Our documentaries take months to produce, and we'd appreciate any extra support on our Patreon 💛 patreon.com/BeginningToNow - Ad-free access to our documentaries - Exclusive Documentary "The Buried Empire" - Video Updates - See sneak-peak videos and screenshots from our upcoming productions - Vote on upcoming episodes
@appusananingthemcha8203 күн бұрын
😢😮llop loirae like is ll😮o polo ooöoioöooooo😊😊😊
@younghokim199422 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@BeginningToNoww21 күн бұрын
Thank you for showing support! Glad you enjoyed :) Much more to come.
@AdamMiceliКүн бұрын
It's really amazing! Excellent graphics and storytelling. Thanks for the effort!!! :)))
@shirlashan7660Күн бұрын
WOW, I love how this video doesn't just go over endless war battles, territory changes, dynasty takeovers like other videos. This presentation is far more interesting. I like how you highlight significant moments in history. Thank you for helping me learn about my heritage.
@vintang196017 күн бұрын
For Chinese people, this video has many errors, but for people who know nothing about China, it can give a general understanding of some major events in Chinese history.
@wengsoonyuen208614 күн бұрын
Please enlighten us the errors made by the author.
@essencelin91413 күн бұрын
This version of history was written by mostly western scribe viewpoints and some eastern scribe
@ChinaLivingLegends11 күн бұрын
I couldn't agree more. If one doesn't have a good understanding of history, they'd better not delve into Chinese history.
@dragondescendant18 күн бұрын
even the color of Taiwan province is wrong.
@Bullsblackhawks935 күн бұрын
I love Chinese history and hate how western bias everything is. Do u have any recommendations
@ronnie78483 күн бұрын
Please do a history of all the countries. I really love your videos
@userme12373 күн бұрын
Second this!
@geetacanpadee8847 күн бұрын
A 5000 year old history explained in a nutshell. May not be perfect but certainly a well deserved attempt.
@quotesnewage7 күн бұрын
I can't just describe how much value it holds , appreciate it
@DAXZ..9 күн бұрын
Thanks bro , thanks thanks thanks!!!!! But to make this video even more better , PLS ADD THE TIMESTAMPS OF NEW PARTS , so that we can do ourur own research too ! 🙏🏻 I can't just describe how much value it holds , appreciate it 🙏🏻
@Þúǰfgʻ-ĺŵǰu79 күн бұрын
CHINA NO.1 ❤❤❤❤❤
@musicbyhamby21 күн бұрын
love these videos. i’m interested in how long it takes you to make each one and gather the research? this type of content is my favourite, in depth history about some of the most powerful countries to ever exist! amazing
@BeginningToNoww21 күн бұрын
Thanks so much mate! They take about 6 months each video. I now have a few people who help out with production so we have multiple videos being produced at the same time now. 2025 should be a much more productive year than the last! :)
@JoelCR213 күн бұрын
@@BeginningToNoww Must be hard work writing all those AI prompts
@NkateDogg11 күн бұрын
Maybe 1 days worth of work. All AI generated
@nidakhan710 күн бұрын
@@NkateDogg this is what I think mostly stock footage and AI.
@phosphate6610 күн бұрын
This is all AI lmao
@thebuliander187020 күн бұрын
Great man. Not sure it's the right niche but if anyone's interested in Chinese warfare across the ages I strongly recommend Schwerpunkt's relative series
@MarinadeReyesTrejos8 күн бұрын
thanks
@Deadround3418 күн бұрын
People watching this stuff never had to study for history exams in school haha
@Musa-k6o6 күн бұрын
Oh my bad they didn't teach me every country's history at school
@ronnie78483 күн бұрын
Why do you assume Chinese history is taught in every country?😂
@datguitar36119 күн бұрын
Hi. This is a very good video, I enjoyed it very much. I have but one minor complaint: You missed an important figure in the Teng period: the one and only Wu Zetian the female emperor. I know you condense the entire history of China in a less than 3 hours video and it's a great effort, but it only take maybe 10 seconds to mension her, for she was an important figure in Chinese history. Good job however.
@wengsoonyuen20866 күн бұрын
Completely in agreement with this important oversight.
@padraicley326515 күн бұрын
It is a Western version and viewpoint, which misses the importance of Chinese culture, especially the imperial Western invasion in the 1800s.
