The Last Jedi Revisited (Why It's Still Terrible) [Zaid Magenta Reupload]

[@Time-machinery-er9dq]

Here's the theme of _The Last Jedi_ concerning failure: failure is the greatest teacher, so because men fail all the time, they need to learn from their failures so they can better themselves. However, because women never fail at anything, they don't need to learn from anything because they're already perfect.

[@sharky7954]

You smell like an incel

[@barkley8285]

hmm well considering 4/5 of the main characters are guys so .... yea? Rey is the only main character that is a women and she fails throughout the movie. Holdo, Rose, and even Leia are soley meant to further their main characters, nothing more. Its not that deep.

[@PhoenixGamerxx96]

I remember watching this video review from Zaid back in 2021 and I still agree with him about how godawful the sequel trilogy including The Last Jedi and how Disney is greedy and mistreats the actual Disney fans and old school Star Wars fans.

[@Jonathanest90s]

🙄

[@TheEverSoTalented]

I thought "The Last Jedi" was one mans ego going from 'I don't think this scene fits this part of the film'....to 'I don't give a crap,I can do what I want!' Thats one BIG reason for the massive failure of what was supposed to be the sequel to a $2billion #StarWars movie...... and yet it Crashed an Burned!? #DisneyLucasFilm #DisneyStarWars #LicenseToPrintMoney

[@bigmacintosh1766]

Thank you

[@bigmacintosh1766]

​@@Jonathanest90sMAP hater

[@ryanbarth6691]

Unfortunately this rant corrupted zaid's mind into disrespecting anyone who likes the last Jedi

[@dangreene3895]

I have watched every Star War movie ever made , except the last one , and that was because of The Last Jedi movie .

[@antoniosalieri1048]

Stick to the original trilogy and even the prequels

[@abelmantor7557]

I'll always prefer the Disney from my childhood. Disney nowadays is just ugh.

[@wisherofsnowdays]

Woke is the word you're looking for, or to be specific postmodern.

[@antoniosalieri1048]

Yep, definitely woke ​@wisherofsnowdays

[@pbh9195]

It is sad that he disabled his channel cause I really was looking forward to his Rise of Skywalker rant which in my opinion is worse then TLJ

[@PhoenixGamerxx96]

Same here. I was hyped for him to make his video rant on The Rise of Skywalker and tear up the entire sequel trilogy for good. But I guess we won't get that now. Sad.😞

[@a.j.medialover]

Same.

[@ajmorningstar6281]

Same

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

Same.

[@darthrevan7307]

Same

[@JamesNerdMan85]

I still agree with this review but what he did was inexcusable. If he didn’t waste his time going after people and telling them he hopes they get shot, his TRoS review would’ve been out for probably over a year. He just couldn’t accept people can like something he doesn’t. I don’t like the sequel trilogy either but I’m not gonna go after people who like them, especially with alternate accounts. And if he really didn’t like them he could’ve just blocked them.

[@bigmacintosh1766]

If people didn't waste their times going after Zaid by attacking him for rightfully criticizing TLJ and the star wars sequel trilogy , Zaid never would've snapped like that. His haters can't just accept the fact that their precious sequel trilogy has it's flaws and they want to be filled in a room full of toxic positivity. Zaid always ignored them but since his haters kept making videos of him, he couldn't take it anymore. I'm sure if you were in his shoes, you wouldn't hold your breathe anymore, either.

[@MetalSandman999]

A lot of less sproblemaric KZbinrs make promises and don't complete things they promise (or at least take ywars and years). I don't think we were ever gonna get that TROS review. In his comeback video it wasn't even brought up if I recall correctly.

[@wisherofsnowdays]

He's probably autistic. Maybe you should learn to be tolerant of people who aren't exactly like you. Especially the disabled.

[@sonicfan2403]

I think it's best he just focus on life. Granted I know there are bridges he'll never be able to repair given how he's acted, but at this point for Zaid, all I would want for him is to just focus and settle down with life. And if he continues, then oh well, that's on him. But I ain't gonna demand him to step down.

[@countof3everybodyOD]

@@sonicfan2403this is how crazy KZbin is. I’ve been watching Star Wars content on it for years and I’ve never heard of this guy. But I love him! What did he do? Why did he delete his channel??? And now he’s come back ???

