The Dark Truth of Why Italy Is Giving Away Free Houses

[@ExplainedwithDom]

Check out the sponsor of today's video Masterworks at: www.masterworks.art/explainedwithdom

[@sygneg7348]

Guys Im gaming I will the sex

[@WifeMamaArtist]

Yeah, we all know they're 'almost' as bad as that fake titles scheme. You've pretty much lost most of the respect you had here...

[@teamextras4life270]

THE DARK TRUTH🤔The forgotten AFRICA MOOR'S RULER of Italy and Europe but Italy or Europe School's and Colleges WILL NEVER EVER Teach THE WORLD That🤯

[@dystopiaahoy]

Scam

[@WoodworkingforAnyone]

You lost my respect by promoting these scammers. The segue was weak as well.

[@fluidice1656]

A major factor is the fact that you basically can't hire anyone in Italy. The insane regulations require a license for everything, even IT positions. Instead of pandering to older populations (for the votes, or cash, if they're domestic or foreign, respectively) Italy should maybe, just maybe, give a tiny bit of a chance to the young. Demographic crisis is a consequence of not letting the young people to work or do business of any kind.

[@gregcarbonimaestri]

L’Italia ha uno dei complessi di tipi di contratti al mondo, c’è ne sono quasi 30. Banalità.

[@Winnas]

This is true of any major western country - people tend to vote in their self-interest and the older the population the more the suck the life and resources out of the young which sprials into national suicide.

[@zeeblankenship5959]

😢⚖️🙏

[@laura.r.1693]

In my opinion they should detax all those professions that earn little such as waiters, cashiers, etc. This would give entrepreneurs an incentive to hire more people

[@michellebyrom6551]

​@@laura.r.1693 income tax affects the employee, not the employer. Yes, it has to be processed by the employer, but zero tax rates simply means that no money is separated out to government. The paperwork still has to be filled to show who is earning what and where.

[@anta3612]

Here's another issue: I was a young Italian who left Italy due to a lack of opportunity. After a successful number of years abroad I decided to return (missed my family, friends and Italian culture) but Italy doesn't make it easy, either, for those wanting to make it back after spending time abroad. It's just all a out quick fixes without thinking or planning with long term solutions in mind (like these free houses which are designed to create revenue for local politicians many of whom don't give a damn about the average struggling Italian). I for one resent this free house giveaway exactly because I know the dark truth behind it all. Anyway, in the end I had no alternative other than to leave again. It's a completely and utterly ridiculous situation.

[@caty9508]

I’m sorry to hear that you have to leave again. You have to do what is best for you but Can you establish a kind of business that may give you an opportunity of income? Best wishes for your future

[@anta3612]

@@caty9508 Starting a business in Italy? I don't even know where to start to explain how crazy that is!

[@BiimGamesDev]

@@caty9508 I closed two businesses and had to leave the country after breaking even for years (in the best years). I tried for 11 years. The solution would be to have everyone brave enough to free the country to be an US colony and quit European Union.

[@Ghairmukamiaroundtheglobe]

Which country or countries did you move to ?

[@anta3612]

@@Ghairmukamiaroundtheglobe I originally moved to the USA.

[@warmbrucuriosity]

After 30 years living in Italy and 30 years trying to help people find work, I can confirm the message of this video. There is also the problem of excessive tax and nightmarish bureaucracy.

[@AAAAAAAADDDDDDDDD]

You describe a communist country- constantly punishing any capitalist freedom and capitalist economy enterprises. Are you sure you are not under Marxist agenda?

[@drk7031]

Try living in the Uk where you can’t see a GP And taxes are super high

[@AAAAAAAADDDDDDDDD]

@@drk7031 Well, the UK is even more communist, and you don't even know why?

[@Rasarel]

After 3 years of living in Italy I gave up . People there have issues with freedom and values, so they become alcoholic and they drive cars completely drunk . Yes, they can't live with themselves, because they feel inferior. French people have values, dignity etc Italians don't have dignity. They put their noses into other people bedrooms. That's not possible in civilized countries like Germany or France. Yet Italian care if you sleep with men or women. Nobody really wants to live in a fascist country with troubled future...

[@thomasandrewmcgonigal5150]

​@@drk7031 Well said,No one held to account over the GP issue,Had to pay out money for private health care treatment.

[@sbrewster1653]

This is spot on. As a Brit living here for over 20 years I continue to struggle to find decent employment. With my education and work experience I was always employed in the UK. If you buy a home or car then your bombarded with no end of taxes. Just try and sort out any form of documentation here and you will lose your mind. Quite honestly I would leave tomorrow but my other half is still attached to this place. History, culture, food etc. is all great, but without economic growth, investment and opportunities it is tough here.

[@jos_t_band3912]

@@beccabbea2511 a human can become a bureaucrat but a bureaucrat cannot become a human

[@maily8388]

Absolutely, it’s history, cultures, foods keeping me going back to Italy for so many times. By the ways, I am from South East Asia.

[@salmazzei5882]

Ditch the dead weight and live your life to the fullest. If you're putting out more (love, energy, money, etc.) than you get in return, it's a bad investment. Never compromise yourself to please others indulgences. Good luck and safe travels!

[@june.w.1288]

Hi! Do you have a YT channel? You could make videos teaching English to Italians. That type of videos are very popular and you don't need a qualification for putting up videos and you doo know your mother language perfectly. That way, you could make a side income. Actually, I might do something similar too, but my native tongue is Hungarian. It's much less popular than English. Ciao!

[@alicedacosta1825]

​@@salmazzei5882Hi!...I read your comment here about living your life and dreams to the fullest and I must say that I absolutely love and agree 👍 💯 per cent with you 👏 the only thing above what you said is that when anyone chooses to do that please, please just don't make children in to this crazy world 🙏 otherwise once you have them you can never ever again have the freedom to dicth everything to live your life that way!....Wishing best of luck to everyone ❤️

[@marcosmenescal2962]

Italy is not alone, Portugal, Greece, Spain and many other countries face gentrification. Italy is a beautiful country with a fantastic history, Italians are really nice people and food is great, but unfortunately the country is ruled by corrupt politicians and the Mafia. Bureaucracy is hell and cost of living is high. Italy is definitely a good country for tourists and for the wealthy, but not for entrepreneurs and the young who want to prosper.

[@fabriziopastorino3792]

instead in your country the politicians are honest, and that they are not in the pay of the corporations, if you think that the mafia governs Italy you don't know him and you are talking just to say. they are much stronger powers that condition Italy

[@deliciouscolours]

The difference is that in Portugal they often ask more than 100000€ for very old, decaying houses. As a consequence nobody buys them and they rot in plain sight. It's the ugliest most depressing thing to see multiple ruins and rotting houses every street you go on.

[@marcosmenescal2962]

@@deliciouscolours I know exactly what you mean, in 2012 I bought a golf villa in Vilamoura and sold it in 2019. I've seen prices sky rocketing since then. The Portuguese real estate bubble will burst one day and all prices will come down, wait and see.

[@rexx9496]

@@marcosmenescal2962 Remote workers and the Instagram crowd are far from done with Portugal. I wouldn't expect prices to come down there any time soon.

[@BB-km5nv]

​@@rexx9496 immigrants are coming from Africa and Middle East to fill the vacuum

[@vincenzocassello]

as an italian 19 yo guy i have to thank you for this video; most of us don't realize how bad our economy is.

[@Alex_Rome]

You are not italian, you are just a russian bot spreading misinformation

[@gregcarbonimaestri]

Certo: quarta potenza industriale al mondo, secondo esportatore europeo, secondo plusvalore, terzo paese più sicuro d’Europa, sistema bancario con più liquidirà, debito più sicuro d’Europa, pieno impiego in città come a Bologna e mancanza di mano d’opera in molti settori...

[@sacramento7935]

Italy is amazing wdym

[@msblue1003]

@@gregcarbonimaestri These is true mostly for the North/central Italian areas, regions... The unsolved South problems will keep Italy national economy stagnant for ever, unless tackled in some productive way

[@Nava_97]

@@gregcarbonimaestri It doesn't really matter how good the north is. The pension system will soon become unsustainable, and the longer the italian voters refuse to acknowledge this, the worst our future will be. All the Political Parties are too scared to loose the majority of their voters, and in the meantime the national Healthcare, the education system and other important services are being sacrificed on the altar of the rich and old.

[@futurekron]

As a property owner in Italy, I know firsthand what a ripoff some properties there can be! Best to buy something that is "habitable" without major renovations/fixes because the cost of doing them is ridiculously high! You need a permit for everything which is crazy expensive, a geometra or architect (good luck finding one who doesn't require a 10.000euro "feasibility study" just for starters), and (some) contractors will take your money and run, knowing that outsiders really aren't likely to sue. Italians themselves don't pay a lot for properties, but boy, they know how to take advantage of foreigners!

[@centurione6489]

True. The problem with 1-dollar homes is that they are located in depressed areas, and the cost of renovation is not 20-30 grand. In actuality it balloons out of control real fast to a point where the home turns into a very crappy deal.

[@marasegal1849]

​@@centurione6489 Unless the person buying the property is a skilled handyman and can repair everything from ceiling to floor and everything in between.

[@gaia7240]

@@marasegal1849 you still need permits

[@monica1518]

Non paghiamo molto per le proprieta??? Ma se sempre più persone non possono permettersi una casa???

[@smelltheglove2038]

Seems no different than anywhere else. The whole western culture is collapsing because “elites” are doing their best to make it collapse. Better off watching it burn from I beautiful location.

[@graemekinder9491]

There's a forum where house owners all shared the cost for a builders licence. Tey also now offer a service where You can get your works signed off for a small cost under this licence. The guy is Italian but has a wife from Australia and was sick of all the madness trying to get his house renovated.

[@Gullvivas]

hi, do you have a name? of forum or those people?

[@HellRyder18]

ngl that's pretty smart. Portugal could use with the same, we have lack of homes and the builder's licenses are crazy expensive....

[@julieritchie3373]

Seems odd not to add the link to this so-claimed share service.

[@lozkko]

I am Italian, and that is all true. But another factor is that culturally Italians like to live in cities, not villages or the countryside. So while house prices are very high in cities (for Italians, but even for foreigners they are not that cheap) in villages not that far away they can be 1/6 of the price. Such extreme differences do not exist in for example the UK (where houses in nice villages can be very pricey, as people prefer to live in the countryside).

[@Bellasie1]

So true!

[@futurekron]

Yes, I learned that too, which is why I'm looking in "rural" areas for another property. Very cheap up north, but seems to be reasonable drive to Milan and other major cities. Americans like me are used to driving some distance on a daily basis. However, it's nice to have public transport in cities.

[@claremartini6267]

So do you think its work buying one of these cheep properties in the countryside if you are a foreigner and not relying on an income?

[@lozkko]

@@claremartini6267 it depends what you mean by is it worth it. You love Italy, love the countryside, and want to live in a small Italian village? Yes. If you mean as some kind of investment, of course not. Regardless of what renovation you do, you probably won't even recoup that money, and it may take years to sell... Italian housing (outside of Milan and a few cities) is in a structural crisis (bad demographics, economic crisis, etc) and doesn't even really keep up with inflation.