@dragondescendant18 күн бұрын
of course, the west would sugarcoat those events.
@wengsoonyuen20866 күн бұрын
You can always enlighten us on the Chinese narrative.
@David-Gerard3 күн бұрын
That was nothing compared to the Japanese invasion of the 1900’s.
@Peter.Joe.39Күн бұрын
exactly 1840, especial " the opium war ".
@Histomaze10 күн бұрын
How really long it takes to create such an amazing and informative content?. one day soon we're gonna be in a competition with you in this History Niche. Best of luck & keep going folks ;)
@lowcostenglish21 күн бұрын
Love the way you add the engsub to the video. Keep up the good work.
@BeginningToNoww21 күн бұрын
Cheers! Glad you enjoyed :)
@HistoryinsecondsTv6 күн бұрын
thx for video
@veeC58014 күн бұрын
Keep up the good work plus effort that goes into making this long video and overlook the attention seekers they can just scroll to another video "fitting" their taste. Its never that serious peace and love to you ❤😮
@StankoAx22 күн бұрын
at the 15th mention of "an even the canibalism was common at this time" I was like, yes, of course
@Marie-ChristineMontegu-e7w3 күн бұрын
🇫🇷 Depuis mon adolescence, j’ai été captivé par la Chine Ancienne. Son Histoire, sa Pensée, sa Philosophie et son avance Civilisationnelle. Et quelque soit mon degré de connaissance concernant Celle-ci, je me « jette » littéralement sur tous documents qui LA concernent. Merci pour Celui-ci 🙏
@gabig947719 күн бұрын
Loved this one so much - super impressed with how much work has gone into it to make it perfect. Thank you!
@BeginningToNoww17 күн бұрын
Thanks so much :)
@brucemooney12774 күн бұрын
I've got great-uncles who grew up here in Canada in the 1950's. They remember being solicited during mass to "purchase a little Chinese'', which essentially meant giving charity for the famine in Mao's China.
@GL-iv4rw21 күн бұрын
Just like with your Egypt video you could've also delve more into the prehistoric times of China and how the people first settled into these river basins.
@TuNguyen-yx5ow9 күн бұрын
Can you make 1 about Vietnam, Vietnam is also one of the earliest civilization in Asia (even more than Japan and Korea) but most people only talk about Vietnam War
@nambao9668 күн бұрын
Earliest civilisation , where source u get that from?UR VC government?
@nambao9668 күн бұрын
Dont you say that the legendary Hong Bang dynasty also counted as real history? Wake up pls
@TuNguyen-yx5ow8 күн бұрын
@ chillout baque , Chinese history book also mentioned a person named Hung Vuong from Giao Chau on their national history book
@TuNguyen-yx5ow8 күн бұрын
@ ngậm mồm con chó ba que Cựu Đường thư, (Hậu Tấn - Lưu Hú soạn, 945 SCN), quyển 41, Chí 21, Địa lí 4, dẫn Nam Việt chí (Lưu Tống 420 - 479) chép: “交趾之地,最為膏腴。舊有君長曰雄王,其佐曰雄侯。後蜀王將兵三萬討雄王,滅之。蜀以其子為安陽王,治交趾。其國地,在今平道縣東。其城九重,周九里,士庶蕃阜。尉佗在番禺,遣兵攻之。王有神弩,一發殺越軍萬人,趙佗乃與之和,仍以其子始為質。安陽王以媚珠妻之,子始得弩毀之。越兵至,乃殺安陽王,兼其地。” - “Đất quận Giao Chỉ rất là màu mỡ, ngày xưa có quân trưởng gọi là Hùng Vương, phụ tá là Hùng Hầu. Sau có vua Thục đem ba vạn lính đánh diệt Hùng Vương đi. Vua Thục nhân đó cho con mình làm An Dương Vương, trị đất Giao Chỉ. Đất nước ấy ở phía đông huyện Bình Đạo ngày nay. Thành nước ấy có chín vòng, chu vi chín dặm, dân chúng đông đúc. Úy Đà đóng đô ở thành Phiên Ngu phát binh sang đánh.Vương có nỏ thần bắn một phát giết một vạn quân Việt. Triệu Đà bèn hòa với vương, rồi sai con mình tên là Thủy làm con tin. An Dương Vương đem con gái tên là Mị Châu gả cho Thủy, Thủy thấy được nỏ thần bèn hủy đi. Kịp khi quân Việt đến liền giết An Dương Vương, chiếm cả nước ấy.” [36]
