The Pomegranate Seed by Edith Wharton (

[@anneinnes5691]

Please, please do NOT be offended by people falling asleep to your storytelling… you have no idea what a gift that can be . In my own case, if I am lucky enough to fall asleep I ALWAYS re-visit your stories to hear them to the end. It is testament to your voice that you can ease an over-active mind to sleep. Be proud of that ability! 😴

[@ClassicGhost]

I did think of doing a sleep stories channel. I tried a sleep story on here but it bombed. I'm glad you like my work though :)

[@ishym352]

I Totally agree I wake up several times a night Knowing very well I haven't finished the story and will always revisit

[@opheliahamlet3508]

Absolutely!

[@CharlieOkeson]

That's why I'm here. And yes, I always come back night after night until I finish the story, cuz Tony has a great soothing voice and (usually) cadence (except when the characters are excited). Thanks, Tony ✌️💤

[@dodiekoehler]

I listen at least the first time through when I'm up and moving so I can get all the story. Only then does it work to fall asleep to. 😊

[@elaineedwards3189]

Thanks! I really appreciated the lecture portion after the reading of The Pomegranate Seed I learned so much and look forward to more readings and hopefully lectures

[@miapdx503]

My husband was dyslexic, and I would read my books out loud to him. It was a lovely thing we shared. He's gone now, and it's nice to have someone read to me. Thank you for this. This is one of my favorite authors. 🌹

[@ClassicGhost]

Take care. Thank you for sharing this xxx

[@aveg7899]

So good to see you, Tony, to put a face to that comforting voice. This is 2 years old, n it's the first time I've heard you read this story.

[@ClassicGhost]

I love this story, though I know not everyone does.

[@snowysnowyriver]

I'm working my way back through your video history. I bless the day I found your channel. Such a luxury to hear these old beautifully written stories read by such a superb narrator. Thank you so much. 😊

[@AbiCroCro]

This is beautifully done, I love that you’re so present with us

[@thurayya8905]

This was the first time I have seen you narrating. It was a pleasant surprise. You look very serious, but that's to be expected given the material. I don't think many people come Edith Wharton for a good laugh. You have a camera, why not? Branching out and exploring is good and curiosity is satisfied. People who don't like it generally don't like themselves. As long as you like it, that's all that's really needed.

[@ClassicGhost]

Oh I am very serious ;)

[@susanmercurio1060]

Another Edith Wharton masterpiece. And wonderfully read by our great narrator, Tony Walker!

[@ClassicGhost]

Hello Susan. Nice to see you

[@MartiWilliams-r2z]

Agree. Thank you.

[@OllieBrand-qo8pp]

If I fall asleep whilst listening to your excellent stories I always go back to where I know I reached and finish the story or start from the beginning.they are too brilliant to miss.

[@teresadelacanal1065]

English is a beautiful language, and spoken like this, I think it is enchanting. Thank you. Best wishes from Mexico 🇲🇽.

[@Axsomaniac]

You help me listen to stories that i need to for college! thank you for narrating!

[@ClassicGhost]

Great! I’m really pleased

[@janmeyer3129]

Your commentaries add so much depth to the stories for me. I like the way they don’t tell me how to think about them, but let me see you chasing them down

[@DS-mh5hb]

A truly talented narrator... thank you for doing what you do and making the world a better place

[@ClassicGhost]

+D S Thank you 🙏

[@joannezabel3747]

I cannot even try to go to sleep without a story from Tony and if I fall asleep halfway through, I get to listen to the rest of it another night so two for the price of one😂❤

[@marcclement7396]

Same here.

[@gwendolyn2001]

I see the husband as Persephone, not Charlotte. He is lured away from the ones whom he loves and is stolen away to the underworld (albeit still alive, as was Persephone). Charlotte becomes Demeter who will search for her loved one. Kenneth's mother is Hekate, who will accompany Demeter on her search for "Persephone." The dead wife is Hades. The question is whether he will have to remain in the underworld--whatever form that takes.

