The Crime Of Being

The thumbnail is a picture of modern day socialists giving the middle finger to a monument dedicated to the people who died due to socialism.
-----
Join the community discord! ► / discord
Watch Us LIVE (And Click Dat Sub Button!) ► / gameboomers
GB Archive Channel ► / gameboomer
Dev Kit Channel ► / @thedevkit
SFO Backups Channel ► / channel
-----
SUPPORT THE SHOW:
BTC:bc1q6udqgvfm9uaj59l24ut7f73wvsfu707kk6pn3m
SubscribeStar! ► www.subscribes...
Streamlabs! ► streamlabs.com...
Patreon! ► / shortfatotaku
Paypal! ► paypal.me/short...
Humble Bundle Affiliate Link! ► www.humblebund...
Amazon CAN Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/322aFAa
Amazon USA Affiliate Link! ► amzn.to/30PLxgN
Amazon CAN Wishlist! ► www.amazon.ca/...
Amazon USA Wishlist! ► www.amazon.com...
-----
SFO-CIAL MEDIA! HYUK HYUK
DA TWEETS ► / sfosecretary
DA FACES ► / sfotaku
DA GABS ► www.gab.com/sh...
DA MINDS ► www.minds.com/...
DA PARLERS ► parler.com/pro...
DA STEAMS ► steamcommunity....
-----
Credits:
Thumbnail ► some dumb commies
Background ► / cryomancerlex
Music ► • Parasite Eve OST - Out...
#JordanPeterson #AndyNgo #Socialism

[@ShortFatOtaku]

moar gaming tonight on GB guys, it's the friday night fren show playing BL2. seeya at 7 pm est: twitch.tv/gameboomers & kzbin.info

[@TheLewylew]

Never make it scroll that fast again, how can I get past and listen while looking at something that fast going across the screen. Made me dizzy af. Otherwise good video well done

[@ugandanknuckles3900]

I knew this all already. You're late as usual Otaku.

[@sardonically-inclined7645]

might want to add #Marx to the video tags

[@legionxfretensis1010]

Hey, what is the monument in the thumbnail?

[@casanimated1715]

There is a difference between socialism and dictatorship like socialism is complex as having good health care means less payments on medical and can afford other things like being able to pay their higher taxes because of the high price of health in USA the taxes can be too high and can end people in poverty having the government pay for something means that the price can be lower than privatized things even with the increasing tax

[@ItsAGundam]

That ending!

[@seed6021]

Love your content!

[@ancientdarkmagic1409]

A wild Gundam has appeared.

[@anthonymerchant2597]

Man I just found this channel tonight and never thought I would see you here Gundam. Your videos crack me and my wife up all the time!

[@musicmind6634]

based ending

[@komododrogo9171]

Unexpected pop-up, keep up the good stuff 👍

[@Hammerhead547]

These envious little worms disgust me to no end, I was taught that envy is a shameful emotion to publicly express or engage in because expressing it is a form of personal moral weakness.

[@kaletovhangar]

They weren't taught that, though. That is the problem, or were too sheltered and spoiled to comprehend that.

[@roycehuepers4325]

Knew someone in college I'd debate with who was honest enough to admit he was a communist because he viewed himself as the next Lenin. He thought he'd be the one in control.

[@xXSpaceMexicanXx]

15:20 Karl Marx's dad fkn clowning on him, calling him a spoiled brat with bitch-bones is absolutely poetic

[@SierraSierraFoxtrot]

I did not see this on Twitter, glad that you're covering this. JBP is on point and I don't think his Biblical example is too dramatic, it's exactly as dramatic as it should be. The story of Cain and Abel isn't even all that far removed from reality, other than the bit about a magical sky daddy. People kill each other all the time because they're jealous.

[@AlessandroRodriguez]

I don't see my enemies as evil, but utterly stupid en the worst case, or misguided by their "good intentions" at best

[@Super-Sheepy]

I always joke that socialists are the new emo but there may be something to it now, great video and fascinating hearing Marx dad's opinions of him

[@Reddreambigfart]

As someone who for quite a while considered himself significantly further left than I am now, I find your collation of leftist writings and historical contexts in service of a larger point fascinating. Your deep understanding of Marxism and adjacent ideologies provides a lot of room for personal reflection and thought, and for as long as it may take to put it all together, I really enjoy when you use different leftist texts that you have read to give that context for those uninformed.

[@Webmaster4531]

He understands so deeply he has no idea Marx didn't invent socialism. The ones Marx calls utopian socialists did and it's nothing like communism.

[@maxieprimo2758]

I love my socialist bashing

[@TheGreenKnight500]

I'm sick of socialism. Marxist socialism National socialist Black National socialism Corpo-socialism Techno-socialism I can't stand any of it. I just want to be left alone. I'm wise on these greedy misanthropic scumbags pretending they're just doing what's best for me.

[@voidwanderer7138]

genuinely 👌

[@opkarl7203]

* pill time! *

[@SergioLeonardoCornejo]

I wish it was more material tbh.

[@MagpieDynamics]

Simple as

[@QueenAleenaFan]

I'm glad that Marx's dad rebuked him so firmly. It makes me feel good that even good people can raise bad folks, and that good ideas remain in the modern era too.

[@wojak-sensei6424]

Marx Sr. should've said "On your knees and wait for me. Now." Then, he'd travel all the way to his flat and whip out the belt.

[@KuroKumo96]

His dad should have cut him off The problem i have with his dad is that he didn’t let Marx fend for himself, instead he exclaimed his disappointment but kept sending him money. Today those parents exist and because they don’t have the strength to tell their children no then society has to deal with them when they come out of college. Honestly if it were me I’d let them struggle on their own and if socialism is really as great as they say then they will make it alone

[@danielsurvivor1372]

@@wojak-sensei6424 He should've made his own book refuting Marx Jr book

[@IronFreakV]

Well even Marxed seemed to dislike the first Marxists ironically

[@Thebigem]

Is his Dad really a Giga Chad?

[@callumsparrow4379]

“Everyone, help me defeat capitalism by making me rich!” gives off the same energy as “Everyone, help me defeat the monarchy by building me a castle!”.

[@crispyandspicy6813]

Not really because a castle is useful as an instrument of war. More like "Everyone help me defeat the monarchy by proclaiming me the new King (with the exact privilleges of the old one of course)"

[@KopperNeoman]

@Crispy and Spicy Oh don't worry. The revolution will build a republic. Sure, the constitution will specifically erode liberties you had under the King, but you can trust the President.

[@inkubus6192]

“Everyone, help me defeat the monarchy by swearing fealty to me!”

[@inkubus6192]

Also, it has a real “anarchist organization”/ “Flat Earth society members all around the world” level of incoherence to it.

[@t.wcharles2171]

@@crispyandspicy6813 sounds like Oliver Cromwell.

[@ZombieCorp999]

"You spend your nights giving birth to monsters", his father had a deep view into his son's mind, Nostradamus could not have done better.

[@randomcenturion7264]

Poor man would have been devastated to see what came to pass.

[@arkcliref]

"Why did i sleep at your mom at that time? Biggest mistake of my life." -marx's dad, probably

[@your_waifu_hates_you]

Imagine if he knows what happened many decades later when the monster birthed by his son unleashed a hell never seen before upon the world.

[@விஷ்ணு_கார்த்திக்]

@@your_waifu_hates_you Honestly, i kinda wish Marx himself lived to see the utter evil&ruin that his "teachings" inspired. The promised bloodsoaked "utopia"

[@Johnnysmithy24]

His ideas quite literally gave birth to the movements with the highest death counts in history. This needs a fucking movie made about him (from a non socialist perspective ofc)

[@ashgonza92]

Seeing Marx's letters from his father makes me realize how much of a bugman Marx was

[@DonPetexX]

He was a parasite

[@zeogold]

Bugman?

[@feliciab5019]

@@zeogold if you watch content from the Lotus Eaters, there is an episode regarding an American “Bugwoman” versus a Canadian Trad Housewife. Watch that for more context.

[@ashgonza92]

@@zeogold KZbin "Luke Smith bugman"

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

Sounds like how a father would write to his son today. I wonder if Cenk’s nephew’s father loves him.

[@DjMaxi005]

Nationalists: "Damn you, globalists!" Libertarians: "Damn you, government!" Socialists: "Damn you, rich dad!"

[@orrorsaness5942]

Globalists: “Damn you, nationalists!”

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

Globalists certainly hate us.

[@jackalenterprisesofohio]

I perfer feudalism

[@lordofthepizzapie9319]

Authoritatians: "Damn you, free will!"

[@Markunator]

Support for socialism is more likely to be found among poor people, cope harder.

[@AsymmetricalCrimes]

My favorite quote about politics is from the KZbinr, Kraut: "If you dedicate your entire ideology to the opposition of something, you will inevitably sell yourself out to something that is worse than what you originally opposed."

[@Touma134]

Weirdly enough wind waker ganondorf fits that bill. Good intentions but the hatred of hyrule and envy of its fertile land corrupted him.

