The PERFECT Attribute Column | FM24 Experiment

[@samhorstcraft7913]

Couple of ideas after watching another excellent video! 1. Perfect column but starting with around 170 CA+PA and having the other attributes randomised so they have perfect physical/mental/technical for longer. 2. Can you win the league with 11 perfect players? But only having those 11 players, no reserves or youth. Just the greyed out players to fill out the squad

[@jayhuahua]

Interesting ideas. I'll log them and add some tweaks because the answer to your 2nd one is unequivocally yes 🤣

[@Reorganiser]

Interesting how much influence the physicals have on the CA. Physical Phil looked, while already being at 190, like a Championship players outside his physicals

[@jayhuahua]

Indeed, yet he still putbin player of the year performances... are physicals the most important?

[@iceisnice6121]

​​@@jayhuahuaIt's probably because he is like a Adama Traorè, but stronger, faster and more tireless

[@Rene17gs]

This series showed how important is playing time, I remember the first time mental mark became an amazing player and now he left so far behind just because his lack of matches played

[@jayhuahua]

Playing time is crucial... you're right. Last time Mark was the man

[@richardmcinnes1049]

Thanks Another quality video, great to watch in some yr videos how much of a difference certain abilities on players make, learnt a fair few that wouldn't have had clue about without seeing your videos, some of the differences been massive suprise in difference they make so nice 1 for time/effort u put in to making quality of your content big respect keep it up

[@jayhuahua]

Great to hear that you have learnt a lot from the videos. Informative is one of the angles I aim for in some. Thanks for watching and hope to see u back soon 🫡

[@lyylski]

One experience I've been curious to see but never seen anyone do is comparing perfect players for each role in one position. So for strikers for example you would have a guy who has 20 in everything a poacher is good at, 20 in everything a F9 is good at, 20 in everything a PF(d) is good at and so on. Would the attacking complete forward be the best player in the world or would a poacher's less is more approach be better for the career?

[@jayhuahua]

An interesting idea... 🤔 i like it. Will think on how best to set things up for it

[@DaniMiste]

It's so funny how you keep saying u can't view the most recent season for Mark, but the season hasn't even started, for e.g you're in June 2037 and you're saying that you don't have the stats for the 2037/38 season :)

[@jayhuahua]

No I'm sure there was a glitch, like he went on loan to forest n it looked like he didn't play, then the following season the stats appeared... i think 🤔 now I'm second guessing myself

[@osianjones7889]

Because u were in July season hadn't started yet 😂😂 ​@@jayhuahua

[@jayhuahua]

Can we all blame either my sleep deprivation, or just being an idiot? I'll accept either 🙃

[@DaniMiste]

@@jayhuahua it wasn't tho, he just moved on loan in that summer u were checking the stats so that's why you got confused, u can check on the video again

[@jayhuahua]

I'll take your word for it. Seems to be the overwhelming consensus 🤣

[@Badri_YNWA]

Quality one mate. Technical Tommy is probably one of the most successful players of this channel. Insane trophies cabinet and goals. Waiting for the next one 💪

[@jayhuahua]

He certainly could be up there for a sole experiment we all know the most succesful person on the channel is Ralph 🤣

[@Badri_YNWA]

@@jayhuahua there's good, there's great and then there's Ralph 😂❤️

[@jayhuahua]

🤣🤣🤣 I wonder what he'd think if he heard about some random guy on YT who seemed to obsess over his virtual career

[@Drummermean2]

Ay, was a great video last time! Looking forward to this one.

[@jayhuahua]

Hope it doesn't disappoint

[@Drummermean2]

It was great, thanks!@@jayhuahua Typical PSG ruining our wonderkids.