@TuNguyen-yx5ow8 күн бұрын
@ Ngậm mồm con cho 3 que part 2 Sử kí, quyển 113, Nam Việt liệt truyện, 53, Sách ẩn (Đường - Tư Mã Trinh soạn) dẫn Quảng châu kí chép: “《史記》卷百一十三南越列傳第五十三索隱引《廣州記》云:交趾有駱田,仰潮水上下,人食其田,名為駱人。有駱王、駱侯。諸縣自名為駱將,銅印青綬,即今之令長也。後蜀王子將兵討駱侯,自稱為安陽王,治封溪縣。後南越王尉他攻破安陽王,令二使典主交阯、九真二郡人。” - “Quận Giao Chỉ có ruộng Lạc, dân trông nước thủy triều lên xuống mà làm ăn ở ruộng ấy nên đặt tên là người Lạc. Có các chức Lạc Vương - Lạc hầu, các huyện tự đặt chức Lạc tướng đeo ấn đồng dải xanh, tức là chức Lệnh-Trưởng ngày nay vậy. Sau đó con vua Thục đem quân đánh Lạc Hầu, tự xưng là An Dương Vương, trị ở huyện Phong Khê. Sau nữa vua Nam Việt là Úy Tha đánh phá An Dương Vương, sai hai sứ giả điển chủ người hai quận Giao Chỉ-Cửu Chân.” [36]
@younghokim199422 күн бұрын
I'm going to hope that the information in this video is all true, because I watched it all.
@fannyalbi904018 күн бұрын
There's no true history.
@younghokim199418 күн бұрын
@@fannyalbi9040 I never said true history, I said true information. Also, there absolutely is true history.
@fannyalbi904018 күн бұрын
@@younghokim1994 ic i replied to a fool. Forget it then
@FuTienyueh17 күн бұрын
@@younghokim1994 It's pretty accurate except the pronunciation
@alsetalokin8817 күн бұрын
lots of lies. tiananmen, tankman, 'ccp' etc
@Wikipediaarticles17 күн бұрын
I love your content my dream to make this type of content but fail fail fail again 😢
@kannan776122 күн бұрын
Thankyou so much my man I have been waiting for this so badly!!!! You are my doctor thanks for the medicine history
@BeginningToNoww22 күн бұрын
Haha you're welcome. I hope you enjoy :)
@heartbrokenwords232953 минут бұрын
Entire history of India ❤❤❤pls sir
@mustafaceylan59718 күн бұрын
Did your channel got demonitazed, why are there no ads? How do you even afford making these thorough and long videos without monetization.
@clairsnow640418 күн бұрын
it's a not so subtly anti china video. 🇺🇸 gov provides lots of money in grants to various organizations to keep up anti china rhetoric. maybe this channel is also a recipient?
@BeginningToNoww17 күн бұрын
Absolutely not lol, we are monetised and this video has ads.
@wengsoonyuen20866 күн бұрын
@@clairsnow6404But you have conveniently forgotten to mention the CCP has also poured in billions of USD in anti US propaganda. Check the CCP United Front activities, CCP bots, CCP foreign agents in the West etc.
@lenaardie455513 күн бұрын
This entire video was written by chat GPT wasn't it? The sentences are extensive, sometimes even incoherent by overly complicated formulations with a bunch of redundant words. It is difficult to follow and grasp the key takeways.
@younghokim199411 күн бұрын
some people are just not that great of a writer. Not saying this guy isn't a good writer, but some people (Iike me).
@ladyhotep5189Күн бұрын
Such weird negative comments here. For people who only have a general knowledge or less, this is great.
@googiecrew22 күн бұрын
Love these topics great video
@BeginningToNoww22 күн бұрын
Thank you :)
@afharris720 күн бұрын
Some of these comments ain't it! I love history and i loved this video! I learned a lot and i love the voiceover. Keep working hard ❤
@BeginningToNoww20 күн бұрын
Thank you so much :)
@mrmat381815 күн бұрын
Comments may not be it but they are true! 😄
@raven50027 күн бұрын
@@BeginningToNoww where are your sources? It would make sense to include them when making a documentary public...
