The Future of This Channel

[@esperthebard]

I want to reiterate how much I appreciate all of you who do support my patreon and my books. You guys don't know how much that motivates me. The thought of helping and inspiring people through these creative works gives me such purpose in my life!

[@jakewarman7277]

Hey esper, I hope the support you've received from this video has been inboldening to your efforts. I know as an artist the self doubt of your work is a struggle, but you are truly a skilled artist with worth while and qualify content. Keep your head held high friend, KZbin is a slow burn at first for everyone I've ever seen but the light at the end of the tunnel will be there. Give yourself some grace on all of this. I highly recommend you try to give yourself more concrete deadlines and limit your expectations of yourself

[@MarvelX42]

I actually prefer disembodied voice over creators being onscreen. Most channels start out pretty good where they are voicing over their videos, but then later they do a face reveal and then it seems that they think they have to be onscreen as much as possible. I need and want to see what you are talking about, not you talking about it.

[@Thivan17103]

I think you have a problem focusing on a key target audience (so it goes up and down) and creating your own brand to stand out more. And you got all of it mixed into one channel - like some is more PC players, others are targeted for both PC and DMs, and then you got DM stuff. You got a big mix of content. This sort of stuff happens. I love your content as many creators don't really go into the detail and expertise you do with your experience. I am not really looking at DMing right now, so much of that when you post I avoid and go weeks or months before I see another video of yours. But, if I did I would like use your expertise to get going, show to my friends, or people I know who need help getting going. WoTC just gives crappy modules, so you get too many robotic DMs in 5th. I haven't seen something like that in your videos - I could be wrong, but that is sorely lacking for many new DMs. You could create seperate channels for each (put those old videos in those channels relating to it) and link them to others which might make your videos get extra looks, and see what works better for you by the views, comments, and interactions. This could place more work on you and I don't know your free time. But, would give you an idea where you should focus your brand and develop it more. Hope this helps.

[@KeyWestReviews]

Your new idea about this vs that! Keep it going man!

[@chefkochjay]

I am 100% here for Lore, history, thoughts, Rankings (due to YOUR comments on them). I also bought Espers Emporium (I'm a backer, even), I also receive your Newsletter, it is awesome. I am not here for active campaigns, though

[@esperthebard]

Awesome! Many thanks to you!

[@MarkLewis...]

@@esperthebard Yes, the only thing I'd add to that is I am here for the interactive campaigns, though. With campaigns, (you play with friends) if you can't do it like Crit. Role, don't do it. However, interactive where we don't watch you play, but we the viewers play with you. That Eldrich Castle was fun! Not going to be for everyone, but fun for many!

[@specterman603]

Same I agree with chef

[@toombs24]

What drew me in was the creature lore/mythology. You are blessed with a great "radio" voice and your articulation is amazing. I also enjoy your world building videos.

[@OneWhoWalksAlone]

youubes algorithm is killing many creators

[@esperthebard]

I've started looking into this. It's kind of shocking. There are channels that have been around for a very long time, with like 1-3 million subs, but nowadays only get like 5-10k views per video.

[@AGS363]

And it can change on a wimm.

[@WallyDM]

You are not alone with the wonky analytics, my friend, I think a lot of us are experiencing this. At times, KZbin can be a crushing grind for creators with just enough reward to keep us making more content. Glad to see you will be connecting with your audience more, because the best reward of having a channel is the good friends and folks we meet along the way. Keep up the great work, cheers!

[@esperthebard]

That's so true. I'm really glad to have met you and other people through this platform.

[@Rells2coolpeoplehavebadtastes.]

Very nice of you Wally.

[@Mr_Welch]

From my experience, you're only getting about ten percent engagement on any Videos these days.

[@bmmac6797]

I can give some insight, I spent like an entire year listening to your tier and lore videos to sleep. Not so much anymore. Never even played D&D but i used to read the adjacent books and games growing up. I think you're an awesome creator but theres probably a ton of people like me that aren't hardcore players. In a way your subscribers might not be a valid indication of the actual fanbase. Like when you DM the hardcores will watch and you'll get 1-2k views, but your old tier lists will get waaaaaay more. Hope that insight helps in some way, you seem like a good dude.

[@esperthebard]

Here's the thing-I still make tier lists. I never stopped. But the views on them have been super inconsistent over the past like 3 years. Some do well, some do so-so, and some basically kill me (imagine working a whole week but your job pays you nothing). This is the sort of thing I'm trying to sort through.

[@rogerwilco2]

@@esperthebard I don't have any suggestions, but I just want to chime in that we are slowly working through your back catalogue and enjoying them a lot. Unfortunately there are only a few quality focussed channels on youtube that can sustain themselves. It's not what the algorithm and tiktok generation find most attractive.

[@jquest716]

I love your channel and your RP Miniature stories saved me during the pandemic, I would constantly listen to them. Thank you for all your hard work and I really appreciate it

[@esperthebard]

I'm glad those adventures helped you through the plague times. I would LOVE to do more narrated adventures like those.

[@kevinsmith9013]

@@esperthebard INDEED.

[@chefkochjay]

PUSH YOUR PATREON MOAR! It sustains.

[@THELUBINTHEMORNING]

Yeah, people forget million ads a day. But they'll remember it eventually if it's consistent.

[@almostanarchybro9129]

I have watched for some time while I like the content I think the issue is the consistency. When you upload there are more random topics to expect some of which even as a fan I am indifferent to. Variety is great but most successful channels and dnd channels have somthing they consitantly upload. Comparing your last 4 uploads (excluding this one) they very wildly in subject and length. The other dnd channel I watch Dungeon Dudes very consistantly makes 30+ minuite list or review videos 2 times a week with some occasianal topic changes. Now I am not expecting the same thing for every channel but I think the variety (which I still appreciate) makes for a lack of consistant core fans that boost the views and watchtime. When watching your uploads it verys wildly on how many views It has in comparison. I do still love the content and wish you the best, most of what I suggested comes from Mr Beast he has made some podcasts talking about his strategys and success which even if you don'tlike his content he knkws how to get an audiance. Wish you luck and success man.

