The Iron Ranger Slayer! Nicks Americana Boots

[@gilesreb]

As a former driller, I can 100% attest to the "blue collar Olympics". I remember when I was about 19, working an average of 95 hours a week in a tough and arguably dangerous job, I was talking to a 50 year old pipefitter on a job site. He said we were insane to work that much, and that he would never do it anymore. He wanted to live his life, etc. My coworkers and I scoffed and said he was weak. Boy oh boy were we dumb. That dude had it made in the shade and wasn't ashamed, while we were breaking our backs in the hot sun, thinking we were better than him for working more/dirtier/more dangerously. Bad mindset to have, glad I grew out of it.

[@jonathanjonathan7386]

well u needed the dough, he didn't

[@gilesreb]

@@jonathanjonathan7386 Yeah fair point. Those were the "get paid Friday and be broke again by Monday" days 😂

[@jeremyt2212]

I'm with you, Carl. This weird sort of reverse elitism where guys say, "You can't wear these boots, you're a college student not a construction worker" or "No real man spends $500 on a pair of boots", is just ridiculous. Wear what you want, buy what makes you happy, don't worry about what the other guy's doing.

[@CarlMurawski]

EXACTLY!

[@AesirUnlimited]

If you can afford it, and it makes you happy. Buy it. It’s a simple mantra to live by.

[@jeremyt2212]

@@AesirUnlimited Exactly, 'If you can afford it' being the operative phrase there. As much as I loved the NYG Nailshank boots that Carl did a video on, I know that I'm not going to rack up $100 on my credit card to buy them, knowing that I can't really afford them. But, you know, if anybody's thinking about any last-minute Christmas gifts for me...

[@EastofVictoriaPark]

I'll take the partially dissenting opinion where I believe the tool should match the need, and if we are talking college/university student, I will assume that in this case they do not come from money, especially at how expensive post-secondary education is in the US. I kind of agree that you should wear what you want, and not to listen to what others say. I also think that not all good ideas at the time are good ideas in the future. As an aside, I hate the qualifier, "real". All men are real men and, more commonly, all women are real women.

[@roveradventures]

I consider it, long term investment for foot health, comfort, and price. With Nick's and Whites you can send em back, have em redone, when really bad fully rebuilt and custom fitted plus the arch support is significant. The custom fit and customization options are pretty nice too so whether you're a college student, retail worker, F1 driver, hunter, actor or a Hotshot /smokejumper. Theres a boot for you and as everyone said, buy what you wish. USA.

[@djswany85]

Hey Carl. I appreciate your comments at the beginning. Part of why I like your videos is your positivity. Keep it up.

[@kurtgarcia7079]

As the old saying goes: "Never skimp on boots or mattresses, because when you're not in one, you're in the other."

[@edrader]

so if you spend a lot of time driving get a rolls

[@ambrose8496]

I'm wearing flip flops right now.

[@Wsherwoodking]

@@edrader Not actually a bad point but I think the reason a Rolls doesn't quite qualify is because you are so far into diminishing returns by that point.

[@zachvigilv9298]

Damn right

[@MrKinghuman]

My ex wife is the same, when ones not in her, she's with the other 🤣

[@joshuayount6074]

For me, if they are going to be the Ranger killers, they have to be in the same price point. 50% more puts them in a slightly different demographic. Great looking boots though.

[@CarlMurawski]

Fair point!

[@nicktrnka1480]

The Nicks are about twice the price as the Iron Rangers. They should be way cooler. Nice boots, but $$$.

[@zachthompson5335]

Nick Trnka “cooler” is personal preference though. Personally I prefer the “cool” of Nick’s but that isn’t the reason I wear Them. For me it’s an assessment of value vs price and what you get with higher end boot makers, value far exceeds price and thus isn’t considered “expensive.”

[@nicktrnka1480]

@@zachthompson5335 I see your point. There is a great deal of subjectivity in a personal preference and value. My thought was that it is not unexpected that the Nicks are better than the Iron Rangers because they do cost twice the price; they should be better. Certainly, one would expect more in value and quality for $500 vs $250 even in a boot. For example, while both excellent on the track, a Porsche Cayman is cooler than a Subaru BRZ. Now the issue is how to justify Nicks when I have lots of boots that are still in good shape; don't want to be wasteful...

