The Economic Disaster of Naya Pakistan [Urdu]

The cold hard facts of the economic performance of PTI in its first year of office. These are the official statistics from FBR and they paint an extremely bleak picture.
But this is not just a video about all that has gone wrong but also about what we need to do to fix things. xWhat we present is a complete transformation of economic policies to favour growth, equality, and poverty alleviation.

[@perpetualnadeem]

Dr Tamiur, this is the most comprehensive analysis of Pakistan's fragile economy. Excellent job!

[@drhamdaankhan3691]

Good job 👍 keep it up)))

[@waqarhabib3488]

Eye opening lectute مجھے پہلی مرتںہ پاکستان کے برے معاشی حالات کی اصل وجہ معلوم ہوئی ہے شکریہ تعمور صاحب

[@moeezehassan7825]

I just discovered you and have already spent a whole day watching your videos. You got a subscriber. Your videos have really given me a lot of perspective on my Marxist journey. Being a BS student, I am utterly dismayed about the lack of information we young students have got about politics and economics, especially about the left wing. I really wish we had more people like you, so we could have gotten a bit more sensible while voting our rulers, and wouldn't have seen this miserable day.

[@ArmageddonIsHere]

Marxism does not work. China just spent 70 years proving it. First 40 years proving it fails. Then next 30 by proving that its antithesis - capitalism - is what actually works. So, don't be Marxist. It DOES NOT WORK!

[@mohammedameen6824]

Pakistan has become a joke 😂😂

[@aqsamobeen4970]

Pure and valid talks of you Dr taimur 👍its reality of our Govt...

[@MM-yg2zj]

It's 2021, and the situation is as deplorable as 2019. IK has proved to be a stubborn leader. No policy regulation, no constructive incentives whatsoever.

[@mazhermirza6518]

and now 2022 ..wrost condiction .

[@amadakbar6006]

Absolutely impressed man. Most critical analysis and comprehensive commentary on Pakistan's economy.

[@divyasethi8499]

Listening to your words I recalled an old event. My father when he was in school, had a friend who went to visit his aunt in Karachi, upon his return he remarked "Pakistan is rich, their taxis are Cadillac". Now you have explained what those Caddies did to your economy.

[@SafariTales]

What year was it? Also, Cuba has Caddies... Depends how you see it. But one thing is clear. Any country that has an unstable, greed, immoral and frickle minded people in charge will have devastating consequences not only for themselves but also for innocent populace.

[@narendrakhilnani6578]

Well put.

[@learnkidsworld]

From now I will not support PTI blindly... Sir you open my eyes.. Great information thank u alot...

[@kashifgaad8923]

Thankyou for providing the latest statistics of economy of pakistan. Your work is comprehensible with justified analytical view. Keep it up and get us informed. 👍

[@razianaheed5791]

Excellent job sir... Itna tou koi dulhan apni rukhsti py nhi roti jitna pakistan ki dying economic situation py apky facts ny rula dia😂😂

[@mand121994]

Probably the only well educated Pakistani I have ever seen.

[@humanculturesareautonomous3020]

'Professor' Taimur Rahman has all the qualities -- glibness, suavity, etc. -- of an accomplished con man. He is a walking and talking answer to the FAQ: What do fraudsters look and sound like? Charlatans like Taimur Rahman puts me in mind of frauds like Mian Iftikharuddin (1907-1962). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mian_Iftikharuddin ------ Here's Pakistani-Swedish academic Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed on Pakistani 'Leftists' (such as con man Taimur Rahman). "It’s only some of the crackpot Leftists like us, who talk about that because we live in delusions; we have spent virtually our lives in delusions and this happens to be our grand delusion. "The Communist Party bragged a lot about its plans (for the new State of Pakistan), but the very first statement of Governor General Muhammad Ali Jinnah, on 17 August 1947, was that there was a fifth column in the country looking towards Moscow and “we have to take care of them”. "So Marxists have been under fire in Pakistan right from day one. It’s a place that has never seen even ordinary democracy; where is the question of freedom for communist ideas? "Pakistan was NEVER a democratic state - not even for a day. If at all Pakistan was a 'democracy,' it was a 'majoritarian democracy'. Don’t forget it was the elected government - not a dictator - that declared Ahmadis non-Muslim. (Dictator) Zia-ul-Haq only capitalized on that; he did not first do it." kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/10/muslims-are-never-grateful-to-those-who.html ------- Here's what Pakistanis actually did to academics with silly 'Leftist' ideas like Prof. Brij Narain (a widely published and acclaimed 'economist' from the Panjab University and an ardent supporter of the creation of Pakistan). kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/09/prof-brij-narain-quintessentially.html

[@akashpq]

Means pakistan has no educated person till then....