[@dovahkiin6488]

Thank you for re-uploading this!

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

I reuploaded his Mass Effect 3 video. Check my playlists.

[@DragonoidColossus747]

if anyone has the playlist of his original TLJ vids lemme know plz

[@traxxorznn1429]

wow good content and good music!! wheres that background music from?

[@PyroMaker3]

Kingdom Hearts series

[@BlackangelKatakuri]

As ridiculous as it would have been Sith and Jedi Force ghosts battling each other would have been so epic Imagine Yoda faces ghost Palpatine.

[@BubblegumCrash332]

It's like the Nazis and Germany were defeated during WW2 but 30 years later they pop out of nowhere and conquer the world. An explanation would be nice

[@LegoSnoopDogg]

But NATO are still in control, but there is still a rebel group for some reason, and they blow up New York, which somehow destroys all of NATO.

[@AmericanUnionState1824]

Even though Zaid wasn't the best of people, I still enjoyed watching his videos. And I strongly agree with him about the Star Wars sequel trilogy.

[@MC69420-v]

Yeah it’s just a shame that his re-review gets bombarded by people who use the “video too long and therefore bad video” or “it came out a long time ago” excuses

[@emperorvader3344]

Ehh i agree Last Jedi has problems (although in my opinion Kennedy was not trying to push a feminist agenda) but Zaid went too far in bullying people throughout the video just for liking the movie. That honestly showed me just how unhinged he truly was. It was honestly like the idea of someone enjoying this movie was alien to him. If I were in his shoes I would have just agreed to disagree and left those people alone. It might not have been so bad if he didnt name drop them throughout the video but Im getting ahead of myself

[@AmericanUnionState1824]

@@emperorvader3344 good point.

[@MC69420-v]

@@emperorvader3344 in all fairness, i partly blame the detractors since they were no better either in terms of opinions, like, they'll say he needs to respect opinions one miniute, and the next they crucify him when he shares his, especially if it's in a negative light. granted he wished death on people and all but still, my point still stands.

[@ryanbarth6691]

@@AmericanUnionState1824 he even said anyone who likes the last Jedi is lying

[@ryanbarth6691]

*Thadmaster7's description* I can't believe I'm doing this again, wanna hear this disgrace of a statement yourself?, be my guest.

[@alexey635able]

> Stop re-igniting your hatred for a movie you personally didn’t like and move on! Looking back on it now, it was a *very* good advice

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

Hard to not recall a garbage sequel when you are trying to rewatch and enjoy the masterpiece that came before it. I have a passionate love for ATLA, not just for the characters and writing and music, but also for being ASIATIC. I have always been a huge fan of precolonial Asian culture. But everything changed when LoK ruined it with the retcons and Americanization of what was an exclusively Asiatic fantasy universe. European culture doesn't exist in the Avatar universe, so it taking over in the sequel is ABSOLUTE nonsense. And now I can't watch ATLA because the back of my mind remembers the crap sequel. I see the established facts that I know are going to get retconned. It's an awful conundrum.

[@shamefuldisplay9692]

The trilogy basically demolished a cultural touchstone and replaced it with crap. It deserves the hate it gets, even years later.

[@bigmacintosh1766]

​@@shamefuldisplay9692thank you

[@bigmacintosh1766]

He never reignited anything. He's rightfully talking about a bad movie and it's flaws. A bad movie will ALWAYS be talked about. People still talk about how bad The Room and Foodfight

[@joeyblowey3460]

Meanwhile RedLetterMedia "Mr. Plinkett" made long form reviews of the prequels over a decade later and not only did no one bat an eye, but people thoroughly enjoyed the reviews despite having some absolutely morbid and disturbing humor in them too that would never fly today

[@countof3everybodyOD]

My headcanon for Han defeating Boba in ROTJ with such a lucky shot was force intervention…and for Luke being shocked to bits by Palpatine, I’ve always believed he didn’t even try fighting back because it was the only way to drag Anakin back out of Vader; seeing his son tortured and almost killed

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

Holy crap, so I am NOT the only one salvaging Zaid's videos?

[@redlinrangerstudio5331]

This 3 hour video has not age well

[@moradkhamlichi9476]

beacause of Mark hamill ?

