Never have i saw such perfect typing which was already matching my own of these characters for about 95% Keep doing more of this style of analysis for more popular series but also ones you ENJOY because I'm all for it !
@user-rg1vo1ho9pАй бұрын
I'd love to see you cover the characters from the animated series "Arcane", especially now that season 2 has been fully released
@saimasadianur40732 ай бұрын
I watched GoT only because you said that you would make a video on it. Finally, it’s here😌
@xripkan66232 ай бұрын
I strongly agree that Arya is an ISFP and not an ISTP as many people think. She has a highly developed inner/personal sense of justice based on which she moves during the entire series. And in addition, as you mentioned, the transformative ability and the fact that she doesn't seem particularly emotional, but more cold/'logical' in everyday life (FiNi instead of FiSi)
@KitsuneRonin2 ай бұрын
Yes! The unicorn/clown social butterfly stereotype of ENFP is really annoying. I like Melisandre for this typing, because while ENFP tends to express a lot of energy out into the world - it is most often in the form of mechanical improvisation and creative impetus, rather than towards social networking. And, at least in my case, I find socializing with people outside my core "Fi-circle" to be energetically taxing. And I love Osha too! Love the suggestions for The Hobbit & Walking dead. Maybe also some Anime(s) down the line - Dragon Ball/Z, One Piece, Bleach etc. regardless, I know I am going to enjoy the future content of CPT!
@MysticWizardMan2 ай бұрын
On board here with the One Piece idea as I myself am a huge fan of the series! Also, hi from an ENFP! Absolutely get you on the Fi circle thing, getting to know new people can be quite stressful (tho also fairly satisfying). All the creative energies are often directed towards a mechanical project (for me personally, I'm working a lot on a fictional world where I bring all my creativity together)
@Aurora-qn2dxАй бұрын
Dragon ball would be very interesting ..would like to see his take on Vegeta's personality.
@Sam_GowmanАй бұрын
Sir, your guitar playing is just ✨✨ Thankyou for your videos
@davidpoole75072 ай бұрын
Never clicked on a video so fast! Didn't expect so many characters. Great stuff!
@TheManWithTheFryingPan2 ай бұрын
Such a delightful video. I think you'd do big by doing a typing like this for Arcane, seeing as season 2 is right around the corner and I'd be incredibly interested in seeing a set of typings like these for that show
@courierquest53452 ай бұрын
Typing Brienne as an INTJ is actually a very spot on angle. She’s definitely possess Fi-aux pride and integrity, but way more inclined in becoming an ideal knight, than an ISTJ. This shown by scenes with Brienne and Sandor together. The latter, being a knight himself at one time, never took knights courtesy serious. Cheers!
@courierquest53452 ай бұрын
Also, both ENFP in the series commit self-sacrifice for the sake of other people 😅 Although, it is not a rare type of death in GoT universe.
