The LitterBox Critic - Why Cartoonmania Failed

[@TheLitterboxCritic]

Hey, Just because I dislike a web series more than this series, does not mean I have ill will towards the creators (except the Rodfellows creators, fuck you guys)

[@KennethV2000]

I want ill will to go to Animator320 for what he had done and he should go to hell. Also Why are u saying we shouldn't send ill will to groomers? Don't be disgusting and a supporter.

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

huh what about those guys

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

What did they do

[@de_dan]

@@JustCallMeHeavy heavy is bomb

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

I don’t think that CartoonMania is terrible, I just think it’s OVERHYPED

[@zaccaryvega]

I remember working with this dude on his reboot (my name/profile pic show up in the video!!) The whole thing was a fucking mess. First of all, he wanted to have 99 episodes. THEN, he started building lore and enemies for the main cast (he was obsessed with the new DuckTales reboot at the time) which didn't fit the "Animaniacs" aesthetic he had put into place. And then worst of all, he just... didn't do much and kinda left us scrambling to figure out everything he had dumped onto us. If he was John K., then I almost became Bob Camp, since I was the one keeping the wheels turning until we called him out on his bullcrap. Looking back, I don't know how I didn't see the red flags early on, but I'm damn sure glad I kicked him to the curb

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

I feel so sorry for you guys

[@hihowareya1456]

EVERYONE STOP BULLYING ANIMATOR320!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AND LEAVE HIM ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!😡😡

[@TheAnimalKingdom-tq3sz]

@@hihowareya1456 If you love him so much, Why don't just MARRY HIM?!

[@untipoinanimado2352]

@@TheAnimalKingdom-tq3sz Hahaha you were great

[@anthonymarziano1921]

what else can you tell me about this guy.

[@BabyLambCreations]

I think this is a good insight on the series demonstrating both its flaws and appeals. Personally, I did enjoy the series and I was impressed at how he used OpenOffice to animate. The designs were pretty cool in my opinion and the voice acting was great. Some episodes were pretty meh and others were pretty funny. However, I couldn't stand all those Victor and Penny scenes (especially when it eventually got over the top which contributed to him getting exposed). I was weirded out by the fact that two toddlers are a lovey-dovey couple. But I thought, given their age, it would be some safe puppy love kind of shit. And of course, I was wrong. People over-glorify it too much with that "Slapstick" episode and since a lot of it is just known for Matthew yelling. A good web series is remembered for lots of notable stuff rather than just something ironically meme-worthy. And since my own web series was mentioned at (15:43), I am obligated to say "THERE I AM, GARY, THERE I AM". However, as much as I wholeheartedly respect your opinion, putting my series on the same level as all those others doesn't make much sense because my series was never even meant to be considered a webtoon series in any shape or form like all those others.

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

If I would, I could polish that turd of a movie he did. Remove all the creepy forced shipping and repeated scenarios of dialogue, make the movie slightly better and more watchable. And have a better ending. The series itself in my eyes is always gonna be a trainwreck. But if people like the series, good on them. I'm not gonna get mad about that, as long as they aren't defending the creator. But i'll never forgive matthew for trying to pull off cancel culture on me by making those exposed videos. And abusing his crew members behind production. Not alot of people know my history with him. If you're wondering who made that google drive link, that would be me. I've compiled all of those screenshots anonymous users have sent me back when the drama still occured. And I was responsible for leaking the infamous 69th floor animation. All of you don't have to thank me, I'm just glad I got him away from talking to kids.

[@ZeepAtomic]

It always depresses me when a cartoon has a cool concept, neat character concepts as well, but turns out to be a huge mess. This show makes for quite a good example.

[@titan-1802]

@john ouren *Oh ShUt Up!* said a Cartoonmania fan

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

Me too… Brat

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

Not you titan I AM TALKING TO YOU ZEEP THE WOCHY!

