynck]

@@itemushmush Ya, I did. I think they waited too long to get out. But I understand when you have a job and home, when you've planted roots, it takes time to make a move. But for about the last year they were there, I was thinking "if you have to, just bring only what you can carry, and GTFO right now". Every time they posted a video I was thinking "well, they're still alive this week".

[@sniperslayer95]

@@AnEnderNon No it isnt Chinese Troll detected. Winnie the Pooh and his Cronies are evil and committing Genocide.

[@robertmallac8398]

What concerns me most about the China is that a lot of Western leaders are keen to adopt CCP polices.

[@ingus5552]

Trudoe liked CCP policy I heaed

[@waancfinzeuz191]

They are coward!

[@JoannaZhu-iw7wh]

and that‘s why you should not believe this bullshit

[@robertschnobert9090]

​Why do you hate China so much? Talking about corrupt China haters in the CCP is important. It's the only way how to improve this beautiful country. Please stop hating China 🇭🇰🇭🇰🇭🇰​@@JoannaZhu-iw7wh

[@henryb6009]

In war, you always end up looking like your enemy.

[@pointlessink6084]

77 years ago my grandfather left China to support his family as an illegal migrant and merchant in the Philippines, he might not able to see his kids and family grew up but let's say we were blessed if not for him and the foundation the created mostly influence by what business practices and culture he brought along and let's say he still managed to pull his mainland family out of mainland China into Hongkong before his tragic death in 1976 This is really tragic and what ever relatives we have left in Mainland had escaped to Hongkong and from Hongkong to overseas, some are already with us since 2019

[@judymckee5992]

My grandfather did that too and moved to Malaysia. We still have cousins in China because my uncle support communism and was send back to China.

[@jumbojumbo6866]

@@judymckee5992 tho my friends one was because of just better job oppertunities and then sending that cash back to china but because china would steal the cash if he did that transaction back to china he couldnt feed his family back there so he very much screwed especially if they are forced to stay in their homes and not go outside

[@hanfucolorful9656]

Serpentz also left from one nation to China. what did you want to say, the Philippines better than China or what?

[@RA1S1NS]

@@hanfucolorful9656 dude, thats 77 years ago,i think his not really comparing, his just thankfull he left china with his relatives

[@t-r-y-i-n-g]

@@hanfucolorful9656 he's just saying communism is bad not the whole country

[@feelincrispy7053]

Ohhh that “I’m going to fuckin kill you” to the Fly is going to be clipped out of context by Chinese government cronies within hours 😂

[@johngifford7725]

Smacked of troll bait.

[@davideyres955]

I think it was a ccp spy fly drone.

[@KENICUSONE]

I had stopped watching and had started to watch other KZbinrs that were living in China but they seemed over time to be used as Chinese propaganda. He is totally CORRECT. He totally nailed it. This was not CHINA BASHING but just telling the simple truth of what’s going on.

[@komlat253]

to be fair half the stuff said in the introduction can apply to many places. ...but this covid code system is probably true. I saw it happen to a random taxi driver when I let him drive me from a near by city .it was crazy by mine has never even been yellow and I've gone anywhere . even medium risk area

[@KENICUSONE]

@@komlat253 : The Covid lockdown especially in Shanghai was brutal. Many small businesses failed and are abandoned.

[@huderocdu3363]

Hey! There are 1.4 billion people in China. How many percent of the population is this moron talking about? Can he govern China better? Twice the population of the US ie 800 million has been lifted out of poverty! How much is the poverty rate of his own country? Which country is more disappointing? At least he shows that China isn’t as controlled as the US. People are normal & they still have rooms to protest. In some countries, people can’t even gather together. For example - the Capitol riot takes only a few days whereas protesters in Tiananmen and Hong Kong had months to voice out before they were suppressed

[@bencze465]

There's corruption in any government and local politicians (not just local) abusing power is not something unique to China. I watched half but there's a lot of generalities really. Every government also has methods to keep you in check like no fly lists in us, they control social security, banks and everything. Sure it's not a place where you crack political jokes, but I think this guy is a bit butthurt for some reason. (i don't know him or his videos)

[@Fomites]

How do you know? I have lived in China and was there recently. Sepentza is a an anti-China propagandist making money riding the anti-China wave of sentiment currently engulfing what left of minds in the West.

[@Lee-cr7gk]

I am Chinese, and what you state about the real estate is absolutely correct. The house price of China has increased for multiple times in recent years, especially in big cities like Beijing, Shanghai or Shenzhen, so it is almost impossible for a student who has been graduated from university to buy a house alone, and he or she needs to borrow the loan to buy it, which they need to spend the whole life to pay back. Therefore, this terrible cycle will move on, and it is deteriorating the whole economy rapidly and constantly

[@micheleyong1900]

Real estate prices going up by the folds is not just in China, it is all over the world in the developing countries. Just check it out n you will see. It is hard for young people all over.

[@brooksanderson2599]

@@micheleyong1900 And, in "developed" countries too. Realestate "flipping" isrampant in the USA! CRASH is comming!

[@micheleyong1900]

@@brooksanderson2599 Yeas that is exactly right. They crashed n up up n away again. Real estate is the best investment of all. That is why being called REAL estate, unlike stocks one can lost one's shirt like thin air. REAL estate, stays something one can hold on to.

[@kilianlach9340]

i smell paid comments

[@micheleyong1900]

@@kilianlach9340 Of course, he is getting paid by youtube advertisers n whoever else handsomely. Attacking the host country n making a living out of it while being a guest is not just rude but extremely immoral. There are great achievements in China n surpassed a lot of other well developed countries, why doesn't he talk about that ? Just so repulsive n irritating. 🐀 🐀 🐀

[@paulhyland7456]

Good on you Winston. Telling it like it is. Well done.

[@georgevavoulis4758]

Thank you Winston for showing us how horrible the corruption is in China 🇨🇳

[@georgevavoulis4758]

Also the lefty mainstream news media in the "WEST" ,Canada ,USA and Europe don't show anything either

[@xeta180]

@@georgevavoulis4758 the whole world is corrupt. Dont get it twisted.

[@LeSyd1984]

If not for the hanzi everywhere in the background I'd think he was talking about every single country on earth, lol!

[@MrSmith-ve6yo]

He especially told it how it is to that fly at 6:29. XD But yeah, these videos are invaluable at trying to understand what the heck is going on in China.

[@davidarriola6412]

There was never a dream. It was always a nightmare of evil for a people that never rose up against the worst government known to humanity.

[@Dumbledoresarmy13]

They kind of did... but they essentially lost and retreated to Taiwan.

[@5133937]

@@Dumbledoresarmy13 Exactly. And they rose up a second time in 1989 and lost again b/c what can unarmed civilians do against the military. But at least they tried, more than once.

[@ninamartin1084]

um there have been worse governments.......Lenin, Mugabe, Kim Il-Sung, Ho Chi Min, Idi Amin, Pol Pot, Leopold 2nd, Hitler.......and those are just in the last century.