[@maximus4765]

Imagine thinking "no act against my enemies is wrong" and unironically thinking you're the good guy because you just cannot comprehend people having other values.

[@Y2KNW]

"no act against my enemies is wrong" is something religious zealots say/

[@rassilkrishnan3120]

but acting against your enemies until there is only you is how you win ultimately and that winning and the ultimate peace it brings due to the state of having no opposition towards your designs and values is worth it. it is just pure logic.

[@DonVigaDeFierro]

"Those who make you believe absurdities, will make you commit atrocities". - Voltaire.

[@artski09]

it's all fun and games till your placed in the helicopter it's goes both ways commie

[@rahn45]

"No act against my enemies is wrong" is simply saying "I want enemies" in a self-righteous way.

[@Tartersauce101]

"There is a huge difference between loving the poor and hating the rich." -Jordan Peterson

[@rogierb5945]

Ask anyone who wants help the poor wether they prefer abolishing taxes for the poor or massive taxation on the rich. Their reply is the answer to wich type they are.

[@pleaseenteranamelol711]

Love the poor? Theres no need to "love" anybody. Just be aware that theres nothing inherently WRONG with being poor, thats all.

[@Tartersauce101]

@@pleaseenteranamelol711 ..........

[@mongoose6685]

​@pleaseenteranamelol711 The point of the quote is that the Left pretends to want to help the poor but actually don't do that as much as hating the rich (which is a futile endeavor). Those that actually help the poor are not waiting on the rich to fix poor people's problems.

[@rollrcoastrbacon2725]

The difference is loving the poor doesn’t get you mom-cooked nuggies in your 3 million dollar mansion 😂

[@ArsSanctum]

While I laughed at the savage 19th century esq roasting Marx's father gave him in those letters, you can also feel the sorrow in the words. His dad clearly loved him, but was pissed off and saddened by the man Marx was becoming.

[@aeldariambitions6334]

I can't imagine how TRAGIC it would be to look at a son becoming, in real time, a drunkard and a political activist for taking and taking. It must have ate him up something fierce.

[@ghoulbuster1]

Accidentally created a demon!

[@wojak-sensei6424]

Can't imagine the feeling of watching your son become a sociopathic dipshit. If I'd even have a son, I'd try to be as close to him as I can in this modern world, because there's a lot of ideologies out there designed to poison minds rather than open them.

[@DuhSinfulDemon]

It's one of the reasons why I am cautious of having kids. I could give them anything they would need and want so they can have a better life than I had, but they could turn into someone with a horrible mindset and ideology

[@bort6414]

@@DuhSinfulDemon You can absolutely raise your children right and ensure they have good values and character. It just requires you find a good woman who supports you and your authority, and you yourself to not emotionally abandon your children in favor of the work of industrial societies. Do not give, let them earn and teach them the value of sacrifice and suffering through their actions, and most of all, be a good example. It's no small task for sure, but seldom is there a more worthy cause.

[@KingSpectre844]

That last bit, wow. Dev giving the terminally online commies a Dadist dressing down was not something I expected. Yet, I welcome it. Great job.

[@live4hockey2]

Stop, stop! They're already dead!

[@jennteal5265]

A chef's kiss

[@jimmybeans1175]

Verbally and mentally hacking them to pieces.

[@kurosan0079]

Let's be honest, these commies needed and still need a lot of dadist dressing down.

[@nottodisushttoagen1309]

It was a surprise to be sure, but a welcome one.

[@thomashalliwell1484]

Those letters from Marx’s father really does prove that the more things change, the more they stay the same lol

[@wojak-sensei6424]

A man so focused on what he lacks that he manipulates and stews over everyone in his life to the point that he thinks nothing but himself and his status? Are we talking about Marx or Pat Batemen here?

[@dean_l33]

Nothing new since the romans created the republic

[@mikecampos1193]

This is why many socialists fail cuz they can never have a good relationship with their family if you still care about your family no matter even though we arguing fight you still got their back and they still got yours that's the sad things between these people they lost that.

[@PanagiotisPolitis-bl9xj]

history is one big circle

[@nmmeswey3584]

"Somebody has to be punished for that crime, and God's out of reach" is such a metal and edgy quote and I love it

[@Dragenthor]

Imma put that in a metal song

[@johndaniel7161]

It actually sounds like an awesome Bond villain line.

[@rusty_from_earth9577]

That’s something Senator Armstrong could have said in Metal Gear Revengence

[@rusty_from_earth9577]

@@Zlyxon That the rest of us shouldn't come to school tomorrow.

[@Usammityduzntafraidofanythin]

Clint Eastwood with an iron on his hip

[@JAKBOT3000]

That quote from Marx's father really hit me. It really is a dad wondering where things went wrong and desperately trying to make sense of his son's radicalization. Something that I'm sure many parents know all too well these days.

[@thisismyyoutubecommentacco6302]

It's a textbook example. of hard men creating good times, good times creating weak men, and weak men creating hard times. Parents are instinctively wired to want to provide a better life for their kids than they had. What they often don't realize is by coddling their children against life's harshness they are preventing them from developing the same skillsets and psychological body armor needed to be successful. Instead they become entitled brats, easily swayed to any attempt to feel "righteous" and "support a cause" that they will literally support anything if it "sounds good".

[@dkosmari]

Marx's father should have been stronger and disowned his son.

[@moonlitegram]

Its telling of how his father bemoans Marx's wastefulness and how much he's spending and yet he still grants his request for the 160 talers. If he was wondering where things went wrong, that would have been a good place to start.

[@DrCruel]

If you're in any way useful, it's because your father really hit you. kzbin.info/www/bejne/ipPOhqp7lLWiY9U

[@kateshiningdeer3334]

I don't remember what documentary I was watching now, but I watched one that talked about Marx and the writing of the Communist Manifesto, and his family, and wow, it was a mess. I actually see a lot of Vaush in Marx - perhaps unsurprisingly. (I'm not a Vaush fan - I've just seen him through other people who I watch.) He was clearly angry, basically incapable of running his own life, and entirely focused on his ideology, to the entire detriment of literally everyone around him. I searched my YT history hoping it was in there, but I didn't find it - It's possible it was on Netflix, Hulu, or Acorn, too. I don't THINK it was the DW "Who Was Karl Marx" one at YT, though, because the one I saw pretty much stayed in the past and didn't talk about how communism was applied in other countries - just about him, his family, and the writing of the book. (Which took his entire life, was still basically unfinished, and Engles put together after Marx's death.)

[@MrLolguy93]

The bitterness and nihilism of socialists is truly nauseating

[@televized1781]

There an answer to this and it's called having a reasonable relationship with religion. Some of the teaching about dealing with the suffering of life, Meaning of life though family/community/etc. All that stuff seems sourly lacking in the Godless world today that produces nothing but nihilism and following one's base needs for the here and now

[@JohnSmith-wx9wj]

@@televized1781 Yep. I found it strange that nietzsche thought just because he stopped believing in a supernatural God that he needed to throw away all of religion and spiritualism. It makes for sick humans. Look at China after the Cultural Revolution.

[@eliseosterbrink8000]

I appreciate your solution to this. Personally, I've never been religious, both of my parents grew up in religious families but renounced religion when they married and moved off together. But they didn't abandon the most important teachings of Christianity. For that, I am grateful. I'm also grateful that they didn't do the opposite and smother me with overbearing religious nonsense instead of teaching actual important lessons. Reasonableness is something that I fear is either lost or very far into the process of being lost.

[@SouthernGothicYT]

one of my favorite anime quotes is "to live is to fight" and boy is that relevant. Life is suffering, but you have the ability to combat it, and I personally think that's what our role as a human is - to be, and however you interpret that is also a key part in being human.

[@TheGreenKnight500]

The thing I hate the most about it is how much it runs off and taints everything in our culture. Even if you're fully aware of what they're doing and reject all of their ideas, it's still very difficult not to catch their contagious negativity.

[@Andyisgodcky]

People to socialists: "you're not special" Socialists: "and I took that personally"

[@DonVigaDeFierro]

"Excuse me, sir. Now that we are socialists, where is the welfare offi-". "SHUT UP AND DIG FASTER! NO QUOTA, NO RATIONS!"

[@theonpointheavy4401]

@@DonVigaDeFierro Sounds about right, the idiots seem to think they will be spared from hardship and become part of the elite (or remain part of the elite), when in reality the vast majority of them will either be lynched or end up as disposable slave labour.

[@user-pt8vr9eq8y]

On god you have to work for that status

[@dafuzzymonster]

Yeah man tell me about, I love paying through my ass for healthcare. Only joking I live in a country that isn't backwards and semi developed so I don't have to.

[@Andyisgodcky]

@@dafuzzymonster guess you took that personally, huh?

[@vindictivefeline5313]

Peterson is absolutely right about them, that’s why they’re so angry. They’re afraid he’s right.

[@sixwingedasura3059]

When you're drawing fire, you're over the target.

[@pavelowjohn9167]

@@sixwingedasura3059 Yep. Or the old "When you throw a rock into a pack of dogs, the one that yelps is the one you hit" quip. Peterson was a little too accurate for comfort with his insight into humanity and our propensity for evil....

