The greatest hot dog topping EVER! Just like NYC Hot Dog Carts!

[@glenng7085]

Ex New Yorker living in Florida , Watching at 2am😂. I've got to tell you your recipe is one of the best representation of NYC ( back in the day) hot dog pushcart onions that I've seen. I'm so freaking hungry right now because of your video , if I had all the ingredients home right now I'd get up in the middle of the night and start cooking!! Looks absolutely delicious 😋

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you! Make it, you'll love it

[@billthomas6296]

I am a retired owner/operator of a hot dog cart and would make red onion sauce every day. I must say your recipe is darn close to my own. I am going to give yours a try because it looks good and I have not made any in a couple of years. Hope to see you make some more videos, I just stumbled across your page and glad I did. Have agood one.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thanks for watching Bill! I hope you enjoy!

[@k.i.m.withkim9512]

Can you please share your recipe do we can compare? PLEASE?

[@eugenesedita]

What’s that chemical name cups of stuff you used?

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

@eugenesedita water

[@thomaskoval8524]

Great recipe.

[@ericsmith688]

Thank you Sir! I lived off these when I was a Marine on the USS New York for fleet week in Staten Island and Manhattan 2011. I would eat 2 of those dogs with onions and a Powerade for basically breakfast cause I was sleeping off my drunk the night before. The burps that you have all day taste like the onions making you want more. Haven’t tried the recipe yet but will soon. I’ve been searching for this for awhile. Once again thanks bud. I live in Bama so we don’t have it like those lucky mofos in NY. Best dogs I’m the world!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you for your service! That's about the time I fled NY for the warmth of the Sunshine State. Enjoy the recipe, and thank you for your support! 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

[@pennyschuerch2806]

I’m in Ny and I can remember going to Brooklyn naval ship yard area and there was a guy selling these hotdogs. Amazing is all I can say.

[@Shuggies]

I will be making this one day... if you would take 1 tip from a well aged cook, I'm a grandmother... try using a Potato Starch instead of Corn starch...WHY?? I'll tell ya 🙂.. corn starch ,when it get back to room temp, goes watery every single time and you have to add more to make it thick again... Potato starch won't do this... it will stay gravy even when you can it or freeze it or even just pop a bowl of this onion reish back in the fridge to use next week.. and this sauce you made will store a fairly Long time because of the sugar and vinegar ... I certainly appreciate you sharing this recipe... thank you 😉👌

[@socalmacguy]

My mom and grandma would take me to bingo with them on Long Island back when I was a little kid (mid 1970s). There was a lady there with a hot dog cart that had these onions. I’ll never forget them. Definitely gotta try this!

[@tomstestkitchen]

Excellent looking sauce, I also use cinnamon in my Hot Weiner sauce.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thanks Tom! That little bit goes such a long way in this recipe. Thanks for watching, and good luck with your channel!

[@Oddzilla51]

As a native Detroiter, I grew up with Coney sauce on hot dogs. But I sure do appreciate and love some red onion sauce! Made it once for a party and all my family and friends loved it, too!

[@deucenahaff]

Many, many years ago, back in the '70's, we used to get dogs from a guy, a NY transplant, who sold 'em out of a panel van at an intersection leading from Albuquerque to Rio Rancho, NM. I'm sure he's long since past, but we've NEVER been able to replicate that exquisite, savory sauce he topped 'em with. But, dude, I think this is IT! Gonna whip some out tomorrow. Thanks

[@roadtrip2943]

There was an old dude with a cart in the bronx at Harris field, 6 baseball fields in the 60s who used wood to cook everything. What a smoky taste. 2 dogs for lunch between games. Never had a better onion sauce since

[@MrPhilsAlabamaHotSauce]

I am a native southern boy with absolutely amazing memories of pushcart hotdogs when I visited New Your City as a young kid. Something abut dirty water hot dogs and that amazing onion sauce. I can tell you how many southerners I have turned on to this great condiment. You certainly can't find it in markets here, but I have made so many variations of this over the past 30 years. I sell my hot sauces at local farmer's markets and curb markets in my local area. Often times, I make a couple of dozen jars of red onion sauce and take them to the market. The people that buy it ALWAYS come back on future market trips and buy additional jars. Unfortunately, I don't always have it there with me and the people who have previously purchased are pretty upset when I don't have it. Thank you for your video and recipe. You include a few spices I have not used and I can't wait to try it your way. Again, thank you for your instruction.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you for your support, I hope you enjoy my version! Do you have a link to buy your sauces online?

