The Prom's Caitlin Kinnunen and Isabelle McCalla Test Their Friendship

Caitlin Kinnunen and Isabelle McCalla have been Broadway costars and onstage high school sweethearts since The Prom opened this past fall at the Longacre Theatre. They share a stage and a dressing room eight times a week - but in all that time together, how well have they really gotten to know each other? We decided to find out with a game we crafted just for the two of them.

[@tiredalex4422]

I think my favorite part of this is that Elliot Page actually went to see the show

[@RainbowQuartz2.0]

*Elliot page now.

[@tiredalex4422]

@@RainbowQuartz2.0 shit u right, literally forgot I had commented this

[@k.j.burnett1634]

@@tiredalex4422 this might be favorite comment ever! Beautiful ✨

[@killianjayden3949]

dont know if you guys gives a shit but if you guys are stoned like me during the covid times then you can stream all of the new movies on InstaFlixxer. Have been binge watching with my brother during the lockdown :)

[@huxleylian8853]

@Killian Jayden Definitely, I have been watching on instaflixxer for years myself :)

[@RE-ip5ze]

"OK babe, I'll bring ice cream to make up" perfect

[@rosalinekender4961]

i think this is the first time izzy has ever mentioned cats and not told the story of how she pet the actors

[@musicaltheatrefan4504]

Are they actually dating? They have so much chemistry omg

[@Jupiter-james]

The one dislike is Mrs. Greene

[@missraredoesstuff]

Jaylin Rae 😂Genius.

[@juliasings6131]

The other 4 are some of the other homophobic people in indiana

[@iLikePotato3s]

I knew Caitlin was a hufflepuff!

[@LB8864]

But for real, could we get them to sing "All I Ask of You" together?

[@capucine9791]

Caitlin is so obviously a Hufflepuff it’s so cute 😂

[@jesslyntania9237]

WHY ARE THEY SO CUTEEE?!?!!?!?!? *cries*

[@RomanyGypsy92]

Now I'm gonna have to go listen to "Moo." Also would love to hear them do a Phantom duet!

[@mollymagarian9759]

OMG I AM A HUFFLEPUFF THIS IS THE BEST THING THAT HAS EVER HAPPENED

[@grav3y_boat]

Molly Magarian Hufflepuff pride

[@ashtonsshoe7848]

2:05 Izzy got so stressed 😆

[@tl003]

So you also came back to these videos after watching the movie?

[@iLikePotato3s]

Lol these two are soo funny

[@booorue4876]

"Im a raven claw with gryffindor tendencies" :O im a Gryffindor with Ravenclaw tendencies. I. Wanna be Hufflepuff SO BAD but i need to be true to myself. Edit: Honestly now im more of a Ravenclaw ;-;

[@iLikePotato3s]

Same but EVERY time I take the test I get Gryffindor! I first took it when Pottermore came out and I took it again recently

[@grav3y_boat]

Anissa same

[@parkergreaves9975]

2:33 is everything

[@veganbeth]

I get the sense from their instagrams that they are dating in real life!

[@kayden1435]

They are goals XD I love them so much

[@SincerelySaskia]

Caitlin should watch “ The Umbrella Academy,” because Ellen Page is in it!

[@goldierichardson9378]

We love Elliot Page!!

[@Tyler_Mills26]

Oh wow I never realized Caitlin had super short hair I thought her curly bob in the play was her real hair xxx

[@cartooncentral263]

Same

[@madelinemobilia1987]

as much as i respect their friendship i really do hope they had some connection that was more then friendship during their broadway run.

[@iamnoob6900]

They're BFFs who Platonically make out Source - a joke Caitlin says during their Babes concert tour? 😅 So yeah I guess that's more than friends its Best Friend Forever

[@FranMSK]

I love them. I'm in love with them.

[@musicprincess9747]

Aww this is so cute and funny XD also yes Izzy's a Ravenclaw too! Same here!

[@booorue4876]

If i could take a celebrity to prom... Zendaya... Anna Kendrick...Whoever play Cheryl Blossom and Hether Chandler :) i dont need to explain. I think i have a type.

