The Gerald Undone Challenge

Everybody loves Mr Undone. The KZbin bros line up around the block to circle jerk with handsome Gerald, but I for the life of me cannot find any of the great guru's cinematic work!

[@freshmediaconcept]

You’re hating and I’m a fan of EOSHD, Gerald never proclaimed to be a director or even proclaim to be the king of real world tests. What he does is give technical/ functional reviews of cameras and he does a great job of doing so. It’s no different than a American Football Quarterback coach or basketball coach that teaches great shooting fundamentals, but themselves never having any professional careers playing.

[@FelixCervantes]

So you go to Consumer Reports for your next auto purchase? How could you judge a Leica with out taking images with it. He was invited to New York for an Atomos event. Atomos took the group out for a video walk. Gerald was the only one their without a camera, that says a lot.

[@ringopaulusch]

I found his work - 252 videos on his channel.

[@PeekHike]

Man, I love your talk! That's so true, That's exactly how I feel too!!!

[@xiyangyang1974]

You are the last man we can trust. Which camera should we buy?

[@vedadrokkor]

Well done. We need more opposition on youtube…not just klickbaiter gang.

[@EOSHDTV]

Somebody has to break the circle jerk. Otherwise it's going to be like an online cartel.

[@bencorwin]

@@EOSHDTV You guys are hilarious drama queens.

[@rsmith02]

The KZbin stuff is aimed at beginners. If Andrew wants to make better conceived videos for a more knowledgeable audience there is a (smaller) market for them. As with anything filmmaking is a funnel and more people enter than make it to proficiency. Selling gear to beginners is easy (and sadly lucrative) so don't aim content at this market.

[@robmcd]

This gem going to make a resurgence. I love Gerald and won’t hate on him because I like his videos. But the last line said in this video is the fracture of KZbin reviews as we know it.

[@friedpicklezzz]

I kinda lost your train of thought halfway, but overall I personally visit filmmaker channels for the creative image, and visit the likes of Undone for a technical analysis. I don’t think a single person needs to cover the whole filmmaking spectrum.

[@EOSHDTV]

He stole my audience. Revenge is due!

[@rsmith02]

Not sure if that is a joke but the internet is a big enough place for all. If you resumed your focus on how to get the best out of equipment and showed real-world use cases (as you are a capable shooter) you could find a new audience. The petty sniping at camera companies and KZbin reviewers is off-putting and doesn't help me any as a viewer.

[@EOSHDTV]

@@rsmith02 It's a joke. I don't do revenge as the assassin I usually call got into an accident in Russia.

[@avarmadillo]

@@EOSHDTV Revenge never seems to me to be a sufficient motive for action---especially when the offense was an unintended result. Truculence never draws a great audience, except perhaps in the boxing ring. I don't think Gerald, or any of the others, have ever been out to get you. The fact is people are increasingly so visually oriented, so passively minded, they're simply not up for the labor and personal effort required to read and reflect on what they have read by their own meager and diminishing powers. They'd rather be told what to think. Passivity is a bane of our infovideo age. All that notwithstanding, when I consider those who do video "analysis" on youtube, it does seem like its come down to a small, self-congratulatory clique, all in cahoots in some weird sense. It's hard not to find it, like all cliques, offensively exclusionary---especially the self-congratulatory part. Having said that you have so much to offer---I would use all that positive content to give your own videos a positive rather than a negative purpose. Just my 2 unsolicited cents.

[@BackusCreativeImaging]

I just found your channel today on a comment on the excellent Camera Conspiracies channel. You're a breath of fresh air as well, binging your videos Andrew. I'm tired of the shilling :)

[@EOSHDTV]

Welcome to the channel. It's the tip of the iceberg, what goes on in this industry. Time somebody blew the whistle on it. Hope you like my future videos. Cheers

[@BackusCreativeImaging]