@Liveforfood939415 күн бұрын
Most importantly is the history. I think real human voice or AI is not important!
@nike2024514 күн бұрын
Funny, how the woman who actually was behind the expansion and flourishing after Taizongs death is not mentioned.
@hueman384018 күн бұрын
Major oversights - no info on the age of the Silk Road, or the very important Hongshan & Liangzhu Cultures, Megalithic period sites, or anything before - very disappointing.
@jackiehoward568618 күн бұрын
could you do philippines?
@tigerimschlamm3670Күн бұрын
how dare you no taiwan
@mrmat381821 күн бұрын
The AI art is often totally off, but you also should take more care whan choosing the portraits! For exammle at 1:14:20 you used Ming Dynasty portraits for Later Liang emperors... both families were called Zhu... And the maps look cool but are often inaccurate too!
@MIRAAJMUHAMMAD_6667 күн бұрын
What about India Bharat Indus valley civilisation more older than Chinese civilisation?
@peterng97862 күн бұрын
That's not a continuous civilization and there was no Indian nation yet before the British came. It was just a throughly divided land mass ruled by many kings and sub-kingdoms. The British united them, penned it and then you guys only got a real country named India as of it today. So, India is not that ancient or old or a continuous civilization after all. You guys should thanks England now for it. Learn your real and truth history first before commenting next time. I hope your storage capacity for information and knowledge are sufficient because your intelligent are limited. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@SushamaHembram-fp1yhКүн бұрын
@@peterng9786I just love seeing stupid, uneducated and worthless people like you, who think thay are smart.laughing at him won't make you look smarter dued. As for unity of india or should I say akhand bharat , we were united for most of history. Proof is the morian dynasty, Mughal Empire, Gupta and many more.
@A_Story_Told_in_Stone11 күн бұрын
That is amazing human live in the world
@kdubz39937 күн бұрын
I've watched this 3 times now and i feel like there hasnt been enough explanation as to why alot of these internal strifes started like over philosophy or wut
@khylebagtas874314 күн бұрын
Next will be The ENTIRE history of Japan then next South Korea
@alvinhii114113 күн бұрын
Just Korea, the division of the Korean peninsula is a relatively new thing
@skyguyxninja565022 күн бұрын
Thank you so much I can learn so much as a history fan. Maybe you could soon make some aufiotracks pls
@user-xiaoshiba14 күн бұрын
看到最后出现了社会信用体系真的笑死我了🤣
@kaiser-of-history22 күн бұрын
Wow, I just started the video and it is amazing! I am going to save this one to my MUST-watch playlist.
@BeginningToNoww22 күн бұрын
Cheers! I hope you enjoy
@NkateDogg11 күн бұрын
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Luiri6118 күн бұрын
当我把进度条拉到一半的时候,我发现它还在讲成吉思汗,我就知道这3个小时的视频催眠效果肯定不错。
@DrMohammedElsayed7 күн бұрын
We are waiting for the Roman empire
@cywg918816 күн бұрын
China has many "historical relics". China has many "cultural relics pictures" that show history. I hope you can quote these "cultural relics pictures" that can truly reflect Chinese history. I hope you won’t randomly quote unfounded “imaginary pictures”.
@Lodge-Of-Lore5 күн бұрын
Love your videos 🙏. I make shorts about, history, legends myths and more.
@AziezIsmaelBaniel17 күн бұрын
Zhao Gao was the true emperor after Ying Zheng the 2nd emperor was merely a puppet and Li Si was also a victim of Zhao Gao even tho they co-conspired to get rid of fu su and Meng tian
@ThomasLauro-w6v16 күн бұрын
Agreed Ai voice turned it off for me
@Jbytzz10 күн бұрын
Oooo do India next
@BeginningToNoww10 күн бұрын
Yes!! It is next :)
@MarcosChavez-ow5yi18 күн бұрын
It would be great to see mesoamerica and or mexico!
@fisayoemmanuel655116 күн бұрын
Please do Russia
@Editor-w8n17 күн бұрын
Very good video and can you do a video on the history of japan please?
