The moment Shay Carl messed up

Listen to the podcast- / romanatwoodpodcast

[@scottlan7122]

The way Shay and Atwood tried to downplay what happened is just sick

[@AngeloRockyOfficial]

who are you to judge, the girl is a cam girl so what she does is sick unholy and what shay did was aswell but who are you to judge

[@scottlan7122]

@@AngeloRockyOfficial What the hell are you talking about? lol

[@slimjiml7510]

@@AngeloRockyOfficial do you realize that what you're doing rn is also judging, that's being incredibly hypocritical

[@michaelrichards669]

Downplay.... Did Shay even have to explain any of it on Roman's podcast?? No

[@Randomstuffs261]

@@AngeloRockyOfficial you didn't understand what you were responding to did you? lol

[@sprunk4143]

I feel so bad for his wife :(

[@hitmanb33b3]

oh please, shay didn't even cheat. He essentially DM'd a pornstar, literally so many men in relationships do the same thing. It truly isn't a big deal. Maybe she shoulda been putting out more.

[@sprunk4143]

@@hitmanb33b3 I really hope you’re single

[@Pika-hr5je]

@@hitmanb33b3uhm no, it’s definitely cheating. Could you imagine if it was the other way around? If she was the one texting other guys then I guarantee all of you guys would be saying she’s for the streets. A loyal man shouldn’t DM other women period. And really shows how you view women by saying “she should’ve been putting out more”. They have kids. A marriage isn’t just about pleasing the man.

[@ave3468]

@@hitmanb33b3honestly so sad and disgusting how you men think. It’s unfortunate that you will believe this is ok but a woman does a single thing “wrong” and she’s the worst person to exist. We don’t need you guys, don’t make it seem like we do.

[@Ash-fp1bb]

@@sprunk4143if he’s not, I feel incredibly sorry for the girl that would ever want to be with this boys mentality.

[@idothings6685]

I lost all respect for him when he tried to blame his infidelities on alcoholism...

[@hus390]

You call texting “infidelity”? It’s not like he had sex with someone else!! That would have been different

[@idothings6685]

@@hus390 too bad he did LOL

[@Raisingwildminds]

​@@idothings6685based on what?

[@guineapigluver10]

@@hus390you’re extremely naive. he was only caught with the text messages. if you think he wasn’t doing anything physical, you are very very slow.

[@rosiebolton4578]

Also mormons will call anything an addiction. He probably had a beer once in a while 😂

[@Swizzlemestix]

Why is she comforting him for his infidelity.

[@chill0141414]

texts

[@xxGravyBabyxx]

I wouldn't be surprised it's because of their religion. Mormons, once they meet their partner, they have to stick with them till death in order to go to heaven. If she even doubts Shay, I wouldn't be surprised if she feels like God is judging her for doubting and punishing him. Mormonism is a strange religion.

[@petastafford908]

​@Btftu I don't think it's their religion that made her, it's called marriage and not to mention they have 5 kids together (not saying you have to be in an unhappy marriage for your kids but you know what I mean) she's not gonna up and leave the second he messes up one time.

[@morghanfreeman2200]

you’ll never see this woman going off on this man publicly especially on a podcast, so ofc shes gonna come off comforting

[@TaylorNicholC]

It's basically part of the Mormon religion, women are treated like dogs and baby factory's

[@madtingz2288]

Atwood downplaying what Shay did right in front of his wife was heartbreaking to watch.

[@arkantos9192]

Shay is one of the luckiest blokes in the world

[@pooja_aggarwal]

Thats what u surmise from this?

[@SofiaAn08]

You are not the victim… we don’t feel sorry for you

[@lucieyorke8107]

That fact she’s comforting him 🤦

[@Finksta951]

About that time is when i stopped watching their content. I used to be a Shaytard but I can't support that kind of behavior. I'm glad they made it through it or whatever but that innocence and close family feel will forever be gone at least for me and thats why I used to watch. It sort of helped ease the pain I was going through when my mom and dad divorced. Ironically for the same reason. It was kind of like going through it twice. After came the heroin and the meth because at least those two things never let you down like the adults you look up to in life do.

[@Finksta951]

Im sober now

[@evanlafrance3978]

Good for you!

[@davidybarra7774]

U are speaking for a lot of us dude. I feel the exact same.

[@wendylajoy8690]

I don’t understand how people can ruin a good thing, but unfortunately it happens all the time.

[@unbothered2023]

Omg i havent seen the shaytards in years omg.