@onimusha13Ай бұрын
@@courierquest5345 I think that one could interpret your comment as ISTJs being unable to take knight vows seriously or desiring an ideal which I'm sure you didn't mean. But what remains as true is that for ISTJs it would be a more linear, lived experience journey than far away archetypal visions of an INTJ
@courierquest5345Ай бұрын
@ You’re right, poor choice of words
@zellusciousАй бұрын
It makes all the sense in the world that Samwell Tarly is an INFP since he was very likely based off of George R. R. Martin himself. Somehow I still have to see Cersei Lannister as an ENTJ because I just don't see any Fe in her no matter how trapped she may be and oddly she is one of my favorite characters even though no one else seems to like her. Jorah Mormont seems more of a softer spoken, calculating and heart lead character which I see is more of an ISFJ, Si-Ti, where he shows that he keeps his cards close to his chest until such time he is ready to fully commit and then he is loyal to a fault where he often ignores his own needs. Melisandre as an ENFP is something I would not have considered but absolutely agree with you the more that I think about it. Still have to think about Ygritte because I rather saw her as an ISFP but I'm trying to see how ISTJ fits and then Osha too because I thought of her as more Se, ESFP, but I can be persuaded perhaps. I do appreciate that you point out how the Psychopaths and Narcissists are too flat to type. Good for you lol
@AnyaAnnika6720 күн бұрын
Hi there completely agree re Samwell & the similarities with Martin, good shout. I'm an ENFJ re Cersei & can vouch for the ENFJ typing. Remember in ENFJs FeSe is generally much more subtle than FeNe and in Cersei's case apart from her children she's generally using it as a means of manipulation which I know I have done. I think the scenes between Marjorie & Cersei perfectly elucidate this - Marjorie can play the wider Ne realm in which Cersei struggles as with that FiSi dip she can't in many ways be other than she is. I can also vouch for when being on the back foot coming off like more of a Te dom as Harry said. I think my FeSe is actually much more apparent in writing than in real time for example (as a dash of neurodivergence is coming into the mix). This is a character who's constantly on the back foot but her Ni authority & the TiNi scheming is very evident, in fact I think this divergence is the biggest give away of her primary type; I think how cunning ENFJs are is very much down played or missed in other type communities - I'm constantly future forecasting. I'm not a dark variants but I certainly given the trauma I've been through have aspects of her personality in my own, in a way she's a villain I emphasise with. Anyway, I always wondered why I related to her on some level. I do think Lena Headey who plays her could well be an ENFJ. Good shout as well re NPDs etc being too flat to type. I don't think it's the same for those with BPD as there is a true self in conflict with the false self & I think Cersei definitely has some BPD traits.
@khalifera2 ай бұрын
you can see an excellent example of Daario's NeFe mask juggling when he literally becomes a different person in season 4!!
@mustaineboots2 ай бұрын
Oh, I just know the spongebob video's coming, genuinely excited
@onimusha132 ай бұрын
A very shrewd typing of Jon Snow as ISTP. I have to say I'm amazed by how your ideas converge with vultology/cognitivetype by Juan Sandoval. It's the only other system to type Johnny Depp as an ISTP, and to acknowledge that being a Ti-dom does not mean being a walking calculator who ignores his Fi. And to notice that a pretty intense Fi-Si can still come from dominant Ti-Ni workings.
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
I have to say I'm very impressed by cognitive type/vultology as well. I was wandering about Gillian Anderson & he correctly typed her as an ESFJ
@raz7m8582 ай бұрын
I'd love to see more character analysis
@francisdemers912 ай бұрын
Nice video, loved the theme there !
@hadiza12 ай бұрын
Sitting! 😍😍😍 Adding to watch next list ❤
@mr.j85682 ай бұрын
I love this but as an ESTP in real life as they say, I have one particular disagreement. When I was first trying to type myself years ago, Jamie Lannister was one of the primary fictional characters I saw myself in. Every Type doesn't just begin and end with a set of cognitive functions, they also have a quite specific "story arc" if you will. It's one of the under-the-radar ways to type someone correctly. You figure out their life journey and that journey usually corresponds to a particular type. “The Navajo have that wonderful image of what they call the pollen path. The Navajo say, ‘Oh, beauty before me, beauty behind me, beauty to the right of me, beauty to the left of me, beauty above me, beauty below me, I’m on the pollen path.’’ - Joseph Campbell I struggled for some time trying to figure out my type and when I saw Jamie, not so much in the later seasons but certainly in the first 3 or 4 I recognized that individual journey or 'path' as more or less the one I was on. To my point, I take issue with how ESTPs are portrayed in fiction though, they're more often villains, often depicted as psychopaths to some degree more often than roguish heroes. Now I agree with your typing of Jamie and ENTP Tyrion, who's my favorite character BY FAR. He's the reason I watched the show. I mention Tyrion because there is a distinctive but fine line between ENTPs and ESTPs. ENTPs are like Hermes the divine trickster, God of thieves and so on. ESTPs are more like Odysseus, the trickster hero. One is more mercurial, one is more action oriented, both are COMPLEX though. Whether they be fictional psychopaths or real life monsters it's become de rigueur to type them as ESTPs. Almost literally every time I turn around. Which brings me to Ramsay Bolton. Even with a limited, two-dimensional development, I just don't see him as the very stereotypical ESTP psychopathic killer. I think he's too much of a sadist to be an ESTP, too into mind games. If Daenerys was the light side of Cersei, then I think Ramsay was the ENTP dark side of Tyrion. When I first watched this, I immediately thought of this scene where Sansa tries to tell Jon how she knows how Ramsay's mind works, how he likes to hurt people: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n3iwnHmbitCEr7c ESTPs are fully capable of what Sansa is saying if it suits them but they are usually so direct in everything that any deviation from their intended goal would be seen as a waste of time. Ramsay was cruel for the sake of cruelty. That's my only quibble, everything else I pretty much agree with.
