Пікірлер
@kai45654
@kai45654 16 минут бұрын
That first season was so funny
@GNAL1610
@GNAL1610 Сағат бұрын
It makes sense though (for Charlton) - if you have a team of players that can’t run at all then of course they’re gonna get beat. Played football with plenty of fat guys who had a great touch and a ping on them but they couldn’t run. This team might be decent at 5 a side but of course will get exposed playing against professional athletes on an 11 a side pitch, doesnt matter how goos their technique and concentration is
@GeoFootballManager
@GeoFootballManager Сағат бұрын
I don't know how many times I've heard u talk about not seeing the results 😂 now I'm starting to think they are faked! Nah messing, another great video as always
@FraseThatPlays
@FraseThatPlays 2 сағат бұрын
It was interesting that Charlton 'found their level' and didn't go down from the National League South. Makes me think if a "5, 10 and 15" experiment (maybe Wigan, Bolton and Huddersfield in League One?) would show where those attributes settle.
@tmtltn
@tmtltn 2 сағат бұрын
But why jumping reach ? Pace and acceleration okay. I don't get it.
@FraseThatPlays
@FraseThatPlays 2 сағат бұрын
It impacts set pieces and the meta is the fact bigger players with less technicals are overpowered.
@FlandPark
@FlandPark 2 сағат бұрын
Yeah I think "insane" is just about right.
@acleedsunited
@acleedsunited 2 сағат бұрын
You've shown how FM gives too much importance to pace, acceleration. Don't know how much jumping reach is overpowered or whether it's just pace and acceleration. I do enjoy experiments with unexpected results.
@AddictedGamerFIFA
@AddictedGamerFIFA Сағат бұрын
Under very strict conditions with almost no variables the FM-Arena testing concluded after 2880 simulated matches with each change jumping reach is the 3rd most important attribute behind pace and acceleration. The order is as follows; pace, acceleration, jumping reach, anticipation, balance, agility, concentration, finishing, work rate, dribbling, stamina, strength, passing, consistency (hidden attribute), determination, vision, long shots, marking, decisions, first touch, off the ball, tacking, team work. Attributes that made no difference compared to baseline; composure, technique, positioning All attributes were dropped by 4 points compared to baseline. Base line win percentage is 46% in 2880 matches, dropping pace by 4 points drops the win percent to 24, acceleration drops it to 29 and jumping reach drops it to 38. All other attributes only drop it within 6% or less of baseline. So it's clear pace and acceleration are the "king" attributes, followed by jumping reach then followed by the rest to varying degrees.
@needfoolthings
@needfoolthings 3 сағат бұрын
Those Attributes are NOT AT ALL shown to be meta or not by what you did ror this video. 1 in pace and 1 acceleration simply means you cannot run. The real comparison would be Charlton having 15 in these attributes.
@carlstewart934
@carlstewart934 3 сағат бұрын
What happens to these clubs after all the players all leave for Saudi Arabia. I’d be intrigued to see the results for few seasons after they’ve all gone
@acleedsunited
@acleedsunited 3 сағат бұрын
Could you do a battle of perfect player positions? Squad 1: Bog standard 100 CA players but perfect strikers (only 1 or 2 will play). Squad 2: Same but with a perfect midfield (probably 4 play) Squad 3: Same but with perfect defence (with/or without perfect GK) Squad 4: Entire squad of 200CA but NOT perfect players. Transfer bans and fixed attributes as usual. Up to you, of course. It's your channel! 😂 Hope you like the idea, I'd like to see it.
@VurtAddicted
@VurtAddicted 3 сағат бұрын
‐ in the match engine none of those attributes are really more important than others in a vacuum. It really depends on roles - in my current save I am in year 2052 and I am pretty confident I haven't met a single player with a 20 in more than one attribute
@selimcardak7799
@selimcardak7799 3 сағат бұрын
Let’s fucking go 🥳
@adzter96
@adzter96 4 сағат бұрын
If you're 1 pace and acceleration I guess you can't get to the ball, you can't get to players to tackle them etc so the other stats don't matter
@VurtAddicted
@VurtAddicted 3 сағат бұрын
Players with 1 pace/acc do not exist in the game, so why is that relevant at all?
@thomas-simpson
@thomas-simpson 4 сағат бұрын
This is ridiculous Charlton finishing bottom with 3 points shows just how important meta attributes really are
@mvsr990
@mvsr990 4 сағат бұрын
If you put together a club of players with the athleticism of a normal person they'd get absolutely demolished 24/7 no matter how good they were in other ways.
@needfoolthings
@needfoolthings 3 сағат бұрын
You clearly do not understand what meta means and what it means to have 1 pace and acceleration.