[@Justfahadlatif]

Probably the 7 hundredth Indian I have seen leaving the same comment under some Pakistani's video 🤣

[@digitalavatar5699]

Dude Imran khan is PHD holder

[@siddoopatil2450]

This type of discussion needed to educate the public

[@pranjalbiswas5023]

A highly comprehensive and detailed economic analysis. Very well explained and well educated speaker. Love from India.

[@MuhammadHaris-hy7vq]

U r a good professor...... I listen ur every lecture

[@bittertruth685]

Dr Temor is really very intelligent person

[@shivohamb5015]

1st time heard some sane & sagacious voice from Pakistan. Otherwise, its just high db "chunache chacha" balming others for all the mess :) ... May your tribe increase there. Good job Taimur bhai. Keep it up...!!!

[@alimavia7078]

main kbi be comment kr k appreciate nhi krta, mger is video khas tor pe ap k smjhanay k style ne mujay apni riwayt torhnay pe mjboor kr dia.

[@Taimur_Laal]

Thank you :)

[@mantiquenawaz823]

All kinds of shit goes viral in Albakistan but not these kind of Intellectual | Progressive or Educational videos. No hope ,sadly :'-(

[@humanculturesareautonomous3020]

'Professor' Taimur Rahman has all the qualities -- glibness, suavity, etc. -- of an accomplished con man. He is a walking and talking answer to the FAQ: What do fraudsters look and sound like? Charlatans like Taimur Rahman puts me in mind of frauds like Mian Iftikharuddin (1907-1962). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mian_Iftikharuddin ------ Here's Pakistani-Swedish academic Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed on Pakistani 'Leftists' (such as con man Taimur Rahman). "It’s only some of the crackpot Leftists like us, who talk about that because we live in delusions; we have spent virtually our lives in delusions and this happens to be our grand delusion. "The Communist Party bragged a lot about its plans (for the new State of Pakistan), but the very first statement of Governor General Muhammad Ali Jinnah, on 17 August 1947, was that there was a fifth column in the country looking towards Moscow and “we have to take care of them”. "So Marxists have been under fire in Pakistan right from day one. It’s a place that has never seen even ordinary democracy; where is the question of freedom for communist ideas? "Pakistan was NEVER a democratic state - not even for a day. "If at all Pakistan was a 'democracy,' it was a 'majoritarian democracy'. Don’t forget it was the elected government - not a dictator - that declared Ahmadis non-Muslim. (Dictator) Zia-ul-Haq only capitalized on that; he did not first do it." kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/10/muslims-are-never-grateful-to-those-who.html ------- Here's what Pakistanis actually did to academics with silly 'Leftist' ideas like Prof. Brij Narain (a widely published and acclaimed 'economist' from the Panjab University and an ardent supporter of the creation of Pakistan). kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/09/prof-brij-narain-quintessentially.html

[@naziakhan5238]

We love to follow "Shaheer Silavi, Zaid Hamid and Hammad Safi" kinda InTeLeCtUaLs.

[@mantiquenawaz823]

Nazia Khan Ya We love to hear these InTellecChAWWALS.

[@arshh23]

@@mantiquenawaz823 this is very funny.

[@narendrakhilnani6578]

Not to mention the intellectual discussions that people are having on this subject.

[@sudiptabaranchakrabarti7434]

The reason of economic disaster, and ways & means of its' recovery is presented very lucidly by Taimur. Irony is there are very few people in Pakistan who can follow through his presentation. People like Taimur would be more useful & productive in India though their debate, comments and review of state of the economy.

[@ABCDEFGH-sn3vw]

He has good knowledge on economy and his way of explanation makes me far better than my economics professor. The extreme economic disaster will occur unless dealth with care and even CPEC will add further burden with around $50 bn on which interest has to paid along with bailout package interest and others interest. Make him at least an advisory to chief economic officer or finance minster as he has some in-depth reformist ideas and rational thinking.