[@futurekron]

@@claremartini6267 it could work just about anywhere if you had money to live on but the problem that I'm having with Italy is the Visa for self employed. They only give out a limited number and they go in about an hour every year. So you could buy a cheap property but never be able to live in a long-term!

[@davidrennie8197]

An Italian friend told me it took 17 licences to open a shop. The short cuts needed to do anything involve paying bribes

[@Sil7531]

It depends where you live. In Northern Italy there is no bribe that can shortcut the number of permissions and licences you need. And I am not saying that bribes do not exist in the North, but that sometimes it can be even worst

[@Mespera3011]

All latin group countries are like this - ancient bureaucracy

[@jamesdellaneve9005]

Yes. I talked to a business man in Florence. He had multiple businesses and had to wait 18 months to open his gelato shop.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

I understand your concern regarding excessive bureaucracy and corruption in Italy. These issues can create barriers to economic growth and hinder entrepreneurship. It is true that Italy has faced challenges in streamlining its administrative processes and combating corruption.

[@kittycat7505]

yeah i was in sicily this summer.. in my moms village , some of the houses look like they have been hit with an atomic bomb, cause it's hard to get the license to build my aunt told me. it looks a little ghetto... but its a cute fishing village and that's why so many of the houses look like that.

[@code001it]

Just for your info: 0:04 Dolomites 0:06 Cinque Terre 0:15 Rome, Colosseum 0:21 Rome, Ponte S. Angelo, Vatican 0:25 Milan, Duomo 0:28 Alberobello 0:34 Firenze 0:54 somewhere in Tuscany 0:58 San Gimignano 1:13 Chianti 1:17 Amalfi 1:25 Palermo 1:35 somewhere Liguria (?) 1:41 ?? 1:55 Capo Miseno, monte di Procida 1:59 Cinque Terre 2:09 Val D'Orcia, Tuscany 2:19 San Gimignano, Tuscany 2:24 Bergamo 2:28 Bergamo 2:30 Milan 2:38 Milan, Galleria VIttorio Emanuele 3:33 Milan, Unicredit Tower and Vertical Forest 3:41 Rome, Colosseum 3:46 Rome, Vittoriano 3:53 Amalfi 3:58 Palermo Via Maqueda 4:07 Perugia 4:10 Portofino 4:24 Milano 4:32 Rome, Vittoriano 4:49 Vatican S. Peter 6:27 Verona 6:48 Ferrara 6:54 P.za dei Signori, Treviso 7:41 ?? 7:45-55 Venice 8:15 ?? 8:21 Cinque Terre, Vernazza 8:26 Cinque Terre 8:42 ?? 9:14 Cortona 9:22 Venice 9:28 Milan, Naviglio grande 9:36 Val D'Orcia, Tuscany 10:02 Abbazia di San Miniato al Monte, Firenze 10:09 Milan 10:20 Rome (Hints for unknown are welcome!)

[@lisafiore7081]

I don't understand?

[@nidhishshivashankar4885]

@@lisafiore7081the scenery

[@philiptownsend4026]

@Lisafiore - he is identifying the places shown in the accompanying photos. Why not? He obviously knows and loves Italy and is trying to spread the love.

[@sanchari.c]

Thanks! ❤

[@mrhatman675]

​@@philiptownsend4026NO STOP THIS PROPAGANDA

[@corradodeluca1320]

I live in Italy and Canada. And I gotta say that sadly Canada has recently been collapsing really fast. Living in Canada is becoming practically unaffordable by most (younger) Canadians. No future. If this keeps going, I’d pick Italy over Canada in a heartbeat ! Also keep in mind that Italians are famous complainers by nature, even when they have it good.

[@katrinagertner4430]

I’m Hungarian and I live in Canada the last 23 years . Yes Canada is changed big time . I love Italy im thinking to move there .

[@arianegabrielle]

I moved to Italy from Canada in January. At least Italians have clear values and culture. Canada has lost its way to wokism and weak leadership and increasing censorship. I will never go back.

[@bambinaforever1402]

I can not understand what about all those moslems coming on boats and rafts? Why they re not put to work on low paying jobs and live in those abandoned houses?

[@bambinaforever1402]

@@arianegabrielle ya, much less p.a #k is

[@sparklelight]

The collapse is occurring all over the world

[@kumarmanjeet4679]

Living with parents has been presented as a negative feature of the society, but with an ageing population, it's nothing but a a great social assistance. Looking down upon close knit families living together is an American social disease. The problem is lack of opportunities for youngsters, and not their strong family culture.

[@gaia7240]

I don't know why people say we have such a strong family culture, it's just normal level of family bonding in reality, we live with them because we are poor that's it

[@smelltheglove2038]

@@gaia7240 I wouldn’t be so quick to dismiss familial living. People who do so tend to be much happier. Also, it’s much better than being lonely.

[@sd-ch2cq]

Being forced to live with (and eventually care for) elderly relatives greatly enhances the risk of elderly neglect and elderly abuse. It's great when people *choose* to care for their old parents, but when it's a burden they never wanted on top of trying to run their own job and their own life it can lead to a lot of stress and frustration.

[@smelltheglove2038]

@@sd-ch2cq I guess, if you’re an ungrateful ingrate n

[@markoshea6833]

In Rome, I was once for a holiday, and the respect for a grandfather, by his son, who ran the shop, was super. I went to the cash register of the son twice and he nodded me to the cash register of his father twice.

[@johnd3982]

I was born in Italy, I haven’t been back since I was 17 and I’m 60 years old. When I left at 17 years old I said one thing back then, it was only good place to live if you are wealthy enough to afford it. Looks like nothing has changed in my life time.

[@purplelove3666]

Wow, that's insane,

[@growinglongisland]

That’s exactly what my mom says! She left Sicily when she was 18 and is now 72 and still loving life here in America.

[@lucasansonisergiampietri5002]

40 years ago the economy was okay

[@isktroboma]

@@lucasansonisergiampietri5002 Italy's downfall has been the euro

[@aquilifergroup]

Sorry to hear that about Italy.

[@Createwithfranzsidney]

Yup, you’ve got this just right, I left Italy in 1996 for the well known reason that at 23 you were already too old for job Announcements requiring: ‘max 22 anni, nella presenza, multilingue, laurea e esperienza’. 😮 All my Italian colleagues at work have experienced good professional growth in the U.K., something impossible in our country where nepotism and personal recommendations reign, giving opportunities to family and friends who might not always be the most qualified people for the job. Also, I remember being at Uni and studying economics, and by the end of the course I suddenly understood why the system would never work: because it’s literally designed to crush workers and students and suck all their earnings and time in endless bureaucracy and taxes on everything possible. I will always love and miss my country, but I can never return. Except for holidays. ❤

[@Saba15-t9d]

This sounds like Norway 🤥

[@Createwithfranzsidney]

sorry to hear that! @@Saba15-t9d

[@Gullvivas]

@@Saba15-t9d Jøss! Not true at all!

[@Saba15-t9d]

@@Gullvivas her jeg bor på Østlandet stemmer dette 100%.

[@Gullvivas]

@@Saba15-t9d It is a huge different between big citys and the country cite and small villages! Not all of Norway are the same! If you have education,you can easily get a good job here.

[@BluCircled]

The thing is even if you find work in Italy as an employee, the salary isn't great, you work very long hours and you might have to deal with a lot of incompetent colleagues who have their job either because they are related to the boss or because they have slept with him. It sucks.

[@recarras]

They do these to keep receiving property taxes. Its an easy way to get fresh money for the government and also a way to avoid the closing of mayor's office in most of these towns.

[@latinhellas6383]

Some US small communities are offering similar deals; eventually they want long-term taxpayers. In Italy, the US, and many other countries of early industrialization, the effects of globalization over the past 30 years or so have been skewed in favor of certain regions and economic sectors, while others have stagnated, declined, or rotted. There is no mystery why the Italian economy has stagnated over the past 30 years, the reason were crystal clear in the early 1990s. Since then, every year a journalist, a professor, a government study writer have been publishing the same article or study detailing the same reasons over and over and over and 30 times over again.

[@mradventurer8104]

not just that! Without such schemes many more houses would turn into ruins. The 1 euro houses schemes often require 20,000 investment, which keep the house liveable for another 10-20 years.

[@cataldoschiavuzzo282]

Property taxes? In scicily if you live in your home no tax

[@marcusaetius9309]

True, this post forgot to mention that the houses don’t get taxed as if they were bought for 1 euro.

[@isktroboma]

@@latinhellas6383 the Italian crisis began with the euro

[@VFAHSN]

The point is our country is hold hostage by the older generations. They control politics, labour, institutions… basically everything. Meanwhile most of people in their 20s and 30s struggle to find a work and a salary which could allow them to be indipendent. Our top 5% minds leave the county looking after higher salary and that has crushed our research and development sectors. Tourist are considered more important than our own students, so that’s the road most of (old) Italians have chosen… being a tourist country.

[@aleksandreliott5440]

Pretty much all western countries are held hostage by the older generations; they suck the life out of the youth so that they might "enjoy" a few more years.

[@angelasmith6526]

As an American, I know and understand that are being looked down upon right now, but we are starving for people to work. Our younger generation would rather be influencers than work, so we now have so many job opportunities for anyone who wants to work, basically in every field....

[@LucaLindemann]

I don't hold a fucking anything dear friend. I'm 55, I lost my job 15 years ago and since then, I struggled to find a new one decently paid. So, we're on the same boat, and it's full of middle age people.

[@deeptoot1453]

Italy and Spain both have this archaic system where seniority and tenure positions are the bread an dbutter if every institution. Completely archaic. The Netherlands has the wxact opposite where every idiot and his grandma can get a job and therefor the con men aren't separated from the high value talented individuals. A system like the US is the best I believe except without the crazy school fees.

[@Peglegkickboxer]

This is the same in Canada and Japan. The older generation has sold out the next generation and we are all suffering.

[@Hrovitnir]

Italy has an insane economic system. It's literally impossible to do something without a license. A license to be paid in advance. Everytime. Side hustle is quite impossible in Italy. You are strictly locked in a massive scheme where you remain what you are in this moment. Assuming you are employed in a company, if you want to start, or even try to start your hustle with a little e-commerce, or even an affiliate blog, you have to pay 12.000 euro JUST TO START, without even made a single sell. Italy is killing the soul of entrepreneurs, those who made Italy great once, and could help the country to rise again...

[@recyclespinning9839]

Italians are very entrepreneur type. If what you say it true and it is now hard to work for yourself, it's probably killing their soul 😢

[@Hrovitnir]

@ReCycle Spinning I can say that because I tried to create my hustle during my regular job. Two times. Just a little bit of context: Italy has 3 type of "doors" to become entrepreneurs. 1) If revenue does not exceed 5000 euro, you can work under "occasional performance" system. It has a lot of restrictions on what you can and you can't do. Basically, it is made to who want to provide consultancy or to be a freelancer, because you have to pay attention to several things that you usually do not pay attention to (for example you cannot bill two times the same customer and you have a cap on how you can bill them). You can issue your bills with your own tax code. 2) The flat-rate scheme is a facility that allows you to pay less taxes than the amount of taxes that would be payable by opening a VAT account the ordinary regime. It is applied until you reach 65k in gross revenue. 3) Ordinary VAT account, the one I told above. If you are employed and you open a VAT account, the salary you earn is automatically included into your potential revenue as entrepreneur, so you have to pay taxes on this, even if you do not make any sale. First time, I told my plan to my tax advisor. Since it would've been an affiliate website, there were no control on potential revenue, so I had to open a regular fiscal position, option 3. I cannot open option 2 because I already have a salary. So I turned to freelancer skills as copywriter. I work under option 1. One year I made a mistake and billed 6.000 euros instead of 5000. Some months later, the year after, I got a phone call by my tax advisor: "if you say you will not do anything in freelance revenue this year, you can handle it paying only 2500 euro in taxes. If you plan to do further, you will pay around 4500 eur. What you gonna do?"