[@FilmshooterOH]

You're one of the reasons I got back into D&D after a many decades break. Thanks for all you do.

[@Fryguysun]

FWIW the tier lists brought me here like with many people. But going over my watch history the videos I watched are your D&D Lore videos (Formorians, Most Evil God, Redesigning the Outer Planes etc) and second, your videos on the 'State of TTRPG/DnD" such as your "Problem with Races" of DnD. One of my favorite videos of yours was your "Monster Sensitivity Training" video a while back. It was very fun and amusing and I shared it as much as my favorite tier/ranking videos of yours. Looking on your video history, it seems like I've seen about half of your videos these past few months, but I think I do actually have to seek them out instead of them popping up in recommendations IIRC unless its really trendy. I'll admit I don't watch much of your 'Adventure livestreams' and the like. I'd love to purchase more focused books. I don't mind size, but I'm not a big fan of encyclopedic compendiums. I'd purchase a Esper's Monstrous Manual or Guide to Dungeons or Esper's Mythology or Outer Planar Setting book very quickly.. .and the bigger the better. But I'm not a fan of books combining a little bit of alternative hero classes, some campaign setting stuff, a few deities and magical items, a modest monstrous compendium etc. Mainly because as a DM there's only certain things I'm in the "market" for so to speak and for example, I'm always looking for new monsters, new planar settings... new faiths etc. If you read this, I hope this helps and doesn't hinder.

[@rub-al-khali4265]

Due versus narratives! Example, red dragon vs. giant. Capitalize the MonsterVerse movie coming this March. I truly appreciate your context, but perhaps you may have reached your cap of fans? Perhaps expanding your DnD into other universe (godzilla, starwars, LOTR, etc.). Many DnD fans like other stuff, and it's always fun to come up with hypothetical secerios.😊

[@SigilWizardClassic]

From my experience viewing this channel starting from around the mid-4e days, I have noticed you have remained consistent in some aspects and evolved in others. You've already mentioned the "disembodied voice" over still images, and yes, the days of slideshow presentations on KZbin are over. There are tons of new ways videos are being made every day and many resources you can find online to help you. Here's a couple that I watch that may serve as inspiration... I've been watching Tales Arcane and I think his videos are very engaging despite them being talking head videos while images of maps pass by slowly in the background. The information is brief and clear, and the inspirations that I've taken from them have been many. You can still have visual aids pop up on the screen to show what it is you're talking about such as if you wanted to show how a GM can set up a goblin ambush on a battlemap, or discussing the appearance of several creatures in a tutorial on how to design monsters. Anto from Icarus Games is another one of my personal favorites. I like the challenge videos he's done and even the video series where he documents his creation process is fun and interesting. His videos have, in part, helped shape how I worldbuild. As for your videos, I've seen a couple of your tier lists... but I don't find tier lists too terribly interesting anyway, so I'm sorry to say that I skip them. Though your knowledge on many aspects of D&D and especially monsters is vast. How you utilize them (and how others can) could be the subject of several videos. I think an army of monsters you design would be a terror to behold. Your art is absolutely fantastic. I was impressed way back during the channel's start. It had that advanced yet imperfect look that made it unique. You've clearly improved since then, so now there is a mastery of sorts. You can make tons of videos showing your map creation process, character design process, etc. while offering tips and advice on how to get better while offering words of encouragement. Tools and guidelines on making new content is what I am always looking for and from what I understand, has a lot of value. Some of my favorite videos from your channel have been the interactive D&D games. Trials of the Neophyte, and Eldritch Castle are a lot of fun to watch. You could probably do one a year. It would be entertaining and you'd get a lot of engagement with your audience. Though I understand it would probably require a great deal of planning. In conclusion, I find your storytelling skills to be fascinating. You were actually the very first D&D channel I found in the days where D&D was rather obscure. 4e was something I had trouble grasping and your "tutorial" adventure (for lack of a better word) on how to run a 5th edition game with The Last of House Valosa was a big inspiration to me to start playing 5th edition. I gained a lot of confidence watching that video and it even inspired some homebrewed rules of my own that I am using for my Dark Sun campaign. Esper, you can go incredibly far, and I think you have some amazing ideas! I'm very glad that you have taken the time to make this update video. It shows your willingness to ask and listen to feedback from your community. I don't comment a lot on videos, but when I do that's because I have something to say.

[@DM_Kat]

When I need info on a specific monster I come to you specifically for it. I wish I could say I watch your channel for other things but I don't. I'll check out what else you do! The book, Kickstarter, and all that other stuff you talked about I had no idea about any of it.

[@RustyKeys72]

I've always loved the interactive adventures. I enjoy receiving the maps on Patreon as well.

[@zakurahiromatta4084]

I'm always here, and I love to rewatch your videos for amazing encounters. I hate to think you're struggling when you have some of the best D&D content. Especially your Bardcast VODs. They are great for while I'm at work. I may be a Minority, but your content always helps me, and I wish I could do more to help you in return ❤

[@aaronmcpherson1297]

sometimes we like how its set up, because its articulate, factual, we didnt come here to get your personal opinion, we like it ofc, we came here to learn, so dont over think it, you do great work!

[@MarkLewis...]