[@parrotshootist3004]

Where was Mancuria? It's now an office in Japan that still issues passports. Did you hear of the Boxer Rebellion? Do you know whose armies put them down? They couldn't fight against Europe, Japan and America, as well as the other side in their own land.

[@beckyraskin8928]

The chinese people had Mao before - his policies lead to mass starvation. Did you know that 50 million (prob more) people starved to death in the 1950's and 60's? Remember that china has been a country for 5,000 years (give or take). The chinese people have a looooong memory. I imagine they've had hundreds of repressive regimes in 5,000 years. As an american, I've tried to research and understand china, but I really don't understand at all

[@RDSyafriyar]

"People shouldn't be afraid of their government. Governments should be afraid of their people." - Alan Moore

[@Chiii.]

Anarchist lmaoo

[@grbradsk]

Oh the CCP is afraid in the extreme ... that's why they have constructed the surveillance state and absolute controls.

[@A_Haunted_Pancake]

@@Chiii. Even a broken clock is right twice a day.

[@jirajira2872]

If this was the people of Texas then they'll be showing the government who is the boss!!

[@kennyaero360]

@Jira Jira pffft mass shooting happen lately and you the self proclaim gun owner cant do anything.. only cry lmaooo

[@trygveplaustrum4634]

"You want to go and protest about it, and you're met with nothing other than *THIS FLY!"* Truly, China knows no bounds.

[@xdwdx]

Honestly, one of the best gems. Surprised not much was spoken on this. Can’t believe it’s a year already •_• 6:23

[@thefoxandthelynx]

I was in Hangzhou with my girlfriend. We both arrived there at the same time from Shenzhen. When it was time for us to fly back home, my girlfriend's QR code turned yellow, but mine remained green. When your code is yellow, you can't fly out of the country or even take a cab. When she called the bureau and asked what happened, no one could give her a straight answer of why it happened. This Zero-Covid Policy makes no sense and the people running the show sometimes done even know how their own system works.

[@zasterheffor]

Was there a resolution? Was she able to get on another flight?

[@thefoxandthelynx]

@@zasterheffor yea, we had to wait a couple of hours at the hotel lobby and then her code turned back into green because she called them about it. Again... no one had any idea why it happened.

[@luichinplaystation610]

She's a spy for the CCP and can't leave

[@greattaiwan2899]

They locked up all people in Shanghai to achieve zero Covid.

[@thefoxandthelynx]

@@greattaiwan2899 Is it working, or just pissing people off?

[@fobypawz418]

Hawaii was starting to get riddled by massive multi-unit and multi-story homes developed by Chinese investors that pushed beyond zoning limits, and took up every inch of a lot. These homes were abhorrent and were designed basically as rental mills, inflating real estate market prices, blocking precious views of the beaches and city for other neighbors, completely defacing middle-class neighborhoods with ugly crackerbox homes. The local community had enough and pushed for enforcement of zoning laws causing many of these projects to halt in their tracks, and making the investors sell off their properties or pay huge fines. They were like pest infesting a beautiful hibiscus flower 🌺.

[@robertbulterman1677]

and who let the Chinese investors into Hawaii?

[@spy33r]

@ Foby Pawz - that's what china is known for... create havoc wherever they go - its a Communist Barbaric Behavior. It's a very selfish country. I mean what do you expect from a country who produce fake and poisonous product to other countries to make money.

[@livreene7250]

@@robertbulterman1677 We will never be short on corrupted politicians...

[@patwhw]

@@robertbulterman1677 The mainland americans.

[@Gizziiusa]

@@robertbulterman1677 anyone can invest. Heck, the Japanese own a whole bunch of Hawaii properties...its been this way for at least a decade.

[@Armenhanmer]

Dude yes. This is public service. You are literally doing us a solid by putting time into this information publication.

[@longbeard-df9ii]

Eye-opening for sure

[@truthteller-o2f]

brilliant plan by the ccp. tons of corruption criminals from china with their vast amount of wealth immigrant to the west ---> welcomed by the west ---> with their vast amount of wealth they multiply in great numbers and colonize the west.

[@g.s.3450]

Excellent reporting; very reality based. Your love for the common people in China is admirable. Your conclusion was clear: the only advantage the Chinese government has is that they can censure and silence at will. That keeps them in power. Keep up the good work!

[@YokoshimaSTAR]

Man, I would have been unknowing without your content. It's absolutely necessary for me to know what's going on in the world, so thank you. Always looking forward for more content. It's very engaging.

[@SBImNotWritingMyNameHere]

unaware*

[@YokoshimaSTAR]

@@SBImNotWritingMyNameHere I chose unknowing because that's a word and it suited what I wanted to say. Keep your obnoxious nose off.

[@SBImNotWritingMyNameHere]

@@YokoshimaSTAR damn ok I was just trying to be helpful but you seem very angry at me :(

[@ascensionindustries9631]

Totally agree. Also no one wants a grammar nazi on KZbin, am I right?

[@MrGunnar69]

It's almost as if the media in the west does not want to report on this for any reason. Could it be for the same reason that the media in China does not report on it? After all, we have the same monetary system. There is no money, only credit (trust). The numbers in your account are someone else's debt, if someone else stops paying their debt, the trust disappears. But do not worry, they will blame Putin.

[@singingbird1115]

There has never been Chinese dream. It was a lie.

[@KalkuehlGaming]

A dream cant be a lie. A dream is always fantasy.

[@zellexy]

A truth can always shatter a dream, though.

[@jackplisken4738]

as there never was an American one too

[@ericvulgate]

A fantasy by it's nature is a lie.

[@thebranch3874]

It was nightmare not dream

[@trippinout.]

I went all over China in 2018. It's not just ghost cities I saw, there were so many highways, train lines and other infrastructure that looked to be unfinished and completely deserted. Glad I got to see the fascinating country when i did because I'd never go there now.

[@daysudl]

go Taiwan

[@FoolishMark90]

Go Malaysia

[@kenik2023]

Go Vietnam

[@jawafreak230]

Agreed! I was there in the fall of 2019 for a semester in Beijing - right until early December, when Corona-Chan hit! I’m lucky to have visited it before it’s economy turned downwards, when their middle class still hand money to throw around, and before the Ponzi scheme real estate economy began to melt down!

[@kennethjohnsonmr.3300]

I went to China in 2006. I was with a group of volunteer teachers who taught at a Junior High School, for their summer school program. There were many strange things that happened, but I will share one of the many stories. They put us in a hotel which was filthy, had mold in the shower and so on. There were several dogs outside in the hotel yard, that were very cute. Every day at least one dog disappeared, until there was only one dog left. When we asked the hotel staff what happened to all the dogs, the staff person said in broken English, they are not dogs or pets now, they are food. This terrible event set the tone for the rest of my teaching groups stay in China.

[@serceskywalker]

Omg that’s horrible 😢😭

[@loveskngm31hstsdaily1]

@@serceskywalker yep.

