The Correct Ranking of the Artist Battle performances of Boys Planet

[@tiredmarley]

Alternative Rankings: Enjoyment Ranking 1_ Say My Name 2_ Switch 3_ Over Me 4_ Supercharger 5_ En Garde Skill Ranking 1_ En Garde 2_ Switch 3_ Supercharger 4_ Say My Name 5_ Over Me 50% Enjoyment 50% Skill 1_ Switch 2_ Say My Name 3_ En Garde 4_ Supercharger 5_ Over Me And if you're on the discord server you get a ranking of all 28 trainees individually 🥸🤟

[@seungminslove1777]

YOU KNOW ZHANG HAO FANS ARE GONNA KILL YOU IF THEY SEE IT I ASK GOD FOR YOUR SAFETY

[@thelsthoughts]

You have a discord server?! 🤯

[@shimjeya5829]

Jay and Gunwook being the 'always getting robbed' duo.

[@StLaRizz]

My favorite part of these stages is the fact that every group had something happen that barely or didn’t get acknowledged by Mnet and we as Star Creators just accepted it: Switch - I actually got nothing lol I just find it super convenient PHanbin was able to join a team where he extensively practiced the choreo out of pure fun and easily became their center and secured his spot in the finals Supercharger - Apparently Haruto can sing and Woongki can rap because.. fuck it? Over Me - Why exactly did everyone keep Jeonghyeon in the group? He fit well but you would think “Kill This Love” G group would have protected their own and just made a part 2 (w/ Jay?) Say My Name - Jiwoong ultimately did fit, yes, but the fact he was grouped with the other 4 and portrayed as a graduating school boy along side them is.. hilarious En Garde - Minion Boy can apparently correctly hit high notes and was given the task to do such because.. yeah

[@catajeong7690]

As a Jaystar I will not be mad if Jay had placed third, sure I am biased towards him, but Zhang Hao deserved his first spot, and kuanji definitely killed this performance, his dancing was amazing!!

[@Halateeez]

You have my respect!

[@novamoin246]

En garde was done dirty by the camera work and also Mnet I feel? Like it was trending after the live performance. But the broadcast sabotaged it. It was also the last performance and Mentor ph1 said it was the best one and he never exaggerates reactions.

[@felisitasartemisiarerung3173]

Yes the camera work for en garde is suck, like the choreo and their energy is way better in their dance practice

[@suspicioussloth]

It feels like en garde’s stage budget was way lower than the rest

[@thethingcalledlisa]

En garde is such a great song, with such a good choreo, amazing performers but the stage‘s sadly not as amazing as the rest, it seems a lot more bland, if I wasn’t that addicted to the song and choreo I’d probably say it was the least memorable performance Supercharger also seemed to have a more bland stage, with a weaker concept compared to the ep 10 performances, I wonder why that happened

[@peachyniki]

@@thethingcalledlisa bland stage for supercharger?? i DISAGREE

[@thethingcalledlisa]

@@peachyniki I purely mean the staging but I guess it’s good since the entire focus was on the trainees

[@samruddhibande2656]

mattchu in cute/refreshing concept >>>>>>>>>>

[@samruddhibande2656]

@ing-wen tsai samee

[@mysteriousplayer248]

I felt the SAME I loved the song En Garde, but the performance just didn't do it for me. I really liked the Switch performance! So cute, and Woongi's comment about marrying Taerae lol 🍐✨ Also loving your "Haruto's husband" comment 😂

[@gunwooku]

Ngl i really enjoyed super charger (probably the most). Maybe because of the energy and my personal taste of the song

[@ahrufue2997]

yea I feel like en garde performance was nice but it wasnt as interesting to rewatch at times, aside from me rewatching for hiroto's facial expressions becuz he slayed. I would say kuanjui or zhanghao were a standout in over me for me, and say my name mattchu killed it. My least favorite is switch just becuz of the song composition. supercharger performance was so rewatchable, like everyone did their part in a sense, haruto and zihao dance

[@thethingcalledlisa]

Seeing how many different opinions there are just shows how amazing all of the performances were, also since you mentioned Takuto I gotta say he was actually quite impressive in this performance considering his first one was quite terrible I‘m scared of Thursday, none (except for the under 16 year olds cause I just can’t with people that young debuting) should get eliminated, I really hope they get to pursue their dreams in the future, they’re clearly working really hard for it