[@zachthompson5335]

Nick Trnka agreed. It’s different strokes for different folks. Just like anything in life that we spend our hard earned money on, it’s whatever fits you needs, wants, budget and most importantly, whatever makes you happy. So long as it makes you happy, that’s a win in my book.

[@savvylifestrategies9445]

I always enjoy your videos, Carl. Most military styles from boots to coats endure. They were designed to be functional, and functional never goes out of style.

[@patriotfox7192]

“Great Men and Women of character from all walks of lives” Amen brother, great opening monologue.

[@brandonkey181]

Nick's boots are really great. They're liked by my non-fashion friends, and fashion friends. Some associate cuban heels as 'feminine', but most agree it looks awesome.

[@dudewuttheheck]

I really appreciate you addressing those people who make those comments. Very well said!

[@PrimalEdge]

1:48 for the next 60 seconds... well said! my first job was in a junkyard, and I turned wrenches till my late 20's.. now I'm in corporate America, I appreciate the look, feel, durability AND YES the style of work-boot inspired footwear.

[@liljuanito123]

Their silhouette is beautiful. Perfect balance between boot and heel.

[@cle_roknn3742]

“Lumbersexuals” I blew my coffee out of my nose, that’s hilarious. I’m right there with you though I have a masters degree, but I started out as a saw hand (had to pay for college), then timber cruiser and log scaler at a very large mill complex. Long hot days either on the mill yard or in the woods, then moved into logging contract supervision. I put in 10 years in the field (admittedly some was part time during college). Then someone took notice and I moved to the office as a forest manager (think forester on steroids) and now wood guru for our manufacturing facilities as well. I need a boot that can walk into an office and look presentable, walk onto a wood yard and hold up to that nasty environment, and possibly cruise timber all in the same day. If it had a steel toe this one could fit the bill, I’m currently looking at a custom Builder Pro because I need the safety toe in the mill, though I love my Iron Rangers if I’m not going to need steel toes. If these had a safety toe they would be perfect for my needs!

[@skycorrigan6511]

I don't work directly in a "Blue Collar" job, but you made a great point.

[@johnmelton8181]

Carl you nailed it! Though I recomend that my friends take a few days vacation to Spokane and be fitted at the store. This goes for both Nicks and Whites. As to affordablity, as these boots are resoleable and later rebuildable when necessary by the factory. What you end up with is a verturaly factory new boot. This adds up to a sizable saving over your life time. I have seen fellow electricians and lineman go their entire working lives alternating with just two sets.

[@pawelszych7697]

Karol oglądam twoje y tube videos i sporo się uczę. Dzięki. Carl I really enjoy learning from you about boots. Thanks for all your work and effort.

[@davehandyside7275]

Ok Carl, you sold me on the Nicks and I have ordered a fit sheet.

[@skycorrigan6511]

How'd the fit sheet go? I'm about to put an order in for the Americana

[@Psycho-Ssnake]

@@skycorrigan6511 I was nervous that I would mess something up. If you feel like you did something wrong you can let them know what you think might be wrong. The odds are that your try on pair will still feel like what you'd want. The phone call helps you discuss any questions or concerns you may have.

[@MachineGod69]

@@skycorrigan6511 ordered my Americana/predator orange, back in January 29 2021. Still waiting.. I went through an App called “Eclo” digital 3D imaging of feet that nicks partners with. Let me know how you like your Americana’s ✌️👍

[@danieljames1065]

This boot reminds me of the 1970’s enduro duel purpose motorcycle. Hit the streets and trails. One bike to cover a lot of bases, although usually not so well. These Nicks seem like they cover a lot of uses, as you mentioned. They do it very well. Just stunning boots,love them

[@dbluntson5243]

This boot looks like it belongs in a museum. I'd be afraid to wear it. Lol.

[@danieljames1065]

Retired now, having wore redwings during 30 plus years of hard, physical work. They were the best boots then that I was aware of and could afford. So I thought. Now having worn boots such as the Nicks, Whites, Wesco’s etc I realize I was wrong. For many valid reasons. Wish I could go back in time and change things

[@bryandiorio7249]

Hey Daniel out of the wesco, nicks, and whites which is your go to?

[@saleemwaheed9956]

Carl your boot game is sick!

