The Evolution of Cycling Groupsets: How Shimano's Auto Shift Drivetrain Works

Christina Chapetta, with support from Shimano, explores the topic of automatic drivetrains and asks whether mountain bikers are finally ready for the fully automatic drivetrain.
For more info read Mike Kazimer's first look below:
www.pinkbike.com/news/first-r...
Supported by 👉 Trailforks Pro: b.link/v63weq
Get unlimited access to all the best mountain biking trails by clicking the link above.
More Pinkbike videos:
Dirt Surf Ready | Value Bike Field Test: Specialized Status Review
• Dirt Surf Ready | Val...
Instant Comfort, Effortless Riding | Value Bike Field Test: Vitus Mythique 29 AMP Review
• Instant Comfort, Effor...
A Budget Bike That Rips | Value Bike Field Test: YT Capra Core 1 Mx Review
• A Budget Bike That Rip...
Pinkbike Merch - pinkbike.link/merch
Subscribe for more content from the pulse of mountain biking.
Website - pinkbike.com
Podcast - pinkbike.link/pbpodcast
Instagram - / pinkbike
Facebook - / pinkbikecom

[@adamvanabel4939]

Thanks for reminding me to go ride my single speed.

[@DreaMinder1]

damn ads are getting smarter

[@usernamefromhell]

I might be old school, or just cheap, but the Shimano CUES clutch drivetrains are the most interesting line up to me right now. They just seem simple, robust, affordable, and highly compatible. Not enough people are talking about it tbh

[@frits8986]

Must say that they can learn a thing or two from SRAM when it comes to launching new products

[@gedrot2486]

Because it's not supposed to and doesn't need to be a hyped up thing. It fully replaces Altus, Acera, Alivio and Deore 10 and 11 speed. Most people will not get excited for this stuff and the few that would actively go out looking for an, and let me be honest with myself, odd ball setup like a clutched 36/22t x 11-45t would be these days will already have heard from it. Bike packers might also be interested in it, since the higher grade CUES upgrade the current touring versions of Deore and Deore XT. Well at least the ones that aren't able or willing to spend Rohloff + belt drive levels of money on their bikes. But those who care enough right now in that space will probably also have already heard of it the week it got first announced. And Shimano doesn't really need to advertise their products in the budget and entry level price ranges. Their budget stuff just simply works and does so more reliably and at lower price points then options from the potential competition. So there is no real competition for them here. At least not yet, looking at LTwoo, etc.

[@usernamefromhell]

@@gedrot2486 1x10 is not fringe at all, it's actually more mainstream than the 12 speed stuff. Most of mountain bikers I know have a standard HG hub, and upgrading to 12 speed is a hassle, and 11 speed gets confusing with all the different standards, but 10 speed just WORKS.

[@hugobci]

That is because CUES justify itself. All highend products need as much ad as development to convince people to buy and use. Marketing in this tier tech is crucial! Why would you use highend tech? Because you are educated to.

[@martinschwartz7342]

I like the something for everyone approach to MTB drivetrains. This is one more option that won’t be for everyone but it will make a lot of people happy. Also, I just want to say that Christina, you have become an amazingly good journalist. I hope Pinkbike will keep you for many years to come.

[@nomad-pq4yw8iy7v]

I thought part of the idea was you could use it as auto ,semi auto or full manual. So it sorta is for everyone! I do say sorta because of the price point and simpler systems have less that can go wrong. my thing would be does it chose the right gear another words how good is the mapping, but that's why it's good to always have the full manual option available so you can have the best of both worlds

[@jerprouse146]

In New Zealand, shifting is when you move into a new flat or house. If you could just hit a button and it was done for you, that would leave more time for bbq and beer.

[@ish474]

Can't believe Shimano didn't want Henry to do this video😂😂😂

[@jamble7k]

"i hate it" - Henry

[@boblipsch4450]

Nice and all, but I think the average mountainbiker would still prefer the good old mechanical drivetrain. Cool video tho!🤟

[@soy_leche]

Whatever is cheap and works is what I want. Could be electronic or not, don’t care.