[@johnbuscher]

@@pavelowjohn9167 I like that one too.

[@speedfastman]

@@pavelowjohn9167 "propensity for evil" lmao.

[@Tyler_W]

@@speedfastman what's funny about that? It's true.

[@dminard1]

Marx's dad eloquently laying his son's fault bare was a joy to read.

[@chadindolad3913]

I'm glad you put Karl Marx's father's letter in there. Never heard about it before but it truly justifies what Thomas Sowell has written in his book about him, manipulative, sociopathic, egotistical, nihilist. Although I still found some of those who still agree with him with genuine positive intentions, I would, unfortunately, say the general followers of his ideology seem to have fallen into the same mindset as he is. And besides, in most cases, it's the means that matter most than the end and the path to hell has always been paved by good intentions.

[@jimmybeans1175]

Any positive intentions that some of these people have are born of naivety. The rest is a front for their own selfishnesses.

[@theeccentrictripper3863]

@@jimmybeans1175 You shouldn't piss on that intent though because it's the only bit of sanity we can grab and pull back towards reality, once their goal morphs from "I want to help people" to "I have to destroy my enemies to help people" you lose the ability to have any discourse with said person in good faith.

[@jimmybeans1175]

@@theeccentrictripper3863 I’m not pissing on it, good intentions can be naive and lead to bad outcomes. I’m agreeing with you. It’s possible to change, but these types are repulsed by the hard work that requires so the task is daunting. Some do wise up as they grow older and actually experience life.

[@theeccentrictripper3863]

@@jimmybeans1175 You're on the money there but that's all the more reason to try, lest we find ourselves also afraid of hard work. Maybe I'm still a bit naïve but it feels wrong to give up on them, at least on my fellow countrymen, the system only works if we look out for each other, not out of force but from a place of genuine concern.

[@jimmybeans1175]

@@theeccentrictripper3863 I agree. These are our countrymen and women. America is worth saving and so are they. Yet being soft on them is what got us here. The path forward should be strong, firm in principle, yet kind and empathetic to each other when possible. Robust debate is needed, and the 1st Amendment must be defended at all costs. But let’s not pretend we aren’t dealing with some seriously deranged individuals mixed among the redeemable.

[@wolfscareglow2425]

these dudes are like the meme "god has given me another day and im going to make it everyones problem"

[@mrshmuga9]

I know someone like this… I’ve had to mute her for “30 days” a few times because her posts were just insufferable. Whining “Conservatives/Christians bad” because they’re not giving and wasting all their money on people like her (single mothers). On one hand, I feel bad for her because she does have a bunch of mental issues, and it affects her work. On the other hand, she also makes no effort to make any improvements. She only cares about getting high to cope, and nothing past that. You’d think after getting knocked up young, smoking weed all the time, gaining a ton of weight, and being in a relationship with a guy who would sexually assault another woman (I think while they were still dating), that you’d start making some changes, but nope. Just complain that people don’t give you free money, as if it wouldn’t be wasted given her attitude.

[@wolfscareglow2425]

@@mrshmuga9 holly shit I feel bad for you now

[@mrshmuga9]

@@wolfscareglow2425 She was a work colleague from nearly I decade ago I stayed Facebook friends with. We’ve only met in-person a few times since and never really talked through Facebook, so it’s not that bad. Just annoying when I see her re-share socialist garbage in my feed, lol. But it’s hilarious because another FB friend is the complete opposite, re-sharing TurningPointUSA posts and other anti-socialist stuff. It’s like two people are having a feud in my feed and neither are aware of it, haha.

[@guilhermehank4938]

"I'm still alive and the world has to pay for it"

[@bungoboy5718]

That little rant at the end really satisfied me. These people have no idea of how the real world works. Some of these Twitter ramblers don't just need to touch grass, they need to touch the entire meadow.

[@zxyatiywariii8]

If these bitter, nihilistic leftists were _under_ the meadow, they'd finally be doing something useful for the environment and the world.

[@p.s.shnabel3409]

But do we really want to give that poor meadow PTSD?

[@ScreamingStar6943]

Same! It honestly felt like a release of pent up anger for myself personified into words.

[@halodragonmaster]

They need to experience retail.

[@TOUGHEYES]

No, don't invite them into the meadows or the forests. They either litter their drug containers everywhere or start burning trees.

[@Doc-Holliday1851]

1:04 “revenge against God for the crime of being” I couldn’t have said it better myself.

[@TheGreenKnight500]

I've had thoughts exactly like that in the depths of depression. I can personally confirm Peterson's assertion. If it wasn't for my upbringing and core values, I would have been one of these tankies.

[@zxyatiywariii8]

That was my life for at least the first 12 years. Of course I didn't have the vocabulary to verbalize that concept, but it deeply resonates with how I felt during my childhood. But so many of these Vaush types are children of privilege, so that's always baffled me. . . 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@Supiragon1998]

@@TheGreenKnight500 I was one of them until I got convinced with logical arguments that communism can't work. The other difference for me is that that feeling hasn't stopped for me since despite that.

[@cnlbenmc]

Well nobody's stopping them from removing themselves from the equation.

[@TheGreenKnight500]

@@cnlbenmc You weren't paying attention. Offing yourself is not revenge. School shooters, for example, are suicidal but they intend to teach everyone a lesson in the process.

[@bleensteen9331]

Damn, Marx's father comes across as considerate, intelligent, well balanced, tolerant yet based, and productive. The shame of somehow producing such an outstandingly rotten son must've weighed heavy on him.

[@விஷ்ணு_கார்த்திக்]

His son singlehanded turned his surname "marx" into a dirty word for the 21st century humans.

[@warrioroflight6872]

Socialism claims to be the great progenitor of love and compassion. And most Socialists I've met were anything but that.

[@Torvar]

Internationally, "Destroying cultural monuments is a warcrime!" Locally, "Destroying cultural monuments is a moral good!

[@phantom8926]

True shit.

[@sirsmithsmitherson5847]

This.

[@SkoomaGodDovahkiin666]

>Destroying Monuments >Warcrimes Those types of- So was tearing down Hitler or Stalin's monuments a warcrime?

[@Torvar]

@@SkoomaGodDovahkiin666 Politician, about to do something bad, looks around at cultural monuments, "Destroying these is a warcrime!!"

[@MissRora]

Unless the "international" place is a European country, then they think it's good because "white supremacy" and "colonialism" and other buzzwords.

[@SupaFlyJedi]

I would love to make a reality show where you get a group of libertarians/conservatives on one island and the breadtube communists on another island. Goal is to survive and build a community on the island. Rules of the show are as follows: 1. You MUST adhere to the ideology you preach to the letter. Capitalism for the libertarians/conservatives and straight up redistribution of resources for the communists 2. No contact with the outside world (other than the camera crews). That's it, I would pay actual money to see this. I think about 100 people on each island would suffice.

[@rhinocore]

Great idea, but how do you pitch a show where everyone already knows how it will end?

[@bUwUmer1260]

@@rhinocore the people your pitching it to are delusional and will be surprised at the outcome.

[@mrosskne]

this has already been done with men vs women, which is close enough since women are inherently socialist. the results were exactly what you think they were.

[@randomduck8679]

@@rhinocore if everyone knows how it ends, would there be so many socialists?

[@AttacMage]

@Prey R I wouldn't say charity would be disallowed. It's a communal act but not socialist.

[@ProfDragonite]

I've been saying this for the longest time. These people hate themselves so much, they'd rather bring us all down to their level than raise themselves to our level. Thank you for explaining it better than I ever could.

[@matthewgiroux9590]

Amen! For me it was the same thing but with the alt-right. Every since they started to kiss the ass of absolute lunatics, I have complete cut contact from them. They are no different from the lunatics on the far left.

[@lunamaria8788]

Demoralization. Like that one guy said.

[@SergioLeonardoCornejo]

They detest all things. Particularly the healthy ones which they think were lacking in their lives.

[@rafaelmusacchio5257]

@@SergioLeonardoCornejo a stable family, love and wealth

[@SergioLeonardoCornejo]

@@rafaelmusacchio5257 worst part is they think they lack them. Some do have them.

[@YoshiTheOreo]

"It's not boiling alive if you pour the water on them. Idiot." *internal screaming*

[@TheLurker1647]

I've met communists before and asked them about the Romanovs. "The Czar?" "Oh yes he deserved it, very bad man." "His wife?" "Oh yes, she was horrible." "And the children?" "...Well, it was necessary..." It's an ideology built upon killing princesses. These people are like stock villains you'd hear about in a fairytale.

[@jackalenterprisesofohio]

Like the whole "Kill the horses to defeat the infantry."

[@tylercoon1791]

“Not just the Czar, but his wife and children too!”

[@guilhermehank4938]

The innocents killed by them are simply "casualties of war"

[@Astolfo2001]

They would really hate Don Bluth's Anastasia then....