[@stephenathon]

Excellent point regarding the MTM aspect of these. Worth the price for that feature alone.

[@CarlMurawski]

I agree. It's truly an eye-opener.

[@holdthatblaow]

Dude, grat preface before the video. I wear my White's and Nicks for casual wear. Not cause I'm trying to look like a bad ass but because for one - I have tricky feet and two - the comfort and support. Great reviews. I think I may look into these once I start wanting versatility from my curved heel pnw boots.

[@aceaustralian]

I must say, your reviews are excellent. You are very professional in your delivery and very informative.

[@CarlMurawski]

Thank you!!!

[@seashellsonazure]

The higher quality things about the nicks over the redwings are what make the redwings better for many people. - The leather on the redwings is softer, still pretty tough. But the overall size/weight and slim profile goes to redwings. - The nicks foot bed/sole has more layers, the redwing is simpler with a real good durable sole. Again lower profile less weight, less bulk. It is like comparing a Humvee with a Wrangler. And the above is even more clear when comparing to other nicks models.

[@kornfedboy]

Somebody asked “ how many life-time boots do you need?” The answer? Just one more pair!!

[@miedziak80]

Middle of summer, I need Americana sandals version!

[@max796428]

I'm with you on the heel styles. I love how aesthetically appealing this boot is but I'll never go back to block heels. Cuban/logger/dogger for me. I used to need custom made inserts for my footwear due to back, hip, knee, and foot pain but threw them all out after I got a pair of loggers from Franks and have a pair of roberts from Nicks on order for casual wear!

[@minceraftfornite4334]

Why not try wedge soles

[@JohnPArgueta]

Great video. I just got my first pair of Iron Rangers after wearing Rockport boots for years. I paid $349 (in 2023) and think that’s a decent price for 🇺🇸 quality. I will look into Nicks Americana ($629) in a couple years as a custom fit sounds pretty cool. 🤘🏼

[@reitmanma]

Hi Carl! You’re video reviews are great. Don’t even react to the negative comments, I would bet that is all they’re going for. (USMC vet)

[@luvillan4641]

Man.. these are beefed up red wing rangers!!! Really nice!

[@dylanmcdougall1712]

Carl never disappoints with a video. Looking forward to getting my first MTM boots in the near future.

[@CarlMurawski]

Much appreciated! You won't look back once you go MTM

[@JJ-lu6mg]

They looks like Iron Rangers on steroids 👍🏻👍🏻. Well done Nicks Boots and what a great name 🇺🇸.

[@stevedoe3994]

Thanks for confirming my next purchase. I have been eyeing the Americana for a few weeks now. I prefer the brown waxed leather. They look amazing! Your channel is costing me. But I can't stop watching. Love your reviews! We have similar taste.

[@nateand3]

I can see now that when I get my work boots, I'll be ready to purchase these soon after

[@joshuayount6074]

Hey man - still keeping an eye out for that 'intro to hats' video! Keep up the good work!

[@Hysteresis11]

At some point you have to ask yourself: " How many pairs of '100 year wear' boots can one person legitimately utilize in one lifetime..."

[@Jorary209]

Personally, there is no limit.

[@edrader]

100

[@drzaius844]

Not really.

[@jonhill373]

For a great reviewer, just one of the benefits

[@pranavkamath4329]

Effectively I’d say 7 or so, for collection purposes there’s only money as the limit

[@richludlam8993]

"How dirty you get at work" love it! Thanks for the review.

[@BobBafaro-ee9ck]

It’s Spo Can. Being from there know for sure. Nick’s are legends just like Whites. Last you a lifetime. Many boots available and Nick’s built how you want.

[@TheAlonzof]

Just received a pair of these boots, bought largely because of this video, and they are the best fitting boots I have ever had. Even straight out of the box, they fit great and are very comfortable. The nice part is that I can now order other pairs from Nick's and get them faster since the fitting process is on file. Definitely worth the price of admission. I have a lot of boots, and while you don't always get what you pay for, I feel like these boots are a good deal.

[@bbmpiano]

Hey, just wanted to ask if you went for the comfot insole ie a size up? I recently bought a pair as well but I'm unsure about this option. Thank you

[@lastofthemohicans1]

Great review. Nicks will be my next pair of work boots. Got rangers and love them

[@carlrest6553]

In the 80s, I wore Indy's, Levi's and t-shirts. I still have those Aiden's, and still wear jeans and t-shirts. Looking back, that look stood the test of time. Fads are nonsense. Stick to classics and you can't go wrong.