[@TheStudioborsbeek]

Try it ... You will be amazed

[@AkiraKDK]

I bought it month ago for my Spectral:ON 23 (EP801)....and I love it!!! It's a game changer...on the Downhill correct gear for a extra kick if you need 💪🍻🥳

[@Analog_Refined]

Absolute masterpiece of a video. I loved the pacing, the editing was amazing and the new way of presenting was really nice. Almost felt like an episode of grand tour haha.

[@D_E_T_R_O_Y_T]

Pinion MGU just laughing at this Shimano 😂

[@janeblogs324]

You ever read a review on pinion? No one keeps them, sluggish, power sapping, hard to shift and won't let you shift without skill, oh did I mention the $3000 price tag?

[@daved2023]

@@janeblogs324 You are referring to the analog version. Go read up on the Pinion MGU with electronic shifting and integrated e-mtb motor and then come back and retract your previous statement.

[@D_E_T_R_O_Y_T]

@@janeblogs324 Man, just watch some reviews on new Pinion MGUs bikes. Shifting is silky smooth, drive system is non-wearable and silent when bike hits an impact. The ability to shift gears automatically and without cranks and wheel rotating is amazing! And there are way more advantages. Here starts the future of eMTB. Shimano with it autoDi2 just suck)

[@janeblogs324]

@@daved2023 how much does it cost and can you provide a link to buy the gearbox right now? I'll bet you $1000 you can't answer either because its not a viable option and won't be till someone else releases a consumer option

[@1969Escobar]

BEAUTIFUL VIDEO!!! Cheers Christina

[@ewxlt]

Who wrote this script? Shimano?

[@Hihopeyouhaveawonderfulday]

If it reduces the price a standard XT drivetrain, I’m all for it

[@jamble7k]

its already about 400 for the xt groupset with brakes 😀

[@MikeesTexas]

Nice work on the video Christina, enjoyed it!!!!❤

[@dansutherland70]

I suspect this is pretty awesome, but it's been overshadowed by the Pinion MGU, which is just a better solution to the problem.

[@Dorkbike]

Interesting tech and nice video. This new eBike tech looks like it would be best suited for an internal gearbox and motor application vs. this traditional rear derailleur and motor combination.

[@theonlymob]

Exactly! Like pinions new mgu

[@robertroxxor]

i didn't know this would actually work, very surprised. great video. personally i'd probably put my money on a belt drive / motor combo ("gearbox").

[@Daiton1100]

Pinkbike does the best ads that look like a video ❤

[@Gothenburg85]

At some point, the sport can be taken away from a sport we all love. "Save the Manuals" is a thing for a reason - for people that enjoy DRIVING the car (like myself). We enjoy RIDING the bike, and in an age of 11/12 speed cassettes (vs the old 3x7/8/9), it's just not that difficult or complex, but still really FUN. More things to break and have to maintain means more time off the trail, and more money. If you want to have all that done for you, just get an adventure/trail motorcycle. Hell, they're about the same price anymore. My Pivot Trail 429 was 6k...... I can get a new Yamaha TTR230 or Honda CRF250F for around 5k... new.

[@_Conrad_]

Key words “more money” that’s what they only care about ,which sucks.

[@Bonky-wonky]

What’s next, a button that makes the bike whip like Bernard Kerr was riding it? For most PB followers mtb is a technical challenge, meaning an automatic drivetrain would take away part of the beauty of riding, timing and modulating the perfect shift which can be highly rewarding. The big question is not if an automatic drivetrain is technically possible or is faster, it is whether who will actually want it. My guess would be mostly ebikers new to the sport.

[@Mp57navy]

"For most PB followers" Not me then. I watch it simply to keep up with new technologies. And I certainly don't get endorphin kicks when I shift gears. I do it, because I have to.