@@EOSHDTV So I'm coming back to this video for some good laughs Andrew. Gerald Undone has been raised up as some guru but like you've eluded to ... where's his footage? I think that's a challenge that actually can't be completed lol. Also, I love all your other videos, especially the Phillip Bloom one and death by a thousand Canon fanboys ... you were in the right. We live in a world of shills, they have no honor. I like your attitude. Anyways, here's my footage: kzbin.info/www/bejne/m6KpZYVtbrN1aa8 - The difference between me and Gerald Undone is I actually made my own PowerGrade in Resolve featuring my custom manually created VLOG-L to Rec709 LUT using the DSC Labs ChromaMatch Pro Color Chart. Took lots of experimentation. I also shoot VLOG-L correctly in the field with middle grey at 42 IRE, meaning this video only took about 10 minutes to color grade. Let's see Gerald Undone shoot log footage properly. I'm still looking for his footage but it's nowhere to be found. I hope you are doing well Andrew :)

[@IchinShek]

Sometimes I forget that people make videos for a living and are trying to sell me something. Then I get the notification that 8 camera tech reviewers have release their unbiased opinion on a must-buy f4 zoom lens that's 4mm wider than the norm...

[@Pedro_Santo]

I actually never searched for his work as a filmmaker. I do like his reviews on gear and opinions on the technical side on things. Keep them coming Andrew

[@EOSHDTV]

Yes I do like his gear reviews although don't always agree with the conclusion like with the Sigma Fp-L. It would just be better if we got to see the images he made, I don't mean paid or for clients, I don't care about that - but I do care about cinema!

[@Studio23creation]

I don't see the point of this video. Seems just like anger, but for nothing. Let him do his camera reviews, even if he doesn't really shoot for a living. It has been a few years EosHD is only anger, anger, anger, bad vibes. That's enough for me. get your shit together man, try meditation, sport, and party with friends.

[@xiyangyang1974]

The problem is that consumers pay double price to pay for the marketing.

[@rsmith02]

@@xiyangyang1974 KZbinr marketing is extremely cheap for companies. They're saving money overall.

[@jesseyules]

You'll find it hard picking a fight with Gerald I think. He's a great guy. And works super hard.

[@EOSHDTV]

Why do you think I am 'picking a fight' with him. It's not personal at all. I sometimes think the British humour goes over many peoples heads. It would be boring if we all patted each other on the back all the time and said 'great job' with an inane smile on our faces

[@RCodyWanner]

check out 9:50 of his “answering your most frequently asked questions” vid - he addresses this question directly

[@PaulKretz]

I placed the time-coded link above.

[@RCodyWanner]

@@PaulKretz a lot of times posting a link in someone else’s comments gets auto flagged as spam

[@PaulKretz]

@@RCodyWanner Sure. But mine seems to survive.

[@avarmadillo]

This is true. Gerald is not pretending to be something he is not. And, IMO, as good as his reviews are, his lack of practical use does show up in as a notable absence in his videos as a lack of analysis concerning practicality and use-ability. His lack-luster review of the X-t4 seemed discouraging. But, for me, it's is the ideal camera to shoot run and gun video. If I hadn't disregarded his discouraging review I would never have discovered what a flat-out joy it is to shoot and edit.

[@rsmith02]

@@avarmadillo No one reviewer will cover all use cases (and Gerald working in a studio is very different from me working in the field) so I'd just consider it as a data point.

[@guerrerosdigitales]

I bought your EOSHD 5 and loving the results. Can you please tell me your honest thoughts on the Sony A7Riii and A7Siii? I have both and I am not planning to upgrade until they both die.

[@ZachAshcraft]

Gerald has said as much in a video that he doesn't do professional cinematography, he just does technical camera reviews. Theres still plenty of value in that. He doesn't need to do both. Just like you don't see Deakins doing KZbin reviews.

[@EOSHDTV]

If Roger Deakins said 'buy this' and Gerald or Potato Jet said NO that's wrong 'buy that instead'... who would you trust the opinion of most?

[@ZachAshcraft]

@@EOSHDTV The point is Roger doesn't say buy this. Nor do Gerald or Potato really. They just share their experiences with the cameras. Their experiences just happen to be different than Rogers

[@rsmith02]

@@EOSHDTV Neither. The equipment Roger Deakins uses is utterly inappropriate for someone on my budget without a crew. His lighting course was similarly flawed- I'm just not in that world. If Gerald gives pros and cons of cameras in a thorough way it informs my decision. Don't really watch Potato Jet. I also watch working wedding filmmakers, etc. as their needs are similar to those in documentary as I am.