Dear Esper, You are my favorite D&D channel! I can't speak for the rest of your viewership, but (constructively) I have noticed an increasing and a very negative approach in your videos over (at least) the past 6 months. In my 40 years of experience in dealing with the public, you can count on several things from your customers and your clientele: "They will be very predictable at being unpredictable, if not fickle." If you have the ebbs and flows of high and low tides, you're actually an appreciated establishment. The question is, "How do I make my business explode with customers?" (Or in your case, viewing subscribers.) Here's a guideline I strongly recommend for any business and YT IS a business. 1) Know your clientele. (likes, dislikes, etc. 2) Supply a unique or rare commodity that you can excel at. 3) Networking. Connecting to people inside AND outside your main platform to increase potential customers by word of mouth. 4) Vigilance at diligence. 5) Recognizing and understanding why upswing and downturn patterns in your business occur. And probably the most important 6) ABP Always Be Positive. Psychology plays a HUGE role in a business. Not to manipulate your clientele, but to motivate your clientele. People pick up consciously and subconsciously on the vibes people give off. Not all communication is verbal. Usually how you say something is perceived far greater than what the message is itself. Always be aggressive, but positively aggressive. 7) Love who you are and what you're doing. 8) Sometimes take 1 step back so you can make 2 steps forward. Take a little break to fully recharge your vocational battery. The Enterprise can't always be on Red Alert and function at peak efficiency. 9) Listen to your customers. You will NEVER make all of them happy, but make the most you can enjoy being your customer. 10) In moments of confusion, take a deep breath and reread 1-9. the answer will be in 1 or several of these points. It's your channel, do what you want, but know we love what you do and thank you for doing it. Mark

[@lucasmesmo]

You know what I love about you, Esper… your constancy, man, you are always posting… though I confess I am not watching the videos cause they are just not into my field of interest - nothing with you. Eu não entendo nada de KZbin, mas vou começar a acompanhar pra dar uma força, meu amigo. Tu provavelmente não lembra de mim, mas eu lembro de ti e te considero pacas!

[@rogerwilco2]

I find your content of very high quality. I actually like that most of your content is not time sensitive, it doesn't matter if it is a new or an old video. Often when we have an hour to spare, we decide to "watch an Esper the Bard video". I find your insight and views on D&D content to be insightful and eloquent. I like it that you aim high. I respect you a lot. I understand that if the channel doesn't pay the bills, you will have to look at new options. I will see if we can contribute a little. I don't have suggestions, unfortunately our world often values volume over quality. Thank you for all your existing content and I hope whatever you do works out.

[@somewherelse]

I'm always glad to hear from you! I think that the advice that other creators are giving you seems really sound. Your books have an amazing amount of content and I think you might get more traction if you published more frequently. So dividing a book like monstrous heroes into multiple works would be a more efficient way to get people using your content. And once people are using your content they could be doing things like writing modules that use it. I can't wait for monstrous heroes! And I would love to see more shorts detailing more of the monsters in that project.

[@dave-daveson]

Hyped for Ichoria! And I enjoy all kinds of your content, regardless of you being in front of the camera or narrating over picture slideshows. You're by far my fave YT channel!

[@lead.farmer]

Here's what you do: go check out your videos over the last 2 years. see which ones netted you more than 50k views, list them all down and look at the commonality they all share. make more of those videos. no offense but the RPGs are spiritual experience... no one wants to see those. monsters causing tpk, powerful cr1 monsters, drow ranking... that's what people want to see. skits and playthroughs...perhaps not. good luck esper. loved your esoteric emporium book!

[@delance3721]

The newsletter is very high quality. I really like the list videos, and the video you did about Home Alone being about the hero's journey. I think your DM tips about how to make and keep combat interesting are very good. EEE has the best monster design of any monster book I've ever read.

[@Charlatano]

Hey man you helped me a lot when i first got into D&D and wanted to learn about it, I stayed because of your great narration and the amazing topics from your videos. Since then its always a great time when I see you in my feed. I do hate how inconsistent the algorithm can be in giving creators a spotlight to their audience. Im just a lurker, but I do hope the best for you and the channel.

[@torinmccabe]

Maybe look into creator communities that share each other's work as an alternative to relying on the algorithm

[@kevinsmith9013]

It boggles the mind that the narrated adventures aren't more popular. Honestly one of the best RPG entertainment experiences out there. I hope you're able to conquer the algorithmic dungeon, and claim the 250k gp of subs milestone!!! Monstrous Heroes is gonna be amazing, y'all! Huge boost to character and campaign options for you! Let your your whole gaming community know about these awesome opportunities for fun!

[@joshwhite1562]

Just found this channel a few weeks ago, but I hope you can keep it going!

[@Blazbaros]

The two recent videos where you drew the cosmological map and the god symbol with the bits of lore were really interesting to me. I love talking about worldbuildong and why we choose to incorporate the things we do. The campaign book sounds great too! I’d love to read more about Ichoros.

[@harveyspectre3512]

I only recently found your channel but I always look forward to your videos. They feel refreshingly authentic and it strikes me that your content comes from experience, not speculation. Keep carrying that torch!

[@squashedeyeball]

Proud of your journey, Esper! We're with you.

[@connorgerald6062]

Super excited for the Ichoros setting book! I always thought you’d make an amazing setting! I know I’d kill to see something like that for your old Novura setting. Or maybe a series of videos that break down parts of the setting? I still listen to your old narrated D&d adventures and short stories. I also miss your reviews of other rpg books like the Tiwidu source book. Maybe a monster ranking video for a 3rd book you really like? Sorry for rambling! No matter what you decide to do I will be here to see! Good work as always Esper!

[@FanZy0127]

Hello there, I'm pretty new among your viewers since I discovered your channel few weeks ago (began to be a D&D DM for a bunch of friends, used to be a GM for some Warhammer and L5R campaigns so far ^^) Thanks to this video, I realize you have a Patreon, I will get into this very soon, the maps look like a true deal to me, with everything else. 😊 Also, I saw few days ago that you created a very cool book, Emporium of Esoterica if I remember it well... I can't wait to be able to buy it ^^ Finished my diploma in December so atm I'm looking for a job, but promise I'll buy it, it def looks super cool :3 Also, be sure that what you do is really really cool, you helped me to discover many many things about the D&D universe. I can't wait to see your future projects. Keep going ❤ ^^

[@esperthebard]

Thank you, this was a real joy to read. Welcome to the channel and related enterprises!

[@BluestoneGargoyle]

I have been subscribed to your channel 3 times at least - and KZbin has unsubscribed me every time, for whatever reason. I've had to go looking for your channel each time, to resub. I'll keep doing it, because I enjoy your content, despite KZbin trying to make it vanish.