@HistoryAi769 күн бұрын
Amir becomes historyian
@aphroditewhy4428 күн бұрын
Li Mu from Zhao should be Lian Po
@ainabend494322 күн бұрын
Now do korea then japan pleaaaaaaase❤
@msknowitallish10 күн бұрын
Wow! I guess this is history, mixing true with lies much
@illsed15 күн бұрын
In old days southern china much happening n flourish vs northern
@340ACP2 күн бұрын
Too many inaccuracies to be useful, nice effort but no dice
@jongilchrist72293 күн бұрын
Empress Wu????
@DriveAndRoasts17 күн бұрын
this is great
@이희-q6d13 күн бұрын
3:44 yi. he is korean yi sun sin
@Delta19G16 күн бұрын
Dear Lord the many ways that life can change in an instant is exhausting, enough to make the strongest of people feel weak. But even though we struggle with our emotions, fear can still hinder. The day life is perfect is not even a fact So keeping faith we shall not hold back Staying strong can be discouraging. But the fact you gave us Jesus.... Nothing is impossible anymore
@Incurabl20 күн бұрын
1:28:00
@victorlikas578112 күн бұрын
what about Africa,
@dragondescendant18 күн бұрын
Wrong color for Taiwan province.
@exploretherapy242121 күн бұрын
I actually got to see a real terra-cotta worrier
@seantan95068 күн бұрын
Hou yi live different era from Xia yu. Hou yi attack the Xia when Xia yu’s grandson king taikang was outside the capital on a hunting trip. Zhou people were from the guanzhong area. Your video is zzz. Can’t watch on. Full of wrong info
@josephineromano483417 күн бұрын
What a detailed description of how china came to be, feel sorry for her being missed used by the west.5000 years & still going strong 😮🇦🇺👏
@samuelbenitez48858 күн бұрын
I am a descendent of yellow emperor by proof of my DNA test results
@craft905411 күн бұрын
The fact that it completely skipped the mention of the Only female emperor of China means that this video is not an accurate account of the history of China.
@DigitalResurrection7 күн бұрын
Are you speaking of Empress Lü? @37:39
@wengsoonyuen20866 күн бұрын
It should be incomplete rather than inaccurate. Otherwise tell us what are the inaccuracies.
@ashhempsall980317 күн бұрын
Interesting. But the longest continuous civilisation at some 40,000 years, is aboriginal Australian, as i know 🐈⬛
@jamesboth378515 күн бұрын
Australia doesn't have Established civilization until the Whites people built it
@EwnetuZegeye-l2c19 күн бұрын
Russian in the middle you know Dad appears with the Cross what ever you one blood don't work for me third world faire order what ever you have in your pocket one cent nottobe faire
@fannyalbi904018 күн бұрын
The trouble of westerner talk about Chinese history is the pronunciation of Chinese name. To minimise it, should present the Chinese character to avoid this issue. Unbearable to watch
@CashTornadoSlotsofficial10 күн бұрын
yea i'm just an average Chinese speaker & i can't understand all the Chinese names & places he's trying to say... 2 and a half hours of a guy who couldn't bother to learn how to pronounce pinyin...
@Jade-sc7ne8 күн бұрын
@fannyalbi9040 Wow! You are a loser, just appreciate how much work and time goes into making this video. You ought to shut up if you have nothing good to say Fanny!
@trevoryin7 күн бұрын
Shouldn't expect foreigner to pronounce correctly. Pretty sure that Chinese also cannot pronounce thai king or burmese king name correctly. It's normal.
@igvc18763 күн бұрын
Lmao have you ever heard how chinese pronounce western names in chinese? It's completely unrecognizable.
@fannyalbi90403 күн бұрын
@igvc1876 did Chinese show off their western history? Stupid cxxt logic
@Osirisdachosen5521 күн бұрын
Where is the migration from Africa to Asia?
@jamesboth378515 күн бұрын
Wrong history. We never migrated from Africa. Homo Sapiens mixed with the native other human species, Denisovian.
@shenghe986121 күн бұрын
too many misinformation and disinformation, too superficial on many major events. 😂
@MartinMureithi-gr5um20 күн бұрын
Make yours
@NkateDogg11 күн бұрын
@@MartinMureithi-gr5um Where's yours?