[@TigerClaw03]

I agree, and I think it further lowers the skill level of newbie level ebikers because you don't even need to learn shifting techniques. The comparison that I think most people understand is a pull-up machine. The eventual goal is to do a pull-up without any assistance from the machine.

[@lanehartwig6917]

This would be really interesting for cross country. You know you can sustain X value wattage, so you could set your gearing to be notice when you are down on power, and automatically down shift. This along with you knowing an optimal cadence could really make a difference!

[@martinhayes5087]

I honestly don't see the point, one wack on that derailleur I've not noticed and it's going to auto shift itself into my spokes 😂

[@johncrowley1203]

Superb presentation!

[@sixty2612]

Personally, I’ve never thought there were any issues with manual shifting. It’s second nature, and I can fully control the gear in anticipation of the trail ahead, which my drive trail can’t ever do. This drivetrain solves a problem that doesn’t exist.

[@dano727]

Great video Christina !

[@jamawl66]

Wow, I never knew shifting gears was such a horrible hardship

[@jimmyridesnz]

Guessing you’re driving a manual car/truck then? 😉

[@NextLevelRiding]

this is surprisingly cool and if it works as designed will be a fascinating development in the industry.....one handed gear changes would change the game for partially disabled riders too!

[@adamwildenstein4474]

top notch production!

[@urobos1]

Anyone else getting Lety vibes here?

[@brian6speed]

I still only drive manual

[@janeblogs324]

I am also heterosexual

[@brianbaker5694]

Semi auto is intriguing. Auto shifting in general seems great for when the fatigue hits

[@quinnthompson]

So, shifting without pedaling works by having the motor crank for you, so the shifter would need to communicate with the motor then.. is that standardized? & I guess this whole system only works on an eBike then. The tech is slick, but I'm im not a fan. I drive a manual, so I guess it makes sense I want my bike to be manual too.

[@casestudymtb]

And probably only the shimano motor

[@Nicoya]

So electronic shifting is all fine and good. I've got AXS on one of my bikes and it's expensive but I appreciate the appeal. But the automatic stuff? I'm just not seeing it. Like if I'm on a technical climb then I absolutely don't want the gear ratio changing unexpectedly, and if I'm on a non-technical climb then why even care. About the only feature that seems appealing is the pre-selection while coasting downhill but that feature seems to require an ebike, and if I'm riding an ebike I'm gonna be caring a lot less about being in the wrong gear for a sudden uphill punch.

[@Gothenburg85]

Great points - totally agree on all.

[@briannyob7799]

I think this could work really well with commuter ebikes where someone just wants to jump on and get wherever they want to go.

[@bruhlord5121]

Or just put a gearbox on the bike like a certain company has in the works. 👍

[@chartreuse1356]

I just don't see the point. Shifting is not a very difficult thing to do. It happens very fast too. It's not like a car where you have a clutch to press first. I don't see automatic shifting to offer any noticeable performance advantage. In fact it is a disadvantage because the system can't preselect your gear based on what you see ahead of you. It can only react. I feel similarly about electric groupsets. I see it's advantages, especially in racing environments. I still would prefer a mechanical system, especially in mountain biking.

[@janeblogs324]

Obviously you don't own an emtb and haven't broken 6 chains in a year. If I deleted your memory and instincts and told you to gear change while pedaling your bike up hill you would break teeth off your cassette. This new system is for racing or people that are sick of the current derailleur limits

[@dylan-5287]

Yep, small advantage with huge disadvantages. Even a child can learn to properly shift but when there's inevitably a problem it's going to be a big old bill and likely not something you can fix at home. It's like creating a robot to wipe your ass, sure some people may need it but most are OK as is lmao.