[@esperthebard]

That is so frustrating. I really wonder how many others YT is doing that to. In any case, much appreciate for your persistence!

[@TwoKnowingRavens]

I love all your content. Especially the nature of the "Stats" series and the lore videos. I love long form "let's play" with full length game sessions. Though I understand big long videos are risky because the juice has to be worth the squeeze. I listen to long form D&D and other ttrpgs while I work, along with science and history lectures.

[@esperthebard]

Thanks man! Always cool to see you around

[@StoryWeaverSteve]

You're A Bob Belcher living in a Jimmi Pesto world. You're work is amazing.

[@kevinsmith9013]

awesome. a burger for you and yours good sir 🍔

[@anathema1828]

Thanks for the thoughtful and passionate content- I’ve only been watching for a little over a year but love the content!

[@darkenedblade2585]

I came to the channel for the teir lists. I then listened to some of the lore videos which were great. Your teir lists are the best videos on the channel. They just are, regardless of how much effort you put into the other videos. I’d try combining your teir lists with what you like doing the most. Maybe rank the 5e premade adventures, and throw in a couple of your own adventures into the mix? The algorithm would churn that out. Other ideas: delving into dnd setting by setting, starting with very popular settings like Ebberon and forgotten realms. When people see those videos are fantastic, they will want to watch the videos of less popular realms such as planescape. You could then make a video on your personal setting. I think people like monster teir lists with a huge monster in the thumbnail. I think you should do a legendary monster teir list, which would be awesome. Finally, it’s hard to be a creator when your audience doesn’t match what you actually want to do. Should you care, is the question? My answer is not if you have the monthly teir list video, which could be about anything. Hope this helps. I love your videos.

[@m.w.3391]

Love your channel. I am broke, and unfortunately, I can't monetarily support you. I watch every video and hope that support is enough.

[@VonBeck411]

Hey, Esper! Please keep on being you. Your creativity and aplomb are what motivates me as I would imagine many others. I might be a reticent, bashful fan, but I so enjoy your enthusiasm for RPG! And remember as a Bard... "the prophetic invocation and styles of compositions"... Keep it up my friend...

[@bbluva21]

Naw, bro - for the record, this channel is criminally under-subbed, and in my humble but correct opinion, one of the best D&D channels on this platform -- probably top 5. The passion, thought, and fresh views speak for themselves, even if it's not backed by the algorithm. I don't usually comment long white knight passages patting even my fav KZbinrs on the back excessively, but it saddens me somewhat to see #TheAlgorithm once again bully a creative person into doing things differently than they want to; to conform to what's 'popular,' what 'works.' Make the tweaks you need to stay afloat, but don't let it turn you and your channel into something you don't feel passionate about creating for anymore. That's the trap they herd you toward. That's the long-term fate to avoid at any and all costs. Keep going, your work is great. 👌

[@JackPackBack]

I just found your channel, and I love your stuff, man. You have a a great manner of speaking, and a really good voice. I'm subscribing, I hope to see more.

[@Gashren]

2:20 KZbin has a main page? ;) I never use it, to be honest, I only use subscriptions view, and once in a while click on recommended videos to the side of currently viewed video.

[@Nazter69]

I have followed your Channel for a long while and enjoyed all of your content. Your one of the people that got me back into D&D after years away, I was a big first ed, and Second ed player & DM in the 80's and 90's played a little 3 and 3.5 and 4th but 5th drew me back and so did your content . I loved your Halloween vids and so much more your an amazing creator. So in closing thank you for some very amazing times spent in the wee hours listening to you and all my best wishes for your channel.

[@stuffstuff6932]

Personally I'm a big fan of high fantasy and your channel and your voice always sparks my imagination when thinking of different types of monsters, classes and archetypes in fantasy. Although saying this I'm not a Dnd player at all. As a viewer I really struggle to think of advice I could give you so my advice would be to try and get in contact with successful Dnd youtubers, or at least observe their channels to try and glean what they're doing to be successful. I know its not all that helpful but I truly hope you make it through this.

[@WinterWolf_NZ5179]

I have always enjoyed the experience of your channel and I wish outside of linking videos to my friends and saying hey watch this guy it's awesome, I wish I could do more to help out at the moment. You are one of only 3 people that I come to for inspiration for DnD and ideas for role-playing games. Thank you for the awesome service you have provided us all.

[@rememberstayangry2366]

Personally I love the format. The disembodied voice of the storyteller is a great driver of imagination. You can easily imagine a character like Elminster, Volo, Professor Snape, or other character telling you these stories.

[@richardrahl1001]

I came to your channel years ago on ranking monsters videos and lore videos. I subscribed because lore videos and a story video you put out that had a wonderful and insightful world to it (maybe in the middle of a lore video? It’s been a long time). You are “The Bard” so we are here for your stories and telling a of things. Your monster emporium is awesome! Your insights are creative and have led to changes in the way monsters and classes get used. Keep up with your poetic monologues!

[@JeremiahJones-gm6id]

Really enjoy your own lore stuff a lot. Also appreciate how much work you put into videos. You do have a great voice man vary professional sounding.

[@gazmataz9217]

I personally love the ranking videos whether they are monsters rankings or subclass rankings. Either way I’m a huge fan of whatever content you are putting out.

[@derrabbit7289]

I listen to KZbin videos while I am painting miniatures, doing chores or driving to work. So everyone is a disembodied voice.

[@JaydenBarker]

Can confirm, I watch all of your videos whenever I see the, but even with notifications turned on I don't see many of them as they go live. I still think you're great anyway though!

[@specterman603]

Just letting you know, ur probably my fav dnd channel, ur also incredible at setting tone and is really deep and thoughtful in ur analysises which i appreciate

[@THELUBINTHEMORNING]

Esper, my amateur opinion is what sets you part is emphasis on finding meaning, and connecting the game to deeper concepts. The other difference from other KZbinrs is how authentic and personal the tone is here. Other ttrpg channels feel more "produced", or more packaged as a product. That unfortunately is what the channel needs to get the success it deserves, as long as it can strike a balance between that, and your own vision.

