The Quran's "Replacement Theology"

[@IslamCritiqued]

sunnah.com/tirmidhi/21/30 sunnah.com/urn/409880 sunnah.com/bukhari/56/223 “The apostle of Allah entered through Adhakhir and prohibited fighting. He ordered six men and four women to be killed…” -Ibn Sa’d, Kitab Tabaqat Al-Kubra, Vol 2, p. 168. archive.org/details/TheLifeOfMohammedGuillaume/page/n299: (page 551) sunnah.com/abudawud/40/12 sunnah.com/abudawud/40/11 sunnah.com/urn/1276880 sunnah.com/muslim/32/30 sunnah.com/bukhari/56 sunnah.com/muslim/32/167 sunnah.com/muslim/46/47 “I was only commanded to do these things that were enjoined upon me.”-Tafsir Kathir, Surah 18:82; www.alim.org/library/quran/AlQuran-tafsir/TIK/18/82 “…whoever of you should revert from his religion - Allah will bring forth [in place of them] a people He will love and who will love Him.” -Surah 5:54 “We destroyed them for their sins and brought forth after them a generation of others.” -Surah 6:6 “If He wills, he can do away with you and give succession after you to whomever He wills, just as He produced you from the descendants of another people.” -Surah 6:133 If you do not go forth, He will punish you with a painful punishment and will replace you with another people.” -Surah 9:39 “And We had already destroyed generations before you when they wronged…Then after them We made you so that We might see how you would do.” -Surah 10:13, 14 “If He wills, He can do away with you and produce a new creation.” -Surah 14:19 “So we intended that their Lord should substitute for them one better than him in purity and nearer to mercy.” -Surah 18:81 “And how many a city which was unjust have We shattered and produced after it another people.” -Surah 21:11 “Then We produced after them a generation of others.” -Surah 23:31/23:42 “If He wills, He can do away with you and bring forth a new creation.” -Surah 35:16 “And if you turn away, He will replace you with another people; then they will not be the likes of you.” -Surah 47:38 “We are able to replace them [disbelievers] with better than them; and We are not to be outdone.” -Surah 70:40b-41 “We created them…and when We please, We shall exchange the likes of them.” -Surah 76:28 “We turned them into ruins. Then, We produced other generations. We caused some of them to follow others, and We turned them into stories.” -Surah 23:41, 42, 44 “Perhaps his Lord, if he divorced you [all], would substitute for him wives better than you.” -Surah 66:5 The LORD saw that the wickedness of man was great in the earth, and that every intention of the thoughts of his heart was only evil continually. And the LORD regretted that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved (עצב) him to his heart. -Ge 6:5-6. This is expressed even more strongly in Gen 3:16, 17 where עצב is used to describe the painful punishment imposed on man and woman which now shackles the existence of humankind alienated from God. Here the verb from the same root is used to describe the pain of God in his decision to destroy his creatures. The same motif occurs in the prophetic pronouncements of judgment when God laments that he must intervene against his people, e.g. Is 2:2-3; Jer 12:7-13. -Claus Westermann, A Continental Commentary: Genesis 1-11 (Minneapolis, MN: Fortress Press, 1994), 410-411. “Do I have any pleasure at all that the wicked should die?” says the Lord GOD, “and not that he should turn from his ways and live? -Ezek 18:23 Say to them: “As I live,” says the Lord GOD, “I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but that the wicked turn from his way and live.” -Ezek 33:11

[@jxcess3891]

islame is a very feminist religion: 1. muhummud increased women employment by introducing mutah and sex slavery as professions. 2. muhummud encouraged gender equality by legalizing wife beating 3. muhummud prevented pedophilia by making it legal to rape prepubescent girls calling it nikah 4. muhummud increased the security and protection of women by introducing adult breastfeeding. 5. muhummud was a true feminist because he identified as a woman. He wore women's clothing, wore eyeliner, colored his hair orange and even sat down and peed like a woman. 6. muhummud also provided opportunities for women to date other men by introducing halala marriage.

[@jxcess3891]

Dear Colin, why don't you collaborate with CP and do a series? CP has knowledge of arabic and you know Hebrew really well. Both of you together would be a deadly combination.

[@IslamCritiqued]

@jxcess3891 we have very different methodologies. He likes to take the sources at face value and run with them, that's great! I'm more into source and historical criticism. The more different the better! Different approaches work for different people.

[@olorunseunenitolumo]

@@IslamCritiqued ME TOO, AMEN We are part of the Body and each part serves it own function. Blessings

[@ophelian4646]

@@sayedf11 There is one thing though, _if_ Christians and Jews read and understood these texts you refer to, the way _you_ think they should - don't you think they *would kill wives, kill babies, kill Followers of Other Religions, kill Sons of Sinners etc nowadays too? Or at least defend that idea?* But Jews and Christians don't do that. Could it possibly be you and your scholars (who taught you this) that have very, very little knowledge about the books of the Bible..? Maybe..

[@Morgow1]

The most underrated Islam critic on KZbin.

[@ReasonedAnswers]

Agreed!

[@MichaelSmith-ku7ki]

Would probably be Bill Warner. And he's probably one of the best.

[@djaflo]

and if that would not be the case: his "comment" section is under the microscope of google's AI-censoring bot...the most scrutinized one of youtube

[@mosesgande7255]

@@MichaelSmith-ku7ki Warner is of Jewish descent, and God has for all time chosen, to, reveal Himself to Abraham and his posterity more than any others!

[@MichaelSmith-ku7ki]

@@mosesgande7255 Well the descendents of Moses actually... And I'd think that you of all people would know that Moses! 😀😳

[@josephololade]

I will add you to my prayer list, may God continue to strengthen you as you keep unveiling the truth about Islam, I am an ex Muslim

[@lollolliii]

God bless you

[@flourishomotola5306]

Hide your name bro. The punishment for apostasy is death. I pray that God protects you.

[@josephololade]

@@flourishomotola5306 am not afraid of death...

[@jasonwasti8016]

Bro you have the softest voice a man could have. Thank you for the good work you’re doing.

[@harrykalos8540]

When i mention Isis beheading children, the first thing a Muslim will say is "they're not Muslim" PLEASE make a 30 second clip titled The verses Isis refers to when killing children, going on to quote Surah 18:74 And Sahih Muslim 1812. It's hard making a stubborn Muslim sit through an entire video, albeit they're only 5 minutes long. Maybe a series of short gotcha clips would be nice...

[@ReasonedAnswers]

And do doubt that same Muslim will turn around blame Christianity for various atrocities, none of which were even claimed to be done in the name of Christianity.

[@DandyLion2024]

absolutely agree 100%

[@beofgoodcheer3348]

I second that !!

[@FromValkyrie]

​@@ReasonedAnswerslook at them wailing about Israel's retaliation after jubilating about Hamas's first attack. They're lost and unredeemable.

[@jeannet7443]

"Islamic sacred blah blah blah" - LOL. Very good.