[@TigerClaw03]

@@janeblogs324 If you break 6 chains a year, there's something to be said of your technique; it's most likely very bad. Any bicycle rider with some skill level would know that shifting to a larger gear under load is hard on the drivetrain, ebike or non-ebike. It's common sense. You're in the wrong gear range when starting the climb...you don't get into the right gear range during the climb...that's one of the techniques you would've developed if you first started riding on a non-ebike. Racers will always prefer to manually select their gears. Yes, the gear shifting has gotten quicker, but all professional racers (F1, MotoGP, etc.) still manually select gears. Lastly, you, the rider, is the derailleur limitation. I think the bicycle industry is going into the direction where the companies are trying to provide solutions to problems that don't exist.

[@janeblogs324]

@@TigerClaw03 then shimano or SRAM axis isn't for you. These new electronic shifting gears are designed for full power thoughtless shifting. You sound like one of those rim brake fanatics that don't want change and want to ride slower while bashing all new technology.

[@TigerClaw03]

@@janeblogs324 I think you highlighted the issue; "thoughtless shifting". Contrary to your statement, knowing when to shift or what gear range you need to be in is a skill. In my opinion, a lot of skills (body weight distribution, shifting, taking better lines, etc) are developed far better when a newbie starts out on an non-ebike than an ebike. Look, I'm all up for new technologies for cycling, but I think, as I previously posted, companies are developing solutions for problems that don't exist. Bikes are already expensive at the enthusiast level, but do we really want to go into the direction of new bikes being $15k+? On top of the non-serviceability of the ebike motors to the at-home mechanic? FYI - I have a Stumpjumper with an AXS drivetrain and a YT Decoy.

[@jankie55]

I would prefer a drivetrain similar to what we have now, but without the derailer hanging down and getting bashed.

[@txisbest2010]

Shimano has 8/11speed internal planetary transmission with both manual/Di2

[@qcTOOL]

OMG, incorporating both my passion in one video🤯😁🤘 Full manual everywhere is my way, but got to admit this one from Shimano for ebike lovers is very interesting. Thx for video👍

[@tims_builds]

It's cool and all but it seems to me most of the problems it solves have already been solved by IGHs, namely shifting without spinning the cranks and even auto shifting has been around for a while in IGH land. For the money (bc I'm sure this is pricey) I'd get a really good IGH that would be lower maintenance and less risk of damage in a crash.

[@FuzzyStone01]

Might be a great experience for skilled riders, but what about new (and necessarily very wealthy) generations, which might never ride real mechanical drivetrain? Mastering your shifting is considerable skill and learning and finally mastering it brings joy. Will setting up your app give you same joy? I might be too old school, yet I understand development will never stop and naturally, it all comes on top of e-bikes. Soon we will print T-shirts with "save the manual" but we will not refer to Porsche anymore :D

[@abuckcat]

No thanks I like shifting and pedaling

[@KeanuSwayze]

I'm done. **Orders singlespeed conversion kit**

[@dodger1x]

My next emtb will be with a Pinion MGU and Revonte One motor

[@user-nf3oq2ge3g]

this is probably another stepping stone to greatness but the idea to shift without pedaling is amazing for tech or trials. I’m on board. Racing times will drop because of this but no more air pedaling

[@justinh7099]

Tried this on a demo bike this weekend. It was meh, but I didn't have access to modifying the Auto settings

[@CT37BN]

I'd like to see Shimano and SRAM do a take on Pinion with their own "original tweaked" trademarks so this next gen type of drivetrain technology can also have it's competition and for sure will drive the prices to more mass market level.

[@davetscantech]

I just got the Di2, auto shift isn’t available in 12 spd only free shift, it’s not ideal all the time. Shimano also says it you use manual shift it will eventually learn which I think is a pretty important part of information. Shimano needs to figure out there website, it’s quite the journey trying to find all the details on this system. The full Linkglide Di2 does shift really well under load(I’m 240) Another feature is the manual shifting can be set to shift 2 or 3 at time or unlimited shifting when holding the shift paddle. It does use up the battery more quickly with all the shifting options on because it’s turning the motor and now powering the derailleur. I really wish Shimano had a range extender option or even just smaller battery to make up the extra usage

[@steveh485]

Nice Porsche. Ill keep simple and manual on my MTB. Maybe the roadie weenies want this.