@Multitudes_2 ай бұрын
“Every Type doesn't just begin and end with a set of cognitive functions, they also have a quite specific ‘story arc’ if you will. It's one of the under-the-radar ways to type someone correctly. You figure out their life journey and that journey usually corresponds to a particular type.” Ooh I agree with this! Granted, different people of the same type can have pretty different journeys and develop in different directions. Still, I think knowing a person’s journey, including where they started out and how & why they developed in the directions they did, is essential to understanding them and indeed often key to understanding their type, especially if they’ve developed in directions that don’t obviously align with their core type. Sometimes I have a hard time deciding whether to use a past or current version of myself when characterizing something about (my experience as) my type because they can be quite different in some ways - yet both feel equally relevant and important. In some ways, I was a ‘purer’ and more extreme embodiment of my type when younger. In other ways, the more developed and mature version that I am today feels like a better illustration. But really, it IS about the whole journey, including the things that change over time.
@mr.j85682 ай бұрын
@@Multitudes_ Yeah, I like how you put that. Everyone is on their individual journey so when you're trying to type yourself or someone else you have to allow for subtle or not subtle nuances. However, even people who live vastly different lives or are at different stages of their lives are still going to have fundamental commonalities on their particular journey their type corresponds to. I think it's best and this is completely subjective, to look at your childhood. Everyone makes certain choices and that will certainly influence their life. However, no matter what your later choices may be, your childhood up to I'll say, your early 20s, shapes who you are and we're less able to manipulate those events a/or circumstances. I've noticed in types that I've very familiar with that within their "story arc" there are even more very specific details that types may share. INFJs for instance may have a missing or mysterious parent or there's some kind of secret or deception in their family life that becomes apparent to them at some point in their childhood. This may cause them to go deeper within themselves in search of truth or identity. Each Type has their own 'thing' and if you examined the lives of a group of people with the same type I'm almost positive you would find some common thread that runs throughout that group regardless of individual background.
@captaindusk8097Ай бұрын
Was waiting for this type of content! Never watched GoT but you can get lots of content this type of analysis/ breakdown . Any future videos of other series/ movies on mind?
@MicrowavedBread2 ай бұрын
Interesting! Michael Pierce actually typed some Thrones characters on his old blog page, and a lot of them were less popular typings that you both had in common. ISTJ for Tywin, ENFP for Osha, ESTP for Littlefinger. Also though not as close, ISFJ for Ned and ISTJ for Davos. There are a few typings of yours that I'm not too sure of, but most I'd agree with, and others have me rethinking things. Thanks for the video.
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@MicrowavedBread So cool Michael had the same thoughts about Littlefinger!
@TheManWithTheFryingPan2 ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonality littlefinger as an estp was the most enlightening type of the video. Your explanation reminded me a lot of my dad, who is a clear estp. He is an expert at finding out how to game any system out there to his benefit. He'll sometimes explain it as him seeing the big picture and knows the "truth" (Ni) or how things really work (Se), but it's always in service of how he can get what he wants out of it (Se). It really was a perfect description of how littlefinger operates.
