The Possibility of Survivor: Third Time’s A Charm

[@GeauxWyatt]

Can you imagine the possibility of an alliance of BIG TOM and KEITH NALE?!? Talk about the ultimate tv gold!

[@jpbproductions3872]

“HE’S A JEW AND HE WON’T EAT THE HAM” “I MEAN YOU BOUGHT IT SO I SAY STICK TO THE PLAN THAT YOU SHARE”

[@ethangc081]

rip :(

[@harrdeeharr]

Putting Abi Maria and Phillip Shepherd on the same cast would be explosive

[@Guitarfreak12345]

I actually heard from Peih-Gee herself that her and Abi-Maria are really good friends nowadays

[@justinpascal8332]

peih gee said that they have a siblings rivalry

[@shinyhydreigon7257]

How good of an arc would it be for Russel Swan to come back and win a season like this. Such a great guy with the worst luck.

[@JMaster9877]

Or Franchessca

[@marycornett3165]

@@JMaster9877 You mean franquesta lol

[@parthshah4069]

Mary Cornett nah it’s francesqua

[@noname-do7sv]

I thought it was Franswessqua or maybe my mouth is just dry.

[@jesmccoy26]

Honestly, he deserves better

[@coolwahl]

Courtney should be on every season...i said what I said.

[@kailifestyle4674]

Agreed

[@santiagocuellar6316]

Maybe not necessarily 3rd time’s a charm but maybe like Last Chance where it’s just people that have never won before not necessarily just people that played twice which would make it a lot easier to cast and would open the door for some people like coach, ozzy, cirie, aubrey, among others.

[@Thesportsmusicgod]

That will only work for the final season

[@marycornett3165]

@@Thesportsmusicgod hopefully that would be 30 years away season 100

[@2Natural]

Spencer is interested in coming back now, according to a IG q & a he posted a month or so ago

[@naruhinatvplus]

If Spencer comes back for another season of Survivor, I don't mind if they put him in a Survivor Fans vs Favorites III along with the likes of Sandra, Domenick, Russell, Cirie, Lauren (EOE), Marty, Jon (SJDS), Jaclyn and Crissy

[@FlaggedALot]

@@naruhinatvplus I doubt FvF will include winners or three/four/five time players

[@everybodyhateswest]

if spencer comes back i really hopes he wins, he is the type of player you forget never won. he was so good.

[@skyblue2267]

Of course Debbie would come back! She’s a gymnast, a part time model and soon to be master strategist.

[@matthertler1475]

And in her free time she’s a waiter at red lobster

[@ruslax]

Model

[@crazy_lol3111]

She also waits at Applebees!

[@iamkonner4813]

6:48 Rudy is more likely to play than him and he’s dead

[@kingklub]

What if they bring Franchessca back but make some twist to get her out first again just to troll with her

[@TheDollyce]

Yeah, bring back Francesca AND Phil Shepard! And put them in the same Tribe!

[@armorvil]

Yup, they should create an advantage only useable on the first tribal council that says "use this after the votes have been read to make a player named Francesca the first person voted out instead". This advantage would be called FRANCESQUA.

[@paigeb96386]

DOLLYCE BEEMAN q aweee

[@vaughnarmour612]

Lmao some men just want to see the world burn

[@williamtucker9497]

I would actually like to see her back and able to play finally.

[@owengette8089]

You know what would be cool would be 2nd timers versus 3rd timers vs 4th timers

[@parkzy2920]

It would probably end up like Gamechangers unfortunately

[@Luckruls]

@@parkzy2920 I think if you put all the bigger threats on one tribe together it would make it more likely that they would team up and stick together after the merge. You would have to have the 4th timers be a group of people that are decent at challenges because if they lost a lot of numbers before the swap or the merge then it would be like gamechangers. I think a Lions vs Hyenas season could work for the same reason listed above. Instill this idea of being a big player and taking out small players.

[@parkzy2920]

@@Luckruls Gamechangers was supposed to be pre-merge vs merge vs winners. What I mean is the theme would fall apart. The 4 timer pool is so weak and those casting might eventually give up the idea for a Gamechangers Season 2.

