The Modernist Approach To Islamic Texts w/ Mufti Yasir Nadeem Al Wajidi

Рет қаралды 3,988

Күн бұрын

Traditional Islam vs. Modernist Islam: Open Dialogue with Dr. Yasir Nadeem
Join us for a thought-provoking discussion on the modernist approach to Islamic texts. Our esteemed guest, Dr. Yasir Nadeem, a renowned scholar and defender of traditional Islamic scholarship, engages in an open and honest dialogue about modern approaches to Islamic texts and how they contrast with the traditional approach.
Timestamps:
00:00:00 Intro
00:00:35 Mufti Yasir Nadeem's Introduction
00:04:10 Modernists as New Age Mu'tazila
00:08:40 Mu'tazila's self-description as "People of Justice and Tauheed"
00:12:00 Do Asha'ira also prefer reason over revelation?
00:19:00 What does modernistic reinterpretation of scripture look like?
00:21:50 The "need" for modern reinterpretation due to temporal irrelevance of classic scholarship
00:27:40 Objection against classical scholarship being based on tradition
00:37:50 Why tradition as the bedrock for law/Jurisprudence is a neccessity
00:41:00 Tangent: How one's demeanor should be with modernists.
00:45:40 Modernist problem with Islamic Consensus (Ijma')
00:49:40 Tangent: Modernistic arguments often discard context for textual sources.
00:56:29 What is wrong with Legal Deliberation (Ijtihaad) performed by the modernists.
00:59:00 Maqasid Al-Sharia and their proper place in influencing the legal rulings.
01:02:20 Customs and when can they affect the determination of Islamic rulings.
01:08:00 Mufti's Classification of Modernists
01:12:30 Why are Sahaba considered trustworthy as de-facto in chains of narration
01:15:00 A possible way of aligning evolution theories with the Islamic narrative?
Welcome to the Project Ihya!
We are a KZbin channel that focuses on Islamically critiquing Modernism and its related ideologies, as well as giving general Islamic lessons.
Our content includes:
Street Dawah clips
Liberal Book Critical Reviews
Relationships advice:
Podcasts
Islahi talks
Question/Answer
Debates
History lessons
We hope that our content will be beneficial to you and help you to learn more about Islam. Please subscribe to our channel and stay tuned for new videos!
Disclaimer: - This Channel DOES NOT Promote or encourage any illegal activities and all content provided by this channel is meant for EDUCATIONAL PURPOSE only.
Copyright Disclaimer: - Under section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for FAIR USE for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research.
Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statutes that might otherwise be infringing. Non- Profit, educational, or personal use tips the balance in favor of FAIR USE

Пікірлер: 14

@projectihya 4 ай бұрын

Timestamps: 00:00:35 Mufti Yasir Nadeem's Introduction 00:04:10 Modernists as New Age Mu'tazila 00:08:40 Mu'tazila's self-description as "People of Justice and Tauheed" 00:12:00 Do Asha'ira also prefer reason over revelation? 00:19:00 What does modernistic reinterpretation of scripture look like? 00:21:50 The "need" for modern reinterpretation due to temporal irrelevance of classic scholarship 00:27:40 Objection against classical scholarship being based on tradition 00:37:50 Why tradition as the bedrock for law/Jurisprudence is a neccessity 00:41:00 Tangent: How one's demeanor should be with modernists. 00:45:40 Modernist problem with Islamic Consensus (Ijma') 00:49:40 Tangent: Modernistic arguments often discard context for textual sources. 00:56:29 What is wrong with Legal Deliberation (Ijtihaad) performed by the modernists. 00:59:00 Maqasid Al-Sharia and their proper place in influencing the legal rulings. 01:02:20 Customs and when can they affect the determination of Islamic rulings. 01:08:00 Mufti's Classification of Modernists 01:12:30 Why are Sahaba considered trustworthy as de-facto in chains of narration 01:15:00 A possible way of aligning evolution theories with the Islamic narrative?