[@chaoticcultivation]

❤ I've been a long time follower on my personal page for years with your old ranking vids, now I'm trying to become a table top creator myself so seeing you still going is motivating. Keep to the grind stone for that keen edge dude😊

[@squattingheads]

I miss the outlandish and kind of alternative miniature rp stories. Later editions sadly missed the VA cast. Also I think the Neo story did too much lore building. With these stories its better to keep it for the audience to try to understand how the world works. Especially with Dune out and successful, it seems like people are interested in more strange and non-western inspired fantasy.

[@zanecrane3687]

While I have been subscribed to your channel, after watching this video I made sure to ring that Bell as well. I am a big fan of your work and I hope to be able to see more of your videos in the future

[@Spiceodog]

I can’t speak for everyone, but I’d be fine with you splitting further books into 2 parts to have a more steady train of content .

[@danielmartinez5505]

Have you thought about collaborating with other creators? Maybe just start small like a voice over and see how it goes.

[@darkenedblade2585]

You could also partner with other creators, especially when you release your kickstarter.

[@TheAestheticDM]

As a fellow creator. I feel everything you’re saying. As a forever GM and creator, I’m mainly here for your world building and GM focused content. I’m rooting for you and hope you reach the stars and blaze a trail for those like me to follow.

[@AuthoritativeNewsNetwork]

going to be interesting watching the Grand Campaign develop. 👍

[@jackmclaughlin648]

I have to say, it would totally behoove you to release more books rather than longer books. Your content is amazing, and it feels like we’re getting more when it comes along quicker, even if it technically isn’t more!

[@esperthebard]

That's actually the plan for the next bit. Instead of super complex books that I have to work overtime for 2 years to create, I'm going to try some adventure modules that I can produce in just a few months. Thanks for the great comment!

[@jasonz7788]

You make quality videos! Thank you sir

[@adamxei9073]

You gonna me make cry 😭 stay strong! I’m here all the time.

[@TheGuidermichael]

I love your channel. Awesome videos as they are.

[@jimmybumcakes6130]

I think, unfortunately, most platforms are trending towards more short-form content, and perhaps finding ways to incorporate that into your channel would drive people toward the longer-form stuff you excel at. I only recently found you (after binging a bunch of Baldur's Gate stuff just in case this insight into what got your channel recommended to me helps), but I appreciate all of the efforts you have put into this channel, especially the recent D&D setting redesign stuff!

[@starcrafter13terran]

Comment 17! I'm starting to watch this video, and I noticed something. You don't pop up in my video homepage when I come onto youtube much. I don't understand why this is because I am subscribed. Maybe I'm watching too many non dnd type videos and it's pushing you down my list of things to watch.

[@esperthebard]

Is your default youtube the Home page or the Subscriptions page?

[@HowtoRPG]

I totally understand Esper. I experience the same issues. KZbin is not a career.

[@scottbloomfield3655]

I can't say for everyone but based on my experience. Watching other channels VS. yours, yours seems to be more inconsistent with the type of videos you release. Most channels have certain days of the week. They release this specific type A video on this specific day of the week or of the month doesn't have to be every week, but they are consistent. Your videos come out, and they all seem sporadic. The videos I like the most of yours is videos where you're either ranking the top 10 monsters of a specific type. Or a specific category or something along the lines but I never know when you're gonna release a new one. So every time I see that there's a new video posted and you i look at it and see, if it's the specific type of video of yours I like and if it's not, I don't know if I want to watch it because I don't know what kind of video it's. I don't know if I'm gonna be interested in it. I can read the title. But they don't always tell me what the video is actually about In the sense, if it's a video that's what im looking for and if it entertains me or Keep me interested and want to watch the whole video. I'm not sure how helpful this information of mine is for you, but I hope it does.. I also like your videos when you're talking about specific things that are in the books you release. Gives me more of an idea if I want to buy the book in the future or not

[@scottbloomfield3655]

I forgot to mention this, though. One thing you do well. I think it is the title of your videos. Are not click bait, Nothing makes me wanna watch a channel less than click bait videos

[@matthewanderson6769]

I enjoy your world building vids

[@thesagepilgrim4441]

A comment for the algorithm.

[@jeremyanderson8433]

Really shame to hear of the challenges you have been facing. You create great content!

[@Gargantupimp]

5:00 to 7:10 This is why I show up for your videos. You see the deeper meaning and you outline it for us. It's not just about the clicks and the memes and the jokes with you, instead you bring the heart, and I just want to say thank you for that.

[@GrinWatch]

Love your videos man. One thing you might try is to add more sound effects and especially add hardcoded subtitles, it does increase the viewing time from my experience. Also activate the multi language subtitles so more people see it around the world. Last thing is people love behind the scenes stuff, like how you create or prepare to write your book. Keep at it legend 💪

[@redfaux74]

My opinion is.... 5E is stupid. It is dumbed down. It limits you personally. I think most people don't even play it. They say they do. They buy the books for the cool-ish art. They watch EwwToob videos. It's like Hollywood, Disney, Marvel, DC, Star Wars, etc. People are sick of stupid changes, they've boycotted, moved on. But they're the big dog now and have the power ($$$) I guess. Until they don't.... Just look at the best movies. Bigger, stronger, faster, tougher.... 5E has become the opposite "for game stability". 🤢🤮 Look at the Tarrasque for example. 😂😂😂 "You HAVE disadvantage"?!? 😢 You HAVE prone?!? Just stupid. Go back to core rules of DnD like initiative, dump this nonsense and do you. You're shackled. No one wants to play a "safe" board game that's not even remotely close to a board game. Sanitized DnD is stupid. You're in an uphill battle. Everything in this game today is anti Esper. You're just too smart to play kindergarten rules. You are so critical in your videos of this lame system and how dumb it has become. Why? Because it is. You're giving life support to a Zombie. Start moving on asap and push that red button when you're ready.

