The real reason menstruating Hindu women do not visit temples | Sinu Joseph ji

[@laenus]

The architecture and vastu of old temples is totally different from new temples ! New temples being built on whims and fancies of trusts and politicians is a wasted excercise.. The energies of old temples is something, the scientific community must explore at length. Ancient technology was more advanced !

[@SadanandkG]

This is the reason, how these temples are the carriers of cosmic energy centres. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@akashbfx3586]

Ancient technologies were good that's y they had smartphone in the ancient times

[@yogeshjain2676]

Ancient archaeological technologies surpass current technology. Many of the old constructions are still unexplainable/reproductible by the modern technologies.. so having a smartphone doesn't make you smart

[@akashbfx3586]

@@yogeshjain2676 by some andh believer the new temples are made same style as ancient style (nagara,kalinga,Dravida,etc) and there is no defference and vastu shastra is still practiced and vastu shastra is nothing , just climatology for india and it doesn't work for other countries Some ancient Hindu belivers won't agree

[@yogeshjain2676]

@@akashbfx3586 I think your earlier comment and current comment are both contradictory. In your earlier comment you were mocking the old technology "Ancient technologies were good that's y they had smartphone in the ancient times" In your recent reply you are saying - the new temples are made same style as ancient style (nagara,kalinga,Dravida,etc) and there is no defference. Please take one stand please..

[@vasanth3371]

If modern science is a drop The science of sanatana Dharma is entire ocean That's the truth for you Jai shri Ram

[@koushiksengupta5784]

Jai shree ram :)

[@davidflinch4139]

Jai Sri ram using modern technology but it's nothing then why don't you stop using mobile phones? Preach what you do

[@vasanth3371]

@@davidflinch4139 I didn't mean stupid things like mobiles and cars What I meant was the core of spirituality And principles of karma , mukti ,moksha And as a matter of fact I don't belive earth was made in 7 days 😂😂😂

[@davidflinch4139]

@@vasanth3371 you said modern science is a drop compared to Sanatan dharma. Okay now tell me what's the equivalent of the internet back then and if cars were stupid did we have space ships before?

[@vasanth3371]

@@davidflinch4139 ever heard of akashic records ? That's internet And being advanced doesn't mean going on creating technology and destroying mother earth Living with earth in harmony is important

[@kawaii_neko_meow_meow]

I am a Hindu girl and even though I touch deities and attend pujas on my periods I have never experienced any kind of bad or irregular menstruation health. I think it's because of our mindsets which make our body react to it. If we think that we are impure and stay away from temples then on the uncertain days like those women who you've mentioned, might suffer and if we don't think like that then in real nothing will happen. I am an empath and I can sense energies around me. And for me I have never experienced energy imbalance just because I am on my periods and I have entered a temple.

[@nirnaytyagi8367]

First of all I want you to understand this never considers women as impure....secondly about the fact that there are certain energies or this whole concept .....so I also wondered why peepal tree has ghost on it at night ...the simple reason was it emits out co² at night so we should avoid being close to it....also that we should not chew basil or tulsi....just because tulsi mata ka apman hai....no reason behind that is .....tulsi leaves have arsenic and certain elements ....that if chewed can harm the outer layer of your teeth and so you can boil them or cook them aur take them with water or directly consume them without chewing.....so everything had a scientific reason but common people couldn't understand those ...so stories are made and with many more ways people were made to believe it........coming back to the point ...you see in ancient times geometry in india was so extensively studied ...that what we call as temples were education centres and spiritual centres....and were made with so much of precision and accuracy....selecting a specific region...building it up with such complex geometry....so as to attain certain energy levels....so these energies definitely affect our body systems ....if we say by science that gravitational pull of moon cause tides ....a very huge volume of water is affected ....so don't you think that energy also affects fluids in our body .....and biologically a women's body systems are far more complexly designed than that of males .....so to protect them and keeping in mind the health of women it was considered.....in your case I would like to say ....see all of us are different in some or the other ways .....may be your body is not that sensitive to those energies as comapared to someone else........my opinion definitely does not mean women should not go to temple or someone should restrict women from going to any temple.....but certain precautions or safety measures should be taken considering all of this.....for example there are a lot of temples in karnataka where men are not allowed ....does this mean discrimination....no not at all....there is certain discretion......so similarly....if women are not allowed to enter under certain conditions....it is definitely not a discrimination....it is discretion.....

[@kanchantinaikar4390]

Even I have touched deities and everything near God while on my period .. nothing ever happened nor it will in future. All this lady is speaking it propagate is pseudo science. People are again blindly following such crap !

[@DiabloNemes]

i just want the wriiten evidences.....even in Garbha Upanisad(ancient book on pregnancy) nothing like that mentioned

[@koteswarris8949]

@@DiabloNemes people did not have to write it down. It was implied.

[@radhikaraman8320]

@@nirnaytyagi8367 so well explained.

[@twinklekarmakar741]

When I was having periods my mother said by mistake also don't came in puja gharh. After some times my father came to home and his one eye has become big and red so painfully seeing that I was totally forgot about my period and rush towards puja gharh and worship lord Shiva after some times my father's that eye became well after that I realised that I having periods and few minutes ago I was in puja gharh but nothing happens😌 In future If I have daughter than i will never stop her to go puja gharh

[@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792]

Your mom is more sensible and matured than you... Respect for your mom.... She did that to preserve our culture and heritage... But a mlecche d@ughter broke that Tradition by not listening to her mom.. What an Excuse you gave by naming Lord Shiva in this.... At last you're mom is much more civilized and culturally matured than you... Har Har Mahadev 🔱🔱🔱 Namaste 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕉️🧿🇮🇳

[@shreyashidash7526]

Tysm mam..

[@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792]

@@shreyashidash7526 Why Tysm for her comment , Ma'am....

[@shreyashidash7526]

@@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792 once I went to temple durring mensuration.. So ty.. For your pure words.

[@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792]

@@shreyashidash7526 Why breaking our thousands of years of followed heritage of not going to temple while menstruation 🥺🥺🥺.... What do you get from this , you can chant mantras no issues , but why de$troying the sanctity of the temple, If you go accidentally no issues in that , but purposefully for going ag@inst the Culture is very bad..... Many women don't go to temple, after being educated and realizing our value of Sanatana Dharma but ppl like you are de$troying the sanctity after being educated and acting like m@$culine fem!n!$ts.... The rule applies for both women and men... If our body is impure and the bathing is necessary...and during periods there is a constant flow of blood , and a positive place like temple, will get affected.... We men never enters the doorsteps of the temple without bathing and cleansing our body and make it pure.... If you have true devotion and the God or Goddess you believe in then you won't try to bre@k the thousands of years followed rules... And don't say that we are more intelligent then our ancestors and we are intellectuals... Namaste 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕉️🧿🇮🇳

[@ramadevilingaraju5375]

I agree that we Indians have been made to think that everything we do is wrong but I'm not sure how the temple atmosphere can affect a woman's menstrual cycle. It is a natural,regular thing.

[@GoutamDAS-ls1wb]

I agree. it is a bunch of BS that the temple atmosphere can affect a woman's menstrual cycle. The writer is obviously not rational!

[@SadanandkG]

Any temple in india constructed as per vastu and as per other rituals is an cosmic energy centre. In the same way our human body is also an energy centre which will have direct influence each other. Cosmic energy can't be seen with a naked eye. Main source of energy concentrated we get from garuda dwajam ( a very big with a considerable height over which a set of small metallic bells as per the vedic specifications in adharvana ved. Some stringent rituals were also performed at time of the erection of dwaja sthambha. The distance between deity ( idol ) and the dwaja sthambha is predetermined as per specifications. The main deity in the garbha gudi is also placed as specified according to the vedas. There is so much to talk about the temples. But for now, let's not discuss about this here. The cosmic energy is received by dwaja sthambha and then is transferred to the deity and then to the light offered by purohit/ poojari/pandit and then to the sata golam and bells. The food we offer to the God/ goddess is refined celestial. This is one of the reasons which will have an impact on a lady who undergo the menstrual period. Jai shree ram.

[@preethishetty6179]

the flow of spiritual energy in temples is upwards like the kundalini. While the as per Ayurveda the direction of apana vayu that controls the period activity in our body is downwards .

[@ashashetty6414]

Yes very true

[@gumnaam4302]

@@GoutamDAS-ls1wb everything is bunch of BS for jutiyas

[@Godzilla9]

Madam sorry to say that you are mistaken. nothing will ever happen if a girl/woman enters any temple in whatever state, particularly menstruating state. there is absolutely no evidence to back your claim. if a temple is the house of god, and god is a creator, god will never harm his own child. Right? please be at peace.