[@TheTowerMacMaolain]

The interesting thing is . A lot of New York City water is delicious and my sand hog relatives would say that the lucky New Yorkers are the ones tapped into a hard rock aquaduct that was built in the 1700s. I do know that the water we had in San Diego when we moved there in 1972 was horrid. My grandmother would complain how she hadn't been able to make a decent pot of spaghetti since moving west. Then she realized it was the water and would boil all her food in bottled spring water and it certainly improved ten fold at least. Grandma was a smart lady and I would pay good money for a plate of her pasta that I didn't have to stand all day in the kitchen making and put up in the fridge for two, three days for it to be just right. But she was right. The water is everything

[@MrPhilsAlabamaHotSauce]

@Tower MacMaolain Oh I know. I used the term "dirty water" hot dogs because they are known by that name in many parts of the country.

[@ricanbrave]

​@Alabama Hot Sauce correction nys call em dirty dogs and it's not cause of the water or anything it's when u see them rubbing tired feet , and then start to wonder where in the he'll do they go to the restroom 🚶‍♂️....ya welcome

[@DeeRodriguez_BallerinaFaLife]

Anyone here that’s not from real NY, I can confirm that he’s spot on when he says it’s a NY hotdog! Excellent job, Sir!

[@imari2305]

Born and raised in NY and I have to tell you, your onion sauce looks really good. Whenever I get one from the vendor I get it with everything; kraut, ketchup, mustard and top it off with the onion sauce. It's my favorite next to a chili dog which I've actually added the onion sauce on top and it's killer. Thanks for sharing.

[@frusengladje6680]

You eat them exactly how I do. The red onion/spicy mustard combo is the best.

[@luispagan4758]

Truly

[@markmcandrews1703]

Love the commentary. Subscribed. Thanks for the video.

[@bulkvanderhuge9006]

"We'll do two of these 'cuz I'm fat" had me laughing. Also, potato buns are the best, MARTIN'S is my go-to for Burger Buns as well.

[@anthonyjordanmoviesandmore2470]

I grew up in New Jersey this was always my favorite hot dog topping I have to make it myself living in North Carolina Beach North Carolina chili and coleslaw by Miles

[@johnsambdman7278]

Thank you for your recipe. This is an honest take on an amazing hot dog topping. I appreciate your time to present this. You are a great American.

[@dc704]

Omg that looks so good. I could just taste it through the phone😋. Cant wait to try this recipe

[@DugEphresh]

Dirty water sauce, yes sir! The king of condiments on the NY hot dog carts, mmm I could go for one right now. Thanks for posting brother!

[@ronaldyeater3322]

Going to make this this weekend🤙. Tip hot dogs when start in pan add few tablespoons water at first so steam, cook inside then outside will cook after evaporated. And on grill get loaf pan on top shelf with hot water don't boil, then when someone wants a dog put on grill for marks, takes 1 min cooked all the way through no burning👍

[@johndavidson940]

I've made this a few times. Instead of using separate seasonings, I've simplified it with using Ketchup and Chili Powder. Makes for an easier cook and comes out very good for dogs and brats.

[@larryhubert8101]

Like that fancy word for water was great

[@danmcclellan2451]

Definitely giving this recipe a try this weekend! Here in Michigan we have kogel hot dogs ✌️ thankyou!

[@irlairwin2071]

In Arizona we wait for KOEGEL on the road every year to get our supply of Vienna’s.

[@301250]

Absolutely superb onion sauce…..the best in the world!

[@Baltihunter]

I’m going to try this. I make a spicy one for Jamaican food. It’s called onion spicy & it cooks in vinegar sugar chilli and thyme until just soft. 10 min. Then serve it cold 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🇬🇧

[@robc.5745]

I use the jarred sauce, But got to try this , And i like to use it on Johnsonville sausage patties, Yum.Thanks for posting. From NJ.