[@Dorkeydaze]

Jeanne T Even critique is getting fed up with the double thought of Islam. Lol love this dude

[@ericlestick7325]

Funny. I heard "Islamic sacred bLAW, bLAW, bLAW." Maybe I'm hearing what I want to hear it again.

[@aalvarez2914]

mohamed kamaludeen yes you can point to Islam, because it legitimized the most horrible, vile actions and behavior, and does to this day. It’s a cancer on humanity. Any religion can be abused, but Islam was designed for it. People who follow actual Jesus’s words will be helping others, and loving their neighbor as themselves. People following Muhammad’s commands will be raping, pillaging, murdering and demanding tribute from non-Muslims.

[@hillstrong715]

@@mohamedkamaludeen3492 You and your colleague @Bersama Hikmah are both anti-Christs. You are following in the footsteps of your evil master and false god, satan the devil, who is the originator of your unholy book the quran. If you continue to claim that the Amalekites are innocents, can we take it that Muhammad and the Arabs are descended from this blood-thirsty and corrupt people whose way of life was in killing and butchering defenseless peoples. They had been warned to change their ways over a long period of time. They ignored this and in doing so brought a judgment on themselves. One modern group that is like them are the pirates who terrorise the shipping of south-east Asia or the ISIS or any of the various islamic groups running terror campaigns in many parts of the world today. Your questions have been repeatedly answered in many different places but you choose to ignore all of this for the sake of acting in the same manner as your evil master and false god, the devil AKA allah of the quran. As I have said repeatably to @Bersama Hikmah, you are called to repent and seek the Only True One Jesus Christ who can save your miserable, wretched and sin-filled life. Only through Jesus Christ can you find peace, mercy and above love in God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). Again, I say to you and your colleague of mischief and evil, @Bersama Hikmah, repent and come out of the slavery and misery that you willingly and willfully have chosen to live in your servitude to satan the devil AKA allah of the quran .

[@sgt.krakatoa1093]

sayedf11 lmao Joseph was 90 🤣🤣 that claim right there is so bs 🤣🤣

[@falsegospel1640]

YHWH - Saves Allah - Replace 😄

[@evthdamis7460]

sayedf11 The spirit that haunted Mohammad, the spirit of the devil that denies the work of Christ, the spirit of false god allah is in your fuel!! What can cleanse your systems? Much more what can blot out your sins? How can you stand before Son of Man when he appears on the clouds with glory?

[@shujaatalikhan4401]

Yhwa??

[@genli5603]

YHWH is the transliteration of Yahweh, which is the name of God. Muhammad didn’t even know the name of the God he claimed to represent. Look up Yahweh or Muhammad.

[@Toolgdskli]

Hi have you done any apologetic debate? Your are soft spoken but sharp in your delivery and with solid knowledge of the scriptures. An interesting contrast to someone loud, boastful but weak in knowledge, like Hijab.

[@jonasa.3040]

Islam philosophy just took an even darker turn.

[@ameen9957]

You are absolutely right Mr.Colin..when a non muslim attracting or welcoming to islam by a muslim they will only show good surahs good hadid and good message from mohammad (only few) ,but when we think and read more about islam muhammad and quran own our language we will realize real cult of islam and fakeness and hate ness of mohammad🙏

[@tomlaureys1734]

@@sayedf11 I don't know about the Bible because I didn't read that. But I will respond to your statements about the Quran. I don't know how you can say Islam is good to women when the testimony of a woman is worth half of that of a man. Men can have four wives but women can only have one husband. If a husband wants sex the wife must comply. In sex the man can penetrate her anyway he wants including anal and she must comply. If they get divorced the children belong to the husband. Men can wear whatever they want but the women have to cover their body. Men can beat their wives if they don't obey him or if he even thinks they won't obey him. Men can have sex with their slaves. Muslims can't even agree on what the Koran means and what the rules are. The different sects of Islam fight over it. Yet the Quran is supposed to be the perfect eternal word of Allah. It's not perfect if God made it such that different people can interpret it differently and understand it differently. It's also not perfect and eternal if Allah needs to reveal future verses to clarify previous versus or correct previous verses. That is not sensible. That is not logical. Therefore it is not from a God but from a non sensible non-logical human who is capable of error. This is clear to any rational human being who uses their intellect to think about it. There is much more evidence that the Koran is man-made and not from God. I'll give you just a few. The sun sets in a spring of muddy water with people in the vicinity. The sun is floating in an orbit. Sperm is produced between the backbone and the ribs (not the testicles). God created the world in 6 days. God created the world in 8 days. The flat-earthers who follow 7th century Islam need to wake up and read their own book again but this time think about it using your human intellect instead of reading it under the premise that it's from God. I hope you all wake up and join the rest of humanity. I wish you all luck my brothers and sisters in humanity.

[@MartinHansenGamer]

Thank you for what you do. May God bless you and your family🙏🏻 Christian from Norway

[@pastaapostle9388]

ManaBanana Christianity without secular values is similar to Islam

[@XISatu]

@@pastaapostle9388 No. Read the Gospel if you please.

[@Endtime-dh9lk]

@@pastaapostle9388 Do you mean secular values like abortion i.e. ripping fetuses and children apart so that they can be removed from the uterus, or now even discussing that one should be able to decide after birth whether to keep a disabled child or "dispose of it"? History clearly shows that moral values were infused into mankind by the teachings of Jesus.

[@pastaapostle9388]

@@XISatu Ok. What does thr bible say about slavery?

[@pastaapostle9388]

@@Endtime-dh9lk Nope. Explain slavery then through the Christian doctrine.

[@meras5465]

Thank you for all your hard work.I have learned so much from watching your videos along with David Wood,and others who work hard in educating people about islam and Muhammad.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Be sure you download the Word Doc! kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYY61-ndGaf7s

[@chrispaige8880]

But Allah wants only slaves; God wants us to become children of God, so the whole theme of the Quran is that Allah does NOT love us while the whole theme of the Bible is that God so loved the world...

[@IslamCritiqued]

God wants a family. He wants us.

[@silverjones2317]

Allah in the koran sura El zareyat 56 says he created humans and Jinn only to worship him.

[@thehandofjibreel8756]

allah is too proud to enter his creation.

[@hillstrong715]

@@sayedf11 Your blasphemy against the Living God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) is just one of the many sins that will be required of you in the Judgment. Unless you repent of your sin and call upon the Lord Jesus Christ to save your miserable, wretched and evil filled life, you will have only your works to justify you. Since there are no works that you can do to wash away your sins, your punishment, which will be a righteous and perfect judgment on you, will be the same as your evil master and false god, satan the devil AKA allah of the quran. He end is already reserved for him and it is in the lake of fire. I ask you, do you really want to have that same ending? No matter what promises your false god has made you, he is unable to fulfill any of them, iirespective of what you may now have received from him. God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) has declared that He doesn't want to see any die but all to come to the perfect salvation that is only found in Jesus Christ. Yet, He gives you your choice and it appears that the Gift of Life from Him is being rejected out of hand by you and those who stand in the same cesspool of hatred, evil, violence, lust and corruption. Do not give the evil one the pleasure of seeing you follow him to perdition in the lake of fire. Instead, repent and call upon Jesus Christ to save you.