[@daianspahava8279]

Carl Rest classics never go out of style. Just like how leather jackets, denim jackets, dark jeans, and white tees are never going out of style just like flannel shirts.

[@carlrest6553]

619 OG Am I missing something? What is funny?

[@carlrest6553]

619 OG Git ut. I have Dickies too. Still prefer 501s.

[@carlrest6553]

Got it. Sorry autocorrected

[@JimmyTwoShoes94]

@619 OG how are Levi's dead? Everyone still wears them

[@TheMapleReview]

Do a 1 year update on these! Would love to see how these age

[@charlesbronson240]

He cut em in half

[@johnsmithington3167]

Smooth, just casually including your resume, absolutely not a lumbersexual.

[@Tainomontana]

I’m a electrician also & have been wearing the most comfortable & lightweight slippers to work for many years, they are actually Red Wing king toe boots & they are literally more comfortable than some of my home slippers & last me about two years of 6 day weeks so they are totally worth the money for more reasons than one.

[@DB-me3jt]

To me Nicks boots look like they really are the boots (and service) that Red Wing makes you believe you’re buying if you step into a Red Wing store.

[@craigslistrro709]

I have been wearing Iron Rangers as my primary footwear since I was 8 yrs old, when my dad got sick of buying me new shoes every month because i was so hard on shoes...... Im 57 yrs old, Change my mind!.... I Live 1.5 hrs away from Spokane,

[@jeffmitchell72]

If I lived that close I'd drive to Nick's and ask them to change my mind.

[@joshuahoward7567]

i work “harder” than most i lay pipe, but i loved your intro i agree 100% I’d never wear ether of these to work because 1 i need waterproof steel toes and 2 because it would ruin them. That said Id love to have both of them for when I’m not at work i was eyeing the redwings but now you have me thinking about the nicks

[@exexpat11]

Plaid shirt, tin pants, goatee with upturned mustache, suspenders, floppy hat, mullet or man bun... $350-$1200 work boots. Works a phone at Amazon. Only thing missing is the Starbucks in hand. LOL! Why do I hear the Monty Python "Lumberjack Song" in my head?

[@CarlMurawski]

Hahahaha I’ve been trying to grow a man bun for months... it doesn’t seem to be working.

[@exexpat11]

@@CarlMurawski Of course I am just joking but there are people like that out there.

[@danielh750]

Never be cheap on Toilet Paper (not possible with CV-19), Laundry Detergent, or Boots! Nick's boots are incredible buddy! However, I like the way the IRs looks compared to Nick's. Sleek enough, and rigged enough. The look is perfect on the IR, and it's just hard to beat. Great video!!! The Nick's sure are special though!

[@raderjohnson3890]

Spo-Can, definitely.

[@Toyotas_n__Tools]

The same guy that calls someone a lumbersexual for having nice boots to work in is wearing sketchers with velcro straps.

[@CarlMurawski]

True story!

[@LKS-1976]

Love my Nicks/Rose Anvil boot. Break in was a bitch. Now, love them.

[@TheDieseldog]

Nice boots. Love my iron rangers for weekends. Could see myself rocking a pair of Nicks.

[@Drifthut]

Listen if you judge someone for wearing boots I will become a lumbersexual and have you jump on this wood. Great video man. Great boots.

[@JayBirdNJ.]

Great video, very informative. As an electrician and now a general contractor of sorts, I've see the reverse elitism on the sites for years. Its like the guys who only have the bare minimum of skill and are stuck doing the shit work don't respect the men who work smarter. It's like their hard work is all they have and they separate themselves into a class all of their own so then can berate others and not regret their life choices. Work smarter, not harder. I respect the mud but I also respect the guy who sweeps up the restaurant.

[@spike6385]

So I don't think I would call a boot that costs 200$ more than another boot, a slayer of that boot. I'd call it a superior product with a superior price.

[@clintpreslar452]

I’d love to get a pair of nick’s someday. I do wish we had a bit more boots in the 300-500 dollar range besides Redwing, Grant Stone, and maybe Parkhurst. It seems like there’s a quick jump from 400 dollar boots to 650+, so I think there’s definitely more room for higher quality than Red wings while potentially reducing costs by using other tanneries or overseas assembly. I’d really like to see thicker insole and midsole leathers in more lower priced boots.