[@redlinrangerstudio5331]

​@moradkhamlichi9476 what? No.

[@MC69420-v]

reciting Zaid's pinned comment (and hoping this gets pinned too lmfaoooo): From this moment onward, if you make either of the two following comments, or say anything that translates to the following, you will be blocked. *"ThE mOvle CaMe OuT tHrEe YeArS aGo! GeT oVeR iT!"* Yeah, the movie is three years old. And guess what? It's still terrible. The passage of time doesn't change the writing quality of the film. People are still talking about how bad this particular movie was because it was extremely bad, a huge controversy involving damage to a historical icon in western culture. You wouldn't have a single problem with reviews of this particular 3 year old movie if it was a positive review. When it's a negative review, suddenly it's "beating a dead horse". People are allowed to reflect on how this movie has aged since the sequel trilogy ended. If you can't handle people still talking about this movie, that's not my fault. That's a you problem. The fact people still critisize this movie 3 years later further proves how quickly it aged like milk. *"WhY iS tHiS vidEo LoNgEr Than ThE aCtUal mOvie?! GeT a LiFe!"* Because there's a lot of content to dissect and critique you twat. These are not nitpicks. These are serious issues with how the movie was written, with gaping plot holes that could've easily been explained if the writers took the time to actually think about their script for 1 second. The Last Jedi has a lot of problems, and explaining those problems requires a lot of time because it was written with no regard for 35 years of established lore, resulting in something completely removed of any logical process. Every scene is bleeding with plot holes and incohesive writing mistakes, culminating in a plot that relies on characters doing stupid things for stupid reasons. This is basically you: "I didn't watch it but I know it's bad even though I have provided no real argument that it's bad because I didn't even see the video to see what I thought was so bad." By making either of these two comments, you are showing no desire to engage with the video and just demonstrated yourself as a crybaby snowflake from twitter who got angry at the title. You just saw "Local youtuber makes negative review of The Last Jedi" and immediately got your poop infested diapers in a twist. You have no right to silence people who rightfully critisize the mountain of cow manure that Rian Johnson and Kathleen Kennedy chose to put out. Unless you have an actual rebuttal pertaining to the points I've made in this video towards the film's writing quality, fuck off.

[@anonheart]

Unfortunately due to typical YT BS, i'm unable to pin it thou i'll copypaste it in the description

[@MC69420-v]

@@anonheart huh, weird, typical dumbass youtube stuff And thanks

[@alditoification]

Thank you for acknowledge our existence. Idiot.

[@brianjordan3841]

Thank u so much 4 calling out Cosmonaut 4 his stupidity in claiming that Luke n Anakin were Mary Sues/ Gary Stus

[@saintsheepy6682]

3:06:42 Apparently when it came to strong female characters, Kathleen Kennedy never even heard of Flora, Fauna, and Merryweather from the original Sleeping Beauty film, who also dismantle her argument, they not only helped Prince Phillip out and raised Aurora for 16 years, they also weren't even Mary Sues.

[@MrGeorge01]

Good review. I also liked the part with apology to Mauler. That shows your maturity and frankly, he deserved it.

[@MrGeorge01]

BTW, if you are in contact with Mauler, can you please remind him that his SW reviews are still unfinished? Also, most people listen to those long videos, not watching them, so no need for heavy video editing

[@insaneyogurt4993]

⁠@@MrGeorge01buddy this ain’t zaid, this is a reupload of his video

[@brianjordan3841]

Well at least Zaid didn’t blame Lucas 4 the outright debacle that was Disney’s mistreatment of Star Wars

[@brianjordan3841]

Don’t forget Anakin had a history of never finishing a pod race much less winning 1 b4 he met Qui Gon Jin n Padme

[@brianjordan3841]

Luke didn’t convince his uncle to buy R2-D2 n C-3PO Uncle Owen called him over to take them in n clean them up

[@MyReligionIs2DoGood]

Well, akshully...😋 Owen called him over to take C-3PO and a red R2 unit, the latter being defective. C3PO then suggested to Luke to get R2D2, after the red bot malfunctioned, which made Luke suggest R2D2 to Owen. So you are both 50% correct. 😉

[@brianjordan3841]

@@MyReligionIs2DoGood fair enough

[@thenerdwholovesentertainme1721]

It's just sad to know that the last jedi could've been a great sequel like empire strikes back but I guess I was just a fool for believing in Disney that despises it's own fans & old school star wars fans.