[@lonewolfp8802]

Kashmir ke chakkar mein Pakistan ki economy doob chukki hain, Nawaz Sharif ne Pakistan ki economy ko peak per pohochaya thha

[@sharifuddin6616]

Dr Taimur (brother): you have analysed the recent and worst economy of Pakistan in very easy and correct way. also showing the figure at each step of your article section.... Thank U so much

[@mirzabilals]

Taimur bhai, very comprehensive analysis. Kamal kar dia

[@Z_Trades]

This analysis is good for short term but it misses a very big fact PTI received bankrupt economy and people are expecting miracles in just one year. There is a global recession on the horizon.

[@pramod6583]

You are so knowledgeable person sir

[@sanasama2209]

Except making Pakistan a big troll factory, nothing has been achieved by this selected PM🙄

[@conesillyvalley7182]

Wow intelligent comment even from a lady with hijab...

[@irfanKhan-nm8pm]

@@conesillyvalley7182 get out indian

[@rashidbhatti7648]

Excellent. Very good analysis. Thank you.

[@Nokapp23]

Indicators (if one does not follow economic indicator) (1) Dam fund (not feasible) (2) WW2, Germany & Japan, (3) Drug problem (Last time Reham Khan said Imran can not stand for 30 minutes. If he does big deal... he gets 2 pm & things like that.)

[@mrababu270]

A realistic and highly convincing analysis by this gentleman. An eye-opener analysis by this genius economist. - An Indian

[@mohinderkumar7298]

Dr.Taimur! PM Imran can see u seated on SOFA in this particular video! 😃😁😀😄😃

[@newbiekhyber]

Which sector is terrorism put into? - Service or Industry. It has to be a growth area, with fantastic career options for Pakistanis, opportunities for frequent overseas assignments, and an eventual free trip to Jannat.

[@devilznik5595]

Hahaha lolz 😅 it should be better put in some "ruhani sector "

[@ZephyrMN]

Ha ha ha, excellent observation!!

[@kalx999]

I still wonder if you are not jailed yet... In Pakistan even ex PMs are not left... How for u?.... Take care Bhai...

[@GovExamsJobsofIndia]

Thatsy Pakistan is a FAILED STATE ...Btw He is in LONDON

[@smitas65]

@HARIS SALIM every country has these kind of individuals. However, you must realise that the facts you are stating originated under govts before India's current govt. Modi's govt too is facing economic slowdown in it's second term. But the difference is that of intent. The main reason for this slowdown is not lack of demand but of govt crackdown in the kind of scams that you have mentioned. In fact, IT collections have gone up in the last 6 years. Thieves like Chidambaram are in jail. You cannot imagine how the Enforcement Directorate and IT Dept are targeting individuals and organisations involved in fraud. The mend will see some troughs, but the crests are outnumbering them. And the prognosis for India is robust. There is good amount of reserves. Only fools are comparing Pakistan with India. There is just no scope for it. I think Pakistan is being hit by a heavy dose of something called REALITY. Other smaller neighbours like Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Bhutan and Nepal don't even attempt to do it. Pakistan has this huge inferiority complex where India is concerned. It cannot even address its financial issues without a mention of India in it

[@ajithreddy4596]

@HARIS SALIM This is called Information warfare. Pakistan's government + citizens vs India's youth. India's government is not taking any part because they know that we can do it. There are 700 million internet users in India. We will over power your government and citizens.

[@smitas65]

@HARIS SALIM Come now, hardly disingenuous. With the world hailing Indians as the most ingenuous and creative, this is one allegation that simply does not hold 😉😅! And these comments here is just Indians paying back their nosey neighbours in a similar (not same) coin. If you can poke your nose in our internal affairs, we can't even comment on your (non existent) economy? ?? Now, that's not fair. I know, I know, for Pakistanis, playing 'fair' has everything to do with skin color, and nothing to do with being just. Please, after all the terror attacks and terrorists you have unleashed on us, allow us our (free) verbal attacks 😅😅😅😅 ...hmmm, "disingenuous" you say? See how we use words to hit you in places that you didn't even know existed. You had the choice of befriending your neighbour. However, you chose enemity. Now watch our 'Kautilyan' response (Ooops, forgot, your history books don't teach you about India's history. You wouldn't know about Kautilya, aka Chanakya 😉😉😅😅)....