[@preethishetty6179]

What you see in the temple isn’t the creator . That what we call the source if creation / Brahman is formless , attributeless . The idols are energised bodies mostly for which prana Prathistah is done and different idols are energised for different purpose and different ways . Not all places have same effect on you . There is a whole science behind creation of idol and the purpose. The temple culture is mainly prominent in kaliyug . Vedic period didnt have that Much importance to temples as yeh society was in a different mindset and mode then today . The basic consciousness of both this periods are quite different .

[@preethishetty6179]

@Megha Singh some experiences are difficult to explain when people talk rationally . As a women we can under stand better . I have every reason to believe her , as I know I have paid price for my rebellious attitude about menstruation during my teenage . I have better health now after I am mature enough to respect the traditions . But now I can see sense and understand the reason behind it after watching her .

[@mystique9337]

As she said it's not possible to explain it in such a short time. Please watch these 2 videos by Sinu Joseph so that you understand better the sukshma science of menstruation and also menstruation and temples kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmPNZnp4r96Geqs kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXvHgqyNmsaMjbc Please watch both the videos

[@khushiparmar1843]

First understand wat god is

[@shreeram3314]

@@preethishetty6179 great knowledge 🙏🏻

[@AM-br5gt]

Temple authoriy should publish the scientific reasons in simple language of certain restriction and spread the knowledge.Then people will understand the main reason behind restrictions.

[@tango2olo]

Gravity.. we are still in the process of "understanding".. still it keeps on working.. and if you disrespect it you will be fuked.. same goes for Hindu laws.

[@preethishetty6179]

And you will have activist at your door and ask you to prove something which is really difficult by some random experiments .

[@AdityaKumar-bl8bd]

You'd have noticed that people often lie to kids about various things. For example, you prevent them from going into a dark room because there may be a cat in there. The purpose of that lie is to prevent the kid from getting hurt in the dark, but if you tell that to the kid, they'll be like 'bitch I fell 20 times today, I don't care' but when you tell them that the room has something that they are afraid of then they won't go. Now, if you tell someone that don't go into the temple during certain time it'll harm you. They'll say that penance is also devoution (that's why people did Tapa in the past). So, how do you prevent a devoutee from going to their Dev/ Devi? By telling them that it'll displease their Dev/ Devi because no devoutee wants to displease their Dev/ Devi just like no Dev/ Devi would want their children to suffer. The scientific reasons that you talk about was also passed down from generation to generation from one priest to another and other such knowledgable people otherwise after few generation the people of the past would themselves have gotten rid of it by calling it illogical but they didn't because of which we still have such practices in place. If you're wondering why we don't know of such reasons today then read the history of past 1000 years and you'll get some idea. I, myself, don't fully agree with everything in the video but being open to an explanation is better than calling everything that you don't agree with/ understand illogical.

[@vijaym7475]

Why are men and women not fighting for men? Below are the list of temples where men are not allowed only women are allowed!!!! Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Brahmaji Temple in Rajasthan. ... Kamrup Kamakhya Temple in Assam. ... Kumari Amman Temple in Tamil Nadu. ... Mata Temple in Bihar. ... Trimbakeshwar Temple in Maharashtra. ... Chengannur Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Kamakhya Temple in Andhra Pradesh.

[@abcde1646]

With all due respect to the lady , Hinduism teaches to question whenever you have a doubt ,unlike Islam which teaches to follow without questioning. The WHY needs to be answered and a few examples will not clarify doubts. I personally know of hundreds of women who have visited temples , kept place of worship in the bedroom without any menstrual problems .

[@saniyalanjekar]

🙌🏻

[@khushiparmar1843]

Before asking question WHY , we must be ready to know about through our own experience and take efforts to use our brain

[@abcde1646]

@@khushiparmar1843 Thank you for your advise . Those having brains try to look for & follow scientific evidence, Logic ,& experience. Listen to everyone but question every new thought. Others will try to chase shadows , which support whatever has been taught since childhood.

[@ayushmishra8628]

@@abcde1646 again that science logic. Why you all think that science is absolute? It's evolving and changing constantly. To put it simply, modern science is not that advanced to explain this. Period. I'm a science student and I know what I'm saying

[@abcde1646]

@@ayushmishra8628 I am a student of science for a little over the last sixty years . I am still asking questions, seeking logical statements based on experience & formed a habit of not accepting anyone's statement without any of the above.

[@saloniabrol7967]

Never happened to me I do all Worship during my periods even the day I have started the going temple during menstruation my cramps are gone somewhere as I just pray to my Maa❤️bless me so I can do bhajans and chant even in this situation and I have experienced her blessings, in fact, I kind if got benefits for doing the ulta😂❤️🙏

[@shreyasharma7206]

Your family allows you. You r so fortunate dear

[@koteswarris8949]

You probably went to a recently built temple (ie temples which weren't built according with the ancient architecture)

[@kanchantinaikar4390]

So do I . . All this makes no sense to me really. People follow such cr@p blindly .. Request you to report this page .. she is spreading unnecessary illogical stuff everywhere

[@koteswarris8949]

@@kanchantinaikar4390 What about the girls who actually faced negative effects because of it?

[@Nimi_Shruta]

Me too dear and my family allows me 😌

[@mythical_dreams613]

Women in vedic age used to pray while being on their periods.

[@malinighosh1836]

28 years of trying to find out what is the reason I was taught not to visit temples during my periods and finally now I’ve been able to understand it..

[@Teamup353]

Menstruating women are basically Untouchable in Hinduism. In this I will provide evidence from Hindu scriptures and how Hindus generally treat menstruating women . first comes vedic texts. . Taittiriya Samhita 2.5.1 “one should not address a menstruating woman, nor one should sit with her, one should not eat her food for she keeps emitting the color of Brahamana murder” . Taittiriya Brahamana 3.7.1 “ Half of his sacrifice is destroyed in the case of hik whose wife becomes untouchable (menstruating) on the day” . Gautama dharamsutra 14.30 “When a man has touched a Menstruating woman, Chandala, corpse; he should bath” . Gauatam dharamsutra 17.9 “Food becomes unfit if touched by menstruating woman” Vishnu smriti 5.104 " If a menstruating woman touches a High caste man, she should be whipped " . Vashishtha dharmasutra 5.5-6 "woman in her courses is impure during three (days and) nights. . During that period) she shall not apply collyrium to her eyes, nor anoint (her body), nor bathe in water; she shall sleep on the ground; she shall not sleep in the day-time, nor touch the fire, nor make a rope, nor clean her teeth, nor eat meat, nor look at the planets, nor smile, nor busy herself with (house-hold affairs), nor run; she shall drink out of a large vessel, or out of her joined hands, or out of a copper vessel. . Baudhayana dharamsutra 1.9.5 “ One should bathe with his clothes on After touching a menstruating woman” . Vashishtha dharamsutra 23.33 “If seonenhas touched menstruating woman, pyre , cemebtry, he becomes purified after completely washing and submerging in the water” . Manusmriti 3.239 “Menstruating woman, Chandala and dogs shouldn't look at eating brahmins” . Vishnu smriti 82.6-9 “one should not look at a menstruating woman, nor a dog nor a village hog” . So basically when Hindus prohibit Entry of menstruating women in temples, they are following their Hindu rules. . Here are some real life incidents in Hindu society. . Hindu temple declares it will only allow women to enter once a scanning machine is designed to check nobody going in her menstruation . Source menstruatingwww.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-3332227/Hindu-temple-declares-allow-women-enter-scanning-machine-designed-check-going-menstruating.html . Women Barge Into Temple That Prohibits Women. Priests Purify It With Cow Urine After They Leave . Source www.indiatimes.com/news/india/women-barge-into-temple-that-prohibits-women-priests-purify-it-with-cow-urine-after-they-leave-248748.html

[@daminipatil1159]

@@Teamup353 here another one comes with his 2 rupees propaganda...

