The Problems of Guts and Blackpowder

Watch me get 5,000 dislikes and fall off super hard
CHAT WITH ME + My Socials:
Discord server: / discord
Discord: melanryo
Twitter: melanryo
The music used in this video is not owned by me, if there is any issue regarding it then please contact me.

[@Melanryo]

I'm not saying the game is bad, just putting out concerns that I would think would be nice to have resolved! Don't get mad at me lol.

[@OllieOConnor]

@Melanryo

[@Melanryo]

@@OllieOConnor @Melanryo

[@RSanes-12.5]

@Melanryo chain?

[@RSanes-12.5]

​@@Melanryo@Melanryo chain?

[@evanneroslavsky9629]

OBJECTION hardcore has runners kill in half the time it does on the regular mode

[@worldyworld8]

Fair, and i especially agree with the endless one, its so bland that the only time you’d willingly go into an endless match is to get old guard.

[@Melanryo]

Nice, I agree with your sentiments ong

[@Ww2_lego-stopmotions]

i died to that zapper!!!

[@litecyborg3248]

But most times you dont get old guard like me

[@Ww2_lego-stopmotions]

@@litecyborg3248 dude the way I suffered

[@Ww2_lego-stopmotions]

@@litecyborg3248 wave 34 teammate did not help with 33 fifer letted me die wave 40 zapper

[@superkingnoob118]

Zappers hitting you from miles away Devs:seems fair

[@Melanryo]

Not their fault tbh, :sob:

[@Pixelon193]

It depends on your ping lol.

[@ninjaepico2262]

@@Pixelon193it isnt, zapper hitbox has been trash for the past almost 2 months eversince the copen update.. THEY HIT U FROM A MILE AWAY EVEN IF U HAVE 80 PING

[@handlemyd-]

​​​ mfw zappers kill me even though I'm behind them

[@Amnionic]

@@ninjaepico2262 weirdly they act fine on 100+ping

[@FürPreußen]

Fezezen is keeping him in his basement. We must put an end to this.

[@Fezezen]

I don't necessarily disagree with what's brought up, like hardcore and endless being shallow (I didn't even want hardcore to be in the game, it was implemented by pulse). I am addressing the zombie grab detection issues with a system that simulates the network ownership system they used to have. I don't think the infantry having more weapons than the other classes is a flaw at all. Most of a team should be composed of infantry anyway. This video just kind of lacks substance. There's not really much of a discussion here. You bring up a supposed flaw, say why you have a problem with it, and then move on without much thought put into how significant it is, or how it could be addressed. I know it's unreasonable to expect a fully detailed idea or implementation because you aren't the developers. Just something a bit more would have gone further. I hope you read this in the tone I intended, I'm not attempting to be mean. It's perfectly fine to bring up flaws, nothing would get fixed if I close my eyes and ignore them.

[@Melanryo]

I was quite late on schedule, so I couldn't include everything I wanted and frankly I was under the impression no-one would watch a twenty minute video so I didn't go into detail. In terms of line infantry, I did re-address it in my discord server. There were multiple issues I fleshed out there and I'm not sure if I can re-hash it properly here. I just believe that other classes should feel like they have options. Line Infantry is currently the only one that feels like it does and maybe the Musician. Options does not necessarily mean weapons. This especially ties into the fact that Priest and Surgeon lack any options at all. And at the same time I talked about the problem of Line Infantry being able to fill quite a bit of roles that other classes can with their variety and uniqueness of weapons. The Carbine and Pistol are too similar and both usually play the role of firing at bombers. So some people could go line infantry instead of officer especially if they want another melee like the heavy sabre. To re-iterate, officer and seaman really do not have options because it's either one or the other and you stick with that most of the time. I don't intend harm with this video or comment. I brought them up and talked about what I knew without trying to go into areas I do not know. It would be disastrous to talk about something I know absolutely nothing about, getting it wrong, and embarrassing myself over it. So that's I guess the second reason why I didn't talk more about possible fixes. I see Guts and Blackpowder as an innovative and unique game and I think the devs could try to innovate again to fix these.

[@Melanryo]

I'm also sharing the sentiment of most people when I talk about these issues because some of these don't affect me as much as they affect other people. Like people in public servers generally do not like endless and that's because it gets boring quickly for most people. I share this feeling so it's up at the front. The issue with the biggest gap between me and the regular person is replayability and the hit registration and that's why they are further back. I've only had trouble with hit registration rarely and I can play the game a lot because I love the game. But for more people I've heard about their issues and it affects quite a bit of people.

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

Nice. Also, theres a bug where if a runner tackles you gets killed via bomber you just stand still and cant move until you get grabbed or die. Pretty annoying

[@Stranger1616.mp4]

Nothing to do with the topic but please make Berezina more worthwhile, the francs it gives are not enough for all the pain you have to go through, Berezina is cool but there's a lot of problems with it too

[@Fezezen]

@@Stranger1616.mp4 The francs you earn is directly based on your contribution to the bridge.