[@jayhuahua]

Great to hear 👍 yup, PSG always spoiling things

[@NoryLevi]

i think the position kinda hurt mental mark, dm is really hard to get a good rating so he wouldnt progress much from match play compares to attackers

[@jayhuahua]

Possibly, but thats what the best position was for his CA, and it was the position that thrived last time so I expected more

[@randomname9949]

Next time we complain about fullbacks not having enough crossing, remember that Phisical Phil grew from 1 to 19

[@jayhuahua]

🤣🤣🤣 great point

[@Ross_McIntyre]

Jude Bellingham a fitness coach, while only having 6 fitness coaching is peak FM

[@jayhuahua]

Very FM 🤣

[@iceisnice6121]

I think that Physical Phil only did the best out of everyone of them is because he had a big jumping reach, pace, acceleration and strenght, the best physical stats out of the whole part

[@jayhuahua]

Yeah the physical attributes seem to be the best

[@e_eyster]

Could be interesting to do it with Staff too... One with all 20 Coaching, one with all 20 GK Coaching, one with all 20 Mental, one wtih all 20 Judging Ability. Release them all into the world (or even to make sure they get picked up put them all on some League 1 team) and see how they get on.

[@jayhuahua]

Yeah. Staff is something I want to do but it is tricky. More so than players

[@WannesDeBacker]

Wonder what happened to Ralph in this save

[@jayhuahua]

Always keep you wanting more 😉

[@SuperMixxx]

technical tommy also was top scorer in championship that 1 season at burnley

[@jayhuahua]

A glittering career indeed. I missed that detail, great spot 👍

[@stephendenis3855]

physical phil would be a joy to watch in the match engine i bet

[@jayhuahua]

🤣🤣 shanking all his shots and passes

[@dannyjesden1335]

What could be interesting is if you could make an experiment with a young Striker (maybe 150Ca/200PA) But make all his attributes, that affects his training/Mentality, hidden attributes extremly bad and let him play for a nonleague club and give him 1 popularity while on the other hand make his "BRother" who has just (Maybe very low like 40,50CA/ 200Pa) but make his mental,training,hidden attribtes that are good for developement very good but let him play for a very good club. Therefore it could be interesting which player has the better carrer. The talented one with no will to train, and not really known or the one with low CA but will to become the greatest but with no chance for a spot in the first team

[@jayhuahua]

Interesting idea 💡 🤔 i like it

[@cramyt]

i had a perfect column-esque newgen in the danish league, had like 2 attributes over 13 in the technical and mental and all over 17 in physicals at cdm. really strange player

[@jayhuahua]

Cdm with those attributes? That is strange

[@charliemcallister6293]

Love this experiment! great video!

[@jayhuahua]

👍 thanks

[@destroyerbros3212]

I'd love to see three teams of the three perfect columns

[@jayhuahua]

Was something we did last year and it was great fun. I dare say we will sneak it in again this year 👍

[@destroyerbros3212]

@@jayhuahua ye I loved it last year. I just love seeing weird teams ig 🤣

[@AltiKisi]

Mental Mark could be a great manager I would watch him

[@jayhuahua]

Based on attributes?

[@AltiKisi]

@@jayhuahua no just he's so cIever

[@hessen5498]

I think Matthias Dahm Got a twin Brother called Thomas Tuchel

[@jayhuahua]

They do look alike

[@timmoore8623]

Did you give the transfer embargo idea a go? Did it pan out at all or did it just fall flat?

[@jayhuahua]

Remind me... was it a worldwide embargo, or something like that? I did something and the sim was underwhelming. I need to add some more tweaks and variables i think

[@timmoore8623]

@@jayhuahua more like a self imposed 5year embargo for different vids, ie : Embargoed Chelsea, Embargoed Man Utd, as individual videos. Allows you to see what would happen if they were to stop making shocking transfer overspends and depended more on their strong youth academies. A few channels have done something similar and it’s interesting to see how letting all the old overpaid players affects the teams and finances. Don’t let the AI do it tho 🤣 They just resign players on even more money to avoid losing them on a free haha. Also seen Llujo give Barcelona £1 billion in debt which forces the same thing basically

[@jayhuahua]

Oh yes I remember now. Kinda like a transferless rebuild situation. I'm struggling with actual playtime this FM. Still got my Leeds save on the back burner 🤣

[@kilo4387]

Me watching this pretending I’m still not gonna make an all 20 wonderkid

[@jayhuahua]

Remember to freeze attributes otherwise they will drop to 14s and 16s

[@Burchxll]

Great video as always !!