[@JonathanGaeta]

I feel the same way because I actually liked TLJ when it came out, I was 16 at the time. But as I got older I realized that everything in that movie broke the Star Wars universe and when TROS came out it just finished the job of killing the greatness of Star Wars to the point where I don’t care for Star Wars anymore, however there is an upside as I only keep my cherished memories of Star Wars with the original and prequel trilogies.

[@thenerdwholovesentertainme1721]

@@JonathanGaeta The only two things I liked about the star wars sequel trilogy was the soundtracks and the fact that these movies made me not hate the prequels so much because at least you were able to follow the story better than what disney was trying to do.

[@BrownMan-gg7dx]

@1:24:36 damn. I know hes exaggerating but just the thought of anybody being more powerful then all those hacks mentioned is ridiculous. 😂 Funny as hell none the less

[@TheoTungsten]

Zaid should post his unfinished TROS rant script somewhere so someone else, perhaps even an AI can finish it and narrate it. Then Zaid should disappear.

[@brianjordan3841]

N with the failure of the sequel trilogy comes the collective realization that the prequel trilogy wasn’t the worst thing in the Star Wars franchise hell we had the Holiday Special as well as the 2 Ewok movies n the Solo movie, these films r more accurate examples of bad Star Wars movies then the prequel trilogy n now they can take their rightful place in the franchise beside the classic trilogy as far as good movies go

[@brianjordan3841]

I just love how Zaid is willing to call out these idiots 4 their collective stupidity especially Kathleen Kennedy

[@brianjordan3841]

R we supposed to forget that Anakin never finished a pod race much less won 1 b4 Qui Gon Jinn n Padme Amidala showed up in his life it was even mentioned b4 the big race scene in The Phantom Menace

[@TrueUnnamedHero]

Finn should have become a jedi in the second movie. Knowing how close disney is to china, im gonna let you figure out for yourselves why it became only rey. ( hint: same reason why finn is made very tiny in the cover art for the Chinese releases of the movies)

[@sputnikman]

JJ Abrams treated Star Wars like it was Star Trek. He ruined it. There, I said it.

[@TheoTungsten]

Can you also upload his old TLJ review?

[@torri776]

The 5 parter? If so, I agree since his Definitive Edition got way more attention than said review, though both are good reviews imo

[@anonheart]

I don't really see a point it given they are titled "old" meaning this is more thought out than his 5 parter

[@TheoTungsten]

@@anonheart His Rise of Skywalker previews then?

[@michaelcorleone3286]

I'm gonna miss Zaid Magenta

[@autisticvenusaur]

:|

[@SSKO2]

Me too honestly

[@g4m3boy42]

Me too. But, unfortunately he will never come back because of the stupid shit that he did.

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

@@g4m3boy42 Never say never.

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

I already do.

[@cursedreality8615]

What happpend to him?

[@muigokublack6487]

LioConvoy did a video on it who was apparently a friend of Zaid but it seems the short version is he kept making alt accounts to harass people over petty slights/disagreements and sending messages just short of death threats and when given a second chance to grow and learn from his mistakes he relapsed back into his old habits making sock puppet accounts and harassing people and when he was called out again he was kicked out by his friends who previously defended him and seems he deleted his channel in a final act of pettiness. Zaid has always had anger issues and seems incapable of letting things go.

[@cursedreality8615]

@@muigokublack6487 damn that sucks I hope he grows and improves from the situation I genuinely loved his videos on the Star Wars sequels

[@muigokublack6487]

@@cursedreality8615 Me too, as this video shows he did a quite through teardown of the film and I was looking forward to his Rise Of Palpatine video.

[@wisherofsnowdays]

@@muigokublack6487 Sounds like he has untreated ADHD. Maybe we shouldn't villainize him just because he's different or has issues. Ever think of that, fuck nuts?

[@SSKO2]

“The last jedi came out 5 years ago and therefore your criticism is invalid, not to mention the video is 3 hours long so it makes it even worse” -idiots on twitter In all seriousness Zaid isn’t wrong for calling those people out

[@alditoification]

Thank you for acknowledge idiots existence to everyone else. Idiot.