[@genli5603]

Allah abolished adoption so that Muhammad could screw his son’s wife. God sent his son to die so we could be adopted by him.

[@israelcrawford8734]

Really appreciating the faster uploads 😎😎

[@sumyunguy6894]

You never disappoint

[@eelcob1818]

sayedf11 Bukhari vol. 7, #65: "Narrated Aisha that the prophet wrote the marriage contract with her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old. Hisham said: "I have been informed that Aisha remained with the prophet for nine years (i.e. till his death)."" From the hadith of Muslim, volume 2, #3309 Aisha reported: Allah’s Messenger married me when I was six years old, and I was admitted to his house at the age of nine…. From the hadith of the Sunan of Abu Dawud, volume 2, #2116 "Aisha said, "The Apostle of Allah married me when I was seven years old." (The narrator Sulaiman said: "Or six years."). "He had intercourse with me when I was 9 years old."

[@courag1]

Actually, if a person wants to get away with any crime, all you have to do is to find the loophole: if you fear disobedience or that your children may leave Islam, they may be killed. If you fear disobedience in your wife, you may scourge her, but if perchance she dies of infection, would the man to be to blame for this or complications of broken bones? NO! If men want a younger woman and is angry about paying for his wife or wives and the children he had with them, if you accuse them of Zina (adultery), the state will put them away as in Iran and the man gets out of paying for anything. Imprisonment is certain, that there ever will be a trial, is not likely to ever happen. The waiting time for your trial to come up, your children who are imprisoned along with their mother, will be grown. Most people whether they are Muslim or from the West, are good time Charlies and would rather have a good time and not think about very much at all. So that so many are so busy with daily life or frivolity, not much will get challenged as thinking is discouraged in Islam.

[@wlan246]

Critical thinking is not merely "discouraged", it is actively punished. One is not a true Muslim unless one accepts everything Muhammad said or did _without reservation_ . (Qur'an 4.65)

[@courag1]

@@wlan246 When things make sense, critical thinking becomes a part of nature, as you observe and notice what works and what works better. But if you constantly get a different result, you cannot draw a conclusion. Muhammad kept people with a totally inconsistent message. The amount of literature to have to read is for most, insurmountable. Considering a book which was arranged by line length it is a nightmare to discipline yourself to read, so people depend on the imams. If you have a nice one, not much harm. But then again, I live in the West, in Saudi Arabia, you would not dare think for yourself even today. But as there are many these days who have an education or who study abroad, they have to be able to draw conclusion as for those in the sciences, you cannot diagnose or prescribe unless you observe. Somewhere in there the ability to think will emerge. One of my sons attended Cal State LA and had a philosophy whose father had become a medical doctor and went back to Saudi to practice. If you are a doctor there you may be called upon to treat amputations of hands and feet so the person does not bleed to death. He hemmed and hawed and would lose his medical license if he did not comply, he gathered up his family and what funds he could take and their clothing and fled to Scotland where he was able to practice medicine. He had concluded that in medicine as he was taught: first do no harm, that he could not participate in a system which Hippocrates would despise. His son told his class about this. Even in a country where critical thinking is forbidden, humanity is stronger. Situations come up which the Sharia cannot tell you what to do.

[@OrpheusXL]

Not to forget the "Book of Repentance"! Abu Ayyub Ansari reported that Allah's Messenger said: "If you were not to commit sins, Allah would have swept you out of existence and would have REPLACED you by another people who have committed sin, and then asked forgiveness from Allah, and He would have granted them pardon." Sahih Muslim 2748 b

[@IslamCritiqued]

This is part of my "Quran Specific" playlist. But yes, several relevant hadith as well! Thanks

[@JattaMD]

It makes me wonder if all it takes for Muslims to be awarded a college certificate is by just shouting the blah blah blah mantra of the Shahada. I think this is really beyond arrogance and ignorance. I pray those following you with open minds get their hearts convicted. Thanks for your work.

[@asemotanosa1200]

Thanks man, great Job, I pray your channel explodes

[@bithiahamariah9139]

Thank you once again. These topics are incredibly clear and precise. Love the clear resources. For those whose first language is not English, his clear, quiet and confident manner of speech will be easy to understand. We need to advertise your teachings on Muslim channels...they would benefit heaps from your videos.

[@IslamCritiqued]

The non-native English speaking part of your comment is important. Thanks! I try to avoid idioms and words that are generally high context in English.

[@sumyunguy6894]

Thank you for existing!

[@carolynnunes3922]

Your voice is so low, even, and soothing to listen to! Your information is stellar, and leaves me wanting more! David Wood recently taught about girls having to give up their dolls when they have their first period, because they are now grown up, and must put aside dolls, because they are idols! Then reading that Aishia took her dolls with her AFTER Mohammad consummated the marriage when she was 9, means that he had sex with her BEFORE she had even begun to bleed! Apparently, she fell ill, and her hair fell out, and took a while to grow back in. Mohammad is known for liking long hair, and so waited for her hair to grow back. When her hair grew back long enough for her to be desirable to him once again, the marriage was consummated, and she took her dolls with her! That kind of trivia is telling!

[@OrpheusXL]

Well, as the scholars know, that this is mentioned, that Aicha played with her dolls when she had been "consummated" by the "prophet", they desperately try the take the dolls away, so that nobody can say anymore: But this is still a girl, because she is playing with dolls! All makes sense this way. You just have to understand muslim minds.

[@Toolgdskli]

Carolyn Nunes I feel so sad for Aisha.

[@FreeRadical7118]

*Carolyn Nunes* IC is very soft spoken, but he wields a very big stick, and he's absolutely toxic to Islam.

[@carolynnunes3922]

Betsy Ross Islam is toxic all by itself! I am a conservative Christian, although I cringe being put into such a box, but it gives people a general idea of where I stand! I love Biblical Zion! “The joy of the whole earth is mount Zion!” Why oh why can’t the feminists see Islam for what it is, and get shrill about FGM! They chant, “My body, my choice,” about abortion, and are silent when IN AMERICA, littler girls are undergoing “female circumcision-Female Genital Mutilation?!? Then there’s child sex slaves, and women being disrespected in general... The LGBTQ people also need to use their clout to protect themselves from Sharia! Especially the guys! They are KILLED in Saudi Arabia and Iran, and other Muslim countries!

[@IslamCritiqued]

"but he wields a very big stick" It's a "tooth-stick" to be precise. I use it to (lightly) beat my wives.

[@waterfull2907]

Your voice just flowles amazing!

[@Tm_37]

You couldn't find a Muslim in the whole universe to explain Islam as peaceful and calmly as this.

[@steveschott4566]

I love your work. You save me a lot of time.

[@able763]

This is a very good point much overlooked in criticism of Islam.