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
@@TheManWithTheFryingPanI see this in my son as well. He's only 6 so difficult to type but I'd probably put my mortgage on him being an ESTP.
@phoenixxsoulАй бұрын
8:15 Harry i hope that you can actually do a comparison between these similar, cognitively approximate types i.e INFP vs ISTP, INTP vs ISFP... Like Johnny Depp is typed by many people as INFP but he's not apparently :)
@aTaurusBabe2 ай бұрын
You’ve inspired me to start watching the show! I would love to see you do a breakdown of X-Men (First Class movie and onwards)
@phoenixxsoul2 ай бұрын
Omg I've been looking forward to more of these series! 🥳 Pleasee do The Hobbit at some point too~
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@phoenixxsoul Heh first I have to redo the LOTR typing into a single video.. changed my mind about a few characters
@phoenixxsoul2 ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonality Ohh really? I'm curious. Looking forward to both trilogies :D
@elzindurakovic60392 ай бұрын
Great video. I am curious why would Melisandre not be an INFJ as she seems to be more of Ni than Ne to me. She seems to be the most focused (on single goal) character of them all and she uses divergent Se-Fe to move everyone along. Also could you do typing of Battlestar Galactica (new version) characters.
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@elzindurakovic6039 I have a difficult time seeing her as Ti-Fe in any shape or form - she seems to have a more mystical, chaos-based sense of reality and those times she does explain her reasoning etc it's usually through some kind of relational appeal, be it to a god or a person. Detached enough to be a Thinking convergent but in my opinion too extemporaneous and indeed mechanistically fluid to be NiTi primary
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonalitynot kissing a** Harry but I agree with your typing of her. The only one I wasn't going to get on board with was when you tentatively said Varys was an ENTJ during a livestream when I'd already had him pegged as an INTP.
@parkerp95572 ай бұрын
The most awated video for me
@courierquest5345Ай бұрын
It’s interesting that ENTPs and ENFPs, both “slippery” types, can easily be switched with their RPG-classes: rogue and bard. ENFPs can be personified as an naturally agile person, seamlessly evading swirling blades, crawling in the shadows of a Te-world, while ENTPs easily charm various crowds of people with melodies they’ve mastered for years.
@johanneslyche83022 ай бұрын
An absolutely fantastic video! I do have one question, though. In one of your videos on the types of LOTR characters, you mentioned how you found it especially beneficial to type fictional characters, as they tend to showcase more extreme/stereotypical behaviour than us regular real-life people. I was taken slightly aback by the statement, because as I saw it, fictional characters would be rather prone to "bad", or in other words, unrealistic, writing, which could result in characters displaying cognition that isn't consistant with one specific type. I would argue that this might be part of why Cersei, for instance, is so difficult to type, as the humans behind the creation of these characters, can never be 100% consistant with how they portray their characters.
@Multitudes_2 ай бұрын
I think both of those things are true. It’s true that fictional characters often aren’t as realistic as, well, real people, and can have all sorts of traits written into them that wouldn’t necessarily coexist in a real person, or that might contradict themselves if the writing is inconsistent and sloppy. But it’s also true that fictional characters can often be more extreme and clear-cut embodiments of certain types or traits due to being less complex and often larger-than-life compared to real people. Another advantage of looking at fictional characters compared to, say, real-life famous people is that we get to see them in a larger variety of contexts, including very personal and private ones. (Also, I don’t think a character being difficult to type is automatically a sign of bad writing; sometimes it’s just complexity, which can make real people equally hard to type sometimes.) All in all, I think they can be a useful illustration of how types can manifest, especially when coming from media with relatively good character writing like LOTR and (at least most of) Game of Thrones. But it’s only a small piece of the puzzle, and the limiting factors of these ultimately being fictional creations should always be kept in mind. Every approach has its limitations; that’s why it’s good to have a variety.