[@gaia7240]

This is why everyone is working irregularly

[@Hrovitnir]

@Gaia I know that. But I don't think that other countries don't have "irregular workers". But UK, for example, allow you to work without VAT position (only with your tax ID as citizen) until your revenue is under 100.000 £. It means have the chance to plan, to start without the fear of break the law if your e-commerce make some sales more than planned... Italy is made for employees. Italy hates entrepreneurs that would try to build some big projects. Italy loves freelancers, artisans and small familiar companies. Because it is believed they are easier to track and it will be easier to tax them. You cannot include my employer's salary to the count of my e-commerce revenue. This is insane... absolutely insane.

[@gaia7240]

@@Hrovitnir yeah, the average Italian doesn't even know what you are talking about

[@BigCookeOut]

I will say, that was the smoothest transition into a sponsor I have ever seen. Everyone needs to do this because I actually watched the entire sponsorship section.

[@cindykpower]

I was like 'what did just happened?😳'

[@Riley-briyon]

Can you help me to come Italy

[@Liberty.LoveXo]

I didn’t 😂 peeped it quickly

[@Mrs.Silversmith]

Out of all the various factors mentioned, I think that the scariest one is population collapse due to low birthrates. It's scary for two reasons. Firstly, it takes a while for the effects to become obvious, but by the time they are, the trend is a couple of generations in and well-nigh irreversible. Secondly, it's a problem across a large number of countries worldwide and soon there just isn't going to be enough immigrants from other places to offset the effects of low birthrates. It won't just be a collapse for Japan or Italy, it will be a collapse for pretty much all of the developed countries.

[@zetranquilo5459]

In 30 years when I reach 65 most people will be my age or older, there will be few children, way less people in the workforce paying taxes and a lot of people who passed their whole lives without a chance to own a home, support a family and no chance to enjoy a decent retirement. A lot of people will be hopeless.

[@Pink_Noodle]

Things will require automation to keep civilization going or we shall see the global social order collapse as populations shrink worldwide. I fully expect the wealthier types freaking out as they watch the value of their wealth vanish as it has no use if they can't exchange it for anything.

[@wright1048]

If all the people of childbearing age move away, of course the birthrates are going to go down.

[@stevenhenry5267]

Ridiculous

[@utente1489]

@@maturedgangz369 you sound mental

[@musamusashi]

As an Italian (not so young) who left Italy years ago, this analysis is rather accurate except it didn't mention the main cause of economic decline. It's true that economic stagnation started in the 90's, but the real decline begun with the Euro financial fraud of 2002, when the buying power of Italians on a fixed wage, was basically cut in half overnight. Add a constantly more corrupt and inept political class, disastrous covid response and jumping on the NATO proxy war cutting cheap gas supplies from Russia, in the last 3 years and here you have this poisonous mix. Most Italians deserve this though, for our passivity and selfishness and incapacity of thinking as a nation and not as individuals in a rat race pushing the next man down in order to stay afloat.

[@zumurudlilit]

Honey go kiss Putin ass 😂😂😂

[@seriouslyfun9740]

Could you explain elaborate more Euro financial fraud? I am find of interest, never heard it before

[@musamusashi]

@@seriouslyfun9740 the German central bank controlled the BCE and set the exchange rate for the national currencies as they transitioned into Euro: the rate for the Deutsch Mark and the French Franc were convenient for those two leading EU nations, those for Italian Lira, Spanish, Portuguese and Greek currencies were at a loss. Southern European countries did not negotiated it the way they should have, and this further deepened the economic gap between northern and southern Europe. When Euro was launched in Italy, you needed almost 2000 Lira for 1 Euro and wages were adjusted at that, so if your wage was 1,500,000 Lire, now it became less than 800 €, but at the same time consumer goods and most private services were echanged as if 1€ was 1000 Lire, so basically overnight is like you either had half the wage you had until the previous day, or you you had the same wage but almost everything had doubled up in price, however you want to look at it. Shops, restaurants, bars etc. doubled up their profits for a while, but when, after a few months, people realized that something was wrong, fear kicked in and sales of goods and services dropped and the economic stagnation, more of a recesion in several moments, kicked in. Add to this disastrous economic and fiscal policies that strangled small and medium size industries, the real engine of Italian economic, plus the fruits of globalization, consolidation of firms into larger and larger corporations, relocation of industry were cheaper labour will offer more profits etc. and you have a full recipe for a disaster.

[@br4infrezz339]

​@@musamusashi thanks for the info

[@Nowhere-from]

​@@musamusashi Gee, to think that the same nations that set up the Euro fraud (northern Europe) now bitterly complain about supporting southern Europe. I did learn that introducing the Euro currency started the fall of Italy as the nation lost power to inflate or deflate its own currency, but the conversion scheme you mentioned is totally new to me, who actively follows news of sorts (except celebrities and sports) and use independent media channels. Mainstream media only gives you very superficial and distorted information. It was understandable that the northern European countries accepted to bailout Greece and have supported the other southern countries. It figures Greece had to pay a heavy price to be bailout and it was ultimately convenient for the northern nations, situation that also applies to Italy, Spain and Portugal with hardly any Mainstream media coverage. It's obvious how much news are ignored by mainstream media and how corrupt the southern European governments were when accepting the Euro. If it's any consolation, here in America we may be worse off than Italy! Again, don't listen to mainstream media. I could never end listing our problems, like housing, hell expensive, pushing many into homelessness. Next, home prices are headed for a crash which will crash the already crashed economy!

[@Roybwatchin]

My wife and I traveled to Italy for our 30th anniversary back in 2016 and was surprised how inexpensive it was then, even just 7 years ago. I was expecting similar costs that I've encountered in many trips to Germany, England, Spain, France and Sweden, but this was not the case. I was pleasantly surprised at how much further my money went for amazing food, nice hotels and other fun stuff we did while there. We are planning to go back in three more years for our 40th. We both really loved the Italian people and culture and especially the beautiful countryside villages. We never ran across any rude people like you can when visiting France for example (although mostly just in big cities). The food in Italy is amazing as well. They claim France has the best food, but I beg to differ. I'm sad for the young Italians, they were so friendly to us while there. We could stop any young person and ask for directions, etc. and they were so nice and friendly. I hope things can pick up for them.

[@ravenclaw783]

Many Americans who have the privilege to travel to Europe, particularly the Southern countries, remark on how inexpensive it is. Well, that's because many people are making 1000 euro per month there. So naturally, the foreign experience is much better than the local experience. It doesn't matter where you live, how much you earn relative to what you can afford makes the ultimate difference.

[@richgreenmusic2211]

The cost totally depends on which part of the country you went to and which parts of the other countries you are comparing to?

[@sunnydeessa714]

@@ravenclaw783as a Spanish here, exactly. Just exactly. Earning 1000€ per month here is a huge privilege

[@donaldkasper8346]

Yeah, and you didn't go to Rome where 30 years ago a taxi from the airport to hotel was $100.

[@user-nj1ob8ht3p]

finally another one finding out on their own, proud of you!😊

[@annanardo2358]

The economy in Italy has been bad for years, I used to live there. Houses in Si Ily selling for $ 1.00 is more or less a bad idea to invest in. 1. Sicily is a seismic zone, you have Mt. Etna rattling around which is connected to Mt. Vesuvius , which rattles unrelentlessly, causing big time earthquakes. THEN, there's that super volcano in the Bay of Naples, displacing entire populations. All of Italy is seismic. Italy is also one hell of a GORGEOUS country. My family is from Abbruzzo. The $1.00 homes take an enormous amount of money to fix and then they crack because of the seismic tremors.

[@firehorse9996]

Tell that to all the people living in California. Paying $600,000 on average to buy a home in San Francisco. And the homeless, drug and robbery problems. When I lived there experienced 5 earthquakes but it's not slowing anyone down from buying it all up.

[@v2plus4]

​@@firehorse9996medium house price in Frisco has been over $1m for a while now

[@evocati6523]

The houses have managed to stay livable for over a thousand years so they're not all bad

[@hons6967]

Then Why are they turning away the Immigrants who change the narrative?

[@BlueFairyRose]

So my dream of living in Centeripe is not positive? Family was there before WW2

[@dheerajb1883]

Fraud sponsor beware

[@--julian_]

hopefully this comment is not deleted

[@jeez5735]

Masterworks is shady af

[@laikanbarth]

@@jeez5735 I didn’t know that. Thanks for letting us know.

[@mauricedavis2160]

🙏🤔😢

[@antbereishit]

People selling you part of something you can't even touch nor utilize? Fraud? No waaaay

[@itaholic902]

Unfortunately, this video confirms my findings. We moved to the region around Bergamo in September 2014, a fantastic region with mountains, lakes (Como, Iseo, Garda) and ... a good flight connection with the rest of Europe. That was important to me because I run a consultancy company in Belgium. Because we did not want to run any risk with rogue construction contractors (which we have had to deal with in Belgium), we decided to buy a new house. However, years later it turned out that the papers were not in order at all, despite the intervention of a notary, and that we would never be able to sell our house in these circumstances. Apparently the construction company had 'good ties' with the notary as well as with the mayor of our municipality. You hear all that afterwards. Although we were not/are not planning to sell the house in the short term, we still wanted to put this in order. However, you cannot imagine what procedure we have to follow for this. After almost 5 years, things are still not in order... and that is largely because our lawyer apparently cannot be trusted either. Luckily I don't have to work here. But every time I fly back after a 2 or 3 day stay in Belgium, I feel very privileged to be able to live in such a beautiful country.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

I'm sorry to hear about your personal experience with the difficulties you have faced in the process of buying and legalizing your house in Italy. Unfortunately, instances of corruption and bureaucratic challenges can create significant obstacles for individuals and businesses alike. Instances where construction companies or individuals may have inappropriate connections with notaries or local officials can lead to complications and legal issues. These situations can be frustrating and time-consuming to resolve, often requiring the intervention of lawyers or legal experts. It is regrettable that even after almost five years, the situation has not been fully resolved for you. It is essential to find trustworthy professionals who can provide the necessary legal assistance and guidance to rectify the situation properly. However, it is heartening to hear that despite these challenges, you appreciate the natural beauty and privileges of living in Italy. The country's landscapes, culture, and lifestyle are undoubtedly captivating, and it's understandable that they hold such a strong appeal. While instances like the one you have described can paint a negative picture, it's important to remember that this is not representative of every experience in the country. There are efforts being made to combat corruption and streamline bureaucratic processes, and many individuals and businesses successfully navigate these challenges to thrive in Italy. I hope that with the right assistance and perseverance, you can ultimately resolve the issues you are facing and fully enjoy the benefits of living in such a beautiful country.