[@ParabolicDavid]

Question... How do i LOVE this video?!? KZbin is stifling my reaction. How is it that you can blindside Islam with a lesson that forwards the gospel and not disturb the peace in the room beside you!?! Bless you for your delivery and insight! Be lifted brother! WOW, each video demands accountability thru insight. Don't Stop Ever! Please!!!

[@xhmaah]

Great catch, I have never realised this. Thank you for enlightening us.

[@rubynibs]

Here from David Wood's channel, Acts 17 Apologetics. If David recommends you, you must be accurate.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Welcome! I recommend starting here: kzbin.info/aero/PLVwt18wNX1gwtNCdaRTHH1sOcRnSOoyKY

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

I do not know if you have the intention to learn Arabic. I think there is the need of an articulate person like you to have his work into Arabic. Anyway, sorry for my unrelated comment.

[@sukd2669]

your videos and personal presentation are excellent.

[@anagodinho5102]

And then, on the opposite spectrum, you have a God that sent His son to die for each and everyone of us, because He loves us so much, and we are all so important. Not a difficult choice to make!

[@danielhartley9003]

This is exactly the kind of comparisons we need scholars to analyze. The canyon between the two deity's

[@phillip0537]

This was really powerful, excellent job.

[@MrLosches]

Your videos are the best.

[@greenzone7371]

In my country a man in his 50s was remanded in the prison custody for having canal knowledge of a 9years old girl ..🙄

[@AlbertM170]

In another country a man in his 50s who had carnal knowledge of a 9 year old girl was hailed as a holy prophet. 🤦🏾‍♂️🤦🏾‍♂️ I wish Muhammad was born in the 21st century. He'd either be in a mental asylum or in a maximum security prison.

[@MadolcheGabbana]

Albert Muriithi Pedophiles don’t last long in the general public of the prison system. The inmates would of killed such a weak ass man who needed to prey on children. Chemical castrations need to become more prominent over these literal demons.

[@classicalmusful]

Hey I saw you systematically categorised and read all of Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim and maybe Ibn Daud. Is there a way I could get access to this? It seems like an incredible resource for someone who has been studying Islamic theology for some time like me. Thanks!

[@IslamCritiqued]

Yes...and then I found out they were all online. Glad I did it though! I'm slowly making this stuff available in a more presentable form. See here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYY61-ndGaf7s.

[@classicalmusful]

@@IslamCritiqued God bless you! Thanks

[@genli5603]

IC, the online ones are being edited to remove some of the most heinous phrasing. I forgot which one it was, but on sunnah.com, one in Sahih Bukhari was altered recently in translation to make it should less horrible.

[@FreeRadical7118]

This topic reminded me of something I'd long forgot, the gruesome death of Umm Qirfah. Have you made a video about her? She seems to be a forgotten topic, but with your research, you'd do a grand job of reviving her memory for 10 or 15 minutes: www.thereligionofpeace.com/pages/games/discover-truth/topics/umm-qirfah.aspx None of these subjects are enjoyable, but we need to know the roots of this enemy our Democracies are sleeping with.

[@birdseyeview6523]

Another outstanding explanation of the cherry picking that Muslims do. The god Allah is not merciful or loving, but that is no surprise given the book Mohammed created.

[@MilesMariae]

Great insights into 'replacement theory' I hadn't noticed this... we get it at the Crucifixion right also,

[@IslamCritiqued]

"we get it at the Crucifixion right also," I'll take that as a joke.

[@IslamCritiqued]

I took that as a theological analogy, i.e. Allah's replacement in the Quran is similar to the concept of the atonement. mohammad kamaludeen is banned. Funny thing is that he can still post comments but nobody can see them.

[@IslamCritiqued]

@Reasoned brought to my attention from his channel recently that ABRAMS, who has been banned here for months, was talking about how I'm too scared to respond to his posts anymore. All of this time he's been posting his nonsense comments, and nobody has been seeing them.

[@IslamCritiqued]

"That poor little abfool is probably about to split a gut in frustration" either that or patting himself on the back. You know their rhetoric. If we don't answer them, we're "running scared"!!!

[@IslamCritiqued]

Yes, I'm thankful for the email, however. That's where the thinkers comment. =)

[@Riphagen1902]

like always you are an amazing teacher you have a great aura of telling things so professional greetings from dying germany

[@IslamCritiqued]

I hear bad things about Germany!

[@Riphagen1902]

@@IslamCritiqued its worse than left wing journos try to portrait it mate .. total end of the german coming in your theathers in 10 years :D

[@IslamCritiqued]

Islam taking over?

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

Aethel Wulf I think Aethel is being too pessimistic. I am European just like him, and not too far from him. I cannot disclose my exact location, but Germany is not dying. Too alarmistic.

[@Riphagen1902]

police not doing their work germans culturize with muslims music gets dominated by muslim rappers almost no german birthrate the family construct is long broken and the other germans are just scared or convert the basic islamic feelings xD to feel part of it mate its disastrous so i dont know what this cretin prophet puppet talks about antifa union with islam but when they stand together in a bar they dont even dare to look at each other hhaha multi culti

[@greenzone7371]

Wow what a great lecture,after watching this video one could see that Alla 👹 is the greatest of all the decivers and a wicked deity . May God bless you for trying so hard to save 🧕🧔👳 Muslims.

[@greenzone7371]

@@sayedf11 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 Allah is shaytan simple repent and be saved.

[@hillstrong715]

@@sayedf11 You keep repeating your blasphemies as if they will affect the outcome. There are only two outcomes here for you, repent and follow Jesus Christ as your Lord and Saviour and continue down the same path as your false god to the lake of fire. Which you choose is something between you and God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). He would have you choose Life in Jesus Christ, but you can choose death in the lake of fire, if you want that.

[@hillstrong715]

@@sayedf11 You keep getting told and you keep choosing to blaspheme the One True God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). In the same manner that your evil and false god calls evil good and good evil, so do you. Allah of the quran tells you specifically that he is satan the devil and yet you insist otherwise. You want to worship that which is created instead of the Holy Creator of all things who is Yahweh (Father, Son and Holy Spirit) Repent and turn from your evil ways to the Only One who can Save you, Jesus Christ. Come and worship the One True God (Father, Son and Holy Spirit). Your time to actively choose a different course than the one you are on is running out. Once you cross that line, you will have permanently chosen the lake of fire.

[@richsellskc]

Excellent. Spread the Word!

[@monicafurtado620]

God bless you bro

[@srinivasnarayana4494]

Super quote 2:14, everyone felt same thing while reading this book first time. Thank you

[@TheJiminiflix]

Thanks for making this video. Well done.

[@paynedv]

Colin. You. Are. The. Man. Very informative and very useful. 😐 Every Christian & Muslim should subscribe.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Glad you enjoyed!

[@saotome6502]

Wow , excellent work.

[@Gabriel-zm2ue]

Bro you should have at least 2 million subscribers

[@brockrumlow]

Just too good!! I bet Zakir Naik cannot find any misinterpreted text in this video.