[@jayhuahua]

🫡 thanks

[@catl9282]

best part are the management changes lmao

[@jayhuahua]

It is best when there is a truly randlm name at a massive club

[@catl9282]

@@jayhuahua ye, idk in what experiment it was but my favourite was Jose staying at man city for like 12 years

[@jayhuahua]

Yeah 🤣 or Tony Mowbray winning the world cup with England was a personal fave, then anything with Ralph of course

[@catl9282]

@@jayhuahua the day we don't check for Ralph I'm disliking and unsubscribing

[@jayhuahua]

Haha i better make sure i check more often

[@cccalmaaa]

I think the reason why the stats weren't shown for the most recent season was because you hadn't simulated through the season yet.

[@jayhuahua]

I was so.sure there was a glitch but it appears not 🤣

[@destroyerbros3212]

Mark took a 600k a week drop when he went to spurs. Sounds like what Henderson is about to do

[@jayhuahua]

1 season in Saudi is plenty though. He was probably reasonably compensated throughout his career

[@destroyerbros3212]

@@jayhuahua ye TBF who wants to play with only 800 people watching when you are in one of the better leagues in the world and still being good enough for the best league in the world. Must be pretty boring

[@Draddar]

Henderson eyeing that Bayern move 😂

[@stevenwinnie6501]

Another (potentially) impossible/unworkable experiment idea. Take the prize money/tv revenue from English football and swap it with that from Scottish leagues and vice versa. Sim long term and see if Scotland can overhaul England in things like Euro coefficient and international comps. Settles an old debate around money in England vs Scotland and might drive Scottish subscribers who I haven’t seen represented in vids in a while (on yours or others channels).

[@jayhuahua]

A nice idea, but yeah sadly with my editor knowledge I wouldn't even know where to start

[@notnatty781]

How many attribute points does a new position take away ? Edit fkn love these experiments

[@jayhuahua]

It's a grey area. So a new position takes up no attribute points, however each position has different weights attributed to each attribute, like a CB's CA won't change if you change their finishing from 5 to 10, but a CF it will, so training a new position will add the attribute weightings for the new position as well, so a new position has an illusion of taking up CA points, but there is literally no exact figure

[@gpmurtle]

No Ralph watch?! Or am I an idiot and missed it??

[@jayhuahua]

No ralph watch here... sadly he isn't england manager often anymore so Ralph watch is losing some steam and sometimes feels a bit forced

[@blobfishking941]

Bath lost 2:0 away at Yeovil. We drop to 6th :(

[@jayhuahua]

Automatic promotion looking less likely by the week

[@blobfishking941]

@@jayhuahua never looking likely anyway honestly Yeovil are not a 6th tier side

[@Ogunfiend781]

If a player is 20 for all attributes what is his PA ?

[@jayhuahua]

20 for all attributes exceeds the max 200 CA, so u need to freeze the attributes so they don't revert down to a figure that calculates to 200/200

[@iceisnice6121]

Will we have the perfect collumn with 5 and 10 stats?

[@jayhuahua]

Not with 10 as it's too high, but i may do 3 or 5's again, or I may do some other variation

[@tommy7977]

give me an all pace / accerlation team sim

[@jayhuahua]

Is that pace vs acceleration? Both max vs min?

[@tommy7977]

just the results of a 20/20 pace acceleration team with say, 8-10 ratings on the others stats. Keep up the solid content! @@jayhuahua

[@MihailBFC]

that sweet 2-1win against blackburn 😂

[@jayhuahua]

👍

[@JordanCCFC17]

SWANSEA?! 🤢🤢🤢

[@jayhuahua]

Lol, is the sick face because they retrained Tommy?

[@ryanallen3116]

Physical phil won 3 golden balls lol

[@jayhuahua]

This was a while ago... did i miss this or something

[@mimistak]

Do you have some problem with the best league of the world that is SAUDI ARABIA ???? Do you want some black costumes visit you 🤬🤬?

[@jayhuahua]

Problem? No problem with the Saudi League. Why do you ask?