The Pulse - Govts Schools Vs Private Schools

...An often heard refrain in the indian society is why should we send our children to govt schools, we can afford and therefore why not a private school , what will the people say if my child goes to a government school becuase only the poor and underpriveleged , go to such schools. .. its exactly this mindset that we are going to talk about in todays show . According to the latest Annual status of education report the gap between private and government schools students’ learning ability has been widening and that almost 29 per cent of rural students choose to pay around Rs 100 to private schools to get education. so how can we bridge the inequality between private and govt schools, all this and much more on this week's episode of the Pulse
Anchor: NEELU vyas
Guests:
Sushil Chandra Tripathi, former Secretary Ministry of Human Resource & Development
Jyoti Gupta, Principal DPS Ghaziabad
Dheer Singh, Principal, Kendiriya Vidyalaya, Gole Market, New Delhi
Anita Rampal, Professor, Department of Education, Delhi University

[@karateking4269]

First of all I would like to thanks rstv jo aise issue ko tv pe laye..🙏 The primary education of Government school is not very good this day..It can be better when the teacher nd parents will be responsible about children...Parents bachhe ko vej rahe h ki nhi ya fir teacher bachhe ko padha rahe h ki nhi en par teacher aur parents dono ko care karna hoga

[@nsingh4251]

Right said , parents का सहयोग बहुतज़रूरी है

[@ishwarkumar303]

I'm from Hazaribag district of jharkhand. At first I would like to give lot's thanks to rstv from the bottom of my heart for this valuable debate. In my district here's also lot's of government's school merge together according to NITI commission programme due to this reason lot's rural children's they are not going to school and suffering from many problems. Here's teacher's also in strike since two months, but our State government they are not taking any initiative to improve the quality education. This is one of the worst government of jharkhand till now.

[@vikramaykar6439]

Hello friend I am from Maharashtra and the problem here is also same ... government schools and the teacher in the school are very careless... childrens are the future of our country and to educate them is our and gov first priority..... but the changes come when we first start it

[@THEDHL124]

Our National Media RSTV. Best program.

[@abhaybajpai1986]

Just do your duty, condition will automatic change.... Hit like if satisfied

[@bagibadal9562]

biggest problem is lack of no.of teachers in gov. schools

[@aspirant8996]

Apply the Allahabad High court judgement: Bureaucrats and government employees should mandatorily be sending their wards to government schools. The gap will finish.

[@zubairullakhan1909]

Instead of government spending money in building statues and masjid or mandir it has to spend in developing infrastructure of gorv school. I think no god will blame

[@Naveen-ut4ft]

100% true.

[@gajendrapsingh8504]

Currently be neet to improve our school education and government school and private school come to gather for making a great and bright India😊

[@zubairullakhan1909]

1.Government has to start english teaching from first std 2.Improve the infrastructure. It is main issue 3.Any job central, state or private sector should give first preference to government school student. It will attract the student and parents to come towards govern school.

[@anantsharma5330]

[Mentality of People] To Take Service - Private School To GIve Service - Govt School

[@user-zj4kb7cb7c]

समाज के बेहद ही ज्वलंत मुद्दे पर राज्य सभा टीवी ने एक बहुत ही सुन्दर सा discussion किया। और इससे हमें बहुत सारी अच्छी और उत्साहजनक , और रोचक जानकारियां मिली। इसके लिए राज्य सभा टीवी के crue members को तहे दिल से शुक्रिया आदाब सलाम धन्यवाद् ❤️❤️❤️❤️👌👍 a lot of thanks dear lovely RSTV..... Have a good future

[@madhavrajpali1257]

Jis din sarkari teacher apne bachcho ko apne hi school me padane lge usi din sb barabar ho jayege private =sarkari

[@nsingh4251]

सरकारी अधिकारी पढ़ायें अपने बच्चों को , फ़िर टीचर्स भी पढ़ा लेंगे , और तब ही सारा Infrastructure भी ठीक होगा

[@surajkmr45]

Tatti karne key liye jagah na hoti tatti sey buri halat hoti kyu padaye

[@s.....k5580]

Thanku so much rstv n a special thanks to the anchor of this program........

