The Definitive Red Dead Redemption 2 Cut Content Iceberg - Part 1

[@McdizzleGaming]

Thanks so much for watching! Drop a like if you want to see more long videos from me like this!

[@theShadowstraggler]

More yes! But don't quit the quick info vid either 😊

[@theShadowstraggler]

...btw I think the thumbnails for your last 2 vids (this and the Max Payne one) looks really good. You should keep this style! Stands out and is easy recognizable. I think it looks best with your logo in the right corner, like on this one ...just my thoughts of course

[@justjosh8869]

Where's my info on gay cowboys 🥺☹️😢

[@tempsitch5632]

The fact that the map isn’t fully opened for Arthur is s tragedy.

[@Ianpravus]

Even the whole chapter 5 its a disaster. Unexplorable guarma its a shame, and this Is main history

[@Gonzas97]

Its called "win the game, get the rewards".

[@ProGamer-lk9qw]

@@Gonzas97 It’s called an “open world” game. Lmao

[@Gonzas97]

@@ProGamer-lk9qw a game that gets more open the more you play it, something rockstar has been making since their first gta game. You play it, you complete its goals, you get the rewards. Thats how videogames work. What a "pro gamer" you are, having no idea how games work, lmao

[@ProGamer-lk9qw]

@@Gonzas97 Damn bro didn’t have to duck me down like that😔

[@TheDigitalApple]

The sad truth is, with the amount of cut content such as the cut trinkets and visiting Guarma in the epilogue we could’ve easily gotten those as part of updates as shown with the Turtle Shell trinket which was originally cut but was added back into the game. However R*’s short sided greed made them abandon RDR and Online for GTA online.

[@party4lifedude]

You'd think they would want the game to have more longevity and replayablility, since people are going to be stuck with it for decades until they decide to make a new one. If they decide to make a new one at all.

[@ghost_killer97]

Man Sadly there's no dlc Content it really hurts rockstar game 💔

[@mr.eternal4439]

Rdr1 remake in the same game would be 🔥

[@SG-qx9ko]

They should do a director's cut, expand chapter 5, enhance the graphics and frame rate for current gen, fix the epilogue John and give him some exclusive stranger missions.

[@T_M___]

​@@SG-qx9kothere's so much more they could do with this game. sadly i think if we're ever going to get more rdr2 content it won't be until after GTA VI comes out

[@billross9132]

There's honestly alot of cut content that can be reintroduced, fixing John's model, finishing guarma, polishing new Austin, adding tempest rims, not to mention all the removed missions and characters

[@BNMS217]

@@T_M___your way more optimistic than me lol. Ive completely given up on rockstar adding anything new to rdr2. Sad bc its clearly the best base product they’ve ever released but sadly the higher ups probably didn’t project a big enough profit margin to justify the cost of producing new content for a game as massive and detailed as rdr2. They will milk gta 6 online for the next 10-15yrs. I think gta 6 will be so detailed that the dlcs will be similar in cost to and time to massive blockbuster movie productions. Thats gonna require a ton of man power. So unless they undergo a massive expansion or are willing to bring in a massive amount of independent devs on contract. i think they will have atleast a 10-15yr gap between gta 6 and any other title they are producing. I honestly think the RDR title is gonna end with rdr2. Makes no sense for them to spend a billion dollars developing another game when they’re gonna make that bi weekly with gta 6 online.

[@Ronuk1996]

This game needs a Directors cut Rockstar basically did it with bully and They did massive DLC for GTA4. i would love new side quests Random ecountsrs and even adding some of the RDR online content like Ecounters to the online.

[@IllsMan900]

I think they continued with DLC for online. I definitely wish they did undead nightmare

[@party4lifedude]

It's interesting that DiAngelo played the game before even creating the music. That's a pretty good way to understand the tone and atmosphere and context that the music will be played in, and really make it fit in.

[@ClaimedMinotaur]

Ngl, I feel like the main thing missing from this game is a proper doomed love story. We saw a snippet with Mary Linton, but imagine if they kept Eliza in the gang instead. She starts out much like Sadie in the beginning, inconsolable and morose after losing their son in Colter, eventually growing to hate Arthur and blaming him for his death. Over time as the Arthur goes through some shit and eventually gets sick, she sees him trying to be a better man and softens to him, never quite being able to love him again, but eventually forgives him towards the end and wishes things were different. They could even have a moment towards the end where they fantasize about buying some land and living out their days with their son. It's a relationship that would echo a lot of couples who split after the death of a child. They still love each other, but their happiness together is forever soured by their circumstances and they are never able to move past it. Feels like it would fit perfectly into this game.