[@Luckruls]

@@parkzy2920 That's interesting I never knew that about Gamechangers, that's probably a better idea than 2nd vs 3rd vs 4th I think you could have some strong casts though we do need more women winners before that happens, otherwise the cast would be too similar to WaW. I would enjoy seeing some male winners we didn't see on WaW if you brought on Tommy, Todd, Earl, Mike maybe even Chris would be fun!

[@parkzy2920]

@@Luckruls yea merianan says it in one of his gamechanger videos

[@blr_blur]

I love when you mention certain people and instead of giving any explanation about them (since it’s usually pretty obvious), you just say “come onnnn” 🤣 makes me laugh every time

[@sarapesenacker4781]

Hey dude can you make a last person voted out every season ranking with those people like Devens or David or Rudy

[@noname-do7sv]

Technically, Devens wasn’t voted out, but yeah I agree it’d be a good idea

[@baki7337]

Malcom and david write would be good aswell

[@gabihunter1749]

Wentworth??

[@kingklub]

I mean you can’t forget Cirie

[@marycornett3165]

RIP RUDY

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

lex was cast for 40 until they changed it to all winners. he said it in an interview with brandon hantz on his youtube channel.

[@marycornett3165]

Hantz NATION has a great KZbin channel he has had Bob winner of season 17 sugar from season 17 20 Corrine season 17 many other survivor players check out Hantz NATION KZbin channel everyone

[@BurstWalkthroughs]

Does that mean he'll be back for season 41? Since I believe they have the cast already, they just have to start filming.

[@greysonwilliams7402]

@@BurstWalkthroughs They wouldnt do 2 returnee seasons back to back

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

@@greysonwilliams7402 not like they havent before

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

@@BurstWalkthroughs who would be back? 41 is newbies anyways.

[@stevester9148]

I'd rather burn down my TV set than have another season of Philip Sheppard

[@savageguineapig5857]

I would pay any amount to have another season of Phillip Shepard

[@NathanHeaver]

@@savageguineapig5857 1 million dollars?

[@AndrewSmith-pn2qc]

@@NathanHeaver For the legendary Philip Sheppard yes!

[@immanuelak2643]

EW NO PHILIP. BUT i will forgive them if they also include franshesqhua and lets see if she would be the 1st person voted out again lol

[@savageguineapig5857]

Nathan Heaver I will pay any amount to have another season of Phillip Shepard!

[@elliekitabjian2069]

I LOVE when the response is just “I mean COME ON” 😂😂

[@jenniferumstead4583]

I loved that with this video you showed the picture of those you considered in additions to the ones you "would" have cast. Really helped me as someone who is terrible with names, hopeful you will do it in future videos! Love these videos!

[@chrisrysz7727]

This might be the first time he’s discussed so many of these people individually

[@realitytime543]

Yau Man said on his ama he would come back

[@58twright]

he had to turn down heroes vs villains because of work obligations i think he would be too old now & tai is very similar

[@potatodog3363]

Tyler Wright tai wouldn’t be too old

[@queenkatara7861]

Tyler Wright Tai and Yau Man aren’t that similar.

[@58twright]

@@queenkatara7861 yeah they are

[@58twright]

@@potatodog3363 not now he wouldnt however a few years & he might be

[@tylerhaggerty4805]

The final cast shown here is the most eclectic looking group since Borneo.

[@dolphinz8116]

Ehh...I think Kimmi has a good shot personally, because there's an easy story there of how she went out in a monumental tribal council and how she, really, was the only TRUE old-schooler to adapt to the game and thrive in it, switching her game from Australia and almost winning in Cambodia.

[@brendanfechter4889]

Fairplay claims he got the call for season 40 when it was gonna be legends not winners. And he was featured heavily in the Survivor at 40 thing they did the week before the premiere.

[@crazy_lol3111]

Apparently Russell and Laura got the call and Russell said it was gonna be rivals!???

[@jpbproductions3872]

14:37 I think you’re wrong. He was in the casting pool for season 42 before production decided just to make it an all newbie season

[@GreenDragon1234]

Who says it’s an all newbie season?