[@thomasstokes9412]

The phrase: "The Devil's in the detail" couldn't be more true of Islam. One other point, Allah also doesn't value sinless humans either: Abu Ayyub Ansari reported that Allah's Messenger (Peace be upon him) said: If you were not to commit sins, Allah would have swept you out of existence and would have replaced you by another people who have committed sin, and then asked forgiveness from Allah, and He would have granted them pardon.- Sahih Muslim 6621 (51:7140) Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (Peace be upon him) having said: By Him in Whose Hand is my life, if you were not to commit sin, Allah would sweep you out of existence and He would replace (you by) those people who would commit sin and seek forgiveness from Allah, and He would have pardoned them.- Sahih Muslim 6622 (51:7141)

[@ReasonedAnswers]

I can't believe I've never heard those hadith before. That is some insane stuff there.

[@heikejohannajahns3257]

Good job, Mister.

[@midnighthymn]

Keep it up, man!

[@maryumali1608]

Thank you IC

[@terminuscoagule3059]

I just fully realized the difference between christian morality and islamic. In christianity there is choice, free will and self determination. In islam there is no self determination, no free will, no choice. A loving God allows his people a choice, a selfish god demands submission.

[@amandasusanne4657]

Anti-Christians also love to cherrypick Timothy 2:12

[@convert2islaam500]

All it is saying is women shouldn't be bishops etc and should learn while bring quiet in church

[@pastaapostle9388]

Christianity without secular ideas is similar to Islam

[@convert2islaam500]

@@pastaapostle9388 not true at all

[@hillstrong715]

@@convert2islaam500 There is also a societal context here as well. If this in not included then the full meaning of what Paul wrote to Timothy is missed.

[@hillstrong715]

@@pastaapostle9388 Your problem is that you have not described what "secular" ideas you are thinking about. Until you define them, you comment is worth nothing.

[@Derek_Baumgartner]

Succinct and clear, as one can come to expect from this channel. It's so interesting how Islamic polemicists will attack Christianity and say that 'Allah is just, since he won't substitute one for another. Your sins are your own....' - when if they've looked into such a topic at all, we find that in Islam Allah does *just that* without any regard for justice. I wonder if they're also merely deceiving, so they can be like Allah who claims to be 'the greatest of deceivers', or if they're merely ignorant of their own theology? Whereas in Christianity Jesus pays the price in our stead (instead of shifting the blame to another, He takes it on Himself!) and offers to pay the price of sin in our stead to any who would 'turn from evil' and accept Him (there's those passages from Ezekiel echoing)! Romans 5:8: "But God commendeth his love toward us, in that, while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us." In one I see grace and mercy abounding in love. In the other I see almost a 'who cares' attitude: something which also seems consistently echoed throughout Islamic theology. What do you worship, Muslims? If you say Allah of the Qu'ran, I have news for you: it is abundantly clear that he is not 'all-merciful'.. nor even *merely just*, much less maximally just! It almost looks like he couldn't care less! Not to mention this same Allah also lays claim to the title 'greatest of deceivers': would you even trust what you read in the Qur'an if you thought it is authored by one who prides himself in being great at lying? Would you trust a handshake from the Joker?

[@IslamCritiqued]

"we find that in Islam Allah does just that without any regard for justice." Yes, I like Paul better: "...so that he might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus."

[@andred3199]

I just noticed a lot of "We will... , We did...," in the quranic texts you quoted, referencing Allah. I thought Allah had no partners. Isn't this 'shirq'?

[@IslamCritiqued]

The so-called "royal We" or plural of majesty. I have never seen any philological support for this, however. Note that, little known to many Muslims, sometimes the "we" is the angels speaking.

[@AlbertM170]

I maintain that it was the voices in Muhammad's fractured mind posing as allah. 😂😂😂

[@IslamCritiqued]

To me, if you're rubbing someone's spit on your face, collecting someone's sweat in a bottle, that's idolatry and therefore shirk. Here are some samples. sunnah.com/nasai/48/332; sunnah.com/muslim/43/115.

[@fantasia55]

Islam Critiqued the ‘Royal We’ began with the Papacy, later emulated by medieval kings. It has nothing to do with Islam.

[@genli5603]

IC, I think it’s probably to imitate certain places in the Bible.

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

I love to read the comments on your channel. hahaha. Some are hilarious, others give you a brain hemorrhage.

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

you attracted a lot of Muslims here. That' s a good sign. I do not know how you manage to stay so calm. After having so many conversations with Muslims, and listening to their apologetics on all sorts of depravities( especially wife beatings, and the child " marriage" and rape of Aisha, I am not so relaxed anymore. It makes me so sick and upset they justify disgusting stuff, especially related to children, that when I talk to them I just not so politely let it all out on the repulsive teachings in the quran. Even if I actually feel bad for them! I just want them to leave this insanity for the sake of humanity! Urgh!!

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

@@thecommenter715 I am not sure how many times I have to repeat this. I support Christians, but I am not a Christian. Anything related to Christianity you need to ask them not trying to justify the sickness of the quran by diverting to something else, in this case Christianity. Now, for your leader Muhamammad, read very carefully! There is zero evidence, ZERO that forcing 6 years old children into marriage with 53 years old men was common. IF indeed it was common -(please Muslims provide evidence it was so common all around the world to FORCE a marriage WHEN a child was 6 with a 53 years old man). it was because men were ignorant back then and it should NOT be excused. Forced arranged child marriage did exist (the “ common” is disputable) because of the ignorance of people, HOWEVER the age difference, 6 years old with 53 years old,was NOT commonly practiced at all. And still this despicable act should not be excused in the context of time and ignorance. People know how harmful it is now. How come this Allah, did not inform Muhammad that having sex with children is immoral? If it was so common back then ( I doubt it, it was common for 6 years old to be forced into a marriage with a 53 years old, evidence please) Allah ( Muhammad’s alter -ego) should have made a priority to let Muhammad know having sex with children harms children and it is a despicable act. Instead this Allah fellah gives the green light for Muhammad to engage in sex with a child ( rape Aisha unable to consent) and forgets to tell him such important detail NOT to set an IMMORAL example to be followed by all people and all times, however did not forget to tell Muslim men, as prescribed in sura 65:4 that having sex with children is ok. That verse gives specifics on child marriage. Muhammad set an immoral, disgusting example; and also provided regulations on child marriage and sex with children , sura 65:4, yet Muslims find justifications for it. The important factor is that you Muslims do not seem to understand that a devine being, being devine, all knowing being, ( assuming it exists) is NOT constraint by time . If Muhammad was in contact with this Allah( an all knowing, all powerful God, the one that sets moral examples for all people and all times) would have told him that those behaviours of having sex with children should not be practiced at any time or in any context. A God is beyond time, or context. Instead gives the green light for Muhammad to rape Aisha and gives previsions in sura 65:4 for disgusting sex with children. Muslims excusing Muhammad’ s behaviour just prove further that Islam is a disgreceful ideology that has no place anywhere, anytime.