[@ANANDKUMAR-qs2kq]

Oh very very great debate but please decide first who will send their children to a govt. school

[@anantsharma5330]

सरकारी विद्यालयों को भी केंद्रीय विद्यालयों की तरह बनाया जाए ।

[@anantsharma5330]

Govt Schools have no comparison.

[@rahulramachandran5330]

RSTV is a great channel Not like Wire , Queen , Arnab Terrorswami , Dhruv Tatti etc etc

[@kalpanajamwal7702]

Very informative and knowledgeable discussion..the host is well informed and well spoken.. thank you RSTV 🙏

[@nandkeshwargope4371]

Thanks rstv

[@pacificocean3323]

Well point made by tripati sir... Private and government schools are not separate. Both are the schools of this nation. Just with afloated terms we shouldn't degrade or appreciate with poor collection of numbers. I don't think great infrastructure enough can change results. Only the real and concrete involvement of top to bottom commitment will bring that change. It's important that policy makers to policy implmentors should equally responsible for this to happen. I think a more comfort zones with out a proportionate skill set is a dangerous possibility... Thank you rajyasabha for bringing what exactly media has to do...

[@nsingh4251]

सरकारी स्कूल की स्थितियाँ बहुत कठिन हैं , ग्रामीण क्षेत्र की तोऔर भी ज्यादा, सरकारी स्कूल के बच्चों के माता पिता का सहयोग न तो बच्चो के लिए होता है , न टीचर्स से

[@deepakkumarsharma1991]

great programme,, thanku

[@bagibadal9562]

nice debate

[@prabhatpandey8190]

I m very obliged for working of RSTV to raise this issue but at the same time a have word to say is that the 70% of our people of india is living in rural areas and their language of communication is hindi or one of the 22 scheduled languages of our constitutions therfore this whole discourse should b in hindi also so that our rural guardians can also known abt the real situation.as far as the education is concerned i totally agree with every single statement of ms. rampal mam she picked d real issuse and according to me the equal education system would b the real solution whereby education would not b a commodity like amount of money equal to amount or quality of education...we r spending a very less percentage of amount of budget,it should b atleast 10% of our total budget.

[@bhimshenkc1040]

Great pannel👏

[@shubh3690]

Fantastic discussion...

[@PremSingh-yj3yz]

Firstly thanks to RSTV which they chooses a good topic and they organized the program. they catches the basic problem of our Indian education system. so i want to say something. if every Indian state gov, take a single decision to change basic education system then there something will happened good. And i realy believe if there change the the basic education system then ther good thing will happened.

[@vikasmeena8017]

Biggest problem in government schools is lack of continuous monitoring by superior officials and government representatives ....moreover loyalness of teachers also play a great role

[@mujahidhussaindar8714]

Gd topic but pvt schools must not treat the students as customers and growth of pvt shd be regulated.Govt should also renovate education system in India .overhauling is necessary in contemporary times.

[@abhinaypratapsingh9535]

Most of the extraordinary students are still belongs to govt. School

[@utkrsh99]

8:09, education is not a state subject, its a concurrent subject, viewers please note it; the anchor has made a mistake.

[@kishanKumar-uw3bz]

👌🏼

[@Anonymous-wz6ky]

Very nice session , govt school infrastructure and management is very bad teachers don't come on time no proper attention on students

[@Gudiya45678]

We need to mk State Gvt. more responsible for Gvt. School reforms & timely report of actions taken by it & implementation. 🇮🇳

[@arunmaurya4034]

English is just a language like any other, Marathi, Hindi, Tamil, French, German etc.. But in India it's not just language it's a skill (i.e. you got the skill to pay the bill).

[@Wilbur-em1hw]

You visit China. Obviously you won't learn Chinese if you are planning a short visit. Same is the case with Germany or Italy. So what languge do use if you don't know the regional language. English. Used by people around the globe. It eliminates the problem of learning a new langugae just to interact with the locals. N be honest. How many languages are you going to learn if you are planning trips to different places. All of em??. Nope. So you need one main language to interact with people around the globe. N that is English.