@HistoryOverdue9 күн бұрын
Good looking out. ;)
@IMBRAHIMOVIC10013 күн бұрын
DAMN WE NOT GONNA MENTION THE GREAT FAMINE IN CHINA DURING MAO RULE LOL
@creationsFREEMAN18 күн бұрын
China is not the oldest continuous civilization, the Australian Aborigines predate China by at least 50,000 years.
@clairsnow640418 күн бұрын
australian aborigines are not considered a civilization in a traditional sense.
@Paralianpoet17 күн бұрын
Civilization bruh.
@wbzd-r2c17 күн бұрын
澳大利亚原住民都被英国佬杀光了,😂
@peterng97862 күн бұрын
Learn what is a civilization first before talking nuisance.
@christopher48014 күн бұрын
Whats with the lame distracting subtitles?......Do you think we dont know how to use the cc button.
@MarcosChavez-ow5yi18 күн бұрын
No commercials and no shitty AI voice?! Great job!!
@Sophie_kang21 күн бұрын
Did you seriously just butchered pronouncing Go Goo Ryu...
@ChinaLivingLegends11 күн бұрын
This is laughable. If the content is generated by AI, it should be carefully verified. People who are not history enthusiasts should refrain from dealing with Chinese history. Thank you.
@HistoryOverdue9 күн бұрын
Agreed.
@RockinLockin2 күн бұрын
This Ai use is disgusting. I can’t watch this generic shit. Soon the voices of videos like this will be replaced by Ai.
@ChinaLivingLegends2 күн бұрын
@ I'm Chinese and can't distinguish voices, but I'm extremely dissatisfied with the content. Whether it's an AI or a human, spreading false information is really disgusting.
@petahills661515 күн бұрын
Australian Aboriginals are the longest continuous civilisation in the world. Over 40 thousands years longer...at least!
@oppenheimer-wz6ix15 күн бұрын
I own a boomerang which IS made in China. Have not got IT to come Back to me yet. To do with The throwing technique?
@sinoroman19 күн бұрын
There are so many things wrong in this video. Misinformation
@drinkwater511716 күн бұрын
Cry
@sinoroman16 күн бұрын
Like saying Julius Caesar was wearing a tuxedo during his reign in 1706 AD
@maxhoughton409222 күн бұрын
clicked away right after i heard the ai voice sorry
@BeginningToNoww22 күн бұрын
It is a real voiceover, we have been working with him long before AI existed.
@R0b721 күн бұрын
@@BeginningToNoww I like the channel, but we all know it is an AI voiceover unfortunately A real, human voice would make these videos 10x better, a lot of people instantly click off AI voiceovers on anything
@dodolkacang140021 күн бұрын
are u deaf? or simply idiot?
@BeginningToNoww21 күн бұрын
@@R0b7 Again, it is a real voiceover artist, I have been working with him since 2021.
@denverrsouthers553121 күн бұрын
Idk why yall think this is an a.i. voice over,he clearly speaks with more inflection than ai
@daovang270318 күн бұрын
Your not even close to the truth history, because Hmong people was living in China before the Chinese
@Tsog400119 күн бұрын
🇲🇳Mongolian history is not Chinese history so defferent ethnicity groups
@luceafarul57919 күн бұрын
By this logic, English history is actually French history. They were ruled by rulers who only spoke French for a time being.
From your comment, I already knew how limited your intelligent are. No need feed you more knowledge or information because your storage capacity is limited. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@NehalHasnain-xh3pk6 күн бұрын
আসসালামুআলাইকুম ওয়ারাহমাতুল্লাহি ওয়াবারাকাতুহ চায়না প্রেসিডেন্ট কে বলি দেশ ঠিক করবে সারা পৃথিবীতে ইনশাল্লাহ আমার নামটা হবে প্রত্যেক দেশেই বলছি যে প্রত্যেক দেশের ছেলে মেয়ে ঠিক করো
@levi-stock16 күн бұрын
All is swell until Xi Jinping came along.
@peterng97862 күн бұрын
Because western can't bully China anymore because Xi made you guys trembling in fear. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@TomdabombNchrone20 күн бұрын
Wow, good stuff bro. Im pacific islander, and apparently our DNA takes us back to China.