[@fhuber7507]

Gamers canbe flaky about what videos they watch. KZbin is NOT GIVING ME NOTIFICATIONS and rarely shows your videos in my recommendations. Subbed, notifications are on... I knew "How to RPG" was going to do a video and searched for it and couldn't find the live stream until it ended. This is how bad KZbin is about pushing their agenda videos instead of the channels we subscribe to.

[@KermodeBear]

Your strength is in your voice, your ability to tell a story, world and character building, and communicating thoughts about conceptual material. I love your content when it goes beyond the surface of the game (which is much of it). Your world-building videos are amazing and thought-provoking. I generally think ranking videos are boring - but yours are different, because you also consider the lore and talk about how it can be improved. It's more than just "yeah this monster has cool abilities." You go deeper than that. The lore videos are great, too. I'm very disconnected from the official D&D lore. I've been playing in home-brewed games almost exclusively my whole gaming life, but when I watch your videos I get inspired with ideas and concepts that I can apply elsewhere. And when you dig into the problems of D&D - the magic system video, for example - you do an exceptional job. It's not about rolling the dice. What makes magic - well, magical? How can you produce that feeling at the table and allow magic to instill a sense of wonder? And that's what I think separates you from other people who do TTRPG content. Many of your videos aren't really about TTRPGs. Well, they are, obviously. But only on a surface level. They seem to be more about telling stories. That is your strength. You bring things to the table that, quite frankly, very few people are even capable of offering. The sad part is the content that I really love the most doesn't seem to get as much traction. For example: Examining Home Alone through the lens of Joseph Campbell's work and the D&D alignment system. Amazing video. I loved it. And I can tell how much thought and care and time was put into it. But only 1.8k views. Your character monologues? Like "The Best Thing an Orc Can Say." They're short, so they're easy to consume, they're well done, they're fun, the give ideas. They're applicable beyond D&D. The great thing is that someone can be playing a game, and, well, it's time for The Big Bad to say something! Well. Load your video, press play. But only 8.5k views. I don't get it. These should be hits. I can't imagine how frustrating that must be. Much of your content is thought-provoking. And I wonder if that's part of the problem. People want the quick hit, the fast answer, the flashy fancy amusement park experience. That's not really what you offer (the tier list videos being an exception - that's a popular thing many people seem to enjoy). They don't care about making magic feel "magical," they just want to roll fireball's 5d6. Sometimes it feels like you've been slaving away all day to create an amazing, five-star, world-class feast, and when you put it on the table, someone reaches for the ketchup and squirts it all over the plate. They just don't understand what's in front of them. I love my dog, he's great, but if I took him to The Hermitage Museum he'd wander around and end up peeing on The Kolyvan Vase. Okay maybe that wasn't the best metaphor, but I think you get the idea. :D And fighting the algorithm? Hell if I know, man. Everyone complains about it and rightly so. As something near-zero-effort to try, have you considered uploading your content to Rumble? It has a 'follow my KZbin account' feature so once it's set up you can set it and forget it. Not sure what the pay structure is like.

[@writernightly2397]

More facecam is a good call. Other d&d tubers like Matt Colville just talk to a cam every video. WebDM is (or was) just two guys talking. YT seems to like that. Maybe invest in a good lighting/background setup with some ambient light? The most engaging d&d content seems to be "helpful" in nature. Homebrew and advice to run the game smoother. Also ideas for adventures, challenges, weird monsters, puzzles. I think your "tier list" videos are the most popular because they give DM's ideas, but are also just nice to listen to in the background. KZbin enjoys the "I did a thing" style video, like your vid of "I'm redesigning the D&D planes". I think vids where you "fix" certain aspects of d&d and share it with the viewer could do well. I'd also personally like to see more Ichoros worldbuilding, could be popular in the context of a "how to build an rpg world" video. YT has also become a long form platform where vids push 30 minutes to an hour or even more. Ppl like your voice, so prob vids of you talking lore, mechanics, game philosophy, storytelling etc for 2 hours straight would do well. "2 hours of the weirdest d&d lore" or something? As much as I love your rp campaigns like Eldritch Castle and Trials of the Neophyte, its clear that the audience for such content is small, especially for all the effort put into the videos. I think future content like that would maybe be more worth it either as an adventure module you sell, or behind a paywall like a gumroad or your patreon or something. I think those that do watch really love it but its more of a hardcore thing.

[@robmatheny2412]

Yeah honestly you’re my favorite dnd KZbinr but there’s nothing compelling me to subscribe to your Patreon

[@writernightly2397]

I also think good vids you do are trying to answer an interesting question like “who’s the most neutral god?”. Questions that would be fun would be some like “Are clerics just pleasant warlocks?” “What does the alignment system actually measure?” “How impressive should a natural 20 be?” “Are the d&d gods even gods?” Just random ideas but I think could both get clicks and be entertaining to hear you ponder about.

[@shadomain7918]

I don't have a YT channel, but I sympathise. Perhaps you should describe earlier in the video specifics about what patrons might get? "This month in my Patreon we've got an article on... and a free monster", etc. But yeah, I've got nobody on my ko-fi, so I may. not be the best judge.