[@shreya9143]

@@daminipatil1159 lolllllll

[@Teamup353]

@@daminipatil1159 Hindoos cant handle facts

[@satyendrsingh6071]

@@Teamup353 bro don't play victim card, Menstrual blood is for reproduction, and that time people have feeling of lust. And also a men having semen in his underwear or having sexual feelings or erect penis donot go to temples. Same women at the time of menstruation have sexual desire at the top, hence they are also not allowed. That's the reason people say that take bath before Pooja. Have a our mind and soul, at the time of men having erect penis and women having menstruation they can't focus on Pooja, they are highly indulged in sexual desires. In temple you are for faith and devotion not to practice how to control your sexual desires. Men in public are also afraid of getting sexual feeling, women sexuality is internal but men sexuality is external, hence it can easily be caught. So men till today use wear pants and fashion is not have great options for men, same women have sexual desires at the time of menstruation, and temple is for devotion, also know even blood through cutted finger is sin in temples. Or fights, agression, abuse, or anything that falls under the category of lust. "Lust distraction that is not helping you to achieve your goal" 🙏

[@aashusuryavanshi8531]

Every story has many sides...we can even get N no. of stories of girls visiting temples and still having everything perfect and also stories of girls not getting periods on time even after following all rules and regulations! There might be possibilities of getting effected by energies of both type either+ve or -ve but making rules mandatory like harsh restrictions with no exceptions and making periods fell like a punishment..its cruel ! At the same time making assumptions and restrictions on basis of stories , not make sense ! Nothing is ever mentioned in any holy book. And now a days getting irregular cycle and cramps is majorly due to unhealthy lifestyle and food habits. So girls are requested to adopt for health lifestyle , thought process and food habits instead of supporting these taboos.

[@Ramgovindan]

I am happy with this explanation but to i believe that there is a simple reason for these taboo. When else is it taboo to go to the temple??? Some of the times you are asked not to go to the temples are 1) when there was a death in the family 2) when a child is born in the family 3) when a lady is having her menstruation 4) when a child has come of age 4) Also when someone has measles or chicken pox etc. This is science that if there is a death then there is an incubation period for a disease since there are no way to know how a person has passed on. Then when a child is born , the immunity level of the child is weak so the family is asked not to go to the temple for fear of contacting a fatal disease and passing it on to the baby or to the child who has come of age. Its all in the name of prevention and if you tell this to the normal people they will not listen so the reason for the fear story that the God will punish them for going into the temple. Off course the are also some energies within the temple but i believe these energies are all to do good for the individual rather then harm to anyone. This is only my take on the understanding of this taboo.

[@khushiparmar1843]

Every energy is different and not for everyone. So if there is any such restrictions regarding certain temples..it's better to follow that

[@nirnaytyagi8367]

@@khushiparmar1843 I wish people try understand this....but they only think of it as discrimination....and not as discretion....it is not prohibited but it is a precautionary measure

[@aashusuryavanshi8531]

I loved your sensibility ..logic and this explanation

[@talented_ignorant]

I just have a thought that energy is energy. Just like electricity. If u have proper circuit u will benifit, if not u might get shock/effected. By default energy energised and women body in certain situation is not compatible. It's not because God is bad and want to effect women or neither like God is good and kind so does not effect.

[@hypatia123456]

Iv never experienced this even once..n iv been very fertile...no cramps...no excess bleeding...no irregular menstrual cycle....this is not an explained...no science here...this could be just a hormonal reaction to guilt n fear induced...thank you..I can go to temples during my period...coz after all the diety does not mind it at all ...to everyone calling this an explanation...its not...where is the science again....its based on individual biased experiences

[@hypatia123456]

@ read the book...the serpant power...by John woodroffe...its a genuine suggestion

[@koteswarris8949]

Nah you probably went to a temple which is not bulti according to a the ancient architecture.

[@hypatia123456]

@@koteswarris8949 vadakunadan temple, thrissur kerala, more than 2000 years old...renowed for its vasthu...in world heritage sites... Shankaracharya has prayed there...please look it up

[@hypatia123456]

@@koteswarris8949 being on your period is just a physiological process....nothing to do with God...what's the point if mind us corrupt n then praying....is a period worse than a corrupt mind?..if ones mind is clear, God will only welcome you

[@koteswarris8949]

@@hypatia123456 oh my goodness, are you serious ? Even after 2atching the video you are saying it's about god. No it isn't. Its about the energy that the temple exudes. I'm glad that nothing happened to you, but...again...its just that it isn't advisable. I have seen the testimony of plenty of other gurls who reported to have bad experiences after going to the temple during their periods (and no, they did not have prior knowledge about this).

[@sv-nb8ev]

I'm a Hindu I'm a woman I go to temple in my periods and I'm totally fine 🎉

[@priyaramaiah5116]

I am a GYN doctor and have been for over 3 decades My mother raised me with these same convictions and restrictions. Was never able to actually find a scientific basis for these ideas. I feel everyone is entitled to their opinions and beliefs…but it’s unfair to impose it on others or to even intimidate or guilt folks into following these notions. To my knowledge there is no scientific basis for this. I respect this speaker for her thoughts and opinions but they are anecdotal at best. We all should feel free to analyse and evaluate for ourselves and certainly have the courage of your convictions.

[@pradeepnpatil]

This an insult to the actual scientific contribution of Indians. Stories like these are why world questions Indian culture and and concludes it is oppressive to women. This is silly and nothing she said made sense. Nitpicking scenarios and just telling people what they want to hear.

[@rohithsharma1476]

Agreed. This is only nitpicking of cases.

[@carrad123456]

Even if what she says is true, how much time person spends in temple 45 min max.. will that causes so many health impacts?? Covid 19 will be laughing at her

[@shuktirode8673]

Well to first question you have to know what the body systems actually are.? Whatever she said made complete sense. Our bodies are made up of energy fields and during period the energy is directed towards the earth. During periods you are more susceptible to energies. Temples have tons of positive energy. You can consider temple equivalent to a mobile tower with lots of energy gathered around. Now if you are susceptible and you go in temple this energy tends to flow within you and cause problems.

[@shuktirode8673]

And to understand periods you have to have them or understand the very science of it. Looking at you people you have never gone through it. If you don't know plz don't comment or before commenting get your knowledge checked.

[@meghaaraathore4058]

I have experienced what she is saying.

[@kalagapalagam]

We need more information on the scientific or ayurvedic basis for her claims of entering a temple during your period causing irrevocable damage. All of the "evidence" here is anecdotal.

[@rawheat9]

I wouldn't confuse her misinterpretation of Hinduism as scientific. Sadly there are thousands of people like this using pseudo science to promote their gibberish. She suggests that the energy in the temples causes menstrual cramps.. which does not explain why millions of non hindu women across the world also have menstrual cramps. The only thing she will end up providing is more gibberish. Hinduism is pure science and not pseudo science hence people like these only end up tainting this great philosophy.

[@nishikural6058]

Ok.. u still haven’t answered our question.. what is the reason that causes all this issue to women and why women? How can we believe theses testimonies are real? And not to hate a particular religion or something..(I’m a Hindu) I still haven’t experienced anything what she ever said.. and yes I can go to temples because temples are for all and we can’t oppress someone of their identity regardless of gender, race, age, caste and nationality..i strongly don’t appreciate an information if it doesn’t have any facts or data.. pls come one guys we live in the 21st century.. let’s change

[@aartigujar2279]

Yes right I also want to know the real reason not bhakti vala reason I also heard that diff bhakti reasons

[@nirnaytyagi8367]

First of all I want you to understand this never considers women as impure....secondly about the fact that there are certain energies or this whole concept .....so I also wondered why peepal tree has ghost on it at night ...the simple reason was it emits out co² at night so we should avoid being close to it....also that we should not chew basil or tulsi....just because tulsi mata ka apman hai....no reason behind that is .....tulsi leaves have arsenic and certain elements ....that if chewed can harm the outer layer of your teeth and so you can boil them or cook them aur take them with water or directly consume them without chewing.....so everything had a scientific reason but common people couldn't understand those ...so stories are made and with many more ways people were made to believe it........coming back to the point ...you see in ancient times geometry in india was so extensively studied ...that what we call as temples were education centres and spiritual centres....and were made with so much of precision and accuracy....selecting a specific region...building it up with such complex geometry....so as to attain certain energy levels....so these energies definitely affect our body systems ....if we say by science that gravitational pull of moon cause tides ....a very huge volume of water is affected ....so don't you think that energy also affects fluids in our body .....and biologically a women's body systems are far more complexly designed than that of males .....so to protect them and keeping in mind the health of women it was considered.....in your case I would like to say ....see all of us are different in some or the other ways .....may be your body is not that sensitive to those energies as comapared to someone else........my opinion definitely does not mean women should not go to temple or someone should restrict women from going to any temple.....but certain precautions or safety measures should be taken considering all of this.....for example there are a lot of temples in karnataka where men are not allowed ....does this mean discrimination....no not at all....there is certain discretion......so similarly....if women are not allowed to enter under certain conditions....it is definitely not a discrimination....it is discretion.....