[@jeffwalrod5124]

get rid of derailleurs and move to an internal gear system with a belt on single cassette and rear cog

[@LajosLasso]

i like to tripple crankflip somethimes, but i need to do that in a specific really light gear for the speed, this is one of loads of times that you allready want to be in a different gear before the computer knows so. im not convinced that this will be the future.

[@lexusstefan927]

1st Gen Sram AXS is as far I go because I prefer having less cables Everything after that is a no thanks

[@jamble7k]

you vill buy the gimmicks and like them 😀

[@TeamCykelhold]

For ebikes, just make a cheap robust drivetrain that isn't an overly heavy boat anchor like linkglide. Doesn't need to have 12 cogs, it just needs to have a wide range.

[@frienduro24]

More important…Is 90s fashion back?

[@Nitrobucket]

I Love Options. I'm not going to naysay it because there's something for everyone. But someone like my wife who just casually rides once in awhile could definitely benefit

[@DC13333]

We will be full auto shift and adjustable abs brakes in a year or 2.

[@fre2045]

What´s next? An automatic balance device, an e mtb where you don´t have to pedal or steer... more time to enjoy the scenery... shifting really isn´t that hard.

[@Tauffan]

Next Cruise technology on MTB...

[@mechpade]

there's the idea of having all the features of a motorcycle on an e-bike. Basically a pedal-able scooter, more for commutes than bombing single tracks. But hey, this is Pinkbike 🤷‍♂

[@livefreeandshred9818]

Whatever man. That Porsche is sick

[@netposerx]

I use my car/van to drive to and from places. I use my MTB to have fun and want to experience riding differently than driving. Same with my surfboard, I don't want a motor boat around, I want to surf. Comparing a car and mtb is pointless. Maybe compare a car to a commuter bike. I love my commuter ebike that gets me around town with little effort.

[@MikeesTexas]

I really dig the “mtb/surfing” analogy…. I feel you on this one!!!

[@wangelite5279]

A reliable wireless gear box and reliable belt drive. Simple yet complex.

[@robins7926]

So, this only works on e-bikes, right?

[@grogerome]

HXR Easyshift had the solution to shift without pedaling nailed a few years ago I guess.

[@MerlinAndreas-ph9sp]

Kualitas sesuai dengan harga ...

[@AntonyLD]

Guys, #PinkBike Have any of you tried a #Zerode ? The belt drive Mountain bikes?

[@jamble7k]

im sure they know about it but shimano had more marketing budget

[@rafaeldegiacomoaraujo8778]

Like in many other comments, it think this makes more sense in a gearbox. Shimano is clearly focused on the ebike market.

[@Maerchensargk]

fine fine... now we got AXS, AXS Transmission, DI2, DI2 automatic and stuff... all great inventions which costs money and so on... but can we now finally price down the manual shifting systems like GX and XT Groupsets... pleassssse 😁

[@tranhai8895]

Is the electronic groupset/shifter the new standard for Tour De France road bikes?

[@Pienimusta]

Derailleur Hanger? What is this? 2022?

[@50whatnomadtravelnursemtb5]

I'm sorry, but I don't need an app or derailleur to help me to decide when to shift, if you get distracted from the trail because of shifting then you are truly a beginner and probably wouldn't dream of paying the price of having this set up. It might be helpful with ebikes but honestly the review i saw he was grinding gears like crazy with this set up.

[@SpineShank7]

Shifting without pedaling would genuinely be nice... Fully automatic seems unlikely to be anything other than jarring, unless you're just doing a long, steady climb up a fire road. Kinda mixed feelings on this one

[@thomasbenito274]

Off topic, that 930 with BBS RS wheels looks and sounds soooo good

[@AppleJack76]

Not a 930. 930's are turbos.