[@EOSHDTV]

So - all valid points guys. I hadn't seen Gerald's explanation about the lack of shots, so my bad on that. He has in fact been up front about it. I also agree there's plenty of value in his reviews, they are very detailed. I still think there is a big circle jerk going on though - a clique. It is very hard to take as somebody who has been working my ass off on EOSHD for over 10 years, to suddenly find myself as a complete outsider in my own industry and to have my audience all disappear and get sucked into the KZbin circular quid-pro-quo of hype artists and marketeers. I don't like what has happened to our community. Big shift from written reviews to glossy reviews in the style of marketing videos. I don't count Gerald as chief amongst the hype artists - FAR from it - but then I don't know him, never even met the guy from all 10 years of doing EOSHD. So it is hard to tell what is really going on and what the relationship is between these guys, whether a manager is involved, how close their relationships are to the PR divisions of camera companies and links to retailers. I think the danger is, reviews become consumerism and fandom. A cult of personality. This is something we should avoid. I've seen it with Philip Bloom and seen the tribal behaviour. Camera community can be more than this. We can ask more searching questions of the camera companies and products, and of each other. Reviewers can break away from the PR relationships they all think are so valuable. It is very one sided actually. They are being used. We can do much more to promote the smaller innovators. Why should Sony and Canon gobble up 99% of the attention? What about Magic Lantern? Small accessory companies? Controversial stories? The genius on my forum who makes Lidar AF modules for Blackmagic cameras? Let's see more of a spotlight on this, and less BIG BRAND HYPE!!

[@MojoPapiFPV]

@@EOSHDTV There are definitely those cases like Potato Jet that are just the unfortunate side of the business model, but Gerald brings something of value to the table. Maybe I'm a rare case, but I haven't bought anything Gerald has recommended because I use what I use, BUT he has saved me from buying things I have been tempted to get, precisely because the "influence" was so strong on some of those products. I feel I can count on Gerald to give me a no BS assessment and cover almost every possible consideration I would have. Also it keeps me highly educated on the subject matter, because I do work as a DiT and DP on a lot of those cameras and it helps me help the filmmaker get the most out of those systems and avert potential issues later. I think of Gerald Undone, as "continuing education" for my "Minor in Mirrorless."

[@Murmeldyrful]

Well then - where’s your work? Don’t know who Gerald is but I DO know that you calling yourself a filmmaker is a bit of a stretch.

[@daniellmiller]

Anyone who has been a viewer of EOSHD over the years can easily find/see Andrew's work. Not that hard. I don't qualify as someone who can say whether it's storytelling/filmmaking but it certainly is a lot more content than I've ever seen from Gerald. I think Gerald's skill is evaluating gear NOT filmmaking.

[@krewcialofficial]

@@daniellmiller just editing videos doesn't make one a filmmaker. Andrew's work is at least very inconsistent (and I'm being very gentle here), for instance his F1 video has exposure levels that are all over the place. So to start attacking people online when you're not very capable yourself, is asking for trouble.

[@bigmichis]

This anti consumerism lecture was brought to you by someone pourpously putting camera bodies worth 20k next to other gear in the frame. For more insights into the fine art of product placement please share, like and subscribe!

[@rsmith02]

Gerald states he enjoys cameras and the technical side of cameras. That's fair and if he wants to make well-shot and well-edited videos about technical aspects of equipment I will watch them if it's something I consider buying. For the actual art of movie making I prefer Marc Bone on KZbin and the actual filmmakers I know and work with for inspiration.

[@freshmediaconcept]

Exactly, Gerald doesn’t stray from who he is. You know what you’re getting. That doesn’t mean can’t be monolithic. It’s basically a tool and assessment, you choose the tools that work best for you. Some are multi functioning while others are not. Doesn’t mean that one shouldn’t exist over the other.

[@freshmediaconcept]

So what if he said that, he’s not obligated to show you what he’s working on. He’s not obligated to do anything that he doesn’t want to do. He states the purpose of his reviews and nothing is wrong with that. Andrew is hating like a 5 year old child.