[@smitas65]

@HARIS SALIM our 1 PAISA also has more value than your devalued Pakistani Rupee 😅😅😅😅

[@honeyv6020]

Thank you sir... For so many days I have been looking videos based on Pak economy... Thank you for your analytical video...

[@honeyv6020]

I'm not a communist but I like facts and different opinions...

[@abdulaleem5022]

Well analysis of Pakistan economy.

[@starboy9384]

Meanwhile imran khan is cleaning toilet in white house 🚽🚽😂😂😂

[@sonusworld666]

Taimur Bhai if the rupee was devalued how come the exporters didn't take advantage of the situation ?

[@sonusworld666]

M Akmal Seriously ?? I mean Pakistan has so much to offer like food products, processed foods, cotton, textiles, ready made garments, etc . What I don’t understand is why the N.A.B. has to interfere over here as well. No wonder your exports were so badly hit .Sorry to say this but its terrible !!!!!

[@digitalavatar5699]

@@sonusworld666 avanmaru orikalum nanakathilla

[@akashpq]

Why every one is talking about PTI govt. why not the establishment?

[@akashpq]

@@shanibaba2010 Be literate please.

[@bilalsajid3315]

teray ko dar nai lgta mout sa BSDKY

[@AmjadKhan-kb6qd]

Economic is my worst subject ever in my education carrier. Mostly i enjoy Economic period in our college Canteen with my friends. I don't remember i attend whole period of economic of 40-min in my education carrier. Today i spend nearly one hour which unveil most of things which mostly i can not describes thoroughly in our daily life chit chat with our friends or in our families so thank you Sir for your very comprehensive detail. Some of interesting parts of this program which makes me some time happy, Sad , Sorrow , Fed up & as IK said "Meray Nojawanoon App ney Ghabrana Nahi Hai ...... "I just afraid that Monkey got Lighter and it is very hard to save country from fire" "Bahyo & Behno ... "WE ARE LIVING BEYOND OUR MEAN .... " This is one of the best sentence used by Sir, Taimur, although we all knew the mean of this sentence but but we neither care to showoff or also further stopped to used costly thing in our daily lives. Most of the time i remember Chinese Nation Sacrifices who makes them now WORLD NO. 1 in very very short span of decades. Some part of program parts which is very interesting start time : 52.32 55.10 56.50 57.20 Thanks for your detail and looking forward you more good detailed program. May Allah always blessed on you and shower his blessing upon you & your family. Take Care.

[@narendrakhilnani6578]

Duh?

[@krilaksh69]

As a student of economics, I liked this video. But you said Pak arms and ammunition are much more advanced compared to India. You know Pak can not fight a conventional war and win which is accepted by IK. With latest upgradation of Rafael, Apache, Brahmos, S400 etc, IK will soon stop threatening nuclear war. India's defence budget is equal to the Pak whole budget. So there is no comparison. Pak is nowhere when we talk about 5th gen warfare. India is counted with few countries which can destroy enemy satellites in space and make modern defence equipment dysfunctional.

[@muhammadrehman6395]

Maybe poor pakistan can only use little nuclear bombs..now they wont hurt india would they?

[@sarkarinaukar.790]

@@muhammadrehman6395 na they won't hurt but problem is that we don't use small bombs ...

[@balajivpatil]

@@muhammadrehman6395 and you will use them on Indian forces near pindi, destroying your own land and population. We will sacrifice our force for this cause, if you like it that way.

[@bilalurrehman9386]

LOLS

[@peacefollower5026]

@@muhammadrehman6395 Let's do some firework 🎆 We are waiting 😉 Aap use to kro fir hum humari counterstrike hogi tb hum civilian & defence ni dekhenge kitne zyada se zyada damage kr sakte h wo dekhenge maybe aapki strike meri city m ho ya delhi m ho but counterstrike ka mauka hume zaroor milega hum to chale jayenge but humare log aapko bhi humare sath bhej hi denge 😉 😂 Bhai is nuclear threat se koi ni darta kitne salon se same dhamki sun rahe h kuch to improvement lao yrr befaltu ki bahas ho rahi h aur kuch bhi ni h

[@bahadurali5715]

This is what we need, the man has done all the homework and has come up with official stats to give us the true picture of so called Naya Pakistan. As a PTI supporter one can disagree with me, nevertheless , he is right on many fronts.

[@BulletproofGOAT]

Explain why he is right. Break down how each of his points will work in the real world. Or is that he sounds like he knows what he is talking about?