[@joseywales1869]

Thank you, really enjoyed this….way better than the 50 things to buy, or 5 best repeaters, that some people continually churn out…….keep up the great work

[@McdizzleGaming]

Thanks Josey, appreciate you, i always like trying something new!

[@aaronswesternassault]

Yessss!!! Been waiting for this. Bring on part 2

[@McdizzleGaming]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@LouwrensEksteen]

I hardly comment at all, but there's one notable thing I noticed was one mission with Rains Fall just after Arthur's TB diagnosis. Rains Fall and Arthur rode around searching for herbs to help Arthur's disease. Interacting with Rains Fall there was an option to speak about Arthur's son. It was there where I first learned that Arthur had a son and they discussed the situation around losing your son, if I recall correctly.

[@McdizzleGaming]

Thanks for the comment! That was such a sad moment and glad they kept some memory his past life a bit in there!

[@2tallGamingMedia]

Big up McDizzle. I started playing RDR2 story again last week, what a game. A big update is coming for online soon, I can feel it. See you soon bro

[@MG-wm9kq]

Not having Mexico was a huge mistake

[@tonyedwards3938]

Agreed especially after RDR1.

[@charliekill88]

yes but I think Guarma was a huge disappointment aswell, its beautiful, but they really didn't to anything with it, I really would've loved to explore the sunny tropical island.

[@maksc3781]

They cut hope for RDO

[@DeadboyViaell]

If they kept Eliza I feel like Arthur's story would be totally different

[@TheRealRunningwolf1980]

The moment I realized IKZ and the Curse wasn’t able to be completed I knew I was looking at an incomplete game and it gutted me..this game is AMAZINGLY BEAUTIFUL and by FAR one of the best gaming experiences I’ve had since the 80’s,it stands among FF3,FF7,ShadowRun/snes&Genisis to name a few that have stuck with me,I gotta admit RDR2 is bittersweet though,to be this amazing and completely be dropped with no DLC like undead nightmare 2 is infuriating. Anyway just wanted to get that off my chest 🤷🏽

[@XOLEEF1]

Definitely keep going go into detail

[@McdizzleGaming]

thanks! i will!

[@philatio3535]

The longer the better. Thats what she said

[@lukebullen705]

Wish i never knew about this its so upsetting. I really wish R* do a remaster before RDR3 where they finish the cut content and add it into the story. Id be more than happy to pay for it again

[@xxe2]

Sorry but cockstar only cares for gta v online

[@Hondaj187AnimationFilmStudios]

0:01 6 years you mean because we’re in 2024

[@McdizzleGaming]

good catch! i am still stuck in 2023!

[@BNMS217]

🤓☝️

[@luke73tnt.]

20 minutes of McDizzle? Yippee!

[@blessedson6379]

TYVM for this masterpiece sir!

[@charliekill88]

27:19 what are you talking about? John Isnt dead during the events of rdr2? why would his ghost show up

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@charliekill88 i’ll have a relisten but the time stamp is longer then the video

[@LightOfReason7]

Good video, way to go man!

[@xSpicySaltx]

16:32 - i know im late, but this looks like a prototype for bully in general.

[@McdizzleGaming]

I can see that! It was from a GDC presentation on RDR2 - That said, many of the ideas from Bully 2 ended up in RDR2 - great video by SWEGTA interviewing a dev on Bully 2 if you haven't seen. kzbin.info/www/bejne/j6XQlZyKrpKGsM0

[@xSpicySaltx]

@@McdizzleGaming oh cool thank you

[@party4lifedude]

You know I can't think of any movies or games that even cover World War 1, usually it's all about the sequel lol. A game where we play Jack Marsden, and the first chapter is about World War 1, and then eventually the next chapter is during the age of Prohibition and we start to see the beginnings of real organized crime, and Jack decides to capitalize on that. And Jack witnesses the beginning of the industrial revolution and its consequences, and we see the world change rapidly with new technology and vehicles. That wouldn't just be a major departure from Red Dead, but from video games as a whole. And I think it's something that could be really interesting if done right. I know I'd be really interested in seeing something like that. I mean just imagine how much the world would change in Jack's time, it's not easy to imagine but it would be cool to "live" that in a video game.

[@moto3463]

So much cut content assume devs were pushed to hurry up and ditch a lot of potential.

[@E3742O]

I’d pay full price for this game again if they added cut content

[@Joe-pg3kg]

I think there are still things that need perfect circumstances and times to line up to discover like the peyote and Sasquatch in GTA5

[@kingartison]

I love that last image of Dutch he deserve it so so much

[@Unlikelihood]

How should the backwater prologue work when Arthur wasn’t part of it

[@McdizzleGaming]

Him and Hosea were in Blackwater, they just had their own thing going on which would be good to explore!