[@indra3046]

Yeah fez is definitely keeping melan in his basement after this video. Rip watermelon 1969-2024

[@Melanryo]

It's so over

[@indra3046]

@@Melanryo it's joever

[@sethivaltas619]

Pretty accurate list of problems here. Although I'd say that the game has much less of a replayability problem than you said, if it stopped being fun after you got to know all the objective and endless maps it would've never taken off in the first place. The game is deeper than the maps, and gets variety through not only the maps, but also which class you play, what weapon you use on that class, the people in your team, the class-composition of your team, the different placement of crucifix uses, charges, and where barricades are placed. The gameplay loop is very much replayable already, but some more variety would be nice I think we can all agree yapping joever

[@Melanryo]

I said that the replayability problem really is very subjective. For most people it definitely exists while for me it's almost non-existent currently.

[@Ryujji64]

everything has its problems and thats fine

[@Melanryo]

I'm aware, I want to see how this video will perform and if I'll get a rage of G&B fans even though I equally love the game :cry:

[@skinskinner]

btw, having locked doors would basically remove the point of sapper, since their actual use was to break down doors, famously seen in the defence of hougomont

[@superkingnoob118]

I'm pretty sure adding bosses every 10 waves would make endless fun

[@French_LineInfantry]

Agreed Wave 10 should be the scrapped tank zombie And wave 20 is other zombie bosses

[@sunburnteggandstuff]

That would be amazing

[@thatonecat7925]

@@French_LineInfantrythey should make it to where the scrapped brute spawns on wave 25 and over seeing as the igniter spawns on wave 20 and over

[@Braian9887]

NOPOOOO9

[@meyæ-n8p]

Its a bit of an overused concept but it is a good idea. Just a little creativity is needed which the devs clearly have plenty of.

[@nguyenduy45123]

1:51 BRITISH MAN CAMEO 🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Melanryo]

🗣🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Tixerduxerfilms]

Rome wasnt built in a day

[@Melanryo]

I never said it was, I mentioned that it wasn't and that the game is new

[@Dinkleman25]

You are NOT Aristotle, Socrates, or Plato lil bro☠️

[@officia111y]

Who let this kid in here

[@SweeTeasGarbageDump]

i could build rome in a day #POSITIVITYMAXXING #POSITIVITYCORE

[@Tixerduxerfilms]

Man i wish my KZbin could grow that quick

[@NySx_lol]

Shoutout to the 5 ppl playing hardcore rn

[@Melanryo]

I play it sometimes lmao

[@krispt8835]

I only play hardcore as I am a sigma lone wolf alpha male and it is only for true gb players not regular server, mobile player-brain slop. Never make this joke again you fool.

[@wolfmoonens3378]

I actually quite like hardcore

[@shuelee9040]

It cool

[@LietunantGreek]

I do. I can't stand 7 infantry in regular

[@engineergaming8272]

2:02 they seriously need to change the hardcore requirements like have atleast 50 hours of playtime and have dur a cuire and like 3 objective map related badge most of the sever i join have like 10 brain damaged dude who doesnt even know what to do

[@karbrecher8251]

We have ideas for hardcore and want to re-haul it sometime, Endless has been neglected in favor of objective, something like an endless revamp isn't out of the question but we genuinely don't know what we'd do with it. Objective is the real meat and potatoes of GB and endless is kind of just slapped on, we tried experimenting with it and ended up with Berezina which arguably a failure. The class balancing is unintentional and we're trying to address it The horrific latency has been addressed in a dev version of the game, it was supposed to be published as a patch, but we just decided on shipping it this update. Some upcoming maps in the future should have systems similar to L4D2 & NMRIH random map generation. IE the map will alternate paths each round. This isn't going to magically solve the replay-ability problem, but it should be a step in the right direction good vid 👍

[@Melanryo]

That sounds amazing, I too mentioned that revamping endless genuinely I have no idea how you could pull it off to make it immersive while also fun at the same time. I'm happy that y'all are thinking of this. Guts and Blackpowder is a very good game after all and I want to see it even better cuz I play it so often :sob:

[@KameradenReal]

Teams, teams are the problems, roll credits

[@Melanryo]

The game is a team game, you cannot say the game is wrong for people sucking

[@BrazilianHere777]

comments guys when the wifi doesn't work straight and die to a zapper 2 studs away:

[@burpy3045]

Yeah most of the community has stated these issues, but some have to remember that its a small team that’s been working on this, and sureee it takes time to get updates but it’s all worth it in the end, and also the reason there hasn’t been any bug fixes cuz of the Roblox engine causing setbacks. (Which is why that runner glitch is happening) but overall great video

[@Melanryo]

I did explain that the game is new and all so they most likely didn't have that much time to fix all those.

[@burpy3045]

Yeah thats true (PLEASE GIVE CHAPLIN A NEW WEAPON)

[@Dinkleman25]

@@burpy3045chaplains getting a new item either this or the next update

[@MrNonExist_HZT]

​@@burpy3045actually chaplain is just an support class and also I don't think chaplains going to use a FREAKING SWORD OR SMTH cuz they believed in Christianity and they don't just randomly kill

[@sponandspon92]

@@MrNonExist_HZT Battle Priests can still be a thing, zealous Warriors of God to rid of the evil!