[@pinkbike]

Lets set the record straight: 1977 911S in Ice Green Metallic 3.0L engine from an 83 911SC SC rear flared arches

[@jpsion]

Ill wait for it to trickle down in 5 years.

[@fidellopez3703]

Si un motor ya te asiste el pedaleo, para que ocupas cambios? Sería redundante la ayuda.

[@asselplage5119]

Who cares about "electro-automatic-shifting"? What about Christina's siiick outfit straight from the 90's?! AWESOME :P

[@JeremyFacer]

Imagine if we had a bicycle drivetrain that didn’t have a rear mech, and could shift at the click of a button… one can only hope

[@toooldfortwowheels2048]

You're being sarcastic no? Pinion and Rohloff are pretty much 90% of the way there. Albeit they weigh a ton and are a bit specialist.

[@Paulklampeeps]

I think he meant not one of those alternatives

[@JeremyFacer]

Honestly as soon as they get the shifting figured out (not a grip shifter) and you can get a good frame with one I'll convert.

[@dudeonbike800]

I cannot stand that term for REAR DERAILLEUR! Everything on a bike is "mechanical," from your headset and brake levers to the pawls in your freehub body. It's a stupid, overly-generic term for people who cannot spell DERAILLEUR and have zero respect for the sport's history. I HATE how this UK word has crept across the pond and despoiled our beloved component. Mountain bikes were firmly established and the industry created in the US, let's continue using the proper term. Bikes have derailleurs, dammit!

[@DougieFresh13]

I wanna go pinion just to get the suspension benefits

[@wryanturner]

This video sounds like Cristina is reading cue cards from a script handed down by someone in Corporate.

[@PeterCPRail8748]

This was an inevitable progression since E bikes have been gaining popularity. This is great tech for older individuals that want to stay in the sport, people with certain disabilities, and individuals that want to ride but not worry about thinking and preplanning gears on a trail. For most of us this will be a non issue, as this tech will be very expensive for the next 5 to 8 years minimum. Plus it ads to much needles bulk like an ebike. Since a battery and motor is required. Also i dont see the chain and chain ring group set around too much longer. The pinion and gates gear box and carbon belt drive, or direct shaft is the future. No derailuers to break or strike. Smooth gearing with gear box at center gravity. Plus less consumable parts to replace. The fact that we are still using Chain, cassettes and derailers with all the past inovations in the last 30 years is a joke.

[@oldkayakdude]

Driven plenty of manuals (aka the anti-millennial theft device), even sequential shifter hyper cars with paddles. Loved the driving experience of a manual, but driving a no transmission torque monster of an EV is stupid fun. For ebikes, the new Pinion combo transmission and motor is where I'd prefer to see ebikes go. For acoustic, manual shifting will always be a great experience.

[@AM-pp5rl]

The equivalent of a off road jeep with an auto tranny....... Lol

[@snowholeoutdoors1769]

In Europe, 80% of the cars being sold are manuals. In the US, it's only 1%, and only 18% of US drivers claim to be able to drive manual. It's more of a competence (or better the lack of) as well as a certain degree of laziness to drive automatic. And no, I don't want an automatically shifting bicycle. First, I am very well capable of doing it myself. Second, I want to maintain my bikes myself. Third, I don't want to be stuck in the middle of nowhere with a piece of equipment that can't be McGuyvered to keep it rolling. Fourth, bikes are (too) expensive enough already.

[@Ferroresonance]

i am really just looking forward to wireless brakes

[@johnlesoudeur3653]

For e-bikes semi-automatic is is the next step but the use of a derailleur will decline as gearboxes take over this genre of riding. Next is the chain, after all the Porsche is not chain driven lol.