[@andrewx7806]

It is this kind f thing that ruins an economy. Countries that prosper have reliable and honest bureaucrats and land management that works. Traveling through Italy I see how buildings are not kept up on the exterior because of insane city rules about repair and painting. Also there are a lot of abandoned buildings and vacant buildings even in large cities.

[@cjraymond8827]

I love Bergamo

[@OutnBacker]

"...some conditions..." truth is, you have to be very well off to do this - because of "some" conditions. Most of these properties are in near condenmed shape. Lots of them are abandoned because the previous owner could not afford to hire the skills to re-model - and - like in several other European countries, there are very strict laws regarding the manner and style required to do the remodel. Re-building a stone hut to the original appearance and design is a very narrow skill field. We aren't talking about some small house built in 1975. More like 1775,. some even earlier. Many were last "remodeled" 100 years ago, and are worse than the original structure. No water, no heat, maybe a single electrical circuit, run bare, and a stone roof that leaks like a collander. Or, no roof at all, with the stone slab shingles long ago tkaen and used by another house two miles down the mountain. Like the Colisseum in Rome: only half of it is still there. The rest was salvaged and used by the various Renaissance merchant families to build their palaces. Not all of them are that bad, but shop carefully, and do your research. What seems like a dream can become a nightmare in Italy - not just because of the work, but how it gets done and who actually does it. You are strictly ilimited in what you can do as the owner. Even though you might have diligently researched the building, and fully intend to make it a Still Life Renaissance painting, Italy has unions and regulations that will shut you down if you take their jobs. Italy wants the finished product for their heritage. That's fine. But they also have a deeply embedded - and corrupt - regulatory system that keeps you out of any cost savings. For instance: if the interior was covered in plaster 250 years ago, theywill insist thatthe plaster be of the identical composition as th eoriginal. Next, the tradesmen that are paid by you to do the job, will mix whatever plaster they want - then check off on the "original" recipe. Corrupt. And you paid for it, and you waited 3 months for the job to get started. It goes on, and you better be well off enough to have a fall back domicile while the project drags. How do I know? I have an Austrian cousin who did this. It was hell, buit he got the job well enough along to sell off to another person who finished it. That person was quite wealthy.

[@TheHoriginal]

Oh boy. This is great information. Thanks for posting!!

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

It seems like you're discussing the challenges and conditions associated with purchasing and renovating old properties, particularly in Italy. You highlight that many of these properties are in a state of decay and require significant investments for restoration. Additionally, you mention the strict laws and regulations surrounding remodeling, which can make the process more complex. These properties often have historical significance, dating back several centuries, and require expertise in specific restoration techniques. It's true that restoring such properties can be quite costly and may require a substantial financial commitment. This reality might contribute to the difficulties and limitations faced by potential buyers.

[@schoomzer]

@@PoisonelleMisty4311 Why did you have to summarize another post? Sheesh...

[@clam371384]

Just got back from two weeks in Italy and was pleasantly surprised by how cheap the food and drinks were. My experience of traveling to Europe has shown that Italy is one of the cheapest countries to dine out. The number of tourists was overwhelming to me even in March, I couldn't even imagine what it would be like during peak season. While I'm glad tourism keeps and helps Italy economically, I also noticed a lot of Italians just don't appreciate tourists.

[@shellieperreault6262]

Maybe there are too many tourists who take advantage of the Italians and act like arrogant pricks?

[@Spaistraveler]

Don't want to offend anybody but from a worker perspective italian tourist economy is shitty.

[@zagortenay33]

" I also noticed a lot of Italians just don't appreciate tourists." Exactly. Italians are full of themselves.

[@lovinglife419]

Possibly resentment, because there’s very little opportunity outside of tourism. Kind of depressing.

[@uchoobe1876]

Most countries that are heavily dependent on tourism usually have many citizens who aren't fond of tourists 😂

[@rexx9496]

Italy is so beautiful, I'm sad to hear that so many people there are struggling. It's weird how the grass is so much greener on the other side. When Americans visit Italy they fall in love with the place, all the history, food, architecture, beautiful scenery and laid back culture and wish they had this.

[@edema.3418]

Every country has its problems, unfortunately.

[@francisdrake7060]

So many? Way less then the USA, do a research.

[@lg206]

You’re missing two key factors. 1. It is the top 10% of middle-class Americans that have the money to travel to Italy. Most of the American middle class doesn’t even have $500 to their name so a 3k vacation is out of question 2. Americans can enjoy beautiful Italy thanks to our American wages. Even consulting managers and bankers in Milan make 2-2.5k euro net monthly but rent near the office STARTS at 1500. Which means only the top earners and trust fund babies get to truly enjoy this beautiful place

[@lg206]

@@francisdrake7060 Exactly. There is not one city in Italy or all of Europe that has homeless encampments

[@MrCenturion442]

I went back to Italy to see we’re my parents came from, I was amazed at how beautiful the country was. I asked my dad why would you ever have left this paradise? He told me in his broken English “you can’t eat paradise “

[@sirmione905]

As a Japanese myself, everything explained in this video sounds familiar except high unemployment rate. Economy growth and average income have been stagnated since early 90s in Japan. There are so many vacant homes in rural areas due to low birth rate and declining population. Nobody wants such home even it’s free cos home owners have to keep paying property tax though house itself has no value. Local governments refuse donations of such homes because property tax is important source of their income. It’s sad to see abandoned homes everywhere in countryside.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

Japan has indeed been facing economic challenges since the early 1990s, marked by a prolonged period of low growth and deflation. These factors, coupled with an aging population and low birth rate, have contributed to the vacant homes issue you described. The declining population in rural areas and the concentration of economic opportunities in urban centers can exacerbate this problem further.

[@michaeljones3694]

my mate lives there. he said any work doing you need doing on your own house you have to employ the local builder, or no-one in the village/town will talk to you. The local builder turns up when he wants. my mate has had to learn to do a lot of jobs for himself or they'll never get done.

[@Another-Layer]

In Venice you can’t fix anything on your house without an approved contractor. There were bed sheet signs everywhere hanging from the houses that said "get out mafia". When I asked what that was about, they said all the contractors are mafia. A home owner can’t rehang a window shutter because it has to be done by a cost prohibitive contractor so they just leave it barely hanging off the wall. That’s why Venice is crumbling and is a giant deferred maintenance debacle. I’m sure this exists everywhere in Italy.

[@JeroenBIG]

I was in ROme Italy at new years eve. Most shops were closed the whole day already. Some were open. Not much economical activity. At 5 o clock in the afternoon I wanted to enter a shop to buy a bottle of wine, just to found out I couldn't get in because there was a government employee checking if the stores all did actually close at 5, the time set by the government. This is Italy in a nutshell.

[@Dezeberbro]

They always close stores for like 3 hours in the middle of the day. It is like they don’t want to grow economically

[@nicolettastrada5976]

@@Dezeberbro c@€??ate

[@ndorobei4391]

In Asia stores open 24 hours.

[@starkiller578]

@@ndorobei4391 Asia isn’t a country

[@nathanseper8738]

Italy's government regulations don't seem to be sustainable. The super-cheap housing seems to be a symptom of that.

[@nicolenotizieeamici]

As an Italian I can confirm. Plus most of these houses are far from cities … so you need to go do groceries etc and all becomes a pain. - maybe now with remote work it can get better BUT most of the mind set has to change.

[@reneamaton7498]

i live in Italu 4 years now and I can pretty much agree with everything.. as young professional you can expect to make a career unless you really learn italian and make great contacts no matter how prepare you are professionally

[@carlogardella5808]

I totally agree with your conclusions. I left Italy 25 years ago just after graduation. Lack of meritocracy, nepotism and a very corrupted and incompetent political class were and still are the main reasons for Italy's decline

[@isktroboma]

the Italian crisis began with the euro

[@tarotgalaxy6822]

@@isktroboma yes the EU is destroying Europe. I know what it’s doing to Ireland….being destroyed..the EU needs to go so we can take back our countries for the people….it’s really fascist now

[@bakeraus]

The scariest thing is "incompetent political class" is by design. We are seeing these affects all over the world.

[@simasj1]

But why people are electing these incompetent politics? Isn't the Italian voting system democratic? Or it has some ridiculous voting system (like in USA) that does not allow to elect "non-systemic" politicians? For example, here in Lithuania a year ago our government which constantly blathers about democracy wanted to push election reform to allow to participate in elections only members of the parties, approved by the head of the ruling parties (after collapse of USSR we had a quite liberal laws allowing to candidate for everyone, who gets signatures of 5000 supporters or so, but we constantly face attempts to limit participation of non-systemic candidates).

[@isktroboma]

@@simasj1 In Italy democracy is only false, fake ... politicians promise you things and when they have the votes they do the opposite, in many situations. For example, the 5stelle party was against the mandatory vaccination, in 2018 it took 32% and then, it agreed with the vaccination obligation. In the Italian constitution war is abhorred as a way of overcoming international disputes, but then, this government sends weapons to Ukraine and is dominated by the will of the USA. I think no country is free of its destiny. Voting is just useless.

[@Joe-pk1kb]

I don't think they want people who don't understand any of this. They want people that will ultimately stay and correct the problem. My wife and I are Americans who bought a home in Italy in 2022. We both work online and that's why these deals made perfect sense for us. We did not get a 1 Euro home however, but decided to spend a little money on a much nicer home in the country. We lose literally no standard of living from America - in fact it actually improves because the cost of living is way lower. I believe with the change in mindset from Covid, people are deciding what really matters to them, and I believe this will have a positive effect on Italy's population crisis, that so many other countries also share.

[@alexamorin5534]

Nice! Planning to do the same. Can you share some more insights about your experience?

[@HellRyder18]

is your income taxed in the US or in Italy?

[@AlejandroMS67]

Your lack of depending on getting a local job in the Italian economy changes EVERYTHING for you given the context of the video/conversation here.

[@dannycorsaro546]

You can run but you can’t hide. But you enjoy yourselves,I would 🩷

[@19mad92]

yes for remote workers feom America it is great and cheap in the Italian South or Center and you can profit from expat/impatriates programs. But Italians are treaten diffrently, we suffer a lot

[@MiamiMorslav]

An Italian friend of mine had a job at Bosch tools corporate offices in Italy he said the whole day was literally like one big coffee break

[@elim7228]

Cause Bosch Never break down

[@diane9247]

Sounds a lot like what I know of France.

[@mariecarton8611]

Yes you are correct. Here in Ireland I had an occasion to speak to a young man from Hungary who was working at a menial job in a tire replacement garage and whe I enquired why he had left a country with such good historical infrastructure and insentifying foreigners to buy homes there, his answer was they have no time for their own youth who get no help whatsoever. 😢

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

It's disheartening to hear about the challenges faced by the young man from Hungary and the reasons behind his decision to leave his country. Issues like a lack of support for youth and limited opportunities can indeed lead individuals to seek better prospects elsewhere. Every country faces its unique set of challenges, and ensuring support and opportunities for young people is crucial for their personal development and the overall well-being of society. It's important for governments to invest in education, vocational training programs, and initiatives that promote entrepreneurship and job creation, providing young people with the skills and resources they need to succeed. Additionally, creating an environment that fosters innovation, attracts investment, and encourages the growth of industries can also generate employment opportunities for young people. Offering support services such as mentorship programs, access to financing, and networking opportunities can further enhance their chances of success. It's important for policymakers and societies as a whole to recognize the value of investing in their youth. By providing the necessary support, nurturing talent, and creating an inclusive environment, countries can not only retain their younger generations but also benefit from their energy, ideas, and contributions to society.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

Efforts can be made to improve the economic conditions, create jobs, and provide incentives for young talents to stay within their own country. This involves fostering entrepreneurship, investing in education and skills development, and supporting industries that can provide sustainable employment. Additionally, measures can be taken to streamline bureaucratic processes and reduce barriers to entry for professionals to encourage them to pursue their careers in their home country.