[@IslamCritiqued]

I read the first part of your link on Surah 65:4: "not once has the word ‘Nisa’ been used for a ‘child(ren)". Surah 7:127 describes the account where Pharaoh kills the baby boys and let's the baby girls live. Here's what Kathir says, "After the dream, Pharaoh ordered that every newborn male among the Children of Israel be killed and that the girls be left alone." Here's the parallel account in Exodus: “When you help the Hebrew women in childbirth, look at the child when you deliver it. If it’s a boy, kill it, but if it’s a girl, let it live.” Here's the Quran: "Their male children will we slay; (only) their females will we save alive; and we have over them (power) irresistible." This is clearly referring to male and female children. And the word the Quran uses: "nisa". So your "Dr. Rohi Baalbaki" doesn't know what he's talking about. With an error that blatant at the first part of the article, I didn't read that rest. That's very sloppy. Maududi: “Therefore, making mention of the waiting-period for the girls who have not yet menstruated, clearly proves that it is not only permissible to give away the girl in marriage at this age but it is also permissible for the husband to consummate marriage with her. Now, obviously no Muslim has the right to forbid a thing which the Qur'an has held as permissible.” www.englishtafsir.com/Quran/65/index.html Tafsir al-Jalalayn: “those who have not yet menstruated because of their young age their period shall also be three months" www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asptMadhNo=1&tTafsirNo=74&tSoraNo=65&tAyahNo=4&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 Asbab Al-Nuzul by Al-Wahidi: “He said: ‘Those who are too young [such that they have not started menstruating yet]...And so this verse (And for such of your women as despair of menstruation…) was revealed.” www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=1&tTafsirNo=86&tSoraNo=65&tAyahNo=4&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 Tanwîr al-Miqbâs min Tafsîr Ibn ‘Abbâs: “O Messenger of Allah! What about the waiting period of those who do not have menstruation because they are too young?” www.altafsir.com/Tafasir.asp?tMadhNo=2&tTafsirNo=73&tSoraNo=65&tAyahNo=4&tDisplay=yes&UserProfile=0&LanguageId=2 Al-Tabari: The same applies to the ‘idaah for girls who do not menstruate because they are too young, if their husbands divorce them after consummating the marriage with them. Tafsir Ar-Razi: Allah revealed {and those who have not menstruated yet}, meaning that her Iddah is like the old-aged woman who reached her menopause. Tafsir Zamakshari: “Those who have not menstruated” are young girls. Tafsir Al-Shawkani: “Those who have not menstruated yet” are young girls who have not reached the age of menstruation. Tafsir Al-Quartubi: {and those who have not menstruated yet} Means the young girls, their Iddah is 3 months. Tafsir Al-Baidawi: {and those who have not menstruated yet} Meaning those who have not menstruated yet. Tafsir Mujahid-Ibn Jabr: Those who have not yet menstruated, their ‘idda is three months. Tafsir Bukhari: He made the ‘idda of a girl before puberty three months. Tafsir Abu-hayyan: “Those who have not menstruated yet” denotes those not menstruated because of being young. Tafsir Al-Fayrooz Abadi: {and those who have not menstruated yet} Those who did not menstruate due to their young age. Tafsir As-Suyuti: {and those who have not menstruated yet} They are the young girls who have not menstruated yet. Tafsir Muqatil ibn Sulayman: {and those who have not menstruated yet} … means the Iddah of the young girls who have not menstruated yet, and they were married and then divorced. Ibn Hajar: (65:4) indicates that giving her into marriage before puberty is permissible.“ Tafsir ‘Uthaymeen: If a woman does not menstruate, either because she is very young or old and past menopause, then her ‘iddah is three months Tafsir Al-Sa‘di: “along with those who have it [menses] not” means minors, those who have not yet started to menstruate. Tafsir Shafi‘ and Usmani: “‘iddah for a woman who does not menstruate on account of minority of age, or because she has attained menopausal age, is computed on monthly basis. Their ‘‘iddah is three months. Islamonline: Since this is not negated later, we can take from this verse that it is permissible to have sexual intercourse with a prepubescent girl. Islamweb: So (in 65:4), Allah set rulings of marriage, divorce and waiting period for the women who have not yet had menses, i.e. the young girls. Islamqa: In this verse (65:4) we see that Allaah states that for those who do not menstruate - because they are young and have not yet reached the age of puberty - the ‘iddah in the case of divorce is three months. This clearly indicates that it is permissible for a young girl who has not started her periods to marry. Encyclopedia of medical jurisprudence: The waiting period for the little girl who has not menstruated is counted as three months, in accordance with the saying of the Most High: “and [also for] those who have not menstruated” [Qur’an 65:4].

[@ReasonedAnswers]

@@ProphetpuppetMtm _"I do not know how you manage to stay so calm."_ IC has the peace of Jesus Christ living inside him. Just saying. :)

[@ReasonedAnswers]

@@thecommenter715 _"Traditionally, across the globe, the age of consent for sexual union was a matter for the family to decide, "_ So you are saying culture, not God's will, determines morality in Islam. Noted.

[@ProphetpuppetMtm]

Sorry unrelated comment, lol Have you watched the last video of " dont convert to Islam"? I had never heard of that particular poet Muhammad seems to have plagiarized his poetry from. What is your take on it? Could this be an interesting subject for you to discuss in a video? Thank you and sorry again!

[@Eirexeyes]

It would be great if you could upload your studies of the Islamic sources to a file sharing website so as for us to be able to strengthen our own arguments..

[@IslamCritiqued]

I’ve been adapting the material to an easily available, simple and fast formate for awhile now: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYY61-ndGaf7s

[@karlmollan6691]

Thanx for this great enlightenment

[@kristygemchua]

Need to turn up the volume on all your videos

[@karldunne5595]

The God of the Bible wipes the floor with all others!!....... 👍.

[@evadlee5883]

Just keep up the good work....

[@t3zw132]

This is a good channel fact checking Islam. I actually landed here after speaking to a Muslim, your video was suggested to me. I kid you not, he was defending wife beatings and told me he believes what it is in the quran, if it is there, God wants it that way. I feel sad, really sad these people abuse their women because they think that is the way of Allah. Really horrible.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Please see this resource. It may help in your dialogues with Muslims: kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYY61-ndGaf7s

[@t3zw132]

Islam Critiqued ok. Thank you.

[@AlexAlex-ie7bd]

Thank you for once again shattering the sacred blah blah blah hhh XD

[@IslamCritiqued]

The subtitle of that book always cracks me up.

[@manithor7572]

Congrats 'islam critiqued' you know Islam much much more than an average Muslim. As a matter of fact, they know practically nothing. They should be ashamed of themselves. However They are the most brazen people on the face of the earth😏

[@coffeecup7084]

Wow I loved it!

[@djaflo]

probably most underrated izlm critic on youtube, and if that would not be the case: his "comment" section is certainly under the microscope of google's AI-censoring bot...probably the most scrutinized one of youtube

[@kvler4785]

Good job Islam critiqued, one of your videos on David Wood channel just got banned from Pakistan!🤣🤣🤣

[@IslamCritiqued]

Are you kidding?