[@albertmanuel5028]

This is something I’ve been contemplating for awhile. I love my Redwings and Helms, but am drawn to Nick’s or perhaps Role Club.

[@Sean-Ax]

SLAYER!!--wait, wrong thing.

[@CarlMurawski]

Lol! It’s never the wrong time for Seasons in the Abyss!

[@Sean-Ax]

@@CarlMurawski Actually, I have a question; do you wear your Nick's boots every day or every other day? People always say you generally shouldn't wear leather footwear multiple days in a row, but the way you talk about your Nick's work boots sounds like you wear them every work day.

[@dshanley7]

Great review, I'm not gonna lie my two pairs of Nick's have seriously spoiled me. I'm not sure I can afford a 3rd pair yet though!

[@CarlMurawski]

They tend to do that. Once you're accustomed to that fit and build quality it's hard to go backward.

[@gedcanonizado]

Nah Carl, this doesn't "slay" the Iron Ranger. It's much more expensive - hence it's only expected to be somehow "better" than the IRs. If they were at the same price-point, then the title's justified. Other than that, this is like a boxing match wherein the fight is between a middleweight and a heavyweight. Still, great vid!

[@heribertogutierrez9057]

I agree 💯%!!! I don’t see how the IR looks “clownish”. I don’t think people who makes these claims of the IR has actually compared a clown shoe side by side since there’s zero resemblance.

[@hannuarmendoza6016]

Iam a boiler but I have nick boots I only use to go out because they look amazing with levis jeans and I love the classic clean look . Dirty at work and a masterpiece outside a work environment

[@jurgenbrandt642]

I love the Americana in brown and could buy immediatly. I would be very pleased if Nick's Boots would have a shop in Germany!!!!!

[@L0ki71]

Great video and above all great channel. You’ve done a wonder job providing info and perspectives on some wonderful products. I am hoping that you could do a review on Truman boots. I am completely sold on Nicks because of the customization but I feel my feet size fall into a more common/general sizing pattern (thank god). But before I make the dive into a Nicks boot I was hoping you’d eventually do a review on Truman’s. 🤙🏽🤙🏽

[@adamg7850]

I don't know if you were sponsored by Nicks or not but Truman Boots are Nicks slayers and Red Wing slayers. Check out the new Truman "Norton" boot which is a collaboration with ButterscotchLBC. (Sold by Butterscotch and found on their website)

[@CarlMurawski]

I wish I were popular enough to be offended sponsorships! Alas, it’s not the case.

[@mikemichaels4500]

My work boots are strictly for safety and function. At the end of the day, they come off and stay in my locker at work. Guys that wear their work boots all the time look to me like they are poor, lazy, or don't give a.f. about their appearance. There is nothing wrong with wearing casual boots that look good and are made well.

[@kittenlover4787]

When I see someone in work boots outside of work, I see a blue collar worker and respect them even more that I normally would, poor or otherwise. Also, I’ve had a couple occasions where my safety toe protected me outside of work, and a couple occasions where I wish I was wearing them. I guess it really depends on your type of work/boot; If you’re talking about knee-high rubber overboots, I see your point.

[@cooper7395]

Dad always said to never skimp on anything that separates you from the earth: shoes, mattress, tires

[@johnminden669]

I've been watching these boots on Nick's website. Really like them!

[@CarlMurawski]

I think they did a great job with these. The Roberts look great too. But how many boots does one need?

[@Sam-hk1bj]

@@CarlMurawski The answer has been the same for years: One more pair.

[@johnminden669]

All of them... All the boots... Lol I have to get the Charley next in natural CXL.

[@johnminden669]

I have the Robert's, man they are nice. More of a narrow toe though.

[@elmarwaldvogel3383]

Great content. I always like the clearness in your speech! I think I‘m going to take the next boot-level. :-) Flirting with Viberg. :-D But this brand (Nick) sounds also very attractive! Thanks for indicating.

[@Tgkjj]

bro ive been looking for a review on these boots

[@CarlMurawski]

Happy to oblige!