[@AnnikaMystica]

@@PoisonelleMisty4311 I am also from Hungary and believe me, most Hungarians think the same. The problem is, that they are not in positions of power to create the change in an increasingly illiberal system that spares no effort to cement its position and its biggest idea is to make friends with Russia and China.

[@nathanseper8738]

I appreciate you taking a serious look at Italy's structural problems and the massive catch behind the free homes.

[@TheHoriginal]

Agreed 👍

[@nathanseper8738]

@@TheHoriginal Yep.

[@user-nj1ob8ht3p]

nahy...for a foreigner w own income is a good investment, depending the project of course, ... not for locals...it does not come out well from the video and of course with a purpose: don t invest money in italy but into my sponsor...😅

[@mikegkerr]

I was in Milan last month. It seemed to be booming. People shopping in the large downtown mall. The restaurant we went to was packed, but many nearby were indeed desperate for customers. Struggling small towns is a worldwide problem. Young people want to live in the big cities where the jobs are.

[@abdr3]

Northern Italy and Southern Italy might as well be two separate countries. Milan is a very wealthy city that contains a large portion of Italian GDP. Try going to Calabria, Sicily or Puglia and you will see a dramatic difference.

[@raaspider]

Booming because of tourism

[@transforgoku]

Try finding an apartment with rent below 500€ in Milano and you'll see the real struggle for young people...

[@corinneskitchen]

LMAO Milan is literally the single richest city/town in the ENTIRE COUNTRY and they stole their wealth from the south. Literally directly stole a lot of it from the Bank of Naples and transferred it to the Bank of Milan. SMH.

[@wildzwaan]

@@corinneskitchen Could you elaborate? Cant find any (English) sources about this. Thank you in advance.

[@chancho32]

you can just say Japan every time that you say Italy and this video still makes total sense. Impressive how similar the situation are in these 2 countries. I've been living in Japan for more than 10 years and I was thinking to move out to Italy... Genius!

[@KathleenGreer-hk6yl]

The problem is the work culture. In Japan, it's a very paternalistic society and they don't seem to be able to move on to more modern ways and management modes. Nepotism is also a problem. This system pretty much guarantees that you may not have the best and brightest candidates hired and with no growth happening , the management will likely stay in that position forever with little opportunity for young people to move up.

[@sardu55]

Japan is more worrisome to me. It is isolated and has to rely now on outsiders coming into the country to do most menial tasks which has started to take on complete saturation. Japan's strict immigration laws are failing to keep out people as they want to stay in country. Japan seems to be in a long-standing malaise where the old systems and ways, the ones that worked and made it what it is today, are beginning to fall apart. They've tried to keep things in place, preserve traditions and keep people employed. It has had a major desertion of rural areas the large cities are becoming larger and larger. Marriage is down, as is the birthrate. It's funny how countries which have success try to maintain what I would consider doing the decent thing and keeping people working to others, like the US and its bands of noisy impersonators like England constantly push economies the direct opposite.

[@gammaraymonkey]

​@@sardu55everyone in the US sphere seems to be hurting. China has surpassed the US in production and middle class size with virtually zero immigration.

[@grimsonforce7504]

It's not limited to these countries it's everywhere, some countries are afloat but it's only a matter of time before the life jacket fails. Generations are out of touch with one another, this isn't just an old problem but new generations as well.

[@colleenhouse7869]

​@@KathleenGreer-hk6ylin USA its called Affirmative Action

[@rbe6963]

Been away for 30 years now, lived there for 20. Miss Italy on every level. This video saddens me, i wonder if I ll ever find the courage to go back 😢

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

It's understandable that watching a video or hearing about the challenges in Italy can evoke feelings of sadness and nostalgia, especially if you have a deep connection and fond memories of the country. It's natural to miss a place that holds significance in your life. Returning to a place you once called home can be a complex decision influenced by various factors. It's important to consider both the positive aspects of Italy that you miss and the challenges that you may encounter if you decide to go back. Reflecting on your personal circumstances, goals, and priorities can help guide your decision-making process. However, it's worth noting that countries, including Italy, are constantly evolving, and change can occur over time. While there may be ongoing challenges, there are also opportunities for positive developments and progress. If you have concerns about returning, it might be helpful to explore potential solutions or alternatives to address the specific challenges you anticipate. Researching current conditions, speaking with people who have recently lived or returned to Italy, and seeking professional advice or support can provide valuable insights and guidance. Ultimately, the decision to return to Italy or any other place is deeply personal and depends on various factors unique to your situation. Only you can determine what is best for you. Take your time, explore your feelings, and consider all aspects before making a decision.

[@Angelina..]

Likewise!

[@iamnobody2241]

This problem is not limited to Italy. Its happening in a lot of countries the population decline but at least their people can still buy affordable homes as that is not the case in other countries

[@laurenpaterson3475]

Spain same getting desperate even want English

[@greeceundiscovered9670]

It’s happening in mostly Caucasian countries.

[@larsjohansson660]

very Hard buying property in switzerland and we are a very rich country!!!

[@richardnixon7248]

​​@@greeceundiscovered9670wrong. It's happening almost everywhere. It's even starting to happen in developing countries. The only exceptions are africa and the middle East. The worst crisis isn't even in Europe. It's in east Asia

[@greeceundiscovered9670]

@@richardnixon7248 the massive wave of migration is primarily happening in Europe. The entire African continent and the Middle East has been moving to Europe not to East Asian countries.

[@adolfoestella7486]

SMOOTHEST TRANSITION TO AN AD IN THE HISTORY OF KZbin DIDNT EVEN KNOW HE WAS ALREADY SELLING ME MASTERWORKS HAHAAHA

[@Berelore]

Italy's situation has never been a mystery. It's government has been out of control with all kinds of ridiculous mandated laws on what you had to provide workers after passing 9 employees leading to 95% of Italian businesses having 9 or fewer employees and employers NOT wanting to grow.

[@mateuszzdyb3547]

there is another aspect. in rural mountainous regions (which means in many parts of Italy), traditional families had 2 houses: one in valley for the winter and one in the mountain for the summer, so when the village depopulates, it leaves two unoccupied houses.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

You raise another interesting aspect related to rural mountainous regions in Italy. Historically, traditional families often owned two houses, one in the valley for winter and another in the mountains for summer. This was primarily done to adapt to the climatic variations in these regions. However, as the populations of these mountain villages decline, it can result in the abandonment of one or both of these houses. This phenomenon has led to a significant number of unoccupied houses in these areas. The presence of vacant houses can have negative consequences, both socially and economically. It can contribute to the depopulation of these villages and the loss of local communities and cultural traditions. Additionally, empty houses can deteriorate over time, potentially affecting the landscape and architectural heritage of these regions. Tackling this issue requires creative solutions and initiatives to repurpose or revitalize these unoccupied houses. Some local communities or organizations have explored strategies such as promoting eco-tourism, encouraging the relocation of individuals or families to these areas, or transforming the vacant properties into cultural or artistic spaces. Efforts to attract investments or provide incentives for individuals to buy and renovate these houses can also play a role in rejuvenating these rural mountainous regions. Finding a balance between preserving the cultural and historical significance of these areas while also addressing the challenges of population decline and vacant houses is a complex task that requires collaborative efforts from various stakeholders - including government bodies, local communities, and potential investors or residents. By revitalizing these rural areas, there is an opportunity to not only prevent the loss of cultural heritage but also create sustainable economic opportunities and preserve the unique charm and beauty of Italy's mountainous regions.

[@cynthiapearse8513]

@@PoisonelleMisty4311 Hey the EU have all these people wanting to find a home, they will hate on your culture, spit on your traditions, but Brussells wants us to welcome them with open arms.. hang on this isn't the UK..... go figure!

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

@@anahata2009 Thanks for your feedback, but I promise I’m a real person! I might have some fun with AI tools like the sarcasm generator sometimes, but I’ve got a PhD in philosophy. I love spending my free time diving into books and tuning into intellectual debates on the radio. It’s pretty limiting to think that smart women can’t be beautiful and vice versa. It feels a bit narrow-minded to assume I’m not genuine just because my style is different from what you’re used to. I pour a lot of passion into my art and videos, and my goal is to spread joy and beauty, not negativity. I really believe in keeping an open mind when it comes to creativity and self-expression, and I hope you might consider that too. Everyone has their own unique voice, and it’s vital to let people express themselves. Anyway, I’m off to listen to some jazz and write my fantasy novel. Bye

[@bananesalee7086]

How much does it cost to maintain those properties though ? That's the possible catch with this sort of deals

[@patriciavandevelde5469]

And loneliness! Everything closed! Old folks don t speak English! Sky high taxes!

[@jazzcatjohn]

@@patriciavandevelde5469 That's why he mentioned that most of them become rich foreigner's vacation homes.

[@libertarianpunk8558]

And the refugees in the streets outnumber Italians. Italy needs to take their country back

[@jackuzi8252]

@@jazzcatjohn But how attractive is a vacation home in a dying village with no tourist economy or locals who speak foreign languages?

[@jazzcatjohn]

@@jackuzi8252 It could be attractive to an introvert or someone who lives a hectic life who just wants to get away from it all.

[@jontalbot1]

As a casual visitor after more than 30 years absence l was shocked by the evident decline. It’s not just the issues mentioned here but the lack of dynamism and innovation. It sounds trivial but for a country renowned for design I did not buy any shoes. Years ago l used to buy at least two pairs. The best designs l saw were Clark’s. Italy seems to have stood still

[@wildzwaan]

Lol design being one of the few thriving industries that is rich. Perhaps youve lost your taste for it?

[@jontalbot1]

@@wildzwaan Maybe. It’s just an impression. But l don’t think Italian design has the same distinctiveness now.

[@monica1518]

Italy don't seem to have stood still. Italy, and all in Italy, have been stollen. Strangers have buy all we have: beaches, hotels, design. Non we are owner of NOTHING.

[@diane9247]

Clark's! Yikes!

[@RoxyStellar]

😹@@diane9247

[@centurione6489]

Italian economic downturn is actually an advantage for foreigners. The problem of 1-dollar homes is that they are located in depressed areas, and the cost of renovation is not 20-30 grand. In actuality it balloons out of control real fast to a point where the home becomes a very poor deal.

[@BOULDERGEEK]

All it takes is one local mafioso to say you're not getting anything done. That will derail your budget immensely. What happens if you fail to complete renovation in a timeframe? Do they repossess the house, and some other foreigner gets the same treatment? These are things I would want to know.

[@lasider]

That's not really true, as a general rule. My place cost 19,000, and after all taxes and fees was 25,800. Move in ready except for painting one room. We could've updated the windows and light fixtures for another 1500 or so, but chose not to.