[@acctsys]

Hmm.. Maybe not built around killing princesses, but being so misled as to accept killing innocents as justified, in the name of the cause. Anything founded on fanaticism and authoritarian rule eventually comes out to be evil.

[@Arassar]

"Socialism is the philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy.” - Winston Churchill Churchill was 100 times smarter than all Breadtubers put together.

[@MrLolguy93]

"But he sais something that is considered racist today, so it's all invalidated" - some dumbass progg

[@毛歌凡]

I have a small question, what is breadtuber?? a bread doing KZbin ??

[@dexter2392]

@@毛歌凡 breadtubers are an unofficial term for left-wing political youtube channels that support socialism. hasan, vaush, destiny, the serfs, etc.

[@greatestcait]

@@毛歌凡 Socialists/communists. It's a reference to the breadlines in the Soviet Union if I'm not mistaken.

[@thegamingsentinel9238]

Churchill will always be based

[@Scornfull]

Damn the ending went for their throats, but you are 100% right

[@thegodofalldragons]

I love for me that it cut off in the middle of the last word, giving the impression that he just kept going after the mic stopped recording.

[@yoloswag1137]

why should i comment myself, when i can find someone who does it better for me and reply to them instead

[@Bobby_Corwen]

He was paraphrasing something Destiny said I can't find where and when he said it, but he said something along those lines.

[@wojak-sensei6424]

Daddy Dev went so sicko mode that the video had to cut off early.

[@weirdowithacello3481]

If I'm not mistaken, he's quoting Destiny, or at least saying something very similar.

[@thetzarofthemountain8222]

I don't think it's too dramatic. I was at a house party and briefly spoke to a communist, it didn't take him very long to take off the mask as soon as he thought I was on his side it was really eye opening (and I come from a country with a deep and bloody history between the two sides). Let's just say if I was his boss I wouldn't want to be tied up and left in a room with him and some blunt objects. And he would need to be tied up because this guy wasn't imposing but would hit you with a hammer when you back was turned, judging from how quickly he went from better working conditions to torture

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

Because they are driven solely by emotion. They don’t believe in order or structure, just winning.

[@guilhermehank4938]

The number of sociopaths in our society is extremely concerning

[@DavidWalker1987]

When that Huxley quote came on screen, i was reminded of one of my favourite quotes by C.S.Lewis: “Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth."

[@jackalenterprisesofohio]

Yeah, but if *I* was an omnipotent ruler.... I would only settle for Ohio and the U.S. Virgin Island.....and a theampark in Europe...................mostly for pranks.............and the ability to do anything

[@Devin_Stromgren]

Allow me to finish the quote. "This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be "cured" against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals.”

[@Touma134]

That was thrown around in the anti-sjw days. Now that's thrown away because now the right is the opposition and is wanting in on those moral treats.

[@QueenAleenaFan]

"I hate that I have to work to eat." I must throw back an argument tossed at me when I said I didn't consent to paying taxes by virtue of being born: go live on some uncared for land and grow your own crops. You will work, still, but it will be all yours.

[@feliperisseto9113]

I think Peterson is absolutelly right in his statements, no exageration.

[@jakeelkins5662]

I don’t agree with him when he says that animals only kill to eat. There absolutely are animals that kill for sport

[@flamingodahlia3703]

@@jakeelkins5662 Ironically science points to us likely being close in relation to those particular animals, so if those animals are closer to us than other animals then it still points to Peterson being right. As I'm guessing you mean apes and porpoises

[@corenlavolpe6143]

@@jakeelkins5662 like cats, those little sociopaths

[@jakeelkins5662]

@@flamingodahlia3703 then maybe it’s wrong to imply we aren’t animals

[@ernestotorelli1209]

@@corenlavolpe6143 To be fair their instinct to kill for sport is to keep their skills sharp and ready.

[@twiggledy5547]

These people mock JP but have you seen their reaction when you point out their poor relationships with their fathers?

[@Supiragon1998]

@Prey R I'd still consider myself agnostic, even though I want to believe, but I'm absolutely convinced at this point that evil absolutely does exist, and it's called leftism/progressivism/socialism/communism.

[@Supiragon1998]

@Prey R Well, I think it's that we're just starting to get into the hard times, but we still have it relatively good. I assume I would start to believe if our society would really collapse because of these chucklefucks.

[@Supiragon1998]

@Prey R As I saw it, both the left and the Cathedral have been escalating in their plans while people in the US still have their guns. Also, I have a hard time imagining financial collapse to be gradual enough for that for example.

[@olivesama]

That's about as low as suggesting that conservatives are generally hicks who must be having sexual relations with their cousins. If the ideas of your opponents are flimsy enough, you should focus on that.

[@DrachonaTheWolf]

I've interacted with a lot of socialists/communists, anarchists, etc., and I was always surprised at how bitter, hostile, and unreasonable they were. Then, one day, a good metaphor hit me. To them, reality is hell; an actual tormenting nightmare. It's everything they don't want. The only escape is utopia; some perfect vision of the future where we somehow have rules without rulers and no conflict. If you disagree, even slightly, then you're a demon. You are a resident of hell, holding them back. You're not a person, worthy of empathy. You're just an obstacle. So is nature, science, biology, etc.

[@WhiskeyPatriot]

Even the Robert Reichs of the world still know we have to make our own in this “hell”. Too bad I fear a lot of Union Democrats are tilting towards the groups you mentioned

[@DonVigaDeFierro]

Yeah. What's more, that mindset is for pieces of shit, because they see the world as a corrupt place full of assholes, and that view gives them permission to be as much of an asshole as they want to be. Adlerian psychology proposes the opposite of Freudian psychology: People want to be assholes, and they will find an excuse. If the privileged, sheltered, western "anarchists" didn't choose that excuse to be assholes, they would have chosen any other excuse. Freudian psychology is flawed in one simple, but key aspect: Not all victims of trauma end up being assholes. Assholes simply appear, and will use any trauma as a personal excuse to become pieces of shit. The biggest """trauma"" of the "anarchist socialist antifascist" morons? Living in a world where they are NOT in power.

[@rahn45]

It's what happens to children who get everything they want their whole lives, eventually that stops happening and then they start behaving like a child who doesn't get what they want. Thing is a child who lashes out and is violent can be stopped by their older and more powerful parents and told that's now how to behavior or get what they want, an adult that does the same thing is incredibly dangerous.

[@DrachonaTheWolf]

@@WhiskeyPatriot I just find it funny that people communicating online lack any sense of relativism. You grab something to eat or drink from a refrigerator, sit down in your air-conditioned or heated home, and use your own personal device to complain about how hellish your world is. It's profoundly out of touch with reality.

[@DrachonaTheWolf]

@@rahn45 Yeah, likely because their parents were absolutely terrible. They lack any sense of relativism. It doesn't matter that they're probably sitting in an air-conditioned or heated space using their personal electronic device to complain online while sipping a latte. They were never taught to appreciate life, and they're so spoiled than anything less than perfection feels like oppression.

[@timerift0]

You should not apologize for that letter from Marx's father it was sooo good. It puts so much in perspective and makes me think everyone who says to read the Communist manifesto should be forced to read his father's letters to him. Keep up the good work.

[@walkingcontradiction223]

"It's revenge against God for the crime of being." Pretty sure it draws so much flack because it's a correct analysis.

[@robertortiz-wilson1588]

Honestly, yeah.

[@emalinedickinson7492]

Dude, this in tandem with that survey where they asked people how much of the US they think is homosexual makes me feel good about the counter action from the logical thinkers. People said like 30%, where it's really like 1.7%. Confirmation bias, echo chambers, circle jerking.

[@arczero1623]

That and complete disassociation from reality over the perceived rate of police violence. A dozen unarmed black men dead at the hands of the police, a tragedy, but not an epidemic by any means. All of this is the result of the media manufacturing consent 24/7. Totally vindicates Daniel Kahneman's Thinking Fast and Slow as well. That people are awful statistical thinkers.

[@grantwithers]

I saw that thing as well, but I'm not sure about those nums, esp among youngsters, I keep seeing things saying it's barely over half of youngsters IDing as straight now. Presumably most of the rest are saying they're a bit bi/gay/les.

[@ablindman3328]

@@grantwithers due to groomers

[@yumyumwhatzohai]

@@grantwithers there's a difference between people who are actually homosexual, and people with actual gender dysphoria, vs the trendy everyone is androgynous non binary blah blah blah crap

[@grantwithers]

@@yumyumwhatzohai and ablindman, both of you guys I understand what you're saying, but overall I cannot be convinced that it is 98+ percent of people that are 100% straight (superstraight if you prefer). It likely is like 95%+ people are overwhelmingly straight, that's likely correct but that leaves a huge area for bi people etc.

[@Wampert]

As a religious person the first error its speaking in religious terms, to people that are not religious, its easier to talk in universals, but ironically the religious points are where a lot of universals are.

[@warrioroflight6872]

Exactly. A lot of people are just ignorant of history on so many levels that it's not even funny.

[@littleking1994two]

That's not irony, if a point is universal it will appear in most religions since it is universal

[@absolutelyyousless7605]

You managed to spell “religious” incorrectly four different ways in the same sentence... Your point isn’t wrong, I just found that funny.