[@DEVY69420]

fair enough,endless only purpose is old guard,after u got it,it just doesnt feel the same at all,and of course THEY HAVE TO F###### FIX THE HITBOX,HOW A ZAPPER HITTING ME 2 FEET AWAY

[@nursestoyland]

Fr, a zapper can hit when i attempt to juke it

[@engineergaming8272]

zapper will always slide forward when they hit which increase their range...

[@thetester1158]

Me stepping backwards one stud:

[@gattungen-ng8go]

because the devs changed the system of the game or something because they were paranoid of an exploit that allows hackers to control zombies and ruin the game. i would honestly rather deal with that rather than getting grabbed by a zombie from continents away

[@mathanychawngthu9528]

zaps installing aimbot to prevent that one guy in wave 24 from getting old guard:

[@ObviousyNoob]

They could add multiple paths for objective maps so it’s not only one way (such as the ability to save an npc, a new type of objective like protecting an npc, any multiple outcome objective map where maybe you have a harder version of the map when you choose to do something differently)

[@MrNonExist_HZT]

About that..........choosing differently on the map part which makes it harder and there is one problem: the lore...... Nah man I am just kidding they could at least make it non-canon or event or smth *s* word

[@Stooltoad5017]

That is a lot of easier said than done. Forcing the developers to redo all of the existing maps plus adding more Development time to new maps would probably be more complicated than it is worth.

[@engineergaming8272]

@@ObviousyNoob they said they aint gonna allow player to save the npc because fate is fate about the different path then nah i dont want to see the entire sever fighting about which path they gonna go

[@superkingnoob118]

I love how runners could chew through armour, totally makes sense!

[@justuraverageplayer_]

The zappers hitting you far away is a internet issue, and runner rip out yo neck ( no armor on neck )

[@gattungen-ng8go]

@justuraverageplayer_ zappers hitting you from far away isn't an internet issue, either you didn't watch the video or your just meat riding the devs

[@vivelespatat2670]

​@@gattungen-ng8goZappers hitting from Narnia IS a ping issue. Your position on YOUR side is different to what the server think your position is on its side. The higher your ping, the more noticeable the difference is. This isn't only limited to Zappers swing too, Shamblers grabs and Runners tackles range are heavily influenced by it. The Bayonet is also affected by high latency, as its the only melee weapon in the game (at the time of writing this comment) to have its hitbox be server-sided instead of client-sided. Not much solutions here other than getting a better wifi/better regions.

[@Notajojoweeb98]

No the sapper armour doesnt have any neck protection so it makes sense that runners can kill you while armored

[@superkingnoob118]

@Notajojoweeb98 Some runners don't have the common sense to chew through the unprotected part

[@GermanSanitater]

I think I know why they're making the cuirassier zombie rn HARDCORE

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

Im sad it's basically scrapped, same with tank because it has a SICK design.

[@engineergaming8272]

they said they are just throwing the idea around so dont have high expectation

[@Cherno_Lad]

honestly the only issue I have with this game is people ringing bells and turning on light houses when the server doesnt want them too, and teammates being shit

[@brentlanzo4667]

They should try making hardcore more realistic instead of hard. That way, casuals can see the new features and maybe even get some new pros

[@superkingnoob118]

Lack of tutorial. Players need of a guide. They're braindead if they don't get teached

[@GermanSanitater]

That's present in most underrated good games tbh they dont give you a path to follow and encourage exploration and figuring things out urself also you can always watch a guide so it isn't needed

[@floriangeyer8646]

@@GermanSanitater the average 9 years old isn't capable of doing so

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

@@floriangeyer8646 Well this is just me, but if someones using their musket literally all the time I think they’re cooked at that point unless theres some sorta popup that tells you to not use your musket too much

[@Rfdp0]

Spoon feeding info is stupid I've seen players that are young that know how to do stuff because they learned from either looking up tutorials or trial and error.

[@superkingnoob118]

@Rfdp0 heh, and I feel like people would skip the tutorial (I AM NOT TALKING ABOUT THAT MINECRAFT KZbinR)

[@wolfiethe2nd]

0:42 erm actually it's 3 years 🤓☝

[@itsyaboidj2297]

I think a way they could improve hardcore is sometime like a miniboss kinda like something to fight as the horde tries to distract you but idk what do you guys think

[@playernotfound9489]

biggest flaw imo: sometimes your teammates suck

[@Kylofunplayz567]

i mean, he aint wrong in the class imbalance

[@user-is7et4gc5x]

I think hardcore could introduce a few new zombies ngl It would make it unique

[@realhaterofbacon]

i feel like the weapon variety problem is less of a game design problem and more of a time-accurate problem having the line infantry be granted the most customization makes sense since there was a bunch of infantry types during the 1800’s. we’ll probably reach a point where newer weapons simply cannot be made because either they were not used by any nations during the wars or they did not exist during the time period everything else i understand tho

[@Melanryo]

That is true and I referred more to item choice ngl

[@mapleflag6518]

When they can easily justify older weapons being present by saying that things are desperate and the nations are using everything at their disposal to try and hold back the horde.