@CurlyFry63
@CurlyFry63 4 сағат бұрын
My local team Weymouth mentioned 🥳🥳🥳
@trakkino
@trakkino 5 сағат бұрын
how about instead 20vs1, try more "normal" players like 20vs10? No team in the world have snails as defenders
@mvsr990
@mvsr990 4 сағат бұрын
Four clubs - 20s, 15s, 10s, 5s. In a way the meta attributes aren't a shock - physical ability matters an awful lot IRL. How imbalanced, though, is it once you get into reasonable physical attributes. Does a team with 20s in the meta attributes demolish a team with 15s in the meta attributes but better attributes elsewhere? Both would definitely be better than 10s but would the Meta 10s still be a functional club?
@handemhan
@handemhan Сағат бұрын
Exactly. We shouldn't be surprised that a squad of players who literally can't run would do so poorly. I reckon re-do the experiment with a team of 10, a team of 15, and a team of 20 for those attributes
@GNAL1610
@GNAL1610 Сағат бұрын
@@mvsr990100%. Also, you could have a player who was insanely technically gifted but slow and he could perform, but he’d need elite athletes around him to do the running. Same as when teams have a lazy attacking player (like Kane, Neymar as he got older) who do no pressing or defensive work but the rest compensate for him. A team full of people that can’t run will obviously get exposed on an 11 a side pitch
@sarahparkinson3021
@sarahparkinson3021 Сағат бұрын
@@mvsr990 it’s all been done haha, meta attr win every time. Not even close
@Darkstaronone
@Darkstaronone 5 сағат бұрын
meta stuff doesnt matter, the only thing that matters is luck. for example i made a perfect striker and it scored less than a 150 ca striker
@thomas-simpson
@thomas-simpson 4 сағат бұрын
Even with luck your not gettig. Relegated with 3 and 6 points without meta attributes they matter and a lot
@Darkstaronone
@Darkstaronone 4 сағат бұрын
@thomas-simpson I mean with normal attributes
@FraseThatPlays
@FraseThatPlays 2 сағат бұрын
Is that luck? It could be bad tactics, worse team-mates, different roles or, if they are in the same team, your perfect striker either isn't tall enough or quick enough.
@christianulrich8234
@christianulrich8234 5 сағат бұрын
haven't watched the video yet but personally i feel like that either jumping reach is really important, or the combination of balance and agility
@haspoon
@haspoon 5 сағат бұрын
This video is MASSIVE
@nickd8380
@nickd8380 9 сағат бұрын
The Dutch second league system is the worst in the world. U can win the first 9 games and win the first period and lose every game and still receive a playoffs spot. U can promote even if u end 20th
@bizon_2024
@bizon_2024 9 сағат бұрын
Why this wonderkid looks like Charles Leclerc?
@pferreiro95
@pferreiro95 Күн бұрын
Ah yes the hall of fame... It is not relative to the saves, so it carries over from one save to the other. The only way I know to reset is is to delete the hall_of_fame.dat file inside the public documents in your computer
@kaygeeandzizi9337
@kaygeeandzizi9337 Күн бұрын
Rafael. What a bargain.
@adamregan4626
@adamregan4626 Күн бұрын
Love the experiments to learn more about this game. It would be nice to have a control team for reference, like a team with all 10 and a team with all 1s
@jhemsall
@jhemsall Күн бұрын
"The Chaaampions" 🎤🎶😂😂
@jvtm7581
@jvtm7581 Күн бұрын
Great episode! Volmaakt means perfect in dutch. So it is THE perfect player ;)
@jeppeballe7181
@jeppeballe7181 2 күн бұрын
I would've have went for agility and balance way earlier. Absolute key for a striker 😂
@billgoldberg1377
@billgoldberg1377 2 күн бұрын
Oh man I hate you haha.. you took him/came from my home town club!
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 2 күн бұрын
What is your hometown club? He didn't move clubs until he was very old lol. Please don't spear or jackhammer me
@billgoldberg1377
@billgoldberg1377 2 күн бұрын
@@jayhuahua Fc Groningen (check his overview show it as last club) Thankfully also a team that ended up doing well in the run 🥳 so for that I can withhold the spear and jackhammer. ^_^.. but there is a timer on the withhold.. better make that Fc Groningen video you wanted soon haha
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua Күн бұрын
@billgoldberg1377 haha so i don't know why it had Groningen as last club, because I copied the previous vid player profile from Scotland, so Groningen should be nowhere near. Fear not though, Groningen have the wonderkid wheel, currently in the edit and coming soon
@TiAgo-FM
@TiAgo-FM 2 күн бұрын
Ajax really struggling
@maxwilliams1060
@maxwilliams1060 2 күн бұрын
Doesn't work on Mac, I can't seem to find the XML you reference that has the new gen faces on it, to replace. I run a search for the file and it's nowhere to be seen, I try the config.xml file that FM XML makes and the new gen faces are not in there to replace... So where does the game save the config.xml file that deals with the new faces the games makes, so I can change it?