[@ZeepAtomic]

@@yvonnejeffreys1723 did you just

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

YEAH I DID! THIS IS WHAT YOU GET AND DESERVE!

[@girlywolfpup1588]

Slapstick is a concept that occurs in most Litterbox Critic videos

[@fizzizzsoda]

*SLAPSTICK IS A CONCEPT THAT OCCURS IN MOST CRAPPY ANIMATED WEBTOONS*

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

hahaa

[@bracket-neutron]

Cartoonmania and its creator are a disaster story worthy of being part of webtoon history. In 2019, I was actually connected somewhat with Matthew, even having him as a friend on Discord during that time unfortunately. At the time, I mainly dismissed a lot of the criticism he got because he was in communities where they were protecting him, and I got a little brainwashed because of it. Seeing what would come or stuff that I ignored in hindsight, it's shocking that he wasn't officially outed until his departure. Even ignoring his disturbing interactions, his series gave off some bad vibes especially when we watched the movie that has no substance to deserve being one. Why he decided to force a shipping with his Penny and Victor characters is beyond me, and given their age it's no wonder he got in trouble for that ship later on. There's also that one Shantae bellydance animation remake he did with Tanya which you didn't mention. I actually remember some of the controversy behind it, and his fans and I just went with his weak apology. Oddly, the reason I actually cut ties was because he was posting some obnoxious stuff on his Twitter, resulting in an unfollow (because yeah, I was sticking up with him at the time even if I was never big on his show). Overall, this was a great review of the Cartoonmania series. Unbiased and thoughtful like critique videos should be, and I agree with you on next to everything said. I am a little nicer in terms of the animation, and admit that it's impressive for the software he used at the time. Still, the limited animation and unappealing style really harm the series, especially so with how slapstick focused it is. Still better animation than whatever that Rodfellows nightmare was, and this didn't have the same production issues that did. Cartoonmania, while not having a super creative or deep premise, had loads of potential and some episodes and ideas confirm that. Matthew made it worse with the way he acted, and that's why there's been such a reevaluation of the series after he was outed. Don't know if it shows how overly optimistic Twitter types are to any animated media, or if it's just the curse of being supportive to anything with a cool idea no matter how poorly it's executed. Lastly, thanks for allowing me to cameo in this at 15:18, geckos truly are sacred critters.

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

My experience with him is quite a trip. I won't try to make it long but to put it in short, we didn't get along very well, mainly with me. Yeah I dealt with things back then that really hurt me and that I put it on him, I wasn't thinking straight at the time. besides with what happened in the community I was in. I'll admit that i went too far when he called me out on that drawing I did on him, while yes i did regret that. I however don't regret being so harsh on him. I originally wanted to voice for his cartoon but it didn't go well and honestly I'm glad I wasn't. Especially after he tried to "expose" me on a video. I was kinda involved with the drama that happened in 2020, I do know who was responsible for the infamous 69th floor animation. If it wasn't for that and his secret account, he would've gotten away with it. I could go on about this more when it comes to me and him but I'll end it here.

[@nobod2567]

Wait that belly dance animation ripped off shantae?

[@GabePickles3837]

The art style kinda reminds me of Garfield. It’s mainly the eyes. And Matthew’s sona kinda looks like a bootleg Jon Arbuckle.

[@titan-1802]

@John Ouren he said *ART STYLE* not animation.

[@littlegyro8340]

That's what I'm thinking! Most of the characters look like Jim Davis rejects.

[@anthonymarziano1921]

So basically, Matthew is kind of like yandere dev

[@CalzoneStudiozOfficial]

except he doesn't take 6 years to finish something

[@nobod2567]

John K too

[@scootermcpeanuts6699]

That’s an insult even to animator320

[@schmampus6701]

They both like kids

[@dalerockman5286]

The wall of animators had the musician George Benson on the list. Can someone please tell me if there was an animator named George Benson because if there isn't, I questioned his inclusion

[@titan-1802]

After doing some research, the closest person i could find was "George Benson Travel". George Benson Travel used to upload Omegle videos, Minecraft animation's (i could only find one), gameplay videos, and vlogs. He also does a lot of Fifa gameplay, actual soccer tricks and goals, plus reactions too. However, he only has one animation and thats basically the "MINECRAFT on Chatroulette". So yeah, George Benson Travel only did one Animation and that was it. Definitely not him on the Wall of Animators.