[@DarkEnergyHealer]

Sorry, but this is not just happening since the past 25 years in China. This was already long time before happening and common knowledge. What the bleep did you or your group think you were going to teach up there?? French???? Unbelievable.. its like taking in all the illegals now and trying to teach them legality 🤡

[@FYMASMD]

When you’re starving, you will eat dog.

[@PerversePoster]

It's difficult to feel bad for one of the most disruptive countries on the globe. I feel bad for the people.

[@g_y.rtz420]

Saw how oppressive and destructive their hivemind civilians can get over little things like taiwan being mentioned by a youtuber and they descend like flies to harass and threaten like their lives depended on it. So no. Theyre all in it together, the lies and the abuse, so they all deserve to fall together.

[@shiro_ai]

they have terrible communist leaders, citizen really need their freedom

[@wangzhi1948]

why not feel bad for all those countries America invaded and bombed? the children got shot because your government .

[@greattaiwan2899]

One billion Chinese are literally slaves of the CCP.

[@PerversePoster]

@@greattaiwan2899 Like I said, I feel bad for the people. Brainwashed as most of them are.

[@bingolittle8725]

Everything you mention is exactly why I got the hell out. So many great talented people stuck there, it's really sad. I have a friend who makes short films, every film she makes gets deleted within 24 hours guaranteed, after she posts them. People these days are happy if the bars are open between 'virus' lockdowns to get a beer and feel normal for a few hours. The increased control is the CCPs way of admitting the dream is over, now it's about CCP survival.

[@sugar934]

No pity for commies. China has been the main factor behind communism spreading around the world. As far as I see it every Chinese is at least partially responsible and they are getting what they deserve.

[@MackNcD]

The grandkids all stifled so a wrinkled, greedy old man can go on.

[@bingolittle8725]

@@MackNcD 100%

[@vincentchauvet6654]

@DidNothingWrong 2nd amendment is a useless gimmick lmao

[@goutfromfriedokra7099]

Where is your friend based in China? Is the younger generation getting more despondent with the CCCP, you see them turning on them soon?

[@stephenphilbin3919]

I get the feeling that the next couple of decades could reasonably be described as repaying the debts accrued from choosing to accept obvious lies as truth.

[@The_ZeroLine]

It’ll be awful for all but the hyper elite with the ability to buy their own armies.

[@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368]

Apathy ensures a sudden, violent, social convulsion.

[@cathjj840]

I agree, with the precision that it applies equally to the US. Methods and degree differ, of course, and the likelihood of a completely catastrophic revolution, but inevitable, paradigm-change is on the way.

[@microfarming8583]

Wow I've never seen anyone articulate this concept so well. You nailed it

[@Huriana10]

All the debt needs to be wiped. It was created by corrupted governments anyway. All the Covid debt is 100% the responsible of governments that purposly created it. If people dont stand up and refuse to take on this debt, they are asking for generations of poverty.

[@mack7207]

I like that their view of social harmony is not to see what’s going on in these chats and find ways to address the problems, but rather to stop them being able to talk about them all together.

[@mrecamping5496]

I'm glad to see someone shedding light on what really happening in China. Went there on an exchange program in 2011 and got set up with a host family in the Communist party. Anytime I wanted to see how the average people lived they would take me to lavish dinners and tell me that's how everyone lived.

[@DD-nv2vg]

In that case…, I would ask about average people three times a day. 🤣

[@algijura]

nope..would asked 4 times a day😂🤣😂🤣🤣

[@JoannaZhu-iw7wh]

gosh，that‘s why you are intelligent incompetent， been to China in person and still believe in this bullshit……

[@DarkEnergyHealer]

Which school or country would do an exchange program with CCP?? Even back then... Wow pls tell me where you are from? At least the kids got a good example of how bad com is? Or have they become shouting Lefties now?

[@gavinlew8273]

"The governments not there to help you, they're there to suppress you.." - What the world needs today are less politicians in government and more transparency.

[@texaswunderkind]

So what you're saying is that it was bad that the Secret Service illegally destroyed documents during the January 6th coup attempt?

[@PrograError]

i'd say the 2010s-20s are the period of increasing dictatorial governments, close to every country has a law about fake news and control of contents without a third party to "oversee". it's often the relevant minister or ministry being the "caretaker"

[@christerjakobsen8107]

@@texaswunderkind >January 6th >Coup >no guns in sight sure buddy, I totally believe it was a "coup"

[@nikolai_kury]

The one who doesn’t understand this by default, even in western countries is an idiot, it’s same everywhere, absolutely It’s like : you should fear the police

[@elizabethclaiborne6461]

That’s not true. You’re repeating the greediest of super rich cannibals. Yeah, a commie dictatorship is abusing its populace, but that’s not all government.

[@tyvid]

When mentioning the property buying abroad by corrupt and criminal Chinese, I recall the onslaught of buyers from China in Australia who snapped up so much premium properties, outbidding everyone else. It caused huge resentment from local Australians and got to a point it was almost pointless going to auctions at all. The only Australians smiling were the greedy real estate agents. To think there are now so many of these properties, often sitting empty that are the spoils of massive amounts of laundered money.

[@samgooi1905]

These are crooks the CCP govt. are going after them. Why didn't the australian govt. extradite them to China ??

[@JanuszKrysztofiak]

When your country is a tyranny and your entire (perhaps not entirely fairly earned) fate/wealth may be erased if the rules considers you don't bow low enough... you would like to stash it in a place where that dreaded rule of the law applies. Applies to the Chinese in Australia, applied to the Russians in the UK.

[@MasterShadowEroticHypnosis]

Adverse possession

[@johardy-bishop9105]

It’s the same for a lot of new buildings in London, too, standing empty on the approach to Waterloo and Paddington stations.

[@rcdarkangel]

@@johardy-bishop9105 It caused huge resentment amongst uneducated Australian's like yourself. Most of us were smart enough to read the data that makes it pretty clear Australia's significant property pricing has fuck all to do with the chinese. They make up a TINY, TINY portion of the market. And less than ever in terms of buyers since covid.

[@ambermarie6763]

so HAPPY YOU MENTIONED LIZIQI, I MISS HER. what she said last time to her fans was that managment company was taking all her money so she boycotted them...

[@philippechaniet5837]

30 years ago, the Japanese bubble wrecked Japan which has been "recovering" ever since although Japan was a stable society. I wonder what a real estate bubble 10 times bigger will do to China, its economy and the world supply chain?

[@shun2240]

Nikkei 225 did surprisingly well this 10 years, seems like the Japanese knows how to generate a profit despite a declining working population.

[@philippechaniet5837]

@@shun2240 Yes and no. The Japanese did reflate the economy injecting trillions of yens. This created a new bubble in Tokyo and propelled the stock market to new highs. Let's see what happens next...

[@shun2240]

@@philippechaniet5837 japanese stock market is still fairly cheap/fair valued, the growth is probably mostly earnings growth + dividend payouts, and it barely reached its ATH in 1989 including dividend reinvestment

[@Taykorjg]

Just gonna move to neighboring countries such as Vietnam. As for the billions of chinese I have no idea. Great leap backwards I suppose

[@1mol831]

@@Taykorjg not backwards

[@HankRearden84]

Feels like all citizens of the world are in this same predicament. Not taking anything away from the Chinese experience as they are uniquely insane but it just seems like a vice is tightening globally.