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 2 күн бұрын
When you make the xml file it saves it in the location where all the faces are. You put that address in the bat on the fmXML program as shown. Unfortunately I don't have a mac so i do not know if it works or what alternative steps are needed to take. Do you have a facepack downloaded from somewhere or badge pack, or kits etc? I am sure they have some MAC related assistance on there. Maybe merge their tutorial with this one and fingers crossed you can find your way
@FraseThatPlays
@FraseThatPlays 2 күн бұрын
Slot still at Liverpool in 2038, unless he left and came back! Also, may need a Dutch football expert here, but my memory banks seem to remember Hedwiges Maduro as a real player (DM for Ajax)? I think he was there a few years after the Champions League winning team that had Davids, Seedorf, the De Boer twins etc.
@jeanfrancopinto2590
@jeanfrancopinto2590 2 күн бұрын
u could add a separate wheel with +values to increase the youth rating of san marino year by year. better rotation players coming through as progresses
@matthewcross8555
@matthewcross8555 2 күн бұрын
That transfer policy was amazing. Do Chairman have hidden personalities and does that affect how good the transfer policy is?
@FraseThatPlays
@FraseThatPlays 2 күн бұрын
Future experiment to move FC Eindhoven's board and staff to a team in another league and country to see how they do?
@DimiPetrevski
@DimiPetrevski 2 күн бұрын
Shouldve done this at SC Cambuur 🟡🔵
@superfrank2684
@superfrank2684 2 күн бұрын
The most boring club in the world! (According to HITC sevens)
@Shamrock-Rover
@Shamrock-Rover 2 күн бұрын
You wil know haha! Kraaijeveld is more pronounced as "Cry-an-veld"
@nicolasarteagaangarita5671
@nicolasarteagaangarita5671 3 күн бұрын
Do it at bursaspor in turkey! They are a fallen giant
@stuartaberdeen
@stuartaberdeen 3 күн бұрын
the player of the year in 2011-12 in the keuken kampioen divisie has kicked on well in his career since then!
@mrlevant947
@mrlevant947 Сағат бұрын
Who is it?
@TheBunglefish
@TheBunglefish 3 күн бұрын
in before 2 minutes is up..... how long before our "perfect" player gets retrained as a centre back?
@JKeoghs
@JKeoghs 3 күн бұрын
Done a save with fc eindhoven recently, apparently they're the "most boring club in football" because they've gone about 50 years without a promotion or relegation, and I thought that title suits me perfectly 🤣 very fun team to use tbf
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
Well they're the stars of the show now. The best transfers I've ever seen. Arguably better than if I gave them a wonderkid wheel treatment haha
@andresjonsson625
@andresjonsson625 3 күн бұрын
This was a great f***ing episode. Love your vids my dude :)
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
Appreciate it 👍 glad u enjoy. I love making these ones and they always seem to go down quite well. Need to venture into other nations as well
@miladsarbaz4287
@miladsarbaz4287 3 күн бұрын
Amazing transfers
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
I don't think I've ever seen better
@FlandPark
@FlandPark 3 күн бұрын
Nice that you're speechless but in a positive way 😉
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
🤣🤣🤣 absolutely. This is what the AI should do more, I've never seen transfrrs so good and consistently good for years and years.
@kaygeeandzizi9337
@kaygeeandzizi9337 Күн бұрын
Rafael. What a bargain.
@Darkstaronone
@Darkstaronone 3 күн бұрын
Why didnt you give him a good national team like france
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
Lol, we've done the French version of this video
@Darkstaronone
@Darkstaronone 3 күн бұрын
@jayhuahua nah I meant make him french so that he doesn't have to lose to France in every major tournament
@lenakastruphuban935
@lenakastruphuban935 3 күн бұрын
omg jay this one soooo good!! 😍watching luuk stuck in the dutch league was sooo fascinating! i love it when you think you've nailed the foreign name pronunciations, it has me cracking up!! 😂 you’re honestly the best, i’m obsessed with your FM content!! 🥰⚽💖
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 3 күн бұрын
I take it my pronunciations are not quite spot on then? Glad you're enjoying the content. Plenty of it to binge 🤣
@baseupp12
@baseupp12 3 күн бұрын
Have you done a video on which position is the most impactful for a perfect player because I feel like a perfect Midfielder would contribute more to club success then a Perfect Striker. While a Perfect Striker would have more individual awards
@haspoon
@haspoon 3 күн бұрын
Can we see your dogs on camera? The huahua behind the jay
@jayhuahua
@jayhuahua 2 күн бұрын
Haha that's certainly a request I can manage, however it may be largely underwhelming, but happy to oblige lol
@haspoon
@haspoon 2 күн бұрын
@@jayhuahua i eagerly await the doggos
@willster947
@willster947 3 күн бұрын
His consistency, important matches and size/weight killed him.
@Big.Carlos02
@Big.Carlos02 3 күн бұрын
Surely you knew what you was doing making Crawley players go to their rivals in Brighton 😂
@mustafachughtai8874
@mustafachughtai8874 3 күн бұрын
congrats on player 3