[@amyjones8114]

Wonderful voice actor and perfect for Wharton’s work.

[@ClassicGhost]

You are very nice . please come back

[@ALAuchter]

You are the best reader I’ve ever heard! Well done! Thank you so much!

[@smeggerssmeghead3100]

Narrated by a master of the speaking voice.

[@ClassicGhost]

I feel a bit of an imposter as but thank you

[@sarahsamaria8283]

Intriguing story. To be the second wife of a widower who was much in love with the first wife. Fancy life style well narrated by the writer. Feel sorry for Charlotte. But where does the letters come from. It's like a reminder to the man that he can't be happy in his second marriage.

[@martiwilliams4592]

Engrossing, gripping narration, visuals enhancing your fantastic story-telling. Your British accent is perfect for the story, which feels more English than American. Worth waiting up for. Think I will watch it again now on the bigger tv screen. Am too wired for the Garden of Mirrors! Thank you for what you do, Tony. Masterful!

[@ClassicGhost]

Awwww.. I hope the resolution holds up on the TV

[@martiwilliams4592]

@@ClassicGhost Certainly does! Impressive! Now, off to the Garden of Mirrors :0)

[@julielevinge266]

Been waiting for this, certainly wasn’t disappointed 😃

[@martiwilliams4592]

[@MartiWilliams-r2z]

Love this, three years later, no tv and new temporary email. Masterful, Tony, You're the best. Thank you.

[@donaldmccleary9015]

Great narration! Thanks! I was thrown for a loop until I looked it up and saw the refernce back to the Greek stories. I love how Edith Wharton wrote the story around the Greek stories and did not outwardly explain it to us. I heard "Call the police" and realized I need to do a little research!

[@rochellerochelle8398]

The most calming and soothing voice I’ve EVER heard. You have the perfect reading voice. I fall asleep to your voice nightly. It’s amazing

[@martiwilliams4592]

Love the visuals, Tony! Truly captivating story-telling!!!!!!Wharton and Pomegranate Seed among my favorites :0)

[@LCmonman]

So so so good, Tony!! I love that you share your voice, writing, and reading talents with us!! Just had to add that I cannot wait for what you read to us on Halloween 👻 📖

[@ClassicGhost]

Well it will be pre recorded. I think I’m going to do a ray bradbury

[@marisaera2353]

Beautifully narrated. Thank you.

[@robanybody4064]

In some ways this story shares a lot with Ethan Fromme, in that the husband craves light andd life but cant escape his negative wife who maintains a hold on him.

[@miapdx503]

Good observation 👍🏽

[@thelorriesweeneyable]

Went to Edith wharton home in Massachusetts this Sumner. Can't get enough of her work lately. So creative

[@ClassicGhost]

I'm a big fan of Wharton as you will know

[@franceswray8340]

I loved watching this reading, which was clear, highly focused, and virtually flawless. I think you should continue to film your readings; you have a really fascinating English face that could easily be transposed onto characters from many periods of British history. The story itself is masterful, building multiple layers of unresolved tension. At the end, we (like the wife and mother), are left hanging in a state of ambiguous and horrible dread. Thank you so much Tony, I am late to the table on many of these stories, but like many others I really appreciate your talented work.

[@jasonfx28]

Oh what a treat, seeing you, as you read! More like this, please!!

[@ClassicGhost]

I gave up doing these you know, as several people said they preferred a blank screen. I was hurt of course.

[@roxannemaguire5826]

Oh, I'm so sorry to learn that. How sad. I really enjoyed being able to watch you read. 😞 It's difficult to understand people, sometimes, isn't it. Thank you for reading all of these wonderful stories to us, dear Sir!!!!​@ClassicGhost

[@sugarfalls1]

I love how you are explaining the deeper meaning of her stories. She is definitely a fantastic writer of symbolism like Hardy and D.H. Lawrence. I'm reading some analysis of her story "The Bunner Sisters." That's another great story of hers and there's so much more of a deeper meaning than what's actually in the story. She is so good at keeping you in suspense in her works.