[@crimsoncrusader518]

He just didn't need to be a horrible jerk about it.

[@GreenTomas2372]

⁠@@crimsoncrusader518 Surely not in MAP/Zaid Magenta’s deficit there's only so much horrible merit arguments one could take and twist the patience of the individual and reviewer. A long while ago I had a few Discord pals worked on a pro Star Wars Prequels video and of course you would get a few frivolous comments that aren’t worth taken seriously; there was at least one of the commenters expressing how defending the Prequels is “cringe”. So me and my Discord pals opened up the discussion with a fairly reasonable reply but the same commenter rather chose to whine, cry, act like a massive toddler about how defeating the prequels makes them “victimized” and engage in an insulting contest instead of an actual conversation and provide a constructive argument like an adult. It went on for up to 45 minutes until we came to the conclusion that the commenter has nothing at to stay and had to put the foot down and block him. At that point we didn’t care about being a “horrible jerk” cuz if you ready think about it; do ya want to waist time interact with annoying people whom talks to much but says so little?

[@SSKO2]

@@crimsoncrusader518 it could've been a LOT worse (but considering what he's done. it most likely has)

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

I Reuploaded 2 of his videos

[@NostalgicGamerRickOShay]

I got three so far. My focus was getting his Mass Effect 3 one.

[@BobbyGulleyYoutuber]

Never was a fan of Zaid Magenta aka MisAnthroPony, especially considering his recent actions. Even so, I do agree that The Last Jedi was a poorly written movie and even more so in Rise of Skywalker. The whole sequel trilogy wasn't thought out well. It's a good example of what not to do in a trilogy. Despite that, even though I consider the sequel trilogy wasted potential, I don't flat out dwell on how bad they were as Zaid does. He makes good points in this review, but he does not need to attack anyone who had a different opinion on the movie than he does. If they like the movies, then that's good. More power to you. Just don't force others to like what you like. And MisAnthroPony should not force others to dislike what he dislikes to people as well. Especially when it comes to movies, shows, games, books, and entertainment as a whole. You can like or dislike a movie, but if someone has a different opinion on a movie you like or dislike, I would not attack them for their opinion. I would disagree with them, yes, but I won't insult this person. I would ask them why they like or dislike it. And if they gave me a good reason why, I would respect that. If not, than I'll explain to them why I think they are wrong on it, but I'll do it in a respectful manner. Now, if this person has insulted me for liking or disliking a movie, then I would simply block them and move on with my day, not insult them back. That just makes you just as bad as that person. That's what I wished Misanthropony would've done. Sadly he didn't. And that's a shame. There were some reviews that he did I liked, such as his MLP reviews and his Pokemon review was very good. But the dude's got an anger problem and he needs to seek help for it. So yeah, I'm glad someone is reuploading some of his old content for history sake. :P ^^ Great job!

[@cursedreality8615]

What did Zaid do in new to all this?

[@ryanbarth6691]

Dude he said anyone who likes the last Jedi is lying and who likes Rey is mentally ill

[@JasonSanchez-fj4xk]

​@@cursedreality8615he called people idiots for loving the last Jedi called them autistic.

[@wisherofsnowdays]

@@JasonSanchez-fj4xk He's probably autistic and ADHD by the sounds of it. No reason to cancel people because they have disabilities.

[@brianjordan3841]

As much as I love Gal Gadot I have to agree if I were given a choice between the live action Wonder Woman n the first ever animated Wonder Woman movie I’d go with that as it was better handled

[@samflood5631]

Just because Last Jedi was a bad movie doesn’t mean it should be a Blight on Humanity.

[@crimsoncrusader518]

Just wondering, why did people like Zaid again? This isn't an insult to the people that like him, I really want to know why people liked him?

[@freddieweaver-g2s]

He is extremely angry.

[@crimsoncrusader518]

@@freddieweaver-g2sWas that an observation or an answer? Because if so, then what's the point if you don't use that anger correctly.

[@sonicfan2403]

​@@crimsoncrusader518 The way I see it was that when he wasn't going overboard with his anger and other stupid antics, he actually put careful consideration into his reviews in detail. It's why I went back to his Last Jedi and Steven Universe videos.