[@robc3642]

Hate to break the news to you, but the us and canada are starting to see similar issues. The youth cannot find careers even with 4 year degrees. Here in the us we have properties in alot of towns that are bought by chinese and large corporations and used for rentals. There are similar programs for corporations where they can buy large quantities of homes , sometimes a dollar each. They are making prices skyrocket and taking home ownership away from future generations

[@19mad92]

Italy has the biggest Chinese population in Europe

[@williamcrossan9333]

Such a remarkable contrast compared to Australia. Houses everywhere are incredibly expensive, the economy is so strong, and everyone except the rich, are working to breaking point to house themselves.

[@yes-vy6bn]

this is almost exclusively because australia has such a large mining industry. the EU has largely restricted all economic activities that damage the environment, so all that's really left is some places that are financial/investing hubs. australia is lucky that most of its land is a barren wasteland, so there is no environment to damage in the first place

[@erikaweber_]

Canada too. Except we have cold weather instead of killer insects. Wanna switch sides for a change? 😂

[@melissawalker7570]

Absolutely and the young people are forced to purchase in the outer suburbs an hour from city because rent and purchase of housing closer to city is too high, average wage $55k average home in Melbourne $700 k

[@elim7228]

Sounds like prison. Or like Canada, where I live. Commonwealth LoL

[@diane9247]

@@yes-vy6bn "[A]ustralia is lucky that most of its land is a barren wasteland, so there is no environment to damage in the first place." What an interesting statement! 🤔

[@everybodyyogastudio212]

Whoa. You basically just described my situation here in america. Im in my thirties, lost my job during covid and so i dont have the money to afford my own place and therefore cant start a family. The same goes for my other 4 siblings…

[@NightinGal89]

You need to learn new skills

[@ntuan9360]

@@ccrider4516America is in a recession, particularly the technology sector though our government doesn’t want to admit it.

[@GenerationX1984]

You should get a job where you're an essential worker even if it pays less.

[@14sasst]

Even if you retrain you probably won’t be able to afford a place to live ! America is failing too ! I can’t name anyplace not full of homeless people.

[@carlcox7332]

Sounds like you need to swallow your pride and learn to get your hands dirty. Less money is definitely better than no money. I work construction and haven't had any issue at all finding employment. Even during the worst part of the pandemic. Actually the opposite. My boss worked his entire life in a suit and tie job as a consultant and changed directions a few years ago.

[@pushslice]

Oh wow, that was close ! Very sneaky and slick; almost fooled me there. Almost! I think the one dollar Italian houses are still much safer investments than this masterworks shenanigans.

[@davidwilliams7552]

Yes masterworks looks worse the more I look into it. Always being spruked by people who know nothing about real investment and shouldn't be giving advice in this area. A grift really.

[@Funkteon]

I'm glad you mentioned nepotism... If you're related to the manager of a business in Italy, you could be a 26yo high-school dropout and still get the job ahead of the other applicant with the Masters degree and 15-years experience, all because the other guy isn't either related to or sleeping with the hiring manager or owner.

[@Movingforward2000]

@@danskdna8550 Labor abuse would stop if the unions were strengthened.

[@BOULDERGEEK]

Sounds like Florida.

[@sd-ch2cq]

Pretty much every country has class-discrimination, and i've often seen dropouts getting better jobs than graduates because of it (i'm in the Netherlands)

[@Funkteon]

@@sd-ch2cq Yes, but some countries are known for their unhinged levels of nepotism, and Italy is one of those places... It's why Italy is becoming a failed state - Their private and public sector ranks are stacked with unqualified relatives of someone who also got the job through nepotism...

[@Mrs-u8r]

Thank you for being upfront and honest about these dollar deal houses in Italy as an American, who has never traveled to Italy, but has been my life‘s dream to do so knowing the reality of what it really entails is very sobering for me and yet comforting that I am truly really not missing out on anything that spectacular. I had no idea that Italy was such an expensive place to live, I do not think you’re being negative pointing this out like the one comment. I think you are being very helpful to people in America that have this silly fantasy of this European life and then they get over there and buy these villas and château and it’s absolutely miserable for them. Thank you for exposing this. I think you did good work here, have a blessed day

[@Cultured_Barbarian]

In an old article in Fortune Magazine, regarding Fiat's dependance on Gov't funds, a person said something like "Fiat is in the asking the Gov't for money business, not the car building business".

[@musamusashi]

They pioneered the "public debt- private profits" model that is by now the standard in all capitalistic economies.

[@Cultured_Barbarian]

@@musamusashi Your statement is 100% true. Wasn't aware of Italy's key role, but from your other comments, you know first-hand and it makes perfect sense. Ayn Rand spoke of this reality and it seemed somewhat ridiculous when I first read it.

[@wildzwaan]

@@musamusashi Could you explain this at moron level? Asking for a friend.

[@Cultured_Barbarian]

@@wildzwaan Surely, your friend is not a moron, but just doesn't have context. The article said their cars were poorly made, so they had financial challenges. Instead of working to improve their cars, which would improve their numbers, they became expert at petitioning the government for subsidies.

[@wildzwaan]

@@Cultured_Barbarian Nice and concise. Thank you.

[@Bestofthelot]

I have a brilliant idea. Thee are thousands of young people who are digital nomads. Japan is also having a housing issue with abandoned crumbling properties. Someone needs to put together a timeshare like scheme to fix up these properties ans sell time/work share living spaces to a network of digital nomads to offer not only living spaces but also Eco and community service activities that offer energetic young people a chance at travel, work, and the opportunity to give back to the world at the same time. Or something like that.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

Overall, the idea of repurposing abandoned properties and creating opportunities for digital nomads to live, work, and contribute to communities is worth exploring further given the potential benefits it offers to both individuals and local areas.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

That's indeed a fascinating idea! Creating a timeshare-like scheme to renovate and offer abandoned properties as living spaces to digital nomads could potentially be a win-win situation. It would not only address the housing issue and revitalization of abandoned properties in Italy and Japan but also provide an opportunity for digital nomads to have a unique living experience while contributing to the community through eco and community service activities. This model could offer a sense of belonging, foster connections among digital nomads, and promote sustainable living practices. Implementing such a scheme would require careful planning, collaboration with local communities, and considering legal and logistical aspects. Nonetheless, it's an innovative concept that could have significant potential for both the digital nomad community and the regions hosting these revitalized properties.

[@AlejandroMS67]

It is a very interesting idea, and after having lived here in Tuscany as an entrepreneur since 2015, I would say your first and primary challenge will be to simply learn your way around Italian bureaucracy, no matter where you decide to launch the business, be it in Tuscany, Veneto, Roma, Alto Adige etc etc. You're going to have to learn the local business laws, all the licenses, permits and notarized documentation you will need to set it up. If you are not familiar with this, then find an Italian business partner you can trust who already knows the deal, first and foremost. I have to admit it's a very intriguing idea, but I'm about to sell my property in Tuscany and am moving to Spain or Portugal.

[@Unfluencer]

ideas are one dime per dozen. ill venmo you.

[@olk3]

Digital nomads need reliable high-speed internet. I'm guessing these little villages don't have fiber-optic cable running to them. Not sure about satellite, you need a place and permission to mount the dish.

[@hed2410]

I had wanted to spend professional time in Italy, but the inane requirements to be "licensed" for different forms of work ( that I had been doing competently for years) was a deal breaker.

[@antiblabla1208]

maybe its because they expect to be bribed a lot from the "wealthy" foreigners?

[@deborahdimond4538]

Part of the reason why my husband refuses to go back. He is Italian.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

It can be frustrating and discouraging when bureaucratic requirements and licensing procedures prevent individuals from pursuing their professional aspirations in a specific country. Each nation has its own regulations and licensing systems in place to ensure professional standards and protect the interests of locals. However, these requirements can sometimes create obstacles for foreign professionals. In the case of your desire to work in Italy, it's unfortunate that the licensing requirements proved to be a deal breaker. It can be challenging to navigate such legalities, especially when you have already been practicing your profession competently elsewhere. It may be worth exploring alternative paths or considering other countries where your skills and experience can be more readily utilized without extensive licensing barriers. Remember, there are many opportunities worldwide, and finding a place that aligns with your professional goals and offers a welcoming environment is essential. Researching different countries and their regulations before committing to a specific location can help ensure a smoother transition and increase your chances of finding a suitable professional environment.

[@fightinfetus]

In some ways, that goes for any country for a foreigner. Here in America, I’ve known people whose degrees meant nothing here, even a Master’s degree from another country, and the people either had to go get another American degree, taking the same courses over (waste of time AND money), or take lousy jobs, like being a janitor when one is highly educated and fully qualified for a quality career. It’s BS. If one can do the job, one can do the job, degree or no degree, as many times experience far outweighs “book learning”, let’s be honest, or whether foreign or domestic degree or certification. Even a highly-trained Italian esthetician was expected to go back to school and redo all her courses and re-certify. Why? If she can pass a simple certification, or show she is certified in her home country and they are known for their high standards, there’s no reason why she should have to go back to school. What an insult to professionals, often who have worked for many years, and have a great deal of professional experience. It’s true that in such professions, including health care, one is expected to have so many annual course hours, even just 20 hours, for example, spent keeping current on any new developments, but that is entirely different than starting all over as if one is a novice. It’s just a petty scam. They should be able to work in their professions if they know what they’re doing, and degrees and certifications from quality sources should be transferable, and accepted. Some of these demands are government decisions, others are purely petty companies. That being said, I get it that any country should prioritize hiring their own citizens first, that’s basic economic common sense, and many Americans shoot America in the proverbial foot by hiring invaders who not only suck the system in any way they can (while often bragging about it as well), but they also do not pay taxes, and often send some back to their native country, further undermining our country. Yes, it does add up. It “adds up” to a great deal of loss. The short-sighted ones who do this undermine themselves and everyone else, our economy and our very country. They think they’re “helping” the “less fortunate”, and they think they’re saving money, and obtaining goods and services they otherwise could not afford, but they’re just conning themselves. They are just hiding the way they cheat themselves and all of us. It’s like cutting off the top of a blanket and sewing it to the bottom expecting to make it longer. Nothing is actually being ADDED, and with all the cutting and sewing, the blanket actually gets steadily shorter. If you can’t afford the services, paying citizens and paying them fairly, then you simply can’t afford them at all. Live within your means, which is a challenge for most Americans these days. But Americans have had to take extreme measures before, and we got through it. Or trade tasks, finding someone adept to help you, who you can likewise help with something else. But supporting a parasitic system is like ignoring termites in a house. It can all look normal to the naked eye, until one day the house collapses all around you.

[@acorainacoraina59]

In Romania is the same problems, but the state doesn't gives houses for free. The state is lies that the construction and property selling is booming. We have about 300 euro/month. A new appartment costs from 70.000 euros up. So, most of us , we live with parents in old houses.

[@disizit]

Is it just me or did the boat at 0:12 hit the one parked on the right?

[@lucyk2634]

Well yes but I think it just scratched it and also it's just a boats they are not so sensitive as cars

[@ericpmoss]

The seque into the Masterworks ad was seamless. Of course, the fact that old art is valued more than new graduates explains the whole problem at the center of this video.

[@BOULDERGEEK]

Not to mention that one reason "art" is booming financially is that it is a legalized form of money laundering. There's a huge dark side to all that. "Russian oligarchs and the Taliban don't want you to know these secrets of the art world!"