[@anantsharma5330]

[Mentality of People] To Take Service - Private School To GIve Service - Govt School

[@Harshit-vu6ky]

When you keep failing in your objective for to long,.... Intension matters a little,..... Henceforth change of executive order is required.

[@nsingh4251]

सरकारी स्कूलों में नर्सरी क्लास नही होता , , वो काम आंगनबाड़ी का है और वहां के काम का आंकलन कहां है, और सरकारी स्कूल में एक ही क्लास में हर क्लास का बच्चा बैठता है , सबको कैसे पढ़ायें एक साथ और एक को पढ़ायें तो बाकी रह जायेंगे

[@ishaverma9480]

Lack of infrastructure and the mind set and status also the big problem in india

[@anantsharma5330]

most of the employees belonging to SC/ST casts don't much for the development of a student and nobody carries control over them.

[@kantarajkumarbhukal9876]

I think the work of census & other static collection work give any other staff . ...mean creat any other vacancy for this...so teacher will be free & also concentrate on student & dedicated towards to study. & through this step . automatically gov.school result will be grow. ..& student & their parent attract to gov.school...this is my personal opinion ...

[@anujram287]

But who will send children in gov school first we have to take decision . Ministers don't want to do this after who become fool in time of vote. We have to force of gov teacher .

[@abhishekbanwala823]

difference between govt school you see also in when they both study in govt school but one speak English very well and other speak hindi mainly factor atmosphere, infrastructure, lack of availability and also lake of teachers equality

[@shahalamwarsi2558]

nice presentation

[@nainimahatha5603]

All country have progress basis on basic education which is provided by govt.

[@Radhachikkarangappa]

IN GOVERNMENT SCHOOL, teacher have to give more focused ..about the state syllabus as par the grades..they go to polio drop programme once year may be and census comes every after 11 years once that's not the problem at all ..whatever the time they have they should utilities it properly.since rural children's parents all of them are uneducated so if teachers give their good knowledge to children may achieve great future. ..

[@pacificocean3323]

I am talking about high salaries and comforts has been paid to government teachers invest their money in the other areas...

[@nirankarpandey1984]

90% teachers specially from UP Bihar are not able to teach and they do not do their own work.

[@ishwarkumar303]

3rd viwer The pannels are so awesome.

[@kishanvyas1810]

A SOLUTION WHICH I ALWAYS THINK -- REMOVE RESERVATION FROM EDUCATION MEANS TEACHER WITHOUT RESERVATION -- PAY PRIMARY TEACHERS EQUAL TO GROUP A OFFICERS AND FACILITIES MEANS MAKE TEACHING A BRIGHT CAREER -- STOP PRIVATISATION AND COMMERCEIALIZATION OF EDUCATION MEANS CLOSE PRIVATE SCHOOLS AND COACHINGS THEN WE WILL GET OUR NEW INDIA

[@sandeep89380]

Everyone should think once - " Things, where are we lagging behind and what is biggest factor that affects us adversely? Most of us would realize that the real concern is 'Education'. Mass education programs have became outdated in this competitive world as per the demands of time. So, we must rethink on our present education system. First thing we can do is to fix the accountabilty of the stakeholders at different levels of hierarchy from top to bottom. As obvious, teachers are the most important stakeholder in the system b'coz of their important nodal position where they are with maximum liability. Now, it got clear that where we have to focus upon ,it's not much on Children, parent, management etc. It's upon the 'Academicians' ! So, Efficient investment on making good academicians and then, proper harnessing of their intellect can make a way ahead. This dynamic factor can make things better as they are today. Now we come on ' Children' , they are second position stakeholder because ultimately they are direct beneficiaries . "Children are the father of nation " - I quoted this, without making our children capable of thinking what's good what's bad, we can't blame them for their reluctance towards education. It should be obligatory for the government to provide better facilities to make level up. Now, about the third driver - 'Parents' . They are intermiditaries between previous two which we have discussed, due to their role here they generally find themselves in dilemma that what's good for their ward and what's bad. Here society is very much effective from behind the scene, to explain it further I want to take an example which is like this - " Parents' mentality to send their ward in a private school has became obligation on them because people think only if you are teaching your child in private school only then you are taking care of him/her as parents. " It's reality and we can't escape from that private schools are getting priority over government schools not only because of this mind set but the strong point here is the quality provided by private schools as compared to the government schools. They are ready to pay more charge but they are not ready to compromise with their ward's future. Last but you can say the crucial one - 'Government'. System needs a better management and implementation on the ground, so that it can deliver better results. Proper monitoring of the investments at ground level is very much needed, so government should assure inclusive effort at community level and try to change the mentality of the people that the education which government is providing is not free. It's harsh reality to accept that government spends more money per child as compared to private schools, due to lack of proper investment of government's money you can say tax payers' money or ultimately say your money, is going in vein. Education should be ethics driven. One thing we must ensure in our present education system is - 'Ethics' , as a driver. By teaching our children mathematics and science, we are making them more reasonable and logical but get fail in disseminating those values which are really needed to sustain those logical reasonings. And that's the reason, our school education system has became a factory to make robots from beings. Must read!! 🇮🇳 Sandeep Gupta