[@tempsitch5632]

DAngelo didn’t “contribute” or “release a song”. It’s a collaboration. Chek out rocco deluca.

[@melseltzer4478]

Awsome info! 😊👏 Didn’t know all this

[@McdizzleGaming]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@SomeClassyToast]

some of it is incorrect

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@SomeClassyToast It's an iceberg video, not science. People can come to their own conclusions after research.

[@SomeClassyToast]

@@McdizzleGaming why do they need to come to their own conclusions when the real answers actually exist

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@SomeClassyToast Do you work for Rockstar? The files only tell a bit of the story, not the entire development of the game. I've cited my sources, and it's discussed in context of theories and contextually where it's from. Can you disprove any of it?

[@xyfnthrn714]

He didn't even make a part 2

[@McdizzleGaming]

I plan on it!

[@ccchhhrrriiisss100]

I really hope that the young Arthur parts will be the epilogue for RDR3.

[@MODZGAMINGYT]

We need Mexico for storymode which would make sense for John obviously because of the events of RDR 1. And Guarma would make much more sense for Online. We could somehow work for Fussar or whoever and make regular trips to and from Guarma. R* could easily add this. I get it that GTA 6 is the priority but they have thousands of employees so there really is no excuse why these things can not happen...🤨

[@OutlawedPoet]

Those employees were also crunched to hell and back just to get RDR2 out, and apparently that's a major concern with GTA 6 right now as well.

[@MODZGAMINGYT]

@OutlawedPoet I don't doubt that but with thousands of employees there is still no excuse. It's a video game, not a mission to Mars. Shouldn't be that complicated. Its nothing more than coding. Lots of coding sure. But still just coding.

[@majora919]

those eliza voice lines sound like AI bro lmfao

[@McdizzleGaming]

I know right, but they aren't, def from the files.

[@majora919]

@@McdizzleGaming were the files in bits and you spliced them together or something?

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@majora919 yea the ones for her were like a few diff ones, maybe 3 diff lines

[@majora919]

@@McdizzleGaming that probably explains it then

[@DennisFrechette-et6gg]

The Free roaming gang would have been very cool

[@McdizzleGaming]

There was actually remnants of the system before it got patched out in 2018/2019! Would have been great!

[@KingSchenk-kx7fu]

You can go to tempest rim without mods😂 you just need to get to a specific spot and pass out being drunk

[@tomhagen7965]

Man I just wished they kept that romance idea. Imagine if Sadie and Arthur confessions were cut content? I glad you posted this. Keep it up!

[@McdizzleGaming]

Thanks! I am glad you enjoyed!

[@lorekeeper2611]

I do not understand why everyone wants to experience Blackwater… like we know basically everything we need to know just by playing the game. You don’t have to see every story beat.

[@McdizzleGaming]

i know for myself it’s mainly about the characters were heard about but never got to know. Dave’s, Jenny etc

[@SomeClassyToast]

there was never a blackwater camp, it always started in colter , there is no herbert moon cut content unless you mean his causal outfits which all other shop keeps have, you're wrong about new austin, yes he was able to go there but it was a freely explorable zone, no crimes commited, there's no evidence mexico was ever explorable, the landmass is there so it's consistent with the first game, the only other cut things about are lod models like el presidio meant to be seen from afar, there are NO bounties for mexico, the textures and models are only in the ps4 1.00 files and are for the LOD buildings like i mentioned before there was no evidence of breeding horses at all, there is cut fowls but these are very likely for ranches, there are no bicyles in the game or in beta, that image of arthur on the bike is a leftover from GTA V, there is no john ghost and that last relationship thing with charles is fake no offense but the video is bloated, has unrelated things in it and you didn't even go over things in very much detail, you missed so much stuff, not much of a definitive cut content iceberg

[@GoldenRDR2]

I believe my last comment got flagged for deletion, just wanted to bring up that while some parts are true, this video has a lot of misinformation and outdated stuff in it. I would check the RDR2 wiki's cut content page for a more up-to-date and accurate list, and I would advise the video creator to do more research into this stuff before spreading false information.

[@McdizzleGaming]

Hey I didn’t flag anything. it’s an iceberg video that has a combo of actual, theories and alleged info, and i did an amazing amount of research. I reviews the red dead wiki amount other sources and even the red dead wiki is wrong in some cases, tbh. I have data mined red dead myself for years and know the game, the theories the rumours. Sorry my hard work has upset you in discussing icebergy things! What part don’t you agree with?