[@gasaul5759]

I really like your channel's working class profile. I follow other channels like Kirby Allison's Hanger Proyect, I like it, but that's above my budget.

[@toddfraisure1747]

These newer Vibram soles are for walking flat ground. They have crappy bite when climbing a steep grade due to the gripping tread stops before where the tread counts, towards the inside edge of the ball of your foot

[@Saw_Squatch]

For the price I love my Chippewa service boot, got them for like $200 on sale, same heritage quality, horween chromexel leather, and in my opinion better silhouette,

[@martyn420]

I'd like to get a pair of Americana boots, but I'm in the UK and fitting looks to be a nightmare.

[@jameswoodard4304]

I can confirm the macho measuring that happens in blue-collar envirnments. Sometimes people will actually work harder (less efficiently) than necessary just to avoid looking weak. "Work smarter, not harder," is a maxim that will not go over well in a lot of blue-collar situations. Of course, sometimes people will surprise you and appreciate doing things in a way that leaves them less busted up and exhausted at the end of the day. The test of character is: Are you *willing* to work hard when the situation demands it? That shows character. Demanding to work hard unnecessarily is literally stupid and insecure. The old-timers often know from experience and wish they had worked smarter in their younger days. Also, there is (somewhat deservedly) a very cynical, mocking attitude that can creep up toward HR-type rules and regulations. Everyone makes fun of OSHA, and a lot of safety and other training is CYA overkill, but things like "Lift with your legs, not your back," "Get help to haul heavy loads," "Use the correct equipment for the job instead of automatically brute-forcing every obsticle," aren't hokey clichés. They're things smart people do so that they can still bend over and pick up their kids in 10 years, and keep doing the tough job that provides for their family and future. But, you'll occassionally get guys that hear something like that, insult the masculinity of the person who dared utter such effeminate tripe, and bull ahead regardless to prove how much of a real man they are. And some aren't even men. There are two cliches of women in hard blue-collar work. 1) The diversity hire/boss's neice with a bad attitude, bigger chip on her shoulder than is good for her, which causes the men to do more work to make up for it, while she hates them for it. 2) The butch lady that nobody messes with. I'm serious. 9 times out of 10, the one that most people are scared of pissing off is the tough, middle-aged female who can hold her own. She doesn't start anything, but she doesn't take anything either.

[@cj0204]

Blue collar olympics! 🤣🤣🤣 I like that. I’m a plumber. I used to be a new construction plumber for about 10 years. Would install plumbing from the ground up. Now I’m in maintenance and lemme tell you that although my job may not be as physically demanding anymore. It’s sure is mentally demanding. Always seemed like new construction plumbers and maintenance plumbers and service plumbers all look down on each other 🤣

[@TheVince1995]

How did you know which arch to pick? Thanks!

[@jeffmitchell72]

I was wondering how the measuring kit takes arch into consideration

[@retroFUNKINgroova]

Two great brands made in America.

[@lonewolf30531]

I use mine for Whole Foods and Starbucks quick runs .

[@phillipschimek7545]

Your are great!

[@greglewis1839]

Spokane, pronounced spow - can. Grew up there, and when I went back east to school I was asked if we had roads and electricity, and if we still fought with Indians. Always enjoy your reviews.

[@blauer2551]

No, we have antifa and safe zones where cry babies can loot and brood because society isn’t fair to them.

[@hantswalker]

Great video. I've watched it twice now. A couple of questions for lifestyle rather than work use: any advantage of 8" rather than 6"? Yours are standard top. Any pros or cons for a roll top.

[@tbaylo4034]

I prefer those “criticisms” of the Iron Ranger look over the Nick’s. I have never liked the look of high-heeled boots. Not good for your feet anyway. I bought Iron Rangers because they had a low heel, and reminded me of a pair of Justin Lace-r work boots I had about 20 years ago. Loving the IRs, and the old school style. Reminds me of old black and white pictures of American men about 100 years ago.

[@Totemparadox]

"Not good for you feet" Wrong. Maybe not good for YOUR feet. Don't talk for others.

[@johnnyregs2378]

I'm a project manager for a large remodeling company. Im a carpenter by trade and started working with my dad when I was 10 years old as his apprentice. I was recently picking up materials for a job site and another contractor there saw me in my clean redwings and nicely pressed pants and gave me the "why are you so clean?!" tired old joke. I said because I was dirty for 15 years in this industry so now I don't have to be. 🤷

[@tranan661]

Great work as always.