[@goatlick21]

11:14 the police finding child porn on matthew's computer

[@toastysheep7110]

The show “CartoonMania” was the horrible thing I’ve ever saw, i used to like of his videos just because he got drama for that, and the show is most likely a clone of Foster’s Home for Imaginary Friends on Cartoon Network, Warner Bros’ Looney Tunes, Animaniacs and Tiny Toon Adventures. and Disney’s Mickey Mouse, Bonkers and Goof Troop. Which had better slapstick than that.

[@titan-1802]

@john ouren you must be fun at parties, and you and along with the braindead Cartoonmania fans ran across the Mountains of Madness, and never watched Eddsworld.

[@CarnoProductions]

Honestly, to see a project that I honestly give little care on, it is shocking to see how much this failed. CartoonMania's most popular video is well the film that I just refused to watch because I've got better stuff to do. And hell even when I was researching him. I found out this guy lives in my state. But besides that, I do think CartoonMania is just something people will just forget. But I'll be for real. CartoonMania is honestly boring and found out this guy is making his reboot which good luck with that. If I wanna give this on a scale I'll give CartoonMania a 4/10 because it's just boring. It sucks that people still support this guy to this day after all he did. I mean the drive's gone now which is bit of a pain. But hey pretty good and informative video I gotta say

[@danielgudinojuarez6729]

This Matthew guy seriously needs to get out of social media, he belongs in a mental hospital and jail

[@starcap75]

No he doesn't!

[@thespongebobsquarepants1999]

​@@starcap75 shut up dick Rider

[@Zorstvaroth]

homer simpson

[@movedtosomenewaccount]

1:14 LOL This is a reference to some awkward GoAnimate rants 1:59 OK NOW THIS SCARES ME THAT WAS WAY TOO FAR

[@Robowil]

The CartoonMania Movie actually made me question my entire life after I watched it. It's that awful imo.

[@titan-1802]

@john ouren yes it is.

[@doodletortlewortle6113]

I always thought that Matthew was on hiatus when I first discovered CartoonMania on June 2022. But it turns out I was wrong, Matthew completely lost his mind back then.

[@knightmarin]

Years later and the art looks the same💀

[@de_dan]

Deadass webtoon

[@ZadoreNichArchives]

Matthew’s trying make a comeback and trying to be a "better person” like bro You can’t try to be a better person if you were called out for being pedo 💀 Once a pedo, always a pedo

[@shadowchasernql]

@@ZadoreNichArchives nah but his show sucked anywayss

[@shoenicemugshot]

You know what's bad? The theme song for this show (which I have knew for some time) is... kinda catchy.

[@shadowchasernql]

that's good i guess

[@klkfanboy6128]

Eddsworld is honestly my first, favorite and quite funny web series i ever watched before helluva boss, happy tree friends, and monster lab came Way better than this trashmania.

[@Z3RO5286]

Yes. Eddsworld is timeless and will forever have it's legacy kept on. Edd's world will forever keep on spinning. It's up there with blockhead and madness combat as one of the best newgrounds series of all time.

[@gregger_mcgregger]

As much as it is impressive considering what Matthew was working with his show is nowhere NEAR worthy or quality that’s comparable to any of those shows you just mentioned (Never in my life did I think I would say I would rather watch Helluva Boss over something else though holyyyy)

[@DeadAirChronicleshorror]

Oh finally somebody made a rant on this God awful series even before Matthew was exposed I thought it was trash Matthew wouldn’t put effort into it and I hate that Stupid villain in the CartoonMania movie He’s so annoying.