[@bhuvaneshkrishna8474]

@@nirnaytyagi8367 what you said is complete pseudo science

[@nirnaytyagi8367]

@@bhuvaneshkrishna8474 okay😌I am not forcing my point on youm...do research and read and most importantly use your understanding to understand .....If u still feel it's just some Vedic bullshit...ignore it....and please do correct me...

[@harshitha3376]

I think olden days temples were constructed on hill tops and there weren’t much transport facilities and sanitary/hygiene necessities. To reach hill top we need to have a lot of physical strength. During periods women will already be suffering from cramps and also because of lack of sanitary facilities they asked women to stay home for 3 days. Now even in 21st century despite of having all the facilities..people making pseudoscience theories for rules that had been created centuries ago is really foolish.

[@akash8141]

Shame to see that a woman herself telling this 😒

[@dharmendratiwari6498]

Dear respected ma'am.. it might be also possible that the women's cases about whom you were talking, with whom such incidents happened as you said, they may have some medical issues.. some unidentified reasons as you mentioned.. is it necessary that a woman shouldn't enter in temple during her menstruation cycle ..?? If yes, can you please elaborate why entering in a temple affect the menstruation cycle??

[@arghya4731]

It is as she said.... One needs understand suskha Or susma level.... Of anatomy. These Sthulla sarir, susma sarir higher Indian Science you can only in the Atharva Veda, Ayurveda. She suggested us to research and read the Ayurveda. We surely don't have time for that right? most people would not read that's why to protect women they used fear. I hope this answers your question Sir.

[@dharmendratiwari6498]

@@arghya4731 ohh... Is it.. but it's not the right way to create fear in society about that.. we all need to get educated about that too... Bcoz, the people of modern generation will not believe in such kind of things, they only believe in logical things..

[@koteswarris8949]

@@dharmendratiwari6498 unfortunately, the so called modern people, when you try to explain them about different sharirs, they aren't gonna believe either will they take time to do some research. And also, there is not enough advancement in technology to prove that it exists, so...they is actually no way to tell them not to do that other than creating fear, which i know isn't the best way, but to protect them you gotta do what you gotta do.

[@koteswarris8949]

@Shruti Sinha when i said the ord modern, i was talking about those people who are westernized, in almost every way. Like i said, sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do to protect people.

[@ajayv1434]

@@arghya4731 suskha level anatomy and all not required. read basic 12th biology book first and it is not Indian "science", if you use the word science tell me who researched it, who published the paper and share that paper with me. You are very desperate to show that every practice we followed has a meaning. hence you are making up random theories and calling them "science".

[@user-ld6me2yt8o]

this has never happened to me though? i have always had regular and healthy periods.

[@bhoomi4278]

Did u go to temple during periods ? Nothing happened like she said ?

[@user-ld6me2yt8o]

@@bhoomi4278 yeah, nothing as such happened. i've had heavy periods since i was a child. and after marrying my hindu husband and going to temples regularly, nothing really changed in my menstrual cycles. No complications after my pregnancy either

[@army_forever3431]

Same. Lol

[@carrad123456]

@@user-ld6me2yt8o there are many times fears instilled in mind. Even if women body functions more on lower chakra during periods and temple is higher chakra. How much time someone spends in temple , 45 min max. That hardly does any impact.

[@testuser3029]

Sheer absurdity. In fact so demeaning to treat woman as an outcast during this period. N tell me brothers n sisters, in these days of nuclear families, the menstruating mother must forsake her duties?? She can never do that. So why r we lying to ourselves??

[@d.phoenix.5d]

And she just induced fear again at the end by saying, "even if you break this rule once and go to temple, it will definitely have an impact on your period cycle".. 👻 ... and luckily she also said, "don't take my word for it". .. yeap, never take the word blindly from anyone; hear out various perspectives, question their authenticity, test it out its validity "in your own individual experience", and if it matches your experience, incorporate it, if it doesn't, ignore it, and ignore "them".

[@s.d.0]

this is very much needed knowledge specially for the Woke.

[@durgabhawanee9957]

Because the Woke are ASLEEP in their ignorance!!!! lol...

[@naveenantony3924]

did she explain y the imbalance is caused?she just said there are some issues or imbalances among women who goes to temple during their periods...confused... do u know the answer?

[@arghya4731]

@@naveenantony3924 It is as she said.... One needs understand suskha Or susma level.... Of anatomy. These Sthulla sarir, susma sarir higher Indian Science you can only read in the Atharva Veda's, Ayurveda. She suggested us to research and read the Ayurveda. We surely don't have time for that right? most people would not read that's why to protect women they used fear. I hope this answers your question Sir.

[@vijaym7475]

Why are men and women not fighting for men? Below are the list of temples where men are not allowed only women are allowed!!!! Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Brahmaji Temple in Rajasthan. ... Kamrup Kamakhya Temple in Assam. ... Kumari Amman Temple in Tamil Nadu. ... Mata Temple in Bihar. ... Trimbakeshwar Temple in Maharashtra. ... Chengannur Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Kamakhya Temple in Andhra Pradesh.

[@adityabahl7709]

With due respect, Dr. Joseph is referring to anecdotal evidence, at best. I am not saying that the science of “sookshma” is wrong. I am suggesting that science needs to be published and brought to common knowledge. If there is any real world study that demonstrated women developing gynecological issues after visiting temples during their menstrual cycles, would be a mind blowing progress in our medical knowledge. And I am sure in today’s age, such a study won’t go unnoticed! Again, I am not suggesting that Dr. Joseph is wrong. I am simply suggesting that such an interview should be accompanied with hard data.

[@ramphal5439]

Sir, who will do it? 98% of the funds go to allopathy and in the balance 2% there are ayurveda, unani, siddha, homeopathy etc. Baba Ramdev has done well documented research in some areas but instead of reading that people will simply start ridiculing him under an agenda. Sir, who will do research as there is no business there in Ayurveda etc and big business is in allopathy. 🙏🙏

[@bhuvaneshkrishna8474]

@@ramphal5439 "Well documented research" means peer reviewed scientific papers that are published in international journals... Not a random baba sending out flyers

[@missbubblemaker26]

thank you

[@Goghwithflow]

Sorry to say... But I visit temples , do Puja and everything during periods and nothing has happened to me... Infact my cramps are also gone. Everything is fine with me.

[@TheBhaskarsingh]

YOU CANT BLAME GOD... IF YOU ARE SUFFERING FROM BAD LIFESTYLE AND RESULTS ARE ON PHYSICAL BODY...

[@smritipuppala3322]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHaUkGNuqJiEbLc

[@joyeetaroy1546]

Hindu women should decide for themselves whether they want to work or rest during their menstruations

[@ultimate6243]

Will you drive Motor Cycle after drinking alcohol? Why not? Because We know it will have bad results. Same way. Women should take rest during menstruation or it will have bad results.

[@joyeetaroy1546]

@@ultimate6243 Answer me one question , is driving motor cycle after consuming excessive amount of alcohol and being in a menstruations circle the same thing ? Obviously not . When you're drunk you can't walk properly and loose the sense of humours . But when you're bleeding you still have a full functional brain and can walk and talk all you want . Most of the people think a woman going through menstruations is impure when it's a natural circle . Again if our religious scripture clearly said that women go through a tough time during this period and they should be well rested and nothing is bad about it I would've accepted this . Moreover every women's experience is different when it comes to "monthly bleeding". Then also our society needs a deep healing when it comes to menstruations so don't put restrictions on women blindly based on whatever a particular person or a group people promotes . When women make choices for themselves that's what we can call empowerment . Lastly she just went around the topic without properly acknowledging it . When you discuss about a stigmatized issue , don't just put few words and leave as if you didn't care

[@FZ-bk9kh]

@@joyeetaroy1546 , poignant observation. Be what may the harm of menstruation and visiting temples, women should retain the autonomy to chose their actions. The restrictions placed on Sabarimala seem less due to concern about the well being of women and more to do with the continual imposition of rules robbing them of deciding on their own.

[@Shivam-kn7yz]

@@FZ-bk9kh i agree but there is another aspect to it eg hanuman is a self-claimed bramhachari , so to respect him womens are not allowed to visit hanuman temple, they can still worship him by themself, there are temples where only womens are allowed to visit because these are particularly made for women that doesn't rob the right of women to worship any deity or visiting all temple another example: everyone has a right to pee just because mens are not allowed in womens toilet doesn't mean they are oppressed and are denied their right to pee

[@FZ-bk9kh]

@@Shivam-kn7yz I agree with you too ...if there is a deity who's temple that women (or men) shouldn't visit for religious reasons then sure. Just saying if the reason presented is that women might be affected negatively if they visit during menstruation then they should be given the right to decide if they still want to proceed. Women are not children to have decisions made for them.