[@Stooltoad5017]

Ehh I mean, were pickaxes used by napoleonic era soldiers? I think the devs can get creative if they are running out of options.

[@pakanankhadat]

zombie runner and zapper: grabbed player from 2 studs away, runner tackled player 2 studs while the player is already stabbing them, zapper hit player from 2-3 studs away Dev: this is fair

[@thunderspark1536]

Also the Devs: we have to do this to stop hackers

[@pakanankhadat]

@@thunderspark1536 I didn't hack also, it still manged grab me / tackled me in 2 studs, I have like 50-60 ping...

[@thunderspark1536]

@@pakanankhadat I didn't say you did, I said the reason they changed it to server-side, which causes the issue, is due to hackers using the old client-side system to hack from their end.

[@pakanankhadat]

@@thunderspark1536 oh, okay.

[@LandwehrRegimentvonSchlesien]

WE GETTING 70,000 DISLIKES AND LOSING ALL SUBSCRIBERS WITH THIS ONE🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯

[@Melanryo]

FOR REAL 🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥💯💯💯💯

[@superkingnoob118]

Add new zombies ONLY IN HARCORE should fix it

[@Veridiania]

why did they add a build limit in the test zone map😭🙏

[@Fatto597]

The reason why I stopped playing it is because every time I get grabbed my whole team gathers around me to watch me die

[@Vorkosis]

I once joined a friend who was playing endless and I got through an entire 5 waves starting from wave 37 before I realised we were on hardcore and not normal

[@pizzareno0910]

G&B has even around waymore than 1 year, they just had to move the game recently which us why it seems so young

[@Melanryo]

AH, I had no idea.

[@MrNonExist_HZT]

​@@Melanryowell is developed on August 2021 (I think I am correct) and it was just an template however on 2022 they just added muskets as a joke and then a month later they started development on Guts and Blackpowder and boom it was released in idk which month at 2022 and then they moved to their game to another game and they added first objective map (probably on the older game one) and idk else

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

@MrNonExist_HZT Yes, the map Hogoumont was made in mid 2021 starting the development.

[@gammaarmy9547]

Issues I have with the game: The bomber mechanics and the zapper hitbox area. Bombers do not explode while in fire but explode when they enter water or either the bomber gets sliced... The hitbox on the bomber is so flawed that shooting the barrel wouldn't ignite it, only when you hit the actual zombie..... Another problem I have is how big the zapper hitbox is, even if the axe doesn't touch you, it still counts as a hit if you aren't a mile away. If they really wanted to make the game so depressing, they could make the axe bigger so it looks more realistic. Not to mention that zombies legs don't break, but I don't really seem to care as much

[@reing304]

It'd be cool if they replaced endless with survival mode, 35 rounds, have a boss fight in round 20 and 35, and then you can get old guard by surviving till the end.

[@Melanryo]

I don't think it should be replaced, rather that endless gets some things that remove its staleness

[@Vikirine]

Nobody plays hardcore for francs I got more francs in regular mode (like good teams)

[@Melanryo]

It's too big of a risk dying tbh and it's not as fun because zombies take like fifteen billion hits.

[@DustEatingMan]

Nah, I'd survive

[@KJ_BG]

I play it to escape mobile servers 🙂

[@ivanivanov-lu6wv]

Alas, I have heard that there will be no weapons for the priest

[@engineergaming8272]

NO shop item will replace the chaplain stake to retain them as a support class surely he will get more holy and teaching item

[@Rfdp0]

They should really make it so water bucket can stop the fuse on the bombers barrel and they just become a normal shambler.

[@user-whatareyoudoing]

That would break the ENTIRE game

[@Rfdp0]

@@user-whatareyoudoing how?

[@evansyiem3433]

@@user-whatareyoudoing They be bombaclattng my fortress that took time to build, also it would be cool if they dropped their barrel far away if you used water bucket and stayed there and we could shoot it ( the problem is lag because of the many barrels )

[@I_also_needed_a_name_so]

pretty sure I once heard that somewhere in the future in hardcore mode if you wake up to a bomber and run away it will throw the bomb at you

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

Replayability stuff: This isn’t much, but for a temporary fix til they can prepare the map better for alternative routes they could do something similar to what a Left 4 Dead addon did, that being having some different props appear randomly on maps each time you play, or having some sort of fence being a minor obstacle Though Im really aware this is just a bandaid fix, though tbh thats sorta the point, although Im honestly not sure if this is even worth the time to code in for the devs just for a temporary fix until they can sort of rework the maps. Priest stuff: Tbh I don’t really see what you can even add to a class that temporarily stuns most of the zombies for a while while trying to not make it overpowered, along with that im not sure about the willingness of a dude whose grinded they asses off to get a class just to find out that they gotta pay for more weapons, but that doesn’t say to stop the developers from trying to cook up new ideas, hell I think they’d surprise me 👍