[@rsmith02]

@@5guysproduction234 In a recent Q&A he said the opposite of that. That he used to do such corporate work, didn't find it fulfilling and that he really enjoys camera technology and explaining it, so his current work is what's on his KZbin channel. I accept that explanation and he owes us nothing further.

[@thirtyinthebin]

Gerald didn't steal Andrew Reid's audience. Andrew Reid alienated his audience. This video reminds me of the narcissist, salty articles Andrew posted when he wasn't invited to some camera show. Where is Andrew's great cinematic work? To build his defence, he includes a few shots from his own videos - camera tests disguised as music shorts he made 10 years ago. I bet he would've loved to be featured in the opening clip he nicked from Gerald's channel, but his invite got lost in the mail again. I think Andrew Reid is about 5 videos away from going full John McAfee and filming himself licking the dirt off his shoes.

[@freshmediaconcept]

This is Andrew’s problem, he’s overly emotional and not in control of his emotions. This is why you have a talented Kanye west who was given the short end of t he stick with his ambitions then you have Virgil who was given the keys to the car and success because he’s less emotional. Andrew is a talented guy, but the scale of your success depends on other people and connections. Overly emotional people choose to fight every battle and never make it down the road of success or take longer than those who choose their battles. In life there will always be people you see getting more when you are just as qualified or better, but you don’t hate or call them out. Continue to do you and success with come, but it won’t come when you throw temper tandrums when things don’t go your way, even if it’s justified. I’ll leave with this “ life is 10 percent what happens to you and 90 percent on how you choose to respond” Get in control of your emotions sir, your a talented guy, every shortcoming doesn’t need a battle or outcry. Choose your battles and stop worrying about another man. “ what he eats doesn’t make you shit “ Success will come the minute yuh decide to control your emotions and responses

[@Rtomasie]

That is exactly it, Andrew feels as though as these "new" guys owe it to him like they should kiss hus feet and pay tribute. This dude has a massive ego and attitude problem, and that is by far the biggest obstacle in his path. If you are a jerk who is constantly antagonising people no wonder they don't want to play with you

[@tifose30]

love this! keep it up

[@firehorseweddingphotograph3995]

“Gordon’s alive?!” There’s a Brit. Zero BS, just honest reviews.

[@avarmadillo]

Gordon's great...just, IMO, too much vlogging---enough!

[@grdnzrnic]

apart from politics, you're the kind of nerd I can respect

[@ageabletvlovecansaveus]

Love it

[@peterchatterton]

Brilliant.

[@KenTheoriaApophasis]

who loves ya baby , thats right, right here

[@orangejjay]

Micro Four Nerds and her friend who also has a channel would like a world. 😂

[@Justin_Allen]

Hm. So what. He has already said he is not a filmmaker in the traditional sense. He does however occupy a space that is needed and that is the analysis and dissemination of information that others find valuable. And I am not a "fan boy" or either Gerald or Phillip (just look at Gerald's giveaway post). However I am someone that finds his information valuable and useful.

[@freshmediaconcept]

Phillip bloom is all over the damn place and isn’t consistent. He’ll do a 2 hour review then forgot to say a few of the most important technical aspects of a camera. With Gerald you know what you’re getting with every review. He doesn’t proclaim to be something he ain’t. He reviews the technical aspects of it and doesn’t a excellent job. He’s not a real world reviewer but doesn’t mean he can’t exist in the space

[@rsmith02]

@Maciej Jan Długosz It's a data point. If a review shows that a camera won't meet my needs I won't spend $200 renting it.

[@pallabmajumdar3026]

Well said, Sir; and we do still watch the BBC in India and adore it. It rocks the English news scene

[@_________1863]

Might as well just title this video "Okay, Boomer"

[@EOSHDTV]

OK Bloomer

[@_________1863]

@@EOSHDTV I saw Gerald's Livestream where you were in his chat commenting and complaining that he wasn't responding to you. We've seen you on Twitter sharing his videos and interacting with him. We've seen you do this same routine before with the camera store guys where you're friendly with some KZbinrs and then suddenly become anti-KZbin once their channel starts blowing up. You've already done this before Andrew. This video has all the credibility of a Logan Paul apology.