[@cat-vv9xb]

Yeap, you either get communism or unchecked capitalism plus conservatism, pick your poison.

[@B.D.E.]

Don't vote for authorotarian leaders like Trump or Le Pen then.

[@giovannamoro8564]

Exactly my thought . Infact i always found chinese presence at the world economic forum very odd .

[@adamrmoss]

Global Capitalism defeated all other systems, but its excesses have aggregated over the decades, and now there’s no serious alternative except Fascism. The whole world is in for a wild ride - God help us.

[@helenhoward5346]

Yes, everyone is suffering compared to 3-4 years ago... However, the draconian brutal lockdowns where the government will just let you starve is inhuman but hey MAO inspired..

[@lightningpo26]

Once the people know that they've been taken for granted it becomes dangerous. Once the trust is gone, its gone.

[@goldsteinist]

Also when people are pushed to the levels they have nothing to lose anymore only winning by stand against the rules … well that’s when hell breaks out. For the powers

[@bloodspartan300]

The real question is why are the 🇺🇸 citizens so passive

[@praetorianstride5948]

Americans have been severed from one another because of actors from foreign countries fanning the flames of disdain for one another. Ignorance towards climate is a huge issue. Womens rights is a huge issue. Those who have a mind inclined towards freedom sees how stupid America has been acting and we feel enslaved by religious extremists who use religion as a means to control, and the aware are suffocated by those who seek “judgement day” aka Armageddon, before giving rights to all Americans. It is a tough situation for pacifists.

[@314rft]

@@praetorianstride5948 About the foreign powers fanning flames part, you're 100% correct. Russia has been intentionally doing that for decades. Read up about "Foundations of Geopolitics" by Russian extremist Alexander Dugin, because that book basically outlines how Russia should go about destabilizing the west. And the scary part? It actually is well received by a large amount of the Russian elite.

[@unlimited971]

@@bloodspartan300 cause most american drink koolaid and illusion of freedom

[@senorbeckon]

Stunning collapse of the inescapable problem ; thank you for your competent commentary .

[@paidrussiantroll1305]

Serpentza has been pointing these issues out for years now. I am stunned that various governments around the world have not hired him for consultations and advice on China. He seems to know far more of current and historical events than many "expert" advisors.

[@callsign_plasma]

it's generally a bad practice to hire people based on their internet popularity and seemingly "i-know-everything" attitude in Russia, there is a popular "china expert" Vavilov, and for most of the people he seems like really knowledgeable China expert, but he is just a moron that makes shit up

[@philtwowheels]

They have their own expert advisers who are very well connected don't worry, there are spy's all over the world and China is no exception.

[@PanzerAce247]

And not having the "Expert" title after his name is exactly, why the bureaucrats that need his advice won't hire him. They either don't have the time to check his resume and therefore don't want to risk it, or have an elitist, title based hiring mindset.

[@rodiculous9464]

Bc his advice would end up costing them money. They care more about the quick bucka

[@EgoChip]

Why would they hire him? China is very much a part of their plans for us all. They are testing their systems in China. It is all coming to the west in the coming years, it's already started to be rolled out. They are intentionally collapsing our economies so the WEF can step in with its Great Reset, with its oppressive social credit system and global currency.

[@josephzhang6958]

I’m a mainland Chinese, as a conscious consumer, I try my hardest to buy as little mainland Chinese made goods / products as possible. And I am proud of myself. Keep up the good work, Winston 👊🏼

[@audience2]

That is OK, you're helping even out the huge trade imbalance

[@lishen9]

@joseph zhang: How much are you getting paid by these anti chinese thugs to talk shit about china, keep in mind in doing so you are a traitor to you ownr race and you think these white foreigners will treat you any differently, theyll treat you like a piece of shit also.

[@petermclauchlan8793]

Seek *First GOD'S KINGDOM etc..✅ ( as per Matthew Chapter 6 & Verse 33 > in The *New Testament of > The Holy Bible . ✅ ✅ ✅ Amen.

[@lnq5414]

@Rodney 1984 I live in China and I really wonder why would people hate communism. Can you explain to me? Did communism China or Chinese people ever hurt you in any way? What is the real reason people like you hate communism so much, if not because of brainwash

[@sergeantblue6115]

your choice i guess but are you sure you avoided all of em cus there is a lot of reexport countries like hong kong and america.

[@shsu7426]

I’ve watched many of your documentaries these past two years. Thank you for shedding light on the social, economical, and political tides in China on a humanistic level, Serpentza!

[@slevinchannel7589]

Ngl, this video here not mentioning how bad Capitalism is and how its blatantly just. uuuuhm... 'not working' in high-scientific-terms... rings hollow?

[@Srpskeoci]

I'm subscribing. I came across some of your videos yesterday and I couldn't stop watching.

[@MrWadevideos]

I am currently here in Shanghai. We were locked down for 60 days. It’s hard to imagine how an economy could recover from that. This video was good. I would add that China also has a serious birth rate and aging population problem as well, which is why they increased they have increased the amount of children people can have twice now in the last five years. There is also the double reduction policy, which I guess is intended to reduce stress on parents and children as well as a decreased financial burden. The idea is that will free up married couples to have more children. However, it also really acts like way to minimize outside information and increase the amount of propaganda to children.

[@houstonr]

Proof ?

[@leiaAleia]

The world doesn’t need more Chinese, oh please

[@dano3952]

It's too late for China they cannot fix it with more kids now. It's like the Titanic now , they're doomed.

[@Dashinix]

@@houstonr nice try wumao

[@houstonr]

@@Dashinix Huh?

[@astrahcat1212]

Not ever about becoming famous it’s about the dream of doing what you love and being able to afford a family at the same time. If you work 15 hours for no home, no point in working and society melts down.

[@omegajoe7014]

THIS! Most people don't realize that China was a moribund state until it started to open up and allow 'freedom' for people to pursue their own goals and improve their lot in life. Communism and central dictates don't work! If people don't get fairly rewarded for their efforts... then they will cease making an effort. If they don't get fairly paid for their work... they will cease to work. If they don't get justice... they will cease obeying the law. If anything, China will be a textbook example to show what happens when you give people freedom and what happens when you take freedom away.

[@hoondailoon4313]

So says the homeless sleeping on cardboard in Lost Angeles.

[@astrahcat1212]

@@hoondailoon4313 yes why some still even try to work at all in that city no clue

[@omegajoe7014]

@@hoondailoon4313 LosT Angeles? The Democrat run city that is trying to centralize everything and slowly going down the road of communist dictatorship? In the state that has used it's centralized control to ban all older trucks causing the greatest supply chain disaster the US has ever seen by driving independent truckers out of business - and adding even more homeless people to sleep on cardboard in the streets? I totally agree with you that it proves the point made.