[@madisonphillips2431]

Invalid Opinion Cheryl Blossom is played by Madeleine Petsch!

[@StephenHopkinsRum]

I love them sm

[@cartooncentral263]

I love these two

[@carolineturner8915]

I saw this show. It was very good

[@WeepingWafflee]

I live for this

[@maggiejones8931]

Why does it seem like every actor is a Hufflepuff?!

[@ele208]

this is actually goals

[@sakurananami4478]

Are they actually dating?? They call eachother babe and it just, the chemistry I can’t And they’re both Bi and that’s tipping me off Also Isabelle singing me and my girlfriend’s (yes we gay) love song to eachother, and them being a ravenclaw and hufflepuff duo like me and her I just, come on

[@sakurananami4478]

Am I allowed to ask if they’re dating or if they dated? The chemistry here, they have the same energy of me and my girlfriend aaa

[@abby_bozung]

No, they aren't dating and haven't before. But I do see it!!

[@riverogue13]

How did they not know “Moo” it went viral in 2018 I-

[@ThePhanomas]

"I'm a Ravenclaw with Gryffindor tendencies" loved it

[@ainsleygibson9196]

I love them so much and I freaking knew Caitlin was a hufflepuff come on

[@s_vlog1013]

They both look exactly like the girls from the Netflix film 💜🤩🥳

[@xsweetiebloomx605]

You mean the ones from the film look exactly like them.

[@laurensimendinger8887]

I’m coming the 26th!

[@glowingskeletons]

How are they adults

[@signalred540]

yes Isabelle let’s be ravenclaws together :)

[@cbjgirl23]

LOOK ITS MY CHILDREN

[@larissacury7714]

😍😍😍

[@goofyscootsnrolls77]

1:35 well wait what ice cream flavor would your fav then.....hogwarts house is important but......I'm a hufflepuff too

[@madisonphillips2431]

1:33 Izzy called Caitlin “babe” are they actually dating! I’ll live in as so I can’t come see this!

[@amandalogan5023]

Madison Phillips nah haha no they’re not dating, they just call each other babe as a joke since they date in the show

[@syd7959]

Asking Alexandria They still call each other babe even after the show has ended lol. I love them.

[@MomentswithMolly]

I know Caitlin has admitted she's dating a girl since being in the show...is it actually Izzy??

[@statictv4451]

Moments with Molly I think Izzy is dating her costar in Aladdin, Clinton Patrick Greenspan. ☹️ I can’t help but ship Cait and Izzy too! 😭😭😭😭 They have so much chemistry together and they are super close IRL too!

[@statictv4451]

Madison Phillips They look sooooo cute together!! I feel bad that I actually want them to date 🤣😭

[@hellobye6364]

IMMA HUFFLEPUFF

[@dAfoodie808]

1:32

[@Sara-uq6km]

2:55 how did i somehow know she would answer that

[@rubyhunt7108]

i ship it???

[@calebross1794]

Elliott Paige for the WIN!

[@Sara-uq6km]

I want to be their friend : (

[@khalifazman394]

the amount of paper wasted in this video annoys me im sorry u couldve used a whiteboard hunny

[@docxen]

wait there is a secret garden musical?

[@phoenixblue-koszalka1518]

Yep!

[@olivergerber]

I have literally no idea about this Hogwarts house thing 🙈

[@vicomtexdaae3630]

But why is Phantom a 'guilty' pleasure? :(

[@vicomtexdaae3630]

Jeff. Lyn. lopez Ive defiantly heard he’s controversial but don’t know the story behind it all. What happened?

[@veganbeth]

Considered a bit cheesy compared to modern broadway!

[@vicomtexdaae3630]

@@veganbeth The prom is pretty cheesy.

[@xecillmaze4740]

@@vicomtexdaae3630 The prom's purposely campy. Phantom is different.

[@evelyne-h9090]

The one dislike is Dede Allan

[@SincerelySaskia]

Caitlin should watch “ The Umbrella Academy,” because Ellen Page is in it!