[@PK-ql5en]

Most of those KZbin bros are not real photographers nor filmmakers. They are mostly reading spec sheets under the guise of ‘reviewing’. The problem with that is they sound smart but because they are all repeating the same things over and over again you can clearly tell they were given the same marketing blurb to read and guidelines on what needs to be said in their videos. Which ultimately makes them sound stupid and lazy and unable to present any fresh thought about the gear they are trying to sell. My point is I would rather follow a photographer/filmmaker, who may even not be the best one, but is actually using his/her gear all day long and knows it in and out. For some reason these type of people usually steer away from a particular camera brand that is super popular with all the KZbin bros.

[@freshmediaconcept]

Stop it! The two are not mutually exclusive. You can have both reviewers who do real world tests along with technical functioning analytical tests. My point is that both can serve a purpose while not shitting in the other as being less useful

[@rsmith02]

Gerald Undone isn't really in this category as he uses high-end equipment like a $1000 test chart, colorimeter, etc. to actually test camera accuracy, light accuracy, show how to grade log, etc. His reviews have a technical rigor most of the others lack (though he has his limitations, he's not an engineer and is relatively new to this type of reviewing. So it's better than most but not the final word).

[@peterhall443]

Really appreciate your candid attitude - it is getting increasingly more difficult to find impartial reviews / information on the internet. Google is no longer a search engine… it’s an addiction. Do you use an autocue? I get distracted when you look away.

[@bergjoe23]

Brilliant I'm waiting for the revenge. Love this dude in real life.

[@KenTheoriaApophasis]

now make a video about the silver haired click weasel

[@EOSHDTV]

Silver haired click weasel, he of TONEH fame, better be afraid. He better be very afraid. Pest control is on the way

[@noraahyhanska1522]

Keep them coming Andrew!

[@BackusCreativeImaging]

Where's Gerald Undone's 1 minute / 1 click Power Grade in Resolve of all shots in a single video? Here's mine: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aZSqfGWLnNOebJY - Where's his footage? Andrew, I still can't find his footage. I don't think this is a challenge anyone can complete. Not fair. I love your British attitude by the way. How dare the Canadians! I love it :)

[@PaulKretz]

Gerald answered it here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5iaqoZnbairbcU

[@damiancanteros]

Support comment.

[@Sneaky-Sneaky]

Nice way to remind the ‘addicted to hardware’ gearheads……that they’re just TOOLS…..

[@abletenor]

finally some professional talk, keep them coming Andrew!

[@nathanpaw]

Funny!

[@TheBlacksheep1967]

There are answers for everything those days in the net (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jealousy)

[@marinrealestatephotography]

To be fair to Gerald, he recently mentioned in a video that he doesn't do a whole lot of shooting outside of his review videos. Also, he does seem to be a victim of the system as much as MOST of the other youtubers: you need to talk about the latest and greatest cameras to get views and one's cinematography skills don't really matter. Also, in support to the Brit's I enjoy watching Extrashot's videos.

[@RockyColaFizz]

As a Canadian born, Naturalized American Citizen, I can say that Canadians are just awesome. However, you do have Gordon, Phillip, and several others from the UK. Our parent is still relevant to its children across the pond. :)

[@PaulKretz]

Actually, Gerald told he had German origin. Just like me, BTW. Although I'm not in Canada =)

[@RockyColaFizz]

@@PaulKretz Well. Pretty much all of us Canadians came from somewhere else. Except for the native tribes. Which crossed the land bridge from Asia. So even they came from somewhere else I suppose.

[@alexiscosar8980]

Keep it up mate 👍🏻 we’re still here ;)

[@guillaumevalli5031]

I like your blog man, but you should do a bit of an internet fasting.... Undone never pretends to be other than a lab boy.

[@yohannsphotographyvideogra9542]

Even if people say you are a shit stir! I think you are a talented fellow that has great humor with great attitude and a sense of fairness. will Waite for your 1 million subscriber .