[@Neobrim]

biggest problem is they havent added cuirassier yet tee hee

[@Melanryo]

To be honest, not at all

[@LietunantGreek]

I wanted to replay after 4 months, and it didn't felt like fun more like forced. Same maps,teammates have become worse and can't literally finish a map. I tried hardcore,felt originally that teammates are the same as the old ones but sappers are again low. I have started to not even want to touch it again

[@BradenMcnair-gx1ls]

Guts and Blackpowder isn’t on V1 so problems are expected

[@Melanryo]

Fair

[@weibozhang5356]

endless is endless waves, it kinda makes sense

[@Melanryo]

yeah but even then, I don't want it to be boring

[@rittyrizzani5705]

1:41 That's not the only thing we can defend with, Runners kill you in around 2 or 3 seconds which is crazy considering the average teammate of guts and blackpowder.

[@Mamafacker]

Endless could be really cool is adding mini bosses Every 10 waves theres like a mini boss and there are like lets say 9 mini bosses And a main boss at wave 100, and after wave 100 is just a spam of wave 10 and 20 mini bosses This would make old guard harder but it makes endless more entertaining

[@greenedleaf2481]

Imagine spawning in discipline zombie soldiers

[@KristianDenev]

Theres gonna be two weapons for seaman class so the class imbalance will be more uh balanced

[@Melanryo]

I did say that

[@KristianDenev]

Sorry I didn't watch the entire video lol

[@gattungen-ng8go]

the navyman hasn't gotten a new weapon in 10 months, and 10 months ago was when the shop was released, nice to see they are finally adding some new ones

[@Rfdp0]

​@@gattungen-ng8go axe 2.0 and pistol 2.0

[@wolfiethe2nd]

This is good! I think that every once in a while in normal modes there could be a chance for a special round! like the VIP or Kentucky ones, maybe they can add it every 5 to 10 games. For me it's repayable because I play in vc servers, people make it more fun! oh, and I also play in small vc servers to, so the game is harder and there actually needs to be teamwork.

[@engineergaming8272]

oh yeah here another issue i point out for mobile they lack features like reloading 1 barrel on double barrel weapon,cancel heal or bless,being able to open inventory,direction lock etc i have absolutely no problem with the inaccessible inventory or reload 1 barrel on double barrel weapon but no cancel button for bless or heal is just flat out dumb pc player can hit space to cancel bless or heal to instantly escape while mobile can do nothing while a bomber is coming toward

[@yrovas9277]

Are mobile players unable to jump to cancel bless and heal?

[@engineergaming8272]

@@yrovas9277 no it doesnt work i always try it and it never work

[@handlemyd-]

Direction lock?

[@engineergaming8272]

@@handlemyd- not even include basically what direction lock mean is you choose a attack direction for a weapon and "lock" the next time you equip the weapon it will be lock on the direction that you choose while mobile can only switch direction and not lock it making some headshot rely weapon quite difficult to use since you have to change direction everytime to equip it again like the pickaxe

[@yrovas9277]

@@engineergaming8272 Yeah I hope they fix it in the future, mobile players deserve to play as good as console and pc.

[@parzma4284]

one thing i wished g&b had for replayability was letting you make custom maps in private servers OR custom maps in a "custom map" public server

[@ex0spher_e]

Really hard to implement

[@triviacat3288]

Nah, i have 414 hours and i play guts & blackpowder 1-2 hours a day. I started playing before the halloween event.

[@Melanryo]

Maybe watch the video.

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

"Eat sleep guts and blackpowder repeat" ahh

[@GAMERUITIMAZILLA]

They can fix the cps on the hand axe 💀

[@Melanryo]

Don't think it's too much of a problem, I don't really use the hand axe lol.

[@AKACoach36]

6:20 this slowly ruined my kiting skills lmao

[@Rarequaime]

Duo kaub hardcore with me also with delicious leg.

[@goodboi1725]

On the subject of hardcore, I do hope they keep the increased health for zombies intact when the revamp is implemented, since it is pretty interesting how strategies can change just because it takes more hits to kill zombies. Still wish the bayonet kept its one shot capability past the early objectives of maps tho. Definitely agree with the lack of loadout variety outside of line infantry. On another note, I can’t help but feel the musician class needs a rework, because as helpful as they are, they are completely mindless to play outside of the bugle subclass (BEST instrument hands down). Maybe they could be given their own bars that gives a stronger boost when filled? Like they take way longer to build compared to the other charges, but the boost lasts all the way through a song. The client and server side hit registration is incredibly frustrating. It messes up the already funky hitbox of the bayonet, and makes runners just horrible to play around when you’re alone. Overall, the video’s solid, now I just hope several months from now that the other classes get just as much versatility as line infantry.