[@ahrufue2997]

@@thethingcalledlisa Yea takuto has been steadily improving since the beginning of the show, and supercharger is def one of his better perfs. Im scared for eliminations too but also becuz we had to wait a whole week since last perfs, I want it over with ;-;

[@christine7295]

The fact that smn team let go of ollie and kept jiwoong was kind of outrageous. Ollie can definitely do jiwoong's part well, and the fact that he looks exactly how a teenager should look should have been enough reason for him to stay in the team. p.s. i literally vote for jiwoong since the beginning, i love him and will always support him

[@yuri-tq4ed]

no fr. they just kept it safe by keeping all the top ranked ppl which ruined it for me ngl

[@thedxrito]

imo i thought they chose teams off friendship 😭 basically the same thing as popularity bc of how cliquey bp is but anyway

[@christine7295]

@@thedxrito yujin and seungeon were there tho?

[@thedxrito]

@@christine7295 wdym? it was hanbin jiwoong matthew seungeon yujin: hanbin and matthew are close, matthew and jiwoong from love killa, jiwoong and yujin from backdoor (practically father and son) i don't know about seungeon but i swear i've seen him interact with the top 9 a lot, also he's just known for insane vocals LOL they all become friends by extension its just like that 🤷‍♀ edit: oh yeah seungeon is literally a yuehua trainee!! him and yujin are close and he's close with zhang hao who's close with hanbin etc etc

[@luvmnz]

cry about it LMAOO

[@leeseo1107]

No cause ive been wondering why people rank switch so low that was my favorite stage ever !!!!! Also Jay got robbed so bad his vocals literally made the vocal aspect of over me

[@yuri-tq4ed]

2:54 youre never letting minion boy go 😭

[@jihye8353]

after watching this is feel a lot less guilty for thinking kuanjui did better than ricky or junghyeon 😅

[@sseaweedflavor]

full disclosure, supercharger has 4 of my favourite trainees and i've been listening to switch non-stop it has himbo energy i can't explain it and i love it even tho it's messy (it makes all the same parts of my brain light up as why not and zimzalabim) I really feel like I'm missing something with Jeonghyeon aside from him being beautiful. Like obviously he can rap but he's not the best or even most engaging rapper in the show and I could give or take his verse in Over Me. Not necessarily because it was technically bad but because I don't know that the song really needed it- or maybe I'm just very sensitive to adding rap verses to songs idk I think it's always a gamble on whether they improve a song, make it worse or just sort of exist, which is how I felt about Over Me. I think people are really underselling the importance of Jay's vocals too; even if he didn't necessarily stand out the most on stage without him the whole stage would have felt flat imo. It's part of the performance and the parts make up the whole. Say My Name grew on me so quickly??? Like I started out meh on it bc it's a little basic but it's the epitome of a simple concept done perfectly and the vibes are Immaculate. buuuut look I love Jiwoong, I want him in bep1er, but sis can't keep running away from having bigger parts and relying on his charisma alone. We know he can sing so I don't know why he won't do it; I always want MORE from him. neway I'm fully preparing myself for disappointment tomorrow. Haruto, Jay and Seowon have been in my votes from the beginning and I have minimal faith in Seowon surviving but hopefully Jay can get back up the rankings and Haruto will start getting the recognition he deserves.

[@anonymuser8662]

I'm glad we agree on the 'visual trio' 🙄 (Han Yujin, Gyuvin, Jiwoong)

[@rxmz2386]

I feel like jays confidence has dropped a lot since I’ve seen him in the first episode. I only watch boys planet an have any picks but jay is super noticeable esp since he expresses his emotions through facial expressions. Like at the start of over me he was smiling and looked like so happy to be on stage? And watching his fancam he looked serious and it makes sense seeing that he heard ppl not cheer for him. I genuinely hope he gets his confidence back bc he can clearly preform well based on his past stages

[@rxmz2386]

Typo- I don’t have any picks :))

[@Romyjohn14]