[@ClassicGhost]

Ta v m :) I’m glad you like her

[@miapdx503]

Now I have to read the Bunner Sisters. I wasn't even aware of it. Thank you 🌹

[@23ONEILL1]

Your analysis really helped make sense for me. The older stories take a lot of concentration for me.

[@mikestanyer6175]

Its so nice to see our friend narrate in person. I do like the pictures also, dont know about the live stories being dismissed? It's all good and ta very much. Best regards from the black country

[@miffy891]

Gosh this was brilliant. So well read. You're fantastic at it and have a great voice. Love your explanations at the end. Also, it's nice to see your face!

[@Linnet09]

Sometimes those of us who listen while falling asleep listen more. I sometimes listen while falling asleep, sometimes don't, but did with this one, restarting it a couple times at the last bit l heard so I don't miss anything. I always like your discussions, particularly in this case, since the connection to Persephone puzzled me.

[@tonyyoung8256]

Mr. Walker--your voice is incantatory & your acting sublime--and used to excellent effect in this story. Thank you.

[@BarbaraJV1]

One gets really engrossed in this story. Brilliant writing and also narrating. You actually feel the empathy for all the characters in this….. even of Elise

[@violetfemme411]

I realized after this, my 2nd listen to this brilliant offering of literature, that I had neglected to comment after my 1st listen a year or more ago. I'm suffering from a brutal bout of insomnia so I decided to revisit Ms Wharton while waiting for the 3rd installment of Hill House. As you may know, at the top of the list of my favorite female writers are Shirley Jackson and Harper Lee. I am beginning to think Edith Wharton might come in at #3. The more I pay close attention to details perhaps missed on previous reads or listens, the more I've come to appreciate the brilliant nuances and seemingly less important details that later show themselves as anything but. Every word has it's own deliberate job, and each is masterful at delivering an overall creeping anxiousness and an almost unbearable expectation. Thank you for bringing these gems to life...and I personally very much enjoy when you read on camera. It's like having a friend or family member reading you a bedtime story. Thank you my friend, for all the time, effort and obvious caring you put into every offering. 💜

[@ClassicGhost]

I was wondering about doing a literature degree. Maybe I'm a bit old though

[@violetfemme411]

@@ClassicGhost Well the obvious yet cliche answer is we're never too old to learn. We only stop when we either die or go mad. I believe you're far from both, so if you want it badly enough....I would think it's more a matter of having or making the time. With your jobs here and there, family and other general commitments it might not be easy. For me, the worst times in my life have been when I haven't any goals or desires strong enough to actually step up and pursue. When fighting my demons becomes a fulltime job. But I'm betting you could make it happen. 💜

[@bonniejohns3179]

You're comment about life hit home for me. I have enjoyed listening while I work so I do not watch but see a face to put to the voice makes listening even better. God bless.

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you Bonnie

[@konstantinoskaragiannis1596]

"The Pomegranate Seed"(1931) is an excellent and very classic mystery Ghost story by a Master of this kind:Edith Wharton!

[@stardust949]

I was really happy you discussed this one afterwards---it helped me appreciate it more. I had no inkling of connection to the pomegranate seed til you explained it. Haven't read the myths in decades. many thanks.

[@glosteiger2517]

Loved watching your face during this. Facial expressions emphasizing the emotions of the characters. Wonderfully done.

[@avril4421]

You read so beautifully. I like to watch your face as you read, a consummate actor, but also more than happy to listen to your voice. A thousand thanks for what you do

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you Avril.

[@pandawan4]

I love being read to by you. I had a migraine and was carsick, so I played your audiobooks and it was so comforting even though I was barely conscious enough to listen properly. I work alone in a lab so your reading pops up there as well!