[@awm8414]

I think for Caleb They should do what they did for Philippines and bring back some people who deserve a 3rd shot

[@johnhepfer4484]

Sadly Keith Nale will never get a third chance. Rest In Peace

[@samrosenau3573]

Lex got asked back for season 40 before it was all winners and he said yes so he is willing to come back

[@johndebate3858]

I would love a peih gee return tho

[@jpbproductions3872]

2:37 he was asked back before Kelly Kahl, Jeff, and Matt decided the theme was going to be winners at war

[@laurahauschildt1708]

It would be interesting to see Kat on another season. She did an interview with Survivor Specialists and she seemed SO different and mature.

[@airtempest8945]

That and, let's be honest, Kat has pretty much all the (only) good moments in One World. Her first confessional (Like, it just encapsulates the Kat experience) to the bacon in a B.L.T. to her blindside to her final speech. So amazing.

[@djspencer6498]

Here’s who I would cast on Survivor: Third Time’s the Charm: Men Rob Cesternino Lex van de Berghe Russell Swan Erik Reichenbach Gervase Peterson Terry Deitz Woo Hwang Stephen Fischbach Spencer Bledsoe Brad Culpepper Women: Shii Ann Huang Ami Cusack Eliza Orlins Courtney Yates Danielle DiLorenzo Brenda Lowe Monica Culpepper Abi-Maria Gomes Debbie Wanner Michaela Bradshaw

[@lukebrennan3378]

Do y’all have any idea what’s going on with Survivor 41

[@savageguineapig5857]

It’s recording now in Samoa

[@charlieradant]

I believe they have shipped the people out already but I don't know the cast

[@bigbrotherspoilers9756]

they might start filming in september

[@58twright]

@@savageguineapig5857 no its in fiji

[@realitytime543]

Savage Guinea Pig where did you get this info?

[@maddenoverdrivelegend2623]

This wouldn’t be a true cast without David

[@caidenmagill1006]

Yessir

[@jesmccoy26]

I was literally just thinking about a season like this and I would was thinking how I would like to see Russel Swan, Michaela, Woo, and Yau man come back although he is getting pretty old now so he is pretty unlikely

[@bennymcshea2448]

#bringbackbobbyjon

[@Joeoguzon]

Like if Erik wasn’t on the cast I would die

[@adamassimakopoulos8566]

this videos make my day

[@Manuxl0]

Can you do the sequester mini review

[@alexanaya9945]

I feel like working for CBS might be exactly why he’d be able to play, any other company no but if it’s in CBS best interests they might let him and I’m sure they’d figure out a way around it

[@Troy_Palo24]

Can you do a casting for survivor blood vs water 2 their are a lot of people who would go just for that season

[@58twright]

it would be blood vs water 3 & he did do a casting video for that its on this channel

[@Troy_Palo24]

Tyler Wright sorry I didn’t know but can u link it I look but could not find it

[@58twright]

Troy Palochak just look it up on here

[@ramilleanthonymartinez3702]

Shii Ann was supposed to be in Heroes vs Villains but had work commitments

[@shinyhydreigon7257]

Does production want Lex back? He was told he was going to be on 40 before it was changed to All-Winners. I would be shocked if he isn't on the next returnee season, assuming he's eligible.

[@sethbryant5539]

4:47 Ozzy and Penner are the 2 that have played again, but not in HvV

[@jeanpauleksteen]

Why he even mention rudy😭 that was cold

[@awm8414]

Honestly this would be a good season idea

[@sillygoosesurvivor]

I'm here for this cast actually. And I think there are some people who could be convinced to come back who may have previously said they wouldn't.

[@sethbryant5539]

14:48 In fact, he got taken out even earlier than Kaoh Rong where he got medevaced

[@awm8414]

4th in Koah Rong 3rd in Game Changers

[@sethbryant5539]

12:33 He didn’t, but it sounded like he said “she hasn’t played since the first season and shit”

[@jpbproductions3872]

Could you do a worst to ever play?

[@samueloneworldproductions6520]

I HAVE LITERALLY THOUGHT OF THIS WAYYYY BEFORE YOU DID AND EVEN DID AN CASTING VIDEO OF THIS MYSELF!!!!

[@jpbproductions3872]

I think Jenna Lewis would do great on a season like this which could also include a “beat to never win” season

[@connorberry9766]

I really wanna see a legends of past and present season

[@bingbong7213]

Can you do a "My Philosophy on the game" BB?