Mine: My no biased list 1 Say my name - this song is my type, my happiness, I felt happy seeing them performing this song. I like cute and bright concept because it gives bright energy. And I saw a lot of fans doing dance cover of this song on tiktok and they really happy to cover it. Best performer: Seok Matthew, I am addicted to his fancam, his smile, energy and expression brighten up my day. 2. Over Me - This song is sexy cool and my other side wanted me to sing this song specially the chorus which sang by the killing part member and I think a lot of fans loved to do a song cover of this song out of the 4(that was so cool) Best performer: Jay literally slaying his part adlib, highnotes. His vocal is so great. 3. Switch - This song is fun and cute I like the choreography of this song specially the chorus part. The members feel they are having fun dancing to it but not as impactful song for me. Best performer : Park Hanbin (keita is my biased) but yeah Park Hanbin did the dance and the killing part very well. 4 Super Charger - Sorry not my type of song but they are all great performer and their versatility are great. Best Performer: Haruto slay 5. En Garde - Choreography wise, vocally wise but not also my type but they are all talented and great performer. Best performer: Gunwook literally slay

[@munchkin5679]

Jay was robbed. That's all I have to say.

[@i.nv.u]

the version that they aired with all the jerky camera movements was so annoying cause how are you going to focus on other members in the MIDDLE of his high note and then give him like no other exposure

[@Spiderpunkrocks]

The thing is all these songs, are actually better than any boy group releases so far this year Oop😶

[@0seunggf]

mnet def didn’t di en garde team justice many live audience said it was so much better live

[@Spiderpunkrocks]

My ranking cause it turned out more differently than I thought. 1. Switch- I thought this is going to be down there with supercharger as my least favourite, but wow the performance had me obsessed and inevitably made me also like the song when I'm really not one to usually like messy songs like this. Favorite trainee: taerae, yes I'm biased cause he's pretty, I give clout to pretty people, pretty privelage exist and I'm part of the problem (okay. Fine park hanbin did the best ) 2. En garde- this song since the start is my favorite together with say my name. And on the official audio the arrangement is chefs kiss, the ending always gives me goose bumps. The stage was alright, tho I thought this is a perfect stage to showcase these trainees stage pressesence, it is just that kind of song. But unfortunately yes they all did great but no one really stand out Favourite: lee seunghwan like I still don't understand why he's not one of the top trainees he basically has EVERYTHING. And as expected I knew he's gonna fit this performance the best 3. Say my name- I've really been waiting for this performance but the line up kinda ruined it for me especially since they actually have the perfect trainees already but let them go to have a team with top trainees. That's is society unfortunately. It was alright but it became more lacklustre than my expectations, still really like the song tho Favorite trainee: Mathew no surprise there 4. Over me- I think this is the case where I expected too much they have the perfect line up, the props, the materials, the quality but it didn't really resonate much on me on the stage unfortunately and idk exactly why, but one of the reason for it really might be because of my high expectations, the song tho is perfect Favorite trainee: Ricky, tho skill wise he wasn't the best but no doubt he belongs to this concept. He did what I was expecting on engarde trainees which is to stand out 5. Super charger- if it's just performance I'll put it on 2nd but as I said I'm not really fan of songs like this and unfortunately they didn't manage to get the switch treatment for me even with a great performance. Favorite trainee: haruto, you really can not beat a trainee who had been through it all with this song lol.

[@christybecera7669]

Song-wise I really like Say My Name as I always like cute boygroup songs + Matthew's smile says it all. Being biased, I will choose Over Me because Jay is there and I can't understand how he got the least votes despite the vocals he served. I also like Switch because that is also some cute+refreshing song. Sorry but En Garde and Supercharger are not my cup of tea, but overall they did great.

[@Spiderpunkrocks]

All the budget went to switch and supercharger and you know what... It's what they deserved

[@anjunxis]

very late to this but i’m glad i’m not the only one who didn’t find en garde super exciting,,, like i enjoyed it but mostly bc i liked the song itself. i saw so many people acting like it was the best performance to ever happen on a survival show and i just didn’t get the hype

[@1sugarplum971]

Fr tho I was expecting SMN performance to be the No. 1, so I was a lil shocked when it didn't. It was all perfect. I can see Bep1er debuting with this kind of song.

[@hanashaumyavialda609]

Finally, someone who said Switch performance is one of the best!!!