[@crimsoncrusader518]

@@sonicfan2403 Ok, though some facts are off, but did he have to call people brain dead, or the R word just for liking it, when he doesn't? Or when he admitted to sending a death threat on Twitter to someone who just said that he should just let people like something that he doesn't? Did that not feel just a little bit off? Not trying to insault you,, I just want to know if there was someone who felt one or two red flags waving around him?

[@wisherofsnowdays]

@@crimsoncrusader518 Would you rather he censor who he is and how he thinks so it can be family friendly? People like you are a pox on this world.

[@Matthias333]

Wait.. this movie wasn't good!?!?

[@antoniosalieri1048]

No It wasn't He explained why

[@KarenMyComputerWife]

Can't say I'm sad that he's gone.

[@crimsoncrusader518]

Me neither, it actually gave me hope for humanity.

[@ryanbarth6691]

I'm happy he's gone

[@wisherofsnowdays]

I can, but I'm not a pvssy who needs to virtue signal so internet strangers might think better of my username.

[@brianjordan3841]

Ehh I would say this trilogy is more like 2 spoiled children fighting over who get to play with George Lucas’s stuff while taking a crap on it

[@brianjordan3841]

I swear it’s bcuz of Rian Johnson’s idiotic idea of dividing the audience in order to make a movie that I can’t bring myself to watch any of his films

[@brianjordan3841]

Huh it’s funny how he keeps bringing up the prequel trilogy n having to make either better comparisons, or corrections to his previous descriptions of the prequels to the sequel trilogy (whether it’s about Jar Jar Binx, Midi-chlorian, Anakin turning to the dark side n being a well written character, who’s a Mary Sue/ Gary Stu n who isn’t, how the prequels made the classic trilogy better while the sequel trilogy damn near wants to kill it etc etc)

[@raymondmcginley5676]

13:02 idk why i thought that was funny

[@crimsoncrusader518]

So misunderstood.

[@brianjordan3841]

Yes Make Star Wars Great Again I don’t care if Zaid doesn’t like Donald Trump he’s the best president we’ve had so far n if someone can come along n fix the Star Wars franchise in a similar manner to Trump fixing America then by god I’ll take it

[@brianjordan3841]

Yeah the sooner Disney pulls it’s head out of it’s ass n gets rid of Kathleen Kennedy the better Star Wars will b

[@brianjordan3841]

I swear to god if u like the sequel trilogy n think that they’re good movies good luck ever describing the prequel trilogy as being bad movies bcuz they r leaps n bounds, head n shoulders so much better then this shit pile dumpster fire Yes Make Star Wars Great Again

[@Billy-pb5gq]

Mk loop

[@davinheagertans4275]

This is an excellent take down of this garbage movie. But there is a limit to how much a person should be loyal to fiction.

[@TyTyMcGinty]

How did you talk like this for 3 and a half hours?

[@Ncholasbloom]

he's so wrong about how goku beat frieza do research before you talk about it

[@crimsoncrusader518]

And much more.

[@chasx7062]

Stop whinging and whining, The Last Jedi is as good as Empire. TLJ is 1000x better than Rebel Moon

[@g4m3boy42]

My guy, TLJ is garbage. Empire strikes back is good but TLJ has nothing good at all.

[@chasx7062]

@@g4m3boy42 Technically, TLJ is superior, empire only has nostalgia muhaha

[@g4m3boy42]

​@@chasx7062Are you dumb? How is TLJ superior? That film has ruined George Lucas's work and it damaged Disney's business.

[@DBWave94]

​@@g4m3boy42Dude, it's clearly bait. Don't feed into it.

[@HugoSoup57]

⁠@@chasx7062You are totally wrong mate. The Empire Strikes Back is widely considered the best SW film for a reason. TESB has mostly great acting, amazing directing, incredible writing, great dialogue, great characters, great visuals, great cinematography, great editing, great pacing, actually amazing worldbuilding, the best emotional weight, and one of the best stories ever told in a blockbuster. The Last Jedi has mostly poor writing with numerous glaring plot holes, poor pacing, poorly written characters, poor humor, ruins Luke’s character, has a badly choreographed fight scene , and did I mention that the story is nonsensical?