[@gyblihylicz9125]

that's a critique.

[@DeadAirChronicleshorror]

@@gyblihylicz9125 yup

[@TSFRGcomedy]

If you think it was trash, then you were one step closer to knowing how wrong animator320 was, to be honest I didn't like his animations either.

[@tyhillbroussard4924]

I used to like this series, but then I stopped caring for it. The cartoon style isn’t that appealing, the animation is too wacky and fast pasted (unlike some animations like Cloudy With A Chance Of Meatballs and Hotel Transylvania), and I think it has too much slapstick, though I like slapstick cartoons like the Tex Avery cartoons, but not ones where the slapstick is overused. And Matthew? Well, let’s just say he needs help. If anyone like this series and still does, fine by me. Edit: Oh yeah, and it feels like a cheap copy of Foster’s Home For Imaginary Friends

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

My comment keeps getting hidden for some reason so I'm gonna say this with how my experience was with matthew miserable and toxic, he got me into alot of problems with turkey tom when he called him out, idk why I defended him at the time. I wanted to be friends with him, got backstabbed and he made exposed videos out of me. then I got him back with what he did to his characters. horrible human being. and he should've never came back

[@greencirclethemysingingmonster]

14:46 link of the floors?

[@CalzoneStudiozOfficial]

Criticism is a concept that Occurs in Most Ratings

[@randalltonbrewster]

12:07 idk why he added Cocomelon (at least it's not wolfoo)

[@ahereticsdoomvideos3216]

11:49 Didn't expect Hazbin Hotel to show up

[@rgbeet]

I can't believe someone brought up Battle For Island Sleep in the year 2022, lmao

[@deaconmaud5194]

In my opinion this show ripped off fosters home for imaginary friends which is better than than that show

[@gyblihylicz9125]

Agreed with your opinion in all honesty.

[@ZeepAtomic]

True.

[@ladyheavdev]

And also IF, which was mid

[@wascallywabbit6151]

Sorry to ask but… 0:36 full version?

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

It's from the composer's soundcloud who has more talent than matthew will ever be, it's named under Cartoonmania Theme Remastered

[@123_its_bopise]

This was a very good watch!! I felt like you explained and talked about things extremely well!! 👍🏼

[@MisterSkullium]

should probably make your characters poses more consistent tbh

[@nyrvajeudy394]

I personally still enjoy the show, but I respect your opinion and can acknowledge the series' flaws.

[@VICS_SFTM2010]

15:54 Music???? Please!!!!

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

What the heck was that part on 13:41

[@realDannyBoi111]

HAHAHAHA THE "Failure adventure" PART GOT ME All of that aside, good rant, especially against this creep and his show.

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

GoAnimate?

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

Also aren't you a guy on DeviantArt

[@realDannyBoi111]

@@JustCallMeHeavy to reply to both of your comments: 1. yes it was a goanimate reference 2. yes i use deviantart idk what that has to do with this but i do

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

@@realDannyBoi111 I was saying that because I know you off of that site.

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

@@realDannyBoi111 I think I might have confused you with another guy.

[@ronaldokaua9009]

7:23 Worse, I have to agree for Cartoonmania that there are more than 100 characters, it needs an introduction showing more of the story in depth, because I'm sure there's something more to the story. but this is different from Mugman where everything is simple and doesn't require that

[@pistolpetereal]

I was in his circle back in the day. Full disclosure, I was the one who got his address. I do admit I took things a bit far and I can’t speak for myself because I was kind of a shitty person when I was a teenager. It was crazy being there to see it unfold.

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

The CartoonMania Documentary

[@RAZ0RL0PEE]

I love how all of my friends call Matthew Homer Simpson. I can't remember his name most of the time so I just call him Homer

[@JustCallMeHeavy]

he kinda does look like hommer

[@BroDude95]

Here before matthew strikes this down

[@jordonthecookie]

The link to thd Google drive doesn't work.