[@DrLipkin]

I'm a forever DM, and I found your channel via your ranking videos. I watch any new ranking videos that come out. I also tend to watch any video that is commentary upon the game itself or the state of play. But videos that are appear to be (I say appear, because I don't end up watching them) strictly lore centered don't get me to click. DnD lore is a mess, and WotC is constantly rewriting it anyway. Ranking videos discuss lore, but they also go into mechanics and your own opinion. It's an aid to me as a DM. Likewise your videos on current events are both informative and editorial. I've never been tempted to check out or purchase your books, because I don't trust homebrew that is sight unseen. Even Matt Mercer, the most famous active DM, puts out absolutely dogshit homebrew content. If I don't know someone's design philosophy, I'm not going to take the risk. I guess my question is "who are you making content for?" DMs? Players? Casuals? Yourself? I'd personally be interested in videos that address game design, but I don't know if that would have broad enough appeal to be worth your time. My favorite content creator right now has nothing to do with DnD. He's a streamer/youtuber named Joov who almost exclusively plays Bethesda video games. But I bring him up because he has a really ingenious work model. He plays challenge runs, which takes him many hours of investment. But he plays them entirely on stream, so while he's making the content and getting the footage, he's also engaging with his audience. After every stream, he puts the VOD onto its own channel. After the run is completed, he and his editor go over the footage and put it together into a compilation, turning hours of content into a digestible and humorous narrative via voice over and talking heads segments. He spends a lot of time streaming, but then milks it into three different content streams. I'm just wondering if something similar wouldn't be possible for you. Maybe creating monsters live on stream, then making a scripted video about the final product (intercut with clips from the stream), and then after playtesting and editing, the monsters end up in a book. Or making a scripted video talking about a subject, but the topic was inspired by something that happened in the mega campaign. This would allow you to throw in clips from the session, and throw people to the longer version at the end of the video. (I'd suggest putting the mega campaign on it's own channel. From my understanding, the algorithm doesn't like different types of content coexisting.) I've definitely enjoyed a lot of what you put out. But for whatever reason, I've never hit the level of fan that finds every video you make to be a must watch. I don't know if what I've written is helpful, or hell, even if it's accurate. There's a saying that applies here. "Consumers are very good at identifying when something is wrong. They are terrible about knowing how to fix it." IE, you go to a doctor because you are sick or injured, you don't tell them how to resolve your issue. I've tried to articulate what I like and why, but I could accidentally be entirely full of shit. Unfortunately, there's nothing for you to do but try new things and hope for the best. I wish you luck.

[@perry9262]

Hey Esper --- Im getting into my first campaign in a while, and while I was talking with the other players, we ended up talking about creators that we like in the D&D space, and you were the first person I thought of. I've been a fan and follower for a long time, and just wanted to say that regardless of whether you're videos consistently reach a certain threshold of views, your passion and love for this hobby bleads theough everything you've put out. I think you have a great ability to articulate the depth and differences between the various monstrous entities that make up the D&D bestiary ---- you're capable of making those monster descriptions and stat-lines feel like more than numbers and words on a page. I really think you may have some success talking about some of the same groups you've discussed in tier lists, but instead of using that format, I think you could really make some awesome long-form content that talks about particular figures in the lore, how maybe you've incorporated them into your setting. I don't know if that's helpful, but I do hope if nothing else that you know that you've made a real imprint on this community, and I'm here for whatever the future holds. Cheers to you, and to here's too many more tales from the bard 🖤

[@s-o-tariknomad6970]

I can relate about the task splitting. I have been making a massive Fantasy RPG for the last few years, but last year I decided to split it into 4 books, and I've finished the first one's body (still waiting on cover art tho). When it's done, I may send a digital copy to you, as you really have influenced how I write RPGs, specifically Monsters.

[@LevattWolfheart]

I enjoy the lore, but my favorite thing has been the solo adventures, which I discovered years later. You do a great job narrating and I felt completely immersed in the stories, especially Trial of the Neophyte. The problem is... I don't think I'm a typical KZbin Viewer. I hate high view count videos, what they do that is successful, doesn't speak to my interests. Sad to say but you probably shouldn't appeal to me if you want success lol.

[@firestorm165]

If I may make a suggestion (more of a request) a DM workshop series might do rather well. I've actually tried working on a couple of campaigns myself; one involving the players gathering men and material to upgrade an old derelict keep in preparation for a siege and another which I've dubbed the Drow Partisan campaign where you work with some Drow trying to break away from Lolth conducting raids and such against a better equipped, better trained, numerically superior and heavily entrenched enemy. Unfortunately I'm rather stumped at how to turn these ideas into a functional campaign so they've been shelved indefinitely

[@xxTerraPrimexx]

With more of the old school revival, could you focus on updating the 3.5 to 5e? Maybe bring back the deadliness of 3.5 era (or percieved deadliness) and make your version of 5e that? Personally I am more of the hardcore DMs (as someone pointed out) that likes the gritty ascetic but also the high fantasy of 5e? I do appreciate that might lose some of the other viewership though so this is quite the catch 22 lol. Keep at it!

[@seanhansz2864]

I enjoy your channel. I particularly enjoy the adventures you develop in the short format (the neophyte, etc.) I’m not big on watching live group play as my pet peeves get triggered (players taking far too long to optimize their turn). I find value in what you do, thank you for your passion translating into something great. Sadly I’m not a patron of any KZbin channel due to a lack of resources. Sorry!

[@krishollow]

I constantly get recommended videos from creators who seem to be specifically women or people of colour. Constantly. 40 views, 130 views etc. I keep trying to remove them. The content is fuken awful. I hate it, even searching for things is a total nightmare.

[@helixxharpell]

I just watched Matt Mercer's how to play dagger heart video. He's giving out the rules for free BUT.. the game requires materials that have to be purchased. Lol. When you have his money & influence its easy to give out cocaine and make you buy the straw to use it. 😉 oh yeah. And the mirror comes separately with a cost.

[@TheRagnarok428]

Hey Esper, 1. You have really pretty eyes and i love seeing your face in videos. I also love the art too, dont get me wrong. But i think adding in your face is a good idea. 2. I just realized i hadnt subscribed, ive rectified that. I love your channel. 3. What separates you from other youtubers in my opinion is the artful way in which youre able to convey stories, emotion and all these great monster inspirations. Other dnd youtubers inform me about mechanics or make me laugh. You inspire me.

[@UltraDonny5000]

I can't commit to patreon but I do like buying things that content creators make. I prefer books by D&Dtubers because I like your takes better than WotC's and want to support good games. Your content gives me trust to take the chance with my limited resources. I ordered Monstrous Heroes because WotC didn't make Savage Species or templates for 5e. I don't like watching other people play games but if a channel would make a campaign into an animated feature or even a graphic novel, that would be really cool too.