[@CarlMurawski]

Much appreciated!!!

[@blueband8114]

That is one good looking piece of footwear. Got to hand it to you Americans, you can design and make good footwear.

[@CarlMurawski]

If it's your style, the northwest makes some of the best work boots around in my opinion.

[@Nowayjose-z2r]

I think the information is presented great! I love how you mentioned it's not really for a job site but you did mention blue collar people talking about getting dirty and sweaty to measure work ethic, which is 100% true. At the same time I don't know most people, even the licensed plumbers per say that make $50 plus an hour who would buy these boots because of cost. This is a stereotype for sure as I do know a lot of Sneakerheads pay crazy amount of money for sneakers. To be fair none are blue collar works, So it would be interesting to see who the customer demographics are for these boots. I say this as I and others would save for a year to get a nice pair of Red Wings when they are starting out at an apprentice and/or school level when in theory you would need the better boot as you are doing 80% of the work, at least all the grunt work.

[@smoothsam7]

That’s true I have a pair of Sendra cowboy boots and they have a tapered heel love them

[@jermsman18]

Awesome boots. Definitely on my wish list

[@jeffreygoss8109]

I hope your right. I have worn redwings for at least a dozen years buying 7 pairs. I have usually bought “work” boots but recently purchased a pair of Iron Rangers. During the break in process staples came through the insoles in both boots. No response from the customer service email/phone so I returned them. It is my belief that red wing is cutting quality to make a few extra pennies. Giving Nicks a chance.

[@JonathanGrandt]

If you hold a photo of the iron ranger next to the Americana you will see, aside from thicker leather, that the iron ranger has a thin welt and a thin rubber sole while the Americana has a thicker leather welt, more leather and then a thicker rubber sole. But all of this aside... the Americana is $200 more than the iron ranger. That’s tough to swing. Especially considering being able to nab iron ranger 2nds for $179-$200. So does it “slay” the iron ranger? I think it needs to be near the same price point to so that doesn’t it?

[@sisleymichael]

The crappy combat boots I wore for years (28, US Army, infantry) resulted in fallen arches. All I ask of any footwear these days is comfort, and no arch support, or it will result in severe pain. I have found the Thorogood 8" or Red Wing 8" moc toe work for me. That soft sole is comfy. The harder the sole, the greater the foot and back pain for me. I also get my boots resoled on time and I get three or four resoles before retirement of the boot. As for what someone wears, hey, wear what makes YOU happy. Life is short. When you sit down to have a beer at the bar with me I am not going to mention your boots. Why? I don't pay for them so I figure you wear what you like, what feels good, what you can afford? Some guys go a lifetime trying to find a favorite. That WAS me. I found something that works for my foot.

[@SuperFlowback]

That’s a great looking boot

[@emeraldcity_]

Any thoughts on Frank's Boots in Spokane?

[@lylebenally6040]

I love my nick’s boots. I got the falcons in burgundy and I just ordered another pair. Rangers in chocolate. I do see a pair of builder pro’s in black for next year.

[@EDHBlvd]

Sorry I need to disagree with you. I would agree the Nicks is likely better made and probably more comfortable. That said, I feel the Iron Ranger looks better. These Nick’s almost look like a woman’s boot. You say the Red Wing looks clownish? It looks like a man’s work boot. That all said, Nick’s makes some seriously manly boots. Just not this pair. Their fireman boots are manly AF.

[@matthewshaw1941]

absolutely love the look of this boot in fact putting it on my lists to get. I was wondering have you looked into Drews boots they make work and cowboy boots they have also caught mu eye?

[@darrenvanderwilt1258]

Being retired military, I have to say, the numerous types of boots I wore were far more comfortable and durable than all the stuff I’ve worn since. The military, and as an extension, boots you highlight, cause less foot problems.

[@adnanlatif1722]

Carl Excellent review I am based in U.K I your opinion which are most comfortable boots made to measure any recommendations

[@franko3227]

My first pr of shoes were boots,cowboy boots! I don't own a pr of shoes only have boots.All my dress boots are cowboy boots and my every day wear boots are redwing, thorogood and a few parkhurst. I will be looking into these for my next pr.