[@crush1an]

Also the fact that Timmy and Tanya look like siblings and there both shipped together which makes Matthew look like a proshipper

[@crush1an]

Also Chompy is my Favourite Character in Cartoonmaina

[@Zadecarlson]

Timmy and Tanya are not siblings.

[@inotpurplegirlgachastudios06]

Fr like when Me and my friend watched it we thought they were siblings☹️

[@Zadecarlson]

@@inotpurplegirlgachastudios06 Timmy said there “just friends” meaning their “not” related.

[@BroDude95]

​@@Zadecarlsonwell he did a piss poor job by not changing up their designs to make it look like they aren't. You know damn well he intentionally made them look like siblings.

[@francolopezquintana]

That's why Animator180's parents disowned him

[@BroKaelaStudios]

12:15 and jacknjellify!

[@KennethV2000]

We should bully groomers like Animator320. Don't tells us not to bully anyone else that was involved. Don't defend the guy btw.

[@mangojumbo]

@@johnouren8464hell no

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

We should not bully people like Animator320 We should bully people like you They are not groomers Animator320 is not a groomer You’re a groomer

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

But We should defend the guy and we should not defend you

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

@@mangojumbo heaven yes

[@titan-1802]

@@Wpoiyttvhfth Geez you are incredibly brainwashed are you...

[@SolarFarle]

I forgot about that series.

[@XanKr1mson]

COUNT QUARTERBACKULA 😂😂😂

[@Elliottproduction148]

2:58 i forgot the animation what was it again

[@ronaldokaua9009]

7:23 Mugman!!! I simply love this series! My Favorite Characters are Mugman Jonnhy and Papa, I could make a video analyzing her, she's very cool, reminiscent of classic SpongeBob one of my favorite webtoons

[@chilpil]

To be fair, you say it's a "Shitty art style" when you're bringing up shows that look worse(no offense), and also, you literally have an MS paint character.

[@titan-1802]

At least the MS Paint character has a better Art Style compared to those shit shows.

[@chilpil]

@@titan-1802 fair enough

[@de_dan]

Homer Simpson looking ahh

[@anthonymarziano1921]

why was show even created, how old is this guy, the chracters are not flesh out what is the point of stanley, what was the creators deal with making victor and penny into a couple.

[@maggiesjourney3877]

Sounds like jealousy to me. He made it work. He made a successful series.

[@titan-1802]

and yet Matthew ended up becoming a Pedophile and the Series' still sucked ass, besides i've seen other Web-animated Series that did a much better work compared to Cartoonmania. so yeah, please put that "SoUnDs LiKe JeAlOuSy" in the Garbage and throw it out of the Window.

[@Kyranyoutubevids]

Agree and why do some of the characters looks like characters straight out of Garfield if you compare Jon from garfield and Matthew from cartoonmania side by side,

[@commando254]

“Cartoon mania: the movie” was actually kinda good I’m my opinion

[@keshaunfarr6400]

11:58 JELO WHAT WHAT?!?!

[@nobod2567]

1:57 WTMF

[@geetoasty]

14:45 these backgrounds look incredibly lazy and awful. Most of them clash with the characters far too much and are too bright most of the time. They're massive eyesores that likely took like 10 min each to make max

[@JalEffect]

What did mattew do anyway ?

[@greencirclethemysingingmonster]

Can you fix the link and bring back the reboot stuff

[@Z3RO5286]

I have seen better stuff on Ms paint. It looks like it was made in paint tools.

[@kootunesscrewy]

This and Durv: The Series... were my least favorite webtoons.

[@HenkGerringa]

just be thankful this is still up matthew likes to take down videos this basically anything that petrays him in a bad way

[@lauticine]

Well I make CartoonMania in Spanish so yeah make sure you watch my videos because the radio parts of CartoonMania and Spanish So we are also what’s your favourite character of CartoonMania Favourite Character is Victor virus It’s Familiar of Casper I mean This is like The same is a good guy it’s really cool in can you what’s your favourite character ?