[@DevBishwasBh]

I am from Nepal. And in the west part of Nepal, women are forced to leave their homes while their mensuration. Also, out of the west, women/girls don’t have the right to enter the kitchen, temple, tap or hand pumps, and some parts in Nepal ladies aren’t even aloud to use toilets.

[@NehaSharma-u2k1l]

paschimi haru le dherai badnaam garexa Hinduism Lai sati pratha,chaupadi,chuwachut sabai tyahi bata suru bhako

[@koushiksengupta5784]

Thank you Sinu Joseph ji for sharing this knowledge with us I've always wondered why women didn't visit temple when they were menstruating and the left always tried to portray it as misogynistic.. but I always thought there might be some scientific reason behind it and today I got my answer :) Our sanatan dharma is filled with knowledge and science we must rediscover our ancient knowledge and teach our upcoming generations about it! Once again thank you Sinu ji :)

[@jacintofernandes2907]

So what's wrong with Islamic or Christian cultures that you so openly protest? A little bit of "evidence" is enough to sway your mind. Religion has poisoned your brain

[@lanchenbalairenlakpam9108]

U r gae

[@vijaym7475]

Why are men and women not fighting for men? Below are the list of temples where men are not allowed only women are allowed!!!! Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Brahmaji Temple in Rajasthan. ... Kamrup Kamakhya Temple in Assam. ... Kumari Amman Temple in Tamil Nadu. ... Mata Temple in Bihar. ... Trimbakeshwar Temple in Maharashtra. ... Chengannur Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Kamakhya Temple in Andhra Pradesh.

[@leenathewise8384]

I love Jesus who said I created you so nothing is bad in you.

[@subashiniganasen3601]

I don't think the reasons these women whom was mentioned about had irregular periods and severe pain because they went to temple. Using Sanskrit terms does not mean that what is talked about is true. I go to temple during menstruation, I am still protected and my health improved. It doesn't affect the cycle it cause problems. It is all in the mindset and guilty feeling a person is made to feel that menstruation is unclean

[@prakashsinha5645]

This is absolutely not true ......I went to vaishno devi temple with my periods first day .....I was having period prblm irregular periods.....bt after dats holy visit all my problems went away.....from dat day onwards I started doing Pooja in my menstrual days also .....fact is dat god fearing women will have prblm in their body....I m a god loving girl....nothing bad happened to me....I think women are in the purest form during their period days.....I realised this after visiting the greatest Shakti peeth maa vaishno devi temple with my periods ....do worship with clean heart ... ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@pushpajankandan785]

Sinu Josep.... I bowed my head... Iam proud of you..... Ur knowledge and about our culture... more over she is from a Christian back ground...

[@iradutta7979]

I think she left christianity.

[@vyoshen4563]

Very good information. We should thank this mother for such a evidence based explanation. Pranams to this mother.

[@templetours9]

Kudos Dr Sinu J for your XLent explanation

[@Omniscient_Cricket]

Wow ,most people don't know this. Fools who demean and raise questions against sabrimala temple must watch this video.

[@KashishSolkhiya]

As being a hindu girl...i also went temples many times during my periods...and surprisingly i never felt kind of impurity or doing some kind of sin to visit temple...all i just felt love for my god... their positive energy inside and around me and it has never affect my life badly neither now or ever... and i didn't find any kind of evidence regarding worship of god during women's. thank you lord🙏❤

[@Butterf1y-effect]

What I think is it's all misconceptions created by people!!!! Do you really think God will think so lowly of us ??? Of his own creation??? I bet GOD never really wants this !!! He just want women to rest !! So that's why going to temple during periods is prohibited!! But still if you want you can go !!! I believe in GOD not in foolish people who creates misconceptions!!! Our GODs always respected women !!! And you think they will punish you or have negative effect on you if you worship them during periods???? No way ! GOD IS GOD for some reason they don't have any cheap mentality!!! They can't punish anyone who just want to worship them with full heart 💓 .. I never believed people!!! I go in kitchen too even tho my mom don't allow !!! I know the reason it was made so that women can rest during periods and don't need to work in kitchen!! But people nowadays create misconceptions say that you will commit sin by going to kitchen during periods 🧿...

[@nabinadas3263]

I literally don't go to temple during periods neither much in other days.. But my periods are very irregular and I have cramps. Why?

[@harshasukheja6031]

I have never visited temple during my periods STILL I have irregular and painful periods. You really think these things are interrelated? Thousand years ago, such rules were made because of lack of sanitary facilities, women were asked to rest. Rest from cooking, working, travelling, visiting temples etc because there were no facilities to manage that blood. But now we have sanitary pads, we do thousands of things while we are on our periods. We cook, we work, we travel, we do everything. When all the things are taken off from that list why only temples are still left? Periods are impure? The lady who is on period is impure? If there were no periods how would our births happen? If periods are impure, our birth is impure, this whole creation is impure. Stop this bullshit please.🙏

[@satyendrsingh6071]

bro don't play victim card, Menstrual blood is for reproduction, and that time people have feeling of lust. And also a men having semen in his underwear or having sexual feelings or erect penis donot go to temples. Same women at the time of menstruation have sexual desire at the top, hence they are also not allowed. That's the reason people say that take bath before Pooja. Have a our mind and soul, at the time of men having erect penis and women having menstruation they can't focus on Pooja, they are highly indulged in sexual desires. In temple you are for faith and devotion not to practice how to control your sexual desires. Men in public are also afraid of getting sexual feeling, women sexuality is internal but men sexuality is external, hence it can easily be caught. So men till today use wear pants and fashion is not have great options for men, same women have sexual desires at the time of menstruation, and temple is for devotion, also know even blood through cutted finger is sin in temples. Or fights, agression, abuse, or anything that falls under the category of lust. "Lust distraction that is not helping you to achieve your goal" 🙏

[@mystique9337]

As she said it's not possible to explain it in such a short time. Please watch these 2 videos by Sinu Joseph so that you understand better the sukshma science of menstruation and also menstruation and temples kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmPNZnp4r96Geqs kzbin.info/www/bejne/hXvHgqyNmsaMjbc Please watch both the videos

[@Satyabhamakrishnan108]

Another ignorant so called feminist If your were not allowed to take rest during periods then you fake hypocrite will be crying on discrimination that we need ample rest during periods..chi shame on you people

[@Satyabhamakrishnan108]

If you don't love scientific sanatna dharma then go to peace loving community who see woman as a commodity and to produce babies

[@satyendrsingh6071]

@@Satyabhamakrishnan108 are you a women, you give a very logical answer, but I request you to please read my answer too,. Written above 🙏

[@jyotiprasadpanda8245]

Hats off to Sinuji for her deep understandings of our knowledge systems & convictions on it's efficacies. 🎩🎩

[@kanchantinaikar4390]

It’s nothing but religious cr@p. There’s no scientific evidences! Stop supporting such baseless content

[@jyotiprasadpanda8245]

@@kanchantinaikar4390 kommies resort to cancel any thing that they can't counter. 😁😁

[@vijaym7475]

Why are men and women not fighting for men? Below are the list of temples where men are not allowed only women are allowed!!!! Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Brahmaji Temple in Rajasthan. ... Kamrup Kamakhya Temple in Assam. ... Kumari Amman Temple in Tamil Nadu. ... Mata Temple in Bihar. ... Trimbakeshwar Temple in Maharashtra. ... Chengannur Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Kamakhya Temple in Andhra Pradesh.

[@jyotiprasadpanda8245]

@@vijaym7475 need to wait till some one properly comprehends it.

[@akashpatel8299]

It's ridiculous.

[@DedsoRupiyaDega]

Dr. Sinu Joseph is amazing, Hindu women should learn more from her

[@satyasingh713]

Mind boggling ancient Vedic science - Hindu women should introspect and decide after their own empirical experience. No sense to learn unscientific theory or western logic from so called experts !

[@joyeetaroy1546]

Hindu women should decide for themselves whether they want to work or rest during menstruations

[@tango2olo]

Hinduism is about Dharma, which is the nature of Human Being. You want to have "belief" so be it.. but if you mess with laws of Human nature, that Hinduism, Ayurveda dictates, you will be screwed for sure..

[@ayushmishra8628]

@@satyasingh713 unscientific? Yes because present science cannot explain it. You all have not studied science in detail and always label everything as "unscientific".

[@ayushmishra8628]

@@koteswarris8949 i didn't get your point.

[@hismajestyize]

Please do upload a video with a long explanation for those of us who'd like to know the proper reason.