[@sash-a_drawing]

i do agree, stuff can feel a little stale, glad hardcore is being revamped cause it's one of my face classes cause preist gets used more often

[@lacktheguy]

0:41 3 years* for g&b

[@Frenchofficerlsoldbat]

8:22 I think if you add in achievements including hidden achievements I find the game very repayable, I also find it fun to try to get these achievements, even if they don't give anything. So yeah I'm one of those people who don't see it as a problem, plus the random stuff that can happen on normal G&B like objective and endless can still add in some replicability. Plus I love hopping onto the G&B discord and play with the people in the channel. Once person I meant larp as a French infantry soldier and we larped along with me being an officer, we beat cata combs with using line infantry tactics and had a great time playing on the house endless map where we kept larping.

[@marklolchanov]

"Я бы хотел что бы улучшили музыкантов и священников. Например можно добавить к музыкантам трубы для дополнение к песне и книжку для пения. У священника можно оружие добавить. Например посох. А то в обновлениях только оружиях. Просто за 270 часов уже надоели флейта да барабан." *translate* "I would like the musicians and priests to improve. For example, you can add trumpets to the musicians to complement the song and a book for singing. You can add weapons to the priest. For example, a staff. And then in updates only weapons. It’s just that after 270 hours I got tired of the flute and the drum.”

[@ImDumb69420]

I worked for fez, he is a fraud

[@Melanryo]

THIS WAS SO GOOD BUT I CAN'T PIN IT...

[@ImDumb69420]

​@@Melanryo awie

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

“The DOWNFALL of Guts and Blackpowder…”

[@SweeTeasGarbageDump]

“Its over for Mr. Fez..”

[@gaychinloong462]

Army bots gonna get added into the game!!!

[@Pelakure]

I heard console players who opened servers can't even use commands because they couldn't chat,

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

Hell we don’t even have the ability to go to a vip server cause of roblox’s ridiculous UI.

[@Rfdp0]

I hate not being able to go in vip servers so I can't do the two other secret badges.

[@preston_1087]

i think line infantry should have a fair amount more stuff than other classes but it's becoming a lot now

[@user-wl5bp3jj6g]

I don't know if it just didn't get it, accidentally skipped it, or forgotthere was one, but the game doesn't seem to have a tutorial either. A tutorial would be nice for newer players, as it can help them navigate the menus, teach them how and what they can do with their weapons, etc. Idk tho maybe there was one and i just missed it lol.

[@user-oi7ow2dv9v]

What if in hardcore everyone will only be able to play in first person and the zombies are slightly faster?

[@this.isabucket]

First thing i have to say... the players are idiots, you could be tackled by a runner infront of someone and they'll turn a blind eye

[@preston_1087]

it would be cool if bomber timers were like half a second in hardcore

[@sunburnteggandstuff]

I hate how the igniter can completely lag my pc

[@Melanryo]

rip pc

[@gattungen-ng8go]

i think it's because all the fire particles are their own independent models instead of being all welded together that makes it so laggy

[@Anglerfishyfishy]

sappers make this game far too easy

[@ryleeculla5570]

Of course their are problems no game is perfect what did they expect

[@Melanryo]

I just shed some light on them, to people who want to see the game be better

[@user-el3gu5sw2u]

omg finally a video that doesnt glaze g&b insanely hard

[@Melanryo]

lol

[@ManicObsevations]

I understand that server side is better for gameplay integrity, but my router is horrendous. I legit can't play anymore.

[@PersonOfEarth117]

tbh I'm usually against like heavy tutorials for games that baby you but G&B literally has no explanation of anything in the game, not even one, making it so that inexperienced players can kill runs by no fault of their own just the fact that they are new and the game explains literally nothing, which can be incredibly frustrating for other players.

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

To me I think that its pretty much self explanatory: Zombies: -If you’re too reliant on your musket you’ll quickly learn to not be so reliant on it due to its overly long reload. -Teammates saving you from grabs can help you learn to start using your melees more often when you need to or to take a step back and learn what you did wrong. -Bombers, well no offense but I mean they’re holding a torch with a barrel, it’d be almost clear to not hit them with a melee, though it’d teach you whenevers right to use your primary. -For Zappers, this isn’t a major concern but honestly you just need to learn from experience the hard way. -Given that igniters appear so often but so far and few I honestly thought it was a teammate using some weird grenade When I was first playing most of this just seemed pretty self explanatory, though I feel like for the average 9 year old playing I feel like they’re done for either way

[@PersonOfEarth117]

@@SomeGrunt_On_KZbin i guess but given it's a team based game SOME explanation would go a long way. As it is right now it's a team based game where half of your team or more is guaranteed to be useless because most people assume that gun = primary like 99.9% of other games like this, they don't know the zombie types leading to common barrel deaths, and well, they simply expect to steamroll gazillions of zombies like it's zombie attack or smth. Though I guess it's a positive in that it's more of a challenge it would be too easy otherwise, since most of the maps are easy if you have a team that can work together, this is why Berezina is almost always a loss

[@gattungen-ng8go]

@SomeGrunt_On_KZbin barrels shouldn't even explode when you stab them, sabres aren't things that light gunpowder on fire

[@SomeGrunt_On_Youtube]

@@gattungen-ng8go To be fair though by that point it’d almost make the boomer redundant if they couldn’t be set off by sabres, pretty sure if the fez knew they’d include it in the inaccuracies wiki page.