@VipulSingh-00033Ай бұрын
Once you said that Ni types have low energy if so how come Breinne "The Knight of seven Kingdoms" is such a warrior and how come then INTJ become Warriors ?
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
Divergent SeTe I would imagine & perhaps her subtype of INTJ. INTJs can be extremely physically adept comparative to INFJs. Perhaps Brienne also has a very fluid axis which say MBTI wouldn't take into consideration.
@WeakkneezАй бұрын
I hope there is a second video that goes over some of the other characters like Loras Tyrell, Renly Baratheon, Missandei, Gendry, Shae, Yara Greyjoy, and Qyburn that come to mind.
@CognitivePersonalityАй бұрын
@@Weakkneez no second video but I provided a blog article in the description covering missed characters!
@SoulGoof72 ай бұрын
YES ITS BACK!!!! DO THE WALKING DEAD NEXT!!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
@peacewalker40582 ай бұрын
I was waiting for this for a long time... Well i was waiting for ASOIAF characters but close enough.
@SH-if8gd2 ай бұрын
Any thoughts on what type Benjen Stark would be? I know he was only in a few episodes,so there might not be enough to type him.I just thought he seemed like an interesting character. Thank you for the video.
@courierquest5345Ай бұрын
Hey Harry! How would you describe Ne-aux (“freedom seeking”) for both Ned, Sansa and Jorah? All of those characters (except for maybe Sansa in early seasons) exert a serious level of Ni-determination. I know you might argue ESFJ have FiNi dip, so why Ni is absent in their underlying stack? Cheers
@CognitivePersonalityАй бұрын
@@courierquest5345 love that! It's a good example of how cognitive traits don't apply to everyone and are more nodes for guessing underlying cognitive functions. Keep in mind though that freedom seeking is subordinate to the Si authority, so if foundations are not solid such as in the above cases you'll get almost none of that trait anyway But Sansa is an ambivert tbh so FiNi would be more conscious there
@courierquest5345Ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonality Got ya! May I assume that lens dominants have a slightly easier access to their Aux+ function? Kudos.
@blurryimage458518 күн бұрын
Thank you! Please, now Arcane.
@FeasibleImaginings2 ай бұрын
Hii there! Do you have enough info about G.R. Martin to have at least a good guess what his type could be? I remember one of the things that stood out from his books was his vividly descriptive writing, rarely of landscapes or the "vibe" in a space(which i suppose would be the realm of NT?), but of more particular settings(ST?). The imagery of venison slathered with honey and hanging on a spit still lingers in my head for example.
@TypeIRL2 ай бұрын
Either estj or esfj.
@FeasibleImaginings2 ай бұрын
@@TypeIRL why so?
@TypeIRL2 ай бұрын
The ability to hold such a singular, complex, constructed reality suggests Ne Aux. Focus on sensory detail suggests Se auth. Could be either with access, but the symphonic modulation of interlocking mechanics is more TN than TS, plus he said once that the reason the books took so long was because he couldn't get his characters to do what he wanted. Not typically a struggle for esfjs. @@FeasibleImaginings
@FeasibleImaginings2 ай бұрын
@@TypeIRLoh that's interesting! Thank you.
@onimusha132 ай бұрын
He's an INTJ
@jograves88592 ай бұрын
Would love to see your take on Dune, if you are a fan
@manaswinipradhan34112 ай бұрын
Can u do for harry potter characters also?
@haniyehsheibani2 ай бұрын
Super!
@noeljoseph4493Ай бұрын
Please make videos on how to parent different types of children
@kavinvendant84502 ай бұрын
Sir.... This is unrelated to the video..... but what type would Vincent van gogh be..... I am kinda curious...... Maybe infp or isfp??..... Just wanted to hear your thoughts.....
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@kavinvendant8450 ISFP/iFN wouldn't surprise me for him
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonalitysorry me again promise I ain't low key stalking Harry (in a traffic on my way to Cornwall lol). That certainly wouldn't surprise me as apparently he had BPD & bipolar as well. I think bipolar is less influential to type but there's no denying I see a lot of people with BPD who are ISFPs in clinical practice.