[@aartigujar2279]

I hear your info twice bt i really can't understand what is under temple why temple impact bad effect on menstrual cycle .. I hear your speech to find scientific reason behind it bt i really don't get any such reasons

[@tej679]

Watch her other videos and read her books Rtu vidya, women and sabarimala

[@amritanshsingh7838]

she didn't showed up any valid reason, neither have I seen such cases as she's telling

[@sanonmars]

I think this is applicable for Old Temples especially like in South which are built with scientific basis so that the people who enter get certain benefit healthvise. And that is harmful for menstruating women's health.

[@dgurunathreddy]

Every temple built with prana prathista will have power, its a process to invoke energy into murti and there are 40 day yagna with continous veda chanting that fills the area with energy and then regular archanas and pooja chant will stabilize the energy. I dont know if there is any person who listens to veda chanting have no effects like goosebumbs or vibrations like feel in body because body keeps vibrating to the sound at particular frequency and to the fact that any sound made vibrates everything around in certain way thats the reason why glass windows break if there is loud sound like blasting

[@koteswarris8949]

@@dgurunathreddy true.

[@harrysimms6742]

I'm laughing beside myself at the nonsensical rubbish being paraded as some kind "ayurvedic science" into the human reasoning as to why menstruating women should not visit temples and the totally idiotic examples given. Even the gods have shortcomings.......design humans in the way they do. Welcome to the modern era, the era of reasoning, rational thought and the beauty of science. NOT

[@ayushmishra8628]

What is time? Please explain Einstein

[@vkj108]

Madam please don't get me wrong this is my sincere suggestion/questions - you should 've also mentioned on all those women who never visited any temple or who do not have a pooja room at home, but still they suffer from cramps, excessive bleeding, irregular cycles, PCOD etc., what mistake did they do? Surely, those who visit temples during periods and get "punished" and those who never visited temples even once during periods but still suffer - who or what punishes them? Is there something we are overlooking? I have some answers but don't know if they are valid. #profvkj

[@carrad123456]

First noone is punished for visiting temples in periods. Stop keeping this in your head. You create your own mindset. If you believe this you will create fear, guilt and shame and later in your own reality manifest same knowingly or unknowingly. Meet your Gynaec .

[@TheKrishna1972]

food and lifestyle also influences ill health and period problems. Our scriptures atr more about prevention than CURE!

[@rawheat9]

@@carrad123456 looks like you just described how how these man made beliefs came about on the first place. People just manifested their own fears into reality. But that is the very reason we need to speak up against these so called pundits and their gibberish pseudo sciences. Hinduism is pure science nor pseudo science.

[@khushiparmar1843]

Going to the temples especially older ones effects one's body this is wat she is saying. She never said people who don't visit temple don't get problems. Please use some brains

[@rawheat9]

@@khushiparmar1843 and I guess what we are saying is that there is absolutely no evidence that suggests going to temples cause menstrual cramps. Just hocus pocus pseudo science.

[@arpitadhar2134]

My periods are always irregular I have never visted temples during periods time

[@Motivation-692]

She is very right. It happened to me… I was ok during my period until I went to the altar to pray and I got severe cramps. It’s better to wait till you’re done. Unless it’s very urgent.

[@yeshwininirwan554]

How the surrounding could affect our internal biological systems or cycle!!...... And there are millions of girls have irregular period and go cramps......this is normal. Sometimes it is effect of hormonal unbalance due to diet or simply PCOS.... whether u go to temple or not during ur menstrual cycle u will get PCOS if you had to!!

[@akshaykumar-gq9wj]

I wonder how temples effect in woman period cycle?

[@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792]

Temples gives a huge cosmic energy which fills the mind with positiveness.... That too in a periods time body gets irritated and weak... If you ask a women you'll understand... Namaste 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🕉️🧿🇮🇳

[@Nothing-uc5mg]

@@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792 I'm a woman and I don't understand it. If temple gives more positive energy to our mind then shouldn't we go more for healthy mind during periods? How these positive energy will affect reproductive system?

[@aadithyanc.koccupyandcolon6792]

@@Nothing-uc5mg Okay , i will ask you a question... If you're going to temple for postive energy... Wilk you ever go to temple.. When you're having fever... Or while loose motion , diarrhea , or without bathing.... If the answer is No.. Then the reason while menstruation the outer covering of the womb is cleaned, so that germs in it is flowed through the V canal ... This is ashuddha... In Biology it's said that clearly during Menstruation women releases bl00d which contains pu$s , g€rms and more.. This is Biology... Now a scientific reason why... Have you ever seen a temple shikara or tomb... It's stands tall... Whereas during periods the energy of the women goes down through they're V canal.. Now don't say that the Normal blood also go and affect our body.. Never because the blood is going on moving through arteries and veins... So it goes up and down.. Whereas the Menstrual blood directly goes down, and there is no come back for it... My mom said what you're seeing in TV ads about menstruation p@ds are not true. Like women This and that work during Menstruation like racing and driving... She said there will be menstrual cramp , headache , stomach ache and more... And hearing the temple bhajan where the mooladhara Chakra faces to the Uttar shikara.. And During periods the mooladhara Chakra faces down... Which creates a negativity within you... I know to prove you're comment you'll say that when I went to temple during periods all felt good.. But that has an affect as well... Even my mom never enters the temple during Menstruation and not Even Pooja room... She says Pooja room is also a mini temple where the lamp is lit.. And I sincerely asked her, during periods women are pure ryt.. She said this... During periods we suffer stomach ache , head ache , cramps and more.. So how it's Divine or pure ?... And she said we're pure during the time when we give birth... And she said how much you go to temple during Menstruation.. You won't feel comfortable as the flow of blood is going down and hearing to the sound of the bell and bhajan will distract the flow and feel you sick.. This is her experience... I promise this what she said.. And I Asked her why Pooja room also she said pooja room is also equavalent temple where lamp is lit and bhajan are Sung.. So it will not be Okay... She said you can chant Mantrams and listen to music..... And during some days my father works at home for help.... This is the best explanation I can give you ma'am.. I gave the scientific explanation , Biological explanation , Chakra explanation and my mother's explanation on this... And FYI there are many temples in bharat especially Shaktha Tantric Temples where during Menstruation women are allowed, many of the Women faces this problem of having menstruation late and early, so these temples fixes it like Kamakhya Devi temple and chottanikara Devi Kshetram and more... That's why we say chakras also place a huge role.... If you've any doubt you can ask.. Namaśthe 🕉️🌺🌸🌿

[@pranavnaresh4675]

You didn't provide scientific evidence for how visiting temple affects women's health. Moreover, if you're depending on women's experience to build up your case, have a pan India data & not testimonies of some women you know.

[@SantoshSatvikL]

If Hinduism is a religion, it does not require any sort of proof from science. Only if you consider it science would you require a proof. And this science is yogic science, not physical science. You need higher sensitivity to dabble in yogic sciences.

[@pranavnaresh4675]

@@SantoshSatvikL what can be claimed without evidence, can be rejected without evidence. If the claim is that temple affects women's biology, you need to provide proof because biology is a Science. Moreover, biology isn't Physical Science, its Natural Science. Natural science deals with living organisms. Also, if you'll read scientific journals, you'll realize a lot of scientific studies are conducted on yogic science, that's how Yoga & Meditation have grown so popular. These studies are conducted via Scientific Method & not by "dabbling in higher sensitivity".

[@koushiksengupta5784]

Hello sir you can get the full information about it in her book ritu Vidya

[@user-fw5qm9vu4s]

@@pranavnaresh4675 u see she has provided the details in her book read it if u wanna know

[@shravberri]

@@pranavnaresh4675 why do you want to verify Ancient Science through Modern Science?? Like, they're completely different things?! Can't you learn Ancient Hindu Shastras without asking for modern scientific justifications for it, please, it's beyond modern science.

[@gurudattag]

So well presented. Thanks for inviting her. And thanks to Sini Joseph for sharing it.

[@priyanshibhattacharjee3789]

Don't just say what happens, explain why those things happen. You're using the word "science" again and again but not explaining the hows and whys, which is what we audience wanted to know.

[@jackandrose2362]

If there is any problem in my menstrual cycle I will take care of it

[@shreyasengupta9510]

She was just as superstitious and orthodox as the next uncle in our indian society. I was hoping to hear a very practical approach and explanation to this taboo and profound stigma. What she said was baseless and didn't make any sense. I hope that you people don't get consumed in such misogyny and detrimental thinking. When we are naturally born with we should learn how to take it normally. It is a personal choice to visit temples or not.