[@bovinicide]

Andrew, you should check out the spat between Gerald and Alister Chapman.

[@rsmith02]

Alister embarrassed himself in that one. It was quite unfortunate for him to trot out generational differences instead of treating Gerald with respect.

[@skymakai]

where was this?

[@easkate]

all of your content is from a negative point of view. you are very salty

[@bencorwin]

Huh? Tech talk is completely different from cinematography. Why are you demanding that he show his cinematography work? I don't get it.

[@TyroneLT]

I think the misconception is the idea that these people buy cameras for the purpose of shooting professional projects. That’s the wrong point of view. The reality is buying the cameras serves more so the purpose of their KZbin channels to review products for their viewing audience. Nothing wrong with that to be honest. What needs to happen is viewer expectations need to shift. If you switch to the Sony A1 just because Gerald Undone did, you really need to consider your priorities. I upgraded to the A7SIII last year and I don’t think I’ve seriously watched a camera review since then because I don’t need a new camera. If the idea of seeing these guys buying multiple cameras within a year bothers you then simply don’t watch. Maybe the content isn’t for you.

[@rsmith02]

Well-stated. Once you have what you need there's no point in focusing on equipment.

[@24framestime]

I’m happy I can get all these different point of views. I have to say Gerald’s (also Gordon Laing and other’s) take on the Sony A1 really made me consider buying it instead of an R5, because I’m looking for a reliable camera for professional work, both stills and video. I think I’ll greatly miss Canon’s ergonomics, color science, DCI and IBIS, but even if I’ll be shooting with an Atomos I need a reliable camera that will not ask for crazy recovery times if it overheats and I think even Andrew agrees with that.

[@TyroneLT]

@Maciej Jan Długosz it’s all about priorities right. If you’re looking at the R5 vs the A1 then what Gerald or any of these other KZbinrs has to say can mos def play into your decision.

[@TyroneLT]

@Maciej Jan Długosz this is true for some KZbinrs but guys like Gerald always make it clear before starting any review what the relationship is between him and the product he’s reviewing.

[@24framestime]

@Maciej Jan Długosz actually the A1 has improved weather sealing according to reviews. I had an A7III for 4 years and never had an issue with it. I tend to keep camera bodies no more than 5 years anyway, with the exception of my 5DMk3 that is way too beaten up to be sold. I’m really really afraid I’ll miss Canons R5 body ergonomics, color science, DCI video, lighter to carry RF lenses than their Sony counterparts and crazy IBIS, but I tend to work on long days shooting and even if I’ll use a Ninja V+ recorder I’m really scared to have the camera shutdown and ask for too much recovery times. They say it overheats from the moment it’s on even without recording and then even if you’re shooting stills it further reduces 8K and 4KHQ / 4K120 recording time. I just can’t see myself shooting all day with the timer fear in mind 🥵 And I really do very much prefer Canon’s footage look than Sony’s, but I need a reliable camera :-(

[@matthiass5751]

👍

[@reflexfilms]

Gerald is Royalty - His execution on presentation, skill, knowledge, analysis and set lighting is proof enough for me. I like both of you for different reasons - Vengeance is a dish best served cold. but Gerald is like Bambi or Princess Leia - untouchable. Plus He's crazy! As a commercial shooter - i agree with your points - knowing your menu and the camera inside out is key to not looking like a tool on set. So real shooters shift bodies irregularly. The downside risk are too much for little visual quality gain. (Stoked S5 / Panasonic Native 16mm - 200mm Pro lenses shooter)

[@jacobeickhardt84]

You have the courage to call out their bullshit. Well done sir! We would not want those idiots to destroy the dream or creativity of those without money for very expensive camera Gear.

[@brelliace6425]

Andrew Reid. You logic is allmost the same as asking a professional Formula 1 driver "why there is no material of him driving in the Rally cars". Like why is everyone interested about hes formula 1 driving but where is the Rally driving im interested in. I stopped visiting EOSHD because of too much bitterness and whining of other peopples success. Stop focusing on other people and start making, teaching etc.