[@SolutiontvStudy]

English is not important but also has become skills. At the same time mother tongue should not be ignored. Public and private school: people feel that teachers are not educate in public schools. Lack of infrastructure. Some teachers running whole school. Classroom situation. Every body wants better education.unless federal government.

[@kunfantaan9927]

Even constitution maker ambedkar also from govt schhol when was untouchble system prevent

[@pritmachand8690]

Education is now a business And thanks to unwillingness of teachers, poor infrastructure, And this become an advantage for private to charge high fees and others extra faltu ka charges. Second no recruitment of best teacher Third PhD bhi complusory kr di Recruitment become more difficult without accountability

[@anantsharma5330]

[Mentality of People] To Take Service - Private School To GIve Service - Govt School

[@Gudiya45678]

Monitoring of these Schools r required.

[@DrScienceAcademy]

Thanks to rstv.. But its social issue some what. Dedicated should prior for teacher. Practically its complicated case but can be defineitly resolve. We building nation ,a india shine 2020. Dont measure quality with the money. I re member a les soon i thought in my class 10 by kushwant singh that higher price paise indicate higher quality. But it's not truth.

[@cb48168]

If English medium and private school not developed too much as glamorous school then never its become a topic . Government schools good.but government schools students don’t speaks English so parents and everyone thought that government schools are not doing well. I’m a government teacher and I assure that government students are everywhere better. Don’t make them weaker.

[@sunitabisht7000]

Private school supporters hit like

[@abhishekbanwala823]

some exceptions also there in govt school like a boy told about our school

[@rukhsaadkhatun204]

mam mera manan h ki gov ko itne schools banane ki jagah jo schools h unko or develop kre or jo inrfastructur h unhe develop kre or govt scholls me bhi starting se english padhayi jaye or bacho ka basic strong kra jye kio ki me bhi ek govt schools se hi padhi hu us time bhi problms thi or aj to jyada h or mne 11 class bina teachers ke padhayi ki h kio ki huamre school me teachers hi nhi the.sbse phle schools me teachars ho or unka basic stronge ho and month me ek br private schools n govt schools ke teachaers ki meating honi chayiye jis se dono schools ki teachars kuch nya sikh ske or bacho ko sikha ske.and one of the most govt ko ese role khatam kr dne chahiye ki 6 to 8 ke bacho ko bina study ke pass kr dna ese role bacho ko kamjor banate h sabkuch teachars pr depend rta h agr teachars bacho ke sath apne bacho ke jaisa behave kre to bache age badh skte h.

[@jpmemory7067]

The main problem of government school is the mindset of teachers and parents. The teachers of government school only focuse on own salary not on students. If we want to improvement in gov. School then we should try that teacher's focus on students not in own salary.

[@nirankarpandey1984]

Govt should hire teachers from other institution like form army, industries etc

[@roaringbanjara9014]

The Main problem lying in government schools is these are not in english medium education ,and now a days no parent wants his or her children to study in other than english medium. But our governments force poor, rural people of india to send their children where even teachers dont know basic english. Capitalisation of education has damaged rural india.

[@ashishpatil7017]

I m a Navodaya student n it is best govt school

[@poojashukla5786]

May I find this video in hindi plzz?