[@GoldenRDR2]

​@@McdizzleGaming It's fine, I think to an extent I overreacted because of a few things but most glaringly I saw horse breeding was included, a point which I know for a fact has zero evidence to back it up besides a model skeleton and was either taken directly from or came from a subsidy of the absurd evil hair leak (and I know this because you mentioned the albino arabian) which has been absolutely 100% proven to be false yet gets spread around the internet avidly.

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@GoldenRDR2 The thing is though, there is no real way to 100% prove something false with video game dev, unless the dev said something themself. I think the Evil hair leak is wild, and I saw a note that it was proven false, but no evidence that I could see of it being false and he knew ALOT from it just coming out on console that was def true in the files , I believe that leak was before the PC release. Doesn't mean hes right but its enough to talk about. It's tough to call things blatantly false when we just don't know, the files has evidence of missing content, sure, but the absence of things within them doesn't mean anything. It's fun stuff to talk about either way

[@GoldenRDR2]

@@McdizzleGaming You are entitled to your opinion but if you can't look at it and see that it's clearly false and that 90% of the points have absolutely nothing to back them up in the files that speaks to the integrity of the video tbh, hopefully you can see that my call for criticism is at least somewhat warranted simply due to its inclusion, even if you don't necessarily agree with my stance on it.

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@GoldenRDR2 brother, i can’t tell you what to think but i am always down for good discussion about red dead.

[@AlanpittsS2b]

We need an undead nightmare for rdr2. Could you imagine??

[@McdizzleGaming]

That would be amazing!

[@jasonkesser]

Great video

[@McdizzleGaming]

thanks!!

[@johnsmith6497]

Herbeta?

[@weplo1597]

Beta epilogue John Marston shouldn't been cut now we have Arthur morgan hybrid

[@McdizzleGaming]

Scarthur Marston

[@weplo1597]

@@McdizzleGaming Arthur Marston invasion

[@frado9194]

Is this an ai voice over? His voice confuses my brain so much seriously. Very odd fluctuating in sentences, and pauses.

[@McdizzleGaming]

lol, no that’s me. Probably some audio editing issues. Sorry my voice is confusing! haha

[@frado9194]

@@McdizzleGaming dude no worries at all, thank you for confirming it’s you!!! Honestly if it was ai I’d kinda be upset, idk why. Thanks for being a human

[@McdizzleGaming]

@@frado9194 no worries man, it was a longer video for me, so probably recording it over a week or so led to some inconsistent audio conditions.

[@frado9194]

@@McdizzleGaming bro i don’t care if you record this in a shed, we need part 2!! I completely understand the conditions, especially when making a video that consumes your time. Have a good one man

[@adamir-magnumCZ]

Comment for algorhytm

[@AndrewPrevi]

Why you sound like AI? Edit: I figured it out, you’re just cutting the vid in between every single sentence lmao

[@McdizzleGaming]

i gotta get better at editing hahaha

[@Reddeadredemption3]

You sound like an AI narrator, why are you talking like that, like 90% sure it's AI

[@McdizzleGaming]

LOL thats wild. I dunno if it's the way I recorded it, but it's not AI, I have hundreds of videos and live streams with me..lol.

[@Reddeadredemption3]

@@McdizzleGaming hmmm 🤔 sounds like something an AI would say

[@theShadowstraggler]

Hey man! Great video! RDR2 still the greatest most detailed game after more than 5 years. R has set a standard the rest is struggling to follow Nice to see you with some longer and more detailed content, you should do this again every once. Lots of interesting stuff here I didn't even know about the horse breeding and companion stuff...or I maybe forgot. That would have been cool. Guess with all the details in this game, all the work and possibilities with having companions on stranger missions etc. would be too time consuming to make, if they wanted to do it justice. Woulda been neat with a blackwater prologue, don't think it would work story wise though. I think it would take a lot away from the spaghetti western intro in the snow. Could have worked as a stand alone story, kinda like "left behind" in TLOUpart1 maybe. But hell to take all my money...give me RDR1 in the RDR2 engine! Both games put together in one epic long story! Then Nuevo Paraiso would be a sure thing in online as well. I would give the R gods my life and soul!! Love & bless man! Great vid! Outlaw for life!🤠

[@McdizzleGaming]

Thanks man! glad you enjoyed!! So much wild stuff. I hope that if/when they do a next gen version they add some cut content in!

[@theShadowstraggler]

Cant wait to check this one out! Will do it later today as soon as Im home 🙂

[@McdizzleGaming]

thanks buddy! Enjoy!!