[@ClassicGhost]

I am glad to be of help

[@ishym352]

You are a grait story teller grait Narrator! I am dyslexic who loves to read but with grait difficulties I find that funny but there it is, being able to listen to a story is much more enjoyable and less frustrating..helps me switch of and tune witch for me is important as i can visualise.. It enhances my imagination brilliant thak you 🙏🏿

[@carolrios9216]

Hey Tony, I must say, you are my favorite, love your voice, love your stories! I Also love your commentary at the end of stories. Just wondering, Is that 1:pm London time? I'm on California time.

[@ClassicGhost]

It is. Now I spoke to someone in Los Angeles at 4pm here and it was early morning. I think it’s about noon with you

[@richardjohnkeeling220]

@@ClassicGhost vvb in.

[@vanillasuncherries]

Hello in 2024!! I love relaxing to your videos after I stop working for the night ❄️☃️💖

[@ClassicGhost]

Happy 2024!

[@Evyenne]

Just found this older reading of yours, Tony, and truly enjoyed the chance to see you perform. This particular story had extra meaning for me, as I’ve been a Charlotte, the second wife of a widower. For me, it was incredibly challenging, just from the circumstances, family, location, etc. Regardless, thank you for all of your work, because I’m spoiled now and have to hear you every day. 😊

[@susandombrowski7711]

Forgot to say, I really enjoy your thoughtful and honest commentary. It adds so much to the experience I didn't anticipate.

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you very much Susan. My mouth opens and the words fall out. For better or worse I guess, anyway thanks

[@blixten2928]

Wonderful to see you in person reading. It's such a plus, so much fun!

[@ClassicGhost]

Nice of you to say. I think I am going to do videos for members but just keep these here audio only in future.

[@starlynn57]

Thank you for your commentary at story’s end; Edith Wharton is a favorite of mine- ---Frome was my first exposure to her clever writing.

[@MaireBeirne-zl6iu]

I agree, wonderful storytelling. Thank you.

[@jodyharnish9104]

It's lovely to see you and put a face to the voice!

[@melfreemans]

Any letter coming into my home from a woman for my husband would have been opened by myself.

[@tomsdottir]

I listen to these stories in bed at night and sometimes they follow me into my dreams. This was one which did, to quite sinister effect. A terrific read of a really wonderful story. Edith must have been wonderful company!

[@ClassicGhost]

I live this story . It’s really disturbing to me

[@nancyleahy2664]

I think this is my absolute favorite Wharton short story!! And your reading of it is simply perfect. Thanks so much Tony...you're a treasure!

[@phoebebiketravel]

What a wonderful story, I enjoyed every moment. Big thank you❤I love your reading!

[@ClassicGhost]

You are so welcome

[@marjoriearmstrong8606]

Thank you! Beautifully read. The commentary has been really helpful.

[@ClassicGhost]

You're very welcome!

[@teddydog6229]

That title was driving me crazy. I remember the story of Persephone being abducted by Pluto but forgot the bit about the pomegranate seeds which keep her hooked to the world of the dead. It's a thin and faint link but unbreakable all the same.

[@ClassicGhost]

It is. It adds a bit of resonance to be sure

[@francesjbutterworth5083]

Your stories has appealed to my imagination I can imagine the story in my mind like a film I can see in my mind.

[@ClassicGhost]

+@francesjbutterworth5083 I love this story but some people i like don’t like it

[@joane1776]

Beautifully read and excellent presentation! Thank you!

[@martiwilliams4592]

Hi Tony! Really am looking forward to your great stories and commentary! Is it at 10 PM Copenhagen time? See you then, I hope!

[@MaggieTheCat01]

I fall asleep to your narrations, but that’s to your credit. You successfully drive out of my mind all of the thoughts that usually keep me awake. I like to listen again during the daytime so that I get to enjoy the whole story. Double the views for you! You’re one of my favourite narrators, by the way. You’re very good at it. Thanks for posting.

[@ClassicGhost]

+MaggieTheCat01 i like the idea that you listen twice. double the views as you say :)

[@hill9948]

I’m still dying to know what the letters said. Could he actually read them? Would he respond? How did they get there? So many questions remain which adds a level of intrigue to the story. Love it

[@andrewkoastephens210]

Thank you for this and thank you for the analysis at the end. I feel I get to appreciate the stories on a much deeper level.