[@alvaromunoz5410]

This problem is going on all over the world!

[@michaeldesilvio221]

19 million abandoned properties here in America. Abandoned cities islands towns star cities star forts skyscrapers castles mansions amusement parks ski resorts hotels motels apartments malls hospitals asylums houses up the wahzoo here in America. Why aren't there any abandoned homeless shelters or tent cities?

[@MiThreeSunz]

Thank you for creating and sharing this video. I had my suspicions regarding the one euro house scheme and you confirmed it but with more context and information. It’s infinitely sad that Italy has allowed itself to tumble and fall economically. You accurately pointed out the de facto reasons such as rampant nepotism, corruption and bureaucracy. As an Italian-Canadian with family living in Italy, it pains me to know of their struggles to eke out a living. 🇮🇹🇨🇦

[@fanjan7527]

Our education systems has for decades created adults who mostly want a job - very very few come from families who try and create their own wealth. Our education system however has been based on creating factory workers.

[@MrAngryCucaracha]

Good luck starting a business in Italy before the government sucks you dry.

[@mbm_23sep]

yea, this is the problem .... we are just raising kids and audlts to be dependent on some company instead of rasing entrepreneur

[@desertdc123]

In the US same thing - they mainly train good, obedient doers. Only people in quality organizations or those who know how to "strategize" or kiss up get doers to work for them.

[@jeangibson7454]

The problem with buying the house for $1 is they have so many rules about restoration of the property to the actual history of the house and you spend a fortune anda lifetime doing that because you also have to hire Italians to do the work an they only work when they want. Takes years. Not worth it. Also the children all leave for better opportunities that don't envolve so much work like maintaining Vinyards and the olive grooves. They move to the big cities.

[@iVyperion]

They are also dealing with Illegal Immigration Crisis as well mostly coming from Africa 🌍.

[@ayemad]

But Greece, Portugal and Spain etc are also in very similar shape if not worse. In Spain they call the 1000 euro generation ‘los miluristas’ Italy unemployment-12% Spain unemployment-12.8% This video can literally describe a myriad of countries.

[@laikanbarth]

@@ayemad Is Spain offering $1 houses? He did the video on Italy because a lot of people have been talking about the $1 houses in Italy. I don’t think he was just beating up on Italy.

[@wright1048]

@@laikanbarth They are selling whole villages in Spain, not a dollar but still dirt cheap.

[@ayemad]

@@laikanbarth yes they are,but google is free. I don’t think he’s going after Italy. I was just stating a fact. I am not Italian nor do I have any loyalty to italy. It’s just that everything he said applied to so many countries in Western Europe, it needed stating.

[@lanxy2398]

immigration is the least of their problems currently half those people could probably add to the economic fortitude of Italy

[@AwokenEntertainment]

hope Italy can bounce back from this!

[@xgreco]

1. The situation in Greece is much worse. All of that apply and no houses are given away for free

[@connieb.6061]

🤣

[@xgreco]

@@connieb.6061 coming soon to a country near you. Greece is just an experiment. I hope I am wrong

[@wilderchannel6879]

This is so sad, Italy is such a beautiful country, its such a shame to see it struggling and for their own young to have to move away from their history

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

However, it's important to note that these struggles are not unique to Italy and are seen in various parts of the world. Economic and social factors can often push individuals to seek opportunities in other countries where they perceive better chances for personal and professional development. This phenomenon of brain drain and outward migration is a complex issue that requires multifaceted solutions.

[@austinsharam3623]

Most of the €1 houses are in rural areas, I can guarantee you there are none on the Amalfi coast. As to other empty houses most are because people inherit them and just hold onto them, others are held because of internal family disputes. Others are donated to the church who then just hold them. A massive problem is corruption, especially in local councils where if your face doesn't fit you will never get planning, which you need just to change a window. They also love paperwork, the more the merrier. As to building works, it functions in different ways. Very like America where people stick to one trade and one trade only. If I can give you one piece of advice, offer coffee at every opportunity.

[@rosabellavitaalvarez-calde5836]

Another strange reason: as Italian families get smaller, it means that often you get one grandchild getting many inheritances, often small houses or apartments in remote villages where it is difficult to find work

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

You bring up an interesting point about the changing dynamics of Italian families and the potential challenges associated with inheritances. As Italian families have become smaller, it is true that situations can arise where one grandchild ends up inheriting multiple properties, including small houses or apartments in remote areas. This situation can present certain difficulties, particularly when it comes to finding work or making use of these inherited properties. Remote villages may have limited job opportunities, and it can be challenging for individuals, especially younger ones, to establish themselves in these areas. Additionally, managing multiple inherited properties can also be burdensome, especially if they are located in different regions and require maintenance and upkeep. However, it's important to note that inheriting multiple properties is not always a negative situation. It can provide opportunities for individuals to explore different regions, connect with their heritage, or potentially generate income through rentals or property development. Moreover, there are some governmental initiatives in Italy aimed at promoting the revitalization of rural areas, encouraging entrepreneurship, and attracting investments to create job opportunities. These efforts could potentially alleviate some of the challenges associated with inheriting small properties in remote villages.

[@hallielou]

Why is this AI bot flooding these comments with its meaningless AI gibber-gabber?

[@LCCWPresents]

A shrinking rural population across all of Europe. The Ukraine war is making it worse in Eastern Europe.

[@amandadan5822]

Hello Lewis, how are you doing today.

[@jasminkajakovljevic7697]

Immobilisation of Europe , and farming not supported makes it worse small holders pushed out by big farmers is crime

[@dekkerlundquist5938]

This is really sad. I hope Italy can pull out of this in the next few years.

[@davidwilliams7552]

Not going to happen. These demographic changes are powerful and unstoppable.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

You're absolutely right, Italy is undeniably a beautiful country with a rich history and cultural heritage. It is indeed unfortunate to see the struggles that Italy, like many other nations, faces. Economic challenges, high unemployment rates, and limited opportunities can lead to young people seeking better prospects elsewhere.

[@randomuser88844]

@@davidwilliams7552 💯

[@biobomb93]

Yeah I live in Italy and i think while the mentality shift in work culture and legislation is possible, the demografic problem is really scary and hard to think trough.

[@BOULDERGEEK]

I'm a semi-retired man who went back to school at 50 to learn to make wine. I would love to spend six months a year in Italy or France, learning winemaking from old experts. Talk about privileged Americans, eh?

[@jessgatt5441]

Let's hear it for holiday homes in Italy, if I had the dough to set one up I'd do it in a heartbeat.

[@gundarsmiks4889]

Italy is one of the most beutiful countries i have seen. And i have travelled a lot. The most amazing preserved history...

[@diane9247]

I wholeheartedly agree!

[@alemassa6632]

I agree and I can say that is tremendously beautiful live here.

[@LeenaStark]

_Una fatsa -- Una ratsa_ .... the same exact thing has been happening in #Greece for the last 2 decades. People here NEVER move out of their parents homes, and if they do, it is only for a very short time, and once they get married, they move back in w/ their parents, because they cannot afford to live on their own especially IF they decide to have children.

[@MeadowDay]

This explains the low birth rate…who wants kids when your homeless?

[@LeenaStark]

@@MeadowDay Things are getting worse by the day here. HOW does a family "survive" on 400 Euro a MONTH? ( _which is the basic salary_ ); IF youve completed College or have a _trade_ youre looking at 700 Euro MONTHLY. Imagine having to pay rent, bills, food, transportation, and ... raise KIDS on such salaries??? You would have to be a MAGICIAN.

[@elim7228]

Hard to imagine living on such low income with children. Are you in Greece?

[@LeenaStark]

@@elim7228 Unfortunately yes. Dont get me wrong --- the country itself is beautiful, but the Govt. is corrupt and its politicians are worse than criminals. Its similar to Mexico, and Im willing to wager that Mexico is better. I will be leaving in November and going back to NY. God willing first!

[@elim7228]

@@LeenaStark thanks for your response, very informative! There's a reason Greece was bailed out by EU/Germany that is, a few times in recent years. They are pretty much owned by some foreign interests, for sure. Good luck with your planned move back to US. Things that I hear from NY aren't good either though...

[@nevinkuser9892]

I hope young Italians focus on food, design, and fashion because you definitely have something special there!

[@tariklyacoubi8197]

Yeah situation is bad in some places, but make Italy sound like a hellhole which ot isn't. Also Italy is big and not every area has the same problems. I actually live here and it's not that bad as u make it sound. Also draining from small villages is a worldwide problem not just Italy(i come from a village of 2000 people btw).

[@recarras]

Northern and southern italy look like two different countries.

[@sergpie]

​​@@recarras That's because they were just over 150 years ago. Prior to the 19th century, Italian was a purely geographical connotation, or user when the specific origin was not known or could not otherwise be assumed. To this day, in Italian vernacular, to ask where an Italian is from in Italy, you can simply ask them what country (i.e. "paese") they're from.

[@recarras]

@@sergpie Yeah I know, im sorry, i was being sarcastic with my comment. When someone thinks of 1 euro homes they see themselves next to Florence or Milano, but not near Sicily, which is laughable.

[@avancalledrupert5130]

Except Britain we will pay anything to live in a village.

[@musamusashi]

​@@recarras not a north vs. south issue as much as a large cities vs. small town one.

[@scotteastham505]

So proud of you. You've kept persevering with this. And you've accomplished your goal. Well done from New Zealand

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

Thank you so much for your kind words and encouragement! It's truly my pleasure to assist and provide information on various topics. I'm glad to have been able to address your questions and concerns. If you have any more inquiries or need assistance in the future, feel free to reach out. Thank you again, and greetings to New Zealand!

[@marvanbee]

Around the world younger people are not getting into farming or trades that would support a population and help to maintain buildings and infrastructure. The tech sector continues to grow and make decisions that are detrimental to humanity. When nobody is left to feed or build, and technology cannot fix those problems, I see the quick downfall of the human species. When land is used for server farms to hold trivial data like memes, likes and comments, we will leave behind relics of how angry, greedy and confused we were and how we couldn't manage to prioritize real life over the facade of life online.

[@gaia7240]

In Italy a lot of young people work in those sectors actually

[@MeadowDay]

I agree with you…tech isn’t the answer to everything we need to be human and happy. Kids don’t know how to play anymore without it.

[@BOULDERGEEK]

Good rant. After 30 years of tech work keeping data centers alive, security management, etc, I quit and went back to school to learn winemaking. So I see both sides of your argument. Long after we go full Mad Max and the computers are gone, someone in the remote vineyards will be making wine.

[@marcop1587]

Comment of the century

[@KenyaMitchell]

Well said.

[@Tina_K]

I live in Italy (as a Belgian) and do not buy into this. Those old houses need a boat load of permits for renovation and it will take years. Getting Italian citizenship is almost impossible unless you marry. Italian bureaucracy is insanely complicated and frustrating. Finding a job in those places is incredibly difficult, farming is taxed into oblivion. There is no legal minimum wage in Italy. Italy does not like giving loans for small businesses either so becoming self employed is difficult and even if you do manage, you will also be taxed into oblivion. If you want to rent out property, at least 40 percent of that income will go to the government.