[@Devin_Copeland]

I think it's funny people still try to put shay down for what he did, it was a dumb mistake that he's owned up to a million times and his own family doesn't hate him for it so who are you to hate him for it?

[@frosty129]

Texting women/men while you’re married is not a mistake. It’s normal. Don’t believe the idiots who frame shay farting as an act of cheating.

[@Roonifer]

@frosty129 Writing a practical novel describing in heavy detail what he would do to the other woman sexually while under the influence of alcohol while married and while parenting young children is not "normal" and it's quite disturbing to see your username pop up in multiple places within this comment section in an attempt to excuse his actions. Especially considering Shay now has further allegations against him. This is not "normal".

[@ave3468]

@@frosty129disgusting. Hopefully you horrible nasty people grow up and don’t hurt others as you go through life. Good luck to the people around you.

[@mynamejev2489]

@@frosty129that is in no way normal

[@skeeyee1643]

I just want everyone to know he never fcked another woman. He didn’t even kiss another woman. He TEXTED another woman while he was under the influence. All that drama, that HUGE scandal was because of that. Lmfao.

[@aqua6613]

Anything to stay relevant I guess...fake drama then.

[@skeeyee1643]

@@aqua6613 i don’t think it was fake drama its just mormons being over dramatic combined with the internet hyping it up because they were advertised as a happy family

[@angelahaas4011]

he literally tried to sleep with Montana Danna look it up, its not just the Cam girl shit

[@Mahaney82]

So he cheated... alcohol is no excuse either.

[@ave3468]

Anything you do under the influence shows what kind of person YOU are. And if you decide to do it that’s ON YOU. You’re disgusting and should never be with a person who genuinely loves you.

[@chloemarie7069]

This is what happens when you’re in a cult.

[@novaparadoxx9043]

You know people can judge him and crucify him and by no means does he not deserve to be held accountable for his mistakes but everyone makes mistakes. How many of many of your fathers or mothers cheated on the other parent? How many of your fathers abused your mom physically or emotionally? How many of y'all don't even know your father because he left and went about his own life? At least he never gave up on his kids. It's wrong what he did but coming from someone who's experienced my Dad doing the same thing to my Mom, I don't love my Dad any less than I did before and I've learnt over the years to forgive him. My Dad is a human and he is allowed to make mistakes. As long as we learn from our mistakes and forgive ourselves so we can move forward, then there is always room for a shot at redemption.

[@AlexMedeiros-yp1yn]

you know i actually kind of agree w you. is it wrong to be a cheater? 100%. is it wrong to be an abuser? also 100%. and i went through something similar to you my mom cheated on my dad for like 9 years straight. i’m almost 20 now and i’ve mostly forgiven my mom for what she’s done and she has done everything in her power to make up for everything which i am eternally grateful for

[@Jose-rq1ig]

Should’ve stayed loyal to your wife like a man of morals.

[@Josey168]

He still has that “I must be in the spot light” and “me, me, me” mentality. I feel more for his wife. He’s just upset he got caught and is now trying to normalize it

[@ericfarkas08]

She is AMAZING for forgiving him.

[@lillylove261]

You spelled dumb wrong.

[@ericfarkas08]

​@@lillylove261Thats your opinion. I disagree with the idea of "cancelling" people. Cheating is a serious transgression, for sure. But that's a very dangerous & pointless practice. Not much is gained from it and it flies in the face of principle of forgiveness. I certainly doubt she forgets what he did, but that forgive him with the knowledge that he's hurt himself and wounded their marriage? That's pretty admirable, in my opinion.

[@kmckenney1311]

Also a former employee of his who has her own channel montanadana said he hit on her

[@laurenrizzuto878]

I was going to post this too.

[@KourtneyCasey]

this is the podcast ive been waiting for. hated him for this, his wife deserved none of it

[@highoffmaar]

i believe he is genuinely sorry. regardless, nothing is reason to be putting him down. people with no kids and no family don't understand

[@erics2091]

This happened in 2017. Why are people still bringing this up? I think they posted a picture on their Instagram years ago of them both naked but covered (Shay and his wife) you saw her bones, she was so unhealthily skinny and Shay who previously lost a ton of weight and somewhat muscular back to his larger self. She didn’t eat or threw up (she always wears baggy clothes to cover this). He went back to drinking and unhealthy habits. The caption was something like both ends of the extreme or something. They were both unhappy. Probably for awhile. Their KZbin channel most likely kept them going. I don’t really know their faith but I think it’s pretty faithful in its belief in marriage. No divorce. So they made it work however they did. It’s their business. Again, news in 2017. I saw this pop up and thought something happened again. No just the same text to the cam girl years ago.