[@ClassicGhost]

+Andrew Koa Stephens thanks again Andrew

[@susandombrowski7711]

I enjoy your many accents! Do follow your instincts and use them. Your emotional interpretation is well thought out. Carry on!!!

[@ClassicGhost]

The accents really are part of the phrasing and when I have a story, say an Irish or Scottish or Australian story and I do it in my normal voice, it doesn't feel right.

[@bluegreenglue6565]

Nice! An exquisite tale, and marvelous delivery. Thank you so much.

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you blue

[@gillmclean3202]

Love your channel, and commentry on this was enlightening. Thank you 😄

[@ClassicGhost]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@cgoodson2010]

Yay, you! I was wondering if you'd narrate an Edith Wharton, and, voila'! Good to see you, too!

[@ClassicGhost]

this is one of my favourites

[@marcclement7396]

Well done!

[@imeka222]

Beautiful deliver.. Bravo....

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you :)

[@shroomyk]

Parts of this story really remind me of "Rebecca". Thanks for the explanation at the end too.

[@ClassicGhost]

+ShroomyK I can see why

[@t.h.337]

Love Edith Wharton. It really comes alive when you read it. Thanks for this.👍

[@tmaz3654]

Tony just found your channel and it is brilliant, your readings are lovely. Often wake in the night so I listen to you and it calms my mind. I agree with the other comments, excellent !!

[@ishym352]

I can relate to that...its comforting knowing I'm not alone To whom it may concern I hope your sleep gets much better 🙏🏿

[@soundsilence2604]

A much appreciated analysis, and a powerful commentary on life.

[@ClassicGhost]

Thank you. I really like your name

[@soundsilence2604]

@@ClassicGhost Thanks. It references my enjoyment of both extremes in equal measure. Your sounds are a treasured find. 👻

[@gohboy56]

Very intriguing, and I just adored your expressions and gestures et all. You are really a talented writer and narrative artist

[@ClassicGhost]

Very very kind. Thank you

[@sleethmitchell]

as to falling asleep... yes, that is troubling. as a child attending classical music concerts, i often fell asleep. a truly enlightened teacher who took us, a class of fifth graders to the concert hall, was not offended. of course, music and stories are different in that regard. and i am guilty of falling asleep. but the GREAT ASPECT of these stories is that they can be painlessly repeated. i ALWAYS return and listen the next day when i am more alert. thank you for these wonderful recordings.

[@ClassicGhost]

I've got all over that now. I am just happy I help people relax

[@KatharinaBeaujolin]

A great pleasure listening to you ! Thank you

[@sugarfalls1]

I love Edith Wharton!! Thank you, Sir Braz!! This girl's an East coaster from Pennsylvania!! Much thanks luvey from across the pond!! Here's to tea and a great story!! "In the very heart of the hurricane, she had found her tiny eyelet!" Now that's such a fantastic metaphor or simile (I don't know which exactly). The authors around the turn of the century are write so vividly and poetically! This isn't just a short story, THIS IS ART!!! beautiful!!!

[@ClassicGhost]

It is art. It’s certainly literature

[@sugarfalls1]

@@ClassicGhost And so is your narration too! The accents, the pauses in all the right places and seeing you actually doing it - it's fantastic and you are as brilliant as the harvest moon. Thank you for explaining the symbolism too! Makes it so much better!

[@MartiWilliams-r2z]

Masterful, Tony. Thank you.

[@cassiesews]

I very much enjoyed the mystery in this story. It was also enjoyable to see you reading it out loud too. Thanks for sharing!

[@ClassicGhost]

+The Victorian Thimble I am very happy you enjoyed it :)

[@susanhepburn6040]

Ireally enjoyed this story, Tony - thank you very much! Because of the language, I thought it was set in England, so it was quite a shock when New Jersey was mentioned. Thanks also for your Afterword. I had already clocked the link to the Demeter and Persephone myth but it was interesting to hear your take on it. I was surprised that it ended the way it did - but she was right to leave it there. I must admit, if I were Charlotte, once she realised about Elsie, I'd have been straight off to the cemetery, expecting to find my husband laying dead by Elsie's grave! Once again, thank you for a great read!