[@dr.rashidali2174]

Well expaind sir g, these kind of scientific lectures on current issues based on cause, solutions and outcome result should be deliver to our youth.

[@asadalisheikh110]

The synergy of IK and establishment should have worked right from beginning. There seems either a planned chaos or total disconnect. The international establishment too ensured that Pakistan economy should not work since 2008. And slide continues. The rise of interest rates and compression of imports did contain CAD but at the cost of Fiscal deficit. The interest rate hike is the major factor to bring the economy down.

[@1954Saleem]

very well presented and explained in layman terms the economic concepts and the current scenario. Thank you . I do have concerns on your element of opposing privatization , still congratulations on your overall explanations . A highly impressive telecast

[@nigelmaccuver9122]

👉🏻 We Indians are manufacturing BMW’s, Audi’s, Mercedes and own Jaguar Land Rover entirely etc etc and consume 1000X times more that Pakistan do. But our infrastructure spending is progressive and strong versus PAKs 0% infra spending.

[@diwakarbabup4784]

Surprisingly refreshing. Level of discourse is so unlike the nonsense dished out by their media, day in day out. Maybe there’s still hope for Pakistan.

[@techauthority1240]

Tamoor Sahab aap k aik ghantau k lecture say buhat mufeed hua. Kafi kuch seekhnay ko Mila. Aik request hay k technical cheezo m EXAMPLES dia krain k concept samjh m aasani ho.shukria

[@AtulKumar-mz7pe]

Mera pura economic revise kara diya bhai ne.... Good.

[@SouravKumar-gy1bp]

it really enhance my knowledge about how economy of a state works. i appreciate ur video.

[@divyasethi8499]

Very informative. Thanks for explaining in simple words.

[@irfanKhan-nm8pm]

Divya why you Indian interest in Pakistan problem

[@divyasethi8499]

My comment was about the program not about Pakistan.

[@iqbalahmed5979]

Only way out is to bring down the cost of electricity. It will help to improve export.

[@murtazakhanshah3740]

Sir, what is the source of data you have available?

[@mubashshirahmad4738]

Peace and salutation, Sir I shall be obliged, if you could help me on the topic of my paper, which I have decided to publish. I have chosen the topic of " critique of materialism". I am certain and quite hopeful from your side, as I see alot of similarities on our philosophical and political thoughts. JazakAllah khair.

[@maqeel971]

Marxist aur progressive ko 'Jazak Allahu Khairah' kaho ge Tau reply kese kre ga.

[@freshnews1366]

If u have money in your bank account than turn your money in to gold or us dollars to get benefits and not face any inflection

[@arjuncalidas2736]

Brilliant analysis.. Every country needs a strong left wing force to counter idiots!! But isn't communism banned in Pakistan??

[@arjuncalidas2736]

@Eagle Eagle JNU is not remotely left.. Stop kidding yourself..

[@zainulabdin33]

No. Left is not banned. Communist Party of Pakistan was banned in 54 (I think) but then in 80s govt lifted ban on Communist Party.

[@ismajaffery6071]

snapshot of Pakistan's economy love the way you explain things convincing arguments.... i will join your party :))))))

[@AliHassan-ws8zs]

I m really big fan of you sir. I love your analysis which is so informative. Keep it up sir

[@tanseerahmad6586]

Very articulated .. sir you are too good at explaining the stuff. And please make videos on daily basis. Thanks

[@sheroo3984]

Great analysis. Present tax method on withdrawal capital from Bank is destroying small investments. Not encouraging at all. Someone is fooling government or these people do not have any businesses mind set.

[@edwardrussell7168]

Very good informative talk.. well done. PTI needs to wake up..IK should stop talking of cricket and understand the capitalist system...

[@arshadm7115]

ڈاکٹر صاحب پاکستان کی اکانومی کو جس آسان زبان میں آپ نے بتایا ہے وہ ایک ان پڑھ بھی سمجھ سکتا ہے بہت ہی عمدہ ویڈیو ہے

[@odnalamaruthi2534]

Well said sir♥️ love you from INDIA 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳I Hope pakistan will be exit the situation

[@kingnouriyt]

Shayad k aap ki baat youthiyo k Dil me uter jye

[@shayar_e_Sukkot]

The good thing is we agree with you, but the bad thing is we believe whatever Media want us to believe, I mean we never disagree..! However, you're lectures are playing a very significant role in educating masses. More power to you ❤️

[@sv6306]

Very informative! One of the best! Sad thing is that you have 37K views while P4 Pako gets to 500K within days.