[@sethbryant5539]

15:56 It seems the casual fans really like her though. Plus, she’s married to Joe Anglim

[@nicolaswest2940]

Eliza’s running for a political position so I doubt she would play

[@sensarmy]

true

[@matthewzittritsch3042]

I think an amazing season could be one with a cast completely comprised of first boots. There are so many legendary cast members who were booted off first and the dynamics would be hysterical. Let's create a season with players who never got a chance to play the game, and guarantee that a first boot will then become a winner. Opinions?

[@sethbryant5539]

18:03 He might be able to again down the road

[@rileyesmay]

They should literally make a season with Jeff on one tribe with people he likes like cochran, etc and then the other tribe has people he dislikes like Fairplay, Colton, etc. I feel like it is super unlikely to happen, but would create an amazing season unlike any others. Even if Jeff wasnt in it it would still be cool to have.

[@Joeoguzon]

Riley Esmay sooo winners at war cast vs quitters and dan spilio

[@rileyesmay]

@@Joeoguzon pretty much but I mean it would never happen but imagine the hatred and drama on the tribe haha

[@brendanconant59]

I wanna see rob back so bad

[@navdieverid8018]

Didn’t some of the people in winners are war only play twice?

[@58twright]

yeah i think so

[@timothylites3653]

Yeah Sophie, ben, wendall, nick, kim, michelle, denise, yul, natalie, adam, danni have only played one time before WAW

[@58twright]

@@timothylites3653 yes

[@MegTalksGlee]

Yeah but the theme name implies having not won before

[@amillionresets3263]

Poor Rudy

[@lauren1969]

I like Erik actually and I would love to see him play again. But I think the problem was Caramoan because he got no screen time in the Reunion show. And made comments about it. Saying how other people from other season and just people in the crowd got more screen time then him and he made it to final 5. I would love to see him back and I know especially for that season the big thing was him as an original fan and then coming back as a favorite. But he got medically evacuated and so just kinda cut that part out of his story. To me he is a very interesting player and I would go see him again in a better light just not a person who gave up immunity.

[@sethbryant5539]

2:46 What reality show?

[@JMaster9877]

Survivor Dynamic Duos

[@davidmujynya5339]

You should do a fallen angel player ranking. Ranking everyone eliminated before the final tribal

[@phifdee]

ALL RETURNEE SEASONS • All Stars • Heroes Vs Villains • Second Chance • Game Changers • Winners at War CAPTAIN SEASONS • Guatemala • Redemption Island • South Pacific • Philippines • Edge of Extinction 50/50 SEASONS • Micronesia • Caramoan • Blood Vs Water

[@coDDR9]

I couldn't help but imagine what if he brought back people from Winners At War lol. Impossible and extremely unlikely, yes, but I would like to see his take on that . :D

[@sethbryant5539]

People like Natalie and Michele are somewhat likely to play again I think

[@twistedreviews9574]

Lex, actually got asked to be on season 40 before they changed it to an all winners season!!

[@denistuohy2535]

If Debbie or Shirin ever play again I’m not watching the season. They annoy the shit out of me. Their first seasons were okay but both of their second outings were mind numbing

[@larryparr2799]

I think production would be able to Convince at least one or more of those players you said doesn’t want to play again but would be a lock if they did.

[@bangjoeofficial]

Yeah 3rd times a charm just doesn't work. It starts off good with the older players because you can almost forget they played twice but once you get into Second Chance and Game Changers it's like, do we really wanna THIS group of players again? I'd rather see Second Chance 2 than this. Don't care to see Abi, Wu, PG, or Philiip again. Their stories are all already told. Abi is annoying. PG WITH Abi is just asking for trouble. The only thing intriguing is seeing Philip interact with Abi but that's just to see a train wreck and that doesn't make a season. I could see this season starting and me being extremely underwhelmed about 4 episodes in.

[@danielbarhorst4494]

This is a solid cast

[@notanotherhimbo5060]

I think if Jenna and Gervase are on, they'd bring on Kelly for the sole fact that they're season 1 players

[@0pacbig32]

Kelly I think it's pretty obvious to me and she did state it in her exit interview's for Cambodia that she does not want to play again. I was even surprised she even wanted to play again at the time since she seemed very out of it by the end of Borneo.