[@chriss4835]

Thanks for putting the actual recipe in the description. Of course Ill rewatch when I go to make it, but it's nice to have a written reference.

[@MRFRAG911]

This gonna sound stupid. Where do i find the description?

[@ws4835]

Beautiful recipe and sauce.

[@mikestein2207]

Looks awesome! I'm in FL too and the store bought is just okay. I'll have to make this. Looks pretty easy.

[@wayne00k]

Just found your channel and this wonderful recipe. When I was just out of high school I was waiting for the Army recruiter to complete my enlistment in the coming October. A neighbor of mine got me a summer job at the auto parts warehouse where he was a manager. The people were great - all Teamsters - but I hated the job... except for two things. At lunch time the "roach coach" would roll onto the lot and sell a sausage sandwich covered in "red onion sauce." The second best thing was that we were right across the street from a Wittman's chocolate packaging shop. I always got invited to sit at their picnic table in the shade of the only tree on the block... and I always ended my lunch with one of the Wittman girls wiping that sauce off my chin. I'm telling you - this is the sauce that dreams are made from! Cheers from Philly

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Cheers to you my brother. Thank you for your service!

[@wayne00k]

​@@SugarSaltFatBoozei just looked through your recipe list - I'm looking forward to trying many of these. Thanks for sharing them

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

@wayne00k thank you for watching! This weekend, i have a great recipe for baked beans coming out

[@dccmealy7358]

Delicious! Thanks for the recipe, using it for Fathers Day :)

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Enjoy! Cheers!

[@tameekam6735]

You've made me fall back in love with hot dogs!! It looks soooo good!

[@Patrick-i7f]

An Excellent Cooking Video. Highly Recommended. Than Yo Very Much For Sharing.

[@alittleofeverything4190]

I'm in. Thanks. I agree with the comment about a splash of balsamic vinegar, not much. It adds a thing.

[@johnd1536]

I love to cook and I lived in the Bronx as a kid up to 3rd grade and to this day still remember the hot dog carts around Fordham rd and going into Manhattan. Don’t live in NY anymore .I’m going to make this and slop it on my dogs! Love your video !

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you! Enjoy the taste of home!

[@marcusvictor49]

I always wondered what that was thrown on my Hot Dog that we got at a NYC cart. Best Hot dog i ever had and I love that you gave this recipe cuz im gonna make this bad boy for sure.

[@jonathanniccolls1592]

Just watching this video, is addictive! I want to make this recipe, really bad. The sauce, the backtrack, and your New York accent narrating, makes it addictive! Yeah, you're more of a Oscar Madison kind of guy, but that's ok. You give us the freedom to use & make any type and brand of hot dogs, buns, and condiments we want to use. That primal grunt @ 7:39, is priceless! I pine for the day, where I get well enough to go back home (an amputated leg, is a big deal), and make this dish! Thanks for posting this.

[@The_Zilli]

will def be checking out this recipe. thanks for the share.

[@vincentrussell7246]

Out of all the videos on this recipe u explained it well and wrote the ingredients down no one else did so I saved this one

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Mine is the best, because I'm in it!

[@joeschmo622]

It's funny, because I was nodding along when I was hearing of the same ingredients as I did my first time trying to emulate hotdog onions. Only I boiled them instead of frying (no oil needed) and the tomato paste mixed in sooooo easily. Bitter from the paste, so cut it with sugar. Hate the stank of vinegar, so rather than putting it in at the end, I put it in earlier so the stank boiled off but left the tang. No starch for thickening, as I just let it boil down to concentrate the flavors and thicken up naturally. And I confess, I did let them thicken quite a bit to become almost "sticky", so I could eat them and not wear them. Didn't do much with spices, and the mix you had looks reeeeally good (the cinnamon surprised me, but yeah!), so I think I'll do that next time. Whatever I didn't use on hotdogs, I just ate with a spoon rather than fridge it. 😂😂😂

[@MrAdmiralKush]

Had to leave New York and move abroad and really miss hotdogs. They have them here but they are hard to find. After being away for two years I finally found sourkrout. This was the last thing I needed to find out how to make and gonna try them this weekend. Thanks for the vid

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Enjoy it, and thanks for watching!

[@yvetted3612]

I finally made it! I love it!!!! Your recipe is the best one I've tried. Thank you

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Awesome! I'm happy you liked it!