[@carrad123456]

You can make up your own mind in case you have open minded family. Or you can read on Hinduacademy channel. They are very open minded. You can also follow or read about Om Swami ji as I find him most open minded guru today. You may also check out various practices in many places where women in periods do perform yagnya. There is lot to explore.

[@satyendrsingh6071]

bro don't play victim card, Menstrual blood is for reproduction, and that time people have feeling of lust. And also a men having semen in his underwear or having sexual feelings or erect penis donot go to temples. Same women at the time of menstruation have sexual desire at the top, hence they are also not allowed. That's the reason people say that take bath before Pooja. Have a our mind and soul, at the time of men having erect penis and women having menstruation they can't focus on Pooja, they are highly indulged in sexual desires. In temple you are for faith and devotion not to practice how to control your sexual desires. Men in public are also afraid of getting sexual feeling, women sexuality is internal but men sexuality is external, hence it can easily be caught. So men till today use wear pants and fashion is not have great options for men, same women have sexual desires at the time of menstruation, and temple is for devotion, also know even blood through cutted finger is sin in temples. Or fights, agression, abuse, or anything that falls under the category of lust. "Lust is distraction that is not helping you to achieve your goal" 🙏

[@furciferpardalis523]

@@satyendrsingh6071 @Satyendr Singh first of all, please don't compare semen to menstrual blood, semen is a genital fluid which occurs during sexual arousal, and menstrual blood is NOT a genital fluid, it's simply lining of uterus shedding during menstrual phase. Sexual desire can occur to a human, at any time, anywhere, but don't say it mainly occurs during menstrual phase, it occurs mostly during ovulation phase when ovum is secreted, also lust ain't a bad things, most of the Hindu temples have kamasutra scripts, paintings and sculptures built, and hinduism only considered desire as a spiritual thing! Please don't spread pseudo science 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@bhakti64]

i believer her. its duty of every hindu woman to remove the fear and discrimination factor and bring more awareness

[@adithyam9557]

Still not know why it happens.. 🙄she just told what we know

[@Sanskrit_eguru]

I am all about research but just a few references and random examples and also the mention of sukshma sharir so no one knows enough to argue. Simply baseless.. ☺️

[@manasvisharma3949]

That's what the reason , no body knows the knowledge,

[@manasvisharma3949]

Go to knowledge gradually

[@yathindrak1295]

Sinu ji, you are a very knowledgeable person and I respect you. But I have to disagree with you on this. There is no proof of concept for this matter. We have to do a study: select a number of healthy menstruating women (hide from them this perceived connection between idols and menstrual cycle) send them to a temple with idols and see the effect on them. That is the way to find the facts. You know like I do that faith and practices can obscure facts in real life.

[@ankitadasgupta5836]

Hey..She has done this experiment and documented the result in her latest book called Rtu Vidya..If you want to know more you can just give a read if you have not already 🙏

[@FZ-bk9kh]

Agreed. Very hard to take such anecdotal evidence as universal. And the 'science' behind what causes these irregular periods is not explained, only surmised. As usual an appeal to ancestral knowledge and not a reproduceable experiment.

[@ankitadasgupta5836]

@Abhash Khare hey how do you know that she is converted manipulated

[@ankitadasgupta5836]

@@FZ-bk9kh yes.. that's correct..but she has mentioned couple of reference links in her book..and i have gone through most of the links and get to know more.. Menstruation itself is a vast subject..who knows may be she will come with part 2 of this version.. anyway she mentioned in one of her video that not to limit the knowledge to her book..this book is a tip of iceberg..i think now responsibility comes to us to further deep drive and get into the subject..as i found this book extremely helpful in my day to day life..so i will invest more time to this subject 😊

[@babutara7374]

@Abhash Khare how come u know that she is manipulated? a converted manipulated lady person can't have soo much knowledge abt Indian Vedic science, she studied Vedic science at her own will.

[@kanchantinaikar4390]

Why are there no such restrictions while going to a church/ gurudwara.. aint this just a religious myth? Request you to stop spreading such myths !!!

[@Light12187]

Idk about gurdwara and churches but women can't enter in mosques during that time

[@kanchantinaikar4390]

@@Light12187 😂😂 women were not allowed in mosques in earlier eras.. they’ve now allowed them to enter the place of worship! I think being RATIONAL and taking decisions on the basis of logic is important..not anybody’s religious beliefs

[@sushantakarmakar1762]

If Devi Devaki has no menstruation than Krishna never born, if Mother Mary has no menstruation than Jesus never born So women must go temple even she has menstruation

[@vijaykris4653]

Yeah who cares I enter temples even after consuming meat products, it's not a big thing!!

[@carrad123456]

People who don't agree with her follow Amrit varsha Guru Ma, Hindu Academy , Om Swami ji for more clarity. These people have blog which says women should not say Gayatri Mantra ! And Gayatri peeth has more women followers who chant twice daily.

[@khushiparmar1843]

Don't spread hatred. Read her vlog correctly

[@carrad123456]

@@khushiparmar1843 there is no hatred, I like listening to her. But there are alternatives available and people should know them. In Kerala many brahmin families don't allow daughters to chant Om irrespective of periods saying it is not meant for women. While in world over women are chanting it. So there are multiple thoughts in this world on same topic and alternative thoughts should not be crushed but discussed and debated , be merit based and based on each person they may choose what suits their basic composition. That is evolutionary science of humans . It has got nothing to do with hatred. Why should I hate someone who thinks differently than me ?? I am not follower of Abhramic thought process nor a follower of b-l-a-s-p-h-e-m-y laws where any change in thought leads to punishments. Hatred is too strong word for difference in opinion and thoughts.

[@vrajupadhyay9900]

I think we should also bring Praveen Mohan for interview 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@gayatricasey6618]

I second that totally... He has no interviews , I searched everywhere.

[@vrajupadhyay9900]

@@gayatricasey6618 actually he has with a girl who reacts to his videos named indi Rosie. Also he is active on fb and insta. Just search indi Rosie and Praveen Mohan u will find the video 🙏🏼 also he was once or twice called on show called ancient aliens on history TV 18 it's also available in KZbin. Hope it helps 🙏🏼

[@gayatricasey6618]

@@vrajupadhyay9900 thanks dear..yes indie Rosie video I also watched. I'll check out history TV too. But nobody has taken a proper personal interview Of him. I really want that. I wish to know his journey n challenges ..n stuff

[@vrajupadhyay9900]

@@gayatricasey6618 yes me 2 I've been in contact with him a bit around 8 or 9 months ago on insta. Hope someday we can see him on many platforms and also the government collaborates with him 😄

[@gayatricasey6618]

@@vrajupadhyay9900 🙏yes I wish that happens soon.

[@Sonakshi687]

This is actually true because I visited kamakhya during my period and after then my period got irregular and almost stopped. Then I started doing japa of ma kamakhya, now I'm in far more better condition.

[@smritipuppala3322]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHaUkGNuqJiEbLc

[@niara6]

You probably have pcos

[@sheemoheeput9544]

The japa must have calmed your stressed life and mind. That's why you are much better.

[@strotasourceofknowledge2414]

Thank you for explaining it. I will suggest my daughter to watch this video.

[@rashtrawaadi3192]

If going temples in periods have a discussion in veds upanishads then when should follow otherwise i think in temples in pure places we go for spirituality which is not related to physical body but to soul

[@pinakiroychowdhury1976]

Why Indian Christians and Muslims do not understand their ancestors were the Hindus and be proud of that ?

[@vijaym7475]

Why are men and women not fighting for men? Below are the list of temples where men are not allowed only women are allowed!!!! Attukal Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Brahmaji Temple in Rajasthan. ... Kamrup Kamakhya Temple in Assam. ... Kumari Amman Temple in Tamil Nadu. ... Mata Temple in Bihar. ... Trimbakeshwar Temple in Maharashtra. ... Chengannur Bhagavathy Temple in Kerala. ... Kamakhya Temple in Andhra Pradesh.

[@RimaDesu00]

They do have male priest😂

[@veenap4621]

Dear Sinu Maam Hats off to you, you are the first woman in India who has given us perfect knowledge about " Why we should not visit temples during menstrual time ". Thank for this ultimate and scientific reason and solution. Finally perfect answer is out . May God bless you 🙏🙏

[@smritipuppala3322]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHaUkGNuqJiEbLc

[@premaakkineni]

Never happened to me 😂 I did all workshops and poojas on my menstruation days there no difference at all

[@Indian-tj9kf]

Because u must be a devil

[@ashokashtekar4265]

Simply Amazing......