[@BlackRose-kx2ho]

Bangladesh is saved as it is not part of Pakistan.GDP growth of Bangladesh in this fiscal year 7.5% where as Pakistan stands on 3.3%.We defeat'm in all sectors.

[@muhummadsaud3722]

Dear kumar swapan, you can not compare a country affected by 5th generation war to a country who is secular , have no nuclear arsenal. Life is all about struggle our future will be very bright in the whole region its just a matter of some years from now ans you will see a huge rise and then maybe you can come here and comment that bangladesh should have stayed as Pakistan. we Pakistanis fight for Islam and humanity and will die for Islam and humanity. The most funny thing is that you will not find even a single example in the whole world where a majority of country which is basically Bangladesh gets separated from the minority. The people of bangladesh still today love Pakistan and vice versa mistake of some individual politicians can not kill the purpose of our independence. Bangladesh zindabad , Pakistan zindabad . I wish that one day bangladesh will change its status from a secular state to Islamic republic

[@Aleem_K_Lodhi]

Thanks Sir..!! Blessed to have you in our times..

[@sndkamaldeep]

Very good analysis 👌👌 Imran Khan is totally flop in all aspects 🤬🤬🤬

[@thedexsense]

@HALAKO KHAN in order to go down, you have to be up. And you were never be up in the past two decades!

[@Unknown-sh8kw]

This guy must be living out side of Pakistan to report the truth 😜😜

[@Ghulam22]

Probably he is hiding with Indians who talk about ending killings in kashmir.

[@mirfaisaltalpur8518]

He is professor in Lahore, living and teaching here. Please don't confuse Pakistan with India, where dissenters are jailed. :)

[@login2earth]

Tension mat le bhai. ye kuch din ka mehmaan hai. Jab Salmaan Taaseer jaisa governor zinda nahi bacha ... Qandil Baloch jaise celebrity nahi bachi .. To ye kaun masoor ki daal hai .. Pakistaani fauj jald hi isko allah ke paas pahunchaayegi ... Yehi hakikat hai Pakistan ki.

[@mirfaisaltalpur8518]

If you go through his channel, you'd realise he has been critic of the system for years now. Yes, Pakistan had problems, but now with Gandhi killers being elected and celebrated in India, it's almost like both countries have swapped places on extremism and bigotry.

[@piyushdas079]

@@mirfaisaltalpur8518 kabhie apni killer history bhi dekh lo....Bhutto se lekar salman taseer tak, osama se leke haziz tak, bangladeshi genocide se lekar baloch genocide...Katil aur jahil quom doosron pe ungli nahin uthaate , bacche

[@irfanKhan-nm8pm]

Very good analysis sir I am really impresse

[@Hassan-fc2ts]

Solution starts at 41:30. Hope you take the time to check the government's direction compared to his suggestions.

[@gokuANDbrolyfusionchannel]

Respected sir ,kindly review this topic again for the current economic conditions 🙏.

[@ajaysirspioneer6083]

Superb explanation. Must for all to understand economics of govt and budget.

[@shahzaibshah6878]

THANK YOU SO MUCH !!! For your elucidation

[@zainumer8919]

Sounds interesting but Please provide the references of all the stats u just quoted.

[@salmarehana9097]

اپ کو دیکھ کر بے انتہا خوشی ہوئ۔ جیتے رہو بچے۔

[@syedabdulsalam4659]

1:20, 313 Billion dollars is the GDP not the worth of the country. Gross domestic product: the total value of goods produced and services provided in a country during one year.

[@manutrivedi1891]

The base level of folks in Pakistan is so low that this "hero" sounds like a Nobel laureate. Good talk though. Informative yet entertaining. Well done bossman.

[@quamrulhassan8205]

Ha bhai such bola, Indian folks are really intellectuals k tarah. Chance miltehi Modiji ko chunte. Aur ye N. Modi sahab keya tarakki le aiya Economy me! Wah wah wah wah! Kab saamjhenge BJB brand aur Pakistani establishment ek dusreko jigri dost hai. Ek Bhagwan ka thika liya aur dusrone Allah ka.