[@durgeshgupta6034]

First viewer...😀

[@Gudiya45678]

Motivate child

[@VISITAadi]

I'm strongly believe that the gap between gov & private school was created by teacher...... Because unhe paise kis bat ke diye jate hai paise to private school jitne milte h fir education v vaisa hi dena chahiye

[@archanadighe6679]

Bro private ko sometimes Kum milta hai as compared to the government one

[@VISITAadi]

@@archanadighe6679 fir b private school quality education dete h gov school se

[@YOGESHYADAV-dn4yf]

Some times wait come Govt. school Vs Private school Vs Metro school.

[@GACOM-dy1yj]

teachers dont work they sleep while class time .first create the new discipline n new rule

[@atifaslamm3441]

Ni

[@GudduYadav-ib8nf]

Dps madam telling teacher are busy in collection of data for sensex😇

[@pacificocean3323]

There area of plan for next month is to where to invest this money saved money...

[@sanyaprasad2158]

Go go KVS💜💜

[@muttannagariindra2237]

There is all round development for students in govt schools, but state govts forcing teachers from core duty of teaching and drive them towards other duties at village level.....teachers for only teaching nothing else

[@farhatkhan7927]

Is kv school a private school

[@Gudiya45678]

+ focus on each Child z Imp. Either Rural or Urban so dey shouldn't lag behind.

[@nirankarpandey1984]

प्राइवेट स्कूल ना होते तो ये govt स्कूल teacher बच्चो के फ्यूचर खा जाता।

[@shivnathchaudhary5325]

The main problem is that in state government school mentality of teacher and also way of teaching of teacher is so bad.In government school some of teacher not doing your job in good way and also have lack of knowledge.there are bad management and infrastructure.many government school like jnv and kendriy vidhalay are good

[@kunfantaan9927]

But jot mam 25 /.is not proper implementing in the village and also in the cities scol and rte is looking as useles

[@jagannath9415]

Most brilient student came from govt. School.

[@kaushikmanoharan9505]

In number of rural state govt schools students attend just for free laptops and such schemes...

[@basheerthazhekoyiloth327]

In this debat , completely ignor about Kerala 's achievement. in Kerala migration from privet SchooIs and Kendreeya Vidyalas to State govt. Scools are areality in last three years.

[@nirankarpandey1984]

UP, बिहार के teachers अपने बच्चों को भी प्राइमरी govt स्कूल मे नही पड़ते।

[@GrowWithDSR]

अपने बच्चों का किसी भी स्कूल में एडमिशन करवाने से पहले इस वीडियो को पूरा जरूर देखें।👌🏻👍🏻🙏🏻🇮🇳🚩 👇👇👇👇👇 kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpevhJugjclgn9k

[@basheerthazhekoyiloth327]

Watch Kerala govt. Schools Ndtv.

[@vikaskumarsinghsingh7193]

Only English service giving. This belt of Hindi language. So please work in the Hindi Language

[@ayeluru]

Vikas Kumar Singh singh Learn English. Hindi doesn’t help get out of poverty.

[@VDhanush]

KV is the best.

[@GACOM-dy1yj]

सबसे पहले तो सरकारी टीचर्स को बदलो उसके बाद जो नए नए लड़कों के पास करते हैं उन्हें टीचर में लो टीचर स्कूल में सेक्स होता है पढ़ाता नहीं है जिसे सरकार खुद देखने के लिए आएगा ना उस दिन पता चल जाएगा कि टीचर्स क्या करते हैं बस खिचड़ी खिला दिया बस बच्चे पढ़ रहे हैं खेल रहे हैं मास्टर से कोई मतलब नहीं है मास्टर चाकुर से बढ़कर होता है यह कैसा चल रही है

[@kanchansoni7711]

private school sapprters hit like....

[@calvaryconventinternationa1156]

Why don't you ask these female teachers from where they get education.jb tk app kuch acha kroge tb tk hmare bche toh study kr chuke honge.

[@PawanYadav-lu6wc]

English language seekhna thik h English medium nhi hona chahiye

[@surajkmr45]

Kyu bhai?