[@Wampert]

@@absolutelyyousless7605 yes, im native spanish speaking. Religus its how i thought it was written, so its "religious" gotcha thanks for the correction!

[@toledochristianmatthew9919]

A lot of our concepts of modern science even came from Christianity, Islam, and many religions around the world. All trying to find the fundamental truth in order to find God or enlightenment.

[@ThechronocrosserII]

I used to get mad at people on Twitter because I was like "NO, that's NOT how the real world works". In my own dumbassery, I discovered I should look at Twitter through a glass window, as 'insane' people. I realized that majority of my friends and co-workers don't ether have a Twitter account or barely uses theirs. It's full of people (narcissists) that believe they know everything, it's fucking incredible and I often wonder if these people come from a state of privilege. America is not perfect 95% of us know that, but you goddamn right I rather live here than some 3rd world country where my rights are striped because of my gender or race AND not have the access to advancing technologies. There are many things I could complain about as well but TLDR: I love the rant at the end; It pretty much sums up my frustration with the platform. I would delete my account, but there is a lot of funny shit i come across on Twitter lmao.

[@zjanez2868]

i dont know where i heard it, but i remember something funny along the lines of: I use social media not as a chat room, but rather as a zoo to see what amazing specimens nature can create

[@frenchfrey65]

I'd delete my twitter too, if it weren't for the fact I follow a few sports youtubers there cuz 99% of the time they avoid politics and talk about sports and tell funny sports jokes. They're genuinely pleasant to be around and follow, which is more than I could say for the rest of Twitter... sheesh...w

[@Jesei1211]

I have such great friends none of them use twitter or even know what it is. Such a blessing to have them.

[@scino55]

Twitter is not the voice of the people, and anyone who so treats it is making a huge mistake. About ninety percent of the posts on Twitter come from less than ten percent of the actual _people_ on Twitter.

[@leekah9981]

Can you give me some Advice When i Enter Twitter? My Parents Allowed me to go to Twitter at my 19th Birthday party, And i am confuse in that Platform Insanity.

[@amergingiles]

Regarding his Cain and Abel allegory, I do not think it's dramatic at all. We had an entire summer of Cains and Abels. Black Men preaching Black Power burning down Black Businesses for the crime of having made it.

[@Supiragon1998]

Uberbased

[@rexnas8150]

Right after you put this out he posted a clip from a QnA of one of his shows. And he actually brings up that quote and explains a little bit more on what he meant. Sadly most people when hearing JBP for the first time or who don't really watch his stuff can be very turned off by a lot of his biblical symbolic language. But with this quote I absolutely agree. Most people I've met, either being very normie or very far left leaning or simply feminist, all seem to think that humanity is a cancer and we should stop having kids and die off. Idk about you but that sounds a lot like wanting to take revenge against God for simply living.

[@mrosskne]

I don't get why he needed to do a qna, it was quite straightforward

[@ArticulatedHypernova]

Curious, what would "wanting to take revenge against God and creation" sound/look like if "humanity is a cancer and should die off" isn't that? Lol

[@rexnas8150]

@@mrosskne a QnA from one of his shows while on tour. It should be the latest vid. But the topic on whether or not things are doing better. And he was basically saying it depends on what you want to do, and it seems a lit of people simply want to destroy everything because they hate everything.

[@rexnas8150]

@@ArticulatedHypernova "Everyone is bad except me guys. I'm smarter than God" 😎 Big Brain Socialist

[@BladeTrain3r]

I've gone from optimistic to rather cynical about human nature over the last decade or two. Time and again the same mistakes are made in ever more sophisticated ways, and both our memory and capacity to learn from them doesn't seem to improve. And now we're hitting the point of actually being an extinction level threat to ourselves, in various ways overt and insidious. One can hope for a better outcome but I can no longer expect it these days. At this point I say let the dice roll, manifest destiny is bunk and if we do end up a failed, extinct species it's because we did it to ourselves.

[@ASpooneyBard]

A while back I had a coworker who would constantly talk about how oppressed and poor we all were (but mostly him). Sure we were probably being being paid below industry standard at the time, but he apparently lived in a stable home (I didn't ask him where he actually lived) and bought lunch out each day. His major hobbies (other than ranting about the "evils" of capitalism) were video games (specifically fighting games) and collecting vinyl records from the 80's. He talked about his record collection a lot, which was so big that he had to keep most of it in a self-storage unit (which he would need to pay for every month). IF YOU CAN AFFORD TO BUY VIDEO GAMES AND VINYL RECORDS, YOU ARE NOT POOR! I DON'T CARE WHAT YOUR HOURLY PAY IS! It never sounded like righteous indignation to me. It just sound like he looked at his modest apartment (again, I'm giving the benefit of the doubt and assuming that he doesn't live in an actual freaking house) and then looked at a 2 million dollar mansion and said "hey, that's not fair" and never got over that. I still lived with my parents so he actually had more privilege than I did at that point. Eventually he just quit that job, because he was tired of our boss "taking advantage of him." I have no idea if ever found employment again, but he probably did, and he's probably still pissed about it.

[@zxyatiywariii8]

Well said!

[@jackiechun4741]

That's not a very convincing argument. The difference between pay of the average worker and CEO has skyrocketed since the 70s. Economic opportunities for zoomers are quite low compared to what the Boomers had. Is there any level of wealth gap that would exist to cause you to say it was not a fair deal?

[@Xplora213]

@@jackiechun4741 economic opportunities might be different but boomers can’t write an app, or become a social media sensation, or start a business (they are all in their 60s and 70s). There are opportunities, you just have to go find them. The property value and surge since WW2? Boomers had to fight hard to get their piece of that pie. We are blessed with their wealth (they will die within a few years and leave it to you). You are not thinking positively about your opposition, your failure to steelman their position hurts your argument… because they didn’t have social programs and the internet to keep them safe and happy like you do.

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

If he were really poor, he would have sold those records. He’s complaining, just to complain.

[@DedAlexFive]

@Order and Madness Maybe the guy is really proud of his fart chalice collection

[@artix548]

In olden days, we simply called what drove Karl Marx "Envy".

[@thisismyyoutubecommentacco6302]

Actually it's interesting you said "I guess socialism requires an outside capitalist society trading with them if it's gonna work?" Yes, yes it does. China's the best and latest example. If China didn't have somewhere to sell the output from their production lines they would have easily collapsed under the weight of just trying to feed their populations long ago. China survives because it has Capitalist trading partners, plain and simple. What destroyed the USSR was they preferred to only trade with their satellite states in the Eastern Bloc, all of which were communist as well. This lead to economic stagnation within the USSR and Eastern Europe that culminated in not only Eastern Europe eventually becoming Capitalist again but also in the downfall of Communism in the USSR.

[@engelsteinberg593]

The last thing is wrong. The Communist part was eager to trade will the west as much as possible, and get basically infinite money from the West trought their subversion spies.

[@theabsolutechadlad5457]

All I can think about when watching this is the Tombstone quote about Johnny Ringo and why he does such heinous acts. "A man like Ringo has got a great big hole, right in the middle of him. He can never kill enough, or steal enough, or inflict enough pain to ever fill it." "What does he need?" "Revenge." "For what?" "Being born."

[@robertbeisert3315]

In a twisted sort of way, such a mindset would make abortion a mercy. If existing is pain, then the greatest mercy would be to prevent existence. How dark a road that is.

[@andrewlivingston1590]

I thought it was just me!

[@ChrisR395]

Thought of that too

[@connorohare229]

I think to a degree that some of the religions were correct in regarding the existence of evil as a universal hazard of being human, the greatest danger our post modern industrialized society has taught us is that the idea of evil is just as fictional as believing in literal angels and ghosts. I admit that to a strange meta level, I'm not an atheist anymore, perhaps a reluctant agnostic at best. But what I've grown certain of is that there is such a thing as unironic evil that cannot be cured with reason alone. 15:12 and dear God, Carl Marx was the Chris Chan of his time

[@Nukestarmaster]

Eh, Chris Chan was a low functioning autist with a difficult home life, Marx didn't have that excuse.

[@theeccentrictripper3863]

Cmon now, there's at least a degree of separation between birthing communism and raping your mom, be nice to the angry man with the beard. I kind of get where you're at with the agnosticism, although I'd still call myself an atheist as I have no material evidence still of a god; having said that my interactions with pre-Christian Greek and Roman philosophy have kind of upended the board when it comes to things like good and evil or virtue and vice and their conceptions of both true polytheism and emanative polytheism don't have to be taken literally to absorb the wisdom they offer. Even the philosophers themselves are a bit tongue-in-cheek and less neurotic than modern philosophers or priests. I'd definitely recommend reading anything from Antiquity and start building up your own moral/epistemological scaffolding rather than relying on modern perspectives alone.

[@lasuperchavasentai1907]

Oh but you don't understand! Marx was "The greatest philosopher of all time"!