[@nazmul5810]

You are a mean miser. It might be your national nature. But praising someone for something well done is not making yourself less important. I am a Bangladeshi who recently observed how you people reacted to a IMF forecast. You do not demonstrate the greatness of great Indians like Tagore, Gandhi,Abul Kalam Azad these days. Why? I believe it is the effect of your populist Hindutva ideology.

[@manutrivedi1891]

@@nazmul5810 at least I am not a Bangladeshi. Glad for partition. Got rid of the losers. Youre a dirty flooded sweatshop. What are you people? Crawled out of the Bay of Bengal at some point I imagine. LoL. I was invited to Dhaka to speak at a conference. It was disgusting.

[@world_panorama]

oh Manu we forget that you are the only genius super man in this subcontinent. toilet ridden nation treat HIV affected people in India , i have visited India a number of time nothing is hidden from my eyes what is India despite of all progress India is still a third world country.

[@nazmul5810]

@@manutrivedi1891 I agree with you absolutely. If some one or some organisation invites someone like you to lecture it must be of very low quality. I wonder how worst of Bangladesh became admirer of best of India - which is you. It is disgusting to talk with a fascist like you forget about sitting there to watch you give a speech.

[@svsnmurthy2227]

India should help Pakistan in establishing public participation in rule

[@AmitMishra-gi5pl]

Imran khan sahab should make an business friendly environment in Pakistan, reduce tax charges on business give them confidence n facility to invest in Pakistan, they should be treated as a national assets, Improve your image globaly, visit country after country for FDI, for FDI u should improve your infrastructure, port and availability of skilled labour , Improve your basic agricultural provide formers to new tech. Resolve farmer's problem, focus on Small, medium and micro interprises sector, provide to youth skill based education diploma after 10th, focus on other province instead of Panjab, improve your tourism sector... Best of luck 🙏

[@awaisits1213]

Excellent Knowledge on Economy

[@devilznik5595]

Why are you questioning political government when you know it imran Khan is not elected but selected. Why don't you question the selectors ???

[@qumbermurtaza9186]

@@good7415 We have freedom go and take freedom from fascist Modi

[@educatedpakistan9485]

Dr shb did not include Corona virus impacts on economy.

[@subhanahmad5038]

The whole analysis collapsed at the start when you didn't talk about the looming BOP crisis and the resultant IMF.

[@SaratAnimation]

Very beautifully explained. Kindly make a video on Indian economy too. How India can achieve 7-8% GDP growth?

[@pankaja7974]

@@nisarmalik9404 will do 🤣🤣🤣

[@muhammadkashif-gx4ot]

Mr. Taimur Rehman you should break your silence on economic disaster of old Pakistan also as prevailing right now

[@realQkstar]

They have a very simple claim: "Once we complete our 5 year term, we'l leave a surplus economy". Lets wait for that and decide based on that. and not get into conclusions too early. cheers

[@vineetsinghgusain701]

Brother... I tell you.... india will also face very tough situations till 2021..... but some how we will manage coz... foreign reserve.... but Pakistan next two is pretty bad... world economy will go much worse.... you see oil price already rising

[@realQkstar]

@@vineetsinghgusain701 You are probably right, Still I am hopeful because the people of sub-continent whether Indians or Pakistanis are the same in many ways and are very resilient. According to experts we are now in a much better situation compared to last year... We are also better than how India was back in the 1990s. After that India opened its markets to the world and got out of the crises. Pakistan is a much smaller nation and is also going to get oil on differed payment for 3 more years. Not to mention that it now got its own oil newly discovered as well and work is going on to install the refinery there at an accelerated pace. The only threat I see is the problem of hostilities and conflict. If the peace process in Afghanistan fails, The conflict in Iran gets started and also the skirmishes with India continued, then that would be a real mess.

[@vineetsinghgusain701]

@@realQkstar dear tell me the names of those experts to whom you have read... first of all... no real economist has said it..that the situation has improved...oil price will rise or decline as per middle east conflict..I don't conflict will increase..situations in Afghan will change... russia will try to enter... russia has changed a lot under Putin... secondly the issue of 90s of india is way different than Pakistan... Pakistan has always relied on imdad... which is now reducing... on the other hand india has relied on working hard... ppl want work here...ppl want to study and grow... terrorism will increase in Pakistan...karachi and sindh will become hot...mqm and ppp will have secret tie up.... kashmir war will need more investment which your army will do... india had faced issue but were way too different a difficult than Pakistan... wait till 2021

[@realQkstar]

@@vineetsinghgusain701 You seem like a delusional, self-glorified, whining and arrogant seer. But we are not here to get opinions from seers.