[@larryt.atcycleitalia5786]

Simple question - is it a toy we enjoy mastering and playing with or simply an appliance? Automatic, push-button, point-and-shoot things are the latter and always will be IMHO whether they are cars, bicycles, cameras or washing machines.

[@dustyburner]

Cant we just have one thing that we have to do ourselves anymore? Geez.

[@lukelackermayer]

nice ad-how much did shimano pay for this 😭

[@jimmy8x541]

it's so weird how i could tell this was a sponsored video from literally the first word that was spoken.

[@zeuszuki6698]

6500 rpm shifts on a mtb, now that I'd like to see 😮 Is that porsche running on 5 cylinders?

[@TypicalGuy84]

It's a boxer engine

[@ninjazzrhythm400]

I never heard of porche with 5 engines. May be youre thinking of the Audi

[@dudeonbike800]

That flat six sounded pretty good to me.

[@jonathanhowson6420]

Cable 11 or 12 speed is great thanks. Bikes don't need this. Cars don't need automatic gear boxes.

[@MikeesTexas]

After the launch of transmission and MGU, The only hope for saving shimano is CUES… I mean, I didn’t see any shots of Christina standing on this derailleur💁

[@Mp57navy]

So, a Pinion MGU it is? Right? RIGHT?

[@thegriff9425]

Over four minutes of preamble before we even start to get to the meat and bones. Waxing lyrical today.

[@moozeex1]

The 12 speed xt derailleur and shifters better be compatible with my e8000.I'm not gonna buy a 1x11 cog casette and new hub for it

[@SubversionGarage]

I could see fully automatic on some E bikes, but the standard will remain manual

[@DjDeepfry1]

Is that your 1976 Ice Green Metallic Porsche 911?

[@dennispikephotography]

Just seems unnecessary to me for MTB.

[@a.r.8850]

not something i have missed, but not having the right gear in place after a few berms really ruins the day

[@bikecontrolsg]

Next time autoRider just like auto pilot, you just have to sit on the bike the rest AI will do the riding hahah by the way the drivetrain remind me of Monty trial bike

[@Stomperproductions]

Pinions new MGU is way more impressive. Gearbox, motor, automatic shifting

[@TypicalGuy84]

At what point does it stop being a MTB? Big suspension, electric motors, automatic transmission or internal transmission, and ABS? Sounds more like an EV motorcycle to me.

[@TypicalGuy84]

Keep it simple and affordable. It's why we all loved bikes growing up as kids. It was our first taste of freedom and transportation

[@bendoesmtb]

@@TypicalGuy84 As much as i ride an acoustic bike, you are literally saying the exact same thing that people said about cars back in the day. "electric, boo!"

[@TypicalGuy84]

@bendoesmtb EV cars do the same thing as ICE cars. They take you point A to point B. By adding motors, automatic or manual transmissions, ABS and other electronics to a pedal bike you are changing it to a completely different form of transportation. I would say a cheaper motorcycle but we are getting close in price.

[@TypicalGuy84]

Sure it's a fun and exciting new tech but let's not pretend they're the same thing. It's like saying a hang glider and airplane are the same

[@bendoesmtb]

@@TypicalGuy84 it may be like that in your country, but here, ebike are speed restricted to 15.5 mph and therefore aren't going to replace vehicles any time soon I understand your point, but at the same time, why should we care about the tech? In the same way you can buy motorcycles without abs, you can buy bikes without them! I also think a lot of these ideas are probably smart. Derailleurs are stupid, let's be honest. Exposed to the elements, dangling off the bike, and expensive. If you have an ebike already, the fundamentally simpler design is a gearbox within the motor unit, as seen in eurobike. And then a belt rather than chain to reduce wear. I'm not saying all bikes should have gearboxes, but ebikes it's a no brainer. Abs, I can see useful on commuter bikes, as yes MTB having brake control is great, but for a commuter there is no need to learn not to lock rear wheels

[@eeeeknine]

Gets in the car but cant reach the peddals =) next take the seat is adjusted forward lol