[@kvler4785]

@@IslamCritiqued No sir, please watch the latest D-Wood vid

[@xenoblad]

Isn't all the critiques of this video applicable to all conceptions of an omnipotent deity with a punishment/reward system?

[@mikkelhansen9419]

Good job. Thanks a lot.

[@patat7196]

would you care to share your thoughts about manuscripts of the O.T? as an example the Septuagint, masoretic etc. Which one would be reliable in your opinion? as the masoretic text compiled very late which is used by almost all English versions today misquote if you compare with N.T. Would you care to make a topic on this?

[@IslamCritiqued]

It's not something I would produce a video on. I don't always default to one or the other. In places where differences exist, it's helpful to evaluate all of the available readings. This is easily done these days, at least from the perspective of collecting the data. On the LXX though, one interesting and more recent (early 90's) development is the recognition that assumptions of a different text type, based on the LXX's rendering of the Hebrew which would appear at variance with the MT, are often flawed. Overall, the LXX appears to be from a Heb text that was substantially the same as what we call the MT. Of course in places where we can check, Isaiah scroll for example, the Hebrew text has been meticulously copied.

[@patat7196]

@@IslamCritiqued the parts im refering to would be when the new testament directly quotes the old, the passages dont really match or have things cut out in the masoretic. I can give u just a fast example: in luke 4:18-19 it says: "The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he hath anointed me to preach the gospel to the poor; he hath sent me to heal the brokenhearted, to preach deliverance to the captives, and recovering of sight to the blind, to set at liberty them that are bruised, to preach the acceptable year of the Lord." Masoretic isaiah 61:1-2: "The Spirit of the Lord God is upon me; because the Lord hath anointed me to preach good tidings unto the meek; he hath sent me to bind up the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and the opening of the prison to them that are bound; to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of vengeance of our God; to comfort all that mourn." LXX isaiah 61:1-2: "The Spirit of the Lord is upon me, because he has anointed me; he has sent me to preach glad tidings to the poor, to heal the broken in heart, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and recovery of sight to the blind; to declare the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of recompence; to comfort all that mourn." "and recovery of sight to the blind" which we find in luke is missing in the MT text. I can give u more examples if you want.

[@IslamCritiqued]

What is your question?

[@patat7196]

@@IslamCritiqued do you think these differences are significant in the preservation of the MT?

[@IslamCritiqued]

"Opening" in Is 61:1 is a reduplicated form that can refer to opening eyes wide (cf Is 42:7). The meaning in Is 61:1 would be that prisoners are let out of their dark dungeons in to the light of day. This goes right along with Luke's Gospel where Jesus made this a reality in more ways than one. "Do you think these differences are significant in the preservation of the MT?" That answer should be obvious.

[@blindvision4703]

Thank God our God is love. Let’s step at the end. God bless you and yours.

[@Crimsonterminator100]

What are your thoughts on Dr. Wood

[@IslamCritiqued]

He's an evil christian missionary cross worshiping racist islamophobe! Seriously though, his personal testimony, not to mention Nabeel. Incredible stuff!

[@Crimsonterminator100]

@@IslamCritiqued your sarcasm is on another level!

[@IslamCritiqued]

I'm just surprised Allah hasn't replaced D Wood with someone else. He likes that kind of thing.

[@spotthecat2412]

@@IslamCritiqued Apparently 'Allah' is still trying to recover from the kicking he took from the apostle Paul.

[@OrpheusXL]

@@IslamCritiqued Did you not know, that David Wood already had been replaced? Allah replaced him with someone similar.

[@br.j9145]

Haha my mom used to say that jokingly when I made some "smart" but funny comment. "You know, you can be replaced." Of course this was always a joke - if she were serious or actually angry, she would never say anything like that.

[@user-cz8gi2om3n]

Calvinists also believe in double predestination, that God caused the Fall in Genesis 3, and that when 1 John says "God is love" that this is only how the Elect experience God, everyone else is "vessels of wrath".

[@silverjones2317]

May our Loving God bless you and give you the patience (couldn't find the right adjective) to read all that satanic writings.

[@JasonWeaver-qx5nx]

Resilience?

[@jb-vd6bi]

Jay Smith British historian Museum some of the oldest books of the Quran , the Quran wasn't completely put together until a couple hundred years after Muhammad and then it wasn't really completed until 1920s David wood studier of the Qur'an the Hadith

[@dcshel]

Love your channel..but lately your volume is so low I cannot hear what you are saying...please correct this

[@IslamCritiqued]

Lately I've returned the audio back to nominal levels. Previously, I was overpowering the audio and that was causing some additional issues. Aside from audio normalization in post processing, I do a "real world" check on my lousy phone speaker as well. The audio comes through loud enough to hear it the adjacent room. I'm sorry you're having volume issues, though from an editing standpoint, I have to have a target DB level and stick to it. If I start to see more of these types of comments then I'll reevaluate. Thanks David!

[@dcshel]

@@IslamCritiqued fyi..your channel has to be maxed out on my volume whereas others are half volume.. And it sounds really lispy now. I hear all your s's really loud. Maybe it's a distance from the mic issue... I'm not sure.

[@IslamCritiqued]

I just checked D Wood's last video. The averages and peaks are consistently about 3db louder than mine. That's not very much. And his seem a bit on the loud side to me. But overall his voice and intonation is more variable than mine. But I'll look into it more if I see more comments similar to yours.

[@genli5603]

You’re quieter enough to tell the difference but super clear.

[@iferufus9117]

I've been saying this for a long time now the God of bible is not the same as the God of quran........one is peace and one is blood thirsty...........i think i know now the difference among them now.....from the help of this channel and my research i now knw the blood thirsty one...........

[@leemcdonald1342]

I really can't think up a witty response for this video. I tried.

[@IslamCritiqued]

I only delete your copy paste.

[@leemcdonald1342]

@@sayedf11 #Thatswhatshesaid.

[@Josdamale]

Thanks for your well researched video, but a few quotes from the OT do not represent the spirit of Christianity in how God deals ultimately with sinners. While Adam and Eve died, and the world was punished with the Flood, it was specifically to these souls that Christ preached when he descended into Hades, as St Peter reports. It is not just that God laments the death of the sinner, but that he will in the end find a way to bring that sinner back to salvation, even if it is at the deepest place in Hades.

[@IslamCritiqued]

The goal was not to compare how God deals ultimately with sinners. The goal was to compare how God regards human life in the context of catastrophic judgment. In the Quran, successive people groups are wiped out and replaced in a too often repeated cycle of stories. The closest we get to this is in the Bible is the flood account. I have an entirely different interpretation of Peter’s words, but that’s another story. Thanks for your comment

[@Josdamale]

@@IslamCritiqued I just recently subscribed. I like your content - well researched - good arguments - and calm delivery. I get your point of wanting to show that God laments when sinners die or are punished, however, this in itself is incomplete and can be potentially misunderstood. Imagine for a moment God claiming to lament that he must kill the children and animals along with the sinful men at the time of Noah. Such a view of God can be quite disturbing. You might not have thought that but a non-Christian could. Consider, however, if one juxtaposed the Scripture of the world being destroyed by the Flood and Jesus Christ descending into Hades to preach to those who died in the Flood. This may show a Muslim a purpose for the crucifixion that they may have never thought of: namely, how Christ used it to preach to and save the dead. It comes down to: he who believes in Christ will never die. This would show that God not only laments the death of a sinner, but can defeat death to save the repentant sinner. It is a powerful message of love. I felt that simply recounting God's sorrow at the death of a sinner may be construed as insincere grief if he is the Judge punishing the sinner and not also the Saviour saving him. Actually, death becomes a means of salvation through faith in Christ. Good video anyway.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Glad you're enjoying!