[@BigAntVideo]

It's wierd - I literally tried to find anything he created only days ago as I quite like the dude, but failed miserably. Glad it's not just me :)

[@rsmith02]

His channel is his creation. His videos look good and are well-edited. Beyond that I assume he doesn't have direct experience and that's okay!

[@BigAntVideo]

@@rsmith02I understand your point, but there is a difference between shooting to sell cameras and views in a nice controlled space, to using them in a high stress environment with a lot of money being spent and seriously anxious people all around. In these times decent menu structures, non-corrupted files, no overheating, no limited record length, fast to access self created presets and fast access to all important features become super important. I find Gerald very engaging though, and take his opinion into consideration. However when I meet a professional who has actually used a camera in anger in real situations over a period of time, I trust their opinion far more.

[@24framestime]

I’m a long time EOSHD follower. It’s true that I lately felt that there was a lot of ranting from you Andrew. I agree with everything you say on your website and channel but I think you could say the same things without so much bitterness, and more of that very pleasing humorous tone you can have, it would better convey your message. I actually don’t care about others cinematic work. I’m happy I can get all these different point of views and reviews. I do pay attention to whether there seems to be marketing ties involves with brands and i do take everything with a grain of salt. From here and there I compare the information. I do really much appreciate Andrew Reid’s pure practical viewing of things from a filmmakers perspective. But I have to say Gerald’s (also Gordon Laing and other’s) take on the Sony A1 really made me consider buying it instead of an R5, because I’m looking for a reliable camera for professional work, both stills and video, and his review actually helped me be more sure about that choice. I think I’ll greatly miss Canon’s ergonomics, color science, DCI and IBIS, but even if I’ll be shooting with an Atomos I need a reliable camera that will not ask for crazy recovery times if it overheats and I know you agree with that.

[@avarmadillo]

An entire tsunami of specs and micro-analysis---all designed to sell, sell, sell. You're on point, Andrew. There's something disingenuous about it all. The one point that trumps all else for me, but is often shunted off to the side by reviewers: usability. After all was said and done for hand held video my choice was and is the X-T4: a joy to shoot and edit. Your own footage looks great...and yes, the opera of Mr. Undone seems scarce to none. I've often thought that weird. Being a career youtuber---strange in my mind. Shouldn't you actually have a real career?!? I'm just asking.

[@rsmith02]

If you're passionate about equipment and education then creating educational technical videos is a perfectly valid career. KZbin is just a distribution means.

[@markusaurelius8807]

Good point, Andrew. Shill cliques are tiresome and spam too much. We need more of you on KZbin and elsewhere online (and offline). Honest unbiased reviews and uncompromising opinions, no bs. That's why I keep reading your blog - you are straightforward and tell what you think. That is why your reviews are trustworthy. Also you as a person have a unique vibe (not a typical plastic fake-ish presenter/smooth operator), which adds character to your texts and videos. Keep it up, man!

[@hcepeda]

Andrew against the world. Chill out man, we all know why those KZbin channels exists. Don't spend your energy talking about the other.

[@freshmediaconcept]

This is why his success and growth is stunted. He’s not in control of his emotions. Leave emotions at the door when it comes to business. Andrew is a talented guy, but is always seen as the kid who yells “but why is he getting the spotlight and not me “

[@mesatc2]

Dogs Bollox Andrew! Piss them all off...breath of fresh air old bean. Subscribed.

[@simonc4764]

You remind me of Steve Coogan. Ever thought about going in to comedy?

[@krewcialofficial]

he would have to be funny first.

[@katsahu2131]

Andrew it’s all about brewing up a persona and getting an audience who will eat it up because they don’t know any better. On KZbin that’s a cinch. These make believe gurus dub themselves filmmakers without having made real films. Gerald Undone is not a real world professional. Nothing in his background except maybe some still photography gigs show it. He is what you call a camera technology fan who’s trick is to keep straddling the line with a certain style of delivery, between adopting the lingo of a professional and, when he gets pushback, backing off into confessing he’s only a camera nerd. He doesn’t do it with bad intention I guess he just can’t help himself but play like guru, telling pros how to do a job he has never done himself. There has been oodles of proof on this over years with wrong information he has put out. You can call him a professional KZbinr though, that he is.