[@crazybobdj]

You nailed it, Bruh! I followed your recipe &I just nailed it! THANKS!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank YOU! Glad you enjoyed, thanks for watching!

[@wayne00k]

Wanted to say this morning I prepared your recipe and another claiming to be from Brooklyn - I skipped all the rest that started with ketchup. Brother - hands down yours is The Best! I can't imagine offering anything else to our guests this Independence Day. Perfect balance of sweet tangy and sour. I'm going to ask my wife to wipe this off my chin... just like in the old - OLD days :) [see note from day before. ] Cheers Friend

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Love it! I'm making a fresh batch this weekend to celebrate America's birthday! 🇺🇲🇺🇲🇺🇲

[@warchitect73]

Dude right! Ive looked for the recipe forever! that it just hit for J4! YES!... You can get it at the stands in SF, but hard to recreate!

[@wayne00k]

@@warchitect73 this works friend. Whomever you share this with will be thankful Cheers

[@nateroo]

I bought Blackie's hot pepper relish and Walter's sweet mustard and tried them on my hot dogs...I guess ya gotta go to those joints and have their original dogs to get what all the people who rave about 'em are talkin' about. I wasn't impressed with their signature condiments. BUT THIS... this recipe is A-BO-LU-LY fantastic! It reminded me of hot dogs I had when I stayed in Secaucus and worked in Weehawken and would cross over through the Lincoln Tunnel to Manhatten and grab me a few hot dog cart dogs to take back to the Secaucus Embassy Suites. That oughta let you know how much I like NY dogs... thanx for puttin' this recipe online. I'm on the west coast and this kicks our dogs up a few notches!!!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Love this! Cheers!

[@davehanson9394]

Nice recipe.. I've not seen Mustard Powder in a NY style Red Onion Sauce before. You say use fresh garlic. I agree. The jarred garlic I do not think has much flavor. However for this sauce, I do get lazy. I use Ketchup, Chili Powder and my current favorite hot sauce is Choula. I like the ease of preparation.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Not for this recipe, but for a lot of other things I'm addicted to the Cholula green sauce

[@valerieneal2747]

​@SugarSaltFatAnother good green sauce is one you can buy at Trader Joes called "Green Dragon Sauce"....its absolutely DELICIOUS!!

[@greylingmccray1136]

Wow , you answered a prayer , i used to eat them all the time when i lived in NJ, Now at 64 i can do it myself. Thank you

[@infoscholar5221]

Been saving this to watch since it popped up in my feed a couple weeks back - I'm from Alabama, but my roommate in colege was from Long Island, and he introduced me to a version of this. I've been making my own version for twenty-odd years, this stuff is A-Mazing, do yourself a favor and make some soon. You'll put it on everything.

[@lovelygirl630]

I just found your recipe!! I was searching because today’s dinner will be hot dogs and I wanted to make it with onions just like the best hot dog stands in Newyork!! And your recipe looks just like it! I’m about to make it and by the way don’t pay attention to the hater who is bitter about Newyork , I appreciate you sharing your recipe… Thank you 😊

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you! I hope you enjoyed it! Who doesn't love a good wiener!

[@The_Cobalt_Lair]

I have a batch of this sauce simmering even as I type. I’ll be cooking hotdogs tomorrow & will top them with it. I cooked it today so it’ll become more flavorful in the refrigerator. I’ll let ya know how I like it after dinner tomorrow.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I'm sure you'll love it! Cheers!

[@k.i.m.withkim9512]

Well??? Inquiring minds want to know! You’ve not responded so did you not like it?

[@markkasper7281]

fantastic tutorial well done

[@theodorerussell3578]

Yes I love your hot dog onion recipe wow it's amazing I will use it all ways

[@porksandwich5693]

We used to call this Sabrett onions because you could get it at the hot dog stands in NYC and Brooklyn. Love it. Wash it down with a Dr. Brown's creme soda.

[@richardthompson6265]

Brother I'm across the pond but holy sxxt this looks delicious gonna try at the weekend just found you and subscribed brother , love from blighty.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Welcome to the party! Always great to hear from our cousins across the pond!