[@artski09]

this is why the idea of the seven deadly sins and 7 heavenly virtues is a good idea to live by you can't rule lawyer your way around them, they apply universally and best of all they are simple 14 words

[@LeavingGoose046]

Anyone who believes the world has no evils has yet to live long enough to see the evils of the world

[@sleepparalysisatthewheel5101]

Seems there's a reason envy is considered a sin. Also I never knew about Marx's father, I feel bad for him. Sounds very familiar to the situation a lot socialist-types have with their loved ones. Nothing new under the sun after all.

[@16m49x3]

Envy is a sin, jelousy is not. I'm starting to think the conflation of the two is intentional. Cause these progressives frame jelousy as evil, while envy is embraced

[@cripplelord6383]

@@16m49x3 I'm not sure I understand the distinction. Aren't both a feeling of selfish desire for the positive aspects of another's life?

[@bladesandswords6136]

The way I see jealousy vs envy: For example, let’s say you have a gf you are quite fond with. You two have a fantastic relationship. One day, you two meet a handsome individual (let’s name them, Mr. Good) and become good friends with him. While you know your gf is faithful and wouldn’t cheat, Mr. Good and your gf are spending a lot of time together. This begins to bother you and you tell your gf she shouldn’t see him any more. Now let’s say for the second example you don’t have a gf but you meet Mr. Good, his wife and children. You notice that Mr. Good has a well paying career and is able to have extra money to give to his friends and family. His wife is good looking, is able to take great care of their children and she will always seek out to cater to his every needs (not out of obligation, but because their love is genuine and that they want see each other happy and to give each other what best for them). His children, while young and still learning, have complete trust in their parent and what ever Mr. Good and his wife says, they listen and do what is told without rebellion. Overall, Mr. Good has a good life. However, you want that life. You want it to a point that you will kill for it. One day you travel alone with Mr. Good and you kill him. You get away with murder and then you marry Mr. Good’s Wife and adopt his children. Example 1 is jealous as you don’t want to lose your love one to someone else Example 2 is Envy as you love the lifestyle of Mr. Good so much, you want to take it and keep it for yourself, even if it means hurting someone for it. TLDR: Jealously is the fear that something or someone will be taken from you. Envy is coveting what someone else has

[@yarlodek5842]

@LeoTheBritish-Eurasian Well, if you call yourself a socialist then we can assume you act like one. This is the problem with strict ideological thinking, you put yourself in a box and your political opponents can use it as a weapon against you. Take my advice: Become an issue-based thinker rather than an ideology based one. And quit marxism (assuming you follow it) it’s mostly bullshit.

[@rahn45]

Envy as a sin confuses me. If you envy a person then you wish to be more like them: To have their strengths and virtues. The envy will pass once you do obtain those strengths, virtues. Perhaps the trap is to envy another's possessions? Though that's just the foundation of capitalism really: To see someone else having stuff you want and deciding that you want to get that stuff as well. Perhaps the sin is the reaction to Envy/Jealousy? To destroy the other person and steal their things as opposed to building yourself up and to earn things.

[@blackheart4182]

The idea that you didn't consent to life may have been true as a child but it rings very hollow from adults. Every day you stay alive is of your own volition. There's always a choice.

[@teemumiettinen7250]

Well yes but no, if you say you want to kill yourself, you will get locked up in mental hospital and dying becomes very difficult. So better not tell anyone you dont want to be alive.

[@kaletovhangar]

They are too self centered and a cowards to delete themselves.Also, I do not think that they actually want to die, but pike author said, they want some perfect world (on their opinions and views) so they feel more like "Fine, I'm too weak, proud, stupid and cynical to make my life better. So I'll actually make life a living hell for everyone else". In short "I'm not trapped with you, you are trapped with me".

[@LeoVital]

It's a sad reality we live in that someone like Vaush, with so much hatred in his heart and who apparently does his best to create division in the world, has so much more visibility than Dev, someone with a far fairer and more nuanced view on the problems in the modern world. Here's hoping that your channel grows ever more! I'm loving the frequent uploads!

[@allenharper2928]

Freaking CAN'T STAND Vaush. I look at his beard sometimes and try to decide which strand of hair I hate the most. He's like the urr example of an insufferable college dipshit that latches on to every word his insufferable dipshit professors as gospel.

[@MillywiggZ]

Has anyone turned Jordan Peterson into a kawaii anime character yet? If so we can get Dev a boddy-pillow.

[@Liquid_Mike]

Without knowing, I'd bet my life somebody has by now

[@rexnas8150]

Lol Rule 42 If it's out there, there's a body pillow

[@RoutaAskel]

Bit dramatic? Perhaps. Is it wrong? Absolutely not

[@philagelio336]

Brilliant video. I’ve never been a socialist or materialist of any kind, brought up in a lapsed Catholic family, but that letter by Marx’s dad made me take stock of my life. Even though my job isn’t as fulfilling as I would want it to be, there’s still a lot I have to be grateful for. Materialists, like Marx, don’t want to live but to get away with living. This critique of Socialism is very reminiscent of Ayn Rand, and that’s why I gravitate more toward her philosophy than most others. “Destruction is the only end that the mystics' creed has ever achieved, as it is the only end that you see them achieving today, and if the ravages wrought by their acts have not made them question their doctrines, if they profess to be moved by love, yet are not deterred by piles of human corpses, it is because the truth about their souls is worse than the obscene excuse you have allowed them, the excuse that the end justifies the means and that the horrors they practice are means to nobler ends. The truth is that those horrors are their ends”

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

It’s not a bad thing to criticize capitalism. It’s what national socialists were.

[@engelsteinberg593]

@@malbasedvalentine3210 Capitalism is basically perfect, so.

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

@@engelsteinberg593 it’s not. Even hardcore capitalists say it isn’t. It’s merely a better choice, but unfortunately corruption, abuse, and manipulation still exist within Capitalism.

[@engelsteinberg593]

@@malbasedvalentine3210 As long there is a Justice System.

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

@@engelsteinberg593 that’s corrupt under capitalist system, because the more recognizable and wealthy you are, the more likely you’re getting off easily or sent to a private prison. Capitalism created people like Epstein.

[@totallynoteverything1.]

I love how the moment Christianity is mentioned, everyone invalidates it

[@Very_Silly_Individual]

Hmm, I wonder if the Bible says anything about that

[@S.D.323]

@@Very_Silly_Individual who cares what a book that condones genocide has to say

[@livenotbylies]

Yeah, I noticed the denials of God are like a tick. Atheism makes so little sense that it requires constant little workarounds to prop up while speaking of meaningful things. Otherwise a good video though

[@chibu3212]

Materialism and antitheism or irreligion goes hand in hand with Marxism

[@DDRWakaLaka]

ew not these two christcucks being absolutely delusional

[@throwaway7969]

"As soon as men decide that all means are permitted to fight an evil, then their good becomes indistinguishable from the evil that they set out to destroy." - Christopher Dawson

[@low_vibration]

*cough* islam *cough*

[@whitemagus2000]

Jordan Peterson does make mistakes when he isn't talking about psychology, in the same way a chemist makes mistakes when not talking about chemistry, or when a nuclear engineer isn't talking about nuclear power, or when an anime buff isn't talking about anime. I have come to believe Peterson about modern nihilism. I was talking to a moderate Democrat coworker, saying that if the green new deal were rolled out and fossil fuels couldn't be used to grow or transport food, 50% or more of the population would probably die. They didn't refute my guess, but agreed with me and said that might be what the world needs. My conclusion is that the AVERAGE Democrat is a cynical nihilist.

[@CoruptedJester]

Just another example. My mother, an average TV watching Democrat told me she would prefer babies die in the womb then grow up with bad parents. Like… my god, just kill everything because life is a little rough? Absolutely horrid.

[@Zayindjejfj]

@@CoruptedJester You know that's a good point. This mindset only believes one thing: that death is preferable to suffering. But JP has been teaching that suffering isn't something that you should go to great lengths to avoid. "Life is suffering, so take responsibility and carry something." Take that suffering and make it mean something, so that you can look at yourself and not be ashamed. That maybe, just maybe... life is worth living.

[@DedAlexFive]

@Abdul Alhaz Everyone loves the idea of half the population dying until its their turn. At least that what I thought some years ago. As you have seen, your average Dem dreg of society would rather see everyone on the face of the Earth dead that having to work in a warehouse. They're pathetic, and I love to see them cry on social media about it.

[@fuckgoogle2554]

Woah, Marx Senior sure sounds interesting.

[@jerm5466]

Learning about the letters from Marx’s father to Marx is really quite eye opening.

[@crispyandspicy6813]

Marx: Cinge Dad of Marx: Based.

[@renon1946]

It's a dramatic description, maybe, but...it's fairly accurate. We haven't reached mass violence yet, but we're damn close.

[@viscountrainbows6452]

Even prestigious award shows are battle arenas in this day and age. Peace sells. But who's buying?

[@darkstarjohnson9573]

Blm riots was just a taste

[@Mechazoid5116]

Yes we have people just dont pay attention

[@Gitbrenna]

We are always two steps from apocalyse. Always have been and always will be.