[@christinaallene123]

Hole up, what are you taking about? Shaycarl and his wife posted a nude photo?

[@prezem5956]

It was in LA basically sadom and gommorah imagin living in a place where cheaters, adulterers, and sinners are Exalted! I know that those things can influence people without knowing it. Check your surroundings. Make sure your on solid ground.

[@pa.b2272]

You young ignorant people need to realise we’re all human and mistakes are apart of life! There’s winning & learning, they only way you lose is if you haven’t learnt anything. As someone that’s been the betrayed and the betrayer before trust me when I say everything will be ok. Accountability, honesty, trust & respect are your best friends. Don’t let the mistakes you’ve made dictate who you are, learn from them and keep moving forward.

[@MrOrangeOctopus]

Of course someone who cheats would write this garbage of an opinion

[@chill0141414]

Ppl are such hypocrites, its laughable. The man was texting a women while drunk, and ppl acting like its the end of the world. lmao Hypocrites.

[@winterblanco7328]

He had 5 children and a wife. Stop normalizing his actions💀

[@frosty129]

@@winterblanco7328so having children makes texting women illegal or what? You people are stupid.

[@Belibra14]

if it was his wife who had done it would you feel the same way?

[@petastafford908]

​@@winterblanco7328nobody is justifying his actions but what did you want Collette to do? Leave him the second he fucks up one time? Defeats the purpose of your marriage/vows doesn't it if you leave them as soon as they fuck up?

[@petastafford908]

​@@winterblanco7328Like whats the point of marriage if you're not gonna be by their side through the "up and DOWNS"?

[@luvlost03]

He will cheat again because she stayed now he know he can get away with it again. Women don't be weak and just stay with a cheating man.

[@hus390]

He didn’t cheated at all. Texting under influence is not cheating. It’s not like he had sex with her

[@deadbeats4417]

@@hus390 emotional infidelity exists

[@michaelrichards669]

coming from a tag: luvlost03 😲😲

[@frosty129]

@@hus390exactly, texting is not cheating

[@Belibra14]

​@@hus390 so you feel his actions were acceptable? If his wife was the one texting would you feel the same way about the story?

[@HaileyLove11]

Once a cheater always a cheater ! Also i feel she lost love for him after that. Even if she won’t say it she did and she lost respect and trust for him too.

[@richardhausig9493]

You are what you do. As you'll find out someday when you stop lying to yourself.

[@RunningSD]

I’m out of the loop. What did he do?

[@sheri-ls9lp]

my name is shay lol

[@QuirkyHipster]

I love her. But I think she is CRAZY for staying with him. He f*cked up MASSIVELY.

[@lindasnyder2976]

Has she woken up and left him yet?

[@mascottie]

What happened? They didn’t say

[@hollamonE]

HE. IS. SO. GROSSSSS!!!!!

[@frosty129]

point that finger at yourself

[@hollamonE]

@@frosty129 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jeneggum6956]

It is unfortunate Shay is only sorry because he got caught. #mormonvalueshaha

[@willw6196]

....🤢🤮.... who cares about your emotions?.. And they have sympathy for him?!....

[@alohajrp]

Shay will always be a father figure to me growing up watching him and the family made me feel like they were more then just ordinary KZbinrs. Mistakes happen that’s life we all make mistakes but it’s what we take from them is what makes you better. I

[@celinapalfrey6001]

The kids ……

[@nikkibrickner5574]

He still needs help

[@jsan5878]

Way to go to bring up the past when this happened years ago just for views..they’ve gone through enough in their relationship and it's not our business anymore

[@Belibra14]

anymore...? It never was....

[@heyitsreyes]

😂

[@jeffryyy23]

This guy is rich from stealing money from other content creators GTFO nobody cares

[@hus390]

Texting under influence is not a big deal!! He shouldn’t have went off of the channel behalf that!! 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@K777angel]

Never mormon but do empathize with this family.

[@hitmanb33b3]

what shay did wasnt even that bad lmfao

[@Trintrinxo]

What happened?

[@idothings6685]

He SA a child

[@Sojogososlow]

Wtf lol he didn’t SA a child why would you even say that… he was dming a cam girl on twitter or something

[@luvlost03]

He cheated on his wife

[@idothings6685]

@@luvlost03 with a child

[@jadenjones9654]

@@idothings6685 stfu it wasn't a child

[@anahitkhachatryan1648]

Vomiiit

[@PepperstoneGB]

*fatty mcpatty shay gay*