@AnyaAnnika672 ай бұрын
Hi Harry it's Emma B. Loving your typing of Cersei as a darker ENFJ albeit I'm not as 'dark' I'm glad you mentioned that ENFJs can be extremely cunning. I would argue that Cersei has BPD or at least some significant traits of the disorder which probably is why she gives off that Fi vibe. Can you please explain re Marg T why you think ESFJs are more chameleonic than ENFJs? I get that FiSi is 'present' when ENFJs synchronise with another person but I have to say I'm generally as an ENFJ a lot more calculated in my interactions with the vast majority of people, people really don't know me or my intentions well at all besides the close few I trust & hold dear. It's not that I'm being disingenuous but I more often feel like I'm playing a role that comes naturally to me, meanwhile internally it's a very different story - the clogs are always turning. Is something other than FiSi going on here? Would being a divergent subtype come into the equation?
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@AnyaAnnika67 Hey Emma! All Fe+ types are calculating and exacting, but FeSe+ seems to genuinely struggle performing in a manner opposite to how it feels.. FiSi+ seems to have a similar thing going on. It's like being so granular forces one to work with what is already there, or change it
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
Ah this makes sense. Perhaps it's when I'm not in the presence of other people that that calculating side seems to rear its head more? Everything appears to be protecting a very vulnerable FiSi from the position of being an ENFJ. Your coaching sessions ( I plan to book more) have certainly helped so far: I'm a lot more honest with myself as to what the underlying emotions that might be driving my behaviour are yet I have no problem compartmentalising this part of myself off...Would this also be FiSi eg the ability to switch emotions on & off at will & let another arise to the surface? Honestly I really liked your typing of Cersei as I'd never considered this before & also find as FeSe is by far more incremental than FeNe it's much more subtle in fact a lot of people struggle to delineate that I'm an Fe dom at all especially in MBTI spaces. I actually relate to her self destructive tendencies when I've been experiencing bipolar depression for instance, luckily I've got a handle on it & matured with age. I also agree that when on the back foot we can appear like Te dominants. I can relate to Danys utilisation of trauma to forge Ni goals but I do feel like her Ti is much more divergent than my own apart from when my stubbornness raises its head. Profound insights, thanks Harry 😊
@felypedaniel54672 ай бұрын
great vid , I think it is the fist intp fictionnal caracter that you have typed in Varys
@kingmin94912 ай бұрын
If you've ever watched attack on titan please consider making a similar analysis to it like this video !
@sarar11382 ай бұрын
Wondering if these are based on show only or books as well? Some characters felt a bit different in the books, like book-Sansa comes off as more of an idealistic dreamer and intuitive observer who is said to tear up at the sight of natural wonders, loves stories and the arts (arguably more so than any other character). Albeit she's pushed into following society's expectations of her at the beginning of the story. It seems less like coming from a place of upholding tradition and more like her wanting a sweeping fairytale adventure. Different to motivations of Ned/Robb overall, I guess more of an NF vibe if I had to describe it.
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@sarar1138 More of the show, I actually considered an ambiverted ISFP for Sansa but type wise would have made for an odd contrast to Ayra in the video. Went with ambiverted ESFJ instead since in the show there's so much role-following and less individualism
@sarar11382 ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonality agreed on ISFP Arya while Sansa does seem to have a strong Fe which Arya can't get on board with initially. Is there enough to build a case for an NFJ? Curiously, with the three queens parallel, she seems to develop, and act in accordance to, visions of how ruling/leadership could function harmoniously (less devotion/tradition more idealism/empathy angle) hence her ending up as queen, with Cersei and Daenerys being foils (preference for impulsive, spur of the moment decisions, ego>public who are used to justify their ego-driven pursuits). I might be slightly biased though as I see these characters mainly through the lens of ASOIAF books :) I concur with most male characters' typing (poor ENTJs). Not sure about some female characters, though love the rationale for Brienne's and Melisandre's types - much more consistent with actual characters than their online stereotypes.