[@VikasTheSunseeker]

My humble respect and pranam to Sinuji. Sinuji is glowing. I have seen her older KZbin videos . She is shining and it clearly shows that the higher power and mother Shakthi is working through her. It’s because of the power of her Sadhna on mother Shakthi.

[@amritanshsingh7838]

Never had any such thing to any of my friend or family while going to temple in periods, And as saying sookshma sharir you didn't elaborate the reason, the incidents are those few that can happen by even by coincidence

[@shubhragupta6462]

but I have gone in the temple during my menstruation and it doesn't effect me at all and not only once I don't even remember how many times I have gone 🤔

[@pallabidas2370]

Realy? When did you go 1st day or 2nd day of your periods? Is there anything bad happened with you after going ? I am confuse actualy

[@nilakanthakatuwal8586]

See who is saying this some rice bag converters sinu joseph intrested in sanatan dharma but don't want to become dharmic

[@dgurunathreddy]

She is going to temples mean she is not christian anymore, its aganist idea of christianity idol worship

[@nilakanthakatuwal8586]

@@dgurunathreddy whatever but when americans and europeans accepted sanatana dharma they changed themselves completely from their names to lifestyle but did she did the same absolutely not so why should accept someone who neither belongs here nor there just vibrates here and there

[@malliksharma]

What of temples. Menstruating women in high castes, especially Brahmins - even women in temple priests' households - are not expected to go out of the house, and also not to touch or meet the inmates of the house. For 3 days they are completely kept in a separate room, or if that much space is not there, in a separate space in the house itself. Food, water, etc. is served to them from a distance, etc. They are to take complete rest. Only in modern times the habits are changing. I don't think there is anything wrong in such separation either unless it amounts to willful discrimination or suppression of such women. It is not discriminatory - it applies to all mestruating women and it is not coercive either - it is just customary. I think for health reasons they devised this and in modern days when time is scarce and people hurry to do or not to do jobs in time changes are coming. However, with such background, it is natural that menstruating women themselves will feel awkward to go to temples, etc.

[@carrad123456]

This happens in which country and which district ? Sounds too regressive

[@vjnrsmhamysore1489]

The only thing is in pain you cannot concentrate!!! In temple u need to concentrate on God for experiencing ultimate happiness

[@tejaldhore8484]

Why is only hindu God restricting menstruating women and not churches and gurdwara?

[@knowledgebank9115]

I still feel like it makes no sense. We can't prove this based on just a few stories. Like, look at the comment section. Some women have told that they never experienced all of this. Like it makes no sense. And our ancestors were so wrong for saying that we are impure. Women are disgusted by themselves because of this. What they did was completely wrong

[@amrutharavi8330]

I visited temple after coming back immediately will have dosha. Wat parihara can I do

[@user-lt9fl8xf8j]

Not just temples, menstruating women are barred from touching the pooja place or idols at home.

[@eusebiomascarnenhas695]

Understand what you trying to say but does this happen only to women who go to temples but not to women of other beliefs visiting their place of worship

[@jagdishramanathan2091]

Sinuji is definitely has clear idea of women ,being a woman herself .

[@shantidevibinnekya2464]

I think this is the thing with me, I sleep in our pooja room, I have six months gap in my lunar cycle

[@divineuniverse4967]

How to follow puja routine during menopause irregular periods which are sometimes a month long

[@rajib8231]

We are simply talking about this so much as if it's followed only among Hindus. Do youknow whether it's not followed in other religions in India? Why always Hindus are targeted? Why do we need to keep justifying ourselves to the world. When i visited Thailand, it's been written openly outside Buddhist temples that women undergoing Menstruation should not go inside. It's been followed silently almost outside of India yet we keep debating and discussing about this as if it is Only existing here. What is happening to the people?

[@_atreyee]

If you really love and believe in God you will not go away from worshipping God because you should always perform your duty according to Bhagavad Gita. Worshiping the Lord, taking care of Him is your duty. And if you really believe and love Him you will not be able to keep yourself away from him. That time you may think that whatever happens to me I don't bother but taking care of Him bothers me. So I would suggest that there is no problem nothing will happen to you. You just keep faith on Him and this will work but YOU SHOULD HAVE BHAKTI IN HIM AND YOUR MIND SHOULD BE PURIFIED means you are not having any negative thoughts or going to bad paths of your life only loving God thinking of Him talking to Him taking care of Him. So if you have this you will not be able to keep yourself away from the SUPREME BEING. Hare Krishna Hare Krishna Krishna Krishna Hare Hare Hare Ram Hare Ram Ram Ram Hare Hare 🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@sailakshmig3139]

Excellent!

[@saragupta3100]

She needs upgrading on human biology. People should be allowed to enter the temple. Please stop this foolishness and educate yourself.

[@manasvisharma3949]

We need to educate ourselves to know deeper knowledge, as we don't know the knowledge how can we experience plz understand it is most deeply from all given in bhagvat Geeta .

[@saragupta3100]

@@manasvisharma3949 what century are we in?? We need to respect women as biologically being and men respect where they come from. Men especially have to know where they come from to know where they are going.

[@manasvisharma3949]

Maam the century we are living in is far less intelligent than everyone thinks , plz understand Vedas are not a short joke . It is not dishonouring women but protecting and celebrating it's menstrual period , we think that women were not respected in that wise age that declined not ended at 5000 years ago . Ayurveda is eternal knowledge which has given to us far more earlier than we think as given in scriptures . It is not hindu it is Vedas. We are very lucky that we born on that place where Vedas emerged it is not ours . Shri krishna said in bg to understand any text we need humble selfless curiosity (jigyasa) , and it requires in every field you see than how come we can understand those most deepest and durlabha knowledge ,this selfless humble curiosity to actually know the truth in scriptures and the present environment, people find difficult in this age due to unnecessary selfish quarrels nobody knows the pure knowledge very less knows and trying to propagate and preach others , everybody due to their knowledge insecurity is trying to subdue Vedic presence which is eternal it has no mistakes .

[@pardeepkrishandhar9464]

Even women were not required to enter the kitchen during their periods.

[@porchelviramr4404]

Brahmins of Tamil Nadu still following this practise though.

[@itskvani]

@@porchelviramr4404 right what you say but present generation of girls don't take it seriously and ridicule the practice..so I say, when you get rest from cooking and other work as a result of this, why don't you just enjoy it..

[@metacritiqebyrajan11]

Very great to feel proud 😁

[@davidflinch4139]

@@itskvani it is ridiculous aunty but agree women can get the needed rest. But it should not be forced upon us.

[@blueeyes3542]

For all the fools making adverse comments, please see her video on "woman and sabarimala" to understand the science and subtelity behind this

[@కృష్ణప్రియ-స3ధ]

Just ordered your books ma'am. Going to receive them on or before 7 Jan 2022 😇👍

[@e.yu.7358]

As a matter of fact, I have experienced a similar effect of a very old place of worship on my cycle - I was visiting an ancient church dedicated to Mother Mary in Abhasia and my period started right there quite unexpextedly especially considering that I hadn't had one for 5 or 7 years before that due to an eating disorder. I didn't have periods for years after that either. So why did I start menstruating in that church? I wouldn't dismiss what the video says about the influence of temples so easily...

[@smritipuppala3322]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHaUkGNuqJiEbLc

[@sheemoheeput9544]

Omg .you are Christian. Why are you making a connection between temples and church . Read the bible well. There is no such things written in bible. do some proper research.

[@rkrishnamoorthy1785]

Well said.It is in the interest of women health only.

[@dineshsivasankaran6157]

A wonderful experience just listening to this previous knowledge.Its like an added recipe to complete the dish prepared for hours. A final stage to be served with its magical touch. Right knowledge at the right time. Thank you for sharing. 🙏

[@suprita123]

Vastu Shastra (sthapatya veda) is amazing Shastra from Hindu literature. Sadly, very few people know the complete details of it ...

[@smritipuppala3322]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHaUkGNuqJiEbLc

[@UNisOUTDATED]

There is a dire need to decode the science hidden in the Sanatan Dharma for the world at large to understand it better. What a wonderful way to explain these phenomena. Thank you 🙏🏻

[@rawheat9]

Sanatan Dharma is pure science. This video however is talking pseudo science based gibberish. It only ends up giving sanatan Dharma a bad name.

[@ayushmishra8628]

@@rawheat9 atleast a different view. I don't think we can or any science today can explain these things. Science is evolving and tbh present day science cannot explain many things. We should invest in researching the reason behind such restrictions rather than debating and fighting.

[@karthika2252]

For people who are arguing here that this is all bs....they will only understand what sthula sharira and sukshma sarira and all the subtle energies when they die!!!! Learning the hard way