[@tkkashat6887]

1.Over me - Vocals were clearly the best and the song was high af. The dance had the most stylized dance to fit a specific concept. It was clearly the best stage. 2. SuperCharger - This was the hardest dance and everybody was stable. Like how? -_- I feel like nobody used to seeing the cute concept trainees pull this off and they arent as popular so yall not judging the stages correctly. 3. Say my name - very middle ground to me I was looking forward to this performance but I had to sit down and think about it maybe I was itching to see it because all of the popular trainees. But I watched it again and it was literally just mid and the chemistry was off. 4. En garde - Basically Hui and Seung hwan saved the performance. I feel like the stage was outdated and the camera was all over the place. I cant remember anything besides seunghwans high note because the camera was all over the place and HIROTO still managed to miss the camera......like wtf was this stage it was not it. Then to add insult to injury Gyuvin who looked like a background dancer gets first. I cant. 5. Switch - Justice for their wardrobe. Shuibo need to sue mnet at this point. Why they make him go up their with them thrift store entensions? Kim taerae voice does not suit every song he sounds so weird in switch. Jongwoo and kamden cant do this concept at all. Sigh atleast kamden sounded good tho. Keita had no stage presence which is a first. No but foreal I had to watch it three times cause them damn EXTENTIONS were wayy to distracting to the stage like they looked so ridiculous I could not take this stage seriously. Also Taerae should have not been singing that damn part he sound too oldmanish for this type song I CANT. Justice for shuibo he might need therapy after his elimination.

[@LiveLaughLoveMika143]

If i didn't watch the promotional videos, I would've been so confused on who tf Minion Boy was 🤣

[@ainjoevicksapinit5778]

The comment about Say My Name being a literal happy pill is so funny to me. Because I was so ready to be like happy and smiley while watching but all I got was meh, that was it? No offense but Say My Namr performance was a bit mid or average for me. It was not bad but was not good either.

[@gabrielguerra223]

Lee Seunghwan got 1sr place I'm my heart

[@Alena-cq1ze]

I'm curious, why Genius Lee last 👀

[@tiredmarley]

For adding that unnecessary rap verse, other than that he did good

[@yujinisms]

Im curious though.. Why is shuaibo ur last fav performer in switch? He actually did great for someone who trained in china, which has a different idol system unlike kpop iykwim. Idk if its bc u dont like him or bc he didnt catch ur attention during the performance, but pls tell me! I need to know😢😢

[@tiredmarley]

He did a good job actually, it's just in some parts his dancing was a little awkward and he did have some problems with his in ear monitor, other than that he did great (the people above him either had more stand out moments or were more consistent)

[@yujinisms]

@@tiredmarley thx for explaining! Off topic, but whats ur opinion abt jongwoos behaviour?

[@romy805]

I was gonna ask why taerae was so low but then remembered they all ate lmao

[@yuri-tq4ed]

my personal ranking aka the correct one: 1. supercharger: do i need to explain myself? 2. en garde: kinda boring after the first 3 listens but hiroto killed it 3. switch: WITHOUT YOU MY ENGINE WILL STOPP 4. over mid: snooze 5. say my name: i have no comment

[@n44talie]

OVER MID…..??????????????? get some help plz

[@carcasscrash]

@@n44talie people are allowed to have an opinion buddy. Over me was my favorite, but idc if its not the same for everyone.

[@andresw6921]

Over mid 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@sombertoeclown3581]

from what I've gathered from ur content it seems as though ricky is your favorite

[@tiredmarley]

Tall and rich, young and handsome 🥸

[@sombertoeclown3581]

@Walya thx babe

[@chaesstrawberry9449]

is this supposed to be satirical

[@thelsthoughts]

Just out of curiosity: why is “minion boy” known as minion boy? 🤔

[@thethingcalledlisa]

Because of his 1 minute pr video

[@noemie2323]

Guys just give some love to Genius Lee too why is everyone ignoring him 😭😭 He was the best in Over Me imo...

[@zb1-mattwoong]

whos ur top9

[@thethingcalledlisa]

Their top 9: 1 I 2 love 3 you 4 I 5 want 6 you 7 Seok 8 Ma 9 tthu Sorry, I had to

[@audioszzone6139]

@@thethingcalledlisa ….

[@mari6694]

Thank you for having the same opinion with me🥹🙏🏻