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
@@CognitivePersonalityHarry would your point re 'role following' also apply to ENFJs? I'm wandering if you also mean 'role following' in a broader sense such as taking on a persona as I relate to that, not necessarily fulfilling a societal role; I can do that but it's not my primary mode de operandi
@Aurora-qn2dx26 күн бұрын
Why cant jon snow fit into infp personality? I was convinced he was infp. Thankyou.
@vicaduch33472 ай бұрын
What do the letters E O A C N that you have all the personality types mean? Also you forgot the faceless man.
@CognitivePersonality2 ай бұрын
@@vicaduch3347 Key is in description!
@khalifera2 ай бұрын
It's interesting there's so much Fe--Ti characters. GoT as a story is very Ti--Fe. The world building depth and the fact it's all about politics. I think George R R Martin himself has to be either an INTP or INFJ (probably NiTi with how long he takes to write those books lol--if he is an INFJ it would make it interesting that he is demonizing so many ESTPs...like a manifestation of his shadow). It's similar to Dune in how the story is a reflection of the author (another Ti heavy person (and how many Fe--Ti types there are!). On some of the typings in this video, with Jorah Mormont, he did a lot out of his attachment to Daenerys. It wasn't just out of nobility, and if anything he's not one to be the star of virtue. He was shunned by his father when he tried to pull a pirate stunt or something, that's why he was in Essos in the first place (and why his father gave Jon Snow his family sword that should have been his). He also deeply loved and wanted Daenerys for himself. To me there's a stronger sensing feeling component to him. Maybe it's the SiFi network off of ESFJ, I don't know. He also just seems more self serving than he lets on. Maybe an ESTP? also, what about Jaqen H'ghar! and Viserys! there's so many characters in this show you can have a field day hahah. Final point, I relate a lot to Bran's whole arc. Extraverted cognition is fairly apparent to me now, and although I'm inhabiting a lot of ENFJ like cognition with the phase of life I'm at, I still feel that natural inclination towards a detached cerebral center. More thinking convergent. I've been considering an ambiverted ENFP, with a stronger INFJ side, which is more in line with my original typing (INFJ with a stronger ENFP side- which honestly could still be the case). Since getting into depth psyche and trauma healing I've very much come back into a very creative, spontaneous, mercurial self that is how I was as a child, but which I abandoned for a more protective NiTi. I think I've been able to access and utilize a strong FiNi network over anything to really get into the self-transformative state to do so. Similar to my reasoning for Jorah above, I have an innate tendency to enliven my experience of life, even if I place a lot of emphasis on being a good person and wanting to help others heal in a very ENFJ like way. Intuition dominance just makes so much sense for me. Stuff like this is really cool and helpful since GoT has been in my head for a long time and I know the characters well. Cool stuff!
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
Some really interesting insights here 😊. I'd just like to point out as a divergent TiNi ENFJ typed by Harry however that the ENFJ isn't necessarily about helping others (I'm paraphrasing here so apologies if I'm not getting the gist fully). Like the INFJ we're much more about the scope of our cerebral impact on the world & limit those we care about, generally speaking, to a select few individuals. Honestly in terms of ethics etc I'm not a 'bad' person (let's assume of not a moral nihilist here) but I very occupy shades of grey & ethics & considerations thereof don't really occupy much of my mental musings. As Harry pointed out with Cersei albeit she's a darker ENFJ, ENFJs are very calculating & cunning type. At the end of the day we want to manifest our Ti into concrete reality & to get people to acquiesce to it, from my own personal position, Fe in many respects is simply a tool to get the job done. Not that I don't care about people evidently I do but people aren't my primary consideration per se especially on a global level. I liked your analysis of Martin I'd actually pin him as an INTP or INFP. Not that you implied this at all but I don't see any polarity in so many characters being on the FeTi axis & GoT being very TiFe centric: my own axis was rated by Harry as 50/50 so hence very fluid. I find it interesting that Martin compared himself most to Samwell.