[@Tol1as]

I've made this and it is fire! 🔥🔥 I have also developed a 15 minute version in case you can't wait for the full hour. Put two sliced onions on a small pan on medium heat. Add 1/4 cup of vinegar, a pinch of salt and enough water to cover. (pre-boiling the onions dehydrates them and the vinegar will keep them crunchy!) After 7-8 minutes almost all the water should have evaporated. Add a tbsp of neutral oil and saute them for 1-2 minutes. Once they get some color, add: 1/2 cup of ketchup, 1/2 cup water, 2 tsp of curry powder, 2 tbsp worchestershire sauce, salt, pepper and cayenne pepper (optional). It shouldn't need any more sugar as the ketchup has enough. In low heat, stir and let it boil down until it thickens into a glossy sauce. Tastes great as a topping for hotdogs and even burgers.

[@abrahamnutrition]

People for those of you that don't know. This is the ONE! Thank you brother for showing how to make red onion sauce the right way!

[@h.collier3544]

Not familiar with this topping in my area but it looks fantastic. Thanks for turning me on to this. Can't wait to try it!

[@rek2bxny]

Omg those onions look so good. It reminds me of NY 😊😂👍

[@frankhinkle5772]

That looks really good and I appreciate your enthusiasm for this family favorite.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you!

[@dbrice71]

Holy Shit! I never wanted some Hot Dogs so urgently, until this video. I'm an older dude born and bred in Miami, I've traveled to Queens on a yearly basis to visit with the majority of my family. Since a kid I loved the hot dog carts. Spicy Mustard with those Onions...the best. Going to make those Onions asap. Thanks.

[@DeeRodriguez_BallerinaFaLife]

I can tell you’re related to them because you’re an wonderful human being, too. Anyone who’s friends with you is damn lucky!❤️

[@tommyboy6267]

Good Golly Miss Molly...that looks sooo good. Gonna try it. A great tip for hotdogs...6 mins in an air fryer. No heating up your grill, no babysitting them on the stove...you gotta try it. Thanks for the 411. Liked and subscribed.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thanks! I've done them in the air fryer. Can confirm: delicious! Thanks for the support!

[@ashleymarie7452]

I like your style and your recipe! Thanks!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you! I like that you like it!

[@BlessingsStreetMinistry]

I love it I make my own in California nobody does it out here so you have to make your own

[@ReachTim]

Being from southern Ohio, we had hot dogs with "hot dog sauce" made with ground beef, spices, etc....and it was NOT chili. Sometimes we also added Cole Slaw. Hog Dog Sauce from the local "Shake Shack" was to die for. I remember mom buying it by the pint to make hot dogs at home. Of course, all things must come to an end. The crazy guy who owned the place burned his Shake Shack down to collect the insurance money. (He may still be in prison to this day; I'm not sure.) The recipe was never shared, so that was the end of that particular wonderful hot dog sauce. I didn't see this onion sauce until I moved to NYC in 1983. When I first saw it being served by the vendors, I thought it was simply ketchup mixed with cooked onions, but after tasting it, I realized it was something different entirely. Your recipe here looks wonderful and I hope to make it some day. Many thanks.

[@simonagree4070]

Best condiment recipe ever! Thank you for this -- you cannot buy anything like it in a store on the west coast. Normally I will settle for a good Mexican salsa on my hot dogs and quiche, but this has to beat that. It breaks my heart when people in the U.K. refer to a New York-style hot dog as something with nothing but ketchup and yellow mustard on it. Not even onions or kraut? No.

[@ppineault]

Looks like a great recipe, can't wait to try it ;)

[@moneysaversilver]

It's funny I ran across you are video because my buddy turned me on to that red onion sauce about 2 weeks ago man that's good

[@karljonez4423]

Lived in the city from 2000 to 2007. Miss those dogs. Will def make this. I hope you do more videos you deserve more subscribers. Well done my guy.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you! I'll be back on the content making grind soon. Just started a new day job, so my attention is there. Have any suggestions?

[@karljonez4423]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze well i am a pizza freak and that was one of my favorite things about the 212. I have been experimenting with homemade pizza. Would like to see that but either way man looking forward to new stuff.