[@andyboog2010]

@@hoondailoon4313 in LA and many more California cities the homeless actually get paid for their being homeless. They make 600 a month from the city each plus 200 bucks additional for food stamps. The shittu state and local govts encourage this behavior. Which is flat disgusting.

[@berryfin4648]

Winston really cares about China and wants to make it better. That's real constructive criticism.

[@joshkooga7204]

I've been watching a number of his vids over the last 2 years..and i never thought to find out his name..is it really winston?

[@bradley8575]

Yeah meanwhile the average whiny American on the Internet WAAAAA! America is worse it’s a third world country in a Gucci belt it’s a shithole Europe and Canada are paradises We should go there. Yeah as an American This is not criticisms it’s just negative hateful nonsense Criticizing is where you truthfully criticize is something not wrongfully criticize or generalize everything I say that the US healthcare system is all about greed the quality care is good but the cost is ridiculous and it should be universal like other developed countries This is true Criticisms not like WAAAA our healthcare is full shit our healthcare sis worse than third world countries.

[@nikkid4890]

​@@joshkooga7204 Winston Frederick Sterzel

[@G.A.C_Preserve]

@@joshkooga7204 Winston like the one in the novel 1984

[@joshkooga7204]

@@G.A.C_Preserve yep🤔😉

[@sarabarker2219]

You go Winston, China is screwing their people in all ways. I really feel sorry for the children and what they have to look forward to, the people need to act now. Time is running out for them, they need lots of prayers 🙏 😢 😔 💙 🙏

[@jont2576]

China's total wealth just surpassed USA in 2021 at 128 trillion dollars.but good to know the China dream is over....

[@lynnjohnny01]

Save your pathetic prayers for people of Ohio and all the 1 million Americans killed by their government during the pandemic. The Chinese people do not need anything from you, not that you have anything to offer.

[@xxkk232]

Well, ppl inside the wall, right now they are satisfied and feel happy with what they have right now,, especially those ppl from rural area, the Chinese government is putting all the effort to build roads and internet, electricity, rail way to those rural area and make sure they can access transportation and resources as convenient as in big cities,,, (even though in many ways, especially ppl from big cities like me, they are experiencing hard time and feel exhausted about all the things, they can’t just tell and address cuz the society is just so toxic and everyone is just bearing what they are facing/doing. If you have some complaints, you would be the “outcast” cuz they just think that it was normal and we should bear and accept of what we are facing right now, even though there are a lot of unfairness in the current society)

[@lynnjohnny01]

@@xxkk232 Chinese people literally don't care. They don't give a crap about the Party, or what an Anglo-saxon sexpat has to say about them and their country.

[@charleswomack2166]

Awesome video Winston! Between this channel, the China Show, China Fact Chasers & the Chauban Hou ( forgot how to spell) , you must work about 80 hours a week. And it is all for the noblest of pursuits, human rights. My hat is off to you Sir.

[@secretbassrigs]

Winston is really late on this one. The Chinese Dream never really happened under Xi Jinping anyway.

[@secretbassrigs]

@Charles womack, why did you exclude LeLe Farley?

[@rearrangingdeckchairs]

@@secretbassrigs He was talking about how much Winston works I believe, but LeLe Farley is doing good things also. 😊

[@JuliaCantley]

China uncensored and China Insights are great to add to your list too lol

[@arishem555]

don't worry, he has back of his sponsors :-D

[@kyleknapp6029]

The exact same thing happened in Mexico back in the 80s when the ex-president Salinas De Gortari opened a bank and later ran away with all the money. He brought ruin to Mexico which caused a sudden mass migration to the US.

[@GringoXalapeno]

Hmm interesting it seems like the late twentieth century in Mexico is mostly corruption after corruption

[@kellikelli4413]

Even the US govt has plans to confiscate the people's bank account money soon. Via the Obama regimes BAIL-IN scheme....

[@KA-vs7nl]

Ah. So a lose lose all around.

[@kellikelli4413]

@@KA-vs7nl And what he DIDN'T say is, China is the TEST country for what's going to happen in the rest of the world. THAT'S the reason for the credit score & phone apps control system... The alleged virus is just the Fear Factor NEEDED to get the sheeple to comply...

[@hanfucolorful9656]

ex-president Salinas De Gortari opend a bank,.... but in China case it is village banks, not the president. it was just a criminal case in china, no need [over interpretation].

[@TheJenSolo]

My heart goes out to the people who had their money and dreams stolen. Shame on anyone who profited from that! I hope the Chinese people find a way to communicate and organize to start a cultural and political change, though I recognize the challenges are many due to governmental grip and misdirection. Thinking it's a local problem is part of the problem. Your videos are always so interesting, thank you. I heard about this situation a few days back through a news channel (don't recall which one) here on YT and just felt devastated for these people. And I knew you'd have a take on it.

[@sara.cbc92]

Don't feel sorry for them. you don't know them. from my own experience, they will eat your flesh and drink your blood if given the chance.

[@MS-ql8ek]

1960 my boss and his parents( a farming family) flee from southern china during the famine, his family was forced to give up their land or die and they left to Laos and he had seen many people who he grew up with get killed. 1970s he witnessed Vietnam War and was able to go into a refugee camp and eventually moved to the USA in 1980s because his dad helped US troops navigate around Laos. In 2022 he and his wife are millionaires that own their own farming company import and export and they are both US citizens. He has tears everytime time he talks about seeing his friends and family get killed back in the 60s

[@slapsymaxy1462]

My heart goes out to "This Fly."

[@michaeldy3157]

@@slapsymaxy1462 you are a fly?

[@angelachouinard4581]

@@MS-ql8ek Your boss has a great book inside him. I am truly sorry for all he lost and happy and impressed by what he accomplished.

[@33and1third]

"you're met with nothing other than... this fly..."

[@Grendelful]

Very true

[@X19-x5f]

"When did you last hear about Jack Ma?" . Yikes, it's been a really long time. It really emphasizes what the CCP is doing to their country. Thanks for this video.

[@VincentFulco]

nice pictures of him sailing his yacht in europe recently. thank god he got out.

[@methira]

@@VincentFulco everyone else stuck there mate

[@RKhuc]

Communists are communists... they never change!!! From the year 1988 - 2021, China was fooling the world badly by letting the world in believing that China is open and has changed to get a lot of investors! In reality, China has never changed. They just need the big money from investors around the world! Before 1990, China was a very very poor communist country that was closed to the world! They are dictators and tyrants... what do we all expect? The world was fooled and trapped by them... that's all!!!

[@diane9247]

Poor guy. Rotting in one of Xi's concentration camps for being rich. Did that actress ever surface? I can't remember...

[@GottEddy]

Jack Ma is a western invention, like Elon Musk or Bill Gates. That's why he got sanctioned by the chinese government

[@secrets.295]

It bothers me that many of my Chinese Malaysian colleagues feels more emotional attachment to China than they have with Malaysia. The way they spoke about China. Its like China is such a prosperous nation and they are supposedly govern wayyy better than Malaysia. In my heart I laughed so hard 😅😅😅. Bad as the Malaysian economy & government is. The government never turned the entire economic systems into a ponzi scheme. This is one of the worst type of governance ever.