[@Yokomation]

i did watch Cartoonmania and yes also did comission the Artist to draw some of my OC´s back in the Day and to be 100% honest, the Animation wasn´t Too bad, sometimes you gotta work with what you got, still hearing you say WebCartoons(or Web animation depends really) age like milk im kinda fearing for my Owen Quoll Alone now.

[@markeyiszra]

Guess what? He's back

[@ILoveAngelGabby]

I saw lol what an idiot, how can he be so confident in making a return after all the shit he's done?

[@ponikoTV]

Oh no 😰 Why he's back?

[@bloodood406]

I think that was just a one-time thing.

[@nikolagamer8846]

@@ponikoTV I think he only came back to make the twosday joke that's all

[@nikolagamer8846]

@john ouren I don't really know

[@BroDude95]

Here before matthew takes this down lmao

[@ExplosiveArchives]

Sticks have been slapped

[@tehhydrothunderspartan5359]

The thing I learned about this show is that some people can have very cool ideas, but with bad execution

[@SuperGibaLogan]

cartoonmania's a good webseries, but matthew littlemore is disgusting and i hate him also is that remote's voice at the beginning???????????

[@PlushieBubbleFlower]

The animations are good tho ngl, i would NEVER animate like that

[@PlushieBubbleFlower]

But I did not know he did this...

[@greencirclethemysingingmonster]

can you fix the link

[@KingAJRocksTheWonderGod]

oh

[@utsutsu123]

what happenee to the guy tho?

[@Darkify51]

1:45

[@GabrielVazquez-e4u]

I like the episodes but not the disgusting things… I thought he was a good guy?

[@GabrielVazquez-e4u]

Oh. And by the way he’s making a reboot it’s not so bad

[@rainbowsonic6939]

WHY?!?!? 4:59

[@SkyAgentYT]

Also Amos19 supports that guy.

[@rosaafonso72]

Are false or true

[@TheMovieAndCartoonFan]

Still better than The Rodfellows

[@vomicom]

i liked the cartoonmania movie

[@EllislovesCrossovers]

Not A Bad Review

[@starcap75]

HIS SERIES WILL BE BETTER THAN THIS TRASHY REVIEW!!!

[@titan-1802]

Yeah no.

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

CARTOONMANIA IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@titan-1802]

*N o*

[@titan-1802]

@John Ouren No

[@mangojumbo]

@@johnouren8464no

[@aceyx2019]

@@johnouren8464 no

[@yvonnejeffreys1723]

Imagine I had the RIGHTS to make The CartoonMania REBOOT

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

Cartoon mania did not fail You failed Cartoonmania succceeded

[@Razer3073]

No it failed

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

@@Razer3073 no it succeeded You failed

[@Razer3073]

​@@Wpoiyttvhfth Matt was exposed for being a predator what proof do you need

[@Wpoiyttvhfth]

@@Razer3073 Matt wasn’t a predator You were jealous of him, so you framed him

[@Razer3073]

@@Wpoiyttvhfth how wasn't he a predator he drew NSFW art of his toddler cherecters ie penny and Victor doing some very adult things plus he was roleplaying minors

[@hihowareya1456]

EVERYONE STOP BULLYING ANIMATOR320!!!!! AND ALL OF YOU JUST LEAVE HIM ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHH!!!!!😡😡

[@Simon-Do-Animation]

It's Not Bullying But Animator320 Is The Ruining The Acto

[@hihowareya1456]

NO NO NNOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!! ALL OF YOU LEAVE HIM ALONE LEAVE HIM ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! LEAVE HIM ALONE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Simon-Do-Animation]

@@hihowareya1456Animator320 Stan. 🤓

[@JoseMat2953]

Suck up right there.

[@nobod2567]

WHO GIVES A SHIT!?