[@jdcooks8435]

Not my favorite, but I do like variety! For my money you can't beat a North Jersey Texas Weiner ala Libby's Lunch, or Hot Grill. That said, I get a hankering for pushcart New York dog from time to time. I think sweet onions are not as good as regular yellow onions for something cooked down this much. As far as the dogs go, my favorite is pork and beef, natural casing, but for this, it's got to be a skinless, all beef, dirty water dog! Thanks for a great recipe!

[@MichaelRei99]

Bad news for you Libbys Lunch is no longer there.

[@jdcooks8435]

@@MichaelRei99 yeah. I heard that a while ago. Broke my heart! I do have THE recipe for Hot Grill's sauce though. Only get Thumanns dogs rarely when my sister drives out to see me.

[@NBA-LejonBrames]

Damn that looks pretty close to the real thing. Ill give this a a shot. Thanks man!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thanks for watching! Let me know how you like it!

[@richardrod4809]

Thank you for your awesome recipe!!! I am surprising my kids this weekend.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I love that! Enjoy!

[@shafi1837]

Great recipe! Thanks for sharing.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Thank you!

[@anniefannycharles9951]

Omg, It looks delicious! 1st time I ever had this was at a Catholic church function with a friend who's a member. In fact, it's called their Hot Dog Social! I couldn't believe how delicious they were. Nobody would give me the recipe! Probably cause I wasn't Catholic?! LOL- I don't know but now thanks to you, I've got the recipe and I'll be making these babies next week after I go shopping. Thanks so much for posting.- A fan in Ft Myers Florida 🌴🙋

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

That's for the support! Let me know how it comes out!

[@zonacrs]

Thank you for sharing this. Have wondered how this was made from my few years living in Connecticut just outside of NYC. Might try a splash of Sherry or Cognac at the end and let it simmer in for about 5 minutes.

[@robertcarter3768]

First vid I am seeing and I am following just for your page name alone!!!! Can't wait for more!!!!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Stay tuned, new videos coming soon

[@robertcarter3768]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze Only saw one "BOOZE" vid, making more?!!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Yessir! There's booze in the next one!

[@robertcostello7399]

I use only the best dogs sabretts with grilled onions and slow simmered bush baked beans.grill the dogs till the way you like. Toast buns on grill too. Put dog on bun top with onions then top with the beans. Soooo goood. Use the extra beans as a side top with the extra onions .yummy to the tummy.

[@joekrim6557]

A vendor from NYC sold Boar's Head™ hog dogs with string attached with this onion topping. A buck a dog...longer than the bun... The mechanics in my shop bought 5 at a time everytime he came. When he didn't, he were sold out... I liken these hot dogs to Nathan's Coney island. The consistency like coleslaw.

[@drewm9660]

I really needed this one.. Thank you!

[@kevinmorang9625]

I am definitely going to make this, thanks!!

[@johnbyrd3369]

I made this and it was good! I will put this recipe in my arsenal for the future. I’m usually a southern chili dog fan, but I promise this will be a part of my cookouts going forward. Thanks for this game-changer!

[@tonymurray814]

Thanks John. Can u share ur recipe for that please!

[@johnbyrd3369]

@@tonymurray814 I followed the recipe above exactly.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I think he's looking for your chili recipe

[@tonymurray814]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze I am. Thanks

[@strykerhalo]

I’ve never had the red onion sauce. I see, and hear everyone really likes it. Will have to try it one day. You ever try fresh Horseradish the stringy kind on your Hot Dogs? Mustard no longer needed, ketchup, and relish not needed. It’s pretty good, gotta be fresh, and stringy HOT though. I enjoy the nostril burn, lol.

[@MylezDaBadGuy]

thanks for the recipe bro I'm from NYC/NJ (moved around) but i miss onion sauce. I'm gonna try the recipe but I'm gonna dice my onions in finer cubes and smaller pieces

[@miacarlany]

the brooklyn secret is put a bit of balsamic vinegar it makes the onions last longer

[@wildlifewarrior2670]

I thought the secret was crack

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Now you've ruined the real secret!

[@burlatsdemontaigne6147]

Good call. Also, sherry vinegar works well too. As long as the onions aren't crunchy it's all good.