[@kkkk6179]

Unfortunately many Malaysian Chinese got their news within their Chinese community, which is heavily infiltrated by the CCP. Then they spread the same news within their own community to reaffirm their beliefs. Which is why you see a lot of similar traits and behaviors between the Malaysian Chinese and the Mainland Chinese when it comes to news like Russia invading Ukraine, or the death of Shinzo Abe. Many Malaysian Chinese support the invasion, and celebrate the death of Shinzo Abe, just like the Chinese in Mainland China.

[@chanman5600]

Funny enough I encountered a lot of Malaysians of Chinese decent are like that, my conclusion is that they are nutcases, double standard and backward. No interest to make friends with them, they are time waster.

[@chrispekel5709]

Dont you have racism written into your laws that make non ethnic Malays into second class citizens? Could this be a reason why they are like this?

[@dadudice6461]

Malaysian government have opposition party. Also Yang dipertuan Agong that holds a lot authority. So they need to control how much corruption they can do. 😂😂

[@secrets.295]

@@dadudice6461 Yang Dipertuan Agong does hold a lot of power but it was never used. 99.9999% of the time he only mind his own business. Even during the height of the 1MDB scandal, Agong never did anything. And as bad as the corruption in Malaysia is. Its not nearly as bad as in China.

[@laustinspeiss]

I really hope the ‘overseas chinese’ are seeing this, and reviewing their behaviour as international citizens.

[@seanclint2711]

It will be a mighty big hope on what u say. Unfortunately, only a handful is not blinded by its system. There is the majority even being outside the country can,t differentiate, completely drawn to the system by their upbringing. It's understandable loving the country of birth. There are descendants who are influenced by the progress and riches of china which is tricky. Then u got the coffers who will stop at nothing as long the big bugs flow. Hope it is. Cheers

[@billybob3302]

They are all spies and should be deported.

[@tranlenamphuong6192]

Dude your content is very eye-opening. Please keep spreading awareness because ignorance, especially one attained by violence is extremely horrifying. I pray one day people can afford to dream and be trully free from whatever oppression they suffered from.

[@rikilshah]

Gotta feel sad for common Chinese folks fighting on the street for their basic rights.

[@johncunner2429]

As an Iranian trapped here, I wish there was a vlogger who would talk about Iran as well. If it's not worse than China, it's definitely not better :(

[@esbenm6544]

Serpentza and Laowhy could only do this after they left China. While they still lived there they had to censor themselves too.

[@johncunner2429]

@@esbenm6544 I know! That's why I can't do it! Islamic regime is the embodiment of evil! The level of mental torture they put us through everyday is insane. If we get to the real life threat you wouldn't believe how easily they kill people on the streets. If I ever get out of Iran I won't hesitate to things similar to this.

[@bendejong1271]

The best to you myn friend. Hope thinks will get bether for your Kids.

[@johncunner2429]

@@bendejong1271 Thanks friend! I hope things get better and we won't see any more evil acts from Islamic Republic around the world and we can all live in peace.

[@bendejong1271]

@@johncunner2429 hope so two. Best of luck to everyone over there.

[@White20445]

The Chinese looming real estate collapse is reminiscent of the market crash of 1929. People taking loans to buy stock, stock that was increasing based on that speculation and huge influx of cash. Suddenly people can't pay it back and they default on the loans they took out to buy stock and it trickles through the whole system.

[@Kokangalang]

But it’s not going to be saved by a magical war that’s on another continent and one that activates your industry. It’s seems that this may be much more permanent.

[@White20445]

@@Kokangalang I mean, all signs seem to point towards war breaking out in Taiwan. It seems things are getting more and more polarized. I assume we might see larger conflicts through out the world as food prices, inflation, and inequality continue to rise.

[@amberhernandez]

Don't forget good ol' 2008 America! That bubble popping wasn't nearly as bad, but it was the worst in modern memory.

[@valenciasainz]

"We have nothing left to loose." Well, that's the problem.

[@max-zo5ew]

Hi CCP Indonesia is better than China :)

[@Luke-re2tq]

Thanks for being there and telling peoples what's really going on behind the curtains! We need more people like you !

[@CmdrWinters]

Try China Uncensored, they do a good job as well

[@richsuggs2982]

I agree with this video. I used to travel to China for work; the oppression of its citizens is incredible. Glad we moved our supply away from that country, as a foreigner I didn't like the oppression. Sad, it is a beautiful country but ran badly.

[@unduloid]

They call it the Chinese dream because you have to be asleep to believe it.

[@FarWanderer81]

George Carlin quote, repurposed.

[@bradley8575]

More like they call it the Chinese dream because you have to be in a concentration camp to believe in it.

[@lookingfortruth1930]

Same with USA in some ways.

[@lucifer12354]

Like America is different 😏🤣

[@Vortex-zb6be]

@@lucifer12354 that's the entire point of repurposing the quote. They are just as bad as eachother.

[@AApron]

The random fly buzzing through your set...lol

[@cosmic4037]

"We are rapidly approaching an era where people vs government becomes a worldwide phenomenon." ~ John McAfee

[@sharkfinbite]

Don't quote John. He was a nut that lost his money later in his life because of his own incompetence.

[@willinton06]

@@sharkfinbite that doesn’t make this one quote any less true

[@vladimirbaudetski111]

John "hammock" McAfee

[@youaregoingtolovethis]

Since when haven't people been fighting oppressive government overreach and oppression? Since the beginning of time. Not any kind of revelation.

[@rhone733]

@@sharkfinbite Truth is truth regardless of the source.

[@brianrad68]

My nephew lived and worked in China for 10 years. He left end of 2020 for a new job in Vietnam. He's so much happier there.

[@luichinplaystation610]

Good luck for him

[@classic20rock00]

May I ask, which industry he works in? Sounds like he had rather good jobs, with the "expat package"!

[@brianrad68]

@@classic20rock00 He worked for an American outdoor clothing company in China. Same industry different company in Vietnam

[@adrenalinemedia]

Have been to China for many times. Last in 2018. I was able to make contact with several people there who gave me an insight on the true economic situation of the "average people". Even back in 2018/2019 the situation was already catastrophic for many. F.e. they could not afford to pay their rents or medical treatments. Pressure of the local party committees was high. I saw empty hotels and other large buildings that were disguised as if they were on normal business. And I took hundreds of photos of their huge, empty fany malls. A big difference to the years before! And that was all BEFORE the pandemic was declared. I was being asked the most stupid questions by businesspeople, because in that era China shut down Google without a proper substitute and VPNs became forbidden. This has caused many operations to stall, since they are not able to "google" even simple, non-political information like tech etc. In that sense, I would strongly confirm your observation and conclusions. Btw: Me and several others who were in China at that time (2018!) came back with a mysterious, very hefty "flu" that laid me down for 2 full weeks with fever and delirium.

[@Freedom-33]

I also went to China and has a great experience with a middle class working family and didn’t have any mysterious illness. People just love drama.