[@sebastianparedes2281]

before i get mad? the thing im mad about is no CROUCHINGGGGGG

[@ex0spher_e]

Which purpose would that serve

[@Docteur_Hex]

​@@ex0spher_emoar accurate

[@sebastianparedes2281]

@@ex0spher_e shooting in smaller locations entering in smaller locations obv

[@evansyiem3433]

@@ex0spher_e "Are you fuckin stupid Mate?" said Barry Williams

[@Stooltoad5017]

The maps aren’t designed with that in mined. Taking crotch shots isn’t all that useful against the zombies either.

[@gattungen-ng8go]

they should make a smaller side team that works on smaller content for the game, such as a new regiment or a new weapon. these would only take like a few weeks and would be nice additions while we wait for the main update to come out

[@hmm2364]

Tbh, the reason I play endless is to kill zombies and maybe clutch for your team

[@WolfieBiz11]

Another flaw I noticed in G&B is the callouts, or sometimes all of the voice lines. The voice acting is horrible. If you play games outside of Roblox like Battlefield 1, the voice acting fits the atmosphere. Something was just off with the voice acting. Maybe they keep screaming despite not being in danger at all. And sometimes, it's awkward when you're in a certain situation, for example, if you're injured(Let's say, yellow health) call the medic, and your character will be like "I'M INJURED" as if your character will die in any second. Also, why is Sweden speaking English in the game? I mean Portuguese soldiers speaking English makes sense because they're allies. But Sweden??? In conclusion, voice lines in G&B are weird because they feel exaggerated, redundant, and awkward.

[@skeletor-1892]

I agree but they can't find good voice actors for Swedes and Portuguese troops

[@Stooltoad5017]

I don’t see why we should hold this relatively small Roblox to the same league as battlefield. Frankly it is impressive as is that the developers went out of their way to find voice actors for all of the various languages that the soldiers speak in their native tongue. I also want to point that, if the voice is softer when they actually on the brink of death, than it would be more awkward. Besides, just because they are in yellow health doesn’t mean they aren’t going through a lot of pain. The devs aren’t made of money and I imagine they are doing with what they have. The developers can’t just go look around online and expect they can afford to pay the same amount as a larger studio can.

[@randomhttyddev9245]

Adding the scrapped zombies to endless would unironically make endless more fun

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

I see them being bosses fr

[@Rfdp0]

I heard they're gonna add crawlers and maybe other removed zombies.

[@engineergaming8272]

​@@Rfdp0the other zombie is considered scrapped zombie due to how generic and bland they are

[@quacktree]

Hardcore is not too bland. Plays entirely differently from regular. There is no way that “endless is stale” is a valid point. While special events could being charm to particular maps, g&b endless is basically the game at its purest. Classes are hardly unbalanced, sure priest sucks ass. It really does. But all the core 5 are exceptionally useful. More accurately, specific weapons maybe slightly too strong or weak. Sappers arent a crucial class at all, it just makes up for how awful the majority of the playerbase (on objective particularly) is. Server sided zombies do suck, and i highly dislike them, but as i’ve played this update i just kinda go “oh okay” when stupid shit happens. It’s pretty bad with runners and zappers. Glad it’s being fixed. Walking around with a runner on you is generally a ping issue on your side. It’s happened to me.. once, in 1,200 hours. The private server complaints are honestly quite… stupid. It’s to give you choices and variety, like choosing a map. Not playijg most of the time on it. I’ll revise this comment later

[@Cutepanda1943]

Endless is stake is a valid point. Endless generally gets boring fast because it is just constantly defending against waves of zombies. And sappers are a crucial class because you can’t just magically make your entire team good and if you are playing in hardcore where their are good players you need one because the zombies are a lot more dangerous. Unless you’re a soloer and your Tactic is just running around in circles so zombies can’t grab you.

[@huzzahh_81727]

A simple a fix to g&b being stale is updates its that simple The more g&b updates the more and more replayability it gets and it will eventually reach the point where there's endless replay ability

[@gattungen-ng8go]

endless is staler than year old bread idk what your trying to say

[@huzzahh_81727]

@@gattungen-ng8go update makes the game and endless mode less stale plus we're getting a new crucifix for the priest next update aswell as other weapons and revamp map

[@Melanryo]

quacktree it's funny that I knew you were gonna comment about endless and I wanted to say that in the video :sob: but great opinion, you have like 1,200 hours and I can get that the game is really enjoyable for you. i suppose endless is that way to some people and it's not a bad thing, but a majority of people think it's kind of stale since they just play objective

[@Dontknownameman]

I just want MORE

[@Decent_edits753]

Now I’m starting to think G&B should add custom map for player to make like piggy for player to play in

[@TotallyNotSnowy.]