[@keithfilibeck2390]

the only thing stopping them is their weakness, they are a weak, emaciated, and most importantly, Daddy Money's Rich, without Daddy's Money, which they'd have to give up to start a proto-revolution, and all the comforts that come with it, they'd be far more violent than they are.

[@wheeeeeha]

"I wouldn't know, I've only ever killed Communists."- Rafal Ganowicz

[@DonVigaDeFierro]

"Do you smoke? "Yeah". "Tobacco? Pot?" "Communists".

[@user-co7fo]

based chad

[@Supiragon1998]

Based. Kill them before they kill you. They WILL kill you once they have enough power and think you're a threat to their utopia if you let them.

[@ghoulbuster1]

My favorite pass time.

[@totallytubular4096]

Dev just admit you think Peterson his hot for his age. That why you keep making videos on him.

[@B1RDSEYE]

This reminds me of something I came up with on my own awhile ago, although I’m sure I’m not the first to have a similar thought. These people aren’t good people. As Jordan Peterson put it, “they do not love the poor, they hate the rich.” They aren’t trying to be good people, they are looking around for the “bad” people, the people that it’s ok to hate, harass and assault, and they’re doing that, then turning around and extolling their own “virtues.” “Look at me, I’m a good person! I hated all the right people! I rejected my own whiteness! Look at me!”

[@Supiragon1998]

They're straight up evil: kzbin.info/www/bejne/inW4ZaehiNqWotE

[@A.Froster]

That rant at the end 🤣. My favourite take on socialist and leftists is the example of my father's small town. Almost everyone there votes left , they're the so called "subscribers" by my father because no matter what, you need to vote left. The problem ? Everyone there hates the so called "refugees" ( they aren't so btw ) which are sent by the government as a quote for every region and approved by the governors. So when i told them that voting for a lefty government that has no problem going with open borders is exactly the problem their brain shut down and they went full NPC mode because "we don't vote for the right here , we are anti fascists". I was 15 when i discovered this , to this day i still mock them when i visit my father

[@engelsteinberg593]

Remenber they that Facism is a leftwing ideology.

[@Snakedude4life]

“My body, my right.” Now: “You are hiding ze unvaccinated under de floorboards, aren’t you?” 🎩 🐍no step on Snek! 🇺🇸🇭🇰

[@flamestoyershadowkill6400]

In german: Sie verstecken die Ungeimpften unter Ihren Dielen

[@adherentofladycolumbia725]

I needed a Dev video today. One of the few people that hasn't devolved into an everyday low level podcast, or an annoying ass 3 plus hour daily streamer.

[@arczero1623]

He certainly keeps the ol' 2014 scripted video than alive. H3H3 wasting all his time on that trash podcast, his own room temperature political takes and stopping any of his funny content was an immensely disappointing process. I miss Carl's old video style, but Lotus Eaters is one of the only podcasts that make it worthwhile for me to listen to every episode.

[@MissRora]

@@arczero1623 It helps that Carl found a great bunch of lads to cohost.

[@arczero1623]

@@MissRora Yeah Callum holds down the fort when Carl's not there and John is the best on the team imo. Great voice, level headed, insightful and doesn't reject memes as hard as Carl and Callum do anime lol.

[@ProxyDoug]

@@MissRora I can't help but feel like Harry looks like Guy Pearce in Memento.

[@kateshiningdeer3334]

@@arczero1623 I'd be hard-pressed to pick a 3rd favorite (after Carl and Callum, of course) but I think mine might be Harry. Good sense of humor, and he works well with pretty much anyone, much like Callum does. And I have to say, bless Callum for the Meme Breaks - the news is so dark lately that those are really helping me keep my sense of humor! I will never lose my love of the absurd! I also love that they're really shuffling people around so you can see who makes good teams - I don't know if that's entirely intentional, but it's making for some really enjoyable podcasts. Some of the folks definitely seem to work together better than others - some balance each other, some help boost each other to be better together than they would be with others, etc. I'm quite pleased with the team of John and Thomas - John helps "brighten" Thomas a bit, and their tendency to both be a little quieter even though they're miked makes it easier for me to just turn up the volume when it's the two of them, vs when either of them are on with someone else, when they're just sometimes a bit too quiet. I am a little worried about Thomas, though - he always seems borderline depressed, poor guy! As someone with depression, I feel that! Leo's a kick - at first I kind of blew him off as just being a comedian, but when he gets serious, he's really knowledgable, too - you just have to get him to be serious, LOL! I really enjoy when Josh is on - I wish he'd do it a bit more often. But I'm guessing that all that research he's doing takes time, so he doesn't get to spend as much time on the air. But I really like his style and how good he is at it. Overall, I'm really impressed with the whole team. And I can't wait to see where it goes in the future!

[@tiobridge841]

I’m not even a socialist and I think I needed to hear that last bit. I’m going to turn off the internet for a day and see what difference that makes to my life

[@Icedragon481]

I wish you well, friend

[@sergeant_chris6209]

Try a week and i bet the difference will be very noticable

[@theeccentrictripper3863]

Tweets are temporary but the glory of Rome is forever. Reading history instead of being terminally obsessed with culture war stuff gave me the grounding necessary to properly appreciate what's going on and how we got here, it also keeps me from being swept along by the currents of time like your average ideologue of any flavor.

[@weridplusho]

Good luck. I've done it and the withdrawal is real.

[@tiobridge841]

I’m back because I habitually check my phone before I go to bed. Unironically the most relaxing day I’ve had in a good while

[@queen_alexandra996]

I'm not even a socialist and I felt called out by that ending speech, lol. Great video, as always

[@Supiragon1998]

I especially did, because I'm only no longer one on logical grounds, deep down, as a disappointed idealist/cynic, I still hate that it doesn't work.

[@crispyandspicy6813]

Cynicism is more or less universal so it's unsurprising.

[@TheLurker1647]

Peterson's statement is absolutely on point, I've been saying the same thing for years. I used to think that communism was the greatest foe we've ever faced, but really it's merely a façade for a far older, far more malevolent enemy.

[@amadeusdebussy6736]

"Winning" cannot be a principle. A principle has to apply universally to everyone in a given situation. So, if you believe in "fair trials" as a principle then you support anyone, no matter what they're accused of and no matter the amount of evidence against them, even if you personally witnessed them committing the crime, receiving a fair trial. That is what a principle is.

[@16m49x3]

You could say everyones right to pursue victory as a principle

[@jimmybeans1175]

Shallowness manifest.

[@xenn4985]

@@16m49x3 the pursuit of happiness?

[@Jay_Hendrix]

Like Kant says. In order for a principle to be rational you have to accept it's application to all people under all circumstances.

[@SergioLeonardoCornejo]

Success matters. But success without principles often becomes failure. Imagine having no loyalty or no goals other than success. Do you call that success?

[@Vertigou]

Overly dramatic but somewhat true. Vicious humans are more dangerous than wild animals.

[@bulletsizednuke1100]

Humans kill more of their own than any other species. Man is definitely worse than animals.

[@BruhMoment-fr4zr]

Human capacity for cruelty vastly outstrips our animal frens too, a lion may play with its prey but it won't extend this "torture" to months at a time or occupy itself with finding new and innovative ways to maximize its suffering.

[@theeccentrictripper3863]

@@BruhMoment-fr4zr Only because it can't; I don't think we're exceptionally cruel by nature, we're just smarter and as a result our capacity for awareness and enjoyment of cruelty is expanded like everything else.

[@malbasedvalentine3210]

@@theeccentrictripper3863 that’s pretty much the answer I was going to say as well. But it’s funny, because aquatic mammals like dolphins, actually are known to rape for fun, and are actually conscious of doing it. As well as kill for fun. So, I guess the more intelligent you are as a species, the more cruel you can be. Fascinating really.

[@kylelacey1212]

It is interesting to note that every single socialist I've ever met has always been angry or bitter, usually incredibly self loathing. When I myself was a socialist, that was me too. It's easy to gloss over this but this sort of illuminates how it may be directly correlated. We are not socialist because we want some better world, we are socialist because we hate the world. We hate what it has become, and are incredibly angry we can do little to change it, so we subscribe to an idea that says it can offer better, and also offer less burden for us. The concept of getting cut a monthly check from the government for simply existing while we sit around and get fat playing Fortnite and eating Mcdonalds is alluring to some I suppose, but in no place has socialism ever been the free stuff young disillusioned people seem to think it is. They have a phony idea in their head that represents their own entitlement and complete lack of motivation to live. Capitalism is far from perfect. FAR from perfect, but I have to give it the credit of giving people the ability to at least achieve some comfort if they put forth the effort. I'm not gonna say achieve success or wealth because I don't think that's reasonable these days. The American Dream is all but completely dead. However, the ability to be comfortable? To have a reasonable wage at a place you don't hate and live in a place you don't hate? You won't necessarily have a mansion or all your needs constantly met without fail, but you don't have to live in squalor. Unfortunately that is precisely where these no work no ethics no motivation people would be in the socialist utopia, except with zero option for getting out save for fleeing or violent revolution.