[@hlatsiieydesu]

I thought it was quite weird that there was no Google. The last time I spoke to a native they hadn’t known of Google

[@Freedom-33]

@@hlatsiieydesu do you have access to, and use Chinas version of google? Or did you not stop to think about the other side of that comment. Google sells the majority of their data, why the hell would China want that type of company in their system?

[@circumcizednun1814]

My god. Is China the next North Korea?

[@amartin9293]

This is why they hate Trump- he was trying to end their servitude and it hurts first when the Marxists go mad to keep power.

[@jacksonrobbins2288]

A Chinese financial collapse would be disastrous for Australia. It's so frustrating that almost every industry has become so impossibly dependent on Chinese investment

[@WindQueen12]

I disagree, Australians are pretty resourceful and resilient.

[@Samookely]

I hope us here in the states can help with that, if we get our shit sorted. At the very least America will always have a very diverse set of land and resources to fall back on that places like russia and china lack. I hope places allied with us have a better time recovering

[@friedbrainz7998]

Ah, we'll be right.

[@tomstraub1148]

Damn. The title , and coming from you, made me a little sad to see. We knew it was happening, but it still gets me. Thanks for all you do !!

[@BobbyGeneric145]

I hope Winston realizes that he is doing incredibly important work. We trust him and he has the connections to get the critical news out of the country.

[@io2068]

China is the perfect example of things Sounding too good to be True.

[@wiadroman]

6:18 "But this is how the Chinese government controls people. You lose your life savings, you want to go and protest about it, and you are met with nothing other then this fly." - comedy gold.

[@elerroniswon1592]

Correction : A Chinese Government Fly.

[@dandarr5035]

If anything, I found what he said to that fly very representative of what the CCP thinks of people who protest. "This fucking fly... I'm gonna kill you if you don't fuck off."

[@Ly2744]

I usually watch the Sabbatical guys channel and somehow clicked on your channel. I’m not a traveller but enjoy your channel and the Sabbatical guy’s channel the most.

[@chitin122]

Problem is modern governments have a hard time dying and being replaced with something new and better. Its sad but all nations stagnate, become corrupt, or implode eventually.

[@I_am_somebody_1234]

A kingdom, long divided, must unite a kingdom, long united, must divide Its a chinese poem, and oh boy is it very correct

[@terenzeujean4581]

howdy, winston! coming in with another banger, another mind-provocating video, you have really led me to think more critically especially about china and issues surround.. cheers!

[@jaman8916]

This man is doing god's work Your videos are very important Thanks!

[@A-Grammie-On-the-ROCK]

Wow excellent video !! So well presented and no lies but telling the truth..

[@kobolila-yt]

I'm dad to a girl we adopted from China 7 years ago and remain a part of the adoption community of facebook. After covid hit adoptions from China ceased and so many families in the process of adopting from there have had their efforts put on hold. It is heart wrenching to witness these families now left in limbo; not knowing if they will ever be able to help these children, give them a home, love and the medical care that many of them need. Further, considering how much of the world relies on products from China, it's collapse could lead to a global disaster.

[@DeadNoob451]

I think you can still help children without participating in human trafficking.

[@turosechil8798]

Plenty of kids need help, i dont know your situation or ethnicity, its only relevant for adoption if its to adopt someone who looks more like the parents, otherwise theres plenty of people who needs a home/love/care.

[@serpentza]

It’s time the world learned to stand on its own again, this abusive relationship has to stop

[@jaydee6268]

@@turosechil8798 you are so old fashioned.

[@jaydee6268]

@@DeadNoob451 true, but legal adoptions generally do not constitute such.

[@mexicotaco0913]

as someone who lived in China between 2008-2014, it feels weird to see China descending into a state like this. Just like you SerpentZA, i've seen China bloom, witnessed how much potential the country has. But looks like the problems they sweeped under the rug is finally spilling out. I hope the best for the people of China

[@wizardbeard69]

you mean the part where 3/4 of the country lives in 19th century abject povery and that time they murdered 60 million farmers? yea, a great place...absolutely fabulous...building cardboard cities isn't "blooming"....if the government was overthrown and the people were allowed to flourish they could without a doubt be the top of the world ladder...she sheer amount of people (human resource) allows them to do things on a scale not many other countries are capable of...they have an abundance of unused land that could be feeding all their people easily and modern rural towns could spring up everywhere...it could be magnificent...but until the CCP is removed, that will NEVER happen...

[@jumbojumbo6866]

@@wizardbeard69 the government can be overthrown its just that the people are being restricted by billionaires to do so but if you watch sri lanka recent videos of the parliament house set on fire its gonna teach someone that man power is at its full potential and not the government.

[@mexicotaco0913]

never said it was great, nor do I support the CCP. I am aware of the issues of China's "improvement" in quality of life -- nothing but an empty shell. But hey, at least people stopped peeing and pooping on the street, right?

[@doujinflip]

2008~2018 is basically China's golden age, that party ended with the HK crackdowns and it's been downhill ever since. The 1st-tier urban China I'm experiencing now feels anxious and stagnant, hard to imagine how it is in lesser parts of the country.

[@lazyhusband]

China is just a giant Ponzi scheme

[@RunningTings310]

hah 1 million subscribers!!! been watching this show off and on for years, crazy to see it grow so big. Always appreciated the story of this bloke seeing the writing on the wall in his home country, being so successful in such an exotic place then eventually moving to so cal where I'm from. I'm also an IT engineer by trade :). Sadly what we see here is a trial run for the rest of the world.

[@Aquascape_Dreaming]

'You'll own nothing, and you'll be happy.' -World economic forum Sure seems like these poor Chinese people are thrilled at had having their money stolen, by their own government, no less.

[@MikeOxlong-]

Yep, coming to a country near you, and soon! 😂

[@JanuszKrysztofiak]

1M subscribers, CCP must hate him :)

[@ben2707]

ive been watching winston since he had under 1000 subs, amazing to see his growth and him following chinas rise and dem..

[@robinsattahip2376]

There's a lesson to be learned here about the evil and danger of so-called smartphones.

[@localextremist2839]

What are you using to type your comment?

[@spacepanda420]

This is horrifying... Scary to think what could happen because of this

[@michaeldy3157]

China will attack taiwan

[@thathandsomedevil0828]

Tianaman Square 2.0.

[@dancroitoru364]

@@thathandsomedevil0828 I would rather hope for November 2022 1.0

[@chanfranc]

@@thathandsomedevil0828 Nah! Any small sign of uprising will be squashed immediately by Xi Jin Ping.

[@TomahawksNShotShells]

War. Thats what can happen. Tensions in the East China Sea between Japan and China, invading Japanese and Taiwanese air space, construction of military forward airbases near those areas, the destruction of Hong Kongs democratic party, military buildup, ect. It's on the horizon

[@NeonTrapperKeeper]

You explain the real estate, bank bust, and unemployment issue really well and how it all ties together, spelling out the end of the Chinese dream. Well done, thank you.

[@ninamartin1084]

Just a matter of time before Serpentza figures out all the same stuff is going on in the USA.