@kavinvendant84502 ай бұрын
Sir.... If u could..... Pls do Harry potter too...... Awsm video btw❤️
@xripkan66232 ай бұрын
I would also like to see a video about Harry Potter characters (based on the books, not the films)
@Sentom232 ай бұрын
I think its natural for a story to have more of cerain types/functions and lacking in others if there is only one writer since they are projecting the archetypes they have most felt in their life experiences. The same thing would apply to typing though!
@parkerp95572 ай бұрын
I think Jon Snow is an INFJ in the books, but not in the show.
@Aurora-qn2dxАй бұрын
I think he is either infp or infj aswell ..even in the show.
@kavinvendant84502 ай бұрын
❤❤
@NotamusicianbutАй бұрын
You typed most of them wrong and your problem with xSTJ or inability to spot them must be addressed before it gets worse! If you're doing it for views or debate in comments and therefore popularity and income, know that it is an extremely dishonest thing to do!
@CognitivePersonalityАй бұрын
@@Notamusicianbut That's interesting, I actually consider the mass-dehumanisation of ISTJs as mindless automatons dishonest. People all too often look at type's productivity and reliability and fail to see the deeper SiFi core of integrity and emotional complexity. If I had a problem with this type I wouldn't type an awesome character like Ygritte as one of them regardless of whether people agree with the accuracy of it. As for ESTJs, the last video I released on this type was something I took care and effort in order to - as with ISTJs - humanise a type that is too often dehumanised with baseless stereotypes and a complete lack of interest in their complex inner worlds. Yes, CPT sometimes takes a different perspective to the mainstream, but it does so in order to honour each and every person. I'd rather people disagree with me than go against my own integrity, but I guess that's my ISTJ side speaking... which according to this comment I must also have a problem with.
Or you might use different framework or different understanding
@DorlaVegas-cw2kz2 ай бұрын
Over done catch you latter
@S_Dennison2 ай бұрын
Typing Ygritte as an ISTJ is insane. I normally love your videos, but I think you overcomplicated some of these characters. Jon Snow: isfp (I thought this was extremely obvious) Arya: istp (possibly isfp) Ygritte: entp, possibly estp (mild possibility of enfp/esfp) Cersei: entj- she had a semblance of Fe, but I think she only used it when necessary but was mostly centered in Te. Her relationship with Margaery showed her weakness with Fe Brienne: Istj Joffrey: esfp Varys: infj Petyr Baelish: infj, maybe a diff type, not fully certain (not ESTP)
@S_Dennison2 ай бұрын
Not trying to hate, I’ve watched u for years, I’m just surprised at how the seemingly more obvious characters are typed. The explanations given were very vague (tho I know it’s a short explanation for each) yet specific at the same time to some random obscure argument or type dipping/divergence. I feel you could have chosen other obscure explanations to make an argument for an array of diff types for each character.
@christianhinojosa8482 ай бұрын
I totally agree with you. I love most of his videos, probably one of the most innovative and best Jungian psyche channels on youtube, but this video was comical haha. I did not agree with 80% of the types.
@AnyaAnnika67Ай бұрын
Sorry but as an ENFJ I'm not entirely getting what you mean about Cersei only having a semblance of Fe. Whilst I'm not a dark ENFJ I do relate to Cersei on many levels & as Harry stated FeSe is far more subtle & less overt than FeNe indeed my own Fe is pretty difficult to detect. It's not about being some lovey dovey do gooder. The semblance between all the Fe doms in this show is that they tend to take themselves very seriously & their role within 'the game'. We also have to remember that one can have a very fluid FeTi axis - I am one of such people. Sorry no hate on my part but I think you're missing some fundamental components of CPT understanding here.