[@tech9d]

I'm gonna make 2 comments, this first one is just why I enjoy your content and channel and the second will be whatever suggestions I have. I love your channel dude, you got a nice voice, I used to listen to your playlists to fall asleep too, especially the older ones when you did funny voices. I personally enjoy that kind of stuff. You have given me so many creatures to use for my very first campaign and inspired me as well! Never give up Esper! The YT algorithm sucks but I think you're aces!

[@raymondsmith4315]

I've been subscribed for years now. My only real criticism is the occasional political digression. I feel like you're better than to be occupied by some second degree reactionary talking point. Even in this video, just in my home page I have some political stuff; but it's generally a reaction channel, and I get recommended plenty of reaction content that doesn't get political too. I have it on questionable authority the algorithm is rewarding people who do shorts? I am satisfied with still photos and narration. I think you're at your best when you're praising the good stuff and roasting to dumb ideas. Have you considered making reaction videos to other people's dnd videos? No matter what, I love the channel.

[@thesagepilgrim4441]

Another comment, this one for Esper: I’ve only recently found your content, and I love the design of your videos, from the opening quotes to the choice of soundtrack. The only thing I’ve encountered in your content that gave me pause was a comment you made in your Oozes video from some years ago. In that video you drew a hard line between a setting like Strixhaven and what you consider true fantasy - in such a way that could come off as very alienating to some listeners. However, I do tend to agree with you about the loss of representation for fantasy lovers in the vein of Robert E. Howard and his peers. So I suppose what I’m trying to tactfully say is that even though the current D&D trends aren’t really reflective of what hoary-headed fans may love, growth requires new blood, and some younger hearts are easily wounded. I’ve noticed that in more recent videos your language has softened some, so perhaps my thoughts are wholly off-base. Anyway, love your videos, here to stay, and wish you the best.

[@stephenmiles8473]

First, i love the wisdom you have to offer us all and is what keeps me here along with your sincerity and appreciation for the art form which is story telling. As for how i found your channel all those years ago? Truth be told i stumbled upon it, while going down the more obscure youtube rabbit hole a D&D video appeared and the rest was history, however finding that video was certainly luck and as you mentioned, the algorithm. As for the popularity i have theories but its not something i can see you doing, if after all these years of watching your videos i think i've learned enough about your personality to say you don't lean towards the silly or goofy style of content creation a lot of the more successful D&D youtubers have and benefit from. In the last 10 years D&D has seen this wave of popularity, from children watching there parents play into being adults themselves, tv shows making it "hip" so a younger audience wants to experience it but i think a larger one is the populous in general we live with today in the western world is for lack of a nicer word, soft. They don't like gritty conflict or sensitive subjects, they think dark and grim truths are less appealing than overly happy, silly, goofy and ridiculously fantastical misadventures. And lets be honest, real D&D isn't always sunshine & rainbows or politcaly correct, devils sell souls & torture, evil overlords conquer and enslave, the lords who are supposed to protect us sometimes use us. Its the reality of a medieval existence. And i think where you honour that reality the large quantity of again lack of a better word, snowflakes, don't gravitate towards it which sadly does also make up possibly half or more of the current D&D community on an international level which has this knockon of causing the algorithm to bury your channel unless someone who appreciate the classic style of play finds you. Its a sad thing, because your content even when minimalist in nature in regards to visuals (stills with narration) holds significant knowledge and i've lost count of the number of times i have been sat there thinking of ideas to throw at my players and i hit a wall and thus need to return to the font of wisdom to aid me in my hour of need. But in short i do think appearing may help your odds, some folk enjoy a form of face to face interaction when they watch a video so it may very well be a good idea to pursue that further. For suggestions i have some but tbh, i don't necessarily think i like them but i do think they may have an effect. 1. would be streaming, i find a lot of people have success streaming when people just looking for something to watch finds it and i would say the number of "live" content is much smaller than "posted" content. People looking for a new or random steam have a smaller sampling pool for live content than posted content. Which may herold some new viewers who appreciate your work. 2. It could be helpful in the short term to have a guest appearence, someone the D&D world is aware of and will if only for the title come and view you. Admittedly, i don't like this one, 50% of people will likely view and leave, 30% will subscribe and leave and the other 20% might subscribe and realise they just stumbled upon a gem enough to continue viewing your work. But sometimes a jumpstart is what we need for the algorithm to take notice, afterall im pretty sure its designed to take note of sudden interest spikes in case its a new trend lord google wants to take advantage of. If i had to suggest someone, i myself would put forward someone like Bob World Builder, his content is usually pretty grounded and informed and where im sure there is silliness present, its not nearly as bad as some others i've seen. Plus he sits in a similar bracket subscriber wise, maybe having a sit down may hold some youtube insight into how the machine can be used as a tool (as it is supposed to be anyway) rather than this bbeg its turned into. Anyway, stay strong Esper, you are a force to be reckoned with, a master of your craft and perhaps the most knowledgable DM i have encountered on youtube or any other platform. Keep up the good word and come hell or high water know we all stand behind you.

[@christianstudtrucker1892]

I like watching videos that contains monologue without additional visual information during my way to work. I use public transportation (Germany) and cannot always look at the screen. Just my thoughts 😊

[@floodcomics]

I love your disembodied voice! Couldn't care less about engagement. Only thing I noticed is that in the last year or two your usual justified critical view, which I have always much appreciated, has been tilting toward the negative and dissatisfied - which in a way I understand, what with 5e being what it is - but it often makes me think you would be more happy talking about a grittier setting like Dark Sun

[@drekbleh7081]

The thing with KZbin is, it's primary purpose is to get people to stay on the site to watch ads. This USED to being about engaging content but now has been seized by a modus operandi of screaming hatef*ck ragebait and opposing factions who demand a crushing conformity. The worst part is that being earnest and somewhat humble means you get shelved. It just sucks.