[@deputy3690]

I thought Howard Stern was speaking! I use onions, Delmonte tomato sauce and vinegar and its really good to.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I get the Howard Stem comparison a lot!

[@kbbl102.5]

Ive got some on the stove now... There was a time id hit a Sabrett stand two, three times a day when i lived in marble hill. I cant eat like that anymore, but this recipe is already bringing back memories. The smell in here is unreal man, this recipe is the truth. Ive got a pot of water with an onion, a bay leaf, and some vinegar going next to it, going to try to clone a dirty water dog. Thanks boss

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Enjoy it brother. I hope it brings back the good memories!

[@kbbl102.5]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze you were right about the cinnamon, that warmth in the air is awesome. I did a pinch of allspice and a splash of red wine when I tasted it before adding the water. It's simmering now. It's gonna be slammin. Thanks again

[@Calvin7237]

Looks good

[@kimberlycooper880]

Looks delicious 🤤 btw… u sound like the “ Howard Stern” of food?!? Voice aka

[@scotsmanofnewengland7713]

If anyone is traveling thru Connecticut on Rte I- 84 you have to stop at Blackies Hot Dog In Cheshire. Easy off and Easy on both ways East and West. The relish they use and used to make which is now outsourced is worth the stop. They also sell small jars of their relish. They are closed on Fridays due to the “ No Meat on Fridays “ catholic rule. I haven’t been there for awhile but they used to sell the hot dogs 2 for $5.00. Enjoy

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Noted, thank you!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I'm performing at Comix @ Mohegan Sun 6/27, I may take a detour.

[@joelongstaff7601]

Very nice thankyou Sir. I'm a hot dog vender in Northern Ontario Canada and I'm going to try this on the cart this weekend. I did coke onions and it made something different for my regular customers to try.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

I'm sure they're gonna love it!

[@ryantourney2879]

I'm very curious...how did it work out ? Did the customers like these onions ?

[@Fletcher109]

You cook like I do. No matter how easy it is - I always make a friggen mess, and takes twice as long as it should. Woman hates it. Nice heads up though, I haven't had a NYC cart dog in 20 years. I do however require skinned dogs. Either local butcher or BoarsHead.

[@Spider-Verse.23]

Nothing better than 80's and 90's New York food

[@MichaelRei99]

I like you a lot! You have a great sense of humor but my onions are the best and I’m going to the grave with my recipe.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Why not share it with the world and live forever?

[@MichaelRei99]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze Maybe I’ll have a change of heart when I get older!

[@saucerguysculpture3525]

Gonna have those the 4 July! Thanks

[@MickeyWattsDeadHead]

Looks amazing! Gonna make this asap.

[@amazon-t3m]

is this recipe printable this looks amazing i have a few old school family recipe boxes but i am making my own now just the best in my onion thank you

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

If you drop down the video description, you should be able to copy, paste and print

[@htuckey]

{I believe I'll try making this one tonight! I'm 81, and still like to cook (among other things) Thanks for the receipt - it really looks good!

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

Cheers my friend!

[@CameraNut1000]

Never heard of this sauce. I will have to give it a try.

[@gdlivo3353]

This classic hot dog sauce is very good. 4 cloves of garlic or 5? The pinch of cinnamon or not? Lots of little tweaks are out there. However there is a simple addition that really lifts it to the next level (for me anyway). Maple syrup. In a half quantity of this classic onion sauce, just add a good squirt of maple syrup and you will be amazed at the difference it makes. I've just eaten 2 for lunch with steamed and buttered bun, 2 slices of cheddar cheese, yellow mustard, egg mayonnaise and topped with the onion sauce. Delicious. Unfortunately I only had Australian red frankfurts so I'm off to the shop to buy some American style beef hotdogs to feed my son when he gets home from work.

[@SugarSaltFatBooze]

5 cloves of garlic, and yes to the cinnamon. Everything can of course be adjusted to taste, buy the recipe as written tastes identical to the Sabrett brand.

[@gdlivo3353]

@@SugarSaltFatBooze I'm sure it is. Not a brand we have over here, but it lifts a hotdog. I'll be making it again.

[@k.i.m.withkim9512]

Your rendition sounds AMAZING❣️

[@misinformationmedia]

Been waiting for this thank you my dude, new sub….