[@vineetsinghgusain701]

@@realQkstar that's a issue with you guys.. you get same with every person who tells you reality... don't get opinions..just read what is about to happen after all the rhetoric will stop... always getting personal with ppl won't help you... as you guys will run to beg

[@llludostarccchamp8839]

Kia naye election ki date aagai he

[@onkarsingh5636]

Brilliant discourse! A tour de force in economics.

[@humanculturesareautonomous3020]

'Professor' Taimur Rahman has all the qualities -- glibness, suavity, etc. -- of an accomplished con man. He is a walking and talking answer to the FAQ: What do fraudsters look and sound like? Charlatans like Taimur Rahman puts me in mind of frauds like Mian Iftikharuddin (1907-1962). en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mian_Iftikharuddin ------ Here's Pakistani-Swedish academic Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed on Pakistani 'Leftists' (such as con man Taimur Rahman). "It’s only some of the crackpot Leftists like us, who talk about that because we live in delusions; we have spent virtually our lives in delusions and this happens to be our grand delusion. "The Communist Party bragged a lot about its plans (for the new State of Pakistan), but the very first statement of Governor General Muhammad Ali Jinnah, on 17 August 1947, was that there was a fifth column in the country looking towards Moscow and “we have to take care of them”. "So Marxists have been under fire in Pakistan right from day one. It’s a place that has never seen even ordinary democracy; where is the question of freedom for communist ideas? "Pakistan was NEVER a democratic state - not even for a day. If at all Pakistan was a 'democracy,' it was a 'majoritarian democracy'. Don’t forget it was the elected government - not a dictator - that declared Ahmadis non-Muslim. (Dictator) Zia-ul-Haq only capitalized on that; he did not first do it." kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/10/muslims-are-never-grateful-to-those-who.html ------- Here's what Pakistanis actually did to academics with silly 'Leftist' ideas like Prof. Brij Narain (a widely published and acclaimed 'economist' from the Panjab University and an ardent supporter of the creation of Pakistan). kbforyou.blogspot.com/2018/09/prof-brij-narain-quintessentially.html

[@sandipkrDas-li4no]

I personaly appreciate you to discuss basic of economy to person like me (gen.people). Please come up with this type elaborate discussion,I will be awaiting.

[@raobilaltariq9379]

Sir great analysis, it was very interesting. I have three suggestions for government 1) the govt owned institutions like pia, railway and wapda are charging high rates and giving no benefit to public so they should be privatised. You can check pia domestic fares are equal to middle east international flight. 2) government should close unnecessary departments like amoor e kashmir, idbp, tcp, etc. 3) our society in general doesn't invest, young graduate of rich families start searching jobs instead of getting self employed. If we don't invest then unemployment cannot be reduced. To encourage people to invest govt should stop pensions to new employees in fact give them gratuity funds so they start business and employee other people instead of depending on pensions which is a burden on economy.

[@virendraprakashsingh3874]

My friend you could be speaking truth but I am sure you will agree that your Government must be aware of the facts and they must have some plans up their sleeve. By presenting a dooms day scenario aren't you scaring some naive people. Nevertheless its important to give a true picture to the masses

[@muhammadtaqi6716]

Document link/reference

[@bajibaji5298]

Excellent thanks

[@AsianDefenceNews]

Kick off all the non performing ministers in IK govt. Trains are not running on time, airspace is closed and merchants are being harassed for taxes.

[@valeriancolaco1112]

Be safe, I enjoyed your brilliant analysis.

[@asmamasroor9802]

please MERE PASS TUM HO ka b review dein sir 😂😂

[@TasadduqAli]

Thant a lot sir I was waiting since 18 /8 2019

[@waseem42khan]

Excellent presentation Taimur Sb

[@stolensoul6857]

Very nice Sirjee,, I request your to dig more,, from early days of Pakistan. What about part 2 of this "Anatomy"

[@astert7123]

Good discussion on PAK economy by mr TAIMUR

[@inaamullah9362]

Sir, some analysis, facts and figures on 2019-2020, and prediction of 2021 plx. If you have already made a clip then plx share the link.