[@ProxyDoug]

This was... pretty cathartic. I find it dangerous to assign such an inhumane motive to a large group of people because, similar to the concept of NPCs in the real world, it's yet another step towards dehumanization, but I've noticed over time that people who were once radical feminists and turned conservative, or vice versa, are equally as vicious regardless of the side they are at the moment, it's the need to have something to destroy, a rage they can't control. Peterson's point is even more poignant when you look at what the left rallies behind. The destruction of innocence, health, entrepreneurship, the sanctity of marriage and the family, all under the guise of inclusivity or justice, all must be destroyed and rebuilt. Hate to say it, but it sure is cathartic to get another piece on why these people are so... off.

[@jimjamjimjam7700]

"Socialism is bitterness" What do you expect from a movement based on weakness??

[@redking36]

A movement based on envy is what I thought.

[@IamaCosmonaut]

@redking36 Envy is a product of a weak mind.

[@Raubabbau]

Socialists are the worst that mankind has produced. Simple anecdote why: I am German and had skinheads as well as socialists in my circle of acquaintances. After visiting the concentration camp in Buchenwald, the skinheads abandoned their ideology and have not relapsed to this day. The socialists, on the other hand, did not put up the special camp in Buchenwald operated by Stalin's secret service, the memorial crosses in Berlin for the GDR refugees who drowned in the Spree or were shot, the Stasi prison in Hohenschönhausen, nothing has changed their opinion. The victims themselves are to blame for their fate, or the SED, which did not understand socialism. Envy, greed, lack of empathy, misanthropy, hatred, socialists embody all this and, in all their hideousness, still act as if they care about the well-being of people.

[@Xplora213]

If there is even a shred of truth to this, God help us all.

[@ghoulbuster1]

"... All the wickedness that mankind has produced..."

[@npcimknot958]

well daryl davis was the same.. he could sit and talk and covert kkk members.. but couldn’t even get a sjw communist/socialist blm person to have a convo.. they threaten to burn down the theatre

[@engelsteinberg593]

Is to note that Nazis are socialist. You may mean Marxian socialists?, they are the worst sure.

[@kronaaaa]

3:06 left wing memes are so cringe they just appropriate what right wing or centrist memes do but worse

[@saisameer8771]

Isn't that Vaush's whole thing?

[@Zayindjejfj]

Keith Woods said something about that and it was very profound. I don't know if he came up with it or got it from somewhere else. "The right memes to truth, while the left memes to power." And that's why leftist memes are often unfunny and have long winded phrases and walls of text. They're not trying to laugh at life. They're just trying to dominate.

[@GELTONZ]

Wow. First of all those letters from Marx's Dad are AMAZING. I mean essentially it shows that Marx was as much a layabout loser parasite as the people who worship him. Second, that rant at the end? Beautiful.

[@rjlundholm89]

I like how Jordan Peterson can say so much with so little and the lefties just get mad.

[@AdjutantReflex0]

I'm not going to lie, the way the video cuts off at the end with Dev just ripping into perpetually online breadtards is honestly just perfect. It makes it look like he's going to continue railing them long after the video ends because that's just how bad they are and how much they annoy SFO. It's brilliant.

[@Arassar]

I've never seen these words from Marx's dad before. Sounds like the guy was based.

[@RedDogDragon]

This was a topic JBP has touched in a few times over the years that has been quite interesting to me. For years I always felt like the villain architype "seemingly all powerful being that wants to literally destroy everything in existence" that often pops up in comic books or video games was just a stupid concept only created due to "villain power creep." But Peterson did a talk that mentioned the Columbine shooters awhile ago where he quoted one of the shooters who happen to write a bit of a manifesto leading to the event and wouldn't you know it, but the guy basically said something along the lines of he would have preferred to destroy everything in existence but lacked the power to do so he would settle with the shooting. Another interesting example was a video Mister Metokur did that was diving through a series of videos this one kid did leading up to a murder suicide where I think he literally flipped a coin to pick who or where he was going to kill. Not because that person had wronged him, but because if his life was so fucking shitty, it would be poetic to do something as horrific as murdering an innocent as a form of "fuck you" to existence itself.

[@jimass13]

A common theme is that the villain was once a good guy who suffered some tragedy that made them bitter. They're convinced that all of being is inherently evil and that they're the good guy by destroying everything. They have a strong sense of morality but it's twisted. You can see this in the story of Noah's flood. God destroys everything because it's evil, saves the tiny sliver that isn't evil, and sends a sign that he'll never do it again. It's sort of acknowledging that the villain has a point - if all of being is evil, it would make sense to destroy it. But God sent a sign saying he'd never destroy everything again, meaning that if anyone claims to be righteously bringing destruction on behalf of God, they're lying. The message is that the villain's viewpoint makes sense but it's not the answer. Another theme is that the villain is a moral nihilist: "there is no good or evil, there is only power, and those too weak to seek it". There is no bedrock loyalty to any overarching principle. Any loyalty they do have is merely a self-interested optics game. When a principle stops serving them, they discard it, unless they think that holding onto it (and thus appearing "principled") will serve their interests in the future. Vaush's stated philosophy basically.

[@rahn45]

It's not to hard to unwrap that mentality. Most people don't have remorse to killing insects as an example, in the case of mosquitos I'm sure people feel satisfaction in dispatching them. All that needs to be done is have people start viewing other people as insects, and unfortunately it's not all that hard to do.

[@cloroxusthestainlessone4324]

@@rahn45 go an Reddit and have a look at the comments on the vids of looters in Ukraine. I know Reddit is a cesspool but fuck me, people are willing to accept smashing a man's balls and hips with a hammer and women beaten and tied to lamp posts with their trowses and pants round their ankles Humans really are vile creatures

[@FM_1819]

Based Pinkie commentor

[@torshavnnewell]

Ik it's his name/webhandle, but calling him Mister Metokur sounds hilariously polite

[@AndrewChumKaser]

The last minute or so of ranting was needed. Thank you, Dev.

[@wojak-sensei6424]

Papa Marx gave a Sargon-level Dadism takedown. Imagine being the outright savant of your ideology, only to be dressed down by big-dick-daddy energy.

[@davidgusquiloor2665]

Learing about an author's real life really gives you an insight into how they came to think and view the world and why they have certain conclusions. In Marx case he was a deadbeat husband, a bad father, a terrible employer, a petty person and in all dimensions of life a really misserable person. It would make sense that the ideology he would help create would be one of bitterness, envy and destruction of everything that works. It's also worth noting that Marx himself was working from a hegelian point of view, so the ideas were circulating around by then.

[@Exli3r]

I knew a commie guy a couple years back he would complain about things But then I realised dude came from a well to do family and only worked cause he could spend money on extra things. Glad to say I didn’t move in and become roommates

[@rileyjfosbre6383]

Marx and these socialists your describing are people who genuinely scare me.

[@thehaloofthesun7174]

No group has killed more people, in such a short time, as Socialism and Communism. And yes, I include the National Socialist (Nazis) there as well. You'll note, their entire basis for what they did was the hatred of reality. Most of these people were atheistic in nature as well, which is why one should always scoff at "atheists aren't the ones killing people". Maybe not, but they convince many more others to kill people. The Khmer Rouge, was probably the most destructive group of these, they killed 20% of their own population, many of which were children. Imagine, 1 out of every 5 people you know being killed by a government saying the same things as Vaush.

[@cccycling5835]

Same. Can you imagine the horror of the Killing Fields? It will happen again.

[@justinambru8529]

I like to imagine, that if Chaz lasted longer, that would have been the next stage.

[@samekhalpherg4821]

Marx was the first NEET, writing fanfiction on his fathers dime

[@Otherlevel51]

Socialism = laziness Communism = laziness personified

[@an-animal-lover]

What's the difference?

[@StripesZB]

When I first read Marx in college-level philosophy, I thought "wow, this guy has some good ideas!" And then I got a job.

[@David-bf6bz]

Never met a smart Marxist... seriously seen some smart folks grifting off Marxists but never met a smart Marxist

[@ExeErdna]

Yeah, since Marx himself wasn't Smart he's basically like if Hasan or Vaush published a book and idiots treated it like a holy script.

[@woodwyrm]

There's a few of them, some can rationally assess the world without ideological blinders and some are just very good at hiding their power-level.

[@warrioroflight6872]

"You can be honest, you can be intelligent, or you can be a member of the Communist party. In fact, you can be any two of the three, but you can't be all three at once." -Saying from the Soviet Union.

[@warrioroflight6872]

@@ExeErdna Marx wasn't necessarily stupid. Jordan Peterson himself described the man as being smart. I don't think Marx's problem was that he lacked intelligence, I think it was that he lacked wisdom, compassion, and a sense of hygiene.

[@Raubabbau]

@@ExeErdna In Marx's time there was no unity in Germany, apart from standardized curricula. When studying law became too difficult for him, he simply changed universities. (Even in his youth he was more talkative than diligent) He moved from Bonn via Berlin to Jena, a university where it was relatively easy to get a doctorate.