[@liw_lostinwonderland]

@@ninamartin1084 everyone already knows that already though

[@1mol831]

We need a New Zealand dream

[@1mol831]

@@liw_lostinwonderland New Zealand should distance itself from USA and become a world leader

[@michaelcheung8297]

I know this is serious but I laughed so hard at Winston’s aggression towards the poor fly!🤣

[@PrograError]

*laser eye *

[@ArthurCheesebag84]

I know right? That was shocking. Entertaining though.

[@mattresbert]

Shoo fly

[@qualat9340]

I think the fly was imaginary to let him more comfortably personify how the government is interacting with its people.

[@cocadoodledoo6346]

It was a Chinese spy fly.

[@trukeesey8715]

Very sad about your brother. I'll not watch the videograph but the headline is enough to see how you might feel.

[@blackbirdpie217]

Knowing how the incomplete ghost cities have been the chief personal investment vehicle, and how empty and useless they really are, the world has been waiting for this shoe to drop. I'm surprised it's taken this long.

[@edwinholcombe2741]

But how did they fool so many people to invest their life savings into non-productive investments?

[@legatrix]

@@edwinholcombe2741 The most privileged get early access and sell them on. To the early buyers, they are productive.

[@ericconnor8419]

@@edwinholcombe2741 People are greedy

[@amartin9293]

Maybe not if they decide to nuke everyone and think they have a place to run. May whoever does this perish first.

[@markmike7933]

@@edwinholcombe2741 It's not like America where if things are going south, Someone Somewhere is going to get that information out...whether online or to the media...Most of the time. Not all of the time. And that's in our Democracy. In a communist state...you just make believe everything is going well and if you know differently, shut your mouth

[@maofangjushi4711]

Thanks Winston, your "lived in China" experiences gives you the ability to analyse China 's problem deep an accurate.

[@MrSandManBringMeADream]

as someone who lives in a third world country which nothing is going any better than china, it's truely heartwarming. we also live in a country with absolute no freedom and no guts to fight back. i know it's not a great scene to see such chaos. but this chaos is also a sign of courage. to be this brave enough to fight back is not an easy thing at all. just wanted to say, this is very inspiring as terrifying it is. and my heart goes for all innocent people in china. may the better days come for all of us..

[@MrSandManBringMeADream]

@@pppperfectbeauty3550 iran

[@pppperfectbeauty3550]

@@MrSandManBringMeADream congratulations 🎉👏 Iran for finding lithium reserve in their country

[@MrSandManBringMeADream]

@@pppperfectbeauty3550 like that changes anything in the quality of our lives lol. i appreciate that tho. it may be useful if we don't die in these few months because government is throwing toxic gas in the high schools.

[@ishowfeelings]

@@MrSandManBringMeADream And? Still alive?

[@MrSandManBringMeADream]

@@ishowfeelings still kickin' yeah. less genocide for now here. thank you for asking

[@lilianafm]

Thank you for being so bold and brave with the information you share.

[@undercrackers56]

The unbiased truth delivered by someone who has love for the country and it's people.

[@lynnjohnny01]

The same kind of "love" that rapists and pedophiles claim when they sexually assault helpless people. American men are all rapists and pedos.

[@ianbardon8581]

Once upon a time.

[@anthonyinzerillo2804]

You're joking right? He's extremely biased and doesn't care about Chinese people at all

[@Entropy67]

​@@anthonyinzerillo2804 He cares more about the Chinese people then you can possibly imagine. You have no idea what you are missing out on. You don't know how it feels to live in a country where you can actually have faith in institutions and government to have your back if your in trouble. Countries that would pay you for doing nothing, if you are a citizen of the country & qualify for financial aid. Countries that are made by people, for the sake of every single person that belongs to that country. CCP doesn't care about you, or any of its citizens. Most people that hear of how it is like to live in your country have nothing but sympathy and kindness for your people, please leave your country and visit one more developed and you will see how the people are cared for in a real government. Then reconsider weather its OK that you & your peoples culture was eradicated and you were forced to live in a dictatorship called the CCP.

[@dallywang6143]

"You lose your life savings, you want to go and protest about it and you're met with nothing other than this... fly." Brilliant

[@kyleshockley1573]

Not criticizing the CCP directly, it was the same apparently for the camp uprisings in the Soviet Union. Political prisoners in Kengir kept to just criticizing the camp regime, rather than the Central Committee. They were crushed by tanks in the end anyway, regardless of how many banners they made saying "Long live the Central Committee of the proletariat!" and only demanding for the camp administration to be held accountable. An attack on Gulag was an attack on the government.

[@Infodumptruck]

The background video of everyday life in china is helpful on its own, just because its plain and honest. Nice touch.

[@enigmawstudios4130]

The banking issue is spreading fast. They're starting to freeze accounts from anyone who's traveled abroad or has any international connection in many different cities

[@sleeptyper]

So eventually cheap chinesium stores on eBay cease to function?

[@tomast9034]

well an old saying here ....yours is what you hold in your hands... especially money. bank account is just a bunch of ones and zeros at some harddrive who knows where and can be put to zero anytime.

[@Wickedtingzz]

@@tomast9034 ya they take all our money and invest it , in who knows what .

[@TexasTimelapse]

@@sleeptyper I hope so.

[@oldmandoinghighkicksonlyin1368]

This will spread to the west, and because of the 9000 IQ move to print money to solve the pandemic woes, all governments have no firewall to prop up failing banks. Convert your money to physical precious metals now.

[@TheSusaneneely]

Perhaps this year will be the end of the “ghost government”…I pray for their demise and the freeing of the people!!

[@meowmeow1733]

Freeing the people to do what? Pick/make a new "government" that's just as bad or worse.... It's not a ccp problem,....it's a corrupt societal problem. The ccp treats Chinese people the way they treat each other daily. One authoritarian government will fall only to be replaced by another who learn (kind of) from the miss steps of the previous and be even more brutal. This is how Asians operate. The only Asian countries who have completely adopted democracy and understand individual rights are those that where broken free from the Asian society authoritarianism bubble are those taken over by democratic countries. True Asian society....China, the Koreas, Myanmar , Vietnamese, Kazakhstan....the list go on,...don't understand democracy and individuality or human rights. Asian society roots isn't based in what the ccp is....what Chinese society is.....is Brutal. It's deeply rooted down to the family structure.

[@Funkywallot]

@DeRucci Ouch....unfortunately it has some truth in what you wrote. Social unrest between the government friendly people and all the others could be the result

[@notnecessary7730]

NOPE!!! sry but not gonna stop because certain countries are supporting CCP!!!! Because it's all part of the NWO agenda!!!!

[@lyndacompton1846]

People of the whole world not just China

[@mushishi9684]

This reminds me when I was little, late 80-90's in Yugoslavia and when this scenario also happened in the same manner and than the inflation and.....Man it was insane!! Pozdrav Winston Beograd 💛U

[@cincarevic]

Hyperinflation here we go again.

[@jerryrichardson2799]

Note to Chinese in China: Don't dream, it's over.