[@princejmn]

@@IslamCritiqued may you please link me to the video with your interpretation of Peter's words, as mentioned above? Can;'t find it on your site. You have great content with is calmly and factually presented. May God continue to strengthen you in your work.

[@boliussa]

Good stuff, but can you do a two minute version?

[@IslamCritiqued]

Sure. Watch it at 10x speed.

[@boliussa]

@@IslamCritiqued I think a lot of your material would be well suited supported with a blog. Not sure if I have mentioned that idea to you before.

[@IslamCritiqued]

Other than converting these videos to written form and posting them in the Word Doc, I don’t have time for anything else.

[@boliussa]

​@@IslamCritiqued I'd imagine that you must have some notes that mention your arguments and references.. so posting that.. either as a word document or copy/pasted from word onto a blog.. (it might even retain much of the formatting when copy/pasting). Or converting the video to written form, that'd be helpful..

[@IslamCritiqued]

I already do that. Please see pinned comment.

[@nukeplatine]

But I will add in the Genesis account, that God has made the 1st testament: that He will never again wipe out humankind. Which makes all the difference.

[@lorefox201]

so, Islam has no ground to prohibit abortion.

[@DandyLion2024]

Allah sounds more and more like a woman who lives to shop and just can't decide if she wants one outfit or the other outfit

[@MarkProffitt]

Normalize the volume to -3db it's impossible to hear you

[@nukeplatine]

Have I any pleasure in the death of the wicked? saith the Lord; and not rather that he should return from his way, and live? As surely as I live, declares the Sovereign LORD, I take no pleasure in the death of the wicked, but rather that they turn from their ways and live. Turn! Turn from your evil ways!

[@hannahgenneath4152]

Well explained brother but can't u get some one to give Tamil translation for the Muslims whose mother tongue is Tamil

[@MadolcheGabbana]

@Comment Section (The Adversary, the Enemy) Satan, Shaitan, Iblis. The Devil IS NOT named Lucifer. That’s a Position the angel, Samael had. A Morning Star. But his name isn’t Morning Star, or Light Bringer, or Enlightenment, Illumination, etc. he doesn’t ever deserve to even be mistaken of having such a title, for there is NO light in him. Samael, Samiel, سمائل Samail; means the “Venom of God" the “Poison of God", or "Blindness of God" That’s why pagan merchandizing has Samael x Lilith all over it, etc. [and a Disclaimer to Apocryphal readers, Shamhazai, Shamyaza of Enoch is NOT Samael. Just a copy cat who was inspired I’m sure by Samael’s rebellion, who did take a third with him but we’re never shown when and where, so over time and in events like Mt. Hermon, the fall of his messengers took place) Edit note: Oh and Allah is definitely Samael.

[@nssratchet]

Sounds like Hydra's algorithm.

[@shaxjack4717]

Where can I contact you? I want to talk to you about something.

[@shaxjack4717]

@yabon banania lol I am talking to the owner of the KZbin channel. If you have some way that I can contact him please share it I have so many questions

[@nativeking698]

@@shaxjack4717 In one of his other videos, he placed his email address in the description box.

[@shaxjack4717]

@@nativeking698 can you link me the video

[@nativeking698]

@@shaxjack4717 kzbin.info/www/bejne/n6LYY61-ndGaf7s

[@IslamCritiqued]

Yes, I don't put my email out in every video. If I have some extra busy weeks coming up I'll generally withhold it since I won't have time to respond anyway. Shax has been in touch. Thanks!

[@pjetri24]

That seems like Calvinism lol (minute 06:30)

[@IslamCritiqued]

You’d have to ask a Calvinist.

[@genli5603]

Calvinism makes an intricate theological device that can’t actually go. Very carefully argued but missing the larger point. Typical German failing. If Calvinism were correct, the gospels and all the rest of the Bible is pointless. God would just shoot us with belief guns. Bang! Irresistible grace! Bang! There is something irresistible in terms of the individual experience, but rebellion was always possible. To make God’s grace narrowly and literally irresistible is to make the lesson of the garden mean nothing. The lesson of the entire story of Israel means nothing.

[@MrX-ve8hc]

Lol it does.

[@TheMountAndBladerX10]

@@genli5603 as a german id like to point out that calvinism, going by its namesake is french/swiss

[@raashidjunaid1841]

So.... the reasoning for the way it's written is because it's guidance. How do you guide your sons and daughters? Do you not get frustrated when they don't listen to you? and also could you also expand on the other things that Kidr did? Now let's put you into the shoes of a ruler/king, would you listen to anyone disrespecting you? And no one was killed just for that except they went to excessive measures with their intensions. Rather than quoting hadiths, would recommend having the story behind it.

[@majormohitsharma7701]

Is substituting them a better option and if it is supported by Sharia then it is disgusting because you are comparing the current human with a future better one. And if God is a ruler he should be tolerant. Because many idiots mock and disobey god intentionaly he can't take everyone so seriously all the times. And according to you if allah is a god who cannot tolerate this kind of behaviour than why does he act upon himself. Why does he needs humans to execute these judgements. If he is already frustrated because muslims don't have Sharia in all the countries and muslim belief is intolerant so god of Islam turns out to be silent. So he is more tolerant than muslims are according to your logic.

[@michaela.kelley7823]

Children apparently can't speak about Mhhamed either. I recently heard a story where a family in the middle east were out eating. The parents of the child told him to hurry up and ear, but his soup was hot. The child said " if muhamed himself were here, I could not eat this any faster" he didn't even say anything negative about muhamed, he was actually praising him, nonetheless, they took the child to the middle of the town, where the child was slaughtered. Muslims, what did the boy say, that was offensive to muhamed? The boy told the truth. Muhamed couldn't have miraculously cooled the boys soup down, considering allah didn't give muhamed any miracles, because ya know, the miracles of the early prophets didn't work. Oh but they did, they always did. Did Moses miracles bring the Jews out of Egypt. Yes. So then they worked. Did Jesus being born of a virgin, dying and resurrecting work. Looks like it did. In fact, it changed the whole world. Back then, and now

[@FBI-ju5no]

Yeah, the answer to his last question SHOULD be obvious. Spoiler: it's not the quran one.

[@redraven1410]

Thank you for speaking truth to the lie of Islam.

[@cecilou7383]

Very interesting. Like dystopia about an omnipotent but not necessarly benevolent God (films as I am mother).