[@vespelian5769]

I've just discovered your channel and gorging your content over the new year. You have an excellent voice and literally, taste and dramatic ability. I like your point about being here to live, especially for those whose business it is to tread the line between the two in life.

[@elisabethanzenberger4534]

Simply wonderful! Thank you!

[@kevinlim2500]

You are a master of your craft kind sir! I am enamored by your eloquence.

[@kaylemon2286]

Tony,Tony,Tony you’ve done it again! Someone said you could read a phone book and make it intriguing. But don’t. Keep up your amazing stories!

[@LouLou-wm4ih]

Thoroughly enjoyed this reading. In fact I’m going to watch a second time. Also new subscriber!

[@creative2716]

Binge-ing, way after the fact. Enjoyed story. Your interpretations are always enlightening. Love seeing your calm face as you read, I would be a bundle of nerves. I'll take you however I can get you, be it recorded in person, in radio or podcast or live readings. Fun just hearing your stories and those of other writers as well. Plz keep up your good works. You are bringing ppl together with a common bond of literature. Blessings on you.

[@ClassicGhost]

Thanks Creative. I may do some more video recordings, not sure.

[@elizah2093]

Very interesting story - quite riveting. Excellent narration. Thank you!

[@ClassicGhost]

Thanks for listening

[@maribriggs9365]

I love watching you read. It almost seems you are doing it from memory. You should have been an actor.

[@ClassicGhost]

I did a lot more of these reading ones once. But it's too late now for me to be an actor I think

[@Hazel_Fox22]

I love to listen to your narration while doing housework or crafting. I have a playlist of your work that I've already listened to during the day for falling asleep to at night. That way, I don't miss out on details...LOL. Thank you for doing what you do, both here on your channel and your career in real life. You are a gem of a person and I hope nobody ever tells you differently.

[@ClassicGhost]

People do tell me differently, but I my mum says they're silly and I shouldn't listen. Thanks for listening :)

[@Hazel_Fox22]

@@ClassicGhost Mothers know their boys! For sure!

[@johnchiecsek6279]

Hey Tony, great work. Thank you.

[@kittima3218]

I found your reading as lovely as usual. I don't know if any other narrator I want to listen to. I adore your accent, and prefer it to the American accent...probably because I am American. I find your accent so pleasant... and dare I say romantic! Keep up the splendid work. Thank you!

[@mariameere5807]

I’ve just seen your notification, I missed a load of them because I’ve over subscribed To about 200- I’m not joking, spiritual channels of all types and because of this I miss the occasional gem 💎 Love this author! Great reading!

[@ClassicGhost]

It was there waiting for you :)

[@nancynickerson4341]

Excellent narration, thank you!

[@calliesoutherland9435]

A great selection 👌 and read beautifully. Thank you for such high quality content ✨.

[@LadyRoseWinters]

Excellent reading-thank you!

[@CarolWoodhouse-w2s]

Excellent! Thank you x

[@hilaryeales1268]

Oh,bravo.....immaculate reading and lovely chat, what a treat👍💛💚💙💜

[@ClassicGhost]

+Hilary Eales Hi, Hilary, very nice of you to say that. I love this story

[@petertomasi7587]

Excellent reading of an awesome story; thank you!!

[@ClassicGhost]

+Peter Tomasi thanks Peter

[@julielevinge266]

Afraid I’d have steemed it open!! Maybe that says a lot about me😔😃

[@tzaph67]

This was excellent! I love Edith Wharton and I like how you read - am very into audio productions . Thanks ever so much, I’m going to subscribe to your channel.

[@ClassicGhost]

Lovely to have you here

[@sanciekemtrup308]

What an amazing storyteller Ty so very much