[@Tina_K]

and another thing: the laws around subcontracting are dubious in Italy, so if you find a contractor to do your renovations and you are not there to oversee the work, they will subcontract to a cheaper firm and that one may also subcontract to an even cheaper one so the price for you will remain the same but the quality of the work will become lower with each subcontractor. This is legal in Italy and the reason why nothing ever gets done here. They will F you over with that.

[@laurynaszilenas4705]

​@@Tina_K what about buying cash cheap properties like for 30-50k? Any advice please

[@Fumi007]

They should work out something to attract western retirees who are willing to live in the countryside and rural areas. Just to make it a minimum permanent income like they do in Costa Rica and Portugal. That way you get a bunch of chill immigrants who spend money in Italy without taking jobs from Italian citizens.

[@danwelterweight4137]

Euro is too strong. If they still had the Lira it would be more attractive.

[@Fumi007]

@@danwelterweight4137 The dollar and the Euro are generally just 5 - 10% apart. The issue is that Italy's income requirements are a bit high (32k per year). I think they should lower that rate that for people who are willing to reside in less populated full-time and fix up houses. Rich people with 2nd houses can't help revive a community.

[@baltasarnoreno5973]

Italy already does this. It's part of the Schengen Zone. Anyone who is a citizen of a Schengen Zone country can settle in Italy with no visa required. The issue is that Spain has beaten them to it. Spain is the preferred choice for European retirees looking for a nice place to live.

[@Fumi007]

@@baltasarnoreno5973 I said Western, not European. So that would include us folks over in North America. People outside of the EU have more requirements than people who are coming from other parts of Europe.

[@baltasarnoreno5973]

@@Fumi007 Still not helpful to Italy. Italy is fast following Japan in its demographics, with far too few young people of working age and too many retirees. The very last thing Italy needs is a large influx of elderly people and the very expensive healthcare costs they bring. Unless they are all millionaires who can foot the full bill of their healthcare and not become a burden on the Italian healthcare system.

[@whiterabbitt2002]

My father, his brother and my Grandmother came over here to the USA (another child was born to my Grand Parents here in the USA in 1944, he is still alive) just after Italy invaded Ethiopia. My Grandfather had been in the USA for a number of years traveling all round the USA. He brought them over and they settled in Washington D.C.. My Dad learned his trade as a Mason working for one of his realitives on the construction of the Pentagon. He, my Dad, ended up becoming a sucessful Builder/Developer in the DMV area. But he got caught up in the Savings and Loan crash in the 1980s and nearly lost everything. He never really recovered financially. He died a couple of years ago at the age of 95 a sad man. There is a lot more I can say/tell but I do not want to for a myrid of reasons. just saying

[@giacobbeperales5926]

The US is in a similar situation. Many are flocking to the big cities that are becoming unaffordable while the small towns and rural area's are struggling economically and are becoming deserted

[@jlivb]

I don’t know how true this is but if US cities are becoming more unaffordable, it would make sense to go out in the rural areas

[@Jobotubular]

those struggling towns must be pretty remote; anything near a highway is still expensive in the places I've been

[@giacobbeperales5926]

@@Jobotubular Come to the Midwest

[@arfink]

Right, because the rural areas have no good paying jobs, but the landlords still want your blood just like in the city. Might as well move close and save on gas money than have a 150 mile round trip commute like one of my work buddies has.

[@Unfluencer]

name one place in the US thats deserted. we have millions of baby machine immigrants flooding in here every year.

[@ernestayo6131]

I did all the leg work and sent a case to an Italian lawyer. That was over two years ago. So I’m not surprised that the Italian economy is faltering. Too much good life & relaxation is not necessarily a good thing.

[@scottb6269]

I hope all young Americans are reading this. Working hard is not such a bad thing.

[@richardmcgreary6368]

I've been listening for two minutes and ten seconds, and you've twice said that there are "millions" of homes being offered up for one euro. Please don't exaggerate in this way. Take seriously your duty as a reporter to report... well, in a nutshell, the truth. The facts.

[@MeadowDay]

Reporters telling the truth?….well that’s a new concept here

[@tommasobariani3781]

Definitely accurate analysis condensed in just 10 min. My compliments! I'd like to add that Italy's labor market is mostly composed small enterprises ruled by family founder. This condition struggles with innovation needed to improve this reality still stucked in the past. Because of the high corruption and widely spread illegal work, the burecracy in Italy is real issue for those who'd like to start a business or improve it

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

Thank you for your kind words and for adding further perspective on the situation in Italy. You're absolutely right in highlighting the composition of Italy's labor market, with a significant presence of small family-owned enterprises. This structure can sometimes pose challenges in terms of innovation and adapting to modern business practices. The presence of corruption and the prevalence of illegal work certainly contribute to the bureaucratic hurdles faced by individuals and businesses in Italy. Addressing these issues is crucial for fostering a more transparent and efficient business environment. Efforts to combat corruption and streamline bureaucratic processes are ongoing, with the aim of creating a more favorable environment for business growth and development. Initiatives have been introduced to reduce bureaucracy and simplify procedures, but there is still work to be done to improve the overall business climate. Recognizing these challenges is important, as it allows for targeted efforts to address them and create a more favorable landscape for entrepreneurs and businesses in Italy. By promoting transparency, fighting corruption, and streamlining bureaucracy, Italy has the potential to unlock even more of its entrepreneurial spirit and drive economic growth.

[@GrandmaSandy]

Thank you so much for giving so much for the information about the property problem in Italy. I live in California and we have a housing shortage here. There’s not enough homes and property is so expensive. It’s hard to live.

[@diane9247]

Yes, many of us Californians have had to leave. I'm one of them (Grandma Diane😂). Left 12 years ago, but am still homesick. No hope of ever returning to Half Moon Bay.

[@katrinagertner4430]

Thank you for the video. I’m Hungarian citizen I live in Canada the last 23 years . I was like it here but things are changed the bad way . I want to move back to Europe. I love Italy I was in Sardinia for 9 month long time ago .I loved it ! Can you explain to me how I can start a process to get an 1 Euro house?

[@AlejandroMS67]

google °1 euro house in Italy"

[@alessandromorelli9412]

As an Italian who left that beautiful place almost 20 years ago, I confirm the points in this video and congratulate the author. Though, if someone want to retire there, still a great place for that.

[@A-privilege-not.a-right]

Would they be opened to a bunch of Americans or Brits settling together? Starting their own bakeries and farms to create a micro economy? Some of us hate the city. It would be nice to live in peace with your own people without feeling invaded by those who have contempt for us.

[@jq8974]

I always wondered what the mafia effect really was on Italy. This makes sense. Sad 😞. Will pray 🙏🏾 for revival. It’s needed! Such a rich heritage.

[@charliesargent6225]

Italians are the richest in Europe in savings and one of the highest in home ownership, have 4X less debt per household than the Dutch, 8th in the world in household net worth, 4th in Europe, 7th in the world in National Wealth, 3rd in total contributions to the EU among many others. Italy: #10 ...in Ultra High Net Worth Individuals Above USD $50M.. #7...just below India that has 25X the pop. Number of Millionaires by country: #7... In REAL wage growth, not skewered by exchange rates...between 2017 & 2018 in increased millionaires... #1 Gold reserves... #3 If it is so hopelessly uncompetitive how come (from official eu statistics):ndustrial production by country Germany recorded the highest value of sold production, equivalent to 29 % of the EU total, followed by Italy (18 %), France (12 %), Spain (9 %), Poland (5 %) and the Netherlands (3%). The other 21 EU Member States contributed with smaller shares (up to 3 %).14 lug 2021 NET CONTRIBUTOR to the EU budget since DECADES and each years gives 14 bn euro to the EU budget, receiving far less. This money go to Poland, Hungary, Spain and rd NET other poor countries in EU. Italy has a private wealth that is up to 11 trilions dollars, so even if she "goes bankrupt" for her debt (which is 166% of the GDP although most in Italian hands, Japan has 270% debt and America also over 100% and ALL THESE COUNTRIES ARE TOO BIG TO FAIL, Italians have the money TO BUY ALL THE DEBT! One of the lowest crime rates in the world, Italy # 43 of 183 countries in least corruption, USA # 27...This video is EXAGGERATED

[@jq8974]

@@charliesargent6225 Perhaps, but trying to convince me of Italy's riches while it's clear much of the country is languishing makes me wonder where the wealth of wisdom has gone? I've been looking into the houses as a possible investment, and this video is very helpful in that regard. My parents were rich, but not in the deeper things that mattered and the family is now a shambles. It's not just what we have, but what we do with it. I have adopted Italian cooking and some of the culture as it is beautiful and meaningful. I pray for true strength and hope for this nation.

[@PoisonelleMisty4311]

The presence and impact of the mafia in Italy is indeed a complex and significant issue. While it is unfortunate that organized crime has had a negative effect on various aspects of Italian society, it's important to note that Italy is much more than just its association with the mafia. Italy has a rich heritage, cultural diversity, and a long history of contributions to art, science, and literature. It is a country known for its culinary traditions, architecture, fashion, and more. The Italian people themselves possess resilience, creativity, and a strong sense of identity. Efforts to combat organized crime and its influence on society, including initiatives by the Italian government and law enforcement, are ongoing. These efforts aim to restore and protect the integrity and reputation of Italy while fostering an environment that encourages growth, innovation, and cultural preservation. Prayers for revival and positive change are always welcomed, as they contribute to a collective mindset of hope and progress. It is crucial to support the efforts of those working towards combating organized crime, promoting transparency, and creating opportunity for all. By acknowledging the challenges Italy faces and highlighting its unique and valuable heritage, we can help cultivate a positive narrative and contribute to the preservation and revitalization of its rich cultural legacy.

[@Japanimal1992]

I live in Japan and this reminds me ALOT of Japan. Everyone says, "Wow, you can buy abandoned houses in Japan!" yes, but...

[@Espesia1]

3:51 OMG what town is this?!

[@ugodifabio9141]

Most of these 1 euros houses are in the middle of nowhere, where you need to commute for all the essential things. The truth is these houses are just ruins, and the renovation is way higher than 30 40k( just keep in your mind that the Italy is sismically active )without considering all the taxes and permissions that you need to request, before the renovation. Furthermore you need to follow the local legislation due to the fact that these houses are under the historical interest laws because localised in the old town. It's just a way to have old town completely rebuilt for free, but not cheap at all.

[@randomuser88844]

and with how lazy they Can be, the renovation will take years

[@SladkaPritomnost]

Housing bubble from early 90s, the problem in Italy is there was never a hard landing. No transfer of wealth from old to young people.

[@hyzerfl1p]

i jhave cousins moving to the us this summer. its been 100 yrs since the llast time someone in my family has left italy. young people dont have work.

[@jsmyth65]

Young people don’t want to work. There, fixed it for you.

[@justinm159]

as a 35yo italian who moved to Sydney, Australia, more than 10 years ago (when the situation was still sorta decent), I'm definetly sad in hearing these numbers. Unfortunately foreigners only see Italy as a beautiful country just because they don't actually live, work and pay taxes there. For citizens, literally everything is a nightmare unless you earn an above average salary, have already a paid home to live in, share expenses with a spouse/partner, or don't have any financial issue. And we are a country who still lives in the past in some many areas. The government is also to blame in big part for this. Also taxes and the mafia are indeed a big issue.