[@joshuasanders7747]

Why do you think Sugar wouldn’t come back?

[@Like_Elsa]

Yau man will only play if he gets his truck back. He’s tired of paying for Lyft.

[@adamk9542]

While I don't think a twist like this would work for a full cast, maybe one or two per tribe on a mostly-newbie season might work (minus David Wright, I feel like that was sort of what they were going for with EoE)

[@eddyy1717]

Came back to this video hoping somebody had done a simulation, hahaha. 😂

[@danb-ue5xg]

What did FairPlay do to ruin his relationship with production

[@jpbproductions3872]

Leave ponderosa early

[@nickp3949]

Maybe an unpopular opinion, but I would enjoy seeing Brad come back. He played pretty well in game changers and he was an aggressive player, so I think he’d have a target on his back coming in for a third time

[@georgestafford7843]

Why did you talk about troyzan? He only played once.

[@sethbryant5539]

One World, Game Changers

[@georgestafford7843]

@@sethbryant5539 I.. I was making a joke on the fact that Troyzan was barely on game changers

[@sethbryant5539]

@@georgestafford7843 Lol that’s true

[@recon4786]

If these were the people I had to watch again (with the exception of Deitz, Lex and others) I wouldn’t even watch

[@LiamHarkins]

They asked Lex back for season 40 before they decided on all winners so I think he’s a lock if they do something similar to this concept.

[@spongenoob2240]

Fallen angels cast

[@kyosotacomics]

Great video as usual. I would replace Philip with Savage or Keith Nale. I think Phillip said on a recent RHAP pod that he doesn't really want to play again (due to how he was edited, etc)... but I could be wrong.

[@baki7337]

Honestly i prefer The normal longer lengths of your videos Editing wise I get it but this kinda seemed rushed like I said tho I Just really like the content

[@wyattcolby4249]

Can you PLEASEEEEEE rank every first boot just like ranking all runners ups and winners

[@elijahisaiah8623]

I find it funny on your cast, you put a husband and wife on the same season hahahaha

[@joeymichel1447]

Wait what about Tom westman

[@joeymichel1447]

I forgot he won lol

[@joshuaclemons5452]

I can’t stand Jenna Lewis but I would love to have any OG back. Having her and Gervase together in one season 20 years later would be so amazing.

[@TheDollyce]

No Brandon. Production had to escort him off the set last time. He's toast.

[@ryleycarroll9486]

The main problem for me is that it automatically cancels out the people that play for the first time after the last all stars/game changers

[@sethbryant5539]

2:09 “Rab”

[@BigMattXXL]

Doesn't Rick Devens work at a CBS affiliate as a news anchor?

[@58twright]

i believe he works for an abc affiliate he will definitley 100% be back again

[@ttewelow1]

You forgot to mention Jenna Morasca

[@justinpascal8332]

She won her first season

[@ttewelow1]

@@justinpascal8332 But hes putting together a cast full of people that have played only twice and it will be their 3rd if they play it again and he forgot to mention Jenna

[@justinpascal8332]

@@ttewelow1 it does not include winners. If it did Cochran would have also been mentioned

[@connorberry9766]

I think Philip isn't physically able to play I think. If I remember that RHAP red carpet interview he is sadly having some health problems

[@cat-mh2wp]

Also he had covid 19 but luckily recovered

[@JG-si9vs]

I think you forgot Tom Westman

[@sethbryant5539]

He won

[@JG-si9vs]

@@sethbryant5539 No I mean he wasnt mentioned when HvV was brought up

[@TigerManRory]

@@JG-si9vs yeah, because he won, second chance and third times a charm seasons only include players who never won because it’s their second/third *chance* to win, but he’s already won

[@caidenmagill1006]

I feel brad culpepper would be a joe/ Ozzy at this point

[@beaksters]

Correction, Third Time’s THE Charm

[@thomascook7029]

Survivor: Final Chances Cast?

[@TheDollyce]

You named some people who would need their walkers to get around! Old Tom? Pulease.

[@awm8414]

I think Caleb would be a good option tbh

[@AAM-pv1he]

Phillip Sheppard, Debbie and Abi-Maria all together.... mushroom cloud stuff lol!!! I kinda disagree with TMR, plenty of good cast members to make a compelling season on offer here?