They gonna recreate the worst events known to a man

[@LuizHenrique-zw5su]

My hard, is core

[@greggersonny]

i think if endless maps had mini objectives they could get more depth and replayability

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

Under absolutely ZERO circumstances will I be doing 999 mini objectives.

[@greggersonny]

@@TheRetroestRobloxian well i think the point of it would be to spice up every few waves and to spread forces thinner so everyone isn’t allowed to just sit in some corner of the map with a staircase or ladder forever. you wouldn’t be doing a mini objective every wave, your team would do a variety of mini objectives every 2 - 4 waves to give waves more depth and feel more like survival rather than parking crappy part of detroit (oh wait..)

[@kaidenxavier3062]

honestly line infantry is just a bias city rn

[@NOOBNOOB-t3m]

btw most hardcore is supposed to be like zombie high hp, does more damage(well if u don't agree, uhh i mean l4d+l4d2 does that and no disagrees idk)

[@Dogeater573]

For endless I think there should be mini bosses

[@junichiandrade6658]

It would be good that instead of taking out updates every 3 damn months they will take a small smart update with new weapons, that would be great, new weapons every 1 month or less and weapons with new mechanics, instead of taking 1 new map, 3 new weapons every 3 months, that is very horrible.

[@NOOBNOOB-t3m]

they should give other class more item😭😭

[@cannibalhordegrmonme]

this is fine

[@Btjumpsc123aresim2]

Guys don't hate on this game just because he is speaking about the flaws of the game

[@Melanryo]

True, don't hate on me either!

[@arandomuserb1]

I hate you!!!! /j ​@@Melanryo

[@certified_u]

It's pretty sad how I can't get old guard when I'm 7/8 on mobile.

[@TheRetroestRobloxian]

You got this man. Trust me. It only took me 80 hours, seriously.

[@GardeRegimentZuFubOfficerKaub]

In my opinion, guts and Blackpowder should focus more on renovating current zombies than adding many more different zombies, better to create a solid base than make a fragile skeleton. They could make zombies with uniforms spawn less but they have different abilities, such as a grenadier maybe advancing quicker or a light infantry zombie being able to try to dodge a bullet by moving away when a gun is fired.

[@Melanryo]

That's a good opinion, that's kind of what I said about hardcore and I didn't say to add many more different types

[@thatonecat7925]

The dodge option would kinda makes since for infected soldiers seeing as the zapper retained the ability to hold its axe

[@gattungen-ng8go]

how the fuck would you dodge a musket ball going 681 mph

[@Rfdp0]

Soooo dodging zombies like from call of duty?

[@engineergaming8272]

@@thatonecat7925 they are smart enough to use their axe somehow for the normal shambler some of then should hold weapon like small knife or anything that lodged on them and use it to their advantage if the thing lodged onto them is a spear then that spear can be thrown to deal massive damage while sapper armor will ignore the thing

[@Baron._]

This problem is VERY prominent with the few people who are dedicated enough to become exceptional at gb, thank you for addressing the problem with this video, i hope the upcoming 👻 ghoul 👻 system works

[@Melanryo]

Thanks for the nice comment man

[@Baron._]

@@Melanryo dont let the haters hate men!!! I'll let you in on a little secret: (we're the community that set the endless wrs and did the 1-4 player runs) though i just stick to endless

[@mrFIame]

@@Baron._ no such community exists, you're just lying 🤫

[@Baron._]

oh no bro they caught me

[@Melanryo]

@@mrFIame LOL

[@angrybirdsmuseum7241]

So you appear to have ignored the mobile server issue, you may not know this but mobile servers are usually memed on for only having bad players and people seem to actively bully mobile players for simply not having a computer that actually runs well or anything of the sort. It’s to the point where it’s basically become a sort of slur when talking about players who are new or just suck at the game. If you look on KZbin there isn’t a video (at least to my knowledge) trying to help mobile players, no tutorials, no guides, no nothing. The only thing you’ll find is borderline discriminatory content targeted at mobile players. This may discourage people with phones or tablets not to play at all because of the lack of passion or even the most basic levels of respect needed to fit in. It’s to the point where my goal in game is to help mobile servers with winning games (not like I have much else to do considering I’ve 100%ed the game) along with being more considerate with there feelings. The one upside to these servers are that people won’t get mad about you not being able to save them for getting pinned by a runner while dozens of zombies are in the way. There a lot more understanding probably because they really only got each other. My solutions for this is to combine the pc and mobile servers to shut people up about mobile players being bad. Or adding a full on tutorial to actually help new players.

[@Melanryo]

It didn't come up to mind, I didn't think of it, and I didn't think it would be that bad from what you have to say.

[@engineergaming8272]

@@angrybirdsmuseum7241 they also lack special features like reloading 1 bareel on double barrel weapon,direction lock for melee,cancel bless or heal,inaccessible inventory which limits the mobile to ONLY have usable item

[@Therapist_Baguette]

I forgot about hardcore...

[@Melanryo]

Makes the point even realer.

[@handlemyd-]

3 people playing it is so real